American Teachers: As Mediocre as American Students?
Making a sustained effort to attract more talented teachers could help solve this problem.
Its common knowledge that American students are mediocre when it comes to taking tests. Now we know that American teachers are too.
In a study published this week by the National Bureau of Economic Research, Stanford Economist Eric Hanushek used new data from the Survey of Adult skills, conducted by the OECD, which seeks to help governments around the world understand the level and distribution of cognitive skills in their populations. Hanushek and his colleagues isolated elementary and secondary level teachers to find out how teachers cognitive abilities differ across countries.
He found a great degree of variance between the literacy and numeracy skills of teachers across the developed world. For instance, teacher skills in the worst-performing countries, like Italy and Russia, are on par with workers with just some college education in Canada, while teachers in the best-performing countries, like Japan and Finland, have skills on par with PhD graduates in Canada.
So, where do U.S. teachers fall on the spectrum? They are slightly above average in literacy skills, but below average in terms of numeracy. These results mirror international assessments of student abilities, in which American students also rank below average in math skills compared to their peers in other developed countries. According to Hanushek, this shouldnt surprise us. He finds that teacher cognitive ability correlates strongly with student abilities.
High-profile efforts like Teach for America were founded on the idea that if American schools can attract high-achieving, intelligent college graduates to the classroom, those schools would improve. Advocates of this strategy pointed to countries like Finland, South Korea, and Singapore, where students get high marks on international measures of student aptitude, and where teaching is a profession that attracts the best and the brightest.
As critics of Teach for America and similar programs have pointed out, these programs havent produced the results many imagined they would. Fordham University Professor Mark Naison, who writes that he was once enthusiastic about the idea of recruiting my most idealistic and talented students for work in poor schools, no longer allows TFA recruiters in his classroom because he thinks the training they receive is too limited and the commitment required of teachers is too short for enrollees to become effective teachers.
Of course, requiring longer training periods and commitments of TFA training recruits will cost more. In 2010, McKinsey & Company released a report that attempted to answer why America isnt attracting the best and the brightest to the teaching profession, and it concluded that pay was a primary factor. In South Korea, for instance, the average starting salary for teachers is $55,000 with top salaries reaching $155,000. Compare that to an average starting salary in the U.S. of $39,000 which maxes out, on average, at $67,000.
Countries with the best education systems have very low birth rates, and a very small percentage of their populations are made up of children. About 20% of the U.S. population is under the age of 14, while only 15% of the South Korean population is in the same age range. Singapore and Finland are similarly aged societies, too. Fewer children means less of a need for teachers, and that means its easier for these countries to make the teaching profession both well paid and prestigious.
But if the United States is convinced that it wants to move up the rankings, simply offering new teachers higher pay and a pathway towards a salary that rivals more elite professional careers is likely the simplest approach. It wont be cheapMcKinsey estimates that raising teacher pay to South Koreas level would cost $30 billion per year, or 5% of what the U.S. already spends on K-12 education.
But doesnt the U.S. already spend a ton on education, you ask? Yes, by some measures. The OECD estimates that America spends more per student, $15,171, each year than any other developed country. But that measure doesnt focus just on government expenditure25% of that figure takes into account what parents spend privately on education. Furthermore, the U.S. doles out its educational resources unevenly. Spending per student varies highly depending on the state and school district, while the U.S. is one of only three countries (along with Israel and Turkey) that devote more educational resources to more affluent students than it does to the disadvantaged.
Corporate America has identified the U.S. education system as one of the biggest obstacles in creating the sort of workforce it needs to stay competitive in a global economy. Some of this problem can be solved by improved cooperation between educators and employers, but part of the issue is simply that workers dont have the core skills to accomplish tasks demanded by a modern economy. Making a sustained effort to attract more talented teachers could help solve this problem.
http://fortune.com/2014/12/12/american-teachers-skills/

This reality is an indictment of the systems - the education system that prepares teachers, the economic system that pays the teachers and the financial and government systems that fail to adequately and intelligently invest in education.
Those are realities and the result is
And this is totally unacceptable, we owe it to our children, grandchildren and the future of the country to fix this problem
1) I think a lot of it, too, is the more things change, the more things stay the same. What I mean: I'm on my 5th "new" math. The first happened when I went to school in Kansas in 1962, and suddenly, instead of just adding 2+2=4, it was a picture of 2 apples + 2 apples = 4 oranges. HUH? Then, we moved back to KY where it was 2+2 again, and I was all right.
Then, they introduced another "new" math in KY in 1967, but only to those special students who weren't "math challenged". I was hit by the "new math, Phase II" in 1968. Then, my step-daughter had a "new" math, and now, my son has had 2 "new" maths. I can't get it, at all. To me, it is still 2+2. When they start doing all this abacus-like stuff, I want to start screaming. The more things change, the more they stay the same. Nothing is really new in math, just the way they teach it. It is just as confusing now as it was then.
2) People talk about overpaid teachers all the time. I left teaching 34.5 years ago because I couldn't make a living, and somehow had to pay for additional education with no money, in order to get a miniscule raise per year, AND maintain my license to teach. I also left because I taught in an inner city school, so to speak, and it was much more fun to bang rocks with hammers than to try to counsel students who didn't give a damn anyway. As far as teachers go-- Never have so few had so many and been so underpaid. I literally had teachers who were just warm bodies sitting at a desk. My son doesn't-- he has real teachers that actually do things, rather than pop aspirin for their hangovers. Yet, FEW of them actually teach-- they are too busy filling out paperwork, and dealing with behavior problems. WE taught him math. WE taught him cursive writing. WE taught him science. WE taught him history, etc. That isn't the teacher's fault, either.
3) There is WAY too much paperwork. As a teacher, you are filmed, in your classroom, all the time, any more. The curriculum is so exact, you can't deviate, and the curriculum is designed so that the students can pass a test. ARGHH! My students were interested in crystals, so we did a unit in crystals. We built models of crystal forms and had a blast together. They learned a LOT about chemistry, geometry, history, etc., all because of that unit. Today, that wouldn't be allowed. The way things are set up stifles learning.
4) I am worn out with my son's text books, which are out-dated, biased, and subject to interpretation. Not only that, but they are also factually wrong. My son knows more Chinese history than his dang textbook. He knows more Egyptian and Roman history than his text book. When he proves he is right, by taking several well-known and highly respected references that show the textbook to be wrong, he still gets the answer wrong on the test. FOUL.
At the college level, the colleges are so busy teaching the theory of things, they miss out on the practical applications. Yeah, I know Boyle's law, but what good is it, if you can't apply that knowledge to a real world situation? What is most work made of? Real-world situations.
I felt like I got a good education. Maybe not the best, but a good one. I'm doing my best to make sure that my son at least knows what I know, and more.
Dowser
I agree
We need to attract the right people into teaching (and keep them there) and in order to do that we are going to need to improve the attractiveness and security of the teaching profession.
Some of the greatest people I know are teachers and the truly gifted and effective teachers stayed at it because they loved the process of teaching kids and shaping the future. It is getting harder and harder to keep the next generation of great teachers in the profession.
There are sub-standard teachers to be sure and they should be forced to raise their skill levels and their dedication to excellence for sure, but we also need to make sure that excellence in the profession is rewarded financially.
Thanks for your feedback and perspective
IMO the Teacher's Unions guarantee mediocrity. They play the usual role of defending teachers' livelihood, but unfortunately some they defend are not worth the candle - their flame burned out long ago.
When I was visiting another city here I ran into a young American English teacher. We were conversing about the places we had visited, and he said: "We was there." When I heard that, I felt truly sorry for his students.
Robert,
This is a subject matter that I can go on about for quite a while. First of all, math in this country has been a problem for a lot longer than this study. I remember when my parents had their childrens clothing store adults then couldn't do math. We are talking about in the 1960's and 70's. When we ran a sale, we would put up charts because our customers couldn't do math in their heads. At the end of the season, we do our 50% off clearance sale. Some of the charts (we kept them from year to year) said "50% Off" and gave the reduced prices, while others had "Half Off" on them. Believe it or not, no matter how many times we would try to explain that 50% equaled half off, almost all the customers wanted the half price chart used. These were people who were in elementary school in the 40's and 50's. It's not that much has changed, just how much money we throw at the problem.
Why doesn't Teach for America work? I can tell you why first hand. They can't teach. Teaching is far more than just having knowledge, but being able to pass on that knowledge while also having classroom management skills, something these candidates don't have. And instead of wasting money training some of our brightest to teach elementary and middle school, how about teaching courses for the teachers who have the teaching skills. Of the over 100 "Teach for America" candidates we had pass through the school I taught at, only one remained. He was a natural at the job. The rest provided us with fun, since we would place bets on when they would bail... none making it past the one month mark.
Inequality among schools is a big problem, one without a good answer. There is an excellent book on this called "The one best system" . To anyone who wants to learn the challenges our school systems face, this is a must read.
There is always room for improvement in Education and I think we should strive to be our best... but given that we are such a large country and our children come from diverse backgrounds, each with their own special needs, I would say being somewhere in the middle, isn't so bad, when compared to small homogenous countries.
Your reference to math skills is appropriate, but why bother learning to calculate or count when technology does it for you? When I was a kid, my grandfather and my great-uncles had clothing stores and sometimes I would help out on the cash. The cash register (or "till" as we knew it) was only able to add manually in the most rudimentary manner. It had keys for numbers and pressing the total opened the cash drawer. If something cost $3.60 and the customer gave us a $5 bill, we would subtract the sale amount in our head and count out the numbers while giving him the change.
Who needs to do that today? If you're a cashier the scanner reads the bar codes and registers the amounts, the computer determines whether the items are taxable and totals the figures, the cashier only needs to key in the amount the customer presents and the screen shows the amount of change to be paid. In fact, a client of mine who managed a Canadian Tire store (a big box store) from the days I practised law invented a computer system to include inventory control in the cash register calculation - indicating when a product was selling out and needed restocking, besides indicating if there was pilfering when a manual stock-taking was carried out.
With mini hand calculaters who needs to bother adding, subtracting, multiplying or dividing which we had to do on paper if not in our heads?
Then what about spelling? I can still remember being asked in grade 6 to stand and spell the word "conscientiousness". Does anyone even WANT to know how to spell today? Why bother, if spell-check will do it for you, or you can at least check the spelling with your iPhone dictionary? Too bad that spell check doesn't know whether you should have written "cite", "site" or "sight". How many times have I seen, even here on NT, members spelling the word "lose" as "loose" when they mean not being able to find something, or write "it's" instead of "its" when the possessive is required. All they need to do is mentally open the contraction to the two words "it is" in order to realize they are mistaken. The confusion between "your" and "you're" is endless.
If that isn't bad enough there is now a further deterioration of the language with text-talk. "C U latr" "R U ok?" - America started minimizing the English language by omitting the "u" from words like "honour", "neighbourhood", or the double "l" from "travelling".
Is it really any wonder why the USA scores so low on OECD education statistics?
I do want to point out that I am not being critical of individuals here, but of the educational system that they have had to endure, and pressures of the societal milieu they have had to survive. Although I had on NV seen where individual members from foreign countries were corrected or even ridiculed by some impolite and/or mean members, I always tried to point out to the victims that I wished I was as adept in their first language as they were in English.
Perrie
I always wait for your input on stories about education.
You know from where you speak and you put it out there plain and simple.
I agree with the points you have made, especially about the complexity of solving the inequality in finding schools. I have often thought that a set figure (combined form the state and federal government) should be allocated to each school for each student in the school district, even if some of those students attend private schools (who in my view should receive no government funding). That would enable the public schools to regain positioning and capability to match (even surpass) private schools rather than lagging sorrily behind.
Buzz
I have some issues with teachers' unions but they are by no means the only or even the biggest problem the education in the U.S.
Funding, funding, funding
Parental involvement, parental involvement, parental involvement
Those are the big two in my view.
Buzz
Good point about automation, but it is important that people possess skills an knowledge about things work (even perhaps especially when the functions are accomplished by computers.
I remember our accounting department coming to a total standstill, when the computer system went down, because our staff was in large part unaware, unskilled, unwilling (perhaps all three) to do it with a pencil and paper.
Buzz
Excelent point
I too this it is largely the system and not the teachers within the system that contribute to the problem, but again they are only a small part of the problem.
Politicians and administrators who have so hopelessly screwed up the funding processes are also culprits.
Under the current system, public schools will never surpass private schools, but we could hope to elevate them to the level that private schools are at.
The main difference between a public and private school?
Curricula.
More funds are put into curricula in public school than facilities. It has become an entire industry directed by the DOE with the rules that come with it.
Free the curricula, take the cuffs off the teachers, and put the money into resources/facilities.
Kinda like it was back in the days when I was in school...
N M
I am not denigrating private schools
But if private schools got no money, including no voucher money for people to leave public schools, and all that money went into the public school systems instead the public schools would raise themselves up and the level of performance of the schools the teachers and the students would rise to the highest levels again.
If there was no subsidy (voucher or tax deduction) for people taking their children out of public schools and into private schools. it would happen less and the resulting funding increases would make the public schools better and fewer would want to leave the neighborhood schools.
What I am describing is exactly like it was when I was in school in the 50's and 60's
I know, and the school system deteriorated anyway to the state where citizens demanded such voucher systems.
What your advocating is a return to the system that has already failed.
What is the big difference between the school system we knew, and the school systems of the 90's and the school systems of today?
The level of governmental involvement. Back in our day all schools were local in nature, curricula was set by local state level organizations, what was actually taught was decided by the local school boards with citizen input.
You didn't have these curricula sets designed by crats up in the federal level and handed down like the all seeing magic learning system that will give everyone the same knowledge.
The local system back in our day taught to the needs of the community instead of an almorpheous federal "Standard" which allows children to graduate barely being able to read.
Get the government out of education, let the true professional take charge with community input like it was 50 years ago, and you will see a lot of these education problems begin to disappear.
No I am saying that we should return to a system that worked for many decades and will work again if it is embraced
Curricula is important but without structure, infrastructure and resources it is worthless.
We must have the facilities, the teachers and the hard and soft resources to make the school system work.
SO long as we expect the government to pay for education, government will and should be involved in education. the essence of public education is the involvement of the community (including state and country), the family, the teacher, and the student - when any of those components fails to function the process fails.
Thanks for the feedback
The main difference between a public and private school? Curricula.
Incorrect. A public schools curriculum is developed by a school board (or its equivalent) in conjunction with a schools administration and teachers. The public is then invited to look at it and critique it. The state nor federal government has absolutely any say in the curriculum. All students, public and private, must have so many credits (or hours) in the various disciplines ( Math, science, etc). See Wisconsins; High School Graduation Standards
Note: Each state has their own and may vary slightly
One of the misconceptions about the federal Department of Education is the role they play. Despite anything you hear or read, the US DoE does not and cannot dictate to any school in the nation, what their curriculum can or should be. They are legally prohibited from doing that. Listed here are the legal duties of the DoE .
Both public and private school must follow states mandatory guidelines to graduate.
A P
I don't say this very often, but I totally agree with you on this one
Thanks for the perspective
In answer to this I am going to offer three links, all concerning Government Department of Education policies and guidelines and where they are coming from and one that is a former DOE General Counsels belief that the Federal DOE despite laws to the contrary, is pushing a national curricula standard.
U.S. Department of Education; State Regulation of Private Schools
Lists the regulations and requirements of every state, which is supervised by it's state department of education.
Cromaine Library; Educators resource, US Department of Education: Curriculum Resources
US DOE approved curriculum resources.
Is the US Department of Education Violating Federal Law by directing standards, tests, and curricula?
Which is a former DOE General Counsel directly asking this question. and sees it happening.
last but not least.
For example the Bureau of Proprietary School Supervision from NYSED.gov rejecting a standard because the Federal DOE has rejected it.
Personally I have nothing Against You Aeon, but you do need to learn a bit more on the subject. Federal Depratment of Education has been encroaching on state and local authority ever since they were created by Mr Carter in the late 70's.
I notice that the states are not averse to accepting federal money for schools in the states.
In my view, oversight and executive management of education in the U.S. needs to be centralized in the Dept of Ed with execution and first line direction/management at the state and district level.
And that is exactly what wasn't happening back in the '40's, '50's and 60's
When this nation was recognized worldwide as having the best education system on the planet.
you stated that you would like to go back to the education system in place when you were in school? well this centralized system of authority will prevent that.
You can't have both.
I disagree
In that great period of U.S. education, I learned the meaning of compromise and that is what is needed
A blending of the best of both federal, state, district and community involvement in the education process.
We can most certainly have both and we must have both if we are to truly fix the education process in the U.S.
We are not going to agree on this, I can see butsincerely thank you for the civil and vigorous back and forth on the subject
Thank you, I didn't want to appear as baiting.
What I learned in that golden period of education in the US was that sometimes compromise is a bad thing.
There are times you must insist in excellence, and in those times the pursuit of excellence is abhorrent to control of any form.
The only thing that is supposed to run on compromise in this country is government. Everything else is allowed free expression to rise to whatever level it can attain.
Today the world is backwards, the government has forgotten how to compromise, but forces compromise on everything else.
And that is sad...
Excellent exchange Robert.
I agree with you on allowing institutions to rise to a level of excellence and compromise between the two sides (full federal control or no federal control at all) is the fountain from which that excellence will flow.
Appreciate your insightful look at issue and the constructive discussion, I learned and that is the point
Nowhere Man,
I'm going to disagree with you totally. The issue is that each state has their own system. For instance, in NYS, X amount of money is allocated to each school district based on number of students times days attended. This is not nearly enough money (never mind the bloated waste of the NYC schools). But we also have a unique system of schools. We buy our homes based on the school systems. Good schools have a higher tax base. I pay almost $17,000 a year in school taxes. The curricula is top notch as are our teachers, who are vetted very carefully. Our school system is on par with, if not better than private schools.
The issue is that our system will not work everywhere. They don't have the tax base.
Also, there is no comparison between NYS schools and Cali schools. California had one centralized system and that is why most people send their kids to private schools if they can. There is just not enough money to go around, and no local tax base. The schools are equally bad everywhere.
That is why I recommend that book.
There really is no right system. Each local must evaluate what works for them.
I agree that private schools shouldn't get public funding... by definition they are private and it is their choice to not send their kids to public school.
Allocation of funds per child is a good start, but federal monies are not enough alone to pay even the leanest of school budgets. There has to be some sort of local tax base for the schools. It would still be a lot cheaper than any private school, if done right.
City school systems are a totally different animal. The needs of their students are vastly different from area to area and that is why it is so hard to manage them.
During the time I worked in the NYC school system, they went from centralized funding to district funding back to centralized. Each had their issue. With district funding, the district knew what their students needed, but was open to corruption, if that district was so inclined. Centralized didn't work well for anyone. I am pretty sure that across the US this plays out pretty much the same with most citywide systems.
You may not agree with me, but this statement agrees with what I'm saying completely.
I'm well aware how schools are funded. I will look at the book, but I will say this, any top heavy authority driven centralized system nationwide will NOT work.
Taxing people to death by mandate is not the answer either.
17,000 a year in taxes? around here we would have an armed revolt. (a lot of political careers would end on that one)
I made no comparison between NYS and Cali.
I was educated in an east coast school system I know the difference.
But however we get there we are more in agreement than not....
LOL Buzz,
I remember learning how to make change when I was 10. Now no one knows how to do basic math in their heads, much less make change. As for spelling, I disagree (and I am dyslexic). My kids are amazing spellers. I don't think that this has changed much since the 1950's.
Good points, but in addition to no federal/state funds directly to the private schools, we need to eliminate federal/state via vouchers and tax deductions to offset tuition costs when they send their kids to private schools.
Property tax is not a good funding mechanism either, as levies are being defeated more and more often because people cannot afford to pay more in property taxes
Most states have seen the myth of money from lotteries prove false and there is a huge problem in some areas where education funds are used for athletic fields, for administration costs and other non-student affecting matters.
I would like to see a portion of income taxes - federal and state going directly to schools in the districts where the taxpayer is living, but I do not foresee that happening anytime soon.
Appreciate the feedback
1) Your first link is a DoE report on State Regulations in all 50 states. It is no more than a compendium of laws pertaining to education in their respective state. It made no recommendations, no mandates, and no legal proposals. Its no more than an encyclopedia of educational laws.
2) The second link is nothing more than a resource center for educators put out by the DoE which is part of their legal mission. No proposals, no recommendations and no mandates.
3) Your third link is somewhat convoluted. It takes one to an article put out by the Pioneer Institute whom, to quote;
The PI article asks the question; Is the US Department of Education violating federal lay by directing standards, tests and curricula? The question is based on another report (non government white paper) called ; The Legal Aspects of the Common Core Standards, Race to the Top, and Conditional Waiver.
At issue on that paper is the Race to the Top Assessment Program which was authorized and funded by congress under the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (ARRA) and has adopted Common Core Standards which is a very hotly contested and ideologically partisan issue.
I should remind you that the federal government attaches terms and conditions to any grants it gives the states, this includes education. No Child Left Behind which was put into place by George W. Bush, via executive order, is an example of this.
Nothing in the third link, and its ancillary links, say anything about any state or school district being forced to change its curriculum. Common Core in itself is completely voluntary and is not legally mandated by the DoE or the Federal government.
Americans confide their health care to entities whose primary mission is to maximize shareholder dividends -- that is to say, every dollar spent on health care is a dollar ill-spent! The result is that Americans have the developed world's crappiest health care results, and also the developed world's highest health care costs. Duh...
Having proved that privately run health care is a disaster, Americans are now busily confiding their children's education to entities whose mission is to maximize shareholder dividends. What could possibly go wrong?
Perrie
A sad but true point - a reality that we need to change and fast
Among the nations that often score highest in schoolchildren's testing is Finland? a couple decades ago, their kids weren't doing too well so they decided to overhaul the system.
One of the key reforms was: banning private schools. (Before the wingnuts go crazy... there are lots of areas where the state has a monopoly. It ain't anti-Constitutional!)
The reasoning was that if there are private schools, then the rich and powerful would put their kids there, and not give a flying fck what happened to public schools -- or even gut the public school budget to save their own taxes. If the rich and powerful have to put their own kids in public schools, they'll make an effort in favor of those schools.
Duh...
It is not a mandate, it is a choice. I could have moved to another district where my taxes would have been more than half of that. Of course that would mean that neither would their education. That beings said, the best of our private schools cost $22,000/child- 38,000/child for non religious schools, the cheapest being the average Catholic school, which is $8,000/child which will end up costing you the same amount as my school district with two kids.
Perrie
Not exactly what I meant.
Take our village for example, we have an excellent grade/middle/high school as well as the county vo-tech high school and over the years school levies used to pass easily.
Now more and more of the village population is on fixed incomes and a lot of the property owners no longer have kids in school - perhaps not fair but school levies for renewal are tough to get passed these days and new levies are voted down soundly.
We must find another way to fund schools that takes the uncertainty of levies out of the process - something on income tax (personal and corporate) 1% or 2% that goes directly into the school funding coffers where the taxpayer lives or business is located.
When we lived in Wisconsin, we rented a townhouse for years in one of the best school districts in the mid-west (as did many many others) and enjoyed all the benefits of the school district without any cost.
And speaking of the private school tuition - my son went to public school in Florida while two of his cousins went to $20K per year private school from middle school on. He breezed through graduate school and has a great job. He had good teachers, he worked hard and we supported him and were involved - funding is not the only problem to be solved
Here, our residents know that their house values are closely tied to the schools, so it rarely gets voted down. But I agree that it shouldn't be the only way to raise revenue for schools. And funding isn't the only solution for every problem.
Having a piece of your skin in the game, does make you take it a bit more seriously.
That being said, not every private school out preforms public ones.
That's un-American ! {grins}
I agree, but that's beside the point. If rich kids are in private schools, then their rich (and powerful) parents will support private schools. To the detriment of public schools.
Yup. It's Finnish...
;-))
What has kept me from commenting on the posted article is it contains flaws..so many flaws and deliberate omissions that I dont know where to begin. For example, take this sentence;
Corporate America is one of the biggest enemies to US education and the public schools this country has ever faced, For example, read these articles;
Imagine the hypocrisy here. On one side, the corporations are saying we need better education and on the other side, they are still outsourcing jobs that educated people can do. Moreover, they are not creating any jobs for these people.
The big corporate push now-a-days is having for-profit schools replace public schools. The dangers here are overwhelming.
There are more issues I have with this article, like it suggestion the panacea for our educational woes can be solved merely by paying good teachers more (which they deserve anyways) without taking into account teaching environments and the reasons men and women want to teach to start with.
A P
I appreciate you sharing your opinion on this topic
This statement is true, what is missing is that corporate America in league with faltering politicians and disinterested parents are largely responsible for the failure of the education system to meet the needs of the private sector industry.
I agree that throwing money at the problem is not the simple solution to a complex problem, but education funding must be addressed and fixed.
Thanks for sharing your view