Israel vindicated by UN damage assessment in Gaza
Dan Smith
http://bit.ly/1p5CB94 , August 24, 2014
An analysis of the damage assessment data collected on the Gaza War by the UN Office of Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (which has never been biased in Israels favor), confirms that Israel attacked Hamas targets in a restrained manner:
*Israel did not retaliate by rote against Hamas systematic attacks on civilian targets; Israel bombed areas which harbored Hamas missile launching grounds and facilities, command posts, terrorists homes and hideouts, operational bases, weapon inventory and tunnels.
*Most of the damage concentrated in very limited areas of 25 square meters of less, while most of Gaza was not damaged at all or in a very limited manner. Less than 5% of Gaza was hit by The Israel Defense Forces.
*The most populated areas of Gaza City, Jabaliya, Khan Yunes, Rafah and Deir el-Balah were disproportionally-undamages: damaged in a very limited way or not damaged at all.
*The areas highlighted by the UN damage assessment report are compatible with the Israel Defense Forces briefings on the location of Hamas facilities, especially in the Shujaiya area, which was the arena of the most intense battles.
*While Hamas concentrated its terror facilities systetmatically and deliberately targetting Israeli civilians in densely populated urban areas in Gaza, the vast majority of these urban areas were undamaged.
*Israel demonstrated exceptional efforts to minimize collateral damage by urging civilians to evacuate ahead of bombings, thus forefeiting the surprise effect guided by security requirements and not by retaliatory or political expediency.
*Israel followed surgical bombing tactic and not carpet bombing. The attacks were not random nor indiscriminate.
*Most of the Israeli bombing hit areas which housed multiple tunnel entrances and shafts, as well as launching sites for mortars and missiles and other terror-related infrastructures.
*15% of Hamas rockets and mortars were short, hitting civilian targets inside Gaza.
http://www.israpundit.org/archives/63599737

Thank you for playing.
Now would you please, please, please:
SHUT THE FUCK UP
There are rules of war.
There are combatants who follow the rules of war, to varying degrees. The data supports the assertion that the IDF carried out its offensive in a manner that showed unprecedented restraint.
The data also supports the assertion that Hamas deliberately placed their civilian population in danger.
I was very confident that this was the way it went. The information, presented by a UN commission, gives me comfort to know that Israel still conducts itself in a morally superior manner, EVEN during war.
Those victims cannot come back, and it is a shame, and unnecessary, and terribly tragic. But the blood of those people is on Hamas' hands.
Yes Israel is held to a totally different standard than Hamas, as Flame has pointed out.
I completely disagree with every point you've made in this post.
All evidence points contrary to the statements you've made.
Have a nice day.
And yet this group who claims to fight FOR the Palestinians still uses them.
So I guess Israel should lay down and take it. Wait,Maybe they should use the same crude rockets...wait, no they are too inaccurate and would probably hurt and/or kill even more civilians. Then you would be even more upset because they would probably hit targets that are civilian, and that actually aren't being used by Hamas as for military purposes. So tell me, Israel should wait until _______ of it's own people are killed to respond, and respond in _______manner. (please fill in the blanks)
Thank you for your take.
Your assessment is overly simplistic, as the report, with accompanying maps, shows conclusive data displaying Israel's restraint, by those more familiar with the terrain than you or I.
The 3 kilometer distance from the Israel border is of importance, because much of this territory is a DMZ. These are the staging areas for the Hamas rockets, as they deploy as close to the border as possible. Israel did not go deep into the territory, as many would like you to believe.
The bottom line is that the killing was disproportionate and against a people who were defenseless from the attack.
And again, the bottom line is that Hamas deliberately made this happen. This UN report corroborates that fact. It is Hamas that is responsible for this senseless number of casualties.
I also think that Israel has a bit more pull with the UN than Hamas.
Plus the UN and the West are scared shitless by Hamas so they are circling the wagons.
You're bound to get it right when you put these 2 thoughts together.
Which on is it, flame?
Flame that is the funniest thing I have read in a long time.
I'm not sure what Israpundit is looking at but the latest UN report says that the damage to Gaza (public and private infrastructure) was unprecedented. I see no statements in the report like those listed above.
There's no debate, nor an attempt to debate the amount of destruction.
When the UN gangs up on Israel, we have to take them seriously, because that would be a moment that the 3rd World has chosen to gang up on Israel. They're going to boycott the produce, so Israelis will have all this cheap chicken and squash.
When the UN agrees with Israel, its legitimacy must be challenged because, well, they're agreeing with Israel.
Read first ---> Assessing The UNs OCHA Gaza Crisis Atlas 2014 Report
The UN report itself is called; The Gaza Crises Atlas . --note, it is in .pdf and is a large file with graphics.
Please. Obama, the United States Government and the terrorists themselves prefer ISIL.
You call that thinking ? LOL !
"Well it would be if Hamas killed them; but it was Israel that did it."
Bullshit. Hamas knew damn well they would be killed by THEIR (Hamas') actions. By your logic if I put a bomb under your chair and it killed you, it wouldn't be my fault as long as someone else pushed the button to ignite it. Even if they only pushed the button because they thought the bomb was in a empty building they were trying to demolish.
"If you think otherwise then I'll tell you what, give the jets and bombs to Hamas and let them kill their own civilians."
Ridiculous, you and I both know this is a Hamas strategy to gain support. Try to get as many innocent people killed as possible. You know what? there are many stupid enough to fall for it, so they keep doing it. Does this make it any more excusable than if they pull the trigger themselves? I think not.
Perhaps you can find the link to the actual UN document
The link I provided leads you to this site. Just the same, people "underclick" where these links are concerned.
2 takeaways from the link:
The main population areas were "disproportionately undamaged".
"While it is indeed upsetting that many uninvolved have been killed, the lopsided portrayal of the IDF attacks onGaza is disingenuous. Israel has said from the get-go that it is targeting terrorists, and the spatial distribution of the damage points (from this third party source) proves the IDFs claims of targetedattacks on terrorist infrastructure, whether they are in fields or in the middle of a neighborhood hijacked by Hamas."
I did not derive any joy from civilian fatalities. Hamas apparently did.
Aeon-- The maps are on the UN website; the "assessment" in the link is not. Unless I'm missing something, someone took the objective data off the UN website and then "interpreted" it to conclude that it vindicates Israel. That would then be the interpreter's opinion, rather than an assessment by the UN.
OK how about a building full of terrorists instead of an empty building. Now it is much more realistic than yours. If you are trying to argue the response of Israel is harsh, you have an point. When you try to argue that Hamas is not responsible for the deaths of people who's backyards it fires rockets from, you will get just that, An argument.
Wow that was an awful long dodge. Answer the question. What is acceptable damage in your opinion, before action is taken and what, in your opinion, is an acceptable response? Try to keep in mind you run Israel, as this question was put, and you know how the weapons are getting in and that if you don't deal with it, the violence continues.
OK so 16 deaths per million would be acceptable to you, the other part of the question is how do you respond? They have killed more than 16 of your people, or people per million. What you gonna do about it?
Anyone who includes an LOL! in their "thinking" should not be surprised when it is not taken seriously , my ears notwithstanding ...
Ah. So just go in and take hamas members to jail. That should work to ease tensions /s/.
I was just quoting your silly-ass comment ... Duh .
LOL! The obvious problem with your plan is that all your actions would strengthen Hamas as they rule Gaza. But never mind that. Hamas will not have you building stuff in their domain. It is also the flaw with your comparison as Patraeus was not building up a community ruled by his enemies. He knew that a government would be installed , and that the US would have plenty to do with it. Gaza is an entirely different situation. So in response to your efforts Hamas kills your social workers installing the parks and infrastructure. It is hard to build shit with people shooting at you. Now what do you do.
The problem here is that Hamas does not want peace, so there will be no peace regardless of what we or anyone else plans until there is no Hamas. The only solution is to get rid of Hamas.
"Israel chose to pull the triggers and drop the bombs; they did not have to.
They chose to because they felt like they had to do something."
It's no longer a matter of choice if it's done out of necessity to save the lives and peaceful existence of its own citizens. That's where your logic fails, flameaway. If you start shooting at me, I'm damn well going to try to stop you, even if you hide behind your wife and children.
Sometimes you don't need to kill people to destroy their lives. You try running to a bomb shelter with 15 seconds warning of a siren almost daily for a few years and see what it does to you. Get real, if you're capable."So an Israeli citizen is four times more likely to be killed in a traffic fatality than as a result of terrorist attack.
Tell me, when are Israelis planning on blowing up their cars and making them unlawful to use?"
Ha ha ha!!!! There it is again - the gun fanatic's argument for countering gun control.
Not only do they not want peace, they've codified that they don't want peace.
"...though there is dispute as to whether these facilities had Hamas equipment and arms in them or not."
In light of the UN's own confirmation of the fact are you denying the truth of their findings?
Thanks for being a "useful idiot" to their cause ...
"I also think that Israel has a bit more pull with the UN than Hamas."
Your statements are becoming hilarious, flameaway. My goodness what people say when they're desperately stubborn. Hamas are Palestinian and the UN considers Gaza Palestinian, and considering how disproportionate the UN's resolutions have been concerning Israel (Remember the UN translator who got caught making a comment about that?) you have the fucking nerve to say Israel has more pull with the UN than Hamas? Now I KNOW your comments are scatterbrained.
I've come to the conclusion that arguing with flameaway over this issue is the biggest waste of time any of us could have. He will spin you around in circles but won't accept any logic or real facts from anyone. He has the Goebbels' ability to keep repeating the same crap over and over again thinking he will convince someone to believe his viewpoint.
Given the UN's historic predilection of taking what some perceive as an anti-Israeli stance on all issues concerning Gaza, I found the title of this thread; "Israel vindicated by UN damage assessment in Gaza" to be rather startling.
The first link I posted was from the "original source" which the OP's article had. The second link I provided (also from the "original source") contained the actual UN report titled; The Gaza Crises Atlas.
The UN report, heavy on graphics, provided no conclusion, which means it's wide open for interpretation. What the OP showed is one persons interpretation of the UN data, which in my opinion, at best, was amateurish and hardly conclusive.
You can accept or reject the interpretation based on your own criteria.
The gun fanatics in meeting the arguments of gun control advocates always use the argument that there are more deaths by auto accidents than by guns, so automobiles should be banned.
The Goebbels reference had nothing to do with Nazis, it was because of his statement about repeating lies until they are believed. I would never call you a Nazi - you're too nice a guy.