╌>

3 AMERICANS, 1 BRITON KILLED IN JERUSALEM ATTACK

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  screminmimi  •  12 years ago  •  68 comments

3 AMERICANS, 1 BRITON KILLED IN JERUSALEM ATTACK

Associated Press

By TIA GOLDENBERG
JERUSALEM (AP) Two Palestinians stormed a Jerusalem synagogue on Tuesday, attacking worshippers with meat cleavers and a gun during morning prayers and killing four people before they were killed in a shootout with police, officials said.
The attack, the deadliest in Jerusalem in years, is bound to ratchet up fears of sustained violence in the city, already on edge amid soaring tensions over a contested holy site.
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu vowed that Israel will "respond harshly," describing the attack as a "cruel murder of Jews who came to pray and were killed by despicable murderers." U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry said he spoke to Netanyahu after the assault and denounced it as an "act of pure terror and senseless brutality and violence."
Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas condemned the attack, the first time he has done so since a recent spike in deadly violence against Israelis. He also called for an end to Israeli "provocations" surrounding the sacred site.

In a statement, Abbas' office said he "condemns the killing of the worshippers in a synagogue in west Jerusalem." The statement called for an end to the "invasion" of the mosque at the holy site and a halt to "incitement" by Israeli government ministers.

Israeli police called the incident a terrorist attack and said the two Palestinian assailants were cousins from east Jerusalem.

The Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, a small militant group, said the cousins were among its members. A PFLP statement did not specify whether the group instructed the cousins to carry out the attack.

Hamas, the militant Palestinian group that runs the Gaza Strip, praised the attack. In Gaza, dozens took to the streets to celebrate the attack. Some people held trays full of sweets and distributed them to drivers and passersby. In the southern town of Rafah, women and schoolchildren waved green Hamas flags and a loudspeaker praised the attack.

Israeli police spokesman Micky Rosenfeld said six people were also wounded in the attack, including two police officers. Four of the wounded were reported in serious condition.

The attack occurred in Jerusalem's Har Nof neighborhood, an ultra-Orthodox community on the western edge of the city far from other recent scenes of violence. The area was surrounded by police and rescue workers following the attack.

Associated Press footage showed wounded worshippers being assisted by paramedics, and a bloodied meat cleaver lay nearby. Initially, police had described the weapons used as knives and axes.

"I tried to escape. The man with the knife approached me. There was a chair and table between us ... my prayer shawl got caught. I left it there and escaped," Yossi, who was praying at the synagogue at the time of the attack, told Israeli Channel 2 TV. He declined to give his last name.

Yosef Posternak, who was at the synagogue at the time of the attack, told Israel Radio that about 25 worshippers were inside when the attackers entered.

"I saw people lying on the floor, blood everywhere. People were trying to fight with (the attackers) but they didn't have much of a chance," he said.

Footage released by the Israeli government showed blood-soaked prayer books and prayer shawls on the floor of the synagogue. A pair of glasses lay under a table, from which blood was dripping. A set of phylacteries hung off the table. A photo in Israeli media showed a body on the floor, covered with a prayer shawl.

Police spokeswoman Luba Samri said the attackers were Palestinians from east Jerusalem, which has been the scene of relentless clashes between Israeli police and Palestinian protesters in recent months. She identified the assailants as Ghassan and Oday Abu Jamal from the Jabal Mukaber neighborhood.

Soon after the attack, clashes broke out outside the Abu Jamals' home, where dozens of police had converged. Residents hurled stones at police who responded using riot dispersal weapons.

Residents in the neighborhood, speaking on condition of anonymity for fears for their own safety, said 14 members of the Abu Jamal family were arrested.

Mohammed Zahaikeh, a social activist in Jabal Mukaber, said one of the relatives of the cousins, Jamal Abu Jamal, was released in a 2011 prisoner swap and re-arrested recently by Israeli police. He did not say why.

Israel has been on edge with a spate of attacks by Palestinians against Israelis, killing at least six people in Jerusalem, the West Bank and Tel Aviv in recent weeks, prior to Tuesday's casualties.

Jerusalem residents had already been fearful of what appeared to be lone wolf attacks using cars or knives against pedestrians, but Tuesday's synagogue assault harkens back to gruesome attacks during the Palestinian uprising of the last decade.

Israel's police chief said Tuesday's attack was likely not organized by militant groups, similar to other recent incidents, making it more difficult for security forces to prevent the violence.

"These are individuals who decide to do horrible acts. It's very hard to know ahead of time about every such incident," Yohanan Danino told reporters at the scene.

Tensions appeared to have been somewhat defused last week following a meeting between Netanyahu, Kerry and Jordan's King Abdullah II in Amman. The meeting was an attempt to restore calm after months of violent confrontations surrounding a sacred shrine holy to both Jews and Muslims.

Israel and the Palestinians said then they would take steps to reduce tensions that might lead to an escalation.

In his statement, Netanyahu blamed the violence on incitement by both Hamas and Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas and said the international community ignores the incitement.

Kerry blamed the attack on Palestinian calls for "days of rage," and said Palestinian leaders must take serious steps to refrain from such incitement. He also urged Palestinian leaders to condemn the attack "in the most powerful terms."

"Innocent people who had come to worship died in the sanctuary of a synagogue. They were hatcheted, hacked and murdered in that holy place in an act of pure terror and senseless brutality and murder," Kerry said.

British Foreign Secretary Philip Hammond, speaking alongside Kerry, also condemned the violence.

Hamas' statement praised the synagogue attack, saying it was a "response to continued Israeli crimes, the killing, desecrating al-Aqsa (mosque)," a reference to a recent incident at the holy site.

Abbas, at a meeting later with security officials, called for calm.

"We call for a complete calm and a halt to all these attacks to enable us to move ahead with our political work," he said, according to the Palestinian official Wafa news agency.

Much of the recent violence stems from tensions surrounding the Jerusalem holy site referred to by Jews as the Temple Mount because of the Jewish temples that stood there in biblical times. It is the most sacred place in Judaism; Muslims refer to it as the Noble Sanctuary, and it is their third holiest site, after Mecca and Medina in Saudi Arabia.

The site is so holy that Jews have traditionally refrained from going there, instead praying at the adjacent Western Wall. Israel's chief rabbis have urged people not to ascend to the area, but in recent years, a small but growing number of Jews, including ultranationalist lawmakers, have begun regularly visiting the site, a move seen as a provocation.

http://news.yahoo.com/several-wounded-jerusalem-synagogue-attack-054944730.html


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

I love the way that bastard Abbas calls for "calm" when it's Jews who are murdered while praying, hacked with knives and axes and shot, when last week he proclaimed that it was "war" with Israel.

Everyone wants Israel to be "calm" while it is Jews who are dying, while rabbis in Europe are being stabbed in the throat with screwdrivers or set upon by Arabs who beat them to death on the way home from prayers, or jumped by three and four Arabs while they are at an exhibition basketball game with their children.

The White House calls for "calm" around the world when it is Jews who are dying, when three month old babies are killed by Arabs slamming cars into bystanders waiting for trains, when innocent teens, one of them an UNACKNOWLEDGED American, are kidnapped and murdered by Palestinian Arabs.

Much of the recent violence stems from tensions surrounding the Jerusalem holy site referred to by Jews as the Temple Mount because of the Jewish temples that stood there in biblical times. It is the most sacred place in Judaism; Muslims refer to it as the Noble Sanctuary, and it is their third holiest site, after Mecca and Medina in Saudi Arabia.

The site is so holy that Jews have traditionally refrained from going there, instead praying at the adjacent Western Wall. Israel's chief rabbis have urged people not to ascend to the area, but in recent years, a small but growing number of Jews, including ultranationalist lawmakers, have begun regularly visiting the site, a move seen as a provocation.

This above is another of the media-spun bias against Israel and does not even mention the growing number of Jewish graves that are desecrated by the Palestinian pigs, a heartbreaking affront that has had Israeli citizens demanding armed guards around the cemetary during the night.

This type of butchery is what will eventually make the Israeli government hunt down and remove every Arab from Israel while the rest of the world labels it "apartheid."

Oh! Wait!!!! The rest of the world already does that! What the hell, Israel.... go ahead and do it! Make yourself and your citizens safe and tell Obama and UN to go screw themselves! Tell them to chew on Egypt for a while and give you a rest... Israel has a right to defense!

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

3 Americans and 1 Brit.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

I heard that too, Mike, but just got the "breaking news" headline that confirmed it, so I changed the title of my article to reflect it. Ironic, isn't it that the dead were American and British? No wonder Abbas is calling for "calm."

Obama couldn't care less though. When Americans are killed in Israel it doesn't matter to him because they are Jewish Americans.

Now if we could convince some black American Jews to head over there and they should fall to the Palestinian Arab butchers, we might get some positive press from the State Department and Psaki. For now, Israel will have to continue to be content with the platitude to "stay calm."

This makes two British citizens murdered by Palestinian Arabs in less than three weeks. It doesn't count the young British soldier butchered and beheaded on the streets last year or those citizens beheaded by the State of Islam.... the religion of peace.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

America needs to stay out of Israel's defense of its homeland.

Israel has as much right of defense as Egypt does and I don't hear anyone calling Egypt out on the destruction of hundreds of Palestinian homes and annexing ground to create a buffer in order to ensure the safety of Egypt from Hamas, the Blathering Butchers of Balderdash.

Once again, the sick and depraved Palestinians are passing out candies and other sweets to commemorate the butchery perpetrated on the worshipers, turning it into a day of celebration. No wonder these pigs in Gaza can't accomplish anything.. they turn every killing day into a holiday and with all the celebrating there is no actual "work" day.

Bear in mind, Fish, they are celebrating the death of Americans... AGAIN.

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    12 years ago

To all Palestinian apologists, take a look at how these subhumans celebrate the murders of innocent Israelis while in a holy place of worship:

2934_discussions.jpg?width=721

2935_discussions.jpg?width=721

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

Americans need to stay out of the Middle East. It's not safe.

Right, when Jews die, Americans need to stay out of it.

But when Arabs die because Jews have to defend themselves, we must insert ourselves deeply into the process, right?

Right?

RIGHT??!!

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    12 years ago

"Impartial" media giant CNN makes another error describing the location of the massacre. Funny how these "errors" so often display an anti-Israel bias.

2936_discussions.jpg

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    12 years ago

Only the Palestinians give honors and cash rewards to the families of terrorists who kill babies: 2937_discussions.jpg

That award is to commemorate his relative's murder of this baby:

2938_discussions.png

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

They glorify terrorism, and get away with it.

When they use their people as human shields, the American Left comes to their defense.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

John,

Hats off, John. Regardless of the senselessness of the killing; regardless of the blatant terrorism of the Arabs, you manage to stay on your misguided point.

Palestinians are the pawn of the Arab world. Open your eyes. Close your mouth.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

Thanks for the heads up.

I'll make sure to skip Syria and Iraq next time I go to Israel.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

Whatsa matter honey, the "whatta douche" didn't work for ya?

Israel is safer than a lot of areas in our fine country.

Methinks you are being the drama queen...

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

If you say so.

There are no travel restrictions, but thanks for the hysteria.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Knives, axes, and guns. For being the religion of peace, 'ol mo sure is an angry and hungry god.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

You are wrong, pokermike.

It is WE, America, who pay the family of the terrorist who killed this baby girl. It is OUR money who pays the salary of the killer.

It is American money who will pay the family of the killers who butchered the three Americans yesterday.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

Gee, wonder what those three American and one British Jews were doing in that Jerusalem MOSQUE?

Were they giving thanks for not being caught after spending the night desecrating Jewish graves?

Idiots. They can't get the story right.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

I have a solution for the Arabs in Israel. Round them up and kick their murdering, dissatisfied asses on over to Gaza and Palestine. Clear every damned one of them out of Israel. They have brought it on themselves.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
But it's a tiny, tiny fraction that supports this. /s
 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    12 years ago

Larry, don't forget their new method of random murder - using cars to run over Israelis clustering around bus and train stations. About the only good things Muslims, particularly Palestinians, are good at innovating are more barbarous methods for untrained, soulless idiots to carry out murder and mayhem on innocent folks.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

Here in my little Southern town, as a friend and I came out of a restaurant last night, she said, "Mimi, what is that written on that car?"

I looked closely at the the oversize letters painted on the side of the van and was surprised to see it read, "Israel has the right of self defense!" It was painted on both sides and the back. The man sitting under the steering wheel stared defiantly at me as two children cowered in the back seat. When I pumped my fist in the air and yelled "Yes! Yes!" he grinned and the children sat up on the seats and smiled.

Whether Obama and the rest of the world likes it or not, Israel has the right of self defense. Netanyahu should tell all of them to kiss his Jewish rear end, he will protect Israelis and Israel first and worry about their feelings when the Christian hell freezes over. The Palestinian terrorists are now knocking on heaven's door, because the laid back Jewish civilians who have left defense in the hands of the IDF and the Mossad are ready to take up the fight themselves, and when ordinary people rise up both heaven and hell tremble.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
It's a death cult and it always will be.
 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

All this has happened and the Israelis have not broken the agreement to not pray at Temple Mount.

Nothing satisfies the Palestinian Arabs. Nothing. So what the heck. Israelis should go ahead and pray wherever they want.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

I don't know of Jews telling Muslims where they cannot pray - Israel permits all religions to be practised, and they don't cut off the heads of those who practise the "wrong" religion. At least the Jews are civilized.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

flame,

That's pretty much the response that came from Fatah, Hamas and Jordan. More or less you and they agree thatit's "understandable" that this would happen.

If that's the case, then what Israel does next in response is no less "understandable".

So now we all "understand" each other.

As far as Israel "expecting more", that's old hat. The Palestinians are getting further away from the nationhood they want by doing this. They are the losers, and will remain the losers. If you want to whine about colonialism, and injustices and disparity, go right ahead. That's white noise. Israel is a sovereign nation, while the Palestinians are a terrorist backed movement.

The Palestinians are getting what the Palestinians have paid for. Innocents are dead on both sides. That's what a war on terrorism looks like. It's not surprising.

It's "understandable".

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

Israel stole their land

That's been explained to you dozens of times. Rather than explain it to you again, I think I'll just take a quote from your lexicon:

LOL

It's pointless to engage with you, because you won't acknowledge facts, so:

LOL

Terrorist fights terrorist.

LOL

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

they don't explain Palestinian resistance.

You're a guy who likes to read. The Hamas Charter and the Fatah Charter will explain it.

they don't explain Palestinian resistance.

LOL

:)

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

resistance toward those that stole from them?

LOL

:)

Just so you know, that's the response you'll get when you say any number of phrases that would only bog us down in debate that we've already had.

Kinda like "again with your bullshit? LOL :)".

Savvy, my friend?

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

Those that "stole" from them? The "charters" that say all Jews must be wiped from the face of the earth? Yep, THOSE charters.

Their undying racism toward Jews explains their resistance. Call it what it is. Racism.

They live to live kill Jews. Jews in Israel. Jews in Europe. They are building up to killing Jews in America; right now they are just beating them up, testing the waters of tolerance in the Obama administration.

Kill the Jews.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

LOL

:)

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

Gee, I haven't heard of any Palestinians in America being set upon by crowds of Jews at exhibition basketball games in front of their kids, then running away like cowards when the police show up.

Haven't heard of any imams being stabbed in throat with screwdrivers on the way home from the mosque by killer Jews, just because he is an Arab.

Haven't heard of any Jewish youths invading an Arab-run grocery store to knock over displays and stomp goods into the floor.

Haven't heard of any gangs of Jewish thugs grabbing bags from Arab customers to inspect them to make sure they are buying only things approved by Islam for consumption or beating up the shoppers if they don't approve of what is in the bag.

Yes, Palestinians are being killed. When they attack Israel.

Israel has the right of self defense.

LOL.

:)

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

Whadya do, break for lunch?

LOL

:)

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

I'm blinded, says the guy who looks at the Hamas/Fatah charters, and still holds on to that grain of ideology that the little guy is always right and the big guy is always wrong.

Partisanship indeed, my progressive friend...

LOL

:)

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

I had a feeling you were a "pictures" and not a "words" guy.

LOL for real

:)

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

When the Palestinians are instigating the murders of Israeli civilians it is not self defense. Even Obama, the chief apologist for Muslim terrorists of the Gaza strip, does not see it that way this time.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

Who is murdering whom, casting the first proverbial stones of death?

Israel has the right of self defense.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

Yes, understanding is what it's all about.

I understand that the Arabs seek to kill Jews, and succeed.

I understand that Israel defends itself, and in the process, kills Arabs.

And yet you only understand one of these points.

So sad for you, flameFrown.gif

LOL

:)

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

I love trivia.

You know what's not trivial?

So many people live in free societies, where thereare absolutely no barriers to historical information, and yet, people like you would rather ignore that history so that they could defend Arab terrorism.

Not trivial, and very sad.Frown.gif

LOL

:)

Yaknow, I used to be irritated by your excessive use of "LOL" and ":)", but now that I'm doing it with every post to you, it doesn't seem so bad after all.

Cheers!

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

Yeah, you don't like that "disproportionate" stuff, do ya.

Ever wonder why they keep doing that, even though they know Israel has the better weapons? There are a few reasons, some obvious, some not so obvious.

One reason is so that ignorant folks in Western countries can take pity on them, not knowing OR choosing to ignore the entire story.

Like you, flame!!

Cheers!

LOL

:)

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

You don't seem to mind it though.

Please point this bullshit out to me. I know you're VERY thorough on sourcing what you say.

Thank you in advance, tool.

LOL

:)

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

Israel defends itself after Palestinians kill and kill and people are baffled by the Jews defending themselves.

It isn't that hard to see and understand. It is only racism and willful refusal to accept Israel's right of defense that perpetuates the arguments.

LOL

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

Brought so low by people armed with knives.

Knives kill. The fucking cowards slit the throats of sleeping babies with those knives, knowing that it will result in bullets and missiles. Cause and effect.

Israel has the right of defense.

LOL

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

OK, now follow me, retard.

You wrote:

You mean the murders? No I don't like that.

You don't seem to mind it though.

When/where did I ever indicate to anyone that I didn't mind people dying?

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

An acknowledgement of the facts on the ground does not equal "not minding".

I would much rather nobody die, but I UNDERSTAND that it's an unavoidable truth.

Your inability to process that saddens me.

Have a good night.

You're attempting to turn it up. Time for me to turn it off.

LOL

:)

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

No, flame. Not gonna do history with you again. Too many times already.

I love trivia.

The point is at the top of your head.

G'night, flame.

LOL

:)

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

And we're right back to the fact that the Palestinians drew first blood with their knives, rockets, tunnel attacks, etc.

Israel has the right of self defense.

LOL

:)

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

Piss on your lack of ability to call the Palestinians hatred of Jews what it is.. blatant racism. Arabs don't just hate the Jews in Israel because of the land situation, they hate Jews all over the world because they are Jews. That is hard core racism, flame.

The Israelis haven't done anything criminal. They have a formed a home and state on land offered to them and which they paid for. Now the world wants them to feel guilty about what they have built and accomplished on that piece of desert.

Screw that. They are there. They aren't going to give it back any more than the thieving murdering Europeans are going to give back Turtle Island to the Natives here. It's a ridiculous argument that is going nowhere.

Neither are the Jews going to allow the bastards who constantly call for their complete annihilation to flood their state via a completely open border. And if the Arabs who live in Israel continue with the terrorist attacks, they may be the cause of deportation of other Arabs in Israel.

Piss on your racism whinge fest. Israel is a sniveling lot of whiners who can't face their own criminality, and like any criminal looks always to place the responsibility for their ill-deeds on others

ROFLMAO...

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Actually the first offense was Israel's coming into existence in the first place.

Not that I'm against this action. But it should have been accompanied by the establishment of a Palestinian state.

Then you don't know the history, Flame. There was supposed to be 2 states... The land that was supposed to go to the Palestinians instead was annexed by Jordan (transJordan) and because of the Israel's won against multiple Arab nations, the land that was promised to the Palestinian by their Arab brothers, who swore that they would drive Israel into the sea with that land being Palestinian , didn't come to pass. It end up that all the Palestinians got was Gaza ruled by Egypt. There is truth in that Palestinians are used as pawns by their ownbrethren.

During the British Mandate period the area experienced the ascent of two major nationalist movements, one among the Jews and the other among the Arabs. The competing national interests of the Arab and Jewish populations of Palestine against both each other and the governing British authorities matured into the
Arab Revolt of 19361939 and the Jewish insurgency in Palestine before culminating in the Civil War of 19471948 . The aftermath of the Civil War and the consequent 1948 ArabIsraeli War led to the establishment of the 1949 cease-fire agreement, with partition of the former Mandatory Palestine between the newborn state of Israel with a Jewish majority, the West Bank annexed by the Jordanian Kingdom and the Arab All-Palestine Government in the Gaza Strip under the military occupation of Egypt.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

That is a false equivalency Flame.

Here is an eye witness to the Sandy Creek Massacre:

I saw the bodies of those lying there cut all to pieces, worse mutilated than any I ever saw before; the women cut all to pieces ... With knives; scalped; their brains knocked out; children two or three months old; all ages lying there, from sucking infants up to warriors ... By whom were they mutilated? By the United States troops ...

- John S. Smith, Congressional Testimony of Mr. John S. Smith, 1865 [22]

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Hiya Flame

[waves back]

It is a false equivalency in the fact that bombs (no matter how you describe them) were being fired back and forward across borders with Israel and Gaza. The common term is collateral damage. And while I will agree it is awful when innocents are killed, it is part of warfare. What Israel didn't do is send in troops to personally hack people to death..., as in what happened here in the US army at Sandy Creek. So horrible a scene, that American's were horrified when it came to light... hence the Congressional Testimony.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

I do know the history, and I'm saying that the two state solution should have been pursued and completed and not bargained away nor should the annexation have been allowed. It's not good to dance on an enemies grave after defeating them.

Two points here that you seem to have missed. The biggest part of the Palestinian land, Trans-Jordan, Jordan took. It was a Muslim brother doing this to a Muslim brother. Then as compensation for this, they promised thePalestinian Israelafter they destroyed her. Whenthey didn't, Gaza is all they got.

There was no grave dancing. This is what happens after a war, one Israel didn't start.

The two state solution is the only thing that makes sense.

I agree, but you need a partner for that. ThePalestinianshave had severalopportunities that could have been real deals, but their leadership turned their noses up at them.

And that the occupation itself has developed into a roadblock preventing even trust that there can be a solution.

Hamas has no interest, ever with dealing with Israel. In fact, the "occupation" has served their purposes well, which is furment hate. Fatah could take the lead....no signs yet.

Israel's fear of an autonomous and hostile Palestinian state is no excuse for periodically bombing the opposition back into poverty.

I must correct this statement. In the West Bank there is work, even within Israel. It is Gaza and Hamas that has chosen this path. It is not Israel who starts the bombing, but they sure do end it. They don't fear aPalestinian state, if it brought true peace, since they have always lived on the doorsteps of their enemies. But they also don't want cars driving into civilians, and people hacking them up while they pray.

This is a two way street Flame....

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Israel's rationale for being an occupier has been reduced to "to the victors go the spoils".

What do you base this on? Do you know how many times Israel has gone to the table to make peace? You need to read this first, before we go there:

And sorry but in all wars the victory goes to the spoils. Tell me John, what would have happened in 1949 had the Arabs defeated Israel... what do you think would have been the outcome? I think you know the answer. And despite that, Israel has tried to make peace.

The Palestinians were supposed to have a homeland, and then there was a war, and Israel won and Palestine's "brethern" lost, and so now it's "too bad , so sad, for you, Palestinians".

John, the land that was supposed to go to the Palestinians was not the land that Israel annexed from the 6 day war, but Trans- Jordan, that Jordan took in 1948. You want to point fingers than do it to Jordan.

Does it ever occur to Perrie, and the rest, that this sounds absurd to some people ?

Actually no, since at least I know the history of the region and I am not being emotional about this discussion.

Here is the problem, Israel will NOT accept the defeated Palestinians as full citizens of Israel. Will they ?

There arePalestiniansthat are full citizens living in Israel right now. Those who left in '48/'49 left to have Israel destroyed. They could have their own country if Fatah wants it that way.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

Yes John, they do stand.

And Perrie fully addressed your misgivings with well sourced factual information. If your comments stand, then they stand addressed.

I can understand if you feel that some people respond to you in a belligerent manner, you need not agree with them even if they are right, but Perrie is not one of those people.

It seems to me that your fears were addressed, but you are unable to change your mind in view of these facts.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

Actually John, the lion's share of her post was factual information. It wasn't her opinion.

As far as the pro-Israel bias on this site, I think it's a credit to this site that people have the courage to speak their views, rather than risk enduringthe usual attacks that accompany disagreement with Israel that we see on other sites.

One thing that remains your opinion alone is that it's an echo chamber. If well sourced informationconstitutes an echo chamber for you, then one can only understand why, so often, you feel opinion matters more than fact.

She took the time to answer your misgivings in a clear and concise manner. You opted out of debate, because you have no response. Because she was right, and you had nothing to say. You preferred to stand on your melting ice berg. Silence would have been a better response.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Flame,

I am not sure if you make these analogies on purpose or you really don't understand the context of the history.

To the Arab nations that surround Israel, the original thorn was Israel. So unless you are arguing against Israel's existence, let's get to what is going on today.

The occupation of Gaza prevents Palestinians from freely exercising their political will to govern themselves.

Wrong. Gaza freely elected Hamas, just as the West Bank elected Fatah. Fatah was floored that the people of Gaza did this, and they are quiteeagerto regain control of Gaza. So Israel's "occupation" had nothing to do with how they govern themselves.

So one cannot simply assume the existence of Israel as a right without acknowledging that Israel's existence is seen as a profound insult by the people living in the area at the time.

Well now we have some clarity. You don't support theexistenceof Israel. Then why pretend you do?

If ISIS tossed a colony in the middle of Kansas I'd imagine that folks there would feel justified in driving out the invaders.

ISIS is a terrorist organization that is brutally murdering tens of thousands of other Muslims for being the wrong type of Muslim. This is why I am calling you out on false equivalency. Israel was not tossed into the ME, nor are they terrorist...You might not like some of theirpolicies, but come on.

And this animosity was clearly known before Israel came into being.

Yeah and? It's a done deal over 60 years later. And in case you haven't noticed the whole region is ripe with hate for one another, Muslim on Muslim.

When the decision was made to go ahead it was done without the consent of the people being infringed upon. This of course led to the Six Days war.

Which Israel won handily.

OK, Flame, I am calling it quits with this comment since it is one total falsehood. The Six Day War was put into motion by Egypt, Iraq,Syria and Jordan, who started mobilization towards Israel. When Israel saw this, they decided not to wait... and hit them preemptively. That is called defence. The Palestinians had nothing to do with the war. It was about Israel's right to exist.

I have supplied you with nothing but facts that I have backed up. You on the other hand have not replied in kind. In fact, I find this not to be a discussion but more like emotional propaganda, which I don't do.

So let me make my position clear.

  1. I Believe in Israel's right to exist
  2. I believe in a viable 2 state solution that will last.
  3. I don't agree with all of Israel's policies, but then again, I don't agree with all of the US's policies either.

I'm done.

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    12 years ago

Who needs facts Robert when one can simply repeat one's opinions ad nauseam? It is much easier that way. Intellectually dishonest and lazy, but easier.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

Flame and Randy...

Please document for me where Jews are working and living in Gaza and Palestine and are part of the government body there.

When you have posted this information, we will discuss how Israelis are just as bigoted as the Palestinians are.

LOL

:)

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

@Robert :

ROFLMAO...

I do enjoy your logic and attempts at diplomacy....78.gif

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

Document it yourself, it's your issue.

No, it is your issue, and Randy's, because I call it bogus. Israel does not have the bigotry toward Palestinians/Arabs that the PAs have toward Israelis/Jews.

That can be easily proved by the lives they live within Israel.

LOL

:)

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

Because I read Perrie's post, and found it rather complete. Are posts only to be ridiculed and met with resistance on Newstalkers? Do I need your permission to express my agreement with someoneon a subject?

Don't think so.

If partisan means that I stand on one side of an issue, I suppose that you are also partisan, as you stand on the other.

Now, I suppose you'll tell me you don't stand on one side, a few hundred posts later.

LOL for real

:)

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

There will be further wailing and gnashing of teeth in Palestine and Gaza... Israel has instituted a new policy of declining to return the bodies of terrorists to their families so they can be buried as heroes for killing Jewish civilians.

They will be buried by the Jewish state in Israel.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

Thank you for your helpful post.

LOL

:)

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Perrie's response was not complete, because she insists on excluding the full context of the situation.

That is because you keep making stuff up to support your emotional responses. I gave you history. You decide you don't like the history, The history of the region IS the context. I give you citations from unbiased sources. You give me me nada.

She has points of faith that are not subject to argument.

Please show me one point of faith. I'd like you to do that.

She listed those at the bottom of her last post.

You are kidding right? I gave you my full disclosure of my stance on the situation. Unless you can provide me with something that would rock my world, yeah, that is what where I am at. That has nothing to do with faith, but the current situation; 2 bitter enemies and the state of Israel not going any where. Please don't put words in my mouth. It's not cool.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

The fact that there are Arabs in Israel at all, working and living there, and allowed to be involved in politics, speaks for itself.

The same is not done in Palestine.

Yes, I said a solution for them could be to round them all up and deport them if they are not satisfied with living in Israel and if their method of expressing their discontent is to murder Jewish babies and other civilians. Works for me.

LOL

:)

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Flame,

I'm no bigot, so please don't label me. As for your questions, I'll answer it for you.

How many Arabs have been in Net's position?

None. Maybe because it is a Jewish state. How is this different from all the Arab states, where Islam is the official religion and there are 0 Jews in their government?

How many have run?

0

What's the percentage of Arabs in Israel's population? What percentage of Arabs are in government positions.

20% of the population is Arab who decided not to leave in 1948 , which does not include: 129,800 Druze,7,000 and1,000 Copts who fled Arab nations,712 Samaritans, 70,000Argentines (both Jewish and Christian),4000Armenians who fled Jordan, 3000 Assyrians,and 5,000 African HebrewIsraelites, and theBaha'i, who fled Iran,whosepopulation is in flux as per their faith, but keep their main temple there.

Currently, there are 120 members in the Knesset , of which 12 are non-Jewish, which is 10%. Now do a google search and see how many Christians or Jews there are in government in any Arab state. You will find the answer is 0.

Now you might find this article from The Pew Interesting. I found these charts really interesting:

ISRPT03

ISRPT10

And may I put that chart in context:

Group [8] [9] Population Proportion of total Growth rate
Jews : 6,119,000 75.0% 1.7%
Mainstream 5,162,500 63.3% 1.2%
Haredi 956,500 11.7% 5.0%
Arabs 1,688,600 20.7% 2.2%
Other 349,700 4.3% N/A
TOTAL 8,157,300 100% 1.9%

Which means the majority of Israelis are not for building more settlements, since the ultra orthodox only make up 11.7% of the population.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

I appreciate so much Perrie's level and factual points on Israeli/Palestinian/Egyptian/Jordanian history and land conflict. Others have attempted to impart the same information but you and the anti-Israel faction here don't give them the respect you accord Perrie.

As for myself, I still sympathize and feel pain for the children who are caught up in the hatred and death and destruction they are born into and have no chance to escape as it is all entrenched in the culture.

I lost my ability to care much about the retaliation they bring on themselves because their hatred of Jews made them reject the initial path of peace, and when a brave Palestinian warrior slithered into the home of a sleeping family when there was no "war" and slit the throats of the mother, father, and three children... a baby only a few weeks old, a toddler, and a child around eleven.

He was hailed as a hero, of course.

So on this subject, yes, I become passionate and obstinate, but even so, if A strikes B with deadly force, B has the right of defense. It is idiocy to expect anyone not to fight back.

At the same time, you also, are obstinate and lack objectivity. You have said yourself you don't know what Israel should do, you just know what they "shouldn't do." That is so impractical and ridiculous a statement it doesn't deserve consideration. It is a non-statement. "I don't know" is not allowed as an answer.

As a matter of fact, on a thread about illegal aliens when it was said that it was impractical to deport millions of them and what would "you" suggest be done, someone responded, "I don't know, but no amnesty." The pro-amnesty commenter said, "If you don't know the answer, then shut the fuck up and sit down."

LOL

:)

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

@Flame...

I didn't tell you to sit down and shut up... I was repeating what one of your buddies told someone to do if they couldn't come up with an alternative for deporting millions of illegals, when they said they "didn't know the answer."

And that is the response you gave once when asked what should be done about Israel's problem with a people who only want them dead. I have never told anyone to sit down and shut up, though I have been told to do that by almost every one of your buddies.

Here is something for you... the Arab who attacked Rabbi Glick, before assaulting him, said to him, "I am sorry, but you are a danger to ____" whatever the name they give to Temple Mount.

Do you know how huge that is? That even though he continued with the attack, he first said, "I am sorry?" Those three words deny him his rewards, and never has a terrorist ever said, "I am sorry" to his victim.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  screminmimi    12 years ago

I must not be explaining the scenario clearly enough, as I did not say you were the one who said it.

Have a safe and happy holiday, flame.Smile.gif

LOL

 
 

Who is online

shona1
CB
Gazoo


102 visitors