370+ US Anthro-Apology Academics Sign Petition Against Israel
370+ US Anthro-Apology Academics Sign Petition Against Israel
Anthropology academics sign petition attacking Israel and pledging to boycott Israeli institutions
By Lori Lowenthal Marcus, The Jewish Press, October 15, 2014
In the never-ending battle of American academics attempting toprove that their own specialty is more devoted to the Palestinian cause and more interested in teaching their students and the rest of the world how evil Israel is, the American Anthropological Association has entered the petition activism olympics.
The anthropology academics are so brave they not only tell everyone how bad Israel is (even when they get some of the facts wrong), by signing the petition they assert their right to boycott the Israeli institutions they believe are complicit in Israels ongoing violations of Palestinian rights.
The anthropologists, you see, are taking this opportunity to distance themselves from their disciplines historical complicity with the evils ofcolonialism. And so, who better to work out their own guilt issues than the Jewish State, of course.
What they are trying to do, like Lady Macbeth, isremovethe bloodstains from their hands, through their own inverted apology, spun as a reprimand of Israel.
These are not anthropologists, they are anthro-apologists.
Here is what they wrote:
The recent military assault on the Gaza Strip by Israel is only the latest reminder that the worlds governments and mainstream media do not hold Israel accountable for its violations of international law. As a community of scholars who study problems of power, oppression, and cultural hegemony, we have a moral responsibility to speak out and demand accountability from Israel and our own governments . Acting in solidarity with Palestinian civil society continues a disciplinary tradition of support for anticolonial and human rights struggles, itself an important departure from anthropologys historical complicity with colonialism. [emphasis added]
These academics have searched the world over for rights not being sufficiently respected to their taste, and found that the most egregious wrongs currently being perpetrated in the world are taking place in Syriano, not thereIraq.no, not there, North Koreano, no there, Chinano, not there. Israel!
And so these academics have dramatically decided that withholding their collaboration with Israeliacademic institutions is what will bring a breakthrough in the Arab-Israeli conflict, by forcing Israel to yield to their wishes.
Because, heck, without these academics, Israeli institutions may not be able to continue functioning, and, as soon as those institutions realize they will be deprived of the honor of working with these anthropologists, why they will rush into Jerusalem, storm the knesset, and force the Israeli government to mend the error of their ways. Because otherwise, these brave academics will abandon them.
If only.
Click this link to read the rest of this article:
http://www.jewishpress.com/news/breaking-news/370-us-anthro-apology-academics-sign-petition-against-israel/2014/10/15/

Who gives a shit? Personally I would wish that Israel would ban any member of any academic department of anthropology that signs the petition from entering Israel for the purpose of anthropological study. It is about time Israel got the balls to ban every person, organization, company or institution that supports or acquiesces to BDS from receiving any products or benefits emanating from Israel whether it is agricultural, technological, medical or manufactured. Then the cartoon in the article above, although exaggerated, might just be a precursor of what can happen.
These anthro majors should be forced to spend some time living in Sderot . Let's see how long their "moral resolve " holds up under those conditions .
Nobody said "disagree" but YOU flame. We are talking about a stupid ban that is counterproductive to academic advance and achievement. Those who sign that ban are the ones who should be banned, not people who just disagree with Israel. Nice try flame, but no cigar.
You must be a holocaust denier to say something that incredibly stupid ...
Tell that to the majority of Arabs who live in Israel who prefer to live in Israel rather than ANY Arab state, INCLUDING the areas controlled by the PA. The minority probably think it but don't want to come out with it because of fear of reprisals.
Thank you. You have just explained why the Peace Process cannot work. Remember that Arafat was offered about 97% of what he wanted, but walked away from the table. Why are the Israelis the only ones who compromise, make concessions - like releasing prisoners who have blood on their hands, like giving up land for peace such as the Sinai to Egypt and vacating Gaza - a lot of good those concessions have done.
I'm not going to invite someone who hates me into my house, flame. It isn't just a "disagreement", no matter how many ways you want to pose it. Signing a petition is an indication of a desire to support taking action against Israel in some way. I disagree with some of the things that Israel does but I will not sign any kind of petition to ban anything that Israel produces, physical or intellectual, nor will it stop me from supporting the State of Israel. Disagree with anything you want but that is NOT taking a step to cause economic or intellectual harm. Sorry, but you simply cannot identify disagreement with supporting action and a ban is action.
Don't play with words with me, flame. You aren't going to be able to twist the truth to suit your bias.
Where can they go in Europe ? They are hated there . They can't go to the US because there are major limits on immigration . They could probably go to Canada or parts of South America but they would be separated from the Jewish culture which they want .
The majority of the United Nations wanted them to live there, and there were already Jews there who wanted them to live there. Even Abbas admitted that not accepting Partition was a mistake on the part of the Arabs - Do you need to see proof of that too?
My internet in China won't let me use google or open up a lot of links that would make the majority argument, but you can do it where you are. Although this poll by Haifa University is 2 years old it indicated that almost 70% of Israeli Arabs would rather live in Israel than anywhere else, including a Palestinian State:
This one is much more recent:
You can attack the sources if you wish as opinion, but the figures don't lie.
How is avoiding antisemitism in Europe a choice ?
You know, flame, you twist and turn, you change the meaning of my words and expect me to argue with you. Here is an example. I said that at the time of partition, the 1940s, the majority of nations in the UN wanted Israel to go there. Then you throw back to me that the current position of the UN is different now - yes it is now that the Arab and Arab-pandering block control the GA.
At the time. around WW2 is where the Jews had nowhere to go. We are not talking about now. Perhaps you don't know the story of the ship the MS St. Louis, or the fact that Great Britain preferred that the Jews go back to where they were being exterminated or were hated or wanted them kept in another concentration camp, in Cyprus. I guess you didn't know that the Prime Minister of Canada, McKenzie King, when asked just after the war how many Jewish refugees would he admit into Canada, his answer was "None is too many" - so notorious a statement it became the title of a historical book about the time.
I'm not going to argue with you any further over this, flame. This fish isn't biting any more.
To me, it's just a waste of my precious time.
Yeah, well, for much ofAmerican academia, livin' in the real world would indeed be a stretch of the imagination. BDS merely makes them feel relevant in their disillusionment.
A character flaw of "Academia" is its never-ending bullshit effort to justify its own viability and existence.
Such groups love to string meaningless words together to make them sound meaningful.
Idiots.
If they truly put aside everything the Israelis have contributed to the world they would be entitled to a measure of respect for their idealism. They don't have the stones to do that. Therefore they are contemptible.
I would still like to give the Jews the land along the Southern border. Only way I can see to finally close that section and secure it.
Go Israel!
Which Southern border do you mean? What land? Please provide a more detailed description.
Then they'll be accused of oppressing the poor Mexicans.
Pardon me for being so blunt here, Mike, but I don't give a damn. And if the cartels are stupid enough to fire on them, the IDF can take them out and dump their sorry carcasses on the Mexican side of the line. Heck, Israel can even have the US National Forest that Americans are warned by our government to stay out of because Mexican criminals have set up drug camps inside it and shoot American citizens who venture into the woods to enjoy the scenery.
I'd rather give it to Israel as allow the drug cartels to have it and it's obvious the fat lazy cows and emasculated jackasses in Washington aren't going to take back the US land they have ceded to Mexican gangsters.
As I said, it's the only way I can see that we'll ever have security on that border.
Go, Israel!!
The entire Southern border of the United States of America, Buzz, that is supposed to divide the US from Mexico. We should give it to Israel as a second Israeli homeland. They can have that big National Forest, too, because out of cowardice, it has been ceded to Mexican drug cartels who have set up drug camps in it.
There are actual signs along the highway that warn American citizens to stay out of that forest because of the danger... can you believe that? A foreign government's drug dealers LIVE in that forest and they SHOOT at Americans who try to enjoy that public land so CITIZENS of this country are WARNED by SIGNS ALONG THE ROAD to stay out of it.
So let's give it and all the land along the border to Israel. I'll bet the IDF won't have a problem keeping the bastards on their side of the fence that should be there but isn't.
Quite frankly, nobody would know this if it wasn't publicized by those who disagree with it. The question is, Who Cares?
It only becomes relevant when such a proclamation influences those with the power and authority to actually act in boycotting, divesting and sanctioning Israel.
As I've pointed out, the stupid assholes are doing nothing more than shooting themselves in the foot, so as AP has asked - who cares?
LOL, no shit Sherlock. Kinda reminds of ol' black-n-white adventure flicks where you would see the hero strutting onto the savanna decked out in cashmere slacks,Dior button-down shirt, and a Rolex could be seen when he gripped the whip on his belt.
Years ago we hada young friend who when she first went to college, her intended major was anthropology and we encouraged her, but not in that field of study. After the first year, she found something more to her liking. I asked her what changed her mind she replied that "all of her profs and most of the serious students were so full of their own shit, that it was amazing that they could see anything without a brown tint"...and..."it seems like the field of anthropology is irresistibly egotistical and too full of it's self to offer much objective analysis".
The comments are starting to seem like the lectures I attended when I took a course in Anthropology, but where is Margaret Mead?
When I say "Who cares?", it's because I don't think anyone should care about what those particular anthropologists do since they're simply acting against their own interests, and as others have said, their full of themselves and of shit.