How to beat the preachers of hate
(CNN) -- It is likely that radical cleric Abu Hamza -- who was found guilty on terror charges by a New York federal jury this week --- will now spend the rest of his life in a U.S. top security prison while his victims will gain some succor from the fact that he is finally behind bars.
However, merely stopping high-profile extremist preachers is not enough if the threat they represent is to be confronted. Much more needs to be done to challenge extremist narratives, ideas and propaganda if we are prevent the next generation of extremist preachers from emerging.
There was a time, during the 1980s and early 1990s, when individuals would rarely become radicalized without direct contact with an extremist preacher of some description.
In this context, preachers such as Abu Hamza became highly significant as recruiters and propagandists. Their ability to tailor the al-Qaeda worldview to young and impressionable audiences in Europe and North America allowed them to target a generation of Muslims born and raised in the West.
However, even though many key extremist preachers have now been arrested or deported -- such as Omar Bakri and Abdullah Faisal -- extremist narratives are still being disseminated and reaching their target audiences.
The fact that an estimated 400 British citizens are believed to have traveled to Syria to join jihadist groups suggests their efforts are having some success.
In tackling extremism we need to ensure universities and colleges are not hosting extremist preachers without providing a robust challenge to their views. We need to ensure prisoners are offered mentoring and support to turn their lives around, making them less susceptible to recruitment within prisons. Online extremism also needs to be challenged with counter-arguments; this could be done through websites and social media accounts that confront the extremist narrative. A recent Quilliam report further details how this can be done.
Arresting key individuals or shutting down extremist websites -- as some European governments propose -- are not long-term solutions to this problem. Extremist narratives only lose their appeal when they are undermined and thoroughly discredited; when the debate is opened up and won by their opponents, rather than being shut down and lost.
We need to enter the realm of ideas and pitch more positive and enlightened values against extreme and regressive arguments.

The hell with that crap. I prefer the Robert Mitchum solution.
Dear Friend Larry Hampton: Thanks for a great article. I agree with, and strongly support your conclusion.
E.
If it were only that simple.
:^|
Thank you Enoch. One of the links provided in the article is particularly pertinent for many of us bloggers...
...very interesting and useful info.
That's why we are losing.
There was a time when America illustrated it's values by not backing down from a fight or coming too silly conclusions about why our enemies hate us.
Killing such radical preachers would only add to their mystique and feed to the myth of afterlife rewards for martyrdom . I suggest low level CO poisoning ... Just enough to remove the edge from their thinking processes. A living zombie does not inspire much followership .
That's what I've been saying about the gang-bangers. Kill them. Put teams on the streets where they keep returning to in order to do their drive-bys and the minute a suspicious looking vehicle slows down and a gun barrel can be seen sticking out the window, pepper the vehicle with gunfire.
No quarter. Kill them. It's the only way to stop the murders of children and other innocent bystanders.
The last time I tried to tell a girl how her body affected me I was disabused of the concept of "freedom of speech" .
Freedom of speech was tainted when so many wanted to arrest and jail the preacher who wanted to burn Qurans.
I suspect you mis-read the article, BF-- the article as posted proposes exactly the opposite...
I was about to say the same thing, swammi. Countering them is probably the best way to handle this.
Also those who make excuses for radical Islam should be countered. Colonialism isn't what did it. If it was, then we would have over half a billion Hindus going on jihad.
There is NO 'excuse' for extremist militant terrorism. Colonialism barely touched the ME as compared to the exploitation in India, Africa & the New World. Further, the ME states are generally bloated w/ massive oil profits, which kind of undermines the whole concept of 'suffering under colonial expoitation'.
We should, however, continually stress that it is militant violence and/or terrorism that we are taking a stand against-- not 'Islam' per se. A large part of the strategy of the militant clerics is to frame their attacks in the context of 'the West/Christianity versus Islam', stoking a religious conflict. Broad-brush statements that 'Islam is the problem' play right into the hands of the ME propogandists, giving them further 'ammunition' to recruit the young, the impoverished & the gullible.
The 'struggle' is NOT about 'the West' versus the Middle East; it's not about Christians versus Muslims--- it's a fight of people who desire to live with peace & tolerance against people who want to thrive on violence & terrorism, regardless of where they come from or how they pray. The Koran isn't the important issue-- it's that AK that's the problem...
(BTW-- take a close look at the pic w/ this article. Is is just me, or does that dude look amazingly like Orson Welles in drag???)