A history book used in school districts across the state is sparking controversy in Seminole County .
A parent called 9 Investigates after finding out his son was learning too much about the Islamic religion in a public classroom.
Ron Wagner read from part of his son's world history book, "There is no god, but God. Muhamad is the messenger of God."
Wagner is not reading the Five Pillars of Islam from the Quran, but rather his son's 10 th -grade world history book from Lyman High School.
"Students were instructed to recite this prayer as the first Pillar of Islam, off of the board at the teacher's instruction," Wagner claims.
Wagner, who is not religious, said he had no idea the public school was teaching so extensively about religion until he spotted a text on his son's phone from a teacher reminding him to complete a prayer rug assignment and study an Islam packet.
"For it to be mandatory and part of the curriculum and in the textbooks, didn't seem right," Wagner said.
Inside of the book is a chapter dedicated to the "Rise of Islam," including prayers and scriptures from the Quran. What's more disturbing for Wagner is that the first 100 pages discussing Judaism and Christianity are missing. The district blames a manufacturer defect in 68 books that are only a year old.
~LINK~
Oops?!
I'd bet the books don't show Israel on any of the maps either.
When will the books be replaced?
Why did it take a year?
Does it say, "There is no god but God," or "There is no god but Allah?"
Should the bad parts of history be included or shold they all be idealized?
I am surprised you want any discussion of religion included.
My understanding of a history class is to learn about dates and facts of events, and biographies of historical individuals. I don't recall having homework requiring me to do religious exercises. In university I took a comparative religions course which provided me with factual information about all major religions, but it didn't require me to carry out any of their practices. It seems Randy, that anyone who says anything that is not within your personal view of being correct is a liar. Please, Randy, grow up. It's YOUR reputation you are slandering.
From the WFTV website :
According to Wagner, Dr. Michael Blasewitz, who oversees the high school curriculum, said, "The Pillars of Islam are benchmarks in the state curriculum."
Wagner's concerns prompted a district investigation that found the teacher never tried to indoctrinate or convert students.
Some other students interviewed by administrators said they were not required to recite the prayer aloud. They did discuss a video played during class about the religion, but Blasewitz got frustrated and stormed out when 9 Investigates asked whether the district is considering changes to the curriculum.
"You're just going to walk away from our interview when we're trying to get information," said investigative reporter Daralene Jones.
Before Blasewitz walked out, he further justified the curriculum, saying students learn specific Judaism doctrine, the Bible and its scriptures, in earlier school years.
"If anything, it's a little imbalanced toward Christianity and Judaism," Blasewitz said.
Federal law allows schools to teach aboutreligion, because it's part of history. But public schools may not teach religion.
"There's a difference between teaching of the significance or the impact of a religion and teaching the specific tenets of a religion," Wagner said.
9 Investigates was told the district will reconsider this book when the contract is up in three years. Some districts in South Florida have requested the publisher rewrite portions because of the controversy.
~~~~~~
Geez , IDK . World history was given short shrift when I went to high school . This type of coverage of religions seems a violation of the separation of church & state to me . This is a PUBLIC high school and the curriculum should reflect that I would expect ...
The concern is that tenants of the religion itself are being taught beyond the scope of teaching history. There is enough of a question about that to cause quite a hubaloo, and has parents across the state of Florida taking notice. One senator from the state has voiced concern as well...
It appears that the books are indeed still widely in use across the state.
Why? Do you know Mr. Wagner personally? Perhaps you have some proof that he is lying and full of shit? The school has not denied this at all, why would you?
I suppose you would say the same if this was an article showing how Christianity was being taught in History classes, with the ten commandments being repeated by the class while they made their own Rosaries? At the same time, the text books lessons about Islam were somehow "missing"?
Talk about bullshit.
Perhaps you should stick to seeding false stories about Fox News personalities.
Larry,
My daughters were taught some comparative religion, but it did cover all of the worlds major religions. No one was required to recite any prayers.
You can't agree with an unproven report . Everything here is unsupported by evidence .
Well, if ya go back to the original article it states...
No where does it say the books have been pulled (regardless of your doubts that "they have already been replaced and that the schools would not distribute them at all"). It does say in the second link I provided, that Senator Simmons is asking if the district should reconsider using the book.
If this parent is making false claims as you suggest, and especially considering all the controversy it has caused, why has the school not denied these claims?
And it doesn't bother youin the least that this was being done, while the history of other religions are conveniently, somehow COMPLETELY ABSENT FROM THE TEXT?
Again, That's bullshit.
False...
How disingenuous John. You know that this article is not about teaching religion as history, but about teaching religion. It's also about public schools using history textbooks that teach about religion, to the exclusion of others. Do you have anything relevant to add to the conversation concerning this article, or are you here to blow smoke?
No disagreement from me there Mickey. The disagreement arises in the definition of teaching religion as histroy, or teaching religion. Also, the disagreement arises from the fact that a hundred pages that included the history of Judaism and Christianity were completely missing from a good number of text, with no apparent concern to rectify that.
In 2010, non-Muslim public school 6th-graders took a field trip to a Boston-area mosque and participated in a Muslim prayer service. Needless to say, those parents also were not thrilled. The school superintendent was forced to apologize.
I expect it had something to do with the era in which I attended high school . History was likely contested heavily in the PTA . The result was an avoidance of all controversy .
I don't even recall any mention of Indians ... or even cowboys .
Huh!?
The links provided ALL say that the books are being used now. Just because you can't believe it, or find links tovindicate your feelings , in no way refutes the fact that these texts are still in play. Jeesh Mickey, why are you so dead-set against seeing the truth right in front of you? Because it upsets your sensibilities? I don't get it. The articles plainly state that these are text books being used right now, and folks are calling for a review of these texts now currently in use. Why is that so hard to believe?
I can just imagine the explosion if the students were taken to a Jewish temple and made to wear prayer shawls and kippas and say "Shma Yisroel Adoshem Elohanou, Adoshem Echod".
Wrong consecutive order. I thought history relates from earliest to latest rather than the other way around. I guess the author of the text put it in the order which he considered the most important.
I can't tell for sure Screminmimi but could this be just another version of what we kicked around back in October?
Sure seems that the Florida dadhas the exact same complaint that the Mass. dad did, which makes me think that this story might be about the same " World ReligionTheme Unit" program that we discussed back then.