Iraqi pilots mistakenly drop supplies to ISIS terrorists
Iraqi military pilots mistakenly gave food, water and ammunition to enemy ISIS militants instead of their own soldiers, a senior security official and a brigadier-general told NBC News. The supplies were supposed to help besieged Iraqi army officers and soldiers who had been fighting Islamist extremists for a week in Saglawyah and the village of Al-Sijar in the countrys western province of Anbar.
Some pilots, instead of dropping these supplies over the area of the Iraqi army, threw it over the area that is controlled by ISIS fighters, said Hakim Al-Zamili, a lawmaker in the Iraqi parliament who is a member of the security and defense committee and acts as a security liaison for service members and commanders formed by anti-American cleric Muqtada al-Sadr . Those soldiers were in deadly need of these supplies, but because of the wrong plans of the commanders in the Iraqi army and lack of experience of the pilots, we in a way or another helped ISIS fighters to kill our soldiers.
A brigadier-general in Iraqs Defense Ministry, who declined to be named, confirmed the incident, which occurred on Sept. 19. Yes, that's what had happened, the officer said, adding that some air force pilots do not have enough experience they are all young and new. Both Al-Zamili and the brigadier-general said there would be an investigation to determine the cause of the blunder.
http://www.nbcnews.com/storyline/isis-terror/iraq-pilots-mistakenly-gave-food-ammunition-isis-militants-n214956

It is a damn good thing we spent so much money training and arming them./s
What exactly is the problem with Iraqi troops? We've trained,armed and at every turn they screw up beyond belief. I get the "new", but honestly there was a military before we arrived and I'd think after the amount of training, and weaponry, they should be able to kick butt! We're able to put a recruit through 6 weeks training, assign to a unit and somehow our soldiers are able to march, carry a gun and chew gum at the same time.
As the old saying goes: "With friends like these, who needs enemies?"
"Mistake", really??? How about some ocean-front land in Florida, or maybe a nice bridge I can let you have cheap?
The problem is not specifically an Iraqi problem. Rather, its a problem with all Arab armies. Different cultures have different values. (Many Americans assume that all countries and groups have the same values as we do-- for better or worse. But there are huge differences).
Current day Arab societies don't function very well. (in different periods in history it may have been different). And the predominant dysfunctional values permeate all areas-- including the military. This is the reason Arab armies of modern times fight so poorly. (The only exceptions being when they have a tremendous numerical advantage over their foe-- or when they are extremely well armed and their enemy isn't. And even then they are often defeated).
Actually there has been a lot of analysis, from a military point of view, of why they fight so poorly. Here is one of the better articles- very detailed but they really nail it:
P.S: This is about the values in Arab society and does not necessarily apply to non-Arab groups in the area such as Persians (Iran), Turkey, the Israelis, the Kurds, the Druze, etc.
Fascinating!
''Why Arabs Lose Wars'', a eye opening article.
It would seem then, that the US shouldactually arm the Kurds with modern weapons and let them destroy ISIS.
Right on. Might make Turkey a little nevous.
But that's not because their armed forces are better-- in fact, they are co sideraly worse.
The difference is the way the 2 sides view human life. After a while most mericans can no longer put up with taking continuing casualties. (After all our loses in iraq and Afghanistan, America is no longer willing to lose any more of our kids). Obama didn't pull out of Iraq because we wee defeated, but rather Americans could no longer stomach war...
Most Arabs, OTOH, don't place much value on human life, because they strongly believe in the afterlife, and that they will spend eternity in paradise if they die fighting for Allah (Peace Be Upon him). And they don't just parrot those phrases-- they truly & deeply believe believe they will enter Paradise.
What sort of mother would want her son to die for Islam? Well, one who believes in death-- because the kid will be in paradise!
The allies fighting in Iraq and Afghanistan suffered casualties due to friendly fire from the well-trained forces. Guess what's going to happen when the allies put boots on the ground anywhere near these incompetent idiots.
They have to want to be trained Lynne.
"To get the paycheck, I have to wear the uniform right?" (Nobody said I had to listen during the training.)
Why Arabs Lose Wars
Interesting. This explains why Obama and the political right is so scared of the ISIS.
Excellent article.
The highly capable and effective NCO portion of our military is, and has been for decades, the backbone of every branch of our military. They are the glue that keeps the ranks and tanks operational and effective. Our effective reliance on NCOs is pretty unique throughout the world.
The other thing about our military is that it is the great equalizer as (for the most part) people advance because their ability to do their jobs, not their color, or social background. They shave your head in boot camp, give you a uniform, then somewhere it crystallizes that you are no more or less special than the other 90 people in your company.
Given the way our military thinks and operates in comparison to those of Arab nations, the trainers that we send to them may as well be from Mars.
I think you need to take a look at the list of friendly fire incidents , the US has been involved in....this includes Afghanistan and Iraq.
What's your point, AP? As many incidents of friendly fire as there have been, put the weapons in the hands of incompetents and poorly trained troops, you can expect a multiple of your list. And that's not counting the ones who turn against the Western troops - think of fort Hood.
Fratricide is going to happen.
Given the always increase in the speed of war I doubt that we will ever be rid of it until we as a species stop wanting to go to war with each other.
Ft Hood has nothing to do with this. If the Army had vetted their officers better that might never have happened. (Think John McCain - Palin)
The biggest problem with the US backed Iraqi forces is that they never even fire their weapons, just drop and run. The weapons are immediately confiscated by the ISIS. US weapons...never fired, dropped once.
26 billion dollars down that rat hole.
Why Arabs Lose Wars
Really appreciate this link! It's a fascinating read I'm still digesting.
Impossible to play General from the comforts of my living room, but I'd like to think if my family and way of life were threatened I'd grow a pair - culture be damned.
Like the old Soviet system on steroids.
The linked article on 'Why Arabs Lose Wars' is interesting, but it sort of begs the queston--
How do the ISIS boys suddenly become better? After all, the vast majority of ISIS fighters are products of exactly the same culture-- one would think that they'd be subject to the same mindset and thereby no more 'effective' than the troops they're facing...
Good question Swamijim.
They have "Jihad" to rally around.
The first rule in fighting is wanting to fight.
Exactly! States like Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, Jordan, Saudi Arabia, and the Gulf emirates are all 20th century inventions ruled by monarchies or dictators. The general public and the soldiers (to an even greater extent as they are asked to risk their lives) feel stakeless and have little desire to fight for their rulers.
Arab societies are tribal/clannish in nature. The Islamic ummahis the biggest tribe of all and apparently winning. It is human nature to want to join a winner, hence the influx of jihadis from Western countries streaming to join ISIS.