Obama: U.S. intelligence underestimated militants in Syria - CBS
Obama: U.S. intelligence underestimated militants in Syria - CBS
Reuters, September 28, 2014
This file image posted on a militant website on Tuesday, Jan. 7, 2014, which is consistent with AP reporting, shows a convoy of vehicles and fighters from the al-Qaida linked Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant (ISIL) fighters in Iraq's Anbar Province. The Islamic State group holds roughly a third of Iraq and Syria, including several strategically important cities like Fallujah and Mosul in Iraq and Raqqa in Syria. It rules over a population of several million people with its strict interpretation of Islamic law. (AP Photo via militant website, File)
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - U.S. intelligence agencies underestimated Islamic State activity inside Syria, which has become "ground zero" for jihadists worldwide, President Barack Obama said in a CBS television interview broadcast on Sunday.
Conversely, the United States overestimated the ability of the Iraqi army to fight the militant groups, Obama said in a "60 Minutes" interview taped on Friday, days after the U.S. president made his case at the United Nations for action.
Citing earlier comments by James Clapper, director of national intelligence, Obama acknowledged that U.S. intelligence underestimated what had been taking place in Syria.
Islamic militants went underground when U.S. Marines quashed al Qaeda in Iraq with help from Iraq's tribes, he said.
"But over the past couple of years, during the chaos of the Syrian civil war, where essentially you have huge swaths of the country that are completely ungoverned, they were able to reconstitute themselves and take advantage of that chaos," Obama said.
"And so this became ground zero for jihadists around the world."
Obama last week expanded U.S.-led airstrikes, which began in Iraq in August, to Syria and he has been seeking to build a wider coalition effort to weaken Islamic State. The group has killed thousands and beheaded at least three Westerners while seizing parts of Syria and north western Iraq.
Clapper told a Washington Post columnist this month that U.S. intelligence had underestimated Islamic State and overestimated Iraq's army.
Click this link to read the rest of this article and watch a video of Obamas speech:
https://news.yahoo.com/obama-u-intelligence-underestimated-militants-syria-cbs-160559427.html

Somehow, I think the USA should have relied on Israeli intelligence rather than their own. All this does is make me more concerned about Iran and its development of nuclear weapons. If the USA is incompetent in determining the true situation in Iran, perhaps Netanyahu is right.
It's that great foreign policy and intelligence Buzz. Does anyone really believe this? Of course Obama blamed it on his intelligence agency. He said don't bother me, I'm putting.
Food for Thought;
$26 Billion in US Aid Later, the Iraqi Military Is a Total Disaster
Well they do have an ample supply of those magnetic "We support the troops" stickers for the back of their cars.
And you can't lay any blame whatsoever to Obama using the Johnson "war" direction methods? You know the one - "My mind is made up, don't confuse me with the facts."????? 'Member that one?
You're saying that Obama has no blame is any of this, right? You're saying that Cheney and Bush are still in the White House, six years later, and are planning all the pitfalls and downfalls of this "Clear and Present Danger"??? And Obama has made absolutely no errors of judgment???
IT'S ALL BUSHES FAULT!!!!!!!!!!
Feel better flame?
Oh no, Mike is dividing us. It's the hallmark of his time on this site. It has always been transparent to most of us. <sarc>
Obama is one of us. He says there is a problem in Washington and he is going to fix it. The only problem is he doesn't want you to know the problem is him.
If George Bush has a son, he would look like Obama or Hillary.
Now can we get back on topic?
This article was about intelligence, and IMO the comments are straying too far from intelligence.
If you mean US Military Intelligence, that's an oxymoron.
I did flame. You are playing the exact game Obama and the "rest" of the Dems are - blame game. You folks can't take the responsibility of admitting - OK, we made a mistake. No, you have to blame anyone and everyone else.
That's the issue. Why is Congress divided so much??? The Dem blame game and the fact that they can't/won't take responsibility for their actions.
So, when are you going to start talking the issue and not Cheney - he ain't the issue here.
Obama chose to rely on wishful thinking rather than a coherent policy. Late last year, Iraqi PM Maliki requested that Obama authorize air strikes against ISIL. Obama didn't do it. I can understand why he would be reluctant to order air strikes because it would make it look like we were taking sides against the Sunni. Still, Obama did nothing. Shortly thereafter, Deputy Assistant secretary Brett McGurk warned Congress that ISIL was growing stronger and was positioning itself to threaten Iraq. Early this year, McGurk's warning was echoed by General Michael Flynn of the Defense Intelligence Agency and he added that the group would likely make a grab for land.
Two months later, ISIL captured Fallujah and then subsequently Mosul. Obama can say that he wasn't sure what to do about all of this and sat on his hands but it is disingenuous to say that it took US intelligence by surprise.
With regard to current efforts, they are ineffective and this shouldn't take Obama by surprise either. All experts agree that you cannot defeat ISIL with an air war, therefore, a growing coalition of nations supplying aircraft is a waste of effort and money without ground troops. There are no ground troops available.
In Syria, there are hordes of Sunni rebels fighting to topple Assad. They are fighting in the corridor between Aleppo and Damascus. Although many of the rebels don't particularly like ISIL, they're focused on Assad and are likely to accept any help they can get even if it comes from ISIL. We, however, are bombing Raqqa to degrade ISIL but Assad has the only ground troops that are likely to take advantage of any loosening of ISIL's grip. Although anti-Assad Arab states are part of the coalition to bomb Syria, nobody else wants to do it because it's a rather clear violation of international law to bomb inside another country unless invited in or approved by the UN. Obama only wants to give arms to Sunni rebels that he is confident won't give/sell the weapons to ISIL. So far, that's just the Free Syrian Army (FSA) but the force has been decimated and will take some time to build up to even 5,000 fighters. Not that long ago, Obama said expecting the FSA to fight Assad/Iran/Hezbollah was a fantasy. Now it's the foundation of a strategy that has them fighting a two-front war against Assad/Iran/Hezbollah and more than 30,000 ISIL fighters.
In Iraq, the Iraqi army has disintegrated. The Sunnis have defected to the Sunni rebellion, apparently draining off a significant number of soldiers we helped train (which BTW probably helps explain why the Sunni rebellion has taken a third of Iraq). No other country is likely to put boot on the ground if we are not willing to do so. After all, this whole problem stems from toppling Saddam when others cautioned us not to do so to avoid exactly the circumstances in which we find ourselves.
ISIL was prepared to be bombed and can easily decentralize. Plus, ISIL is not only holding ground, it's gaining ground. ISIL can attract fighters by showing that it's standing up to the combined air force of the US, Arab states, and Europe. This is the wrong message. Obama needs to stop hoping for miracles and fight this to win. Send in ground troops and crush ISIL now, without getting involved mired in Syria.
That's how people usually miss the bus.
Obama can deflect all he likes. I held Bush accountable and I'm doing the same thing for Obama.
Send in ground troops and crush ISIL now, without getting involved mired in Syria.
Good plan and strategy. As soon as I see the upper 1% and politicians offer to sacrifice their sons and daughters on front line duty solely to protect corporate assets (like the Mosul dam) then maybe I'll support US ground troops to combat the ISIS....maybe.
And too many positions are needlessly lost.
And your endless, pathetic attempts to keep Obama squeeky clean of being a human are disgusting.
ISIL is a non-discriminatory organization and will attack us without regard to whether we're in the top 1% or bottom 99%. ISIL targets dams and electric plants etc because controlling these kinds ofresourcesgives them control over the population. If you want to prevent control,then you deny them the asset.
It's a volunteer military. If called, they go.
Of course. They have the technicians to operate the dam and a banking legal team backing them.
After that, they will forcibly take over a few ships and invade America. Sounds logical to me.
What's your point? Not related to the thread.
Probably in the same proportion that the bottom 1% go to Harvard. It's a volunteer army. If you don't want to fight, don't volunteer.
I'm not following what you're talking about but, if you're suggesting that we can only be attacked by an invading army, then al-Qaeda has already disproven that assumption.
John - you keep saying your nose isn't up Obama's butt and that you have definitely said "improper" things about him.
I've done a lot of searching and can find no, zero, none, nada, zilch, uuhh uuhhh, nothing to support your claims.
Give us - all of us - just ONE link where you have said something "improper" about Obama. If you can't, which I doubt, then STFU about how you don't always agree with him.
Well, one could ask you-- to your knowlege,have a lot of the "ninety-nine -percenters" volunteered to fight for America in the middle east ?
Have a large proportion of the "economy challenged" volunteered to go fight in the Middle East?
As far as I can remember, there has never been an attack by Islamist terrorists invading by boats! The assasination of RFK? the two attacks on the World Trade Center (You do remember there were two entirely separate attacks...??) Fort Hood? The Times Square Bomber? The shooting at LAX? The Underwear bomber? The Boston Marathom bombers? etc, etc. None were exactly "naval invasions"!
Quite possibly-- either that or some people in the organization just have a lot of "financial smarts":
Actually it's a profound statement that who controls the energy sources controls the society that depends upon them. Only recently has solar energy made inroads to refute that statement. I'm sure that Arkansas Hermit can provide another solution, but other than people such as the Amish, and (some) hippies, are willing to go back to pioneer lifestyle.
During WW2, it didn't matter if one were a 1%er or otherwise, people signed up and put themselves in harm's way. Now, many decades later, will citizens volunteer if the country came under attack as it did in WW2? Or will such an attack be labelled "workplace violence"?
Well, if they don't get it on their iPods/iPads/iPhones, they'll never know about it, nor will they have to get off the couch.
In his interview Obama said "THEY" underestimated; not "we."
But when bin Ladin was killed he took the credit for "GM is alive and bin Ladin is dead."
Is this the kind of childishleadership America deserves?
"What I don't understand is why the Arab states don't take the lead in dealing with this situation."
It's because they're fucking cowards.
We had a draft for men only during the Vietnam war and lost.
Perhaps a blend of the two can work."
Draft or volunteer, we have the best military in the world and completely irrelevant if you don't know when and how to use it.
Of course the counter to this is that al Qaeda in Syria's goal was to oust Assad. (If they really wanted to retaliate against the U.S, they would move elsewhere, not Syria. Sunni al Qaeda was there to fight Shiite Assad , and the a faction that was more extreme decided they wanted a caliphate, and named themselves ISIS. (Islamic State in Syria). After getting rid if the Shia 'heretic" (Assad" they wanted not only to replace it with a Sunni stat, but a theocratic one as well.
The problem with US Intelligence is that it is a joke. To wit:
The Ten Biggest American Intelligence Failures - From Pearl Harbor, to 9/11 to today, the US intelligence operations rate near zero.
Seven Biggest Intelligence Failures Under the Obama Administration - Consider that this president is taking advice from intelligence that have proved themselves as consistently wrong,
September 11 and the Adaptation Failure of U.S. Intelligence Agencies - A research report from UCLA
The CIA and the Culture of Failure - Book review.
Intelligence Failure in Iraq - What else is new?
Maybe we should outsource our spying operations to Israel. A failed president who has an obsession for Assad, a failed (and massively expensive) intelligence operations and a top heavy pentagon that is practically married to the profit motivated military industrial complex, all spell trouble to America and its citizens who will be saddled with this debt and a growing Arab world that hates us.
The situations in Iraq and Syria are quite different. The Sunniresistance to Assad really had no bearing on our decision to removeSaddam and it's our removal ofSaddamthat set the stage forthecurrentinstability. If Saddam were still in power, sectarian violence probably couldn't have spilled over into Iraq from Syria because the Iraqi Sunnis would have no reason to revolt against Saddam who, himself, was Sunni. The current Sunni Iraqi revolt is against a Shia-dominated government that took Saddam's place.
To me, this has nothing to do with arms dealers and corporate interests. As you note, we are in the midst of a clash of cultures. Given the internet and globalization, our values will come into conflict whether we like it or not. Extremism is, in large part, a violentresistance to the erosion of Islamic values. I get that but I can't stop the world from turning and neither can they. ISIL cannot be allowed to establish a terrorist state and use all the oil wealth under its control todestabilizethe rest of the world either through attacks or market manipulation. Al-Qaeda has proven what terrorists can do and ISIL would be able to do much more than that. This is likeEbola. It poses no direct threat to us right now so why should we deal with it? Because it's a deadlydisease thatspreads and we need to deal with it before it gets to us.
I prefer to stay out of other people's business unless their business negatively affects mine. Syria has no affect on us and I would not get involved in trying to topple Assad. As long as there is war, there will be war profiteers. That has no bearing on whether I think we should go to war. As for who sold us the original fraudulent bill of goods on Iraq, the "bill of goods" was bad intelligence. You seem to think the bad intelligence was cooked up by war profiteers. Maybe but it can also come fromtheintelligence services of other countries. Now which source might that be? You can eliminate the European nations who urged us to exercise restraint. Cross out the Arab countries that cautioned us not to invade. Iran hated Saddam but we don't use their intelligence so you can cross them out too. So which country is left that stands to benefit from Saddam's removal and is also a country on whom we rely for intelligence in the area?
Joining ourselves toIsrael, a colonial oppressor, is one of the primary reasons theyhateus.
Cheney, Cheney, Cheney, Cheney
What the hell does he have to do with Obama's screw-up and his current intelligence botching?
Considering that countries like America and Canada are run by independant and substantial governments, then why do they support Israel? Let's guess what you're going to say. How about: The votes of less than 2% of the voters make a huge difference in an election. Or, AIPAC and its Canadian counterpart own us. Or, Netanyahu is the tail that wags us dogs. Or, we cannot possibly win an election without Jewish money. Or. the Hollywood Jews promised they'd put us in the movies. Or, free speech means the Jewish-owned media will crucify us if we don't. Or, some of our best friends are Jews. Or, all the Jews who are in control of the world's banks will call our loans. Or, any combination of the above.
Just remembered, even Australia has come on board with us, and for sure India will too.
By the way, it's not quite kosher to post a quotation ADDING YOUR OWN WORDS TO IT. It can be misleading, intentionally so.
This same independent country supported slavery,institutionalizedracism,the forced removal/decimation of Indian tribes, and South Africanapartheid. Plus, few raised an eyebrow when TimeMagazinenamed Hitler man of the year in 1938. It took a while but we came to our senses. Jews of conscience oppose Zionism so opposing Israel is notequivalentto opposing Jews.
I have no idea what you're talking about.
Me too but I'm not going to let a mad dog attack me just because I don't like the ticks that he carries.
And George Soros supports them.
Don't confuse them with the facts Gunny.
Funny you should bring him up. He dropped SodaStream as part of the BDS movement to prevent investment in companies that sustain the Israeli occupation and settlements. He is now a Jew of conscience.
He was also a self-admitted Nazi collaborator as a teenager in 1944.
Soros = Scum
He was just 13 or 14, accompanyingsomeone who protected him by pretending to be his godfather. The man was tasked with inventoryingproperty that was being confiscated and the boy followed him around. If he were now blindly supporting Israel, this "scum" would be praised for deceiving the NAZIs.