Massachusetts Father Mad Just Because Public School Teaches ‘There Is No God But Allah’
Massachusetts Father Mad Just Because Public School Teaches There Is No God But Allah
Millions of students in public schools dont understand fractions or pronouns at even a basic level but students in the oceanfront Boston suburb of Revere, Mass. are taking the time to learn all about Islam in the most embarrassingly shallow and cheerleading way imaginable.
Part of the textbook prints the Muslim Call to Prayer, according to Boston NBC affiliate WHDH .
I bear witness that there is no God but Allah, it says.
The textbook portion also reverently celebrates Muhammads life.
Muhammad never expected to change world, the admiring, rah-rah textbook reads.
Muhammad later tended sheep on the dry hills like many young Arabians, the text explains. Later he became a successful merchant and married a wealthy widow. However, he felt as though something was missing in his life, so he went on a retreat.
The founder of Islam was upset about the cruelty of his people, the text also optimistically explains. They killed baby girls. They treated their slaves unkindly. And Muhammad had a strong sense of right and wrong.
One local parent, Anthony Giannino, is upset about the textbooks treatment of the Muslim religion.
No religion should be taught in school, Giannino told WHDH. It says Allah is their only God. Thats insulting to me as a Christian who believes in just Jesus only.
We dont believe in Allah. I dont believe in my son learning about this here, Giannino added. If my son was from another country and came here, he would have been catered to.
The mad dad said he pulled his son out of his elementary school when he found out about the textbooks treatment of Islam.
Other parents say they dont see what the problem is.
What is Muslim about? What is Christianity about? Thats what I teach at home, parent Idalia Garcia told the Fox station. Everybody should respect everybody elses religion.
The school district superintendent has since penned a letter to parents assuring them that the congratulatory statements about Islam are merely part of the districts history curriculum.
http://news.yahoo.com/massachusetts-father-mad-just-because-public-school-teaches-161617637.html

This isn't "history." It is selective indoctrination.
I never, in my entire time in school, had any teacher "teach" about the story of Jesus. We had Jewish students in my classes, and no one "taught" about the "history" of Jews either.
Looks like the caliphate has gone from creeping to striding.
The real annoying thing here is the double standard. If they were teaching Christianity, the teacher would already be fired and it would be front page on every paper.
Someone said, a few days ago, that we (U. S. citizens) have rolled over.
Is it true?
While there is not enough information regarding the ENTIRE course content, just wondering how would one teach history of the ME w/out the tenants of their government which is the tenants of their faith? I'm all for historical accuracy; personally before we begin teaching the accuracies regarding the Middle East how about we get rid of Columbus Day and the other watered-down versions of American history.
Given the lack of elementary school children's reasoning abilities I question the entire premise, what is the purpose?
It is teaching religion, blue, not Muslim history. There is a difference. We learned about the Crusades in history classes and why they happened, but we did not learn about the "Lord's Prayer" or the birth of a man called "Jesus" or about the Jewish belief that "The Lord our G_d is One."
We learned about the rise of a prophet named Muhammad and his spread of the religion called Islam, but we did not learn ABOUT Islam and the call of the Islamic prayer... that is teaching religion and is not a separation of church and state, a violation of the Constitution.
Bet you didn't bother to read any of the articles about the village in England that started out this way and eventually had the entire school and the population immersed in Islam, the students and population threatened with their lives if they complained about the males and females being separated in classes and the females made to wear Muslim dress to school?
The government had to make a sweep of the entire school administration when a parent finally had the guts to go outside the area to Parliment about it.
Looks like, 1stwarrior, at least above the Mason/Dixon.
I think the premise is for years, the Supreme Court has said there is no place for religion in public schools. So teach about the guy that invented Islam, that doesn't need to include call to prayers and the like, just as teachers should also be able to teach abouta man named Jesus that was the essence that started Christianity. Both of these taught form a historical context is fine, but more than that becomes teaching religion.
As to getting rid of Columbus Day, that is a different topic that has been addressed in other articles.
Dear Friend Lynne Adams: I concur. Elementary school is not yet the time to teach about religion, human intimacy, and other such topics. It is simply too early in childhood development.
As a guest speaker at various places, and as a Proudly Orthodox RabbiI am always very careful to use maximally inclusive language, respect alternative and frequently incompatible viewpoints, and insure that whoever is in the audience can feel comfortablewith what I say. To do otherwise isn't being religious, it is misusing a position of power. There is nothing gracious about that.
There is a place for the objective study of world religions. Higher education would be that place. Colleges, universities,institutes and seminaries are all appropriate places. By that stage of development comparative religions are fair game, if taught truthfully, objectively and responsibly.
Homes and Congregationalschools aregood places to become acculaturated in one's own religion growing up.
Public schools for world religions are not. There is a separation of religionand politicsfor many reasons.
Peace, Knowledge, Harmony, Fairness, Respect for Others, and Abundant Blessings to One and All.
Enoch.
Enoch, your wisdom serves you well and speaks volumes into my life - thank you.
I'm grateful for the sacrifices made by so many before me to live in a society where separation of religion and governance are assured every citizen. Perhaps the problem in teaching Middle East history is the fact it's intrinsically linked to Mohammad and Islam, which is the reason elementary school is, IMO, not an appropriate venue.
To the outrage of parents or grandparents
, I suggest being involved in your local school boards, PTA's or any organization chartered with teaching our children.
Does the course include descriptions of all religions? I didn't get a course in comparative religions until I was in university - when a whitewashed version of a religion would not have impressed me.
Judging by the way they teach Islam, I guess they teach Christianity by saying that the Crusaders were humanitarians handing out candies.
I found the link to the teaching material being discussed in this story.
edhelper.com ( World Religion Theme Unit )
Anyone interested can go get a taste of what is being taught at which grade levels.
Things like;
General Information
What Is Religion? (Grades 6-8)
Buddhism
What Is Buddhism? (Grades 6-8)
Christianity
What Is Christianity? (Grades 6-8)
Islam
What Is Islam? (Grades 6-8)
etc..
I clicked on a few of the 6-8 grade links and the info came across to me as very brief thumbnail historical descriptions of the different faiths, taking no stand as to their divinity or for the good vs bad value of any of the faiths that I read about.
Just looks like a general history study of the worlds major faiths to me.
Then it's agreed: No Islam, Jewish or Christianity ideological ingratiation in any public schools which includes science.
Yes, as I said... and agree.
This link does not indicate that this is what is being taught at this specific school. It appears to be a generic teaching "helper" to plan class activities.
Teaching about religion... any religion.... is not the place of a public school teacher.
Your comment sounds like a little selective tolerance. I'm pretty sure it would not have been shown to a teaching of Judaism or Christianity.
No, it is not agreed, Aeon, because this school principal did not include in his letter to the parents any mention at all of a future plan to include any teachings about Jewish or Christian religious history.
And I am fairly certain that if the school had any plans to do so, in an effort to calm the anger of the parents, he would have mentioned such plans in his letter.
We are currently in a conflict with Muslim extremists and I think it's completely appropriate for the school (whose mission is to educate children) to include information in its curriculum that gives the children some idea of what members of all the world's great religions actually believe. The parent quoted in the article objects to children learning things that he, himself, doesn't believe. If the school is going to dispel ignorance, then the perfect place to start is with a basic understanding that everybody does not see things the same way (between religions and within them) and that we can respect our differences without compromising our own beliefs. Good for the school!
Mimi my search of the subject turned up this image in one of the news stories ;
The link provided above does seem to be where the material being taught at this specific school is coming from. Of course the first page is just a summary, a starting point, but it looks like you can get to the full lesions from there if you're so inclined.
Different religions and their impact on us, like different political systems or social movements can have their place in public schools as long as they're taught as part of our human history, (as this course seems designed to do), and not as religious dogma.
Screminmimi again, go to the link I provided, ( World ReligionTheme Unit ), the other religions you mention plus about 23 others from around the world are already part of the teaching plan.
There was no need to mention them in the Principals letter as things to be added in the future since they are already there, part of a comprehensive teaching package that introduces students to most of the major religions in their world.
As the other religions are part of the future teaching package, I would cautiously withdraw my objections. Had I been the principal, however, I would have informed the parents of the plan to teach the roots of the other religions to stem their objections.
I'm still of the opinion that trying to teach religious history comes pretty close to stepping on the toes of a parent's jurisdiction; I don't see a Muslim being any too happy about a school teaching a Muslim child about any other religion, even in a purely academic way.
Just have to wait and see how this one plays out.
Thank you for all your research.
Your welcome Mimi. I may be an old dog these days but I still enjoy chasing the occasional rabbit now and again.
Well remember just because the part about Islam caused a ruckus doesn't mean that other religions haven't already been discussed.
Shoot,if the class was taught alphabetically, like the summary page is laid out, then they might have already gone from Buddhism thru Zoroastrianism and are now having lively discussions about "The People of the Totem Pole" which is also part of the curriculum.
Well, if that's the case then its OK. (Isn't it time we got rid of that nonsensical "separation of church and state" nonsense, anyway?)
/sarcasm
Couldn't agree more! Parents who complain and scream the loudest are (in my experience) those who are absent at board meetings, PTA's and often have no idea who the teacher is must less administrators, counselors, department heads, etc. Instead of feigning outrage a concerned parent would engage the system entrusted with their child's education.
I believe that the Supremes have already ruled on that...???
You don't know what happened there any more than I do, blue. It could be that he attended a meeting and was told that Islam was the only thing being taught. We don't know because the story doesn't go into detail.
Why don't you chill the fuck out and try to be civil for a change.
Where I come from schools work like this;
The principals and teaching staff hash out a state approved curriculum, with the input of a District Administrator. Then the curriculum goes to the School board where the public gets to view it and ask questions. It is at this point in the process where parents need to get involved, but dont. Once the Board approves the curriculum, its set, period. No one can change it.
I have NEVER heard, anywhere in the U.S., of a school notifying parents that a particular part of any curriculum has been reached unless the Board, PTA or other involved parties mandate it before it is approved. An example would be, a principal will notify parents if anything like sex education is mentioned and allow for parents to opt-out of it for their children.
What makes this Massachusetts case so tragically amusing is that the father, et al, obviously never bothered to attend PTA and School board meetings when all of this was decided then approved. These lunkheads though, are the first ones to run around like chicken little, screaming bloody-ass murder because they were too ignorant or self-involved to get involved in the process.
Even in my extreme fundamentalist Baptist grade school, we were taught about the existence of other religions and the very basics but thats it. Such topics are universal within public and private schools. So teaching children about the various worldwide faiths is NOT inconsistent with primary education.
Maybe the father needs a refresher . . . then he might learn that Jews, Christians, and Muslims all pray to the same God (the God of Abraham).