╌>

Palestinian groups Fatah, Hamas announce accord that could threaten Mideast peace talks

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  larry-hampton  •  12 years ago  •  60 comments

Palestinian groups Fatah, Hamas announce accord that could threaten Mideast peace talks

JERUSALEM Rival Palestinian political factions Fatah and Hamas on Wednesday announced a reconciliation deal that could lead to the formation of a unified government , raising significant new obstacles to further negotiations between Israel and the Palestinians.

Fatah and Hamas have announced similar accords previously, only to see them fall apart, but the latest announcement drew swift condemnation from officials in Israel, which considers Hamas a terrorist organization. The Obama administration said the tentative deal which could lead to a unity government by the end of May was disappointing.

~link~


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Larry Hampton    12 years ago

This could seriously complicate our efforts not just our efforts, but the efforts between the parties more importantly to extend the negotiations, State Department spokeswoman Jen Psaki said.

Psaki called the timing of the announcement troubling. It came days before the expiration of Secretary of State John F. Kerrys deadline for an outline of peace deal and could be a spoiler for Israeli and Palestinian discussions this week about ways to keep the talks going.

The ball is in the Palestinian court to explain how the proposed unity government would work and what effect it would have on talks with Israel, Psaki said.

At a news conference in the Gaza Strip, Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh and senior Fatah official Azzam al-Ahmad, a representative of Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas, said the two sides had fulfilled a national responsibility to reach an agreement.

 
 
 
Enoch
Masters Silent
link   Enoch    12 years ago

Dear Friend Larry Hampton: Peace is not everyone's agenda in that part of the world. If it were, it would have happened decades ago.

E.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Enoch, true.

Abbas hedging his bets only reveals his hand...actually Hamas' too.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

If their primary purpose in life is to hate and to war against Jews, why would they ever in this world want peace? They throw out "conditions" that they are convinced will not be met by Israel then blame Israel for not wanting a peace.

I would like to hear a reporter ask some of the Palestinian people, "If peace were declared between Palestine and Israel today, what would you do when you wake up tomorrow morning?"

The hatred of Israel is needed in order to keep them from turning on each other.

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    12 years ago
"...threaten peace talks." A headline that surprises no one. they don't want peace, they want a total and complete surrender of the Jewish people.
 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

The Obama administration said the tentative deal which could lead to a unity government by the end of May was disappointing.

Now I'm really confused . Also , how does Fatah accept Hamas ... they should want their heads on a platter after the blood bath Hamas pulled before their election .

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Bingo; both factions have such weakened positions that they recognize the need to unify, or continue to slide. Both fatah and Hamas have lost quite a bit of their citizens support on the street; and, it's no wonder.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Larry Hampton    12 years ago

I agree completely Mimi, Israel has acted as a buffer for the Arabs, for a long time. If it wasn't for Israel, they most likely woulda wiped each other out.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

The Palestinians are not interested in peace; they are interested in justice. Israel maintains a neo-colonial occupation of Palestine, forcing the Palestinians into the West Bank and Gaza. Rather than letting the Palestinians return home (a solution I favor), Israel is dragging out negotiations over an independent Palestinian state while simultaneously reducing the viability of any such state by spreading Jewish settlements over the available land. Fatah controls the West Bank; Hamas controls Gaza. Neither side represents the other so it makes sense for them to join forces for a unified approach. Otherwise, any deal struck by Fatah may not be recognized by Hamas. The fact that the US and Israel think Hamas is a terrorist organization should not be used to negate the fact that Hamas is the elected representative of the people of Gaza.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

The Palestinians are not interested in peace; they are interested in justice.

That is one of the primary reasons that there is no agreement. Israel is interested in peace for themselves and the region. The Palestinians have proven time and again that they will use violent means to further their goals. It is written in their charters.

Israel maintains a neo-colonial occupation of Palestine, forcing the Palestinians into the West Bank and Gaza.

You can give the occupation any label you like; Israel has complete control of the land by virtue of their victory over the kingdom of Jordan in 1967. They annexed the territory, period.

Rather than letting the Palestinians return home

There is no home for the Palestinians in Israel. They left. They lost war after war attempting to conquer territory that was granted to Israel via UN Resolution #189. That's Israel's land. These surrounding nations attacked Israel and the UN's Resolution. The land is Israel's. "Home" is used here in a rather subjective manner, to put it mildly.

Israel is dragging out negotiations over an independent Palestinian state

One of the reasons that this debate often becomes chippy is because there is clearly blame to be laid at the feet of both parties for various stalemates. Here, the poster lays blame on stalled/failed negotiations squarely and completely at the feet of Israel. This is what we refer to as a "non-starter". The poster completely omits/redacts the myriad stalling tactics of the Palestinians, including the times they completely walked away from negotiations. While it's occurring in real time, we take note of the Fatah/Hamas "reconciliation". Hat's off to them; they belong together. One incites to violence, the other out and out perpetrates it. But the poster ignores this, and swings his bias completely to one side.

while simultaneously reducing the viability of any such state by spreading Jewish settlements over the available land.

Again, the poster does not separate those settlements that are legal versus illegal and earmarked for destruction. Israel evacuated nearly 10,000 settlers from Gaza in 2005 in order to clear it for Judenrein Palestinian territory. BTW, that was done without negotiations. It was done as an act of good faith. All it got was more than 10,000 rockets, and a shell-shocked civilian population within striking distance. But only one side suffers, as the poster continues:

The fact that the US and Israel think Hamas is a terrorist organization should not be used to negate the fact that Hamas is the elected representative of the people of Gaza.

Israel, the US, and the EU, and many other nations across the world do not THINK that Hamas is a terrorist organization; it IS a terrorist organization, and there is ample evidence to support that fact. Just because the Palestinian people elected them does not mean that Israel and the world need to subject themselves to the same abuse that the Palestinians of Gaza have chosen. This is the centerpiece of the stillborn nature of the Palestinian movement. Their very existence is contingent on struggle. And again the world and the poster blames Israel.

When the victim card is dropped from the deck, there might be a chance of something positive taking place. Until that time, Israel will place the safety of its people above everything else. And when people stop making excuses for the failed movement, perhaps it will look to stand up on its own and create a fresh narrative - one that doesn't include the destruction of a neighboring nation.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Larry Hampton    12 years ago

The Palestinians are not interested in peace; they are interested in justice.

If that were true, they would not elect terrorist organizations to run their government,or represent them. It's like hiring a burglar to gaurd your safe.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

That is one of the primary reasons that there is no agreement. Israel is interested in peace for themselves and the region. The Palestinians have proven time and again that they will use violent means to further their goals. It is written in their charters.

There will be resistence as long as Israel continues a colonial occupation.

You can give the occupation any label you like; Israel has complete control of the land by virtue of their victory over the kingdom of Jordan in 1967. They annexed the territory, period.

And the resistence to occupation will continue, period. I note that there are as many Palestinians as Jews and their number is growing. There are also 300 million Arabs in the surrounding countries. If Israel wants to fight until the end of time or until they are destroyed, then fine by me but I think it would make more sense to follow South Africa's example . . . end apartheid and have one nation where differences can be resolved at the ballot box. Jews do not have an inherent right to a Jewish dominated state.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

There will be resistence as long as Israel continues a colonial occupation.

Yes, that is a prevailing opinion in the Arab world; they will somehow outlast the Jewish people. That may or may not be true, but whatever the case, they do not take into account Israel's resolve. Never have. They thought suicide terrorism would expose their weakness. It did not. They fought, and continue to fight a propaganda war with Israel. Fact is, all ashore that's coming ashore. Those lines are drawn. Waste of time. They think that BDS will crack the Jewish State. But business remains brisk.

Jews do not have an inherent right to a Jewish dominated state.

It was created with that intention, and as such, that right remains, and shall remain in perpetuity. You and any number of Arabs can repeat that all you want. It will not change the facts. You also provide cover for other countries that have Muslim dominated states that will remain as such. In fact, 4 of them are so named as Islamic Republics.

If you are interested in learning anything here, it would be helpful to take this home:

When the 2 parties sit down and complete a negotiation, this issue will be resolved. History has shown over and over again that it is the Palestinians who are the intransigent party.

Arafat walked away, but you excuse that.

Abbas walked away, but you excuse that, and somehow blame the other party.

Why you ignore that is beyond my scope of comprehension.

To you, it's always Israel's fault. It's always Israel's responsibility to cave. It's always Israel's responsibility to compromise her safety. It's always Israel's responsibility to agree to preconditions prior to a negotiation. What use is there in negotiations if the store is given away before the sale begins? What did Israel get for handing Gaza back to the Arabs, besides thousands of rockets. They extended their hand and gave back territory without asking for anything, and that's exactly what they got. Nothing. And you think that your "analysis", which completely ignores history, is somehow the "solution" to all that ails the conflict.

 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   Swamijim sez    12 years ago

...political factions Fatah and Hamas on Wednesday announced a reconciliation deal...

Would it now be proper to refer to the 'unified Palestinian front' as Fat-ass?

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

"Jews do not have an inherent right to a Jewish dominated state."

Oh yes they do.

San Remo Anniversary

Today in History

The Middle East keeps making the headlines. The carnage in Syria, the weekly violence in Iraq, the political instability in Lebanon, the uncertainty in Turkey, the threat posed by Iran in the region, all seem to take a backseat to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and the perennial pursuit of the peace process. A lasting peace seems like a chimera chased by indefatigable peace processors U.S. Secretary Kerrys initiative being the last one in a long line of failed attempts since 1993.

When the resolution of a complex problem hits a stalemate repeatedly and almost predictably since its inception, the smart thing to do is to revisit the fundamentals, long forgotten in the past twenty years of diplomatic frenzy. A look back at recent history is essential.

Ninety-four years ago today, on April 25, 1920, the Supreme Council of the Allied Powers (Britain, France, Italy, Japan and the U.S. as an observer) gathered in San Remo, Italy, and ruled on the disposition of the Middle East territories previously held by the defeated Ottoman Empire, after having heard the claims of both the Zionist Organization, headed by Chaim Weizmann, and the Arab Delegation, headed by Emir Faisal, at the Paris Peace Conference of 1919.

The San Remo Conference was a momentous event in that it drafted the map of the Middle East as we know it today: Over 97% of the land was adjudicated to the Arabs, which resulted in the creation of the new exclusively Arab states of Syria, Lebanon, Iraq and, later, Jordan. The geographic region known as Palestine was designated as the Jewish National Home, to bereconstitutedthere in consideration of thehistorical connectionof the Jewish people to the land.National rightswere exclusively granted to the Jewish people collectively, while the non-Jewish people of Palestine were granted individualcivil and religious rights. These were the terms used in the San Remo Resolution later confirmed in the Mandate for Palestine (1922) and approved by the 52 members of the League of Nations to highlight thepre-existing rightsof the Jewish people to the Land of Israel, hitherto known as Palestine since Roman times. These documents, and the ensuing Franco-British and Anglo-American treaties that were separately signed in the early 1920s, are based on the Mandates System stipulated in the Covenant of the League of Nations and are therefore binding to this day under international law. The acquired rights of the Jewish people to the land west of the Jordan River are preserved in the UN Charter and in the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, even though the Mandate for Palestine expired in 1948 when the State of Israel was proclaimed.

The usual detractors of Israel regularly ignore, dismiss or strongly reject the validity of the provisions listed above. But their arguments ring hollow:

They claim that the Supreme Council of the Allied Powers had no authority to create a new political entity in Palestine. They forget that in the wake of World War One, the same Supreme Council created new countries in Europe (Yugoslavia, Hungary, the Baltic States and a reborn Poland) on the ashes of the German and Austro-Hungarian Empires.

They claim that a Jewish home in Palestine was not intended to be in all of Palestine. Had they read the full text of the Mandate for Palestine, they would find 15 instances of the phrase in Palestine which cannot leave any doubt as to the inclusion of the whole territory.

They claim that the purpose of the Jewish National Home mentioned in the Mandate was not to lead to a sovereign Jewish state. Here again, they are most selective in their singling out Israel, because not only all the neighbouring Arab states were created through the same Mandates System, but even Mandate territories in far less developed areas in Africa and elsewhere became sovereign states in the second half of the 20thcentury, such as Cameroon, Togo, Benin, Rwanda, Burundi, Tanzania, Namibia, Papua New Guinea and Samoa.

But among all Israels detractors, the Palestinian Authority showed a particular animosity against San Remo. A document issued on April 25, 2011, by WAFA, the official press agency of the Palestinian Authority, shows that[San Remo] is the root of all Palestinian catastrophes and sufferingsand bashes the San Remo Resolution as the work ofZionist gangs.

Now is the time to give precedence to factual evidence over biased opinion. On this 94thanniversary, we should remember that territorial claims on Palestine were finally settled at the San Remo Conference. Diplomacy should not be forever divorced from international law.

Salomon Benzimra, P.Eng.

Canadians for Israels Legal Rights CILR

As well, it seems to me that the UN declared Partition using the words "a homeland for the Jews". In my opinion the "occupiers" are in fact the Palestinians, rather than the Israelis.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

If that were true, they would not elect terrorist organizations to run their government, or represent them. It's like hiring a burglar to gaurd your safe.

It's nothing of the sort. To them, Hamas is not a terrorist organization but rather an organization resisting an Israeli occupation.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

Yes, that is a prevailing opinion in the Arab world; they will somehow outlast the Jewish people. That may or may not be true, but whatever the case, they do not take into account Israel's resolve. Never have. They thought suicide terrorism would expose their weakness. It did not. They fought, and continue to fight a propaganda war with Israel. Fact is, all ashore that's coming ashore. Those lines are drawn. Waste of time.

I don't know about outlasting the Jewish people but they can outlast Zionism. Recognizing resolve works both ways. Arabs can have as much resolve to regain their land as Jews had to take it.

It was created with that intention, and as such, that right remains, and shall remain in perpetuity. You and any number of Arabs can repeat that all you want. It will not change the facts. You also provide cover for other countries that have Muslim dominated states that will remain as such.

Colonialism is wrong regardless of intent and people have a right to resist it. And no, Muslim dominated states are not similar to Israel because they were not created by displacing the indigenous people. Israel is more similar to NAZI Germany in its practice of population removal.

If you are interested in learning anything here, it would be helpful to take this home . . .Why you ignore that is beyond my scope of comprehension.

Let me share my equally useful tutorial with you. The Palestinians walk away because what they are offered is a South African style Bantustan rather than anything that approaches an equitable distribution of land. Why do I blame Israel? Because Israel created this mess by pushing people off their land!

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

First of all, I reject the notion that the world's colonial powers have the right to give away other people's land. Colonialism is wrong and people have the right to resist it. Second, even if I were to agree that people can be dispossesed, the interpretaion of the documents cited above is subject to interpretation. I side with the"detractors". Third, among other things, the position in favor of Israeli domination omits UN Resolution 273 which recognizes the Palestinian rightof return to their homeland. Finally, this problem will never be resolved as long as two groups claim exclusive control over the same postage-stamp size piece of land. Let the Palestinians return home and make it one nation. One man, one vote. Resolve your differences at the ballot box like everywhere else on earth.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

And no, Muslim dominated states are not similar to Israel because they were not created by displacing the indigenous people

LOL.

Tell that to the Kurds.

And while you're at it, tell it to the Armenians.

And of course, tell it to the 800,000 Jews who lived in Islamic countries until 1945, when they were expelled. Of course, you conveniently ignored this fact, which effectively negates the bulk of your argument.

The Jews of the Middle East who were expelled from the Islamic countries with little more than the clothes on their back, were absorbed into Israel, and given full citizenship. They were welcomed, unlike their Arab counterparts who placed them in "refugee camps", where they still live today. There are Palestinians that are prevented from intermingling into the population of their "brethren" in Egypt, Lebanon, Syria, Jordan and yes, the Palestinian territories. They are not afforded the same rights, education or self determination that the rest of the population is entitled to. Jews are Jews, no matter where they come from, but apparently, not all Arabs are the same, at least to each other.

The bottom line is that the situation that the Palestinians are in is self imposed. It's not within Israel's control to "liberate" them. It's within the control of the Arab League, and their puppet, Mahmoud Abbas.

Israel is more similar to NAZI Germany in its practice of population removal.

Apparently, your aim was not really to debate me, as this last comment illustrates.

I have no intention of engaging anyone that sees value in this comparison.

Good day.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

Tell that to the Kurds. And while you're at it, tell it to the Armenians.

Most countries in the Middle East were created by dividing up the Ottoman Empire, not by population displacement.

And of course, tell it to the 800,000 Jews who lived in Islamic countries until 1945, when they were expelled. Of course, you conveniently ignored this fact, which effectively negates the bulk of your argument.

It doesn't negate anything. If the Jews wanted to return, I'd support them doing so. Would you do the same for the Palestinians?

There are Palestinians that are prevented from intermingling into the population of their "brethren" in Egypt, Lebanon, Syria, Jordan and yes, the Palestinian territories. They are not afforded the same rights, education or self determination that the rest of the population is entitled to.

All quite irrelevant to the Palestinian right to return.

The bottom line is that the situation that the Palestinians are in is self imposed.

It's not self-imposed; it's the direct result of Jewish colonialism.

Israel is more similar to NAZI Germany in its practice of population removal. Apparently, your aim was not really to debate me, as this last comment illustrates.I have no intention of engaging anyone that sees value in this comparison.Good day.

Population removal is wrong no matter who does it. If you think that it's wrong for Nazi Germany but right for Israel, then I agree that further discussion on this subject is pointless. Good day to you too.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Larry Hampton    12 years ago

What hamas is to them, doesn't changewhat hamas is, which isa terrorist organization. It does however reveal that indeed, some cultures are better, than others. Some bring more value to the table than others. Ya know, like cultures that continue to thrive on death and destruction, even when the most pragmatic of choices, namely to live in peace withtheir neighbors, exists.If the Palestinians gave a rat's ass about being "un-occupied", beingtheir ownstate, they have, and continue to make poor, poor choices for leaders.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

To them, Hamas is not a terrorist organization but rather an organization resisting an Israeli occupation.

What occupation ? Israelis withdrew completely from the entire Gaza strip a few years back . If the were occupying it why don't they have troops stationed there ?

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

Jews were not aliens who came from outer space and "drove the existing population into the sea" (as has been threatened against them), but have been there for thousands of years. There is lots of proof of that so that doubters such as we have seen here now could not argue with it. As well, there are legal rights as have been indicated. So don't give me the shit about colonizing, which is what the English did in Australia and New Zealand and (with the French in) Canada and yes, even the USA.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

I'm referring to the occupation of Palestine, not the occupation of the Gaza bantustan.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Larry Hampton    12 years ago
  • As a strictly legal matter, the Jews didnt take Palestine from the Arabs; they took it from the British, who exercised sovereign authority in Palestine under a League of Nations mandate for thirty years prior to Israels declaration of independence in 1948. And the British dont want it back.
  • If you consider the British illegitimate usurpers, fine. In that case, this territory is not Arab land but Turkish land, a province of the Ottoman Empire for hundreds of years until the British wrested it from them during the Great War in 1917. And the Turks dont want it back.
  • If you look back earlier in history than the Ottoman Turks, who took over Palestine over in 1517, you find it under the sovereignty of the yet another empire not indigenous to Palestine: the Mamluks, who were Turkish and Circassian slave-soldiers headquartered in Egypt. And the Mamluks dont even exist any more, so they cant want it back.

So, going back 800 years, theres no particularly clear chain of title that makes Israels title to the land inferior to that of any of the previous owners. Who were, continuing backward:

  • The Mamluks, already mentioned, who in 1250 took Palestine over from:
  • The Ayyubi dynasty, the descendants of Saladin, the Kurdish Muslim leader who in 1187 took Jerusalem and most of Palestine from:
  • The European Christian Crusaders, who in 1099 conquered Palestine from:
  • The Seljuk Turks, who ruled Palestine in the name of:
  • The Abbasid Caliphate of Baghdad, which in 750 took over the sovereignty of the entire Near East from:
  • The Umayyad Caliphate of Damascus, which in 661 inherited control of the Islamic lands from:
  • The Arabs of Arabia, who in the first flush of Islamic expansion conquered Palestine in 638 from:
  • The Byzantines, who (nice peopleperhaps it should go to them?) didnt conquer the Levant, but, upon the division of the Roman Empire in 395, inherited Palestine from:
  • The Romans, who in 63 B.C. took it over from:
  • The last Jewish kingdom, which during the Maccabean rebellion from 168 to 140 B.C. won control of the land from:
  • The Hellenistic Greeks, who under Alexander the Great in 333 B.C. conquered the Near East from:
  • The Persian empire, which under Cyrus the Great in 639 B.C. freed Jerusalem and Judah from:
  • The Babylonian empire, which under Nebuchadnezzar in 586 B.C. took Jerusalem and Judah from:
  • The Jews, meaning the people of the Kingdom of Judah, who, in their earlier incarnation as the Israelites, seized the land in the 12th and 13th centuries B.C. from:
  • The Canaanites, who had inhabited the land for thousands of years before they were dispossessed by the Israelites.

As the foregoing suggests, any Arab claim to sovereignty based on inherited historical control will not stand up. Arabs are not native to Palestine, but are native to Arabia, which is called Arab-ia for the breathtakingly simple reason that it is the historic home of the Arabs. The territories comprising all other Arab states outside the Arabian peninsulaincluding Iraq, Syria, Jordan, Lebanon, Egypt, Tunisia, and Algeria, as well as the entity now formally under the Palestinian Authoritywere originally non-Arab nations that were conquered by the Muslim Arabs when they spread out from the Arabian peninsula in the first great wave of jihad in the 7th century, defeating, mass-murdering, enslaving, dispossessing, converting, or reducing to the lowly status of dhimmitude millions of Christians and Jews and destroying their ancient and flourishing civilizations. Prior to being Christian, of course, these lands had even more ancient histories. Pharaonic Egypt, for example, was not an Arab country through its 3,000 year history. The recent assertion by the Palestinian Arabs that they are descended from the ancient Canaanites whom the ancient Hebrews displaced is absurd in light of the archeological evidence .

~LINK~

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

What hamas is to them, doesn't changewhat hamas is, which isa terrorist organization.

It's a matter of opinion, not fact. One man's terrorist is another man's freedom fighter.

It does however reveal that indeed, some cultures are better, than others. Some bring more value to the table than others.

. . . and some are simply arrogant.

Ya know, like cultures that continue to thrive on death and destruction, even when the most pragmatic of choices, namely to live in peace withtheir neighbors, exists.

Israel can't expect to take the land by force and then live peacefully on it while the indigenous people live on South African style bantustans.

If the Palestinians gave a rat's ass about being "un-occupied", beingtheir ownstate, they have, and continue to make poor, poor choices for leaders.

We are in no position to lecture anyone else about poor choices in leaders and, in the case of the Palestinians, the leadership really makes no difference because Israel has never had any serious intention of allowing the creation of a "viable" Palestinian state. Living peacefully got them nothing. BTW, if Israel thinks peaceful co-existence is laudable then they wouldn't have taken the land by force and created this mess in the first place.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Larry Hampton    12 years ago

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

Jews were not aliens who came from outer space and "drove the existing population into the sea" (as has been threatened against them), but have been there for thousands of years. There is lots of proof of that so that doubters such as we have seen here now could not argue with it . . .

The overwhelming number of Jews in Israel immigrated from Europe. There has been no significant Jewish population in Israel (Palestine) since they were driven out by the Romans 2,000 years ago. Immigrating from Europe and displacing/dominating the indigenous population is colonization.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

Arabic is a language. All people who speak Arabaic are not descended from inhabitants of Saudi Arabia any more than all people speaking English are Anglo-Saxons. The fact that control of the land has changed hands doesn't prove that the Palestinians weren't there and, even if it did, they were damn sure there when the Jews returned 2,000 years after being pushed out by the Romans.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago
 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Larry Hampton    12 years ago

The fact that control of the land has changed hands doesn't prove that the Palestinians weren't there and, even if it did, they were damn sure there when the Jews returned 2,000 years after being pushed out by the Romans.

So are you saying that Jews didn't also live in this area, before Israel established statehood there? That there were not Jews living in the area of the Levantearlier in the century before statehood? Hmmm?

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

So what!! Jews have been there for thousands of years. Besides, the almost a million Jews from Muslim countries that were forced out of their homes and businesses are in Israel as well now, multiplied by their now extended families, or are you saying they're not Jews? That's not an insignificant number. And who gives a shit WHERE they came from - they're Jews and as far as I'm concerned they BELONG there whether you like it or not.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Larry Hampton    12 years ago

There has been no significant Jewish population in Israel (Palestine) since they were driven out by the Romans 2,000 years ago.

"No significant" as in, second-class citizens...

In 70 CE, the Second Temple in Jerusalem was destroyed by the Roman Empire, effectively ending Jewish rule in the Land of Israel until 1948.

While the Jewish population was not given a decree to leave the land, the conditions, such as the fiscus Judaicus, a special tax imposed on Jews, were grave enough to convince most residents to disperse around the globe.

A Small Community Remains

Still, some Jews did remain in Palestine. Bar Kochba led a small band of Jews in a revolt against the Romans from 132-135 CE in response to the building of the new Roman city "Aelia Capitolina" on the grounds of Jerusalem. While the revolt was met with violent and harsh retributions, by the end of the century, the Romans officially permitted Judaism as a sanctioned religion in Palestine.
When the Christian Byzantines took control of Palestine in the fourth century, many restrictions were put on the remaining Jewish community, from banning intermarriage between Christians and Jews to forbidding Jews from owning Christian slaves. There was talk of banning Judaism outright, but those plans never came to fruition.
Despite its smaller pool of scholars, the rabbinic academies of Palestine were able to complete what is known today as the Talmud Yerushalmi (Jerusalem Talmud). Though the Babylonian Talmud is considered to be the more authoritative work, the Jerusalem Talmud is still one of the most important contributions to Jewish literature.

Life under Muslim Rule

In 638, Caliph Omar conquered Jerusalem from the Byzantines, launching Muslim rule over the territory. While Jews and Christians were considered second class citizens, the amount of direct persecution decreased substantially.
The community in Palestine was fairly quiet during the early Islamic period. A rabbinic academy was formed in Tiberius (and later moved to Ramle) in order to compete, unsuccessfully, with the ten Jewish academies in Baghdad.

Christian Rule: More of the Same

In 1099, Crusaders arrived in Palestine and created a Christian kingdom in Jerusalem that lasted until 1187. The Crusaders banned Jews from living in the city of Jerusalem, though they were permitted to live in the rest of Palestine, and were permitted to visit Jerusalem.
But Christian rule was short-lived. In 1187, Saladin and the Ayyubid dynasty conquered Jerusalem. Indeed, while Christian Europe wanted to establish a permanent presence in Jerusalem and the Middle East, they eventually retreated to Europe after the Muslim recapture of Acre in 1291.

In 1258, Baghdad fell to the Mongols. Fearing a collapse of their empire and wanting to prove their strength, the Muslim rulers imposed harsh sanctions on Jews and Christians throughout the region, including Palestine. These restrictions--including wearing special clothing and doctors not being allowed to serve Muslim patients--were enumerated in the seventh century Pact of Umar, a list of laws concerning non-Muslims living in Muslim lands that had previously rarely been enforced.

~LINK~

Immigrating from Europe and displacing/dominating the indigenous population is colonization.

You are spreading a myth 1ofmany...

The Ottoman Rule: New Opportunities for the Jewish Community

The Ottoman Empire conquered Palestine in 1517 and held it until the empire's decline at the end of World War I. The Ottomans, though practicing Muslims, were much less harsh on the Jewish community than previous Islamic empires and actually allowed them to thrive. The Jewish population in Palestine had exploded in the previous decades with the influx of Spanish and Portuguese Jews who had been expelled during the Inquisition. The Jewish communities in Jerusalem, Tiberias, Gaza, Hebron, Acre, and Safed greatly increased in number during this period.
In Safed, Rabbi Isaac Luria revolutionized Jewish mystical thought and established Safed as the center of Kabbalistic study. Also in Safed, Luria's follower, Joseph Caro, wrote the Shulchan Arukh, which remains the most influential Jewish legal code to this day.
In 1798, Napoleon invaded Egypt. Though he never captured Palestine, the European influence on the Middle East did have positive effects on the Jewish community. A number of reforms in the 19th century led to more rights for Jews, with full citizenship being granted to them (along with all others in the Empire) in 1876.
By the end of the century, after an increase in anti-Semitic incidents in Eastern Europe, Jews started moving to Palestine with the hope of one day creating a Jewish homeland there. This was the beginning of the modern Zionist movement that officially became an organized body with the first World Zionist Congress which was held in Basel, Switzerland in 1897. By 1909, Jewish settlers had founded Tel Aviv, the first all-Jewish city in modern Palestine.
By the end of the World War I, the British had taken control of Palestine as part of the Sykes-Picot Agreement with France in their partition of the soon non-existent Ottoman Empire. This would not be the last political change in Palestine. Conflicts between the Arab population and the growing Jewish population would, in the coming decades, alter the face of the Middle East.

~LINK~

...Jews have always been a part of the indigenous population!

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Immigrating from Europe and displacing/dominating the indigenous population is colonization.

Actually the Jews in that region were granted all of Jordan too under the Balfour Declaration . But they were screwed out of the land east of the river .

Crying about the rights of the Palestinian Arabs is absurd . They are the primary discriminated against group in the middle east . No other country allows them full rights when they are even allowed to move . Egypt won't allow the Gaza strip free access to Egypt . In fact the Egyptians pawned off the strip on Israeli in a peace settlement just so they wouldn't have to deal with that bunch of smugglers and terrorists . But its good you can be so easily manipulated by Arab propaganda . Have you always been this naive ?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

I'm referring to the occupation of Palestine, not the occupation of the Gaza bantustan.

Wow ... so you actually have no knowledge of that region . Thanks for revealing that . FYI Hamas is the group in charge of the Gaza strip . Their only interest in the "West Bank" region is to usurp the leadership from Fatah .
Fortunately for Fatah they have the protection of Israel or they would be decimated by the terrorist Hamas .

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
Your grasp of this is somewhat underwhelming. As I said, I wasn't referring to Gaza so your point escapes me.
 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
I'm saying the Jews were driven out 2000 years ago by the Romans. Whether a small Jewish population existed prior to a mass return is irrelevant.
 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
The Jews were driven out by the Romans 2000 years ago. Some returned much later under Muslim rule and were again driven out by Christian crusaders. This period is generally referred to as the Jewish diaspora. There was no significant Jewish population left until Zionists in the 20th century advocated a return. Why a return? Because they weren't there! The Zionists ignored the Palestinian population and claimed that the land was unoccupied. The slogan to spur a return was a "land without a people for a people without a land." Now they spin the lie the other way and claim that the Jews never left so they really didn't take anything because they already has it. It has become clear to me that They will say anything and do anything to get what they want.
 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
I guess navet works both ways in that you are easily manipulated by Israeli propaganda.
 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

And you are easily manipulated by Palestinian propaganda.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

It doesn't matter a damn what happened 2000 years ago. In THIS century the land belongs to Israel. That's what happens in wars.

If Israel wants to fight until the end of time or until they are destroyed, then fine by me but I think it would make more sense to follow South Africa's example . . . end apartheid and have one nation where differences can be resolved at the ballot box. Jews do not have an inherent right to a Jewish dominated state.

Are you that ignorant or just trying to be ingenious? One nation, and resolving differences at the ballot box is out of the question when it is a given that the majority, which would be Arabs, want to completely wipe Jews off the face of the earth, and in elections would ALWAYS hold the upper hand.

We're talking about Muslims/Islam here, where mothers and fathers think nothing of murdering their own daughters for any number of perceived insults to "family honor" and Islam. They legally hang seven year old children as spies. They stone to death women and girls who have been raped or run away from abusive husbands two and three times their age. It's all legal.

Jews may not have an inherent right to a Jewish dominated state in your opinion, but it is the only way they will survive, and they DO have a right to survive. Bottom line is the state of Israel belongs to them and they can govern it as they see fit for the welfare and survival of the Jewish people.

Throwing away all the argument about whether Israel is entitled to the land they govern, all you have left is the absolute undeniable fact should Israel allow Arabs to gain the majority, Muslims have no qualms or hesitation in passing laws that would mean the end of Jews.

Whether you or the rest of the world feels it is an act of apartheid for Jews to maintain Israel as a "Jewish" state, only a complete fool would deny it is the only way for them to survive. And the truth that any idiot should realize is that no country on this earth will allow the influx of foreign immigrants as voting citizens to the point that the original citizens of that country would be displaced as the majority, losing their style of government, their culture and their ability to worship their chosen religion/s.... except the United States of America, evidently.

You will NEVER see Germany being anything but a country of Germans; Russia being anything but a country of Russians; Japan being anything but a country of Japanese... and on and on. That is the reason countries have immigration laws and policies.. so they can maintain control of who makes up the population. America has lost sight of that, and France and England are regretting their open door policy that has resulted in so many problems with the Muslims who have almost taken over. Even Canada has begun to look more closely at its liberal immigration policy. Israel isn't in actuality doing anything different than the other countries in seeing to it that Jews retain their identity.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

I guess navet works both ways

All you can do is guess . If that's what you want to do have fun . Just don't expect you will be convincing other readers with your uninformed guesses .

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

All you can do is guess . If that's what you want to do have fun . Just don't expect you will be convincing other readers with your uninformed guesses .

Just giving my opinion which is no less worthy than yours.So aslong as you feel free to share your "guesses"I will feel free to share mine.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

I "guess" that is why there will never be a solution to the conflict.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

It doesn't matter a damn what happened 2000 years ago. In THIS century the land belongs to Israel. That's what happens in wars.

The history sets the context for today's struggle so it absolutely does matter. I know the land is occupied by Israel and as long as Israel occupies the land there will be resistence by those that were displaced. That's what happens when a subjugated people break free.

Are you that ignorant or just trying to be ingenious? One nation, and resolving differences at the ballot box is out of the question when it is a given that the majority, which would be Arabs, want to completely wipe Jews off the face of the earth, and in elections would ALWAYS hold the upper hand.

Given the choice, I'll pick ingenious (lol). What is truly ingnorant is rejecting a democratic solution to the problem. Two people cannot have exclusive control over the same land and there are as many Palestinians as Jews. South Africa had some of the most vicious racists on earth (excluding us of course) and they have managed to end apartheidwithout the numerically superior black population exterminating the whites. And so what if the majority has the upper hand? that's what democracy is all about.

We're talking about Muslims/Islam here, where mothers and fathers think nothing of murdering their own daughters for any number of perceived insults to "family honor" and Islam. They legally hang seven year old children as spies. They stone to death women and girls who have been raped or run away from abusive husbands two and three times their age. It's all legal.

A truly stupid and biased comment designed to imply that Muslims are too murderous or subhuman to be trusted with a vote. In any event, one way or another, Palestinians will eventually regain their land. Racists in South Africa figured that out, dismantled the bantustans, and integrated its society. Israel should do the same.

Jews may not have an inherent right to a Jewish dominated state in your opinion, but it is the only way they will survive, and they DO have a right to survive. Bottom line is the state of Israel belongs to them and they can govern it as they see fit for the welfare and survival of the Jewish people.

That is not the only way they can survive. See above.

Throwing away all the argument about whether Israel is entitled to the land they govern, all you have left is the absolute undeniable fact should Israel allow Arabs to gain the majority, Muslims have no qualms or hesitation in passing laws that would mean the end of Jews.

And what Muslim country currently has laws that have put an end to Jews?

Whether you or the rest of the world feels it is an act of apartheid for Jews to maintain Israel as a "Jewish" state, only a complete fool would deny it is the only way for them to survive.

I think only a complete fool would argue that pushing the Palestinians onto South African style bantustans is the only way to survive. This is not a solution but a receipe for endless conflict.

And the truth that any idiot should realize is that no country on this earth will allow the influx of foreign immigrants as voting citizens to the point that the original citizens of that country would be displaced as the majority, losing their style of government,

No country on this earth is currently in the same situation of having pushed the indigenous people out of the country. The last example was South Africa.

You will NEVER see Germany being anything but a country of Germans; Russia being anything but a country of Russians; Japan being anything but a country of Japanese... and on and on. . . Israel isn't in actuality doing anything different than the other countries in seeing to it that Jews retain their identity.

These countries are not similarly situated. None of themare colonial occupations mired in a war of resistence against the indigeous people they displaced. Again, Israel is more like South Africa. Follow South Africa's example, stop seeing the indigeous people as subhuman, dismantle the bantustans, integrate the society, and resolve differences at the ballot box.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

A truly stupid and biased comment designed to imply that Muslims are too murderous or subhuman to be trusted with a vote.

Why is it "stupid" when it is the truth?

While it is true that there are Jews living in Muslim countries who have not been decimated, we are speaking of Palestinians becoming the majority in Israel... Palestinians, who have stated more than once that they desire to wipe Jews completely off the face of the earth.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

And what Muslim country currently has laws that have put an end to Jews?

You must be kidding. Even if they don't actually have written laws, there are a number of Muslim countries that have in other ways forced Jews to leave, usually with all their property confiscated. Try being a Jew in Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Qatar, Yemen, etc. Are you unaware that about 800,000 Jews were forced to leave those countries after Partition? What do you think life is like for the Copt Christians in Egypt? Abbas has already said that not one Jew will live in a State of Palestine. What do you think happens to a Palestinian who sells his property to a Jew? You really ARE naive. No wonder you take the position you do.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

A truly stupid and biased comment designed to imply that Muslims are too murderous or subhuman to be trusted with a vote.

Why is it "stupid" when it is the truth? While it is true that there are Jews living in Muslim countries who have not been decimated, we are speaking of Palestinians becoming the majority in Israel... Palestinians, who have stated more than once that they desire to wipe Jews completely off the face of the earth.

The comment is anti-Islamic dogmatism masquerading as truth. Although somePalestiniansare a bit over the top (as is true with some Israelis), they do not represent the views of the entire voting population. The same animosity was present in racist South Africa and there was no slaughter of the white population when they ended apartheid. Whipped dogs tend to bite so stop whipping them. Share the land. One man, one vote.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

And what Muslim country currently has laws that have put an end to Jews?

You must be kidding. Even if they don't actually have written laws, there are a number of Muslim countries that have in other ways forced Jews to leave, usually with all their property confiscated. Try being a Jew in Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Qatar, Yemen, etc. Are you unaware that about 800,000 Jews were forced to leave those countries after Partition?. . . You really ARE naive. No wonder you take the position you do.

And try being a Palestinian in Gaza. The object here should not be to make each other's lives miseable for all eternity. Instead, it should be to work out an equitable solution. To me, it's simple: share the land. One society. One man, One vote.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Palestinians have no intention of sharing anything with Jews. You cannot work out any type of compromise with a people whose only goal in life is to kill Jews.... not if you are Jewish.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

Obviously 1ofmany is not Jewish, and he is a Palestinian sympathizer who would rather see what happens to the Jews when Hamas is given leave to do what they have always threatened. I see no reason to argue with that person any more - it's not worth the effort.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

The comment is anti-Islamic dogmatism masquerading as truth.

There is no masquerade in anything I stated as it relates to Islam. Or are you saying that all those atrocities, complete with names and pictures, were falsified?

Muslims don't kill their female children for the crime of dating outside the religion? Muslims don't hang seven year old children as spies? Muslims don't force young girls to marry men two and three times their age? A young woman actually did not have her nose sliced off her face as her punishment for running away from an abusive bastard husband three times her age? Muslims don't always blame the female for sexual assault against her person, and stone her to death for her "adultery?"

Wow, all those lies and doctored pictures...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

your point escapes me.

It was a simple point so I'll just repeat it :

Fortunately for Fatah they have the protection of Israel or they would be decimated by the terrorist Hamas .

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Agree with you on this, Buzz.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

I would like to hear a reporter ask some of the Palestinian people, "If peace were declared between Palestine and Israel today, what would you do when you wake up tomorrow morning?"

The answer could be: "I would immediately go out and get a great job that either rescues me from unemployment or pays me 3 times what I make now." (wishful thinking)

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    12 years ago

Israel and the West serve the Arab world and much of the rest of the Muslim world as an excuse for their woleful failures. Much of the impetus behind the resurgent aggressiveness coming out of the Muslim world is the misguided belief that the return of their glory days of conquest and riches will come if only they return to the "pure" Islam of the 7th century and the succeeding millenium.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

On some level you must recognize that you're sterotyping an entire religion based on the actions of a few. Surely, you know that there are hundreds of millions of Muslims who do not engage in these activities. When Rev Jim Jones's followers killed each other and themselves because they thought it was God's will, you didn't holdthe Bible or Christianity responsible. Same goes when a Catholic priest molests an alter boy, or when the KKK cites the Bible as justification for their actions, or when Mormons marry children or engage in polygamy, or when Christian zealots burned women alive as witches, or when the South used the Bible to justify slavery and then casused the deaths of a half million men rather than abolish the practice.

Both religions have their fair share of opinionated and self-righteous imbeciles.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

No wonder it escaped me. Your point has nothing to do with what I was referring to Israel not Gaza or the West Bank.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

I agree completely Mimi, Israel has acted as a buffer for the Arabs, for a long time. If it wasn't for Israel, they most likely woulda wiped each other out.

Actually that's kind of what's happening in Iraq. Northern Iraq is far from Israel's borders (actually Iraq doesn't border Israel at all)-- so since they can't kill Jews there, they are turning on each other.

In fact in all the countries of "The Arab Jihad" (AKA "The Arab Spring"), they are fighting each other because they know that Israelis too strong militarily to confront.

 
 

Who is online

JBB


84 visitors