Trump fires defiant acting attorney general
President Donald Trump fired the nation's acting attorney general Monday night after she refused to defend an executive order he issued last week restricting immigration in the name of national security.
In an act of hgh political drama just ten days after taking office, Trump replaced Obama administration appointee Sally Yates with the U.S. Attorney in Alexandria, Va., Dana Boente.
"The acting Attorney General, Sally Yates, has betrayed the Department of Justice by refusing to enforce a legal order designed to protect the citizens of the United States. This order was approved as to form and legality by the Department of Justice Office of Legal Counsel," a White House statement said. "Ms. Yates is an Obama Administration appointee who is weak on borders and very weak on illegal immigration."
Yates, who was the No. 2 official at the department before Trump's swearing-in and has been running the department since that time at Trump's request, sent a memo Monday saying she doubts the wisdom and the legality of the directive blocking immigration from seven majority-Muslim countries.
"My responsibility is to ensure that the position of the Department of Justice is not only legally defensible, but is informed by our best view of what the law is after consideration of all the facts. In addition, I am responsible for ensuring that the positions we take in court remain consistent with this institution’s solemn obligation to always seek justice and stand for what is right," Yates wrote in a memo released by the department earlier Monday.
"At present, I am not convinced that the defense of the Executive Order is consistent with these responsibilities, nor am I convinced that the Executive Order is lawful," the acting Justice Department head said. "For as long as I am the Acting Attorney General, the Department of Justice will not present arguments in defense of the Executive Order, unless and until I become convinced that it is appropriate to do so."

Yates memo suggests she views the order as legally suspect not solely because of its wording but also because of statements Trump and others have made about it. Trump indicated in an interview last week that the order was intended to give Christians an advantage in the immigration process. An outside adviser to Trump, former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani, has said the order grew out of Trump's effort to find a "legal" way to follow through on his campaign trail promise to ban Muslims from entering the U.S.
I rarely vote up my own comments; as this was someone else's excellent comment, I thought it worth such, as well as repeating.
Again.
The head of the ACLU said tonight that they will win in court and this order will go down. Mainly for the reasons you mentioned. Using Trumps own words it is based on a religious test , which is unconstitutional.
Exactly.
Ya wanna go after would-be-terrorists, go for it. Ya wanna go after a religion, you've ran smack-dab into the constitution. He's going to end up looking like a complete doofus, and us with him. Not to mention, not catching any fucking terrorists.
Trump is incompetent beyond words.
He cannot just let the woman go, he has to attack her character
"The acting Attorney General, Sally Yates, has betrayed the Department of Justice by refusing to enforce a legal order designed to protect the citizens of the United States."
Betrayed? People should be given a medal for betraying Donald Trump. The nation is in disgrace.
A 31 year old far right nationalist named Stephen Miller is Trump's senior policy advisor and is said to be the person behind the flailing immigration ban. This is nuts.
Yup, and I think the word traitor being bandied, is merely the beginning of his strategy in this exchange Rump has with DC and various Depts from here on out.
Welcome to Amerika.
And the head of ICE. Saturday night massacre. He is rushing toward an impeachment
Aye Comrade.
Does anyone know if such a thing has happened before? I'm asking the question because my knowledge of the American Government is mostly limited to having watched the complete "The West Wing" TV series, starring Martin Sheen, and the movie "The American President" starring Michael Douglas and Annette Bening.
I wanted to amend my comment but the "update" and "delete" icons are not showing on my comments. What I wanted to say is that I'm asking the question because my knowledge of the American Government is mostly limited to having watched the complete "The West Wing" TV series, starring Martin Sheen, and the movie "The American President" starring Michael Douglas and Annette Bening.
Yet another glitch. Now the icons are showing up, but they don't do what they're supposed to do.
Yet another glitch. Now the icons are showing up, but they don't do what they're supposed to do. Now the update showed up and the icons don't appear again. This could drive a person insane.
Just refresh and wait.. it should clear
Okay, I just refreshed. I ate an orange. I think I'll let the chain of comments to stand to see if anyone qualifies to win the Oscar.
Another thing I wanted to say was that either POTUS as depicted by the actors would have been far superior to the choices you were limited to in reality.
It's even possible that Jack Nicholson playing the POTUS in "Mars Attacks" might have been superior. If you can follow the chain of my attempt to post comments, you deserve an Oscar.
Great question Buzz, and I am not sure. I did find a couple of wiki articles that offer some insight.
Buzz -- To my knowledge, the only incident that's remotely similar is the Saturday night massacre when Richard Nixon forced the head of the justice department to fire the special prosecutor, Archibald Cox (because Cox dared to question him).
I think Trump's executive order is foolish and counterproductive. However, Sally Yates either has no idea what her role is as attorney general or she deliberately decided to martyr herself as a snowflake hero. She is appointed by the president to serve in a subordinate executive agency. Her job is to defend the executive branch in court not appoint herself the arbiter of a dispute between Trump and his detractors. The court decides what's lawful, not her, and the issue is not decided until the highest court has spoken.
If she believes that the policy is ill-advised, then she should have asked to speak directly with the president. If he didn't want to meet or refuses to change his mind after meeting, then she has two choices: tow the line or resign. To declare that she will do neither and instead announce that the justice department will not defend the order is insubordinate beyond belief. Trump acted properly in firing her.
Her job is NOT to defend the Executive Branch in any manner. You have no idea of the job of the Justice Department. Her job is to be the lawyer for the American People! Not the President! It is the job of the AG to represent US, the American people, even if that means going so far as indicting, arresting and prosecuting anyone, even the President, in the Executive Branch! The Justice Department is not under the control of the President! The AG does NOT work for the President! The AG does NOT work for him! The AG does not exist to defend him in anyway and in fact the AG exists to possibly prosecute the President if needed. The AG is the American People Lawyer! Not the Presidents! She did not work for him! The AG NEVER does! She worked for US! American civics, jr. high school level.
The AG does NOT work for him! The AG does not exist to defend him in anyway and in fact the AG exists to possibly prosecute the President if needed. The AG is the American People Lawyer! Not the Presidents! She did not work for him! The AG NEVER does! She worked for US! American civics, jr. high school level.
It is you that is incorrect.
The office of Attorney General was established by Congress by the Judiciary Act of 1789. The original duties of this officer were "to prosecute and conduct all suits in the Supreme Court in which the United States shall be concerned, and to give his or her advice and opinion upon questions of law when required by the president of the United States, or when requested by the heads of any of the departments."
The United States Attorney General (A.G.) is the head of the United States Department of Justice per 28 U.S.C. § 503, concerned with legal affairs, and is the chief law enforcement officer and chief lawyer of the United States government.
He or she serves at the pleasure of the president and can be removed by the president at any time for any reason; the attorney general is also subject to impeachment by the House of Representatives and trial in the Senate for "treason, bribery, and other high crimes and misdemeanors".
Maybe you need to step up to a college level course in Government operations.
The Attorney Generals office defends the government (administrative branch mainly, Congressional upon request of congress, except for criminal actions) and it's actions in court, And unless you missed it the President is the head of the administrative branch of this government. If her conscience cannot allow her to do such, then it was proper to remove her.
And it seems that her politics have gotten in the way of her duties.
It seems that while the AG defends the government, and does indeed work at the president's pleasure, the AG's actual duty to the President is ...
give his or her advice and opinion upon questions of law when required by the president of the United States
..., and the AG's opinion was that there were insurmountable legal/constitutional issues.
And her opinion on the issue was such that she decided that she could not fulfill her duties to the government. AND, since she chose not to resign, she was properly fired.
Right, wrong or indifferent her duties are to defend the government and it's actions. That is, if we are a nation of laws.
Her personal political opinions got in the way of her job.
You cannot spin it into the action in question was legally deficient, that is up to a court to decide if it gets that far.
Her duty/job is to enforce it, according to the law, she refused to, she was fired for it.
Regardless who it is, the Constitution doesn't change, and pity the poor schmuck that trump forces headlong into a battle with the constitution.
Well, that is up to a court to decide isn't it?
She was a liberal Obama appointee, isn't going to be the last time an appointee is going to refuse to do their job while they are temporarily filling in till the confirmations are done is it?
She WAS doing her job. Trump just didn't like her legal opinion. However it was her job to look at the order and decide if, in her legal opinion, it could stand up in court. She decided it could not and she said so. That is what she is paid to do. There is no politics involved in her determination. You just don't like her decision. Tough shit. She was fulfilling her obligation and doing her job without any prejudice in any direction.
She WAS doing her job. Trump just didn't like her legal opinion. However it was her job to look at the order and decide if, in her legal opinion, it could stand up in court. She decided it could not and she said so. That is what she is paid to do. There is no politics involved in her determination. You just don't like her decision. Tough shit. She was fulfilling her obligation and doing her job without any prejudice in any direction.
She can give advice but the president isn't required to take it. As head of the executive branch, the president makes the decision on whether to pursue a policy on behalf of the federal government, NOT her. She gets paid to defend that decision and, if she refuses to do so, then she has abrogated her responsibility. In this case, she really could not possibly say that the entire executive order is unconstitutional in every respect because the matter has yet to be litigated. Once she stepped into the shoes of the president to either set policy or block it, then her determination became political (especially once she went public). She was dead wrong and any executive would have canned her ass. I've seen government attorneys get carried away before but I never have seen anything this outrageous at so high a level.
give his or her advice and opinion upon questions of law when required by the president of the United States
..., and the AG's opinion was that there were insurmountable legal/constitutional issues.
A couple of things Larry. Look closely at the words "when required by the President of the United States". All the President required her to do was obey orders. If, for any reason whatsoever, she decided that she couldn't obey, her only choices were to resign or be fired immediately. If she was of the opinion that there were "insurmountable legal/constitutional issues", she should have gone to the President and said so privately (taking her letter of resignation with her). The minute that she made a public statement like that, her opinion stopped being a legal opinion and became a political opinion. In essence, she attempted to give orders to the President, being well aware that the chain of command goes in the other direction. She demonstrated then and there that she had no integrity and being fired was the nicest thing that could happen to her. If she had done that to a private client (violated attorney/client privilege), she would have been disbarred.
She was and is a hero. The AG gives advice to the President. The AG does not obey orders from the President.
The AG gives advice to the President. The AG does NOT obey orders from the President. The President does not have the authority to order the AG to do anything. He can fire the AG (at great political risk), but he can not order her/him to do or not do anything legal in their job. The AG is a separate authority.
All this tells me is you haven't really a clue about how the administrative arm of government actually works....
And, the more you rant otherwise the more you prove it.
The AG gives advice to the President. The AG does NOT obeyorders from the President. The President does not have the authority to order the AG to do anything. He can fire the AG (at great political risk), but he can not order her/him to do or not do anything legal in their job. The AG is a separate authority.
An independent agency (like the federal reserve for instance) is not in the executive branch or directly under the control of the president. The justice department is not an independent agency but rather an agency within the executive branch and the executive branch is headed by the president (as has been pointed out). The president can order her to do anything that isn't blatantly illegal. Here, however, all she was required to do was defend the executive order in court. If I wanted to undermine the order, they're less less blatant ways of doing it (like putting no real effort into the brief or oral argument).
Again, like everyone else in this situation, she has two choices: either do her job or resign. Instead, she choose to use her authority as head of the justice department to openly defy the authority the president has as head of the executive branch. If she didn't understand the limits of her authority before, Trump just educated her by bouncing a stick off her head. Her 15 minutes of fame is over.
Sorry Larry, her opinion and advice is to the President, not n a memo publicly circulated to the Justice Department disputing the president (her boss). If she cannot convince the president that she is, in fact correct, it is her duty to either enforce the order, argue for the order or resign. She did none of those, so she was fired. And rightly so.
I think the order is largely unenforceable and will be likely struck down by the high court. But as a government employee you do what your boss says or you quit. If you won't do either, you get fired.
"give his or her advice and opinion upon questions of law when required by the president of the United States"
Agreed, Larry, but she didn't give this advice to the President, she notified all of her subordinates that she would not defend the President's Executive Order.
"give his or her advice and opinion upon questions of law when required by the president of the United States"
Agreed, Larry, but she didn't give this advice to the President, she notified all of her subordinates that she would not defend the President's Executive Order.
The AG does serve at the pleasure of the President. However it is the job of the AG to prosecute cases that are Representative of the people of the United state and not OF the President. The Justice department is a semi-separate branch of the government in that the AG and the top officials are appointed (with advice and consent of the Senate) by the President and can be fired by the President. However it is extremely unusual, very, very, very rare for a President to fire an AG and it is usually only done in self defense when they are on the wrong side of the law and are close to prosecution or realize that they are facing a case in which they can not possibly prevail and it always, always considered scandalous when they do.
However that is not the end of the case. The Justice department can and usually does, if it is a serious case (and it usually is if the President fires an AG) appoint a Special Prosecutor who is beyond the power of the President. That probably will not happen in this case since the AG that was fired was only an acting AG until a full time AG is approved by the Senate, which MIGHT be Jeff sessions. However to indicate that the AG is somehow an employee or reports to the President is to have a gross misunderstanding of the function of the Department of Justice. For instance the FBI, which in the Department of Justice, is currently investigating Donald Trump and his ties during the election to Vladimir Putin and possible financial transactions involved. If the Department of Justice truly reported to the President then the President could order that investigation stopped. However, even if Jeff Sessions does become the AG he can not stop the FBI investigation as it is an investigation already in progress.
Currently there are 5 investigations into Donald Trump and his possible illegal connections to Russia both during the campaign and currently. He does not have the power to stop any of them, even those overseen by the new acting AG and whoever replaces them as full time AG. The President is the President, however their powers are limited. They do not run the Department of Justice. They can hire and fire, but they can not direct prosecution or start or stop investigations into anyone or anything. Even themselves or people who work for them, like Steve Bannon.
Excuse me I think it is your legal blinders.
Where did you say you got your legal training?
Amazing that people can be on the earth this long and not understand how the world works. Why do people think the President has the right to appoint his/her choices to agency heads? This person was a previous administration appointee. Some appointees understand that they serve at the pleasure of the sitting president. Some think they are larger than life. They get fired.
That's how it works. That's how it's always worked and how it will continue to work. But I'm glad Randy has a new hero.
It doesn't take much to get liberal hero status, does it it?
However that is not the end of the case. The Justice department can and usually does, if it is a serious case (and it usually is if the President fires an AG) appoint a Special Prosecutor who is beyond the power of the President.
Nixon, in his Saturday night massacre, proved that the a special prosecutor appointed by the AG is NOT beyond the reach of the president. He simply went through AG's until he got the result he wanted.
That probably will not happen in this case since the AG that was fired was only an acting AG until a full time AG is approved by the Senate, which MIGHT be Jeff sessions. However to indicate that the AG is somehow an employee or reports to the President is to have a gross misunderstanding of the function of the Department of Justice.
The AG is the head of an agency within the executive branch and the executive branch is headed by the president. All cabinet level officers within the executive branch report to him, they serve at will, and, if they don't do what he says, he can fire them.
For instance the FBI, which in the Department of Justice, is currently investigating Donald Trump and his ties during the election to Vladimir Putin and possible financial transactions involved.
And even the head of the FBI (who has a ten year term appointment) can be fired by the president. Bill Clinton did it.
I hope more Americans have the strength to stay true to our constitution and our country like Sally Yates. The AG is supposed to be an independent body that protects and follows our country's constitution.
This could have been avoided had President Trump and his Administration taken the time to consult the experts that work for "We the People" of the United States. Trump's arrogance and ignorance is destroying our country.
"This order was approved as to form and legality by the Department of Justice Office of Legal Counsel," a White House statement said."
So, obviously, there is disagreement between at least two government agencies.
Trump and his cohorts are liars. I don't believe anything they or their supporters say.
The AG is supposed to be an independent body that protects and follows our country's constitution.
Really? another Ignorant liberal chimes in.
Why don't you tell Eric Holder that he wasn't supposed to follow Obama's directions then.
Or guns across the border that came back and killed americans was really protecting americans and the constitution.
Or actually what your demonstrating that the constitution is situational for you. when your party holds the offices it means one thing, when the other side holds the offices it means something entirely different.
Hypocritical much?
Please point out where I have ever said or suggested that Eric Holder was supposed to blindly follow President Obama's orders. I'll wait
The justice department falls under the executive branch the buck stops with the president. That's why Obama was able to direct the justice department not to prosecute states like Colorado for breakinto federal laws regarding marijuana.
She isn't going to get it Dean, the language is too complicated...
The lady just fired was just the interim Attorney General.
Now just what is the interim Attorney General?
She was the senior member of the Former Attorney Generals staff, when a president leave office his cabinet members leave at the exact same moment. Which means that the Attorney General is now gone, the most senior member of his/her staff steps up as the Interim Attorney General just to keep the DOJ offices functioning until the incoming AG is confirmed and installed. Once that happens the interim AG resigns and leave the DOJ.
She was a lame duck place holder from the start.
A nobody from the previous administration just to keep the office functioning, never intended to last beyond that.
So what this is is a political stunt coming from someone that is going to leave the office anyway.
But one thing it does reveal in spades, is the situational ethics of the democrats that were in Obama's administration.
The sooner they are gone and replaced with people that hopefully actually do have some ethics, the better off we will be.
This will eventually come to pass and all the perfect people will be removed, probably making as big a media splash as they can.
I just wish we could do this on this board also.
Maybe then we could actually have some decent discussion of real issues and not this contrived tripe being passed off as discussion.
But it is showing one thing, how many people on this board haven't a clue about how the government actually functions.
And it's amazing....
You accused me of something and I asked for evidence. Where is the evidence?
Well you see, this is a perfect example of the crap we see every day.
I didn't accuse you of anything.
Wwell I'll tell the truth, I did accuse you of being ignorant.
THEN,
I told you to do something.
Huge difference there which surprises me that you didn't understand that simple difference.
And it just serves to prove the statement I made which you appropriately put this response to.
Isn't it amazing how that works?
okay
Just to be clear, I think a strong AG is one who gives independent advice and by that I mean giving the advice that he believes is correct not simply telling the president what he wants to hear. But the president makes policy for the executive branch and for the federal government, NOT the AG. Once the AG has given advice and the president makes a decision, the duty of the AG is to carry out that decision as best he is able . . . not frustrate it by refusing to defend it in court.
Exactly.