Racism motivated Trump voters more than authoritarianism
Racism motivated Trump voters more than authoritarianism
By Thomas Wood April 17 at 6:00 AM
During the 2016 presidential campaign, many observers wondered exactly what motivated voters most: Was it income? Authoritarianism? Racial attitudes?
Let the analyses begin. Last week, the widely respected 2016 American National Election Study was released, sending political scientists into a flurry of data modeling and chart making.
The ANES has been conducted since 1948, at first through in-person surveys, and now also online, with about 1,200 nationally representative respondents answering some questions for about 80 minutes. This incredibly rich, publicly funded data source allows us to put elections into historical perspective, examining how much each factor affected the vote in 2016 compared with other recent elections.
Below, I’ll examine three narratives that became widely accepted about the 2016 election and see how they stack up against the ANES data.
The rich, the poor, and the in-between
The first narrative was about how income affected vote choice. Trump was said to be unusually appealing to low-income voters, especially in the Midwest, compared with recent Republican presidential nominees. True or false?
[ How fights over Trump led many evangelicals to leave their congregations ]
The ANES provides us data on income and presidential vote choice going back to 1948. To remove the effects of inflation and rising prosperity, I plot the percentage voting for the Republican presidential candidate relative to the overall sample, by where they rank in U.S. income, from the top to the bottom fifth. The dashed horizontal line shows the average likelihood of voting for the GOP presidential candidate that year; a point above that means an income cohort was more likely than the other groups to vote for the Republican. To most directly test the Donald Trump income hypothesis, I’ve restricted this analysis to white voters.
2016 was plainly an anomaly. While the wealthy are usually most likely to vote for the Republican, they didn’t this time; and while the poor are usually less likely to vote for the Republican, they were unusually supportive of Trump. And the degree to which the wealthy disdained the 2016 Republican candidate was without recent historical precedent.
Authoritarians or not?
Many commentators and social scientists wrote about how much about authoritarianism influenced voters. Authoritarianism, as used by political scientists, isn’t the same as fascism; it’s a psychological disposition in which voters have an aversion to social change and threats to social order. Since respondents might not want to say they fear chaos or are drawn to strong leadership, this disposition is measured by asking voters about the right way to rear children.
[ Hackers just dumped a trove of NSA data. Here’s what it means. ]
The idea is that voters anxious about change and disorder will say it’s best to encourage children to follow rules. For instance, respondents are asked whether it’s better when children are considerate (likely more liberal) or well-behaved (likely more authoritarian), or whether they should be self-reliant (likely more liberal) or obedient (likely more authoritarian).
The next chart shows how white GOP presidential voters have answered these questions since 2000. As we can see, Trump’s voters appear a little less authoritarian than recent white Republican voters.
Did racism affect the voting?
Many observers debated how important Trump’s racial appeals were to his voters. During the campaign, Trump made overt racial comments , with seemingly little electoral penalty. Could the unusual 2016 race have further affected Americans’ racial attitudes?
To test this, I use what is called the “symbolic racism scale” to compare whites who voted for the Democratic presidential candidate with those who voted for the Republican. This scale measures racial attitudes among respondents who know that it’s socially unacceptable to say things perceived as racially prejudiced. Rather than asking overtly prejudiced questions — “do you believe blacks are lazy” — we ask whether racial inequalities today are a result of social bias or personal lack of effort and irresponsibility.
[ Why did Scott Pruitt refuse to ban a chemical that the EPA itself said is dangerous? ]
In the chart below, you can see the scores for white voters who supported the Democratic and Republican presidential candidates between 1988 and 2016. For clarity, the second and fourth items have been reversed so that the larger values always indicate higher animosity.
Since 1988, we’ve never seen such a clear correspondence between vote choice and racial perceptions. The biggest movement was among those who voted for the Democrat, who were far less likely to agree with attitudes coded as more racially biased.
So which of these had the biggest influence?
Finally, the statistical tool of regression can tease apart which had more influence on the 2016 vote: authoritarianism or symbolic racism, after controlling for education, race, ideology, and age. Moving from the 50th to the 75th percentile in the authoritarian scale made someone about 3 percent more likely to vote for Trump. The same jump on the SRS scale made someone 20 percent more likely to vote for Trump.
Racial attitudes made a bigger difference in electing Trump than authoritarianism.
Thomas Wood is an assistant professor of political science at Ohio State University. He studies public opinion and elections. Follow him on Twitter @thomasjwood.

Bottom line:
Racial attitudes made a bigger difference in electing Trump than authoritarianism.
I wish I could say that I'm shocked but.....I'm not. Nothing like the scum of the earth bringing out the best in people.
Sadly I'm not surprised either. Without the strong support of the Alt Right, White Nationalist Racists embodied by Steve Bannon and Brietbart, plus all of the ol' gang of Racist groups like the Klan who answered Trump's constant and loud dog whistle, along with a very strong shove over the top by Putin, his diapered ass would not be sitting where real Presidents, instead of a phony one, have sat.
BTW PJ, great poll and unimpeachable sources. Both Ohio State University and The Washington Post. And being a U of M fan that first part was hard to say.
Racial attitudes made a bigger difference in electing Trump than authoritarianism.
I wish I could say that I'm shocked but.....I'm not. Nothing like the scum of the earth bringing out the best in people.
One indication-- what David Duke said about Trump:
Former Ku Klux Klan leader David Duke is calling Donald Trump's electoral victory "one of the most exciting nights of my life."
Duke, a white nationalist who unsuccessfully ran for Louisiana Senate, tweeted early Wednesday that his supporters played a major part in paving Trump's road to the presidency.
"Make no mistake about it, our people have played a HUGE role in electing Trump!" he wrote.
This was pretty well known throughout. When you have tweets and videos and facebooks praising your campaign for speaking out on behalf of the silent white majority, it is a safe bet you are not attracting choirboys and girls.
Yes, but it's good to have it right there in black and white although those who support this piece of shit won't believe it because it's facts after all.
Well everyone knows that facts, like the truth, have a liberal bias.
Yes, but it's good to have it right there in black and white although those who support this piece of shit won't believe it because it's facts after all.
Just like every poll I saw before the election (& there were lots of 'em) said that Hillary would win the election.
But even though all that information was there "in black and white" some people didn't believe those polls because its facts after all, that Hillary would win.
Lots of facts proving Hillary would win-- in black and white no less (OMG!!!) why didn't the fools believe all that "scientific" proof that Hillary would win?
(Oh-- and did I mention?-- all that data proving that Hillary would win was....IN BLACK AND WHITE!!!)
"This scale measures racial attitudes among respondents who know that it’s socially unacceptable to say things perceived as racially prejudiced. Rather than asking overtly prejudiced questions — “do you believe blacks are lazy” — we ask whether racial inequalities today are a result of social bias or personal lack of effort and irresponsibility."
This has to be one of the most screwed up polls I ever seen in life. How can anyone take this seriously?
This has to be one of the most screwed up polls I ever seen in life
I couldn't agree you this statement any more. I mean..... how screwed up are people that they are so intimidated by other races that they would vote this scumbag into the oval office. They must really hate blacks, women, and other non white peeps.
How can anyone take this seriously?
Facts are funny like that.......It's right there in black and white. Sorry you don't like it.
I mean..... how screwed up are people that they are so intimidated by other races that they would vote this scumbag into the oval office. They must really hate blacks, women, and other non white peeps.
I didn't think there were enough angry white racists left in America to help get Trump elected, but it looks like I was wrong.
This has to be one of the most screwed up polls I ever seen in life. How can anyone take this seriously?
It's really sad to see how disturbed these people have become. I guess they are going to run in the next election as ""I'm Not Donald Trump".
First thing I see in the article is a link to the Huffington Post and The Washington Post. Then Vox, the website that introduced itself as being a different kind of news source saying they were going to explain the news so people would understand it. One of the most Liberal websites every to come about. Not to be outdone, Politico is the next link in the article and then back to the Washington Post for several links.
If it makes them feel better, I guess it's worth it to them. They aren't learning anything, but at least they feel better.
To test this, I use what is called the “symbolic racism scale” to compare whites who voted for the Democratic presidential candidate with those who voted for the Republican. This scale measures racial attitudes among respondents who know that it’s socially unacceptable to say things perceived as racially prejudiced. Rather than asking overtly prejudiced questions — “do you believe blacks are lazy” — we ask whether racial inequalities today are a result of social bias or personal lack of effort and irresponsibility.
This is a perfect example of why social science is not an actual science. Racial inequality is obviously the result of social bias because "racial" inequality is, by definition, based on race. However, lack of success economically can be based on social bias, lack of effort, or both. If this same question is put to blacks, you'd probably get the same breakdown by party but I doubt anybody would seriously suggest that blacks who voted republican did so out of racism. If blacks would answer the question the same way whites did based on party, but the motive for the answer is assumed to be different based on race, then maybe the poll is racist.
The poll admits its racism. It clearly sets out that it is a poll of "whites only". I haven't seen a sign like that since the 1950s. I wonder how it might differ if it were not a racist poll and were inclusive instead. I wonder also if it were inclusive how it would compare to a similar poll made after Obama was elected. And as in any poll, the questions are designed and the persons chosen to reply to elicit desired responses. I would have said the same had the poll's result been different. Ah, but how fast the lefties have jumped on unquestioning justification, notwithstanding these factors.
And as in any poll, the questions are designed and the persons chosen to reply to elicit desired responses. I would have said the same had the poll's result been different. Ah, but how fast the lefties have jumped on unquestioning justification, notwithstanding these factors.
Some previously mentioned over-generalization as being a common logical fallacy leading to unclear thinking. There's another type of fallacious reasoning,that's actually rather interesting. Its called "Confirmatiion Bias".
Here's one description of "Confirmation Bias I found
Your opinions are the result of years of paying attention to information which confirmed what you believed while ignoring information which challenged your preconceived notions.
("Conformation Bias" is merely a high falutin' way of sasying that most people pay attention to, and tend to believe, any new information that reinforces their existing prejudices...and ignore information that contradicts them...)
Some might consider it unpatriotic to question their own opinions - to try to comprehend the other side of the coin.
Your opinions are the result of years of paying attention to information which confirmed what you believed while ignoring information which challenged your preconceived notions.
("Conformation Bias" is merely a high falutin' way of sasying that most people pay attention to, and tend to believe, any new information that reinforces their existing prejudices...and ignore information that contradicts them...)
I can go for the first part of this Krishna, but why does it have to be prejudices in your last part?
Oh course people are more inclined to believe anything that reinforces their current beliefs and it is not easy to see other things that contradict those beliefs by anyone.
My current belief is this poll is a Liberal's way of dealing with loss of their candidate. They have to continue to reinforce the belief it had nothing to do with her by coming up with these wild accusations that racism was the only reason she lost to a big mouth candidate who had no respect for Political Correctness at all. He wasn't prejudice, he attacked anyone who attacked him, only twice as much.
I think they better start learning something because "I'm not Donald Trump" isn't going to go very far in the elections to come.
Bring it down a bit professor. You're point is a good one but I don't think it applies to this article. Social science is like behavioral science. There's a science to it but it's an evolving one since it's driven by how people respond and react. This is about what motivated a group of voters to vote like they've never voted before and the common factor was determined to be because of race.
This is about what motivated a group of voters to vote like they've never voted before and the common factor was determined to be race.
I think the poll is flawed on its face both as a matter of science and logic. It strikes me like a transparent attempt to prove, through a false analysis, that Trump was elected by racists.
They weren't all racists just most of them. The rest were dumbasses or anti regulation, anti equality, anti immigrant, anti civil liberty.........in other words, dumbasses.
I vote the rest were mostly just dumbasses....
They weren't all racists just most of them. The rest were dumbasses or anti regulation, anti equality, anti immigrant, anti civil liberty.........in other words, dumbasses.
IMO one of the most common fallacies to clear thinking is the widespread tendency to iover-generalize. It happens out side of the Internet, but seems to be more extreme online.
It really annoys me when people say:
People voted for Trump because..
And equally fallacious:
People voted for Hillary because..
Why? Simply because both the statements are inaccurate. They both imply that there was only one reason that people voted for their candidate. And all people voting for any candidate do not do so for the same reasons!
It is true that an unusually large percentage of racists voted for Trump. (IN fact, if memory serves, David Duke said that Trump was the first pres. candidate in a while he felt he could support).
However, all Trump supporters did not vote for him because of racism-- in fact, many are not racist in the least. They voted for him for other reasons.
However, all Trump supporters did not vote for him because of racism-- in fact, many are not racist in the least. They voted for him for other reasons.
But even beyond that, to say that the ones who voted for Trump for reasons other than racism did so because:
They weren't all racists just most of them. The rest were dumbasses or anti regulation, anti equality, anti immigrant, anti civil liberty.........in other words, dumbasses.
Very similar. Yes-- I'm sure some of the non-racists who voted for Trump were dumbasses. And some were anti regulation, and/or anti immigrant, and/or anti civil liberty.
But again-- there were some who voted for him form other reasons as well. (And to deny that is misleading).
I can think of at least two other reasons-- both of which are significant. (And unless Democrats stop believing in these over-generalizations, they will continue to lose elections...),
I agree!
Me too.
Me too.
Buzz-- both you and Perrie are correct in this regard!
Well said, Krishna. It's the typical overly wide brush used to cover over everything instead of actually searching for all the answers.
They weren't all racists just most of them. The rest were dumbasses or anti regulation, anti equality, anti immigrant, anti civil liberty.........in other words, dumbasses.
Pj: do you know anyone who voted for Trump? Or what's more relevant-- have you ever spoken to a Trump voter and asked them why they voted for Trump?
Pj: Do You Know Anyone Who Voted For Trump? Or What's More Relevant-- Have You Ever Spoken To A Trump Voter And Asked Them Why They Voted For Trump?
Yes, I actually know a number of Trump voters. 3 are siblings of mine. 2 live in Paw Paw West Virginia and they are reeeeedneeeecks 100% along with being alcoholics. They've lived on the system off and on and never really had any motivation to improve their lot in life. One actually left her kids to fend for themselves and ran off with a man. We're really proud of her. Then there's my brother. He believes that women should stay at home and take care of their men! My sister in law is quite the little woman. She's so timid and weak and does whatever my brother tells her to do. He's a fine specimen of a man in between the drugs and alcohol binges. They are true Republicans and avid Trump supporters. hee haw
I don't visit "home" much.....lol
Do you blame them for taking what the system is offfering or the politicians that set up the system that rewards laziness and punishes productivity? This is what the welfare system does creates this situation. I think we all know someone that has decided no work is preferable to work because the collective will supply for them.
Well said. Many of us voted for Trump to ensure that the harridan would not appoint another liberal activist to the SCOTUS. Success.
I think the poll is flawed on its face both as a matter of science and logic. It strikes me like a transparent attempt to prove, through a false analysis, that Trump was elected by racists.
That does seem to be the case.
It would be interesting for someone to go back and evaluate the amount of African Americans that voted for President Obama, especially in his first presidential election and survey 'why?'. I wonder if the results would also be boiled down to racism? Though that would be less than politically correct.........
This is about what motivated a group of voters to vote like they've never voted before and the common factor was determined to be because of race.
I think that is true.
However, the key phrase is "a group of voters". That does not mean all groups of Trump voters-- only one. There were numerous other Trump voters who did not vote for him based on race (I know some of them...).
Assuming that because "a group" (i.e. one group) voted for him for this reason does not mean that all-- or even that most-- did for that reason.
To believe that is a logical fallacy. (Its called over-generalization, although there's a second common logical fallacy involved in that sort of thinking as well).
This is about what motivated a group of voters to vote like they've never voted before and the common factor was determined to be because of race.
Well, since this study was about what motivated voters to vote who had never voted before-- it has only looked at a small minority of those who voted for Trump!
BTW-- for that small group, from what I know-- that would seem to be true- (for voters who never voted before).
Although, interestingly, many people commenting here don't realize that-- that are making the assumption that the study said that all Trump voters were studied-- when in fact the study was only about a very small minority of Trump voters!!!
This is about what motivated a group of voters to vote like they've never voted before and the common factor was determined to be because of race.
Sorry Krish, but you misunderstood that sentence.
This is about what motivated a group of voters to vote like they've never voted before and the common factor was determined to be because of race.
"Like" is the key word, and it makes the sentence mean something other than what you think it does.
Try this -
This is about what motivated a group of voters to vote in a way they've never voted before and the common factor was determined to be because of race.
This is about what motivated a group of voters to vote like they've never voted before and the common factor was determined to be because of race.
Sorry Krish, but you misunderstood that sentence.
This is about what motivated a group of voters to vote like they've never voted before and the common factor was determined to be because of race.
You're right-- don't know how I missed that!
And its the the change that is significant. (Democrats voting for Hillary and Republicans who voted for Trump doesn't help to understand the election-- because that what they usually do. What made the difference between this presidential election and the last one was voters who voted for Obama last time and who switched-- and voted for Trump this time.
So why did these voters switch? Well, for starters, the states that voted Democratic last time and who went Republican this time were mainly "Rust Belt states".
Well, for starters, the states that voted Democratic last time and who went Republican this time were mainly "Rust Belt states".
They were and are desperate and I don't blame them. The Democrats couldn't bring their jobs back and they believed that Trump can. He can't. Most of their jobs didn't go overseas, they went to automation, robots. And the ones that did go overseas are not coming back no matter what Trump does. Only the creation of new jobs can help. New technologies and the opportunities for them to retrain for little or no money to fill them in areas such as clean energy. Also, if the infrastructure bill actually goes through (and I believe it can), then there will be a massive need for workers in the Trades. Not everyone needs to be a IT Specialist when they can make a really good wage as a journeyman welder or electrician or carpenter or other construction worker or support job that supports their family.
Well, for starters, the states that voted Democratic last time and who went Republican this time were mainly "Rust Belt states".
They were and are desperate and I don't blame them. The Democrats couldn't bring their jobs back and they believed that Trump can.
Well, I'm not going to get toom partisan here. But basically, that's the main reason Trump won. ..jobs.
If California or Massachusetts goes Democratic, it doesn't change things-- because they almost always do-- just as the Deep South and Rocky Mtn states usually go Republican.
To see what changed this time-- look at the "Rust Belt" states in the industrial mid-West. Blue collar (mostly unionized) factory workers.One of the main pillars of the Democratic Party.But this time most switeched-- they went for Obama last time, but Trump this time.
Why? Because people had lost "secure" jobs they had their whole working like. Trump said he's bring back jobs-- enough of those folks believed him to vote Republican (many for the first time in their lives).
So the main implication of this article (That Trump's voters were racists) is false and misleading.
That's what I said.
"racial" inequality is, by definition, based on race.
Theoretically, yes,
But some people believe otherwise. For example, some people say that if you hate/discriminate Muslims you are a racist-- that obviously you're views/actions re:Muslims is based on race.
Which is, of course, total nonsense. Why? Because Muslims are not a distinct race (or for that matter even a distinct ethnic group). Islam is a religion-- not a race!
White Nationalist Claims Trump Made Him Beat Up African American Woman 00:41
A white nationalist leader claims President Donald Trump directed him and other supporters to remove protestors from a Trump rally in Kentucky. According to Politico, the man is accused of assaulting.. Source: Wochit Headline News - about an hour agoI got to say, that I am having a hard time believing this poll. I know a lot of people who voted for Trump, and many of them did it because they were sick of the status quo and business as usual in our government. None of these people are racists. In many ways, they were a lot like the Bernie voters, but have a different political POV.
I am sure that there were those who voted for Trump because they were racists. But there is no way he could have won on the racist vote alone. That would be like saying that Obama won on the black vote alone. It just didn't happen.
Exactly!
And BTW, I also know some Trump voters as well. One did not vote for him because of race issues (although I suppose he is a bit prejudiced-- but that wasn't the reason he voted for Trump).
However, I also know 4 or 5 others who voted for Trump-- none of them are racist. (In fact one is non-white...and an immigrant as well!).
The problem in this discussion that leads to fallacies in logical think is due to...over-generalization!
No matter, Perrie. To those who support and agree that this article is NOT flawed will support ANYTHING that will explain the reason their candidate lost. "Any port in the storm" they say, and there is a port in which they can find shelter - and as I have seen from so many articles and comments here, they don't have the guts to weather the storm, to roll up their sails and survive through the reality of it.
and as I have seen from so many articles and comments here, they don't have the guts to weather the storm, to roll up their sails and survive through the reality of it.
What a ludicrous comment.
What a ludicrous comment.
Yes-- I was totally shocked by it as well-- after all, ludicrous comments are so extremely rare in political discussions here!.
/s
"Any port in the storm"
Well, if you can't find a good Port, just about anything else will do (just as long as its not something like Thunderbird or Night Train ...yuk!
Dow's Vintage Port 1963
A bottle of Dow's Vintage Port 1963 may set you back three hundred dollars but this port really is as good as it gets . It's incredibly well-balanced, with lots of concentrated berry flavor and earthy notes on the nose. The alcohol flavor isn't overly harsh, and the tannin just noticeable on the finish.
I never drink...wine...
Accepting a glass of wine from a vampire is similar to buying grivelach from a mohel. (If you don't understand that, ask your wife).
I understand and it reminds me of a joke. A man walks through a Jewish neighborhood everyday on his way to work. Each day he passes the same shop that has a large ticking clock hanging in the window and a Star of David on the glass. He doesn't think too much about it until on day when the clock at his house stops working. So on his way to work he brings his clock along and goes into the store front to talk to the man. He starts to explain that his clock doesn't work when the man stops him and says "I don't fix clocks. I'm a Mohel." The man is confused and says "So why do you have a clock hanging in your window?" To which the Mohel says, "So what do you think I should have hanging there?"
When you marry a Jewish woman you get to hear a lot of good Jewish jokes! LOL!
I've been married to a Chinese woman for more than 8 years and I haven't heard a Chinese joke yet.
A bottle of Dow's Vintage Port 1963 may set you back three hundred dollars but this port really is as good as it gets. It's incredibly well-balanced, with lots of concentrated berry flavor and earthy notes on the nose. The alcohol flavor isn't overly harsh, and the tannin just noticeable on the finish.
I totally agree. (But it is a bit expensive, so as a result I try to limit myself to drinking only 1 bottle/week!)
There is a gourmet store near here and in their liquor department they have a bottle of Napoleon Brandy that sells for $4,000.00 (plus 10% tax). I have always wondered whenever I pass the heavily locked case just what a snifter of that would taste like? (sigh)
No matter, Perrie. To those who support and agree that this article is NOT flawed will support ANYTHING that will explain the reason their candidate lost. "Any port in the storm" they say, and there is a port in which they can find shelter - and as I have seen from so many articles and comments here, they don't have the guts to weather the storm, to roll up their sails and survive through the reality of it.
"Confirmation Bias":
Your opinions are the result of years of paying attention to information which confirmed what you believed while ignoring information which challenged your preconceived notions.
And while everyone is trying to figure out whether of not that supports their political agenda, let me say that it applies to some people of any political POV!
It's funny that some people refuse to accept that:
A. The Dems ran a shitty candidate
B. A large swath right down the middle of America is sick and tired of the Same ole', Same Ole' of politicians saying all the 'right' things, then going and making themselves and their cronies rich, while doing nothing for their constituents.
many of them did it because they were sick of the status quo and business as usual in our government.
It is sad that people would vote for someone as profoundly unqualified as Trump was/is. How do they sleep at night?
It is sad that people would vote for someone as profoundly unqualified as Trump was/is. How do they sleep at night?
Sheesh-- Do you actually not know?
OK then-- I will tell you.
The reason is-- that while you have a very strong opinion on the subject..believe it or not, Trump voters have a different opinion.
Seriously-- not everything thinks exactly alike. (After all, if they did, we wouldn't need to have elections...would we?).
Understandably, this comes as a shock to you-- but here's something to think about: everyone isn't exactly alike!
(And just as you are so sure that you are right and they are wrong-- they feel the same way about people with your political views).
Diversity is pretty Amazing, eh?
The reason is-- that while you have a very strong opinion on the subject..believe it or not, Trump voters have a different opinion.
Why don't you tell us about Trump's qualifications.