The Right to Refuse Service
We have all (orsome of us) have seen the signs that read
No shirt, No Shoes, No Service
We Reserve the Right to Refuse Service to Anyone
Pull Up Your Pants or Do Not Come In
Screaming Children Will Not be Tolerated
Etc
We also are all aware of civil rights that protect people from discrimination for specific reasons.
Do you think the above reasons for refusing service are valid?
The reason for this article is a sign I saw last evening in an email
Is this a reasonable request by the owner?
If you think it is or is not, please tell us why.
Also if you have a humorous sign regarding service or refusal of service, please feel free to share it but please do not include discriminatory signs regarding race, gender, religion, etc.
Thanks in advance for your participation
Tags
Who is online
86 visitors

When is it okay to say "we reserve the right to reserve service ........"
cerenkov
Thanks for the feedback and perspective
Good point
One that I've seen frequently is:
"In God we trust-- all others pay cash"
I can see the one about no shirt, no shoes, no service. To me, that just addresses a dress code for the restaurant.
There is a restaurant here, a very unusual one, on the river-- Mike Lennig's-- that require all the men to wear sports coats and ties. If someone doesn't have a coat and tie, they bring them a bright blue one, so that people can remain in their dress code. This is a very unusual restaurant, as the waiters dress in long coated tuxedos, but it is located in a graveled woods, in tents, and people eat off picnic tables. I haven't been there in years-- but the food is good. It's across town, and the traffic makes it about an hour's drive.
I don't think I'd eat at this particular restaurant, because the signs seem to be hostile. It's funny to see signs like this and then be waited on by someone from Bosnia, say, and they speak a sort of over-pronounced English/God-Knows-What gibberish.
Dowser
Thanks for the feedback and the perspective
I think I also would look for another place to eat or shop if I saw this sign, but it seems somewhat reasonable that the native language of the owner and workers be the language of commerce in the establishment, though as it is pointed out above that could hurt business.
I have seen places that require credit cards or exact change for purchases as the money goes directly in a safe because of robbery concerns - some would say that creates hardship as well.
There are a couple of spots around here that have unspoken/unwritten dress codes - an upscale winery nearby has a very fancy (and expensive) restaurant and a caf - which are actually side by side in a single large room separated only by a service area for the staff. In the caf the dress is more casual and in the restaurant it is jackets with ties and dresses. We go there quite often and guests are seated based on how they are dressed and I have never heard anyone complain or make a fuss.
Here's a sign I would not mind seeing and a policy that once enforced might cause some behavioral changes in parents
When you refuse service based on a pre-condition, it's sort of like pre-censorship (you don't kick people out after they've done something, you prevent them from entering based on their looks or language). In today's world, we can easily tolerate well-advertised conditions for refusing service, because it will not be very "good for business". In general, the public has lost its patience for the rationalizations ("if he don't speak English, I ain't communicatin' with him") used by those who would discriminate against their guests, friends, neighbors and co-workers.
Businesses should beallowedto discriminate as long as their practices are clearly posted and advertised. They can be satisfied serving a smaller community of like-minded customers. Just don't expect their suppliers, bankers and credit-card servicers, advertisers and more broadly-based businesses to cooperate. Maybe some common trade-marks can be developed that businesses could display to identify themselves.
A business should have the right to refuse service for any reason or no reason at all. I'm glad we still have all male country clubs. Sometimes it's nice to get away from the cackling hens.
Dean
Well that is a perspective - I am not sure that there are that many "male only" country clubs any longer - The Augusta National and St Andrews now have female members for example.
So long as there is not a discriminatory basis (race, religion, sex, color, sexual orientation, etc) for the service refusal but rather one based on social standards (e.g. no shirt no service) a business owners should be able to refuse service
Sometimes it is the customers who are discriminatory: "Please do not seat us near the loud and drunk rabble".
RIO,
Check the spelling of "service" in the headline.
The "When ordering, speak English" began in Philadelphia in 2006. At the time, I wrote the following in a local newspaper :
This might be a bit of a surprise coming from a liberal like myself but it's not only about whether an entrepreneur who operates in the public space has the right to refuse providing service.
If a refusal is based on health-related issues, by all means refuse service, not just because it's bad-for-business. If it's based merely on style or taste-preferences in dress/appearance, I'd say "no," the 14th Amendment should (pardon the pun) -- COVER that.
"Screaming children," I'd equate that with otherwise boisterous, unnecessarily loud or rowdy behavior; although a child-is-a-child-is-a-child, assuming the child is with a parent, the parent, IMO, should leave the premises with the child until the child stops screaming. Paying the check if the child doesn't stop complicates the matter.
"We Reserve the Right to Refuse Service to Anyone," sorry NO! If my wife i.e. is wearing her Star of David necklace and the entrepreneur is anti-semitic can she legally be refused service, either overtly, or, simply because "We Reserve the Right to Refuse Service to Anyone"?
What if the customer is hearing-impaired and communicates in "sign"?
A Mac
Sorry about the typo and thanks for the catch- I fixed it
Thanks for sharing your article - I agree that a person cannot be refused service because they are Jewish (your example) or gay, or black, or female, or disabled because that is discrimination and it is illegal and I also agree that the owner of a business may require that customers order in English in order to be served (so long as that is the only reason service would be refused)
Thanks for the detailed feedback - always appreciated
Agree
The question was primarily about the requirement to order in English to be served, assuming no other discriminatory practice was at play
Look at it in reverse. What if European and Asian countries implemented a no European or Asian laugage, no service...We'd see Americans screaming to high heaven.
This owner, IMO is being an asshole. But that's his right.
Probably not good for business.
No. We are not an only English speaking country. We have no official national language and are not likely to ever have one. If the owner or server can not understand the language being spoken, then pointing and gestures usually get the job done. I have had no trouble ordering food in restaurants or at markets when the owner spoke only Russian or Spanish. The owner of this establishment is foolishly turning away profitable customers. Horrible business practice and model. Do they have the right to? I don't think so. However they certainly are stupid to.
I can see the one about no shirt, no shoes, no service. To me, that just addresses a dress code for the restaurant.
And violates many local health laws.
Exactly, Cerenkov which is why "for any reason" is a "NO". "ANY reason" allows the proprietor to simply tell the individual he/she is being denied service simply because he/she (the proprietor) reserves that right.
In reality, NO, no business that operates in the public space reserves such a right.
I have been ignored to the point of being refused service in France, due to my inability to speak French - pretty much the same thing.
Americans do complain about it but that changes little
Whenever I travel - I have a phrase book or have mastered basic phrases to order food, hotel, get a taxi, but things say thank you and etc.
Once you give it an effort it helps.
I agree it is his right and that he is likely an a-hole and that this is not going to be great for business.
Randy
That has nothing to do with the situation which is whether a proprietor can require that business be conducted in English
Also true
Yes I think they do
Also likely true
Geno's Steaks is a Philadelphia restaurant specializing in cheesesteaks , founded in 1966 by Joey Vento . Geno's is located in South Philadelphia at the intersection of 9th Street and Passyunk Avenue, directly across the street from rival Pat's King of Steaks , which is generally credited with having invented the steak sandwich in 1933. [ 1 ] The cheesesteak has since become a signature dish for the city of Philadelphia. After Joey Vento's death in 2011, restaurant ownership was passed to his son Geno Vento. [ 2 ]
History
According to Vento, the name 'Geno's' was chosen because 'Joe's Steak Place' was already in business. He improvised the name from a broken door on which someone had painted 'GINO' and modified the spelling to prevent confusion with a regional fast food chain called Gino's . Vento later named his own son Geno, who now works in the family business. [ 3 ]
Geno's was awarded Best of Philly for Best Takeout by Philadelphia Magazine in 2000. In April 2004, a branch of the shop opened in Citizens Bank Park , the home of the Philadelphia Phillies . This location was closed in 2006 and replaced with Rick's Steaks (operated by Rick Olivieri, grandson of Pat Olivieri , founder of Pat's King of Steaks).
On August 23, 2011, 71-year-old owner and founder Joey Vento died of a heart attack . [ 4 ]
Description
Geno's menu is very similar to that of Pat's. [ 5 ] Geno's claims to have sold up to 4,500 sandwiches daily. [ 5 ]
The walls, roof, and interior of Geno's are decorated with memorabilia and hundreds of autographed and framed photos of celebrities who have eaten there.
Vento was a supporter of the family of murdered police officer Daniel Faulkner . The family supports the death sentence of Mumia Abu-Jamal , who was convicted of Faulkner's murder, and publicly opposes the movement for the retrial or exoneration of Abu-Jamal. Geno's has sponsored several fund-raising events in support of Faulkner's family, including the 2000 First Annual Justice for Daniel Faulkner Block Party [ citation needed ] and an annual Daniel Faulkner Memorial Motorcycle Run. [ 6 ]
English sign controversy
A sign on Geno's window gained press notoriety in 2006, during the immigration controversy. [ 7 ] The sign reads: "This Is AMERICA: WHEN ORDERING Please "SPEAK ENGLISH"." [ 8 ] The Philadelphia Commission on Human Relations filed a discrimination complaint, arguing that Geno's violated the city's Fair Practices Ordinance, which prohibits discrimination in public accommodation, by "denying service to someone because of his or her national origin, and having printed material making certain groups of people feel their patronage is unwelcome." [ 9 ] Vento had previously said the signs are directed at the Mexican immigrants in the surrounding neighborhood. [ 10 ]
Vento said that no one has been refused service for not speaking English, but said, "If I can't understand you, you might not get the sandwich you thought you ordered." [ 9 ]
The Philadelphia Commission on Human Relations found probable cause that the sign is discriminatory. The commission says the sign could make non-English speakers feel unwelcome or discriminated against. [ 11 ]
Vento enlisted the aid of the Southeastern Legal Foundation, a public-interest legal organization. [ 11 ] In 2006, the Foundation had defended a bar owner cited by the Ohio Civil Rights Commission for a sign reading "For Service, Speak English." That case was settled when the owner removed the sign. [ 12 ]
Responding in an interview with Fox News analyst Neil Cavuto , Vento stated that he does not turn away any customer, and therefore does not discriminate. He also vowed to keep his sign displayed no matter how much pressure he receives. He explained to Cavuto that his parents had to learn English when they came to the U.S. He said that if his customers order in any other language, he'll give them Cheez Whiz on bread. Vento posed some rhetorical questions: "If one goes into a Puerto Rican neighborhood, how many signs would be seen in English?" and "When one is on the telephone , it may say press 1 for English, press 2 for Spanish; but where is the number for, say, Italian or Korean?" [ 13 ]
On March 19, 2008, Philadelphia's Commission on Human Relations ruled that the restaurant did not violate the city's Fair Practices Ordinance. [ 14 ]
Six
Thanks for all the info
I find this sign offensive for a number of reasons, but chief among these is that anyone incapable of speaking English will probably also not be able to read the sign, which is written in English. So what is it's point, really?
I'd like the sign better if it was written in a number of languages -- e.g., English, Spanish, French..., and read: "We're sorry, but the workers in this restaurant are all monolingual and only speak English. You may be unable to communicate your order if you don't also speak English -- and may like to bring an English speaking friend with you next time you come around."
James
Then it would be a newsletter and not a sign
No real need to be rude and crude in your perspective
What if he got here yesterday?
Obviously the sign is for the benefit of the customers able not only to read English but to appreciate its patriotic symbols.
I agree with BF. This is a really poor business decision on the part of the owner.
International tourism is a $200B a yearindustry in the U.S. So if the tourist from Germany, China, Finland, etc etc can't speakEnglish he can't eat there...Not very smart on the part of the owner.
No real argument from anyone that it is a bad business decision in that it costs the business sales dollar.
It should also be obvious that the proprietor may not care if the individual "got here yesterday," and would deny service merely on the language basis.
Responding in an interview with Fox News analyst Neil Cavuto , Vento stated that he does not turn away any customer, and therefore does not discriminate. He also vowed to keep his sign displayed no matter how much pressure he receives.
And there goes his tourist dollar right out of the window. Terrible business idea.
The jingoism (bluster and bravado) in his sign might be a touristattracter.
Only for right wing American tourists. IMHO. It will drive non-American tourists away and if I were still a hotel General Manager I would advise my foreign, non-English speaking or who are not fluent in English guests not to go there because of a hostile environment to non-Americans.
Have you ever tried speaking English in Miami ? It can be the same thing .
When in Rome.....
I recall that during my first trip to Dallas I and some friends went to the Traildust Restaurand which served absolutely wonderful huge steaks - I was able to finish my two-pounder. I guess I missed a sign on the door because I was told I could not eat there unless they were permitted to cut my tie and hang it on the wall (with hundreds of others). Fortunately I was not wearing a Georgio Armani $100 silk one so the remnant of my tie might still be there.
Although both English and French are dual official languages in Canada, if you happen to be eating in a fine restaurant in Quebec City and try to order in English, the waiter will call you an "Anglais-tete" meaning "English head" (considered to be a derogotary term). However, the food there is worth tolerating the insult.
Philly is a international city. There is bound to be people on vacation who don't speak English. Talk about bad business practices.
The only place I have ever ran into this kind of arrogant discrimination was Paris and it happened many times. I always make an attempt to try and speak the language of the country I am in, but the Parisians are particularly rude about Americans speaking their language. At the Musee D'Orsay, I was told that the restaurant was "complete" (full), when I asked the young woman for a "table pour quatre". The place was quite obviously not complete, so I repeated my request.. and she ignored me. I went and got the Maitre D and he apologized and yelled at the young rude woman and sat us promptly.
Another time we were in a restaurant and the waiter was speaking English to Germans and only French to us. I happen to speak German and asked the Germans if they wanted him to speak English to them. They said no, but he didn't know German. They asked why I asked and I said because he will only speak French to us. They laughed and said to me in German that the Parisians don't like Americans and in any case, he was an "Arrogant Scheisse Kopf", which of course he was. When it came time to pay the bill, we left no tip. Now most Americans don't know that tip is included in a meal in France and so they leave the usual 15%. I really would have preferred not to leave him a bloody dime, but it is included. The kicker to the story is that suddenly he could speak English... 'Where is my tip", he barked at us. Oh you can speak English now, I said... good understand this, you arrogant SOB, we are smart enough to know that the tip is included, even for a rude waiter like you.
Now turn those tables around, and be a visitor here and have that happen to you. At least in France there is a national language and I found their behavior rude. Here we don't have one, and I find that sign rude.
But he has the right to have it up so long as he is spelling out his terms of service.
The French cannot be surpassed for arrogance. They wanted French to be the international language, but lost out to English, so they will display their displeasure at their language being snubbed very openly. You have seen it in Paris, and I have seen it in Quebec.
Buzz
Interesting feedback and perspective thanks for sharing it with us
Perrie
Thanks for the detailed perspective and feedback
Good points
I have been to Paris several times and totally agree that
It is also a given that business will be lost
There is much disagreement in and out of the courts on this one, but I tend to agree with your point that
Cerenkov
It is good that we have choices to make as to where we spend our money
Buzz
Most of my time in Canada has been spent in Ontario (in and around Toronto) and I find the people to be most friendly and helpful
I have heard of some issues as you describe in Quebec
Really it is always bad business to refuse service. Where I work if I have someone I don't want to provide service to I simply price it accordingly. Either they will go somewhere else or it will be worth my while to put up with their BS. I really don't know why everyone doesn't work this way. If you don't want to bake a cake for, or photograph a gay wedding just tell them the price is double or triple what everyone else charges. If they ask you why the price is so high (or even higher than your advertised price you can just say something like "we find that gay people require a higher service level than many of our other customers so we price it accordingly, and offer a special package for our gay patrons". Prove/disprove that in court!
Personally I think an owner of a private small business should be able to refuse service for any reason, like I said it is bad business and they probably won't be in it for long if they do this and there are other ways of getting your way other than straight up refusal. So I think it is simply a bad idea in general.
Another angle on it would be the question as to whether the non-English speaker has any means of ordering what she wants. If the menu is in English and the staff all speak English exclusively, what are they gonna do? Being incapable of communication can't be anyone's fault in such a situation (especially regards the newcomer or visitor). I have heard that there are menus in some places with pictures of the food items on them. Maybe that'd help?
Anyway, the sign is obviously for those who read English. So it is just dumb.
96
I appreciate the feedback and perspective
A couple of questions/points
Couldn't that be discriminatory and illegal in some instances? In the case of the business in this article, are you suggesting that non-English speakers pay $5.00 for a hamburger and English speakers pay $3.00? Really?
I am not a lawyer or a legal scholar (perhaps someone who is will chime in), but that statement sounds blatantly discriminatory against a protected class. Just my opinion of course.
So long as refusal of service is not based on a bias against a protected class, refusal of service would seem legal in my opinion, but I agree it is bad business, as it purposely turns away revenue.
Of course it would, in some businesses. Obviously in a restaurant this wouldn't work but in many businesses it will. In my examples of photography and baking a cake prices vary depending on the "package" of bundled services. For the cake example size and what you want it to look like will vary the price.
However for a restaurant maybe you could use my favorite reason of all (from the movie "hamburger") :
BTW in my business there is not a set price for most items, just "suggested list". If I am quoting only hardware to a pain in the butt I quote list, if they want services bundled the price goes up drastically from there.
Well maybe you are correct, the statement of reasoning for the higher price still seems patently discriminatory to me.
Thanks for the back and forth
Actually, I have been in Quebec City and found them to be very nice. But years ago, when I went there as a teen, they were not. I think they have grown to be an international city.
I must admit that I have not been to Quebec City for at least 30 years, so if it the residents have changed, I didn't know it.
Robert... there's a similar sign in a coffee shop in Hurley, WI. The espresso comes with a "free puppy".
Eva
Either option would scare a parent
Dear Friend RIO: In all matters culinary, Jay's Diner is way out ahead of the Vanguard.
Anyone who obeys the law, and pays gets service.
Jay's even target markets to populations segments under served. They outreach.
Their daily specials tell this story well.
Saturated Fat Sundays: 15% off any meal served to anyone with 85% or more arterial blockage. Spiced suet crowning melted cheese over whatever you order, then deep fried to a golden ash.
Moribund Mondays: Buy any entree, get the second of equal or lesser value discounted 50% with proof both diners have been deceased for at least fifteen years.
Terrorist Tuesdays: A blue plate special of internal incendiary fare. This includes re-fried beans, baked beans, raw cabbage, hot Jalepeno peppers, beer and soda. All for $3.99. Any magician who can eat this, lie on their back and self levitate gets the meal free. Be the first at your table to go boom!
Woe-be-tide Wednesdays: All patrons on whom the sun of good fortune never shines get one meal free if they pay 250% of another meal of equal cost.
Thirsty Thursdays: During non-happy hour, all drinks are double priced. All foods heavily salted.
Frail Fridays: If the check weighs more than the patron, the price isn't affected in any way. This offer void where prohibited by law. Good while supplies last. Some ingredients settle during shipping and eating. Do not pass water, do not collect any tip left for a server.
Stripper Saturdays: 20% deducted from the total for anyone who takes off one fifth of their clothing.
See you there next Saturday.
Enoch.
Dear friend Enoch
Your feedback and perspective always puts a smile on my face and wisdom in my head
Thank you and peace and happiness to you
Dear Friend RIO: As to you and yours.
Enoch.