╌>

Analysis: Did Democrats Miss the Boat on the Women’s March?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  spikegary  •  9 years ago  •  22 comments

Analysis: Did Democrats Miss the Boat on the Women’s March?

Source

Millions of people showed up to protest the new Republican President in one of the largest demonstrations in history and the Democratic Party was barely in sight.

This weekend's enormous women's marches in Washington, D.C. and elsewhere are the latest signs that the official Democratic Party apparatus, hobbled by a post-election lull that saw it lay off staff and freeze some operations, has so far missed out on opportunities to head the resistance to Donald Trump.

Only one of the seven candidates vying for the chairmanship of the Democratic National Committee, South Bend Mayor Pete Buttigieg, attended a march, while the others participated in a forum held as part of a conference of Democratic mega-donors in Miami.

And as outside groups rush to capitalize on the moment, the party risks ceding its authority in the growing anti-Trump movement to organizations it doesn't control. Independence from the party can add credibility, but comes with downsides, as Republicans learned with the Tea Party.

"Millions of people are coming out to march and protest, and it's not because of the leaders of the Democratic Party," said Dan Cantor, the national director of the progressive Working Families Party, which both endorses Democratic candidates and runs its own candidates on its ticket. "This movement and energy can't ever be run by the leaders of the Democratic Party, as it will also need to be able to hold Democratic elected officials accountable to standing up to Trump."

Established Democratic groups were slow to fully endorse the march, and made limited efforts to collect participants' information in order to communicate with them and try to convert marchers into volunteers and donors. While some groups had a presence, there were relatively few clipboards visible on the National Mall Saturday.

"We need to harness this tremendous grassroots energy and perhaps spend a little less time behind closed doors talking to rich donors," said Democratic operative Lis Smith, who is supporting Buttigeig. "It would've made a lot of sense for Democratic and progressive groups to have had a bigger presence at these nationwide marches, as we need all the help we can get in the years ahead. After the success of the Women's March, I suspect that we won't see the same mistake repeated again."

In the weeks leading up the marches, many professional Democrats quietly lowered expectations in case they were not successful, given real concerns about the organization behind the events.

"At first there was reluctance to embrace from a lot of progressive organizations because it was not something that we were pulling together ourselves. Do we embrace or just let it happen?" said one official at a progressive group granted anonymity to speak candidly. "Quite frankly, it probably was successful because it wasn't organized by such and such Democratic group."

Turning that energy into a sustained, organized movement remains a challenge. But enthusiasm is often more valuable than infrastructure, as the 2016 election showed.

"The infrastructure does exist. It's just a question of plugging people in who are coming, perhaps for the first time this weekend, to understand what they can do," said Marcy Stech of Emily's List, the Democratic Women's group that hosted a training for 500 potential candidates after the march in Washington, D.C.

What's unclear is how many of those people will be funneled into the Democratic Party itself.

"People are looking for creative ways to take action and not necessarily wait to take marching orders," said Vicky Kaplan, the organizing director for MoveOn.org. "The Tea Party was very successful in getting people in their own party to choose sides."

The Tea Party movement sprung up organically after a defeat at the ballot box, then became more institutionalized by large "grass-tops" organizations like FreedomWorks and the Koch Brothers-funded Americans for Prosperity.

But it was always a double-edged sword for Republicans, as it fought a two-front war against both the Obama administration and the GOP establishment.

The Tea Party's leaderless independence was a source of its strength and credibility, said Leah Greenberg, a co-founder of "The Indivisible," a guide for progressive resistance to Trump, which looks at the conservative movement as a model. "You have to have some faith in people once they've been activated to figure out their own next steps," she said.

But that independence also made it impossible for the Republican Party to control, especially during contentious primary campaigns.

Tresa Undem, a pollster who has worked for reproductive rights and LGBT rights groups, said what's driving people to the streets is Trump and Republicans in Congress — so the Democratic Party can only steer things so much.

"I'm not sure how much influence the Democratic party or progressive groups will have with controlling the momentum," she said. "They can tap into it, but I think the momentum has started and will end organically," she said.

This weekend's marches were far less confrontational or ideological than the Tea Party. But both were born and incubated outside the top professional ranks of their ideological movements.

The Tea Party was inspired by a rant from a TV commentator, while the march was sparked by a Facebook post from a grandmother in Hawaii and carried to fruition by a group of organizers with only limited affiliation to the Democratic establishment.

"This outpouring today is extraordinary and inspiring. But if all this energy isn't channeled into sustained pol action, it will mean little," former Obama advisor David Axelrod said on Twitter Saturday.

In the end, major Democratic groups like Planned Parenthood did get onboard. And many members of Congress, governors, and other leaders proudly marched in Washington or their districts.

Now, many Democrats agree the party needs to let the marchers take the lead.

"Anyone who hopes to lead in either party needs to be listening to folks who turned out on Saturday...not capturing that energy but listening to it," said Ilyse Hogue, the President of NARAL Pro Choice, one of the sponsors of the event.

Despite Rep. Keith Ellison and former Labor Sec. Tom Perez, the two leading candidates for DNC Chair, echoed the point point, even though they missed the march.

"This weekend's marches showed us who really holds the power - the people," Ellison said. "And it proves to so many, including my own niece who invested so much during the election, that the Democratic Party must support and partner with the energetic activists we saw."

Perez said the party, "must keep up this energy and organize, organize, organize around our shared values of decency and equality while addressing the structural turnaround our party needs to support those efforts."

But it will be at least another month before either, or any of the other candidates, will have a chance to do that, as the national party waits until its next chair is elected in late February.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   seeder  Spikegary    9 years ago

In a meeting with their megadonors.  I wonder if Soros was sitting on his throne waiting to drain the blood of sacrifices because of the loss of all his hard earned money thrown at this election?

These folks seem to keep doubling down on the things that lost them the election, they don't connect on any level with far too many Americans-just wealthy donors and pseudo-intellectuals.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   seeder  Spikegary    9 years ago

And, I do believe America needs the Democrats to be part of a balanced government.  But radical left wing liberals?  Not so much.  The fringes have been lumped in with both parties and now they play to the extremes.  Need to get back to representing the group of us in-between them.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    9 years ago

Trump was the result of a breakaway GOP establishment who wanted to run Jeb Bush and did not want to address the immigration issue. Now, it's the democratic party's turn.  Conspicuous by their absence, there were no "pro-Hillay" marchers there. The women involved were against Trump being elected, not because Hillary wasn't.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   seeder  Spikegary  replied to  Aeonpax   9 years ago

I still believe that the Democrats need to do some soul searching and some real thinking and strategic planning before the next election.  Their message did not resonate, and it's not just Trump, but up and down the election lines at all levels.  Normally, if that happens you try to figure out the cause and take steps to remedy the cause and win back those voters that voted against you or didn't even bother to vote.  You don't wait for the other side to 'trip and fall'.  That's not the message to have, the message to have is this is how we're going to represent you form now on, if you give us the chance.

The march was a perfect opportunity to turn a new page in Democratic party book and put  anew face on themselves-they failed to do that this time.  How many more chances do they think they will get?

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax  replied to  Spikegary   9 years ago

You are very correct. This was a lost opportunity for the dems. They could have gained some support amongst the Bernie Sanders crowd.  Then there are the ex-democrats (liberals and progressives) who have gone to the Green Party.  ---- Yes, they squandered a beautiful opportunity.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.  replied to  Aeonpax   9 years ago

Gary and Aeon,

I would agree with you, but this march was grassroots, so I am not so sure that the Dems were ready with a message. I think that right now, they are trying to redefine themselves. That is going to take some time, if they are going to be effective in the next election. Right now they are too fractured. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Aeonpax   9 years ago

Aeon and Gary, although you seem to be in agreement, I am not so sure. 

Gary thinks the Democrats aren't moderate enough. That is not your issue, is it Aeon? 

In any case, I don't know how anyone can say, 4 days later, that the march failed to provide a base for anything further. 

Anyway, if Trump keeps it up we will see more protests before long on an ongoing basis. 

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   seeder  Spikegary  replied to  JohnRussell   9 years ago

Very true, I think next election is going to go to whoever wins the middle.  Trump did not appeal to hardcore republicans.  Their support was mediocre at best. 

I believe that the woman's march was a ready made place for Dems to be there and express support-the beginnings of a message.  They could have been standing there saying much of nothing, but they weren't.  They accuse the right of being the party of big money, but where were the Dem leaders?  With the mega-donors.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P  replied to  Spikegary   9 years ago

I think next election is going to go to whoever wins the middle. 

Watch that, Spike. 

I said that in '08, and the parties picked tickets from the edge.

In order to win the middle, you have to nominate a candidate from the middle, and that takes involvement from the parties, to push their candidates platforms in that direction.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   seeder  Spikegary  replied to  Jonathan P   9 years ago

Might be that people learn and try not to repeat the same errors.  Of course its all a crystal ball at this point

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P  replied to  Spikegary   9 years ago

I believe that the trend has been the commission of greater and greater errors over the last couple of decades. I think the Democrats have a unique advantage in having lost the election. They can look at themselves in a more objective manner, and work to remedy what has fractured them so badly. The march was not a good start, as it continued to serve their frustrations more than their goals.

I'm not a political pundit, but I am a student of policy. I can say with absolute clarity of conviction that they have to lose the identity politics if they ever want to regain the confidence of the entire nation. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Jonathan P   9 years ago

And I think Donald Trump has to change if he ever wants to get the votes of half the American people.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P  replied to  JohnRussell   9 years ago

ignored

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   seeder  Spikegary  replied to  Jonathan P   9 years ago

John, this is not an argumentative article about Trump.  I'd like to keep it that way. 

I think Jon is right, that the Dems have a unique opportunity to stand up and shine, if their leadership is strong enough to see the opportunity.  Let the other side do whatever they are going to do.  The Dems should become a unified party with a unified message-not trying to undermine the other side, but standing up for what they believe in-what the Dems believe in, not what the fringe believes in.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    9 years ago

perrie-halpern and johnrussell;

 Do you know what makes the Green Party so attractive to me? a) It is "non profit", unlike the duopoly and b) they are against needless war, which profit the corporations.

Obama and the Clintons damaged the democrats beyond repair. The little inroads they could have gained by being involved in the woman's march, is lost.  The religious right still has a death grip on the GOP.

The only way to go is third party.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Aeonpax   9 years ago

I appreciate that Aeon. BTW, Perrie wants a third party too. One of you would be a fourth party though because your idea of a third party and hers are not going to mesh much. 

How many parties should we have? 

As far as the Democrats being beyond repair, that depends on whether or not we remain a two party country as we have been for almost all of our 240 years. The history of third party success in the U.S. is sparse. 

It is highly likely the Democrats will revive, although I do agree with you that it needs to be much more progressive. 

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.  replied to  Aeonpax   9 years ago

Aeon,

I only offered an explanation, not an endorsement. You must have forgotten my position here. I am an independent, and there is nothing I would love more than a third party, since as you pointed out, when you only have 2 parties, you really only have 1 choice. I'm all about choice.

 
 

Who is online






69 visitors