In ancient Egypt, women had the same status as men and were treated equally. My, how far we have come. Good for Ms. Watson. I agree and she's right on target.
I wouldn't think so. "Allowing" means that a greater someone is giving permission to a lesser someone to do something. By giving a bunch of old men, the Pentagon, the power to 'allow" women to serve, we are acknowledging that women need permission from men to do something and only serves to reinforce the notion that women are lesser than men.
In my mind, it should just be. "Allowing" shouldn't be necessary.
I think she did a beautiful job and expressed herself wonderfully. I also happen to like the term "Gender equality". I think it expresses the concept better. Not something to attain, but granted from being human.
That's a reasonable question. She did an excellent reading about the topic but are those her own words? Landing Ms Watson was a coup for "HeForShe" campaign as she is articulate and passionate...but then again, she is an actress.
I think a better question might be-- does she truly believe in what she said? Is do you think she is actually opposed to gender equality? If those are indeed her ideas but she used a speech writer to help her express her ideas more powerfully than she could (in a way that would better get through to audiences)-- why would it matter?
I don't know-- did FDR write his famous "a day that will live in infamy" speech (Pearl Harbour) himself? How about some of Churchill's moving speeches? Did MLK write his "I Have a Dream Speech" himself? How about the Gettysburg Address?
If those were genuinely their ideas-- would it matter is they had a speech writer take them and express them better than they could? Or is that even relevant....???
Women in the US have the right to vote. There was a time when they couldn't (did you know that?).
African Americans used to be "property" (slaves). Certainly you must be aware of that?
And even after they legally got the right to vote-- in many Southern counties they couldn't. They were forced to go to segregated schools. They couldn't eat at lunch counters that were "Whites Only". This existed in the U.S.-- this was not only Apartheid South Africa:
Have you ever heard of: Indra Nooyi? Meg Whitman? Mary Barra? Virginia Rometty? Irene B. Rosenfeld? Ursula M. Burns? Denise M. Morrison? ( Link )
How often do you see ads like this today:
Children's book:
Do you really believe these changes are so bad-- that the way things were in the past are so much better?
The better question would be how much was she paid to do this?
Lincoln wrote his own speeches, but I digress. Getting an famous actor to support your cause, which I'm sure Watson does, helps things. The Scientologists do it all the time.
Her message was just, her speech was well delivered and it got the attention it deserved by having someone famous speaking it.
Son of Harry Krishna: It was only well into the 1980s when women were no longer considered chattel to their husbands - in the state of Connecticut. It was lawful to assault one's wife until then (I have forgotten the exact date that a woman could have her husband arrested, sorry)
I did not mean to give the impression that women have full equality yet. We still have a long way to go in the U.S. -- and in many ways its even worse elsewhere. What I was trying to say is that, as slow as it is, the overall trend is that things are getting better. IMO to say that things have gotten worse for women over time is totally false and misleading. (And defending ancient Egypt? Well, I really find it strange to defend a society in which slavery was practiced-- and considered to be OK).
Getting an famous actor to support your cause, which I'm sure Watson does, helps things. The Scientologists do it all the time.
One of the things that annoys me is not so much that celebrities endorse things (not only causes but various products) but rather the fact so much of the population thinks a product (or cuse) is superior because a famous person endorses it.
Just because a person who was born with a great singing voice, athletic abilities, etc ensorders a dedorant or a particular brand of any product-- what makes people think they are any more astute than, say, your next door neighbour-- or aunt? And many of these people are total assh*les in their personal life.
Some people are sincere. I believe Angela Jolie does a lot of good work promoting good causes? And in terms of money-- some famous people have done lot for worthwhile causes-- in some cases not making money from it, in fact even contributing large sums of their own money.
Some people do a lot of good work, but some people negate it because they have money-- are the bashers just jealous of these generous people? (Bill Gates, Michael Bloomberg and Bill gates come to mind).
Among the 526 characters from the French films, there were zero female leads or co-leads."
WTF? Do you read New republic often? If so, no wonder you're so misinformed about so many things!
Top 100 actresses of French Cinema
I suppose new Republic never heard of Anouk Aimee, Brigitte Bardot, Anabella, Mirielle Bain, Juliette Binoche, Daniele Darrieux, Catherine Deneuve, Jeanne Moreau-- just a few I noticed while quickly perousing the list....
Celebrity endorsement is a valid topic for discussion in itself. It has also to do with being ideal role models. For example, if Justin Bieber were to endorse something I'm sure I wouldn't buy it.
Interesting. NPR just had a broadcast about women characters in video games, their portrayals of women being rape or abuse victims or evil sex objects.
W need to change our ideas about women and men, we need to teach our children better than this.
We definitely have a lot of work to do!
The fact is, there's been a lot of progress. And-- its also true that we have a long way to go!
BTW, if anyone didn't recognize that list of names I posted-- here's the complete list-- they are all CEOs of major corporations!
Having so many women in such high positions of power would have been unthinkable not so long ago (and those n the list are not merely top management-- they are all the top boss in their firms0:
In April 2014, Barra was featured on the cover of Time ' s "100 Most Influential People in the World." [5]
_________________________________
Mary Barra's GM Pay Could Top $14 Million, Putting Her in the Big Three
Periodically, public outrage pops up over the lavish pay packages of corporate executives. Last week was one of those timeswith an unusual twist: General Motors ( GM ) faced criticism based on allegations that Mary Barra, its new chief executive officer and the first woman to lead a U.S. automaker, wasnt being paid enough. It was, for a brief time, cited as evidence that the gender pay gap persists, even at the highest echelons of corporate America.
The numbers seemed flawed from the get-go, as Bloomberg Businessweek s Sheelah Kolhatkar made clear, since they didnt include stock awards tied to company performance. On Monday GM released further details to make it clear that Barra will be quite well paid: She could make as much as $14.4 million this year.
True things are true-- a significant number of women have high ranking positions (some even being the top boss) in some major corporations-- and are earning big bucks. And: overall they are still greatly under-represented, and overall there is still a significant pay gap from men.
In ancient Egypt, women had the same status as men and were treated equally. My, how far we have come. Good for Ms. Watson. I agree and she's right on target.
Who does the 'allowing'?
The Pentagon?
I wouldn't think so. "Allowing" means that a greater someone is giving permission to a lesser someone to do something. By giving a bunch of old men, the Pentagon, the power to 'allow" women to serve, we are acknowledging that women need permission from men to do something and only serves to reinforce the notion that women are lesser than men.
In my mind, it should just be. "Allowing" shouldn't be necessary.
The world could learn a lot from Indian culture.
Kudos to Emma Watson.
Great one, Grump! To the point and precise
Did Emma Watson write the speech?
I was being sarcastic. I should have put a sarcasm tag on that comment. We have gone backwards these last 5000 years.
Do you expect Ambivalent to know the answer to that question?
I think she did a beautiful job and expressed herself wonderfully. I also happen to like the term "Gender equality". I think it expresses the concept better. Not something to attain, but granted from being human.
That's a reasonable question. She did an excellent reading about the topic but are those her own words? Landing Ms Watson was a coup for "HeForShe" campaign as she is articulate and passionate...but then again, she is an actress.
Agreed Kavika!
I think a better question might be-- does she truly believe in what she said? Is do you think she is actually opposed to gender equality? If those are indeed her ideas but she used a speech writer to help her express her ideas more powerfully than she could (in a way that would better get through to audiences)-- why would it matter?
I don't know-- did FDR write his famous "a day that will live in infamy" speech (Pearl Harbour) himself? How about some of Churchill's moving speeches? Did MLK write his "I Have a Dream Speech" himself? How about the Gettysburg Address?
If those were genuinely their ideas-- would it matter is they had a speech writer take them and express them better than they could? Or is that even relevant....???
Women in the US have the right to vote. There was a time when they couldn't (did you know that?).
African Americans used to be "property" (slaves). Certainly you must be aware of that?
And even after they legally got the right to vote-- in many Southern counties they couldn't. They were forced to go to segregated schools. They couldn't eat at lunch counters that were "Whites Only". This existed in the U.S.-- this was not only Apartheid South Africa:
Have you ever heard of: Indra Nooyi? Meg Whitman? Mary Barra? Virginia Rometty? Irene B. Rosenfeld? Ursula M. Burns? Denise M. Morrison? ( Link )
How often do you see ads like this today:
Children's book:
Do you really believe these changes are so bad-- that the way things were in the past are so much better?
The better question would be how much was she paid to do this?
Lincoln wrote his own speeches, but I digress. Getting an famous actor to support your cause, which I'm sure Watson does, helps things. The Scientologists do it all the time.
Her message was just, her speech was well delivered and it got the attention it deserved by having someone famous speaking it.
I did not mean to give the impression that women have full equality yet. We still have a long way to go in the U.S. -- and in many ways its even worse elsewhere.
What I was trying to say is that, as slow as it is, the overall trend is that things are getting better. IMO to say that things have gotten worse for women over time is totally false and misleading. (And defending ancient Egypt? Well, I really find it strange to defend a society in which slavery was practiced-- and considered to be OK).
One of the things that annoys me is not so much that celebrities endorse things (not only causes but various products) but rather the fact so much of the population thinks a product (or cuse) is superior because a famous person endorses it.
Just because a person who was born with a great singing voice, athletic abilities, etc ensorders a dedorant or a particular brand of any product-- what makes people think they are any more astute than, say, your next door neighbour-- or aunt? And many of these people are total assh*les in their personal life.
Some people are sincere. I believe Angela Jolie does a lot of good work promoting good causes? And in terms of money-- some famous people have done lot for worthwhile causes-- in some cases not making money from it, in fact even contributing large sums of their own money.
Some people do a lot of good work, but some people negate it because they have money-- are the bashers just jealous of these generous people? (Bill Gates, Michael Bloomberg and Bill gates come to mind).
WTF? Do you read New republic often? If so, no wonder you're so misinformed about so many things!
I suppose new Republic never heard of Anouk Aimee, Brigitte Bardot, Anabella, Mirielle Bain, Juliette Binoche, Daniele Darrieux, Catherine Deneuve, Jeanne Moreau-- just a few I noticed while quickly perousing the list....
LINK
Celebrity endorsement is a valid topic for discussion in itself. It has also to do with being ideal role models. For example, if Justin Bieber were to endorse something I'm sure I wouldn't buy it.
We definitely have a lot of work to do!
The fact is, there's been a lot of progress. And-- its also true that we have a long way to go!
BTW, if anyone didn't recognize that list of names I posted-- here's the complete list-- they are all CEOs of major corporations!
Having so many women in such high positions of power would have been unthinkable not so long ago (and those n the list are not merely top management-- they are all the top boss in their firms0:
First on the list is Mary Barra:
True things are true-- a significant number of women have high ranking positions (some even being the top boss) in some major corporations-- and are earning big bucks. And: overall they are still greatly under-represented, and overall there is still a significant pay gap from men.
5 % is NOT a big pay gap . That is the latest estimate from the govt .