To a generation of younger Americans, waging the War in Afghanistan must seem like one of the things our government does as a matter of course, like collecting taxes or distributing Social Security payments. The vast majority of students graduating from high school this spring have no memory of a time when we weren't fighting in that far away country. And soon enough, some number of them will likely arrive there to continue the campaign.
Donald Trump, in one of his occasional peacenik fits on the campaign trail, expressed enthusiasm for ending the war. Now that he's in office, however, he's mulling another surge of troops to support the beleaguered and hopelessly corrupt government we helped install in Kabul.
At least 90 killed in suicide truck bombing in Kabul
The reasons why we should risk more American lives and spend more taxpayer money on such an adventure are, at best, unclear. The arguments for why we shouldn't, on the other hand, are quite obvious.
The first argument is that nobody knows what victory in Afghanistan would even look like. We originally invaded the country in order to remove the Taliban government, which at the time controlled most of the country and provided a safe haven to Osama bin Laden and Al-Qaeda.
Bin Laden is thankfully dead, but Al-Qaeda has moved on to establish safe havens elsewhere, and the Taliban now controls more territory in Afghanistan than at any point before the invasion. ISIS is getting in on the action, too, having claimed a stretch of land along the porous Pakistani border.
Progress is being made, in other words, but not by us. Trump's generals hope he will send an additional 3,000 to 5,000 troops to the country to help remedy the situation. To put that number in perspective, we currently have about 8,400 troops there, down from 100,000 in President Obama's first term .
How such a modest surge would do much to defeat the Taliban, or bring them to the negotiating table, is anyone's guess. Far and away the most likely scenario is that it just prolongs the current stalemate, which at this point seems to be America's only real goal in the country. Defeat may be inevitable, but can be prolonged indefinitely.
Perhaps defeat is too strong a word, because America doesn't lose wars anymore, so much as we just don't win them. Since the end of World War II, we've waged a number of them, but had only one or two clear-cut victories: the 1983 toppling of a Cuban-sponsored junta in Grenada , and perhaps the emancipation of Kosovo from Serbian rule via a brief bombing campaign.
Why is that? Well, it's not for lack of cash. Despite the frequent Republican lament that our military is somehow hobbled by budget cuts, we still spend more on our armed forces than Russia, China, France, India, Great Britain, Israel, Australia, South Korea, Brazil, Iran, Spain, Canada, and Turkey combined.
Proponents of such expenditures often note that this allows the U.S. to garrison its forces worldwide, from Europe to Africa to Asia. That's nice, but you'd think, for all that money spent, we could decisively vanquish enemies like we did when we were a poorer, weaker country. Defense spending gobbles up roughly half of our discretionary budget, so if we're not in the business of winning wars outright anymore, perhaps we should wage fewer of them and spend more of that money on other things.
The rejoinder here is that modern wars can't always be fought to decisive conclusions, but are still worthwhile. The world wars were big conflicts, which we now avoid in part by constantly fighting small ones. If no entity is in a position to pose any kind of real, existential threat to the United States, then the little wars in Iraq, Syria, Afghanistan, and the rest are a small price to pay.
In reality, the price is quite large. Thousands of Americans have died in our post-9/11 wars, along with hundreds of thousands of the foreign civilians we set out to liberate. In a pure dollar amount, we've sunk more into Afghan reconstruction that we did to rebuild Western Europe after World War II.
Army Rangers may have been killed by friendly fire
For all that, Afghanistan remains a backwards, largely illiterate, and essentially feudal society of competing tribes and Islamist militants with no real central government. Setting up some kind of stable democratic government in Afghanistan was always a transparently fantastical notion, but for all the money spent, it stands to reason that we should expect a little more by way of results.
Yet Afghanistan remains a sideshow, one only rarely talked about on the campaign trail in 2016. The public's focus has long since moved on to other calamities. We've reduced the longest running war in our history to background noise.
This makes sense, to a certain extent, because why would we bother ourselves with a problem with no solution? Leaving now would be traumatic for the national psyche. This is the war we waged to avenge the greatest attack ever launched against us; how can we admit to ourselves that that fight is ending in what could be charitably called a draw?
The other option – a seemingly endless war in a place of limited strategic interest -- is not much better, and in many ways far worse. In a 2015 interview, then-candidate Trump once famously called the war a "mistake." Tellingly, it's one of the few statements he felt compelled to retract under political pressure. Say what you will about women and POWs, Mr. Trump, but never call the Afghan War a mistake.
In that same interview, Mr. Trump asked how long Washington expected American forces to remain in Afghanistan: "Are they going to be there for the next 200 years? You know, at some point, what's going on?"
This is still a pressing question. And now that he's president, he has the opportunity to provide us with an answer.

For a better understanding of how long we have actually been involved, read the book, ''Charlie Wilson's War''....
The one that that will stand out the most is his quote, ''we fucked up the end game''.
Why are we still there?
That is a favorite book of mine. The movie is quite good as well.
It was a very good movie and Tom Hanks did a great job.
I don't know, Kavika. I wish I did. I have heard that we are staying there to defend the people we 'liberated' from retribution by the Taliban. But I don't know if that is right...
Once again the Taliban control much of the country and ISIS is there as well.
All we have done is cost lives and spend money. IMO, it simply isn't worth it.
Trump is considering adding thousands of troops to our force in Afghanistan and restarting a "surge".
Sigh...
3,000 to 5,000 more troops which doesn't mean much except more Americans with targets on their back.
Even the ''mother of all bombs'' did nothing to change the course of what is happening there.
I don't think that anything will. It is what it is. I want to bring our girls and boys home.
If the Taliban terrorists were the only terrorists on earth it might make sense to stay there and suppress their activity. But they are not.
I remember when it was announced that we were going to invade Afghanistan. I told my wife, we have learned nothing from the British and the Russians. It will never be conquered.
When the Russians had been there for several years, the news was all about the Russian Vietnam, well, if we wanted a second Vietnam, we have it. The result will be the same.
Steve, about the only difference between Vietnam and Afghanistan is the number of American killed.
When the Russians were driven out, American had a great chance to stabilize the country. But, for the lack of a few million dollars we chose to ignore it and years later went bumbling back in and are still there, and probably will be there for years to come.
Charlies Wilson quote, ''we fucked up the end game'' is spot on.
Steve,
Here is where we made our mistake. Regan decided to take down the USSR, we had to help the Mujahideen. They learned everything about us. Our weapons, our tactics, our character.. and with that, they learned to despise us. And who came from that? Bin Ladin. It was Reagan's obsession with Russia that did this to us. Between that and the first gulf war, 9/11 was the inevitable outcome from it. Yes Charlie Wilson had it right, but had we not been there in the first place, he wouldn't have had to be right.
Good question, there is nothing we need to protect in that part of the world.
We didn't go there to protect. We went BACK there for payback for 9/11. The nation building was just a line to justify the payback.
We went BACK there for payback for 9/11.
Not as much as to interfere with the extremist activity in Afghanistan & the neighboring mountains in Pakistan ..
Which is where the plot for 9/11 originated.
Bin Laden is dead, time to come home.
I don't think anyone would disagree with that... but it doesn't mean that the terrorism will go away either.
I had no problem with the attack on Afghanistan to go after Al Qaeda and the Taliban. We were attacked and no retaliation was unthinkable. What I had and have a problem with was the nation building occupation that followed and the fact that the invasion of Afghanistan was used as nothing more then a springboard to launch a completely unnecessary and unbelievably stupid war of choice, unprovoked invasion and conquest in Iraq. Bush was wrong to do that and wrong to keep troops in Afghanistan. Obama was wrong to keep troops in Afghanistan (especially after Bin Laden was killed) and Trump is a mental midget if he not only doesn't pull the troops we have there out, but rather adds more to them.
Going after Al Qaeda was the right thing to do, but we didn't finish the job and instead invaded Iraq, which was IMO one of the most stupid things the US has ever done.
Now all these later we are still in both countries. And who knows for how much longer.
Early in our excursions in Afghanistan after 9-11, special forces and CIA operatives had some success working with, and imbedding with warlords. While it wasn't perfect, it did kill a shitload of terrorists, did establish some important relationships in country, and was not nation building.
Larry it started out with the best of intentions, but soon morphed into nothing and the attention was turned to Iraq (a huge mistake)...Once that happened you could kiss Agfanistan good bye. We have been bungling along for the last 15 years.
I believe America's continued presence in Afghanistan is to keep the Russians away from taking over. IMO all those warring tribes and feudal societies should just be left alone to kill each other off. It would be no loss to the civilized world. It is the Kurds and the Yazdis and innocent peaceful Christians that need protection.
Buzz, I think that the Russians learned their lesson the last time that invaded. I don't think you'll see them try that again. They have been a tribal society for thousands of years, and have never really been conquered by anyone.
We have created more problems there than we have solved.
As Larry mentioned in the first invasion when we went after Al Queda we used special forces that managed to get the various war lords on our side and they caused considerable damage to Al Queda...After that we lost focus and Bush decided to invade Iraq..
Everything went downhill from there.
You're probably right, Kavika. I guess I don't know enough about it. Oh, that we should all have hindsight, but prior to taking any steps.
You're probably right, Kavika. I guess I don't know enough about it. Oh, that we should all have hindsight, but prior to taking any steps.