Via: petey-coober • 11 years ago • 27 comments
There have been numerous reports about the recent Muslim extremist attack on the Paris satirist office . If a similar attack happened in the US would it be labeled a hate crime ?
In the US the issue of hate crimes seems to have a lot to do with what is said during the commission of the crime . If the above reports are accurate I expect there would be such a determination by the FBI . Opinions from all you NT amateur lawyers ?
I include myself under the classification of NT amateur lawyer . So the following is my non-expert opinion :
Only if the incident was precipitated by an employee or ex-employee would it be a "workplace incident" . The only other example I can allude to is Major Nidal Hasan at Fort Hood . He was in fact an employee ... How does that sound ?
I expect we amateurs have landed on a consensus . If we can just get a few more we could have a quorum ... And sorry that we likely don't agree on Hasan . But I'm open to hearing other arguments about that case .
The issue is how would US authorities label it if it happened here . Hate crimes have very specific criteria that they are judged by . Does the incident meet those criteria ?
If this massacre carried out by Muslim terrorists were carried out in the U.S., there would be no need to enhance the penalties through hate crime legislation already on the books. It being a planned armed assault and murder of specific employees of the publication would automatically make it multiple counts of first degree murder. It would then be a capital crime worthy of the death penalty (in most states) or life without the possibility of parole. The addition of charges of terrorism could be assessed if proven the acts were an attempt to coerce the government to outlaw the actions of the publication as detrimental to the safety and welfare of the public good.
You have brought up several important points ... at least 3 that I can see : 1] Does hate crimes legislation cause more problems than it solves ? 2] terrorism is certainly a likely charge to apply but it might not succeed in certain venues That is where hate crimes legislation comes into play . 3] For example if the crime had happened in Dearborn , Mi the outcome of a prosecution for either of the crimes you mentioned might be in doubt . That is where hate crimes legislation comes in . That is from my amateur lawyer POV .
Petey, my comment was strictly addressing the question you posed in the post regarding a similar crime to today's Paris mass murder happening in the U.S. The addition of hate crime enhancements would be redundant as the penalties for the perpetrators would already be the maximum allowed by Federal or any state law (death or life w/o parole).
It is clearly a workplace incident, in the eyes of the workers and employees.
It is clearly a hate crime from a religious standpoint.
I am also an amateur lawyer, but have actually served at representing people on the few occasions that the law allowed me to.
From a political/national defense point of view it is a terrorist act.
From a workers compensation point of view it is a workplace incident.
And it is a bigoted hate crime.
One must understand the most important side of this IS bigotry, pure unadulterated hate. something you are not going to alleviate with laws or understanding.
When bigotry takes to using force as it's means to it's ends, only greater force will cause it to give pause. The same as it took the application of federal force and forces to combat bigotry in our own south.
It will take the same level of commitment by the entire world to fight back against the coming onslaught of religious bigotry.
It will only succeed if the rest of the world can put aside their differences.
Well ... I'm afraid I've gotten the pageview bug . It happened on a recent article which took off on google for reasons I haven't a clue about . After the dust cleared it had > 2000 pageviews :
I wouldnt know if the Paris crime would constitute a hate crime in the US. Its actually very rarely used here and when it is, it's politically motivated.
Ive been against hate crime enhancements from the start as they are nothing more than feel good laws enacted to pacify certain people. As many have predicted from the start, they do nothing to prevent crime.
Murder is not something one does to show their affection and love for another person. If so, it would be called a love crime. With the possible exception of legal prohibitions such as euthanasia, etc, all murders involve a degree of moral turpitude or, in the vernacular, hate. Calling murder a hate crime is needlessly repetitive.
Based on the reports of what was said it sounds like it might be a hate crime :
...
Anyone have thoughts about the hypothetical US legal ramifications ?
In the US the issue of hate crimes seems to have a lot to do with what is said during the commission of the crime . If the above reports are accurate I expect there would be such a determination by the FBI . Opinions from all you NT amateur lawyers ?
It happened at the office of the publication.
That would make it a "workplace incident", no?
I include myself under the classification of NT amateur lawyer . So the following is my non-expert opinion :
Only if the incident was precipitated by an employee or ex-employee would it be a "workplace incident" . The only other example I can allude to is Major Nidal Hasan at Fort Hood . He was in fact an employee ... How does that sound ?
Why are you here ? If you're disinterested , go away .
Please stay on topic. Petey isn't it.
'sigh'
I suppose you're right. I'm not much of an amateur lawyer.
My opinion is that it's more an act of terrorism than a hate crime.
Go away ... You haven't a clue what the topic is .
I expect we amateurs have landed on a consensus . If we can just get a few more we could have a quorum ... And sorry that we likely don't agree on Hasan . But I'm open to hearing other arguments about that case .
[Is the] Paris attack a "hate crime" ?
Well, it certainly isn't a love crime.
Would anyone else like to express their opinion about the Nidal Hasan case ?
Aeon ,
The issue is how would US authorities label it if it happened here . Hate crimes have very specific criteria that they are judged by . Does the incident meet those criteria ?
If this massacre carried out by Muslim terrorists were carried out in the U.S., there would be no need to enhance the penalties through hate crime legislation already on the books. It being a planned armed assault and murder of specific employees of the publication would automatically make it multiple counts of first degree murder. It would then be a capital crime worthy of the death penalty (in most states) or life without the possibility of parole. The addition of charges of terrorism could be assessed if proven the acts were an attempt to coerce the government to outlaw the actions of the publication as detrimental to the safety and welfare of the public good.
Mike ,
You have brought up several important points ... at least 3 that I can see :
1] Does hate crimes legislation cause more problems than it solves ?
2] terrorism is certainly a likely charge to apply but it might not succeed in certain venues
That is where hate crimes legislation comes into play .
3] For example if the crime had happened in Dearborn , Mi the outcome of a prosecution for either of the crimes you mentioned might be in doubt . That is where hate crimes legislation comes in . That is from my amateur lawyer POV .
Clearly ? Try putting on your reading glasses ... Or else enlighten the rest of us with your profundity .
I can't hear your voice over teh internets . Next time try a *sarc tag .
Petey, my comment was strictly addressing the question you posed in the post regarding a similar crime to today's Paris mass murder happening in the U.S. The addition of hate crime enhancements would be redundant as the penalties for the perpetrators would already be the maximum allowed by Federal or any state law (death or life w/o parole).
Not in every situation . See 3] above .
It is clearly an act of terrorism.
It is clearly a workplace incident, in the eyes of the workers and employees.
It is clearly a hate crime from a religious standpoint.
I am also an amateur lawyer, but have actually served at representing people on the few occasions that the law allowed me to.
From a political/national defense point of view it is a terrorist act.
From a workers compensation point of view it is a workplace incident.
And it is a bigoted hate crime.
One must understand the most important side of this IS bigotry, pure unadulterated hate. something you are not going to alleviate with laws or understanding.
When bigotry takes to using force as it's means to it's ends, only greater force will cause it to give pause. The same as it took the application of federal force and forces to combat bigotry in our own south.
It will take the same level of commitment by the entire world to fight back against the coming onslaught of religious bigotry.
It will only succeed if the rest of the world can put aside their differences.
So far, we have been unable to...
You talking to me?
I was being serious.
the 'roo, can go hop himself.
(No matter what pic Petey uses to represent himself, he isn't a 'roo)
I'm not making this comment to make a point ... only to drive the pageviews over 100 .
I never saw you as a post whore Petey,
Please SAY IT AIN'T SO!!!!
Well ... I'm afraid I've gotten the pageview bug . It happened on a recent article which took off on google for reasons I haven't a clue about . After the dust cleared it had > 2000 pageviews :
I wouldnt know if the Paris crime would constitute a hate crime in the US. Its actually very rarely used here and when it is, it's politically motivated.
Ive been against hate crime enhancements from the start as they are nothing more than feel good laws enacted to pacify certain people. As many have predicted from the start, they do nothing to prevent crime.
Murder is not something one does to show their affection and love for another person. If so, it would be called a love crime. With the possible exception of legal prohibitions such as euthanasia, etc, all murders involve a degree of moral turpitude or, in the vernacular, hate. Calling murder a hate crime is needlessly repetitive.
That seems to me to be far too broad a generalization . IMO there are times when it is a necessary legal determination to insure justice is done .
Use of the word " nothing " is again an assumption that you have considered all cases . You haven't .
Not really . Quite a few murders are done in a cold blooded fashion especially if a gun is involved .
Since the topic of Charlie Hebdo continues to fill the front page even a ttt article like mine revives from its coma ...
I am calling for an official time of death . Let the new thread be born :