Spicer's Mistake and the Democrat's Over-Reaction
Spicer's Mistake and the Democrat's Over-Reaction
by Alan M. Dershowitz, Gatestone Institute, April 12, 2017
Sean Spicer made a serious mistake when he compared Bashar Al-Assad to Hitler, and to make matters worse, he got his facts wrong. He quickly and fully apologized. There was no hint of anti-Semitism in his historical mistake and his apology should have ended the matter. But his political enemies decided to exploit his mistake by pandering to Jews. In doing so, it is they who are exploiting the memory of the six million during the Passover Holiday.
The Democratic National Committee issued a rebuke with the headline "We will not stand for anti-Semitism." Its content included the following: "Denying the atrocities committed by Adolf Hitler and the Nazi regime is a tried and true tactic used by Neo-Nazis and white supremacist groups that have become emboldened since Donald Trump first announced his campaign for president." By placing Hitler and Trump in the same sentence, the DNC committed a mistake similar to that for which they justly criticized Spicer. Moreover, the DNC itself, is co-chaired by a man who for many years did "stand for anti-Semitism" -- namely Keith Ellison who stood by the notorious anti-Semite Louis Farrakhan, while denying that he was aware of Farrakhan's very public Jew-hatred. It is the epitome of Chutzpah for the DNC to falsely accuse Spicer of standing by anti-Semitism while it is they who are co-chaired by a man who committed that sin.
Nancy Pelosi, the House Minority leaders, falsely accused Spicer of "downplaying the horror of the Holocaust." But by leveling that false accusation, Pelosi herself is exploiting the tragedy.
Steven Goldstein, a hard-left radical who heads a phony organization that calls itself "The Anne Frank Center for Mutual Respect," accused Spicer of "engage[ing] in Holocaust denial." He called Spicer's mistake a "most evil slur" against the Jewish people. Goldstein claims to speak for the Jewish people, but he represents only himself and a few handfuls of radical followers who are not in any way representative of the mainstream Jewish community. He repeatedly exploits the Holocaust in order to gain publicity for him and his tiny group of followers. Shame on them!
These over the top reactions to a historical mistake made by Spicer that was not motivated by anti-Semitism represents political exploitation of the Holocaust. Spicer was wrong in seeking to bolster his argument against Assad by referring to Hitler, and his political opponents are wrong in exploiting the tragedy of the Holocaust to score partisan points against him.
The difference is that Spicer gaffe was not in any way pre-meditated, whereas the exploitation by his enemies was carefully calculated for political gain. All sides must stop using references to Hitler and the Holocaust in political dialogue. Historical analogies are by their nature generally flawed. Analogies to the Holocaust are always misguided, and often offensive, even if not so intended.
On CNN the other night, Don Lemon asked me if I was "offended as a Jew" by what Spicer had said. The truth is that I was offended as someone who cares about historical accuracy by Spicer's apparent lack of knowledge regarding the Nazi's use of chemicals such as Zyklon B to murder Jews during the Holocaust. But it never occurred to me that Spicer's misstatements were motivated by anti-Semitism, Holocaust denial or an intent to "slur" the Jewish people. Nor do I believe that those who have accused him of such evil motivations actually believe it. They deliberately attributed an evil motive to him in order to pander to Jewish listeners. That offends me more than anything Spicer did.
Extreme right wing anti-Semitism continues to be a problem in many parts of Europe and among a relatively small group of "alt-right" Americans. But hard left and Muslim extremist anti-Semitism is a far greater problem in America today, especially on university campuses. So those of us who hate all forms of anti-Semitism and bigotry, regardless of its source, must fight this evil on a non-partisan basis. We must get our priorities straight, focusing on the greatest dangers regardless of whether they come from the right or the left, from Republicans or Democrats. The fight against bigotry is a bi-partisan issue and must not be exploited for partisan gain.

I doubt that I will ever disagree with Dershowitz.
A well expressed opinion. It's pretty sick that the Democrats jumped on this.
"Hitler didn't gas any Germans!"
What's wrong with that? Well, OK, it's monumentally callous and historically false and... well... clearly anti-semitic (Germans aren't German if they're Jews?!?!)... ... and it was said by the Press Secretary of the President of the United States...
Other than that.... there's no reason at all to get upset!
"Hitler didn't gas any Germans!"
What's wrong with that?
What's wrong with that is that it is not what he said. A terrible bunch of gaffs without putting words in his mouth. Nice job on proving the point of the article
Washington Post :
“I think when you come to sarin gas, there was no — he was not using the gas on his own people the same way that Assad is doing ,” Spicer said, mispronouncing Assad's name. “I mean, there was clearly, I understand your point, thank you. Thank you, I appreciate that. There was not in the, he brought them into the Holocaust center , I understand that. What I am saying in the way that Assad used them, where he went into towns, dropped them down to innocent, into the middle of towns, it was brought — so the use of it. And I appreciate the clarification there. That was not the intent.”
(Emphasis added)
Spicer clearly says "not using the gas on his own people "... so he clearly considers that the Jews were not Germans.
The Germans slaughtered Jews in every way imaginable, including mobile gas chambers that murdered local Jews in their own village. How is that less than what Assad has done?
More importantly than this word or that, Spicer unquestionably was saying that what Assad has done was worse than what Hitler did. That is obscene!
OK let me get this straight. You KNOW it was a gaffe and have admitted so.
Definition of gaffe
1 : a social or diplomatic blunder committed an embarrassing gaffe when he mispronounced her name
2 : a noticeable mistake Kwan did not fall today, as she had in Friday's short program, a gaffe that left her in fourth place. — Christopher Clarey
Spicer clearly says "not using the gas on his own people"... so he clearly considers that the Jews were not Germans.
So although you admit is was a gaffe you also are assuming you know what another person is thinking, and there fore you know what he meant to say? Need I say more or does this sentence spell it out clearly enough?
More importantly than this word or that, Spicer unquestionably was saying that what Assad has done was worse than what Hitler did. That is obscene!
IF Assad did it....it is comparable in that they both used gas on defenseless people..
Where did I agree with "gaffe"?
IF one accepts that this was "just a gaffe"... then by the same occasion one is saying that Spicer's empathy for mass-murder victims is only at an "oops/gosh" level. That's just as bad, in my book.
The White Supremacist fringe of the Internet certainly would like to believe that Spicer's words were not a gaffe:
White Nationalists And Neo-Nazis Use Sean Spicer’s Hitler Comments To Validate Holocaust Conspiracy Theories, Attack Jews
I think that the Press Secretary of the President of the United States does not have the right to make negligent remarks about mass-murder and then just say "oops" to be forgiven.
So you don't forgive humans for being human, and don't forgive mistakes. You must have been most upset with Obama on several occasions too./s
Do you ever read what I actually write? Or do you always just make stuff up and put the necessary words in my mouth?
What does "forgiveness" have to do with this topic? And how does Obama come into it?
You brought up the word "gaffe". I answered you... so you changed the subject...
Wow.......
So you don't agree with Gaffe fine. Perhaps also "forgive" was not the right word. Perhaps I should have said IGNORE.
What does Obama have to do with it? He is being used for comparative purposes and has said a whole bunch of crazy shit you either forgave or ignored.
The especially stupid and/or offensive gaffs are bold. So you are outraged some presidential lackey said something offensive. Did you give the former president himself a pass for insulting:
Once again you are proving the accuracy of the article. The mistake of Trump's lackey is unforgivable but the democratic presidents mistakes are forgiven and/or ignored without a second thought. Seems a bit hypocritical. Say didn't BO also call slaves "immigrants" how did you feel about that?
It looks to me like you are uncomfortable discussing the behavior of the Press Secretary. At best incredibly callous, at worst downright anti-semitic. So you want to talk about Obama.
That's perfectly understandable.
Dishonest, but understandable.
Moreover, the DNC itself, is co-chaired by a man who for many years did "stand for anti-Semitism" -- namely Keith Ellison who stood by the notorious anti-Semite Louis Farrakhan, while denying that he was aware of Farrakhan's very public Jew-hatred. It is the epitome of Chutzpah for the DNC to falsely accuse Spicer of standing by anti-Semitism while it is they who are co-chaired by a man who committed that sin.
Have to love this part from the story. So Spicer misspoke and he apologized. Was it a gaffe? Sure. How many out there have ever (and/or still do) held Jesse Jackson to his remarks about "all the Hymies in Hymietown". The left immediately forgave Jackson. But they aren't willing to do the same for Spicer. I wonder what the difference between these two men might be?
Hmm...
So, no one. As expected.
So Spicer misspoke and he apologized. Was it a gaffe? Sure. How many out there have ever (and/or still do) held Jesse Jackson to his remarks about "all the Hymies in Hymietown". The left immediately forgave Jackson. But they aren't willing to do the same for Spicer. I wonder what the difference between these two men might be?
Gary, I haven't forgotten that comment, and frankly I can't stand Jessy Jackson. But are we going with the two wrongs makes a right defence? The one thing that Spicer did that was better than Jackson is apologize... but how can someone be that ignorant of the facts?
No, we are going with someone said something wrong and apologized for it and we should all put on out adult pants and get on with our day. But if people want to spend an inordinate amount of time trying to portray Spicer as an anti-Semite, then I guess that's the game that is on. What Jackson said, to me, was far worse and for the most part, got a pass on it form the left.
Not long ago, this Administration celebrated Holocaust Day... ... ... without mentioning Jews...
Once is perhaps a screw-up.
Twice is perhaps a really, really bad screw-up.
Will you continue to say, "Oh... just another screw-up" at the third, fourth, fifth, ...
OK from a non political standpoint, the man is either ignorant or callous.
Maybe we should tell him to take a shower at Dachau. Ask him how he feels after that.
The real story should be, "SEAN SPICER APOLOGIZES!"
I just happened to come back and check out this article that I posted a while ago. I had no idea about the number of comments that are totally off topic. I guess if I had not been sleeping while all that was going on I would have flagged about a third of the comments on this article. Now it's old news, but at least it did get a rise out of a lot of members, a lot more than my articles on Classic Cinema or Canada group, or my photo essays on Discovery or Creative Arts groups. Oh, well, you're all asleep now so who cares.