╌>

Is Sally Yates A Hero or a Villain?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jerry-verlinger  •  9 years ago  •  70 comments

Is Sally Yates A Hero or a Villain?

Image result for Gatestone institute Logo   by  Alan M. Dershowitz   February 1, 2017 at 4:00 pm

Acting Attorney General Sally Yates was fired by President Donald Trump because she instructed the Justice Department lawyers not to defend Trump's Executive Order regarding travel to the U.S. by people from certain Muslim countries. She is neither a hero, nor a villain. She made an honest mistake when she instructed the entire Justice Department not to defend President Trump's wrong-headed executive order on immigration.

The reasons she gave in her letter referred to matters beyond the scope of the attorney general. She criticized the order on policy grounds and said that it was not "right." She also referred to its possibly unconstitutionality and unlawful. Had she stuck to the latter two criteria she would have been on more solid ground, although perhaps wrong on the merits. But by interjecting issues of policy and directing the Justice Department not to defend any aspect of the order, she overstepped her bounds.

2264.jpg

Former U.S. Acting Attorney General Sally Yates (left), and President Donald Trump. (Images source: Wikimedia Commons)

An Attorney General, like any citizen, has the right to disagree with a presidential order, but unless it is clear that the order is unlawful, she has no authority to order the Justice Department to refuse to enforce it. This order is multi-faceted and complex. It raises serious constitutional and legal issues that deserved nuanced and calibrated consideration from the nation's highest law officer. There are significant differences between the constitutional status of green card holders on the one hand, and potential visitors from another country who are seeking visas. Moreover, there are statutory issues in addition to constitutional ones. A blanket order to refuse to defend any part of the statute is overkill. If she strongly disagreed with the policies underlying the Order, she should have resigned in protest, and left it to others within the Justice Department to defend those parts of the Order that are legally defensible.

I, too, disagree, with the policy underlying the order, but I don't immediately assume that any policy with which I disagree is automatically unconstitutional or unlawful.

The President has considerable constitutional authority to control entry into the United States by non-citizens and non-residents. Congress, too, has some degree of control over our borders. The precise relationship between presidential and congressional power has never been defined by the Supreme Court. A more responsible Attorney General would seek to analyze these complex issues before jumping into the political fire by a blanket refusal to defend any part of the order.

In addition to failing to do her duty as Attorney General, Sally Yates handed President Trump an underserved political victory. She gave him the power to control the situation by firing her, instead of herself maintaining control by resigning in protest. It is the President who emerges from this unnecessary confrontation with the undeserved status of hero among his constituents.

I do not know Sally Yates except by reputation. She is highly regarded as a career prosecutor and public servant. My criticism of her is not personal, but rather institutional. These are dangerous and delicate times, and anyone who wants to confront the newly elected president must do so with wisdom, nuance and calibration. She played directly into his hands by responding to an overbroad order with an overbroad response. President Trump has now appointed a new acting Attorney General who will defend the order, or at least those parts of it that are legally defensible. Any individual Justice Department official who feels uncomfortable defending this controversial order should be given the freedom by the Department to decline to participate in the case. There are plenty of good lawyers in the Department who would have no hesitation standing up in the courtroom and making the best ethically permissible argument in defense of the order. I have had many experiences with Justice Department lawyers who personally disagreed with the prosecutorial decision in particular cases, but who vigorously defended the government's position.

Sally Yates did what she thought was right. In my view she was wrong. She should neither be lionized nor accused of betrayal. Nor should President Trump's critics, and I include myself among them, accuse him of doing anything even remotely close to President Nixon's infamous "Saturday night massacre." Nixon fired the very officials who were seeking to prosecute him. That constituted a personal and unethical conflict of interest. President Trump fired Yates over policy differences. It may have been unwise for him to do so, but it was clearly within his authority.

Now we will see our adversarial system at work. Excellent and dedicated lawyers will continue to bring challenges throughout the country against this ill-advised executive order. Other excellent lawyers will defend the order vigorously in court. Ultimately the issue may come to the Supreme Court (with or without a full complement of Justices). That is the way our system of checks and balances is supposed to work.

[ Link to Original Article ]


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    9 years ago

She is neither a hero, nor a villain. She made an honest mistake when she instructed the entire Justice Department not to defend President Trump's wrong-headed executive order on immigration.

Did she actually make a mistake? Given her years of experience, I think she was well aware that to instruct the enire Department to stand down on Trumps Exec Order and to state her position re; the 'policy' behind the order, was going to result in being dismissed by our new President/Dictator.

IMO, she decided she was not going to serve this new administration and decided to go out with a bang. (my estimate on the amount of the advance on her anticipated book will be around $250,000) 

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  Jerry Verlinger   9 years ago

Wow! You posted an article from the Gatestone Institute and (a certain member whom I can not name because I'd be accused of the CoC violation of "Calling Out") didn't come on board to declare it to be a biased right-wing anti-Muslim rag as he always does when I post an article from that source.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger  replied to  Buzz of the Orient   9 years ago

"Wow! You posted an article from the Gatestone Institute....."

Yeah. I follow them to see what the likes of John Bolton are up to. Although they are considered a Right Wing think tank, this article caught my eye because it was written by the famous civil rights, defender, Alan Dershowitz. (an odd place for a Dershowitz article)

I posted it because the  Dershowitz viewpoint here is the same as mine regarding the place she put herself into by openly defying Trump..

 

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  Jerry Verlinger   9 years ago

I admire Dershowitz, and read everything he posts that I can find. Even thought he is a bit left wing I think he would make a great SCOTUS judge.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton  replied to  Jerry Verlinger   9 years ago

Yeah. I follow them to see what the likes of John Bolton are up to. Although they are considered a Right Wing think tank, this article caught my eye because it was written by the famous civil rights, defender, Alan Dershowitz. (an odd place for a Dershowitz article)

Dershowitz has been a regular contributor at the Gatestone Institute for many years with over 200 articles.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  Buzz of the Orient   9 years ago

Wow! You posted an article from the Gatestone Institute

Wonder why that certain person didn't come out?  Maybe that certain person agreed with this article and that's what that certain person bases all of that certain person's opinions on as to whether it is a conspiracy or right wing nut site. LOL

Agree = good site

Disagree = fake news

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  sixpick   9 years ago

I think you know who I meant.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    9 years ago

I agree, right or wrong, she of all people should have known her role, and stayed with it to the end.

Allowing her political judgment to overcome her duty was a mistake, one that is too often made in today's American political scene.

And it's not just the book, she will be a living martyr to the progressive cause. The speaking fees alone are going to be worth millions. Then the advocacy groups who need a lobbyist.

A good argument could be made that she saw her opportunity and took it, maximizing the face time value as the first progressive to directly stand up to the president.

Opportunist to the end in my opinion.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  Nowhere Man   9 years ago

I agree. She cashed in. There was no principle involved.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger  replied to  Cerenkov   9 years ago

There was no principle involved.

The principle is that she gave up three decades of working for the public so she didn't have to work under the nasty, prickfaced Donald fucking J.Trump.

We can't be sure, I think it may have been calculated, but there is a possibility the financial factor did not occur to her until after she made her comment.

Anyway, from following your past comments and positions, 'principles' are not within your area of expertise.  

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  Jerry Verlinger   9 years ago

You're calling me unprincipled? Fuck you, Jerry.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger  replied to  Cerenkov   9 years ago

You're calling me unprincipled? Fuck you, Jerry.

Those are your words Cerenkov. I just said principles are not in your area of expertise. If you take that as an accusation that you are unprincipled, then maybe that is the problem. 

To me, I am saying the values of your principles might come into questioning by some people.  

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger  replied to  Nowhere Man   9 years ago

Allowing her political judgment to overcome her duty was a mistake, .....

 I don't think so. It was a calculated move.

And it's not just the book, she will be a living martyr to the progressive cause. The speaking fees alone are going to be worth millions ...... A good argument could be made that she saw her opportunity and took it.  

I don't know about "millions", but it will be a lot more than she was getting from the DOJ

......, maximizing the face time value as the first progressive to directly stand up to the president.

I don't see any evidence she is a "progressive". (you've got to get out of the habit of thinking everyone that you do not agree with is a progressive). She didn't maximize the time. The time was there, she decided she was not going to work for a bully prick, wanna-be dictator, Donald Trump, so she bailed with a nicely placed parachute.

Opportunist to the end in my opinion.

It only knocks once.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Jerry Verlinger   9 years ago

You know, most of what you say here I have to agree with my friend, except one thing...

 "you've got to get out of the habit of thinking everyone that you do not agree with is a progressive"

I know it might seem that way, but over time you soon realize that I'm not brain dead whiner.

I formed my opinion based upon her statement in refusal to enforce the order, and the language she used to say it. Which bears much similarity to other known progressives. So no, I do not know with any certainty that she is a progressive, but her actions mimic one very well.

And I feel very confident in that assessment of her political leanings.

And given her recent hiring, I think I'm right on the money.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    9 years ago

`

To me. Yates made a calculated move and has her 15minutes of fame.  Coincidentally, she immediately found other employment after she got fired.  Not an icon in my book.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    9 years ago

I agree with Dershowitz. Rather than resign over political differences, Yates decided that she would use her position as a platform to yell "fuck you Trump". That made her a hero to the liberal anarchists and a villain to those who view her as a political hack who tried to usurp executive authority. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    9 years ago

Bluntly, hasn't Sally Yates been vindicated? 

Five federal court judges from locations across the country have now reached the decision that the Muslim ban is illegal. Which is what Yates said before Trump fired her. 

She wins. 

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  JohnRussell   9 years ago

Bluntly, hasn't Sally Yates been vindicated? 

Five federal court judges from locations across the country have now reached the decision that the Muslim ban is illegal. Which is what Yates said before Trump fired her. 

She wins. 

Just so you know, all that these courts have done is issue temporary injunctions pending further litigation on the merits of the case. Those orders are subject to appeal in each federal circuit. Each court that issued an injunction has yet to reach a final decision and, when they do, that order is subject to appeal as well. The fight is not over.

But the issue with Yates was never whether her advice had merit (the order had obvious problems). Her job is to defend the executive branch and get a court ruling. She does not have the right to pick what she will defend based on whether she would have issued such an order if she were the president. She stepped over the line from giving advice to literally forcing her advice on the president by refusing to defend his position in court. Basically, she attempted to usurp the executive authority of the president by abusing her authority as attorney general. Trump was absolutely right to fire her whether or not her advice proves to be correct in the end. If the attorney general won't defend his position, then she should be removed and replaced by someone who will. 

A crazy democratic hack of an attorney general jumped in front of a crazy republican presidential train and got run over. Now she's just a stain on the track.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  JohnRussell   9 years ago

She wins = unemployment benefits

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  sixpick   9 years ago

Liberals are becoming more and more unhinged. First, there was all the crying and hand wringing. Then,  the pointless and self-degrading vagina protest. Now the lawyers are committing professional suicide. They're like flies bouncing off the windshield of a speeding car. 

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    9 years ago

Her job is to defend the executive branch and get a court ruling. 

No, her job is to defend the American people.

Now she's just a stain on the track.

Only in your wet dream.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  pat wilson   9 years ago

Her job is to defend the executive branch and get a court ruling. 

No, her job is to defend the American people.

Defending the executive branch headed by a president elected by the people and defending the American people are one in the same. If she thinks her job is to protect the American people from the president, then she grossly misunderstood her role. But it doesn't matter now. She works at the pleasure of the president and it's his pleasure that she no longer serve. She's done.

Now she's just a stain on the track.

Only in your wet dream.

She's a hero only in yours.

 
 
 
Old Hermit
Sophomore Silent
link   Old Hermit  replied to  1ofmany   9 years ago

Defending the executive branch headed by a president elected by the people, (constitution), and defending the American people are one in the same.

 

 

One in the Same is not a given.   Just ask Jeff Sessions.

(Sessions),   “If the views the president wants to execute is unlawful, should the attorney general or deputy attorney general say no?”

(Sally Yates),  “Senator, I believe the attorney general or the deputy attorney general has the obligation to follow the law and the Constitution and to give their independent legal advice to the president,” she responded.

 

Her legal opinion was that the executive order was not a lawful one and she made her expert opinion known publicly.  Trump fired her, as was his right. 

 

As to how history will view this episode?

Well, Archibald Cox is remembered as a man of integrity and honor, Nixon, not so much.

Ms Yates maintained her honer & integrity.  Hero.

Trump looked like someone with tiny hands dropping an easy catch and then blaming the ref.

 

 

 

 

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Old Hermit   9 years ago

 Her legal opinion was that the executive order was not a lawful one and she made her expert opinion known publicly. 

I don't have one single problem with this, she is entitled to her opinions.

Trump fired her, as was his right. 

Absolutely. but NOT cause of her opinion. But because of her ACTIONS. She instructed the entire Justice Department to not do their jobs remember? Which was way beyond her authority, and highly unethical.

I don't know but when my employer tells me to do it this way, I had better have a very good reason (more than just my opinion) for doing it some other way, or I can expect to be fired also.

By deciding to instruct the department to not do their jobs as relates to the presidents order, which carries the force of law by the way, she effectively substituted her position for her employers. And that is also highly unethical for a lawyer.

the only way to deal with such was to tell Mr President that her opinions would not allow her to defend such an order and tender her resignation, then quietly leave office.

No, she had to make a huge political splash in the media with it by forcing the president to fire her.

Which was also unethical. (and politically motivated)

But then that is what we expect from liberals today, they could care less about ethics or honesty or integrity when it comes to their beliefs of what is right for everyone else.

And for most Americans, she has simply offered one more item of evidence of it.

Politics before the nation. and Progressive Liberals know better than anyone else.

Better we find out now rather than a month from now when she could have done a LOT more damage.

 
 
 
Old Hermit
Sophomore Silent
link   Old Hermit  replied to  Nowhere Man   9 years ago

Absolutely. but NOT cause of her opinion. But because of her ACTIONS. She instructed the entire Justice Department to not do their jobs remember? Which was way beyond her authority, and highly unethical.

 

Sorry NwM but once again, in your strange need to normalize how Pres Trump is acting, you've overshot the mark.

Just following orders is not a defense for carrying out an UN-Lawful order.

She, (and the stay orders from several judges since), assume the EO to be unlawful.  Once Yates reached that conclusion, of course she must tell her people to stand down.  Not to do so, turning a blind eye to an illegal order being carried out by her department, would truly be and act of Party over Country.

The military and civil servants pledge to defend and protect the Constitution not any Superior who happens to be giving out unlawful orders, Presidents included.

She was correct in all of her actions and, of course my opinion is the correct one, backed by the known facts, while you once again are blowing smoke.  Sorry. (snark)


Better we find out now rather than a month from now when she could have done a LOT more damage.

Let's just hope that more folk will have the integrity, honer and bravery to step in when needed, like Mrs.Yates did, before President Trump does a LOT more damage to the Country than he's all ready managed.

Wonder if Jeff Sessions will have the backbone of AG Richardson & AG Ruckelshaus showed when Nixon gave them unlawful orders or Mrs Yates after she received what she deemed to be an illegal order from Trump?

Or will Sessions just be another lackey like Robert Bork?

Time will tell.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  Old Hermit   9 years ago

Just following orders is not a defense for carrying out an UN-Lawful order. She, (and the stay orders from several judges since), assume the EO to be unlawful.  Once Yates reached that conclusion, of course she must tell her people to stand down.  Not to do so, turning a blind eye to an illegal order being carried out by her department, would truly be and act of Party over Country. The military and civil servants pledge to defend and protect the Constitution not any Superior who happens to be giving out unlawful orders, Presidents included.

This is all part of a false analogy because nobody asked her to carry out an unlawful order. She is part of the executive branch and the executive branch is headed by the president. He is the president because he was elected by the people and both the people. The attorney general cannot say that she defends the people against the president because, for the purpose of legal representation, the people and the president are the same. To view it any other way creates an imaginary conflict of interest. 

The executive branch appears in court through attorneys in the justice department. In this instance, once an executive order is challenged in court, the justice department defends it. Like any other attorney representing a client, the attorney general can approach the president and give the president her opinion on the likelihood of litigation success. Like any other client, the president can decide what he wants to do in light of the advice. The attorney cannot gum the whole thing up by refusing to step aside or file anything unless the client agrees with him. That's completely unethical. 

Unless and until the court speaks, Yates' opinion on the legality of an executive order is just her opinion. The purpose of going to court is to get a judicial ruling. If the court determines that the executive order is illegal, then and only then does she have grounds to refuse to carry it out. Until then, the executive order is presumed legal and lawful. By refusing to get a court ruling because she disagrees with the substance of the order, she was derelict in her duty and properly removed so that the justice department can function.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  Old Hermit   9 years ago

Defending the executive branch headed by a president elected by the people,(constitution), and defending the American people are one in the same.

 One in the Same is not a given.   Just ask Jeff Sessions.

I think it's always a given even if we ask Jeff Sessions. 

 

 

(Sessions),   “If the views the president wants to execute is unlawful, should the attorney general or deputy attorney general say no?” 

(Sally Yates),  “Senator, I believe the attorney general or the deputy attorney general has the obligation to follow the law and the Constitution and to give their independent legal advice to the president,” she responded.

The question was directed to giving "legal advice" and that's precisely how Yates took it. What is meant is that the attorney general should give independent legal advice consistent with the law and constitution rather than just tell the president what he wants to hear. Nothing in the question or answer remotely suggests that, if the president refuses to take the advice, then the attorney general should seize the reigns from the president and prevent him from driving. This is utterly ridiculous and Trump properly ended this democrat mutiny as quickly as it started. 

 

 

Her legal opinion was that the executive order was not a lawful one and she made her expert opinion known publicly.  Trump fired her, as was his right.  

He would be justified in firing her simply for making her legal opinion public because the intent of the disclosure would be a blatant attempt undercut the order at the same time she was defending it. But she went far beyond that and publicly announced that she would not defend the order even though it's legality had yet to be determined by a court.

 

 

As to how history will view this episode?

Well, Archibald Cox is remembered as a man of integrity and honor, Nixon, not so much.

Ms Yates maintained her honer & integrity.  Hero.

This is nothing like the Archibald Cox episode. In that case, Nixon was trying to prevent a special prosecutor from doing his job. In this case, Sally Yates was refusing to do her job as part of a partisan political stunt. 

There is nothing honorable about what Ms. Yates did. She knew she was being replaced so she used her position to shout from the roof top "fuck you Trump" before she went out the door. I think it was deplorable.

Trump looked like someone with tiny hands dropping an easy catch and then blaming the ref.

Yates looked like someone, with an oversized head, who snatched the ref's whistle and blew if herself until they led her stupid ass off the field.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    9 years ago

She's an unemployed bolshevik.

 
 

Who is online




125 visitors