How Ahmed’s clock became a false, convenient tale of racism
When is America going to get serious about the problem of white kids getting suspended from school for nothing?
By now youve heard the story of Ahmed Mohamed, crowned by the Daily Beast The Muslim Hero America Has Been Waiting For after the 14-year-old brought to school a beeping, strange-looking homemade concealed device that turned out to be a clock.
School officials, thinking, as 95% of Americans would, that it kinda looked like a bomb, hauled him out of class. Police put him in handcuffs and, even after the confusion passed, the boy was suspended from school.
That earned Mohamed a planned trip to the White House, a message of support from Hillary Clinton, an offer to stop by Facebook to meet Mark Zuckerberg and an invitation to be an intern at Twitter.
The police overreacted. Yet the device did look like something Ethan Hunt would lob out of a helicopter at the last minute in Mission: Impossible. As National Reviews Charles Cooke pointed out on Twitter, the scary-looking tangle of wires looks a lot more like a bomb than a pop tart looks like a gun.
Josh Welch, a white Maryland kid with ADHD who was 7 years old when he was kicked out of school for chewing a Pop-Tart into the shape of a pistol and pretending to shoot other students with it, must be puzzled.
Wheres his White House invitation? Wheres his chance to start networking at Facebook? His parents were forced to hire a lawyer and spent a year and a half just trying to get the suspension erased from the kids record. They were repeatedly refused.
I stand with Ahmed, too. But I also stand with Alex Stone, noted Reason writer Robby Soave. Alex Stone, a 16-year-old white kid from Summerville, SC, wrote a short story in which he imagined using a gun to kill a dinosaur. For this his locker was searched and he was arrested, handcuffed, charged with disorderly conduct and suspended from school for three days.
Obviously the White House and Mark Zuckerberg couldnt be bothered to comment, but youd think that, at the very least, Stephen King would have sent out a tweet expressing outrage that imagination was being punished.
Nada.
In Dyer County, Tenn., Kendra Turner says she was suspended for saying, Bless you after a student sneezed, and that her teacher told her that she would have no godly speaking in class.
Modal Trigger
The homemade clock that Ahmed Mohamed brought to school Photo: AP A school administrator said, This was not a religious issue at all, but more of an issue the teacher felt was a distraction in her class. Uh-huh. School leadership offered no explanation for the photos posted by students that showed bless you on a list of expressions banned in the classroom. Turner is still waiting for her call from President Obama.
Are white kids being punished en masse for dopey quasi-infractions because of their race? Of course not. Thats ridiculous.
But its equally absurd to suggest that you have to be Muslim, or brown-skinned, or live in Texas, to be subjected to overenthusiastic use of school discipline and police force.
It never would have happened to a white kid? It happens to white kids all. The. Time.
The main difference between the Ahmed Mohamed case and the others is that the mainstream media and the leftist point of view it presents just cant let go of Ahmed. Ahmed is too useful to their narrative to be a one-day story.
That Bristol Palin said on Facebook that President Obama didnt need to get involved in the situation proved irresistible for the media, which loves to depict America as a bitter standoff between red-state hicks on the one hand and sophisticated members of the cool bicoastal techno-media club on the other.
Lets just savor for a moment that the musings of the daughter of an unemployed former governor constitute national news. This year the brother of a sitting president made derogatory comments about the leader of the free world and the reaction from the media was crickets.
Malik Obama gets the courtesy of being ignored because he has also said some crazy things. Now imagine Bristol Palin making loony statements. Would the media decline to cover them?
For 14 years and two weeks now, the left has been desperate to find some evidence, any evidence, that Muslims in general are facing deep-seated discrimination because a few Muslims attacked us on 9/11.
That American Muslims have instead mostly been treated with respect and courtesy ought to be a point of pride, but at no point will the left ever say, Isnt it great that were such a pluralistic and tolerant country?
The left-led push to turn a man who was, as of 2004, an obscure state senator with no particular accomplishments, into the president four years later, was centrally and crucially about race. Everyone else was being subjected to a bait-and-switch.
Instead of being credited with enlightenment for being the only white-majority country ever to elect a black leader, now were told that everything is about racism.
http://nypost.com/2015/09/19/how-ahmeds-clock-became-a-false-convenient-tale-of-racism/
Tags
Who is online
77 visitors

That doesn't even go into the fact that the clock itself was simply the contents of a mass produced Radio Shack clock from the 70's with the insides transferred to a pencil box.
Irrelevant!
"The main difference between the Ahmed Mohamed case and the others is that the mainstream media and the leftist point of view it presents just cant let go of Ahmed. Ahmed is too useful to their narrative to be a one-day story."
The President isn't calling the girl who got suspended for saying god bless you when someone sneezed. Why is that?
Why?
His engineering teacher gave him an "A" and praised him for his ingenuity in "creating" the clock. He should have confiscated the clock until the end of school day, because the teacher must have known the furor it would raise in this post 9/11 era if others saw it.
For that matter, the student must have known it too. He couldn't have been that oblivious. The entire incident appears to have been planned to provoke the reaction it did.
Unlike it is to the bigoted, ethnic-cleansing, haters-on-the-right. (SARCASM).
YOU USED HIM, SEAN!
Or are you so myopic as to miss the forest for the trees?
Not really . Obama used him as did certain social media types . Sean is publishing a seed from a newspaper . And this article pointed out the contrast of the treatment of non-muslims . Why do muslims get a special pass from the media ? That is what caused this distinction to happen.
When did this get to be a Twitter society ?
When the bird-brains canonized a teen who should have known better than to bring something that looked like a home-made bomb to school.
His teacher [the 1st one who saw the contraption] praised him for it but then said to not show it to anyone else , which he proceeded to do anyway .
A comment on another article about this was that he was just a teenager and had no awareness of that bringing such a contraption to school would stir up such an uproar. I fully disagree with that; even teens today would know it looked like a bomb, and being a Muslim teen he would know the implications of it.
The first teacher he showed it to warned him not to show it to anyone else, and he did anyway.
Do you boys hear yourselves?
"Sources?" "Only hearsay."
Remember when Breitbart, right-wing flunky, Jim Hoft told the lie that the shooter of Gabby Giffords was an Obama supporter?
The right-wing lie machine will hang itself with its own rope!
According to?
By all means, let's talk about the reporting of the Giffords shooting. If you say Hoft, some incaonwquental blogger, blamed it on an Obama supporter we can put it on one side of the scale for lie machines.
Let's put all the mainstream and liberal news outlets that blamed the Tea Party or Sarah Palin ,of all people, on the other. Guess which sides wins?
Its Jim hoft vs Paul Krugman, the Daily Kos, Keith Olbermann, NBC News, CNN etc.etc.. The chair of the DNC was falsely blaming the Tea Party a year later! Talk about lie machines.
The boy was interrogated for more than an hour; he was not permitted to have an attorney or a parent present then, taken away in handcuffs BUT NOT CHARGED.
Do you have a son? Would you accept that scenario if it was your son?
I'll accept "suspicious" but not the the way the situation was handled; and you Constitution-lovers shouldn't either.
FYI:
They didn't evacuate the school, like you do when there's a bomb.
They didn't call a bomb squad - you know, like when it's believed there's a bomb
They didn't get as far away from him as possible,you know, like when it's believed there's a bomb
They put him and the clock in an office:you know, UNlike when it's believed there's a bomb
They waited with him for the police to arrive, and then they put the clock in the same car with the police.
Then they photographed it
Oh, I don't know about that. And you sure as hell don't!
Police must notify a person of their Miranda rights before taking them into custody or interrogating them. If they do not, they risk having a judge throw out any statements or admissions that the person in custody might make.
Determining the exact point when police officers have taken someone into custody presents difficulties, however. Obviously, an arrest constitutes police custody, but other situations can amount to police custody even without a formal arrest.
Wrong again,
Police are free to approach any child and question him about whether he was involved in a crime but, just as an adult can never be forced to answer questions from police in an interrogation, the child is not required to answer. The child can refuse to answer questions and can request that a lawyer or a parent be present.
A parent or lawyer also can refuse to allow the child to answer questions. If police, including officers on the street and school police officers, begin questioning a child and the child requests that she be allowed to call a parent or have a parent present, the police should stop and allow her to do so. But police are not required to contact parents or obtain parental permission before approaching and questioning a child.
If a child is in fact arrested, detained or taken into custody; or if the police do something that would make a reasonable person feel like he was in custody or not free to leave, any questioning in that situation is considered custodial interrogation. Any statements made by the child during custodial interrogation will be admissible only if the child is first advised of his Miranda rights or given his Miranda warning. The Miranda warning is the statement that a person has the right to remain silent and the right to consult with an attorney, and that anything a person says to police can be used against him in court.
Just as with an adult, if the police arrest a child and question him without reading him the Miranda warning, nothing the child says will be admissible in court. The police can use the information to help with the investigation of the casefor instance, talk to another person the child reports was involvedbut the confession cannot be used to prosecute the child. If the police arrest a minor or take her into custody and do advise her of her Miranda rights, the minor cannot be required or forced to answer any questions. The police can ask any questions they like, but the child is free to remain silent or to answer some questions but not others.
When the Police Conduct Improper Questioning
If the police arrest or detain a child and refuse the childs request to call his parents or another adult, or to talk to an attorney, there can be more consequences than the childs statements being kept out in court.
The parents could file a complaint with the police department or local government against the officers or department involved. If the situation was particularly serious and the child was physically abused or deprived of food, water, or rest while being interrogated by police, the parents could file a lawsuit on behalf of the child for violation of the childs civil rights.
...
And all they knew was that it was a clock.
The kid never claimed he had a bomb
Apparently you declare victory in defeat.
They took the boy away in handcuffs, would not allow him to contact a parent, and school suspension has nothing to do with police custody. NOTHING! Technically the boy was arrested albeit not formally charged.
Arrested (by definition) without Miranda Rights/Warning!
We will see if there was "probable cause," but either way, an arrest was made and the boy was denied his Constitutional rights.
The boy was taken away in handcuffs!
It's not as open and shut as you make it, Cerenkov.
Anything pre-Patriot Act is practically null & void . The violations to the bill of rights are many & ongoing with no sign of letting up anytime soon .
I don't disagree entirely, Petey, but I can't agree with the "anything," nor the "practically" as they are non-specific qualifiers and generalities.
There are still laws and rights and the Patriot Act is primarily with regard to data collection as it relates to terrorism and I am troubled by the conflation of a Muslim kid, a clock and the inferences and implications that this makes him a bona fide terror suspect.
I doubt that this case will ultimately come down to the police citing "probable cause," but if it does, I will concede your point.
They arrested him because they it was an intentional hoax, not because they thought it was a bomb.
It'd be nice to hear from the school, but we can't because the family won't waive their privacy rights and allow the school to tell its version of what happened in the classroom.
Amazingly though, the family had a PR firm spreading their story within a day. But they won't let the school talk. Why do you think that is?
Fair enough . But I don't think the issue of being a "bona fide terror suspect" is separate from the appearance of being one . Reality is that authorities can only go by superficial appearances until they do an investigation . In the case of the cop on the beat who shoots a boy for pointing a realistic looking water gun the mistake is understandable even though regrettable .
Miss leading at best Cerenkov, at least from the reports I've read.
The teacher he built the project for and whom Ahmed showed it to in the morning, told him he had done a great job but to keep the project out of sight because it could be mistaking for a bomb.
Ahmed then put the project away in his backpack and forgot about it.
Much later in the day, his home made clocks alarm went off and the teacher of the class he was in at that time asked about the noise. He told her it was his homemade clock's alarm going off.
She asked to see it and it was at that point the foolishness started.
Not misleading, ArkansasHermit.
Forget hearsay. He's doing an excellent job of digging his own hole. Watch or readsome of this guy's media interviews. He can't even remember whether his 'engineering teacher' is a male or female.Also, in other interviews, he talks about how surprised he was that anyone would think his 'clock' could resemble a bomb, and that the possibility of that perception never even entered his mind. Apparently he forgot what he had said in previous media interviews, because in those, he discussesthe steps he took so people wouldn't think it was a bomb. He said that he purposelydesigned it with wires and cords sticking out soit would look less like a bomb.Look in the dictionary under 'pulling pure-d-crappola out of one's ass', and you'll find that comment as an example.
Andthis:
...is 100% false.The device had to be pluggedin for it to work. So he plugged it into a wall outlet prior to the start of his last class. Knowing that it would benoticed by his English teacher and his classmates, he hid it by pulling a trashcan in front of it.
The foolishness started the instant he decided to scare the shit out ofa bunch of 1-year-oldswho didn't think very highly of him.
Threeelements of his stupidity bother me more than anything else. First, he didn't 'invent' anything. He simply moved the components from one housing unit to another. He's claiming someone else's contribution as his own. That pretty much makes him a thief and a liar. Second, he pulled this stunt during the anniversary of 9/11. That pretty much makes him a huge piece of crap. Third and perhaps most importantly, in the State of Texas, public school representatives, which in this case includes both MacArthur High School representatives and Irving ISD representatives, are prohibited from releasing any information regarding a currently enrolled student. They can't even confirm or deny the name ofa student. This idiotcan say anything he pleases without fear ofreprisal. That's why the pissed-off parental cavalry has entered the picture.
A point to ponder:Why would this 'inventor' notmake his'inventions' accessible during TV interviews?That he has been labeled an innocent'teen inventor' wrongly accused, is thebasis of this entire mess. When asked to show his inventions, he says he either no longer has them (i.e. his Bluetooth speakers), or that hehas copyright theft concerns by showing them on TV. What a load of baloney.
He is making foolsout of a lot of prominent people, and frankly, I'm beyond half-past don't give a shit.
Hearsay or not, never underestimate the power of close proximity, a really nosey nature, a telephone, and a MacArthur parent-filled client list.
An "intentional" hoax would consist of creating the overt impression that the device was a bomb the boy did the very opposite telling his teachers that the clock was a clock. There is no indication from the boy, the school or the police that at any time the boy, in any way, tried to give the impression he had a bomb.
This situation occurred in Irving, Texas
BACKGROUND
Mayor Of City Where Muslim Teen Was Wrongly Arrested Is Anti-Sharia Crusader
Further
When an atmosphere of anti-Muslim sentiment is generated by a high-ranking elected official, this by propagating a FALSE BASIS OF FEAR AND HATRED, common sense would indicate to any "reasonable person" that conflations such as the clock incident are waiting to happen.
And this one did.
The Mayor of Irving eroded common sense perceptions with anti-Muslim fear-mongering that was subsequently debunked!
Not permitted? Bullshit, Mac. Law enforcement is not prohibited from asking questions under such circumstances, it's just that the information obtained can not be used in alegal proceeding.
And another thing, his parents werecalled shortly after he was taken to the principal's office. I know where they live, andit is a 5-minute drive from their house to the school. However, they decided it was more important to call CAIR and Imam what's his face and their pallies at the Dallas Morning News, and have them all waiting to yell and protest and take photographs by the time Shorty was removed from the school in handcuffs. It takes time(about an hour, apparently)to get that kind of thing organized.
Let me ask you this: What if it were your son? You seem like a smart and disciplined man to me. Would you be ringing the media bell before youchanged out of your house slippers, raced to the school, and asked your little darling what happened? Surely you want to get both sides of the issue, and then make up your own mind, right? Forget the fact that you would have NEVER let your son leave the house with that stupid contraption. Pausing to rally the troops before seeing with my own eyes that my son is ok, goes beyond suspicious. Add to that the known facts, and while we're at it, the hearsay, then I could conclude that my son would be spanked, grounded, and spanked again...regardless of the factI am a staunch opponent of physical punishment for children.
I am angry about this, Mac. This kid is being praised and coddled and given gifts and trips and whatever else,when all signs point to what his true intent was. And if MITpromises him a place at their school, then I'm going to question that school's past and future achievements. At the very least, he is claiming a Radio Shack patent as his own. He didn't 'invent' the case, and he didn't 'invent' the clock. Putting the two together doesn't change those two facts in any way.
If it was, then an adult had their hand in it. Studies have shown, that sadly, most children under the age of 13 know very little about 9/11.
Well said Feronia!
This is all much ado about nothing. I would say from both "sides".
The kid should have informed his teachers that he wanted to show them a clock he had invented, and got their interest involved , the day before.
What is interesting about stories like this is more the reactions from the "audience" than the event itself. Forums and discussions choose sides and go on and on over what is really a very minor event.
This incident seems to be ''over the top'' to me. The kid loves science, built a clock, put it away in his backpack and the alarm went off. Then the drama started.
I don't see an invitation to the White House as deserving. Could be the kid is confused over the whole incident.
''Banned words'', well if we go down that path, what about ''banned books''....Both are a crock.
Ordinarily, I would agree with you, Perrie, but I find it hard to believe that any Muslim teen, especially one living in Texas, is not aware of the prejudicial fallout of 9/11, the Boston Marathon incident, the Ft. Hood massacre, and even though Muslims were not involved, the numerous school tragedies.
Kindergarten students have been expelled for pointing fingers at friends and saying, "Pow!" and for bringing G.I. Joe's to class; this clock looked like a makeshift bomb and he was told by the first teacher he showed it to not to show it to anyone else. It should have been secured in his locker or confiscated by the first teacher.
It certainly didn't warrant a presidential intervention.
Disagree.
Whether or not the failure to do so makes anything said inadmissible in court is irrelevant and a separate issue that does not negate the law regarding the individual's rights.
That's the first I'm hearing this but even if I accept it as a fact were the parents notified that the boy was being interrogated in isolation by four police officers? That's my issue.
Speculative on your part; and again, if I accept it as fact, I would hope that some public knowledge would be available regarding a boy taken from a school in handcuffs subsequently determined as innocent or guilty, charges or no charges, the media has a duty to factually report and the public has every right to know.
Before I respond, and I will, I deem your assessment speculative (but if you can provide a source of that scenario, I will certainly consider it).
If it were my son and I was not notified regarding the police interrogation until after-the-fact, I would, upon such notification, ask my son and the police officers or representative of the police department, if my son, at any time during his interrogation in isolation, was given a Miranda warning and/or asked for his parents.
If both answered "no," or my son said "no" and the officers said "yes," I would formally request a written affidavit from the police and do so in the presence of a witness though not necessarily the media. This admittedly would be an effort to create a "paper trail" in the event of any/all subsequent legal action.
Again, if there is no credible source for this information, it's speculative. Please provide a source.
As for politicizing this ALL SIDES you and I agree that it's expedient and I oppose it. But let us not lose sight of the issue and the incident itself.
It absolutely should be a non-story. But when the family hires a publicist and President and the democratic front-runner for the presidency try to exploit the situation for political gain it ends up becoming much more of an issue than it deserves.
Surprise, Sean, we agree.
But YOU posted this "non-story" and around the site, seem to think it's all right for Trump, et al to perpetuate and establish a political base on the birther lies, and to agree with a town hall call for ethnic cleansing of Muslims in America.
"Nothing comes from nothing," Sean. Failure to repudiate the ramping up of Muslim-hatred and craziness on one side then being indignant regarding trying to defuse it on the other side that's hypocrisy, Sean.
Let's say I accept that premise, bf.
If that's what happened, it could only have played out as "planned" in an environment rife with anti-Muslim hype by those who perpetuate it, in full or in part with calculated and intentional untruths.
A portion of the American public WANTS to believe that all Muslims are terrorists or potentially so.
Some prophecies are indeed, self-fulfilling.
Thanks for the info Sister Mary, I missed the part where Ahmed plugged it back in before the start of his last class.
As for your general theory that this was all some sort of sinister Mooslm plot to make Texans look the fool, well that's just a pool shoot with too many banks before the ball drops for me.
First teacher keeps the project till the end of the day. No plot. English teacher takes the word of the science teacher. No plot. School principal takes the word of the science teacher. No plot. Cops talk to everyone at his school, sort it out there. No plot.
Etc., etc. Too many banks for this to be a truly planed shoot. My opinion only, of course.
Sister Mary, do I remember you saying that your mother worked at Mount St. Michael Catholic School?
If that's true & it's the one W. Davis street then I spent a little time on campus there in the early 70's, dating a couple of girls that were being detained there.
Small world.
Mac,
I don't believe that this was about anti-Muslim sentiments.
Here is an interesting article from the Independent (yes a paper for Independents)
Last week, Ahmed Mohamed, a 14-year-old from Irving, Texas, was arrested for bringing a clock to school that his teachers said looked like a hoax bomb.
After Police eventually released Mohamedfrom police custody, his story went viral.
President Obama even invited Mohamed to the White House to show off his clock.
Education facilities in Texas (and most states) have a zero tolerance policy in place when it comes to situations like Mohameds. School officials believed it look like a weapon, so they acted according to the schools code of conduct and alerted authorities to handle what they perceived as a potential threat.
IJ talked to Jonathan Gilliam , a former FBI agent, about the way the issue was handled.
On Mohameds detainment:
On whether or not the clock resembled a bomb:
How he would have approached the situation as an FBI agent:
Then, we asked Gilliam if he believed it was set up like a hoax bomb:
Since Mohameds arrest , he has told the media that he felt like a terrorist and that he was being interrogated.
...
In other words, for the FBI this was SOP.
As for your general theory that this was all some sort of sinister Mooslm plot to make Texans look the fool, well that's just a pool shoot with too many banks before the ball drops for me.
First teacher keeps the project till the end of the day. No plot. English teacher takes the word of the science teacher. No plot. School principal takes the word of the science teacher. No plot. Cops talk to everyone at his school, sort it out there. No plot.
Etc., etc. Too many banks for this to be a truly planed shoot. My opinion only, of course.
And mine.
Hold up! We don't need this kid to make us Texans look the collective fool. It's common knowledge that we don't need any help looking foolish; we do just fine on our own.
And, I did not say that it was some 'sinister Mooslm' (and I've never seen that word before) plot.I never thought for one instant that he intended to blow up the school or kill people or whatever, but I do thinkhewasa picked-on kid whose payback plan backfired. And being picked-on was of his own making. He was a horses-behind to teachers and students alike, so my sympathy stops a bit short of yours.
The first teacher did not keep that thing until the end of the day. The kid kept it until he could carry out his silly little mission, which was to scare the shit out of kids that had been picking on him. He certainly wasn't prepared for the collateral fallout. We are talking about a kid that was demeaning to any and all females, including teachers, classmates, and evenhis mother and sisters. We are talking about a kid who is used to preferential treatment in his family, and also from the Muslim community here in Irving. He gets taken down a peg or two, then gets pissed, and now he and President Obama are going out for drinks and dancing. I've seen more worthwhile media causes.
And yes, both my grandmother and my mother worked at M St. M. My grandmother taught art and Spanish, and my mother was in charge of the girls swim club.This was late sixties/early seventies. Are you willing to spank over a name or two? Believe it or not, I still have my grandmothers class files, or at least most of them.
No, but we can follow the law when police interrogate a "suspect".
There was no evacuation of the school, so, no one considered the situation thought anything other than a "hoax," if that
No one called a bomb squad
Occupants of the school didn't distance themselves from the "bomb"
The boy and the clock were put in an office
All involved waited with him for the police to arrive and then they put the clock in the same car as the police.
By all means, once it's determines there's no imminent danger, interrogate the boy but as I posted several times an individual under these circumstances are entitled to be apprised of their Miranda rights.
Justified in full or in part there is an anti-Muslim climate in the United States Irving Texas' mayor has fanned that fire (as I also have specifically cited).
Subtle or overt, PC aside, there is a history of ethnic/racial/religious discrimination in the U.S., inevitably having some affect in the judicial system.
I've been consistent throughout AND SPECIFIC; facts are facts and when allegations are made in America, those making them have the obligation of satisfying "The Burden of Proof."
What distinguishes America with regard to fairness and justice is the Constitution and the concept of due process. In the confirmed absence of a clear and present danger, THERE IS NO EXCUSE FOR THE DISREGARD OF AN INDIVIDUAL'S RIGHTS.
Generally speaking, by all means, refute any flaws in what I specifically state, but I am not responsible for defending what I have not stated.
FRI SEP 18, 2015 AT 09:01 AM PDT
Mayor Van Duyne has this community's full support in regard to the fact that Sharia law has no place in our city, county, state or federal government. It is as simple as that.
What are your thoughts on that, Mac? Do you find that the members of Muslim communities in the United States of Americashould only be held accountable by authorized Sharia Law tribunals in the United States, and that our laws, both civil and criminal would not be applicable to anyone of Muslim faith?? I'm going to answer for you: Of courseyou wouldn't be in favor of that. Well, neither is Beth Van Duyne.
If you want to see a person with an agenda, here you go:
He's not doing too badly for being a simple taxi driver, is he?
The source of information regardingAhmed Mohamed'sfather is here .
Why you get so worked up over all this, every time, is anybody's guess, honest to god.
I wish you would get so worked up over the trillions of dollars that get extracted out of our economy and into the pockets of the already wealthy.
There was never such a threat! The Mayor created a straw-man based on the hate-Muslim sentiment flames fanned by Trump and other ethnic-cleansing types.
This kind of propaganda is how holocausts begin!
Irrelevant; it's not the function or responsibility of police officers to interrogate based on whether or not they believe what they learn from an investigation will end up in court and/or be admissible.
IT IS THEIR RESPONSIBILITY AS I HAVE SPECIFICALLY NOTED to not abrogate the rights of citizens being interrogated!
Bend over backwards all you like to deny the reality; it smacks of a bias.
What's your problem with giving a Miranda warning as required by law?
Fifth time
Police are required to read an individual their rights (i.e., a Miranda warning) before they may interrogate or question a detained individual. However, a line of questioning by the police is only an interrogation if the individual is determined to be in custody.
" Police custody " is generally defined as anytime the police deprive you of your freedom of action in a significant way. Realistically though, it means being arrested. Some jurisdictions treat detentions differently than arrests, though, and a Miranda warning isn't required in such a situation.
Once handcuffed, the boy was under "arrest."
What Are Your Miranda Rights?
The Miranda warning (from the U.S. Supreme Court's Miranda v. Arizona decision), requires that officers let you know of certain facts after your arrest, before questioning you. An officer who is going to interrogate you must convey to you that:
When the Miranda Warning Is Required
It doesn't matter whether an interrogation occurs in a jail, at the scene of a crime, on a busy downtown street, or the middle of an open field: If a person is in custody (deprived of his or her freedom of action in any significant way) , the police must read the Miranda rights if they want to ask questions and use the answers as evidence at trial.
If someone is not in police custody, however, no Miranda warning is required and anything the person says can be used at trial. Police officers often avoid arresting peopleand make it clear to them that they're free to goprecisely so they don't have to give the Miranda warning. Then they can arrest the suspect after getting the incriminating statement they wanted all along.
For more detail on these issues, see Miranda: The Meaning of 'Custodial Interrogation.'
Pre-Arrest Questioning
Do you have to respond to police questions if you haven't been arrested? Generally, no. (You typically don't have to answereven if you're under arrest.) A police officer generally cannot arrest a person simply for failure to respond to questions. (There are, however, situations where you might have to provide information like identification; see Daniele Watts Controversy: Can Officers Demand ID? )
Post-Arrest Questioning
The almost-universal advice of defense attorneys is to keep the old mouth tightly shut when being questioned after an arrest, at least until after consulting an attorney. Suspects all too frequently unwittingly reveal information that can later be used as evidence of their guilt.
Consequences of Failure to Provide Miranda Warning
Without a Miranda warning, what the arrestee says in response to custodial questioning can't be used for most purposes as evidence at trial. For more detail, see Statements Obtained When Police Violate Miranda: Can They Be Used Against You?
When Police Come Down Too Hard
A vioaltion of Miranda rights doesn't necessarily mean that the officers coerced the statement out of the suspect. But if they did, not only is the statement inadmissible, but so too is any evidence that the police obtain as the result of it. (To learn more about coerced statements, see Miranda and Involuntary Confessions .)