╌>

Detroiters Vow Resistance After Judge Rules There is No Human Right to Water

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  z  •  12 years ago  •  38 comments

Detroiters Vow Resistance After Judge Rules There is No Human Right to Water

LWmmeqs.jpg "The people of Detroit are vowing resistance after a federal bankruptcy judge on Monday ruled that the city can continue shutting off water to its poorest residents if their bills cannot be paid.

Judge Steven W. Rhodes at the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Eastern District of Michigan declared that citizens have no implicit right to water, that he lacked the authority to issue a restraining order to stop the shutoffs and that doing so would be a financial hit to the city already in the throes of bankruptcy. "There is no such right or law," Rhodes said.

Advocacy groups had filed for a temporary restraining order against the Detroit Water and Sewerage Department to stem the shutoffs until a plan is put into place to ensure that Detroiters can afford access to clean water.

The plaintiffswhich include the National Action Network, Michigan Welfare Rights Organization, Moratorium Now and the Peoples Water Boardargued that the city implemented shutoffs unfairly, without adequate notice and with little financial assistance for poor people who lack the means to pay ." Source

********************************************************

"Shutting off water service to a privately owned residence or a rental property sets the stage for a series of several potential, fairly predictable legal blowback events, all of which brutalize the families who fell behind on their water bills.

Because there is no longer water service, the structure can be condemned and ordered vacated as a public nuisance, in violation of most municipal housing Codes. Because there is no water, there is (in fact) a fire hazard, and the unsanitary conditions (unflushable toilets, no water for bathing, cleaning, or cooking) may (in fact) make the dwelling unfit for continued human habitation.

Children in that unsafe household environment can be petitioned into foster care by protective service agency workers, with the custodial adults charged with parental neglect. Single adults, living alone who try to remain in an unsafe, unsanitary condemned home, can be petitioned into the mental health system, the theory being that such a subsistence lifestyle is evidence of inability to provide for their own basic needs, creating an immediate threat to their own physical health and/or the safety of others living nearby."

Water is a human right.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    12 years ago

Boy this is a thorny one to say the least.... and I can see both sides of this issue.

One has to fight to earn the right to survive on this rock from the very first breath taken at birth. The water one would obtain from digging their own well, or hauling water to their home comes at the price of the excavation, or physical effort. The price one pays for clean water being delivered out of a faucet at ones home is to pay for what others have expended as an investment to get water to that faucet.

Life on earth is not free of charge, it comes with a cost. Water is required for life, thus access to life giving water has a cost.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago
 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

I seeded an article about this several weeks ago when it was first mentioned that this was impending. Then another article was seeded later about PETA offering to pay water bills if the people would agree to go vegan.

If these people have their water shut off and they are evicted and made homeless, and their children taken and placed in foster homes, and single adults petitioned into the mental health system, the cost to the city and state will be far higher than the water bills.

I'm sure that all the state and municipal areas are watching this play out with nervous breath, because the final blow will impact the entire country and all water systems... especially in the half of the nation that is suffering severe drought and where the cost of water services is rising far beyond what many are going to be able to afford.

If the poor in even one city are given a pass on paying their water bill, those in every city across the nation will step onto the band wagon. And if they are given a pass this time, they will expect it time and again. It is the nature of the beast.

This is what chronic dependency on welfare has created.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Having made the above comment....

People cannot live without water. With illegal aliens trying to cross the Southern border, many have left stashes of water in different places across the desert so they would have access to the necessary life-saving liquid. The US has spent many an "aid" dollar to assist foreign countries in developing sources of water delivery to their people. It has long been acknowledged that humans can live longer without food than without water.

Something will have to be done about the situation in Detroit. Turning all these people out and making them homeless is not a viable solution. Neither is shutting of all the water for so many and setting up an immediate health hazard. If nothing else, the US will not allow its international image to be tarnished as the richest country in the world treating its poorest citizens in such a way.

Glad I'm not in charge of resolving this crisis.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

There should be an absolute floor below which we allow no citizen to sink.

That is the crux of the problem right there. When one month is allowed to slide, the second month should never be allowed to. The second month should be demanded along with arrangements to pay a portion of the previous month, or the water is shut off.

Chances are a household can find a way to have it turned back on for that amount far easier than it can with three or four months in arrears.

As I said, I'm glad it's not my responsibility to handle this situation. The water company will be seen as the bad guy here, and they are not. On the other hand, for the sake of sanitation and the very real health of the entire city, water has to be provided for all these people.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

The second paragraph concerns the situation right now. The first one is what should have been done at the beginning. If it had, the people might have scrambled hard to come up with the money before it became such a large bill they could in no way handle it, and for the subsequent months they might have made sure they had the money available somehow.

As for the current situation, as I stated, this many people can't be made homeless by eviction nor can they be allowed to stay in those dwellings without potable water and create a dire health hazard that will affect the entire city.

The city should never have allowed the unpaid bills to go past two months.

Does that clarify it for you John?

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
Do we let these people lounge about while we pay their bills, or do we walk by while they expire from thirst? There has to be a happy median somewhere.
 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

Oh. my. gosh.

All I can say is that this would NOT fly down here in KY. Here in Louisville, we maintain a fund where the indigent can still get water, and their bill paid. It's called keeping our city healthy, so something. Part of the mayor's campaign to make sure that Louisville is the US' Most Compassionate City. (seriously!)

I know that Detroit is having a hard time, but this has MANY far-reaching implications.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

Here in Louisville, and in many cities, it is illegal to use a house well if a municipal supply is available.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

The judge ruled that there was no "implicit" right to water. "Implicit" means "absolute" or "implied". You are putting your own words that were neither spoken nor meant into the mouth of another to say the judge ruled there was no HUMAN right to water. Your headline is false and misleading. In the context of this situation, what the judge meant was that in accordance with the facts of the case there is no absolute right to free delivery of water. IMO the judge is correct. The fact that humans require water is not relevant to the legal case at hand, so wring your hands and whine about it but the judge was correct.

When I saw this my first thought was that judges are supposed to base things on their interpretation of the law-- not on someone's view of "human rights". What are "human rights"-- I think different people would have different opinions people differ on what rights humans have & do not have. Isn't the legal system supposed to based on law and not the popularity of something? (Popular opinion is not always the same as what the law says-- if it were, rather than trial by jury, guilt or innocence would be determined by a public opinion poll!

Anyway Buzz-- what does a mere English teacher like you know about law anyway?

(/sarcasm)

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

I realize the contradiction in what I said. My thought is that if the water were shut off while the bill is at a lower amount, and arrangements are made with the person to facilitate payment, it would show the homeowner/renter that the water company is determined to have payment or there will be consequences, but they are willing to entertain options.

By allowing the bill to go beyond a reasonable amount of time the water company gives the impression it is willing to carry the bill beyond the amount of time any creditor would be expected to do so, giving the debtor a sense the company understands the quagmire of debt he and his fellow citizens have fallen into through the economic hard times being experienced throughout the entire city and indeed, the country itself.

With the once proud city of Detroit announcing its plan to file for bankruptcy because it cannot pay its own bills, can these destitute citizens, 98% of whom are probably barely existing on social services, be blamed for grasping the straw of hope that the water company will be decent enough to grant them the mercy of acknowledging that they, too, cannot pay the high cost of the precious life force that is needed to ensure they can continue to live?

What type of monster would flip the switch to shut off water, when it comes from the rivers and lakes that flow from the veins of Earth itself, knowing that they and their children will DIE if they don't have it? Surely their Mayor, their Congressman, their Senator, their PRESIDENT, won't allow that!?!

I don't need anyone to explain the reality of power companies to me... I'm talking here of people who are most likely less educated and see things on a more emotional and basic level.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

If it is wrong to turn off the water, it is wrong at six months, AND it would also be wrong at two months, which is why I said that the two sentences don't go together.

Two months is much too short a time to expect people to turn their finances around.

Detroit has some serious problems-- this is one of the worst dilemmas, but there are others.

IMO, there are two parts to this-- shortterm & longterm. In the short-term (and that should be considerably longer than two months)-- all residents must have a adequate water provided. (& food as well).

Longterm, the entire economic mess that is Detroit must be turned around. A better economy, many more jobs, adequate healthcare, lowering the crime rates, etc. While most people outside the area seem to feel that that is impossible,I am very optimistic for Detroit's future.

Many corporations as well as individuals are stepping in to help. For example, people might be surprised to know that Whole Foods has opened a new store in Detroit! (Also one in New York's Harlem, BTW). This not only creates jobs*, but also provides people in the area with access to fresh produce and other healthy foods, as well as free classes on nutrition & healthy eating. Many innovative people-- some who recently moved to Detroit-- are working hard to help the city turn-around.

__________________________________

*Creating jobs has more benefits than just for those workers. When a new store opens up, both the newly employed and the company pays taxes-- which help the government. But perhaps more importantly, people who formerly lived in dire poverty & are now employed now have some money to spend-- which help the stores where they spend it-- and help those stores expand-- which means mores jobs for more workers!

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

This is a lot of people, Dowser and the amount is huge. Nevertheless, these people cannot be deprived of water.

And I will add this... half the country is in a drought, and the rest of the country is having their water bills raised to pay for the water their areas are selling to the areas that don't have any... and it is a big mess.

It's also one of the reasons I am personally against massive immigration. We do not have the natural resources to continue the way we have been going. When social services are reduced in my area for the indigent and the handicapped, for the elderly, and another Food Pantry location reduces the number of days it can service a neighborhood, it's a sign we can't handle what we already have.

Resources are finite... all resources. Especially natural resources, and water is at the top of the list.

The people in Detroit, for the safety of all the citizens there and to stop a massive riot of people attacking and breaking open fire hydrants to obtain water... will have to be given water. There is no way the federal government will allow the image of the United States to be tarnished in the international theater as a first world nation that allowed thousands of people in a municipal city to die of thirst and spread feces-laden disease throughout the streets.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

I was unable to open the link to the original article so I was not aware that it bore the same headline that AeonPax used. Therefore I cannot say that her headline was false and misleading - in fact it was the original headline that she copied that was false and misleading. I have therefor amended my comment to remove my accusation of AeonPax. However, I stick to my guns that the judge did not say that water was a "human" right.

My original comment, as amended:


The judge ruled that there was no "implicit" right to water. "Implicit" means "absolute" or "implied". The article's author put his own words that were neither spoken nor meant into the mouth of another to say the judge ruled there was no HUMAN right to water. The headline is false and misleading. In the context of this situation, what the judge meant was that in accordance with the facts of the case there is no absolute right to free delivery of water. IMO the judge is correct. The fact that humans require water is not relevant to the legal case at hand, so wringing hands and whining about it is of no avail because the judge was correct. Law and morality are not necessarily coincident.

Ah, yes, Krishna. What do I know about law? 7.gif You will have to ask an expert, but unfortunately FutureLegalEagle is no longer among us. 24.gif

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
Good point, Robert G. At what point are these people responsible for their own existence?
 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

Yes, lower the fricking water bill. The city is trying to have the poorest people pay the freight. A lot of cities with big deficits have raised their water prices a lot lately. That is not the way to make a city work.

Sounds good in theory.

But for most of these people their inability to pay is not because they have so little income because their jobs pay so little. The problem is that they don't have any job! No savings, no income at all.

(And ironically, raising the minimum wage won't help much here either-- because so many people aren't working-- so they don't even have wages that could be raised).

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    12 years ago

I didn't know that, but it makes sense as to why it is.

Of course there will be those that will complain that it is violating their rights. If I recall, purchasing a home in suburbia, you don't get control of the airspace, nor mineral rights when you sign for the deed. Plus there are the zoning laws.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    12 years ago

A very sad state of affairs indeed Flame.

The locust have come and gone....... Maybe now some will see the need for laws and regulation to dampen the bad aspects of capitalism while ensuring innovation and competition. Of course we have a few libertarian/Teapers that will go to their graves believing that it would be best to have no regulations or laws with regards to corporations.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    12 years ago

Do we let these people lounge about while we pay their bills

This is a perfect example of a Republican/conservative lie....the false assumption that the poor do nothing but lounge around. It's an extremely stupid statement but it's also a long held canard by the political right.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

I know people who work 2-3 jobs to make it. Yet, they cannot, at times, afford their water bill. There is no excuse for demonizing the poor!

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    12 years ago

It's also one of the reasons I am personally against massive immigration

We already have about 20 million illegals here in the US. Our electrical, sewage, water and transportation infrastructure is holding up well, despite it's old age.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

I can only hope!

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    12 years ago

That is the crux of the problem right there. When one month is allowed to slide, the second month should never be allowed to. The second month should be demanded along with arrangements to pay a portion of the previous month, or the water is shut off.

This is a lot of the problem. Detroit is owed billions in water and taxes because they have not been collecting it. People see they are not paying and are getting the service or not paying taxes with no recourse, so they continue this until they have dug a hole they can no longer get out of.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    12 years ago

And this is due to the financial collapse and poor decisions made by automakers.

Sorry, Detroit was in very deep shit before the Auto industry started having problems....that was merely the last nail in the coffin. The city had already experienced severe population decline and that was due to years of taxes being raised by Colman Young to pay for his projects. After the tax hikes people left the city in droves which made revenue decline and the dumb ass still didn't have money to cover his projects. (why would anyone continue to live in a city with some of the highest taxes and worst services?) Young was a smart thief that never got caught and managed to keep getting elected no matter how much corruption there was associated with him (much like Kwame). He also never stopped bilking the city for everything he could. (much like Kwame)

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
AP, your reading comprehension needs work. I presented two clearly ridiculous extremes for illustration. I also indicated that neither was acceptable. Get off your partisan high horse.
 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    12 years ago

You clearly don't know what "clearly" is.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
Clearly, the businesses must be pursued as well. They probably have lawyers though.
 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
Apparently I had too much faith in some readers. I'll dumb it down next time.
 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

No, Aeon they are not. Most people pay no attention to the brief interruption of electrical services about twice a day that are rotated through the systems, there are frequent brief lines in the news about disruptions in planes, trains and automobiles, the sewer systems haven't been able to keep up for some time now and half the country is in severe drought as water wars are being waged.

Even before the drought there were various stories of contamination in city and town water supply and drinking water was trucked in.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

All these people should form a citizen's group and engage a lawyer to represent them. It is a dangerous health risk and is at the least endangering children to deprive them of water.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    12 years ago

Please do. Maybe that way you can read what you write.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Aeonpax    12 years ago

I'll just say this...when you can prove that immigrants, legal or illegal, are the cause of our deteriorating infrastructure, I'll believe you. Until then, it's just another far-fetched bias fear I have no wish to entertain.

US infrastructure problems were identified in the 80's without the addition of immigrants. Now there is the poisoning of public waters via strip mining and fracking to contend with.....both pet projects of the Republican party.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

I don't honestly believe that ANY of the founding fathers envisioned a world where we were all dependent upon public utilities for water. Or one where it would be illegal, in some areas, to drill your own well, or to collect rainwater.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

Aeon, I agree with you.

Fracking is BAD for drinking water. And we are just letting it happen...

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    12 years ago

Oh I agree it shouldn't be happening in the first place.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
I am so smart that I write things even I can't understand? Thanks, I guess. I don't think it works that way though...
 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

Things seem to be getting pretty desperate in Detroit:

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    12 years ago

I'd rather have the iPhone 6. That city has been a disaster since the riots of 67 when the knuckleheads drove all the honest hard working people out of the city.

 
 

Who is online

devangelical
JohnRussell


76 visitors