Prayer in public schools? Only if you are Muslim.
DEARBORN The Council on American Islamic Relations of Michigan (CAIR-MI) staff recently met with Dearborn Public Schools Superintendent Brian Whiston to discuss concerns from some parents regarding prayer accommodations in Dearborn Public Schools.
Dearborn Public Schools has implemented a policy which fully accommodates student-led prayer in all the schools, as well as unexcused absences for students who leave early on Fridays for Jumu'ah prayers. CAIR-MI is currently in discussion with Melvindale Public Schools to get similar accommodations for students that are now in place for Dearborn Public Schools.
You may find it equally outrageous that this "prayer time" only applies to one religion.
Tags
Who is online
127 visitors

CAIR and illegal aliens are succeeding in turning the US into a 3rd world country - and our present administration thinks nothing of it.
It is against the law and by turning a blind eye to lawlessness you encourage it.
Imagine the uproar if Jews or Christians were doing this.
This policy battle comes just three years after the activists successfully persuaded school administrators in Michigan that Christian and Jewish literature should be banned from campuses there.
Michigan has become one of the front lines in America's culture war. Long considered the cultural capital of Islam in the U.S., Michigan is home to nearly 300,000 Muslims, particularly in Detroit and suburban Dearborn, making it the second largest enclave of Middle Easterners in the West, after Paris.
But unlike many immigrant generations that came before them, the Michigan Muslims are not assimilating. Rather, they are litigating, and seem to be using the courts, and cowering liberal public officials, to create a privileged place in the U.S., where Sharia law reigns, and the rule of law, as Americans traditionally have known it, does not.
Consider the following:
What is going on here is nothing less than an assault on the religious liberty of Christians disguised as simple requests for accommodation of Islam.
Christians and Jews, simply put, in Dearborn, are second-class citizens, as if they are residents of an Islamic Republic, where they are considered infidels, without full civil rights. Local police departments refuse to allow Christians or Jews to distribute Bible-based literature, for fear of infuriating Muslims, but let the local Muslim preachers use the city's own loudspeaker system to announce daily calls to prayer.
Not only can Muslims pray in schools but non-Muslims are b eing taught to pray like Muslims.
Allah akbar! folks.
Get used to it for two more years.
Coming from you, that isa stupid-azz statement - ignorant even - and coming from you.
Grow up John - comment on the thread/article and quit bashing the commenters.
Read what 96 has posted. In fact, if - and that is a very large IF - you were to canvas/google the Islam religion for Chicago/Illinois - you would be embarrassed by many of your blithy comments.
Chicago Islamic Center -cicmasjed.org- 3357 West 63rd Street Chicago, IL (773) 436-8083
Nation of Islam - www.noi.org - 7351 South Stony Island Avenue Chicago, IL (773) 324-6000
Radio Islam - www.radioislam.com - 700A Chicago, IL (312) 750-1178
Islamic Information - www.iiie.net - 4390 North Elston Avenue Chicago, IL (773) 777-7443
Muhammad University of Islam - www.muichicago.org - 7351 South Stony Island Avenue Chicago, IL (773) 643-0700
Ahmadiyya Movement In Islam- 2136 West Van Buren Street Chicago, IL (312) 226-0500
In 1996 the Greater Chicago area has over eighty Islamic organizations and most of them attached to an Islamic center or a mosque. The estimated population of Muslims in Cook and the collar counties is 350,000 , almost 5% of the total population of the region, and GREATER than the population of Michigan - as a whole. The Muslims have surpassed the population of Jews and many other ethnic groups.
And, that knowledge makes me a "birther"???????????
Only from you John - only from you.
The problem here is that it is not across the board. When you start making different rules for a particular group you are on a dangerous slippery slope.
Unfortunately, it is not just today, it is a bigger problem than most realize or are willing to admit.
Not at all. Just posting information the MSM ignores. The facts are what they are. I admit I try to post these facts that I believe the MSM intentionally ignores. I also admit that thse things disturb me. Doesn't it bother you that exceptions of prayer in school are being made for one group and that it is pretty much non existent in any news source other than those siting a triumph? This doesn't mean I want to "push all Muslims off the Grand Canyon". that is your assumption. I am a lot more concerned with the way our government is responding to them.
Why do you always turn a topic around to, and attack Christians regardless of if it has anything to do with the topic or not Hal? What Christian wronged you so horribly for you to harbor such hate?
I am talking about treating all religions the same and you feel the need to point out some unrelated event in which a different religion is trying to do what I am decrying. I am pointing out the law applies to all religions. Your the one going off on a tangent.
As the thread deals specifically with Muslims demanding and receiving the authorization to conduct prayer services in school, I need to understand what the Detroit schools don't understand about SCOTUS's "ruling" that states, specifically, no prayer in school - period.
This is part of the problem 1st. The laws are being "bent" and infractions are "overlooked" In the areas where there is a high Muslim population. Laws like prayer in school. They have been serving Halal meals in the Dearborn schools as well (this is being pushed heavily to be expanded to other public schools in NY and other states) but you won't find any Kosher items in any of the schools in any of the states regardless of Jewish population. The point is that government/government institutions are making special accommodations for a specific group of people with a specific belief and that is not the way it is supposed to work.
When I wen to public school in Ohio, back in the fifties and sixties, we said the Lord's Prayer and the Pledge of Allegiance every morning and while no prodigies or multi-millionaires came out of the class neither did it spawn any lunatics or sociopaths.
I have no problem with prayer being excluded from public schools so long as all prayer is excluded from public schools.
EXACTLY!
Be careful, it is not PC to point this out.
They don't call it Dearbornistan for nuthin' ...
I seeded this story a few weeks ago... got no comments except a couple of the same shit being handed out right now. It got turned into a bash against Christians and the fact that the Muslims first campaigned and lobbied the city council to forbid the Christian children from leaving school early on Fridays to attend religious classes because it technically was against the law (they cited the separation of church and state) was conveniently pushed aside.
This situation has little to do with religion and everything to do with the insidious cancer of Islam that has become a protected disease within our society and within all western civilized nations. In an effort to show that we are tolerant and can embrace diversity, our government has told the citizens of this country that we have no national language, no national heritage, no national customs, no national traditions, no national pride... nothing in our country truly belongs to us, we are the bastards of the world order, we are the killers, the takers, the destroyers, the beserkers... we live only to apologize for living.
And the Muslims.... oh, the Muslims... we must wipe out any trace of Christianity in our government, in our schools, in our public institutions, in our cemetaries, in our public functions. We must completely separate any aspect of religion from anything we say or do... unless the person or group involved is Muslim and Islam.
A teacher showed a cartoon involving Mohammad to her class, which happened to include a couple of Muslim students.. it was a high school class. Next day a group of Somalis were protesting outside her classroom carrying on like a bunch of idiot jackasses, insisting she be fired for insulting "our precious prophet, what she did was illegal!" Now there is going to be "an inquiry" into the matter. What a fucking crock of shit! "An inquiry!" This happened in the United States of America, by the way. Not in a damn third world cesspool. None of the Somalis protesting even had a kid in the classroom. They are wailing and gnashing their teeth saying it is not freedom of speech to insult the prophet! Fire the woman! We demand you fire the woman!
So let's see if "the woman" gets fired for this. Let's see just how far Islam has taken over this Land of the Free and Home of the Brave.
The school district involved in this article first stopped all its students from leaving school early on Fridays to attend their Christian religious classes. Then the Muslim contingency approached the town council and the school board and demanded that the Muslim students be allowed to pray when they wanted to during the day and to leave school without prior arrangement with their teachers or the school, to attend religious sessions both on and off the school grounds. In every school district where Muslim students attend, the schools have made arrangements to provide classrooms for the students to pray.... a room for the boys and a separate one for the girls.
This has less to do with religion than it does with a show of power and control. And as we all know, the head of this country has already bowed down to the rulers of the Muslim world.
For the above reasons I am strictly against any prayer in school. I do understand what Hal was saying. Periodically, Christians have tried to get prayer in school... like when they found a loophole about self initiated prayer by students.
What if this was a Muslim group? Don't you think they will go there with this? I do.
It is best that we keep prayer at home or in houses of worship and then we wouldn't keep running into these issues.
I think this sentence sums up what is happening pretty accurately.
Only if you let that happen.
Take the 9/11 Mosque.
Before 9/11, there were more than 130 mosques in NYC, two of them right by the WTC. The one that they wanted to to convert into a "Muslim Center" would make 3, since it was in operation before 9/11.
After 9/11, they wanted to make it the tallest building in the area. The sign of a Caliphate.
NYer's are a very tolerant people, but they understood the meaning of this specific mosque. It was to show domination... and it's funders CAIR have links to the Muslim Brotherhood. So we protested not to have it built. And due to all the bad publicity, it wasn't.
This had nothing to do with it being Muslim, but the message this particular mosque was sending.
Like any other group, it is easy to ID and hate, if that is where we want to go. I think as a society, we should treat Muslims no different than any other group that has come here. If we do that, there will be nocaliphate.
Several years ago, there was a controversy in Toronto, Canada about a public middle school allowing the 400 Muslim students to take over the school cafeteria every Friday afternoon for prayers.
Notice the usual Muslim gender segregation even among children: boys in the front, girls in the back, and far in the back are menstruating girls. Since they are considered "unclean", they are allowed to attend but not to participate in the prayers.
Hal, what I have been saying all along is the rule should apply to all religions but you are like a broken record stuck on Christianity. Which brings us back to the original question...
Funny that the REAL war on women is completely ignored isn't it.
I agree 100% but unfortunately this is not what is happening and this article is proof of that. Illustrating this exact problem is why the article was posted in the first place.
Gene,
There is a difference with your statement and mine. I just said to treat them no differently than any other immigrant group... therefore, no special treatment. Hence why I said earlier that there should be no prayer in public schools. It makes a cleardelineation between their wants and the law.
Seattle is the city where the Somalis are demanding the teacher be fired for showing the drawing of Mohammad.
Seattle. Washington. In the United States. Of America.
There is going to be an "inquiry." Because the Muslims demand it. Because "freedom of speech" does not mean that one can show a drawing of the great prophet Mohammad, which is against the law, no matter what land you are in.
Good to see this seeded.
For a little background, I found this article to be informative...
My comment on another seed, as relevant here as there:
Very true. Americans are assimilating with the Muslims - teaching Islam in the public schools, providing them places to worship in public facilities, allowing CAIR to successfully bully Universities (remember Brandeis), permitting shouting down speakers who don't please Muslims, fearing mentioning the expression "radical Islamists", turning a blind eye to the harrassing of Jewish students (UCDavis), etc. etc.
Paving the way for the Caliphate. France...England...soon to come to America.
Gene,
I totally agree... but that is what I was saying.
Gunny, almost your words exactly were spoken by the Moroccan-born Muslim Mayor of Rotterdam in the Netherlands only a few weeks ago. Here is the title of the newspaper article in a U.K. newspaper:
Moroccan-born mayor of Rotterdam tells fellow Muslims who do not appreciate the 'freedoms' of living in the West to 'pack your bags and f*** off' on live TV
Read more:
Ask Buzz and a few others about how their governments treat/react to the Muslim demands. 'Member? In Canada, NO Muslim has been nor will be given citizenship. In Australia, same thing. In fact, the Australian PM has said exactly the same thing - you come here, you obey our laws - we don't obey yours.
The U. S. can keep the Native Americans down, but they can't control the Muslims???
Why are you complaining, Nonya Afai? Americans are kissing the asses of Muslims.
And you Muslim radicals go to schools and kill everyone just because someone said God instead of Allah. I guess words are more important to Muslim radicals, especially knowing they won't be kept.
Pretty much the point of the article. Let's treat them all the same.
RIO put it nicely
Sure don't worry about a group coming into your country and trying to change and shape the countries laws to suit them.
Would you like to start a debate on how much this happens with each group?
John, my basic problem is not knowing how to write/respond to such low levels for you to understand - and I apologize.
You and Hal both keep beating the same dead horse and I keep saying it ALL needs to be kept out
Not sure what you are getting at here. I am talking about an established country in which a group comes in and tries to change laws. Are you saying I shouldn't complain because 100's of years ago settlers came here and made their own laws? So we should let others come in and make their own laws? Can you tell me what country you are from so I can go there and change the laws to suit me? Maybe outlaw Sharia? Maybe make it legal to own a gun?
You are very good at deflection and avoiding the question.
let's see if you are capable of answering a direct question.
Do you think it is OK for people to immigrate to an established country and change the laws of that country, regardless of whether violence is necessary to achieve that goal?
BTW I noticed you avoided naming your country, that would have given a more level playing field on your argument wouldn't it? I think you will not provide this information so you can keep attacking America without anyone commenting on things your home country has carried out that may be a little controversial. A cowardly stance at best.
Or, the typical stance of a troll and impostor.
Typical liberal argument as well. Deny facts, deflect, imply racism.
Nonya,
You make huge jumps in logic here. What many Americans are saying is that Muslims are free to practice their religion, but not to make it part of our public schools. The separation of Church and State is part of our Constitution. I wouldn't want any one's religion in our public schools, not just Muslims.
96, what makes you think that Nonya is a liberal? I truly doubt they have any political agenda other than anti American.
Nonya,
You need to learn your American history and the Constitution before you make these outrageous claims.
Our laws come from our Constitution. The right to bear arms (guns) comes from ourConstitution. It is the 2nd Amendment. And actually, there are many Americans that chose not to bear arms, too.
And you would have to prove this outrageous claim:
How many years has the US been in Afghanistan (btw invited to stay)? As far as I can tell, the Afghanis are still their traditional selfs.
Funny how you enjoy that part of our Constitution. There are many places in the world where you can't do that. Just remember that when you go off all anti American. You know there is a reason you are here. More freedom, better chance at getting ahead. You never want to talk about that.
NOWHERE does the article make this claim. You are twisting things and jumping to BS conclusions as usual. Want to post the exact sentence in the article? Well of course you can't because it is typical made up JR BS.
Question to Nonya Afal: "How are you doing today Nonya?"
Nonya Afal: "I would be doing fine except that the American military is killing babies while they sleep, American banks and businesses are stealing the resources of the rest of the world and impoverishing billions of people, and the American people are the most ignorant, bigoted, violent, and selfish people ever to walk the face of the earth. Other than that, I am doing great."
I have checked and no Gene.. they are not fake.
John,
Self initiated prayer is allowed in schools. They are not provided special times or places to pray. It must be at off times and not intrusive.
I disagree 96. Once you allow prayer in a public school, you open the doors legally for other faiths to do the same thing. There is a reason we have a separation of church and state, and this is why.
Spot on BF
What the Muslims are doing is working to have every other religion's prayers taken out of schools, and only Islam's prayers left in them. And they are very effective at it, because no one wants to upset the Muslims.
Yet Nonya enjoys life here in the good old US of A.
The live among people they despise. How convenient. I wonder if he tells this to any other Americans, or keeps this hate just for the internet?
Actually, Yes, it does. Here is a blurb from an article discussing that CAIR went out of their way to strip this same practice from other schools that were not invoking Muslim prayer.
This was the reason given for them attacking schools that advocate any prayer other than Muslim.
I said it before and I will say it again. I am fine with keeping ALL religion out of schools as long as we keep ALL religion out of schools.
TMI - OMG - TMI
Didn't read the article, did you. Specifically states that first the Muslims in the community complained about the Christian prayers in the school and the Christian children being allowed to leave early on Fridays for prayer classes.
After that got stopped, they then got Islamic prayers into the school and permission for Muslims to leave the school grounds to attend religious sessions without prior notice to teachers.
(You will receive fifty lashes at sundown, after evening prayers, for using the word "baloney" and conotates the actual word "bologna" which is made from pig entrails and should never be used when speaking of Muslims or Islam.)
My pleasure John.
Quit your bullshit John and link the EXACT QUOTE, WORDS or STFU
BF, I always suspected you were one of those naked moss-burners that my Mama warned me about.
Oh yeah - they also want the Bible as the state book.
...and Jesus to be their mascot. The kids can draw pictures of Him and nobody will kill them.
This sounds a lot safer for the children!
Still aren't going to tell anyone where you're from, can't say I'm surprised. TROLL!
How did I know you would ignore the fact that CAIR is fighting to remove all other religion from schools.
I agree and that is why I keep saying I am fine with removal of prayer from schools as long as ALL prayer is removed from schools. CAIR is attempting to allow only Muslim prayer.
Though I live here now, I would hate to be a native of MS if this is what the Magnolia State Heritage Campaign wants the state to be known for. These guys should be tarred and feathered for such a ridiculous idea.
CAIR is doing what it does, and I wouldn't expect them not to. They push for Muslim rights and at the same time, are a front for extremist groups. Theywould also be disingenuous in work for equal rights, when that is obviously not what they want (they ask for more rights for muslims). Now, that all being said, does notexcuse non-factual information.
The title of this article is misleading, as it appears that various groups are attempting to gain more rights for prayers, both Christina and Muslim, in MI schools. I'm not saying we don't need to be vigilant, or aware; but, that crying wolf only leads to disaster down the road. We do need to be bold in assertions of ourrights, but circumspect while doing so. Keep on eye on Dearborn, but so far, the public education system seems to be walking the tightrope.
After being tarred and feathered they should be drug behind a paddle wheel on an old river boat. Tom Sawyer or Huckleberry Finn should be the state book if they just have to have one.
Where are you from TROLL?
As if to confirm your statement..
This article is about Muslims pushing Islamic prayer while suppressing others. Tell you what Hal, You find a situation where Christians are pushing their own prayer AND suppressing other prayer at the same time and I will be all over it.
Read up.
I won't assist you any further than that. You have google, and you know how to use it.
That is not an example but nice try. Maybe you can actually find AN EXAMPLE? You know, a situation in which this actually happened. Oh and the example must be less than 200 years old to be relevant BTW.
Ack! I could have went the rest of my life without that visual. Thanks a lot!
Yea, I knew you were too much of a coward to say where you are from. Deny facts, deflect and imply racism is all you got. Are you really so ashamed of your home country you will not even name it? How sad. It is obviously much worse than here or you would leave and go back home seeing as you hate America. I live in America BTW.
How much would you wager the coward is taking advantage of every form of government assistance available while she spews her hate?
Nonya,
I have yet to call you names. I have asked you some questions based on your responses. You might have taken the citizens test, but you don't seem to like being here, or for that matter have any respect for America at all.
First of all, all news lies, and not just here in the US. And the rich have the run of the world, not just the US.
And your fixation on the Second Amendment kind of confuses me, since you are using the first a lot.
I am free to vote and my vote does count. Just recently I used my vote to stop the culling of geese in my area. That meant that I beat the rich country club who wanted it.
I am not so sure why you are so angry at the US as if being rich is only here.
At least I am not afraid to say what country I was born in. You attack and insult the US but you won't name your home country. Why? Are you really so ashamed of your country? Is that why you left it?
People who are murdered by cowardly followers of Islam can't be bought again at WalMart either. Perhaps you should go back to the country you are so ashamed of you will not speak it's name.
Do you want to know what is rude? You are the epitome of rudeness and arrogance (among other negative traits). You come on a discussion website primarily of Americans simply to insult, lie about, and demean everything about our citizens and our country. One simply has to look at your 100+ comments in the short time we have been afflicted with you to see nothing but anti-American monologues.
Nonya,
I am Indian so please don't lecture me on being Indian. Indians also fought to protect the USA. They love this country despite the injustices done to them in the past. Ironically, you speak for us.
I have never clapped at the loss of innocent life. Is it easier to think of us as always the aggressors?
As for free speech, try saying this stuff in China, Russia, Iran. Let's see how long it would take before you were in prison. Some things are pretty good here.
Frankly, I don't care where you are from. But what I do care about is how much you criticize the USA, and yet, you relocated here. How good was your old home? Probably not so hot, otherwise you wouldn't be here.
Nonya, I think everyone on this site can agree the us the US has done things we are not proud of, but we do the best to correct those things. I am active in government to try to fix these things. You claim you love America, you have a funny way of showing it.
I told you I live in America
What is rude are your posts. You obviously don't have the guts to discuss any issues your home country has but you will sling the mud at us. Like I said before, you are a coward.
Your home country must be a real shit hole if you are willing to stay in a country you hate so much just to to avoid your own. Can you tell us why you left?
Anyone can pray at anytime during the school day, if that is their desire. The schools cannot hinder that, nor can they actively promote prayer. As long as they are doing neither of these, I have no problem at all. (Well, except for the fact that I am not religious and do not see the need to pray to anything.)
So the question arises: Is the making of allowances for the one religion a preferential treatment, or merely an accommodation made due to the large muslim population in the particular school? Muslims are required by their faith to pray in certain fashion at certain, specific times during the day. If the christians in the school had a similar requirement (which they don't) you can most likely rest assured that the outcry would be coming from them about how it is their constitutional right to not have their religion discriminated against.
Religion in general equals a great waste of humanities potential. But it would be wasted killing each other for something different if religion was not around....
Mr. Gunny,
I will not tell you my country because then you find out there we kill if you try to leave Islam. We stone women and "men" of my country rape 9 year old girls and I not want to hear negative of my country. I only spew negative of yours. I leave home country because it is shit hole but I hate America too. I use "" around the word MEN because we use word "men" very loosely. There are no real men in home country only women abusers, pedophiles and those too afraid of Islam to stand up to it. We fight like Iraqis of Mosul. We are country of cowards.
Love Nonya
I agree. Wow, twice in one day. How about that? There are also people who believe if there was no religion there would also be a much larger absence of moralism.
Racist at best.
"This is true. I can show you news that isn't lies about it. I can show you graves, but you won't listen to Instead, you call babies terrorists and blow them up from Washington."
All wars have collateral damage. It is hard to minimize this when cowards hide among women and children.
"Where is Saddam? How many countries have you destroyed and then set up dancing governments?"
This is true. The only true statement you have made. Now let me ask you, did you leave your country because as a women you are tired of being oppressed? Are you tired of your men raping 9 year old girls? Did you leave because you left Islam and would be murdered if you didn't leave?
There is more to being American than "paper to say so" they hand that paper out to damn near anyone and you are proof of that. You have a lot to learn.
You usually make fairly cogent comments Broliver, but I disagree with you onthis. Some, maybe even many,Christianshave fought battles in attempts to reinstate some of their practices in public schools, but our laws have for the most part continued to make inroads in separating religion from the State. In many cases, Christians themselves have made the changes in their practices to accommodate their belief in that separation as well. The reason why we don't see Christians being as expressive about prayer in school isn't because they don't believe in prayeras practicing their faith,or because they wouldn't like to; but, because they have been forced to that by law. You seem to make the argument that Muslim religious directives are more important than others, because many of them seem to take them asmore important.
If my religion practices stopping for 5 chocolate breaks a day over soap operas, that doesn't mean my public school should accommodate that, any more than they do any other religion.
Nonya,
The only question I want to know is if America sucks so badly why did you come here. You could have gone anywhere. You have nothing but bad things to say about our society... then I wouldn't want to live here, if I was you.
I know what it is Hal, If it is the huge problem you claim it to be it shouldn't be very hard to provide an example.
Yes, they're called idiots. Prisons are not filled with atheists.
Facts are facts regardless for the source. I provided you enough information including the school districts they protested the same actions from other religions in. Here it is again: Roseville public schools. You can prove or disprove it easy enough with a search of your own. Or you can stay willfully ignorant.
BTW I think everyone knows the LWN will not even call it Islamic terrorism much less report on it in a negative light. Just like the "news" they provide on Obama.
When's the last time you did roll call?
Nonya,
There are many white people who don't hate anyone. They have come to the USA for the same reasons you did, for a better life.
When you talk about blacks, you might not realize that there were many whites who helped blacks in the 60's get equality. It is not fair to say that all whites are bad, just as it would not be fair to say all Muslims are bad.
There are two kinds of richness. One is money and the other comes from character. I would much rather be rich in character than just money.
Who are these white people who hate? The white people who came to America, came from all over the world. They don't all hate.
I am sorry that your town is no more.
[rolls eyes]
Yes I know the percentage is low However, let's not overlook other variables mentioned:
Atheists love to tout this statistic and show it gives them ground to claim an upper hand on morality, but this is not so according to James Croft, doctoral candidate at the Harvard Graduate School of Education and blogger at Temple of the Future:
Crofts point about racial injustice is not one that should be overlooked. A 2009 Pew Research poll showed that 87 percent of African Americans identified as religious. When we look at the U.S. population as a whole, African Americans make up roughly 13 percent of the overall population, yet the percentage of African Americans incarcerated in the U.S. prison system is nearly 40 percent, according to a 2009 report by the U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics .
So when you have 87 percent of one racial group claiming to be religious, and the prison population is made up of almost half of that racial group, it is no surprise that the number of religious people in prison is so high.
Aranico also questioned how many of these inmates found religion after entering prison:
Prisoners are also known to claim religious beliefs because of special benefits inside of prison. A prisoner could claim to be Islamic in order to receive halal foods or claim to be Jewish for kosher meals. You can also use religion as an excuse to opt-out of medical procedures such as a tuberculosis test. While the percentage of these false religious claims is unknown, it is worth noting that they exist and can skew numbers in different directions.
Religious prison outreach programs are also very popular in the prison system and do offer many inmates a chance to feel as though they can be forgiven for their crimes. So it would not be wrong to point out that while many may not go into prison claiming any religious affiliation, they may end up finding faith inside as a way to cope with incarceration.
Both Aranico and Croft seem to look past the morality issue and focus on a social injustice problem. One should also be leery of generalizations that everyone in prison has done something morally wrong. Due to the war on drugs, large numbers of people have been locked up for victimless crimes, so a high percentage of a prison population has committed no moral injustice.
One cannot overlook the importance of race on this issue. African Americans make up only 13 percent of the U.S. population, and only 14 percent of the drug-using U.S. population, yet 37 percent of those arrested on drug charges in the U.S. are African American. It seems that race plays a very significant role in this number disparity.
Keeping this in mind I think the percentage would still be pretty low. Point taken.
So is that picture.
Nonya,
I was a teacher for over 20 years. I will know more about my countries history than you will ever know. That isn't a put down, but it is meant to make you understand that you don't know how complex our history is.
Our founding father. many of them were against slavery. Read the Koran. Adams and Jefferson and Franklin were all white men who cared about blacks. But there was a bigger war at hand. The war for Independence, and there was no way the south was going to sign the Declaration of Independence with an anti slavery clause, so it was removed.
You use the word Yankee, yet that is the word identified with the North. White people who fought to free black people. White people who hid black slaves.
Our history with Islam has also been long. We had the Barbary Wars. Do you know what that was about? Read about that here:
We were not the aggressors there. It is also why Jefferson wanted to understand Islam.
You should learn more about these white men you condemn. Here is another interesting article:
So no, white people don't hate black people.. or any other kinds of people. They are no different than those who hate us. Hate begets hate... so no one is really clean of it anyway.
Just arranging your broken up statements into something that makes sense.
You are just too cowardly to admit where you come from so we can discuss it. You don't want to discuss that. You just want to insult America. You really are ashamed aren't you? Or are you afraid? Why are you afraid/ashamed to discuss where you came from? Why do you hide it? Is it really that horrible?
Larry,
As was noted elsewhere (I think by 96) the CotUS mentions establishment and free practice of. Establishment of religion the federal Government cannot do, and neither can it inhibit the free practice of religion. This whole article is based on the false premise that christians cannot pray in school while muslims can. This is false and a lie that is used to enable hate mongers to whip up angst against muslims and a feeling of being persecuted in for being a christian. In other words: Bull-pucky.
To illustrate, take for example public schools in NY State. Upstate rural districts are overwhelmingly christian. In those schools, permission is given to the children who's parents wish them to attend classes pertaining to catholic confirmation on certain afternoons, thereby achieving the same type of treatment that this article is complaining about. The protestant christians do not receive this time off. So it is recognized that different religions have different practices for christian religions. Why should it be any different for non-christian religions?
Downstate, the mixture is far more diverse, and around New York City there is a proportionally greater number of jewish people than in the upstate areas. As such, allowances are made for the practitioners of Judaism up to and including holidays from school (everybody gets them off). The practice is not (currently) given a second thought. In the parlance of the people arguing in agreement with this article, this would also be seen as preferential treatment. It is not. It is a recognition of different people having different religions and attempting to accommodate the same.
So, looking at this whole tempest in a teacup from the outside, it looks to me like the schools in the Dearborn area are attempting to abide by the letter and spirit of the Constitution by allowing the muslim community to pray as per their religions dictates (Free practice of Religion). The whole premise of the article (Muslims can pray while Christians can't) falls flat on it's face when you look at the CotUS, what the First Amendment says and what the current laws are around those, and at the duplicitous christians pushing this agenda. If the christian religions had in place a requirement to pray at specific times of the day, facing in a certain direction, assuming a certain posture, you can bet your sweet bippy that there would be accommodations made Because the CotUS is worded as it is.
I have no love for any religion. Religion has, imo, run it's course as a positive force and needs to get out of the way so that humanity can realize more of it's potential. The muslim religious directives are no more important than any other religions', but it is fact that the muslim faith requires the faithful to perform certain actions at certain times, while christianity, for the most part, does not. (Ignoring the strictures placed on Sunday, as most American christians do, too.)
The linked article is as logically flawed(and incomplete)as the source for this thread.
Nowhere, I repeat, nowhere in the linked articles is the connection made between the teacher passing out permission slips and CAIR reaction to it with the CAIR initiative to gain equal recognition by the school districts. The authors of both articles are conflating two, separate issues.
Please read my response to Larry below.
No, this is racist:
"How much would you wager the coward is taking advantage of every form of government assistance available while she spews her hate?"
How is that racist? She has not disclosed her race or where she is from. The only thing one can ascertain from her posts is that she is a low life just like the comment implied.
To what race? There are many immigrants that are a productive addition to our society. Her comments prove she is an ungrateful low life that hates the country she now lives in as well as about half the people in it. Someone like her would be very likely to milk the system.
1st said:
Sorry. The ScotUS said that prayer cannot be organized by the state per the establishment clause of the 1st Amendment.
96 said:
No. In areas of high muslim population, the schools haveaccommodatedthe religious views of muslims per the freeexerciseclause of the 1st Amendment.
Good article, Larry.
Thanks for adding This Larry
I agree, It really is a good addition. I am glad you took the time to read it, and I'm glad I did too.