Trevor Noah destroys states celebrating Confederate Memorial Day
http://mashable.com/2017/04/27/daily-show-trevor-noah-confederate-memorial-day/#SB5QaExOqkqP
A small number of states in the South observed Confederate Memorial Day this week and Trevor Noah has a few questions for those who decided to celebrate.
“First of all, the Confederacy fought the Civil War to defend slavery,” the “Daily Show” host said Wednesday night. “Why would you honor that? Secondly, what are black people supposed to do on this holiday?”
Noah attempted to unpack the controversial holiday during Wednesday’s episode, but he couldn’t get past the racial undertones of the Confederacy. He even found a stunning similarity between all the people who spoke out against the holiday on local news channels. (They’re all black.)
The host did try to cut some slack for those who genuinely believe that Confederate Memorial Day celebrates their ancestors’ history and somehow doesn’t honor white supremacy. But, as Noah pointed out, that’s a hard case to make when some confederate monuments literally have the words “ white supremacy ” engraved onto them.
Noah also addressed the threats that workers tasked with taking down these types of statues have received, showing just how serious some people are about defending the Confederacy.
“City officials are wearing full body armor because they’re afraid that radicals with extreme beliefs might kill them,” he said. “I wish there was a word to describe those kinds of people.”
But the “Daily Show” host didn’t just bash the state holiday. He also offered some suggestions to make the Confederate Memorial Day ― and those racist monuments ― fair for everyone.
“If it’s all part of your history, then maybe you should include all of the history,” Noah said. “If you want to have the monument, then you should have to have a slave next to it ― for context!”
Tags
Who is online
97 visitors

He has a good idea. Require every statue of a confederate hero be accompanied by a statue of a slave in the field.
that COULD bring back the lawn jockey industry, its was killed by PC a while ago.......(SARC)
Or put them in a museum where they belong.
or put them on private property.
Either way, I am good. But they don't belong on public land.
Confederate Memorial Day , also called Confederate Heroes Day in Texas , is a public holiday observed by the U.S. states of Alabama , Florida , Mississippi , South Carolina , Louisiana and Texas since the end of the American Civil War to remember the estimated 258,000 members of the Confederate States Army , Navy , Marines , and militia who died in combat while fighting against the United States. [1] The day is also marked by observances in many other states. It is observed in late April in most southern states to recall the surrender of the last major Confederate field army at Bennett Place on that date in 1865. [2]
not only about statues
Confederate Memorial Day , also called Confederate Heroes Day in Texas , is a public holiday observed by the U.S.
I've never heard of it, and I can assure you it isn't observed with any pomp and circumstance in Texas. As a matter of fact, I just checked every calendar in the house, and none of them had a 'Confederate Heroes Day' pre-printed notation on January 19th. However, Juneteenth, officially observed on June 19th, is freaking huge. The entire month is fill with festivities relating to the abolition of slavery. Happy to say that one does have a pre-printed notation in all of our calendars.
On a related note, Texas Belly Laugh Day is observed on January 24th. I've never heard of that one, either.
On a related note, Texas Belly Laugh Day is observed on January 24th. I've never heard of that one, either.
You ought to look into that. I'll bet it's a real hoot!
Either way, I am good. But they don't belong on public land.
Sounds like the perfect solution to me. Museums or private property. Problem solved.
John , this might be off topic , and if you deem it is please feel free to have it removed. when they raised the CSS Hunley, there were still remains on board and they were treated to confederate honors as is custom , now the customs of honoring repartated remains in the manner as the country they served is common even if the country no longer exists. Is that wrong?
and keep in mind that by federal law, confederate graves , and monuments of memorial are protected as if they are US war dead and monuments, we had that discussion and I posted the relevant law during the battle flag incidents where they were being removed from graves on public lands. Like it or not , they are still considered by law , graves and memorials to US Military dead.
There is a line there to be drawn between simply honoring those who died for a given state, and engaging in "lost cause" ideology.
"Basic assumptions of the Lost Cause have proved durable for many in the modern South. Lost Cause tenets are frequently voiced during controversies surrounding public display of the Confederate flags and various state flags. Historian John Coski noted that the Sons of Confederate Veterans , the "most visible, active, and effective defender of the flag", "carried forward into the twenty-first century, virtually unchanged, the Lost Cause historical interpretations and ideological vision formulated at the turn of the twentieth."
There is a line there to be drawn between simply honoring those who died for a given state, and engaging in "lost cause" ideology.
John, you can honor a cause or a person, and still avoid causing pain and suffering to others. No one wants to think their ancestors died pointless deaths. As for 'lost cause ideology'...that's your term, and it sucks. So does your 'family picnic' comment. It's rather pompous of you to think you should have a say in the way anyone honors their family history.
Personally speaking, I'm proud of my family history, both my adopted family history, and my birth family history. My birth family gave me my Cherokee heritage, and my adopted family gave me everything else. I'm immensely proud of my Uncle Elijah P. Lovejoy and the part he played in the abolition of slavery. But his other passion was the for the term he coined: Freedom of the Press. I think you have heard of it, right? Uncle Elijah died fighting for the very thing we enjoy here...speaking our minds.
This is Uncle Elijah's monument in Alton Illinois, which is about a 4-hour drive from where you live.
If someone wanted to tear it down, they would have to go through me and my family to do it. But if someone felt strongly about adding some sort of Confederate mention or amendment, we, as a family, would encourage it. Today's descendants of the Confederacy had nothing to do with killing him. They are just as entitled to honor their ancestors in the way they deem appropriate. Both sides of the story should be important to every American citizen.
Besides, just like pro-choice doesn't mean pro-abortion, pride in one's Confederate ancestry doesn't mean pro-slavery.
As long as they use the word "confederate" in any of their language, terminology, monuments etc, it is not acceptable. The Confederate States Of America was the world's first avowedly white supremacist national entity. The confederate flag was flown in battle in service of that government. It is what it is Sister.
It's fine with me. If it pisses freedom strippers off even better yet. I don't buy into that PC crap the lefties keep trying to force upon us.
As long as they use the word "confederate" in any of their language, terminology, monuments etc, it is not acceptable.
Oh for crying out loud. I call you John. Does that make you an American Standard White Colony 1.28 GPF two-piece elongated round-front with a 12" Rough-in?
Or in simpler terms...
Actually it's more properly called a Crapper and it was named after a plumber named Thomas Crapper, who in the 1880's became the first royal supplier of Crappers to Prince Edward who later became King Edward the VIII and by the way, I love those elongated front ones because if you are an older man like myself it makes sure that while sitting down you will not accidentally piss between the crapper and the toilet seat (I refuse to tell you why that can happen) and onto the back of your pulled down pants or PJ's. Very nice! We have four Crappers in our house and only one is one of the elongated ones and one of my lottery dreams is to have a house with nothing but the elongated ones.
We have a Confederate cemetery in my area. BTW, it is not public land. It is quite a nice memorial and if the ceremony bothers anyone, then, that's their problem. Up the road a piece is the Marriott Grand Hotel. At one time, it was just the Grand Hotel with a history of being a confederate hospital. In my part of the South we get along fine without any outside help. It is called respect for one another!