IF SHE IS, IN FACT, CONFIRMED DEAD … ISIS IS OUT OF BARGAINING CHIPS … A HAMMER SHOULD FOLLOW
Bargaining Chip
noun - "negotiating asset"
ISIStoday confirmed for the family of American hostage, KaylaMueller that she is dead.
Whether the American hostage, female aid worker Kayla Mueller, has in fact been killed by a Jordanian airstrike against ISIS targets in Syria as claimed by ISIS, or by ISIS itself
this band of barbarians that protects itself primarily with threats of, and, acts of murder and mayhem against innocents in my opinion, from America's standpoint HAS DESTROYED ITS LAST NEGOTIATING ASSET!
The ISIS Rules of Engagement (ROE) rely primarily on using innocents both literally and figuratively as human shields against its annihilation thus, in order for the "civilized world" to cut its losses RE:ISIS
drop the leaflets then drop the hammer "Cease and Desist, Disband, Surrender, Direct Your Operatives -- Current and Future to Dissipate and Disappear, this as of the time line defined herein; failure to comply "
Dilemmas by definition offer choices, none of which are ideal or even nearly so. We continue to hear that "it will take years to destroy ISIS."
Lose the scalpel drop the hammer
before ISIS captures more Kayla Muellers and/or holds entire regions hostage.
Anyone with a better idea leave a comment.
Tags
Who is online
81 visitors

Agreed Mac, also supply the Kurds with the weapons that they need, and if Jordan needs more support, give it to them.
Sometimes, removing cancer requires the destruction of some of the surrounding healthy cells.
THIS ARTICLE IS AS MUCH METAPHORICAL AS A SERIOUS STRATEGY it can be praised or castigated via intelligent commentary.
One can only hope.
Nah.... Fallout.
BLU-82.... Go conventional in a "Big Way"
Just how serious is the ME for getting rid of ISIS? They are the "hammer" and should respond appropriately - not the U. S.
They '"should" but should they not why risk ISIS taking more American hostages and urging domestic terrorism vis social and other media?
Make it clear that there's no future in it.
I totally agree Mac. Time to take down these fools and show that there is no winning with terrorism.
When good people do nothing....
I don't care what they think after they're dead.
If it is perfectly clear that the ultimate objective is to destroy ISIS in a manner that will cut future loss of innocent lives, and there's no bullshit lie-campaign that's about i.e. "WMDs" (a.k.a. "oil), then any anti-American/West fanaticism will be of the usual kind a separate, on-going matter.
I have no better idea, but think we should give the people that have been over-run a few days to get out of there, and then help the Jordan/Israeli Coalition fuel/air bomb them into oblivion. They will only understand death on a massive scale...
Well, perhaps we should introduce them to eternity. If they feel they have been martyred and will get their 70 virgins, fine. I could care less, as long as they are gone.
Hence my
"You win a war by making the other poor dumb bastard die for his country."
G.S. Patton
Agree with you Mac.
Oh yes, I agree with you wholeheartedly!
An army of these girls could do the trick (she's even got her own hammer). Give those sexually-repressed Islamic jihadist fanatics some real "Shock and Awe".
Hey... What's she doing wearing my old tool belt?
From your lips to God's ear A Mac.
I just don't think it's real enough to Americans yet. The reality of ISIS as an existential threat, is a boogey man to most so far. Regardless of the number of times we've been hit over the head with Islamism, we fail to take the threat seriously. Until ISIS is found carrying out offensives in the US, we'll continue to treat them like a JV team. We should fight them over there, not here; but, so far, it simply isn't real enough toenough Americans to allow for the type of hammer-fall needed to eradicate ISIS.
I surely don't want to see our troops in harms way. I don'tthinkISIS can be handled strictly from air strikes or drone either though. ideally, there would be other ME countries that would put boots down,,,so far only Jordan, at that just recently.
So John, how does one respect the threat that ISIS represents? How do we separate the politicking from the ideology that attends any discussion of war, aggression, and defense? I hear what you are saying, but at sometime we will come togetherin strategy to take care of this terrorist group, or they will be on our shores pulling the same crap. Would you define A. Mac's article as inflammatory, fear mongering, if you would? I mean, do voices that call for attention of, and actionstowards ISIS, only matter if they are voicesthat agreepolitically with a party'sideology?
Hopefully Obama will follow Jordan's lead but I doubt it. Still looks like we are playing a dangerous and losing game in hopes Assad will be overthrown. There is a reason we only really hit them hard in Iraq besides the fact that we have Iraq's permission.
And, don't ask what she's doing with my hammer
With the situation in Syria the last few years, I have never wanted Assad to be overthrown. My best-case scenario would be continued wholesale slaughter by the Assad/Iran/Hezbollah alliance versus the ISIS/Al-Nusra Front and various other Al-Qaeda types there for a prolonged period. All sides of this war are enemies of the U.S., Israel and the Western world.
This problem with fanatic Islamists will be solved when the Muslims in the region finally say: "We've have enough bloodletting. We must eradicate these Islamist vermin if we are to have any hope of normal lives. If we truly need a reformation of our dysfunctional Islamic texts and Islam in general, then let's do so".
Hal,
This has nothing to do with reason. They can feel that they are going to god, but at the end of the day, if there is no ISIS, we have won..
Bombs away.
Agreed Dowser!
BTW factoid:
No where in the Koran does it promise 72 virgins.
Damn are they going to be bummed.
Neo-cons?
From what I have read, they are the mostisolationist.
Dream on guys, LOL!
Wait? John are you talking about Armageddon/end times?
Spot on Mike!
I will remember that you made that statement. It is especially poignant if it is on the side of those who provoked or started the war.
LOL!!!
You notice they didn't say 72 virgin WHATS. Poor goats!
Don't ignore the way John snuck in his personal feelings about Israel being the sole cause of the whole conflict.
This is why I have said we should keep out of it and let them kill each other from the beginning.
Unfortunately, I don't think this will happen anytime soon. The biggest part of the problem is that in following their religion they do things most of us "westerners" think are "radical" They simply don't see it as radical. This is the way they live and Sharia law is "normal" to them.
Here is a fine example. This is at the "Muslim Peace Conference" in Norway it is worth a watch.
Don't let the title fool you. It is not just stoning. They WANT Sharia law. ALL of it. He asks of all Sharia, not just stoning. He just happened to list that separate along with death.
This guy is speaking the truth. This is simply the way they live their lives. We just don't understand them.We can't have it both ways, that is, on the one hand urging the Muslim World to repudiate and join the fight against ISIS, while on the other, painting ALL Muslims as terrorists and/or working to impose Sharia law across the earth.
Wonder if she needs any help holding up her "tools"????
They seem to be doing a good job all by themselves.
Hey 1st, did you mention something about losing your hammer?
Is this it?
I am not trying to paint them as terrorists. I am trying to point out what is acceptable to the majority. Sharia is a way of life for most Muslims and they see nothing at all radical about it. This is the simple truth Amac, you just proved my point. You don't understand this.
...
...
If you look up the populations of these countries and do the math you find MOST Muslims DO support Sharia law. This is the straight fact.
HEY, we have the greatest hospitality system in the world WE deliver more hospitality on a daily basis that most other countries combined.
We know this cause they complain abut this ALL THE TIME!
Since we are such a hospitality driven culture that is weak and decaying, I say that we provide all the hospitality we can and deliver them to paradise as fast as we can. I mean we are known for our efficiencies also.
We should introduce them to our efficient side.
A.Mac is right. We shouldn't generalize. We must realize that Muslims are divided among many factions: the radicals, those who risk their lives and oppose the radicalization openly, those who don't affect non-Muslims but privately practise Sharia (including honour killers), those who want to change the society in which they reside to fit their beliefs (clearing the path to the Caliphate), those who don't risk their lives by sitting on the fence and keeping their mouths shut, and finally those who just want to maintain their faith in a peaceful way and fit into modern society and NOT try to change it to fit their beliefs. As you can see, one cannot generalize.
I agree buzz, we should never generalize and that is in no way, shape or form what I am trying to do. I am simply supplying some numbers.
And blamed it on conservatives also.
If one thing, he is consistent with his hate.
Someone should remind him, Liberal Democrats are running the foreign office these days.
Almost 8 hours passed before someone opened a can of ready-quip.
Impressive run.
Dropping leaflets telling them to disband, surrender etc within a time frame does nothing. It gives the right to declare to the world "we gave them alternatives and fair warning." It shows us to be "provoked retaliators" who offered one last chance for the enemy to walk away and never return.
It's a Theodore Roosevelt thing.
I understand, if the numbers in fact are reflective of the way Muslims actually live their lives, that it's pure nonsense to say it's "their fight" not ours.
I reiterate, it can't be both ways.
Every action has side effects . Destroying many lives In ISIL may be accompanied by the loss of many non-ISIL people in Syria .
Because of a tendancy to use human shields, as has been proven elsewhere, loss of civilian life would be inevitable.
I should have addressed these comments as well as offered the numbers on the subject. These numbers point out the people who want Sharia. This is not in any way meant to imply they seek to spread it and/or kill to do so. I agree that extremists and terrorists are every ones problem and not just a problem of moderate Muslims.
What I AM saying is I think people don't realize how many Muslims Live under Sharia and like it that way. They don't understand the huge differences in our cultures.
I AM also saying we should not attempt to change or meddle in the countries in which Sharia is law and the people like it that way. Like backing dictators in Egypt. After they had free elections they voted for Sharia. Problem is that Sharia does not work in a democracy. Our beliefs are simply not compatible.
No question; that's why I cited that the ROE were established by ISIS, that it created a dilemma and, that we should leaflet before dropping the "hammer."
I also used the phrase "cut our losses," implying that there have been losses and would be more.
I also stated that, sometimes to cure a cancer, some of the healthy, surrounding cells must die in the process.
Doing nothing is not a viable option.
In Iraq the biggest issue is separating the innocent Sunnis from the collaborator Sunnis ...
I'm not sure if I agree with that . This is only one American life . What makes her life worth the auxiliary costs such an action would entail ? Is it that she is female ?
Here's a thought . If the people in the engulfed region are not interested in their own defense why should the US take on that responsibility for them ? The Kurds are doing their part . The Iraqis ... not so much .
"ONLY"?
I'm not going to expound on my incredulity.
Possibly someone else will.
Just curious what number brings down the hammer?
War really is hell . People die from it , but not nearly as many as those from annual traffic fatalities in the US . Yes ONLY ONE LIFE . Get real ...
Cars in traffic primarily expedite useful and/or vital activity.
Terrorists do not.
Throwing out the baby with the bath water
Not if you ask the terrorists ... I've long suspected that ISIL had a method to their madness . The hidden motive is there's too damn many Muslims in the world . How to slow down their formidable reproductive rates ? ISIL has the answer ... kill them [& don't worry about collateral damage ] .
Yeah
WTF was I thinking?
Judging Muslims from western standards ? Yeah WTF were you thinking ?
"Judging Muslims from western standards ? Yeah WTF were you thinking"
I defer to your PhD in Islamo-fascist Culture
Incidentally, my western-standard way of looking at ISIS has revealed to me that it is barbaric.
Surely in your Doctoral dissertation that appears somewhere.
When has that approach ever been of value in the middle east ? Imposing western standards there is what George W. Bush tried to do ... surely you're not advocating that approach ?
''Then what?''. Barbara, the way things are now for Americans there, almost certain death, anything that we do will cause more death. From nothing to all out attack.
I don't want to see American ground troops inserted into this. Airpower, intel, logistical support, including supplying the Kurds and Jordan with weapons needed.
I have no such assumption; my "plan" is an ultimatum wrapped in diplomatic-for-appearance-only packaging.
Destroying one's enemy from the "high road" whenever such a tactic is available, is the way to go. Going about this in the way I delineate removes all legitimate grievances that start with "you never gave us any warning nor possibilities for capitulation."
It's clear that ISIS is not interested in negotiations, but for appearance sake, we take the moral high ground.
Then fuck 'em!
I said nothing about imposing western standards in essence I'm saying " cut it out or your fucked," knowing full well that ISIS won't cut it out and we'll fuck them."
Bush lied about WMDs, then tried to cover his ass with, " we're going to spread democracy throughout the Middle East ".
The only "standard" I advocate is "eradicate the bastards," that after going through the showmanship of a faux offer of surrender (knowing damned well ISIS won't).
There is actually one other American prisoner at this time but again, the dilemma exists because of ISIS' using innocents as a hedge against being attacked. If we fail to attack be cause of hostages, ISIS lives another day to take more hostages, etc. .
So give me a plan that makes more sense than the one I've posited. I'll listen.
Nahhhh - mine's a "tad" bit bigger than the one she's holding.
Works for me but I don't buy the "airstrikes alone won't do the job." It really depends on what we drop from the air.
There are lottsa places, too many places, for ISIS to hide. The only thing I can think of that we could drop with any real assurance of wiping them out would involve nuclear strikes. That doesn't sound any good at all.
There is another way than "dropping the hammer" . Starving ISIL of funds has far more chance of success . That's because there is a constant flow of more fighters going to join ISIL :
AP Exclusive: 20,000 foreign fighters flock to Syria, Iraq
Here is the funds starvation approach :
Turkey's Latest Plan To Drain $3 Million A Day From ISIS Is Working
Petey,
No argument about starving ISIS but until it fully dies of starvation, how many more lives will they destroy?
Dead people/entities don't need "to eat."
So , your main concern is about saving lives ? How unlike someone from Troy ...
Do you understand the phrase I used early on to address such a concern?
Here's a thought . You're not concerned with saving lives ... just feeding your own ego.What you really are interested in is saving one particular life . Would you have the same concern for the life of someone who looks like Bill O'Reilly instead a girl with a cute smile ? Of course not ...
Here's another thought
You do this shit every time you can't rebut an idea.
Uh how 'bout Greta van Susteren?
Your comment is pathetic and a real stretch for relevance.
Pathetic is your ridiculous claim that you interested in saving lives . It is a well established historic precedent to go to war over one pretty woman . I'm speaking of Helen of Troy of course . It's so useless that you won't even admit your silly-ass weakness for a pretty face .
If you had an inkling of the enormity of your ignorance on the issue of collateral damage that happens during a real war you would shut up and own up to your innumeracy . You would also withdraw your horrific accusations against George W. Bush as a war criminal when in fact he saved quite a few Iraqis from being killed by S. Hussein . But no . You can't admit that anyone was saved from that monster . What this means is that you share the blame . This would be silly if it wasn't so horrific ...
The woman is one of many murdered by ISIS and the fact that she was an American being held hostage as an ISIS 'bargaining chip" and, warning of future such "chips" this was the proverbial last "straw," the one that "broke the camel's back," the last (possibly next to last) bargaining chip as far as America is concerned.
Wow! Ignorance! How many hundreds of thousands died in Iraq because of Bush's bullshit war? Not to mention the destabilization of the entire region by killing Saddam --
You need to get yourself educated and possibly consider anger management.
Your aggressive, ill-conceived attacks on members who you cannot viably debate is a deterrent to dialogue in these threads.
I feel sad for you I sincerely do.
It would serve you well to disagree without making things personal and sometimes far out there.
Once again -- I'm finished with you in a given thread.
The camel in question is yourself . The rest of us know better than to expect ISIL can be bargained with .
Thanks for spouting your unproven ignorance . What is well established is that Hussein was a bloodthirsty tyrant who murdered and tortured many thousands . And he had help from his relatives in power as well ... his sons . But feel free to ignore the proven history . While your at it feel free to ignore the Kurds who have finally gotten the support they needed . They are the only forces in that region who are capable of standing up to ISIL ... Do you care? Hell no ! Can't even recognize a positive development that came out of Bush's war ... Your anti-Bush focus borders on insanity .
Your words :
Heed your own advice !
Your talent for running away is well established at this point . When the going gets you act hurt & run away ... What a sick joke . One more thing to consider . Iraq was under the torture yoke of Hussein for many years . Bush freed them from it . Al quaeda came in and massacred those numbers you spoke of . IT WASN'T BUSH'S DOING !