High Schoolers Post Video That Scorches Bill O'Reilly And Fox News For Lack Of Journalistic Ethics
community » Discussions » Category » News & Politics » Discussion » High Schoolers Post Video That Scorches Bill O'Reilly And Fox News For Lack Of Journalistic Ethics
0
Category: News & Politics
Via: bob-nelson • 11 years ago • 64 comments
High schoolers didn't post that video left wing nut Jeff Grimshaw did. There is nothing fair and balanced about Jeff. The important message here is that Jeff is using these kids to promote his political ideology. There is nothing ethical about what he is doing.
So... you didn't bother to watch, did you? You cannot possibly think this video is not the work of the kids who appear in it, unless you simply do not watch it.
Thanks once again, Dean... for a magnificent demonstration of denialism!
People south of the Mason-Dixon Line probably understand that O'reilly hosts an opinion show. I guess the reporting/opinion distinction is a little much for the kids of Vermont.
Regardless of who, what, when, the high school studentsshowed some initiative, and maybe expanded their knowledge. Better than posting 'selfies' with each other.
You should be careful about your own "character assassination" of an area. Bill O'Reilly grew up in the town next to mine Levittown, Long Island, NY. That's right... he is a Downstater New Yorker. So New York does have what you call "wingnuts".
I have spent much time in Bennington, VT. It is one of the nicest, most polite towns you could want to visit. Lots of traditional values. These young students did a fine job of showing what yellow journalism is. That clip looked like it came off of Jay Leno's "Jaywalking". To call that journalism, is embarrassing. Here is what I am talking about:
I would have liked to have seen the one they did on the NYT.
You should be careful about your own "character assassination" of an area.
What character assassination? Do you really doubt that Fox viewership is vastly higher in Alabama than in Vermont? Or that Alabama schools are not as good -- teaching creationism and so on?
I'm sure that there are many fine people in Alabama, but statistically they are swamped by the wingnuts.
That clip looked like it came off of Jay Leno's "Jaywalking".
The two clips are actually very different. Leno asks questions that are asked of candidates for US citizenship. It is not ridiculous to suppose that all US citizens should be able to answer them. (Incidentally, I got them all right, so I guess I get to keep my passport...)
The Fox guy asks... his own leading questions, his own directed-answer questions... about Fox's own vision of America (as opposed to actual facts concerning America). There is no reason to expect anyone other than a die-hard Fox loyalist to answer those questions as the pseudo-reporter thought they should be answered.
Leno's questions have a kind of legitimacy. The Fox guy's questions have none.
The two clips are actuallyverydifferent. Leno asks questions that are asked of candidates for US citizenship.
The Fox guy asks...his ownleading questions,his owndirected-answer questions... aboutFox's own visionof America (as opposed to actualfactsconcerning America).
Leno's questions have a kind of legitimacy. The Fox guy's questions have none.
I watched this earlier, and thought-- Wow. They hit the nail on the head. I would like to see how other news media stacks up to their digging, as well!
YAY for intelligent high schoolers!
Yesterday, my son's Social Studies class, was joined by several other classes to meet a Holocaust survivor. The man spoke with them for about an hour, and when he was done, one of my son's classmates commented to my son, "He wasn't really a Holocaust survivor, because he wasn't in a death camp." Proud of my boy, who stood up to him and said, "What do you mean??? His life was drastically affected by the holocaust! He was lucky to have survived! Show some respect!"
Most of these kids are so ignorant, it's frightening... I mean, I can't fault the kids for being ignorant, if they haven't been exposed to certain things, but, what is frightening is that their parents are so ignorant, they taught them nothing! Ugh.
T he headlines were inevitable: Fact-Checking Site Finds Fox News Only Tells the Truth 18 Percent of the Time, Analysis: Over Half of ALL Statements Made On Fox News Are False, Fox News wins battle for most-false cable network. One particularly dim-witted account, written by Jameson Parker, reads: A new analysis by PunditFact found that of every statement made by a Fox News host or guest, over half of them were flat-out false. Whats more, only a measly 8 percent could be considered completely true. In other words, a fancy review of hundreds of hours of video confirmed what many who watch Fox News with any regularity already know: Fox News lies. A lot. Like all the time.
The study from PunditFact (a subdivision of PolitiFact), which is not really a study, says no such thing. You do not have to rely on my word for that: PunditFact itself warns against using its figures to draw broad conclusions, e.g. that Fox News lies like all the time. (Like, is this like a 1980s Valley-girl movie, or are you just, like, functionally illiterate?) That is because the study is an exercise in drawing nonsensical conclusions from arbitrary data.
Advertisement
The most obvious problem though certainly not the only problem, not even close is selection bias: PolitiFact is a readership-driven online publication, and thus it exercises a great deal of discretion about which statements it chooses to evaluate and why. The most obvious factor is that it evaluates only statements that are disputed. Specifically, it evaluates only statements that are disputed and that its editors believe will be of some interest or benefit to its readers.
Fox News is a personalities-driven opinion network with occasional news reports; it is inevitable that its broadcast hours will be more rapidly punctuated by controversial statements than those of, for example, ABC. Unsurprisingly, the opinion-heavy Fox News and MSNBC both have relatively high falsehood scores on the PolitiFact report card, while CNN doesnt. Its not as though Michaela Pereira never says anything that might be disputed she simply never says anything that is interesting, true or false, so nobody cares. Or, as PolitiFact puts it: We use our news judgment to pick the facts were going to check, so we certainly dont fact-check everything. And we dont fact-check the five network groups evenly.
No kidding. Say what you will about Bill OReilly, nobody ever made a living out of pretending to be Rachel Maddow . (No, Chris Hayes doesnt count.)
PolitiFacts kindergarten-level methodology here is to take the total number of statements it evaluates, tally up the mostly false, false, and pants on fire ratings, and then do a little division. Given the underlying selection issues, this amounts to nothing more than doing meaningless arithmetic on meaningless data. If PunditFact editor Aaron Sharockman spent more than 20 minutes on this so-called research, he should demand a refund from his university. (Given that he has a B.A. in journalism, he should demand a refund on general principles.)
By the same measure, approximately 100 percent of statements made by Paul Krugman evaluated in National Review are 1. mostly false; 2. false; 3. pants-on-fire; or, my own favorite designation, 4. wearing-full-Wayne-Newton-makeup-while-singing-Danke Schoen-at-4- a.m. -under-a-bridge-in-Cleveland crazy. But that does not mean that the sum of what comes out of Professor Krugmans mouth is 99 and 44/100 percent pure B.S., like some Bizarro World version of Ivory Soap it just means that we mostly tend to take notice of him when hes wrong. If he says you should try the cheese plate at Il Bambino, give the claim due consideration.
The deeper problem with PunditFact is the bias in how it evaluates statements. Consider two structurally identical questions: In the first, it considered Chris Wallaces claim that Hillary Clinton had defended Syrias President Assad as a possible reformer at the start of that countrys civil war. That statement, the editors decided, was only half-true, because that was not expressly her opinion. Rather, she had said that members of Congress of both parties who had visited Syria had suggested that Assad was a possible reformer. (Never mind that Mrs. Clintons claim is itself untrue , a three-Pinocchio offender in the Washington Post s judgment.)
In the second instance, PunditFact considered a claim from Bill OReilly, made during an interview with President Barack Obama, that he had not accused the administration of obscuring the motive behind the Benghazi attack for political reasons. OReilly had in fact interviewed people who said that, but he himself had not made that claim. PunditFact nonetheless rates it mostly false, because OReilly had, in its view, nurtured suspicion. Mr. OReilly and Mrs. Clinton were engaged in precisely the same rhetorical strategy: the time-honored Washington dodge of using others to suggest indirectly what you think or suspect yourself, e.g. its a serious charge, some have said, it has been suggested that, etc. In both cases, the statement was made on Fox News, but Mrs. Clinton gets a pass (not expressly her opinion) while Mr. OReilly gets labeled a liar for precisely the same thing. This is what simple bias looks like.
Its mostly a matter of sympathy not with different news networks, but with different political figures. When it considered Eric Bollings claim that the great majority of new jobs created during the Obama administration have gone to men, PunditFact labeled that a half-truth, too, even though, in its own words, the numbers are right. Why? Because as an attack on Obama, it rings hollow. Not exactly Karl Poppers intellectual standards at work.
But the fact is that unsupportable, boneheaded claims such as over half of ALL thanks for that all-caps attack, Einstein von Brainstorm statements made on Fox News Are False will live forever, because people are mostly interested in having their biases confirmed and their values affirmed rather than learning new things about the world and how it works. True, much as I like yelling at people on television, it is pretty hard to feel too bad for Fox News and MSNBC over an exercise in confirmation bias, but this sort of sloppy thinking and malicious manipulation does have the effect of leaving the polity a little dumber than it absolutely has to be. And that is an unforgivable sin.
I thought the students produced the video... Isn't that what it said in the article? This isn't the article I read, but one similar... I can't find the orginal article, it was linked on FB.
I was going to post this too, but Bob posted... I closed the tab with the original article, and, naturally, can't find it again... Sorry!
Watch the video, Robert-- one of the girls is reading something while speaking. Her eyes are tracking back and forth. I think a couple of them do, but she is obviously reading something. Perhaps they prepared their dialogue beforehand and used a prompter, or large cards, so they wouldn't forget them...
Eh, they're kids... It is hard enough to be all grown up and speak so intelligently, off the cuff. Many times, I've longed for a teleprompter, or something...
Regardless of who, what, when, the high school studentsshowed some initiative, and maybe expanded their knowledge. Better than posting 'selfies' with each other.
At what age do liberals grow up and become capable of seeing things for what they are? This is nothing more than the video itself as Perrie showed in a video. This children didn't take any initiative, nor did they learn anything other than the propaganda from the other side. Everyone had a script to read and they read it, kind of like that fellow who has spent millions in the last 6 years flying around campaigning, reading the same old BS. Looks like he would have it memorized by now, don't you think and wouldn't need all those teleprompters even in classrooms. Well that was really funny, Obama making a speech in a class room where the teacher teaches the students everyday and Obama has to have a sound system set up.
I don't know who wrote the cue cards or teleprompters, and that's a fact. But, I don't think their answers were memorized.
And yes, you shouldn't use kids to push an agenda. However, I don't think that is the issue. The issue is journalistic integrity of Fox news. As I stated above, I would love to see how the other news outlets stand up to their digging.
I clicked on the video thats how I know for a fact that it was Jeff who put it on Youtube. Click on the video and see for yourself before making yourself ridiculous.
Dowser, everyone of them were reading from a teleprompter or script they didn't write, I feel confident this is true.
How do you know that Six? Many of my kids projects were done at home but when into production at school.
It's almost child abuse to use children to push your agenda, but what's new?
Why assume there is an agenda? I think that their points were spot on about journalism. I would have also liked to have seen the one they did on the NYT, to see if they were practicing what they preached.
OK, instead of defending Fox's journalistic ethic, we've had the source denigrated-- who published the video, the kids that made the video, the ethics questioned of who published this, accusing them of "using" kids to get his message across, when, maybe the video just came to his attention and he published it. Then, as a last resort, you compare it to MSNBC, sort of like, if they do it, why can't we kind of thing... Who is accusing whom of sophmoric conduct?
No one is actually defending Fox's journalistic ethics...
Why do some many people believe it? Because it tells you what you want to hear?
I throw out a challenge, to everyone here who exclusively watches FOX news. If you will NOT watch Fox news for a week and watch CNN for a week, I'll send you $10. Do I have any takers? 7 days, starting on Monday, through Sunday of next week. Reply below, please...
We'll draw up a contract. Anyone that watches it, or posts articles or seeds derived from a subsidiary of Fox news will be disqualified. $10 to any takers of the bet. But, you have to be watching Fox news now, exclusively. One week of CNN.
Don't do it people that's cruel and unusual punishment. Anymore than fifteen minutes of Wolf Blitzer and you are risking PTSD. It's easier to watch an hour of Nyan Cat than ten minutes of Wolf.
No one is actually defending Fox's journalistic ethics...
Why does anyone have to defend Fox New's Dowser? We know Fox is just like all the rest of the channels, they have an agenda, but most people don't realize it's not what they think. They think Fox is different than any of the rest of these stations and separate, but that is not the case. They like the rest of the stations are playing their part in the big scam. Kind of think of it like attorneys.
OK, instead of defending Fox's journalistic ethic, we've had the source denigrated-- who published the video, the kids that made the video, the ethics questioned of who published this, accusing them of "using" kids to get his message across, when, maybe the video just came to his attention and he published it. Then, as a last resort, you compare it to MSNBC, sort of like, if they do it, why can't we kind of thing... Who is accusing whom of sophmoric conduct?
How about looking at my comment in context ? I was replying to THE aeon pax . Her comment demonstrated extreme bias in her attack on Fox w/o also mentioning MSNBC etc
That's very true Brolly. And while we're all being distracted important things are happening in this country and world which will affect us, kind of like the old days before WWII or the early 1900's in the Russian Empire.
Look, if we take an overview of all of the news networks, I would say that there are very few of them that don't have a bend to their depiction of the news to some extent. The question is do we support them or not. When we tune in, we are supporting them.
And when we tune in to only one, we may be supporting them, but when don't tune in to many and sort it out we are supporting ignorance. History, living history is the only way to find the truth and still it is nearly if not impossible in many cases to find the truth as we only know for the most part what we hear. Only when we have evidence that can't be denied do we actually achieve some semblance of truth.
I would like to see how other news media stacks up to their digging, as well!
I would too, but unfortunately, we live in a real world. That is an expose designed from one side to the other. which affects it's integrity/honesty for me.
I don't think the other side would fare very well.
I don't think that there is a person here who can deny that journalistic ethics have taken a beating in the last 20 years.
On day one of college journalism 1301,I wastaught rule #1: As future journalists, it was important that we understand our role as 'gate-keepers' in relation to reporting in a factual and unbiased way. It would be years before the phenomenon of 'journalistic spin' would become a meme. Shoot, the term 'meme' wouldn't even become a meme for another 15 years. In my day, opinion was opinion, and fact was fact, and differences in the two were quite obvious. Now, I am sometimes embarrassed to admit that I have a communication degree with an emphasis on journalism and photo-journalism. I didn't spend all that time in college just to be lumped in with those on the sensationalistic and/or tabloid-esqueside of the fence.
The rise of the internet has, to resort to an often-used metaphor, left gate keepers guarding their gates while the rest of the wall crumbles away. What has disappeared is the medias once respected gatekeeping role used to dictate the newsworthiness of an event in terms of its importance and also its validity.
Make no mistake, the kids in the video are very capable of understanding 'spin' when they see or hear it, and probably more so that adults. But the true problem is that 'spin' has been fundamentally embraced by all sides of an issue, especially when it suits a less than honorable agenda.
In regard to O'Reilly and Watters, itwas easy to spot that theywere relying heavily on innuendo, sarcasm, and laughter accompanied by an over-abundance of eye-rolling, in an effort to be believed. Also lovely, is that they picked on the citizens of Bennington, Vermont , which has a population 15,764. Had they focused their attention on a large cosmopolitan city where political lines are more defined, and the citizens more out-spoken, Mr. Watters would have been handed hissilly behindon a plate.
More importantly (IMO) is this: I bet that neither Mr. O'Reilly nor Mr. Watters expected any kind of rebuttal from the specifically-targeted tiny town, especially by high school students. It was a mistake for both men to underestimate the'liberal, pot smoking,ski bums'of Bennington, Vermont.
It seems to me that Fox represents something deeper than bad journalism. It is an invitation to its viewers to ignore reality in favor of a fantasy world where dogma replaces fact.
Creationism, personhood, Benghazi, 47%, not-native-born, and on and on... Reality is what Fox thinks its viewers want it to be.
I guess we have different definitions for "opinion". They presented extracts from the Fox "news interview". Then they presented the jounalist's rule that was violated.
Sorry I missed all the fireworks! It looked "interesting". We went out to dinner, and when we came home, we all watched a movie together on our new Amazon Fire Stick, and I've spent most of the day going over applications for the geology board, and avoiding having to work on the awful comparison I have to do... Now, I need to get started on that.
However, I noticed that one would take my challenge. Sigh! I can't afford to give more $$. And there would be those who would behave dishonorably, and say they hadn't watched it when they had...
The important message here is not that Fox News is a pack of lies -- everyone already knows that.
The important message here is that there are at least a few of our children who are learning to think.
Of course... they are in Vermont, not Alabama...
....."they are in Vermont, not Alabama".
My guess is the same thing would happen in every state NOT south of the Mason-Dixon Line/
High schoolers didn't post that video left wing nut Jeff Grimshaw did. There is nothing fair and balanced about Jeff. The important message here is that Jeff is using these kids to promote his political ideology. There is nothing ethical about what he is doing.
Sure. I picked Alabama at random. Any number of other havens for wingnuts would do as well.
So... you didn't bother to watch, did you? You cannot possibly think this video is not the work of the kids who appear in it, unless you simply do not watch it.
Thanks once again, Dean... for a magnificent demonstration of denialism!
You're as bad as Jeff you know damn well it was Jeff who posted the video and he's a political hacktivist.
Regardless of who, what, when, the high school studentsshowed some initiative, and maybe expanded their knowledge. Better than posting 'selfies' with each other.
Bob,
You should be careful about your own "character assassination" of an area. Bill O'Reilly grew up in the town next to mine Levittown, Long Island, NY. That's right... he is a Downstater New Yorker. So New York does have what you call "wingnuts".
I have spent much time in Bennington, VT. It is one of the nicest, most polite towns you could want to visit. Lots of traditional values. These young students did a fine job of showing what yellow journalism is. That clip looked like it came off of Jay Leno's "Jaywalking". To call that journalism, is embarrassing. Here is what I am talking about:
I would have liked to have seen the one they did on the NYT.
What character assassination? Do you really doubt that Fox viewership is vastly higher in Alabama than in Vermont? Or that Alabama schools are not as good -- teaching creationism and so on?
I'm sure that there are many fine people in Alabama, but statistically they are swamped by the wingnuts.
My point is that it is a dangerous thing to over generalize. We northerners have "wingnuts", too.
But take Atlanta, which is the south, and it is mostly liberal.
The whole point about this video, is to be accurate in reporting. I hate to be a nit picker, but that was my point.
Agreed!
The two clips are actually very different. Leno asks questions that are asked of candidates for US citizenship. It is not ridiculous to suppose that all US citizens should be able to answer them. (Incidentally, I got them all right, so I guess I get to keep my passport...)
The Fox guy asks... his own leading questions, his own directed-answer questions... about Fox's own vision of America (as opposed to actual facts concerning America). There is no reason to expect anyone other than a die-hard Fox loyalist to answer those questions as the pseudo-reporter thought they should be answered.
Leno's questions have a kind of legitimacy. The Fox guy's questions have none.
Actually, you have a very good point here.
Ah, Dean...
You may have noticed, below the video:
That blue text is kinda special. It is called a "link" if you click on it, you will go to the page where I got the video...
For pity's sake, Dean!! Watch the video and go to the link, before making yourself ridiculous...
I watched this earlier, and thought-- Wow. They hit the nail on the head. I would like to see how other news media stacks up to their digging, as well!
YAY for intelligent high schoolers!
Yesterday, my son's Social Studies class, was joined by several other classes to meet a Holocaust survivor. The man spoke with them for about an hour, and when he was done, one of my son's classmates commented to my son, "He wasn't really a Holocaust survivor, because he wasn't in a death camp." Proud of my boy, who stood up to him and said, "What do you mean??? His life was drastically affected by the holocaust! He was lucky to have survived! Show some respect!"
Most of these kids are so ignorant, it's frightening... I mean, I can't fault the kids for being ignorant, if they haven't been exposed to certain things, but, what is frightening is that their parents are so ignorant, they taught them nothing! Ugh.
How Stupid Happens
T he headlines were inevitable: Fact-Checking Site Finds Fox News Only Tells the Truth 18 Percent of the Time, Analysis: Over Half of ALL Statements Made On Fox News Are False, Fox News wins battle for most-false cable network. One particularly dim-witted account, written by Jameson Parker, reads: A new analysis by PunditFact found that of every statement made by a Fox News host or guest, over half of them were flat-out false. Whats more, only a measly 8 percent could be considered completely true. In other words, a fancy review of hundreds of hours of video confirmed what many who watch Fox News with any regularity already know: Fox News lies. A lot. Like all the time.
The study from PunditFact (a subdivision of PolitiFact), which is not really a study, says no such thing. You do not have to rely on my word for that: PunditFact itself warns against using its figures to draw broad conclusions, e.g. that Fox News lies like all the time. (Like, is this like a 1980s Valley-girl movie, or are you just, like, functionally illiterate?) That is because the study is an exercise in drawing nonsensical conclusions from arbitrary data.
The most obvious problem though certainly not the only problem, not even close is selection bias: PolitiFact is a readership-driven online publication, and thus it exercises a great deal of discretion about which statements it chooses to evaluate and why. The most obvious factor is that it evaluates only statements that are disputed. Specifically, it evaluates only statements that are disputed and that its editors believe will be of some interest or benefit to its readers.
Fox News is a personalities-driven opinion network with occasional news reports; it is inevitable that its broadcast hours will be more rapidly punctuated by controversial statements than those of, for example, ABC. Unsurprisingly, the opinion-heavy Fox News and MSNBC both have relatively high falsehood scores on the PolitiFact report card, while CNN doesnt. Its not as though Michaela Pereira never says anything that might be disputed she simply never says anything that is interesting, true or false, so nobody cares. Or, as PolitiFact puts it: We use our news judgment to pick the facts were going to check, so we certainly dont fact-check everything. And we dont fact-check the five network groups evenly.
No kidding. Say what you will about Bill OReilly, nobody ever made a living out of pretending to be Rachel Maddow . (No, Chris Hayes doesnt count.)
PolitiFacts kindergarten-level methodology here is to take the total number of statements it evaluates, tally up the mostly false, false, and pants on fire ratings, and then do a little division. Given the underlying selection issues, this amounts to nothing more than doing meaningless arithmetic on meaningless data. If PunditFact editor Aaron Sharockman spent more than 20 minutes on this so-called research, he should demand a refund from his university. (Given that he has a B.A. in journalism, he should demand a refund on general principles.)
By the same measure, approximately 100 percent of statements made by Paul Krugman evaluated in National Review are 1. mostly false; 2. false; 3. pants-on-fire; or, my own favorite designation, 4. wearing-full-Wayne-Newton-makeup-while-singing-Danke Schoen-at-4- a.m. -under-a-bridge-in-Cleveland crazy. But that does not mean that the sum of what comes out of Professor Krugmans mouth is 99 and 44/100 percent pure B.S., like some Bizarro World version of Ivory Soap it just means that we mostly tend to take notice of him when hes wrong. If he says you should try the cheese plate at Il Bambino, give the claim due consideration.
The deeper problem with PunditFact is the bias in how it evaluates statements. Consider two structurally identical questions: In the first, it considered Chris Wallaces claim that Hillary Clinton had defended Syrias President Assad as a possible reformer at the start of that countrys civil war. That statement, the editors decided, was only half-true, because that was not expressly her opinion. Rather, she had said that members of Congress of both parties who had visited Syria had suggested that Assad was a possible reformer. (Never mind that Mrs. Clintons claim is itself untrue , a three-Pinocchio offender in the Washington Post s judgment.)
In the second instance, PunditFact considered a claim from Bill OReilly, made during an interview with President Barack Obama, that he had not accused the administration of obscuring the motive behind the Benghazi attack for political reasons. OReilly had in fact interviewed people who said that, but he himself had not made that claim. PunditFact nonetheless rates it mostly false, because OReilly had, in its view, nurtured suspicion. Mr. OReilly and Mrs. Clinton were engaged in precisely the same rhetorical strategy: the time-honored Washington dodge of using others to suggest indirectly what you think or suspect yourself, e.g. its a serious charge, some have said, it has been suggested that, etc. In both cases, the statement was made on Fox News, but Mrs. Clinton gets a pass (not expressly her opinion) while Mr. OReilly gets labeled a liar for precisely the same thing. This is what simple bias looks like.
Its mostly a matter of sympathy not with different news networks, but with different political figures. When it considered Eric Bollings claim that the great majority of new jobs created during the Obama administration have gone to men, PunditFact labeled that a half-truth, too, even though, in its own words, the numbers are right. Why? Because as an attack on Obama, it rings hollow. Not exactly Karl Poppers intellectual standards at work.
But the fact is that unsupportable, boneheaded claims such as over half of ALL thanks for that all-caps attack, Einstein von Brainstorm statements made on Fox News Are False will live forever, because people are mostly interested in having their biases confirmed and their values affirmed rather than learning new things about the world and how it works. True, much as I like yelling at people on television, it is pretty hard to feel too bad for Fox News and MSNBC over an exercise in confirmation bias, but this sort of sloppy thinking and malicious manipulation does have the effect of leaving the polity a little dumber than it absolutely has to be. And that is an unforgivable sin.
~Link~
Hope this helps. LOL
They were reading off of a teleprompter or cue cards, I thought. Their eyes were moving...
I thought the students produced the video... Isn't that what it said in the article? This isn't the article I read, but one similar... I can't find the orginal article, it was linked on FB.
I was going to post this too, but Bob posted... I closed the tab with the original article, and, naturally, can't find it again... Sorry!
Watch the video, Robert-- one of the girls is reading something while speaking. Her eyes are tracking back and forth. I think a couple of them do, but she is obviously reading something. Perhaps they prepared their dialogue beforehand and used a prompter, or large cards, so they wouldn't forget them...
Eh, they're kids... It is hard enough to be all grown up and speak so intelligently, off the cuff. Many times, I've longed for a teleprompter, or something...
At what age do liberals grow up and become capable of seeing things for what they are? This is nothing more than the video itself as Perrie showed in a video. This children didn't take any initiative, nor did they learn anything other than the propaganda from the other side. Everyone had a script to read and they read it, kind of like that fellow who has spent millions in the last 6 years flying around campaigning, reading the same old BS. Looks like he would have it memorized by now, don't you think and wouldn't need all those teleprompters even in classrooms. Well that was really funny, Obama making a speech in a class room where the teacher teaches the students everyday and Obama has to have a sound system set up.
this is the only information I could find about Quantum Leap Extension Program... It's fairly interesting.
...
Dowser, everyone of them were reading from a teleprompter or script they didn't write, I feel confident this is true.
It's almost child abuse to use children to push your agenda, but what's new?
Speaking of child abusers...........
I don't know who wrote the cue cards or teleprompters, and that's a fact. But, I don't think their answers were memorized.
And yes, you shouldn't use kids to push an agenda. However, I don't think that is the issue. The issue is journalistic integrity of Fox news. As I stated above, I would love to see how the other news outlets stand up to their digging.
No, in fact. It doesn't. The article recognizes that Fox lies constantly... but seems not to consider that to be a default.
That's consistent with Fox-fandom, but disqualifies the author as a journalist.
Really? You're confident.
Interesting.
What tells you these kids are not reading their own words?
Thank you, Robert, for your incisive analysis. So unexpected...
I clicked on the video thats how I know for a fact that it was Jeff who put it on Youtube. Click on the video and see for yourself before making yourself ridiculous.
Yeah, they're just kids... If my son's classmates are any indication-- they're pretty clueless...
Look click the link look at the uploader.
Astonishing...
Thank you, bf, for another of the high-quality, thoughful contributions that are your hallmark.
We can always count on you to bring to the conversation your usual... crap.
Having proven your anonymous manhood, you may now jerk off.
I agree it is more astonishing but I don't think it's something that would stimulate me to whack off.
Bravo to those young adults. Fox has absolutely no ethics, journalistic or otherwise.
Bravo to that sophomoric effort ? How about mentioning the shameless mob pandering by MSNBC ...
How do you know that Six? Many of my kids projects were done at home but when into production at school.
Why assume there is an agenda? I think that their points were spot on about journalism. I would have also liked to have seen the one they did on the NYT, to see if they were practicing what they preached.
By definition... these kids are sophomoric, since they are probably sophomores.
My son just finished the work for a project at home, and he took it to school to video it... So, that doesn't prove anything.
I'd like to see the NYT one, too!
OK, instead of defending Fox's journalistic ethic, we've had the source denigrated-- who published the video, the kids that made the video, the ethics questioned of who published this, accusing them of "using" kids to get his message across, when, maybe the video just came to his attention and he published it. Then, as a last resort, you compare it to MSNBC, sort of like, if they do it, why can't we kind of thing... Who is accusing whom of sophmoric conduct?
No one is actually defending Fox's journalistic ethics...
Why do some many people believe it? Because it tells you what you want to hear?
I throw out a challenge, to everyone here who exclusively watches FOX news. If you will NOT watch Fox news for a week and watch CNN for a week, I'll send you $10. Do I have any takers? 7 days, starting on Monday, through Sunday of next week. Reply below, please...
We'll draw up a contract. Anyone that watches it, or posts articles or seeds derived from a subsidiary of Fox news will be disqualified. $10 to any takers of the bet. But, you have to be watching Fox news now, exclusively. One week of CNN.
Don't do it people that's cruel and unusual punishment. Anymore than fifteen minutes of Wolf Blitzer and you are risking PTSD. It's easier to watch an hour of Nyan Cat than ten minutes of Wolf.
So, I take it you refuse the challenge? I mean, gee, I didn't make it unbearable, like you had to watch MSNBC... Just the news, CNN
Why does anyone have to defend Fox New's Dowser? We know Fox is just like all the rest of the channels, they have an agenda, but most people don't realize it's not what they think. They think Fox is different than any of the rest of these stations and separate, but that is not the case. They like the rest of the stations are playing their part in the big scam. Kind of think of it like attorneys.
Yes, let's watch CNN. Completely unbiased. LOL
Everybody Blames somebody sometime...
Everybody wants to do it too....
Something in the way your logic goes by
Tells me that you like to do it too
How about looking at my comment in context ? I was replying to THE aeon pax . Her comment demonstrated extreme bias in her attack on Fox w/o also mentioning MSNBC etc
Bob, you need to read past the first paragraph to learn anything. LOL
That's very true Brolly. And while we're all being distracted important things are happening in this country and world which will affect us, kind of like the old days before WWII or the early 1900's in the Russian Empire.
Like what? Are you alluding to something sinister?
Nothing Brolly.
Thank you
Look, if we take an overview of all of the news networks, I would say that there are very few of them that don't have a bend to their depiction of the news to some extent. The question is do we support them or not. When we tune in, we are supporting them.
Just food for thought.
And when we tune in to only one, we may be supporting them, but when don't tune in to many and sort it out we are supporting ignorance. History, living history is the only way to find the truth and still it is nearly if not impossible in many cases to find the truth as we only know for the most part what we hear. Only when we have evidence that can't be denied do we actually achieve some semblance of truth.
Except for local news, weather and sports, I stopped watching all MSM TV news about ten years ago. I get 100% of my news online.
Study: People Who Don't Watch the News Are More Informed Than Fox Viewers
Those are sentences presentedby this counter-CNN videoas proof that the people at this rally had valid things to say, which were ignored by CNN.
I would too, but unfortunately, we live in a real world. That is an expose designed from one side to the other. which affects it's integrity/honesty for me.
I don't think the other side would fare very well.
I don't think that there is a person here who can deny that journalistic ethics have taken a beating in the last 20 years.
On day one of college journalism 1301,I wastaught rule #1: As future journalists, it was important that we understand our role as 'gate-keepers' in relation to reporting in a factual and unbiased way. It would be years before the phenomenon of 'journalistic spin' would become a meme. Shoot, the term 'meme' wouldn't even become a meme for another 15 years. In my day, opinion was opinion, and fact was fact, and differences in the two were quite obvious. Now, I am sometimes embarrassed to admit that I have a communication degree with an emphasis on journalism and photo-journalism. I didn't spend all that time in college just to be lumped in with those on the sensationalistic and/or tabloid-esqueside of the fence.
These days, this seems to be the norm :
Make no mistake, the kids in the video are very capable of understanding 'spin' when they see or hear it, and probably more so that adults. But the true problem is that 'spin' has been fundamentally embraced by all sides of an issue, especially when it suits a less than honorable agenda.
In regard to O'Reilly and Watters, itwas easy to spot that theywere relying heavily on innuendo, sarcasm, and laughter accompanied by an over-abundance of eye-rolling, in an effort to be believed. Also lovely, is that they picked on the citizens of Bennington, Vermont , which has a population 15,764. Had they focused their attention on a large cosmopolitan city where political lines are more defined, and the citizens more out-spoken, Mr. Watters would have been handed hissilly behindon a plate.
More importantly (IMO) is this: I bet that neither Mr. O'Reilly nor Mr. Watters expected any kind of rebuttal from the specifically-targeted tiny town, especially by high school students. It was a mistake for both men to underestimate the'liberal, pot smoking,ski bums'of Bennington, Vermont.
Yes.
It seems to me that Fox represents something deeper than bad journalism. It is an invitation to its viewers to ignore reality in favor of a fantasy world where dogma replaces fact.
Creationism, personhood, Benghazi, 47%, not-native-born, and on and on... Reality is what Fox thinks its viewers want it to be.
Here's the difference: these kids didn't just toss out a baseless "I don't think... ". They proved their point.
Other than the general error of criticizing Fox, can you please be specific?
What do you see as errors in the kids' video?
I guess we have different definitions for "opinion". They presented extracts from the Fox "news interview". Then they presented the jounalist's rule that was violated.
I see facts, there. Not opinions.
Damn Robert - I like that
Sorry I missed all the fireworks! It looked "interesting". We went out to dinner, and when we came home, we all watched a movie together on our new Amazon Fire Stick, and I've spent most of the day going over applications for the geology board, and avoiding having to work on the awful comparison I have to do... Now, I need to get started on that.
However, I noticed that one would take my challenge. Sigh! I can't afford to give more $$. And there would be those who would behave dishonorably, and say they hadn't watched it when they had...
Best of luck to all here!
Yeah, me either.