NYC - Achievement Tests No Longer the Basis for Passing Students to Higher Grade
Looks as if the bad old days of social promotion are returning to New York City public schools.
The de Blasio administration Wednesday scrapped the results of standardized exams as the chief measure for determining promotions in grades 3 through 8.
This is absolutely dumbing down the standards, said Mona Davids, head of the NYC Parents Union.
Undoing one of the major policies of the Bloomberg administration, schools Chancellor Carmen Faria said teachers and principals would now adopt a more holistic approach that relies on everything, including classroom attendance, to determine which students move ahead and which get left back.
Test scores would no longer be used as the primary or major factor in making those decisions, Faria said.
This new way forward maintains accountability, but mitigates the unintended consequences of relying solely on a single test, Faria said.
Education reformers immediately questioned if the city was returning to the days when kids were promoted as they aged, regardless of their ability to make the grade.
It also raised red flags because teachers have a stake in promoting students, since their evaluations are based, in part, on how well those students perform.
Campbell Brown, of the Parents Transparency Project, said promoting kids who arent prepared would be disastrous.
No one benefits from the promotion of a student who is not ready for the next grade level particularly the student himself or herself, who will be ill-prepared and at risk of never catching up with his or her peers, Brown said.
If there is a set of metrics other than exams to determine if a child is truly ready for the next step, were all ears, but not if that criteria in any way waters down the standards for promotion.
Faria insisted Wednesday that standards would be maintained.
The test still counts because the test will give us some idea of what strategies the kids need, she said.
There will be a list of what needs to be in the portfolio [of students at risk], how it has to be graded, and there will be other measures. Theres a uniform standard. Take my word for it.
The new policy is a stark break from the Bloomberg administration, which demanded that students score minimum grades on tests to get ahead and required 32,205 kids last year to attend summer school. Of those, 8,057 still ended up repeating a grade.
Under the Bloomberg administration, students who scored at the lowest level would advance only after being reassessed and scoring at the next highest level.
The latest rules for the citys 425,000 elementary- and middle-school kids de-emphasize the Common Core exams and give more power to teachers and principals to determine students fates.
Albany this year blocked the use of Common Core results in student evaluations for at least two years, forcing schools to devise new methods for promotions.
In the revised system, teachers will assess students based on their overall work. Principals will make the final decision on promotions.
In an advisory on how the new system will work, the DOE said teachers and principals would use multiple measures, including the holistic assessment of students work.
The city also is scrapping a multiple-choice exam given at the end of summer school.
Legislators who opposed Common Core applauded the changes.We have long taken the position that using tests as the sole or primary factor in making decisions about a childs future is both unwise and unreliable, Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver and Assemblywoman Cathy Nolan said in a joint statement.
But reformers warned of the consequences.
When the test scores of nearly half our citys kids warranted possible grade retention, our focus should be on ensuring high-quality instruction on the front end, not on changing the bar for promotion, StudentsFirstNY Executive Director Jenny Sedlis said.
http://news360.com/article/233217239
Tags
Who is online
98 visitors

Academic achievement will no longer be the primary factor in determining whether a student is to be promoted to the next higher grade or not in NYC, but rather a holistic approach to te whole studnt will be the determining factor.
Is this good or a step backward?
It's a step forward in the Democrats quest to create a society of morons dependent on government.
An article written by a "Right Wing Group" New York Post which is owned by Rupert Murdoch also the Wall Street Journal and Fox News, what other report do you expect them to write, the new policy is not to teach to the test as the children had been taught, but to teach courses, then test on information in those courses, that's the way I was taught and NYC Board of Education wants to get back to those policies, Bloomberg ran the BOE like a corporation, the children were not educated, they were only taught so they can pass the test...
If they can't read English, the next step will be to change all the textbooks to Spanish and require English students to learn Spanish before attending school.
CM
As always appreciate the feedback
The source is immaterial, the point is whether the "holistic" approach to student evaluation as the standard for promotion to the next grade is the right or wrong answer.
Is there something factually wrong with what the story says the changes the mayor is making in the NYC schools?
The point is that even if a student fails to meet academic requirements for promotion to the next grade, other factors will be considered and the student could be promoted despite not meeting academic standards for promotion to the next grade.
That is the point and that is what is wrong with educational standards these days.
Dean
This is a serious issue and reckless hyperbole does not advance the discussion
scremminmimi
See response to Dean above
What do you think about meeting grade standards versus "holistic" student evaluation for promotion to the next grade>
That is the question at hand
RIO, I don't know enough about what is going on in the Schools, but I did hear about the Teachers and some Parents protesting Common Core and boycotting the test, I will check further and get back with my findings...
New York Parents Coach Kids to Refuse Common Core Tests
CM
I have no particular issue with common core, as I see it as at a minimum a step in the right direction that can be modified and updated as time goes on.
But there must be standards of achievement for promotion grade to grade that are empirical otherwise children will be promoted through and out of the schools without learning what they need to in order to be prepared for life after high school
Again thanks for the feedback
I can see drawbacks in giving too much weighting to standardized tests. However, a "holistic" approach means a subjective approach. Which means that promotion will move more towards what it usually is in most major U.S. cities--- a lot more weight will be given to race & ethnicity, and less to the actual merits of students.
I did not say that standardized tests were the end all and be all of measurements but there must be empirical rather than holistic standards for the promotion of a student from one grade to another.
Your point is spot on!
Thanks for the feedback
But there must be standards of achievement for promotion grade to grade that are empirical otherwise children will be promoted through and out of the schools without learning what they need to in order to be prepared for life after high school
children will be promoted through and out of the schools without learning what they need to in order to be prepared for life after high school
The item in bold is in fact what is happening right now in many of the school systems. The addition of the holistic measurements would give the educators a second and much needed look at the true progress of their students.
Don't throw the baby out with the bath water!!!
Can someone explain to me what the "holistic approach" will include? It's not easy to make a comment without understanding the criteria.
I agree that basing things on standardized teting just doesn't work. And that we should look for other ways to evaluate kids.
In theory, "holistic" means sounds good. But the problem with that is, it depends on the skill, as well as the lack of bias,of the evaluators.
My experience is that many school teachers, IMO, are some of the least qualified people to be evaluating children (& many shouldn't be teaching them either!).
Buzz
The actual holistic metrics have not been clearly delineated, except that the article does say that good attendance will play a role in it.
So just showing up will be considered an accomplishment, just like being in the Senate or the House
Larry
What holistic measurement or factor will be a good reason for promoting the child to the next grade if he or she is unable to do the required work and has failed to learn the basic knowledge of the present grade?
We wonder why kids graduate high school without basic math and language skills and thus are ill prepared to enter the work force, well holistic based promotions through graduation are the reason.
Dr Krishna
I am sure that there are poorly qualified teachers, but there are a lot of great people in the teaching profession that are qualified and dedicated to teaching, evaluating and helping our children.
Basic skills must be learned and mastered in order to create a basis for future learning and the attainment of life skills and promoting someone through graduation from high school without those skills (no matter what holistic measures are the basis) is wrong for the child and the child's future
Could these be examples of "holistic" requirements?
Knowing how to tie one's own shoelaces.
Clean fingernails.
No more than 3 piercings.
No more than 20 square inches of tattoos.
Being able to count from 100 to 1 (i.e. backwards).
Taking a bath at least once a week.
Being able to play the scale of C on the piano (one octave only)
Being able to take apart, clean and rebuild an AK-47 without shooting a classmate.
Knowing what day and month 9/11 happened.
Being able to solve these riddles:
1. Which weighs more, a pound of butter or a pound of feathers?
2. What colour is a greenback dollar?
3. What is the shape of a full moon? (This one can be tricky)
Buzz
A humorous look at a serious issue, which I must admitgot a chuckle out me
Thanks for that
On a more serious note, I wonder what holistic situation would warrant promoting a student to the next higher grade when they are unable to satisfactorily complete the work at their present grade level.
No one seems to be offering that simple answer, because there is no good reason for promoting that child to the next grade level, unless education and learning are less the objective than making sure the kid feels god about him(her)self.
Krish is spot on.
I worked in the system when we had "social promotion" and it was a big failure. I can also tell you that constant testing, teaches children how to take a test, but little more.
When we were kids, we were taught all year long a curriculum and then given some testing skills for a week and then tested in math, reading and science. That worked.
I can tell you firsthand that the ELA sucks. It has been around for years, and now they are making it longer. Yes, NY is ground zero for the uprising and I am glad that we are fighting this in mass.
Not that bad Mike.
Who can answer the last riddle?
It has been my experience, with my three boys going to pubic schools in three different statesas I was reassigned a few time, that the quality of the education received is largely dependent on three things parental/community involvement and support, the cadre of teachers and the focus of the students (influenced greatly by the parents).
I am advocating a mix of both the Holistic IMHO would be the social development that we are currently not seeing in our young people today. Besides being able to read, write and do math our children need to learn life skills as well I guess some would call that socializing. Maybe if more attention were to be directed to social skills we might have a chance to spot some of these troubled kids before they get to the level of say Columbine.
So for 3 hours nobody has been able to answer the third riddle. Guess that's saying something about your American education system.
Buzz
I did not realize that you were really waiting for an answer.
I would say that it is round or nearly round at least - I am sure that at some point someone more expert in astronomy than I will give us the exact answer
Thanks for all the feedback
You would have been right, Robert, if the moon were just a 2-dimensional drawing on a sheet of paper, but the question was about the shape of the moon, the actual moon, not a drawing, so the answer would be a sphere. Does that mean you would fail "holistically"? (I said that one could be tricky LOL)
I once read a statement that said: "The aim of education should be to teach us how to think, not what to think." I believe that to be true. These days I'm trying to get through a long biography called "Einstein, his Life and Universe" by Walter Isaacson. It is full of technological jargon that really slows me down and I damn well can't understand too much of it, but the book does speak about his early life when he was not particularly able to handle formal "rote" education, but because of the family environment he enjoyed (his father and uncle were in a very technological business and he learned much from them about electricity) he developed a fascination with math and physics in a visionary manner. In fact he did not even speak a word until considerably later than other children. He is certainly the example of why the 3 R's are not necessarily that important for someone with brilliance and vision, and a reason not to be too concerned if your child is not an immediately recognized genius.
Heck, I was going to say it was the same shape all the time.
Did that come out of Obamacare?
When I went to school, we didn't know what an IQ test was. The teacher just popped in one day and we took a test. As I understand now there are study materials for IQ test, SAT test PSAT and all kinds of tests.
I've watched some examples of COMMON CORE techniques being used in the classroom and find some of them quite interesting and feel there are probably good and bad things about it. I'm generally inclined to be more regional so this is probably a surprise to some of you.
I think using every creative means to teach our children has to be beneficial as long as it is balanced. I know I am more of a visual person. Some people are more inclined to read and do better that way. Give me examples, pictures or visual instruction and I'll figure out the rest myself, but that's me. Some can learn easier by reading.
I believe the 3 R's should be taught in the most creative way possible to maintain a young person's interest. Without maintaining their interest there is little learning going on in their minds.
Balanced testing that aren't so ridiculous as the example in the comment above would be my idea of the correct way of testing a child to see if they have progressed enough to move on to the next grade level.
With all the tools we have today, it should be much easier than just looking a black board with a bunch of numbers on it.
Buzz,
The fact that he was not a traditional learner probably accounts to a large degree as to why he was able to advance the Theory of Relativity. He came at things from a different perspective, as such, his understandings of them were from a different perspective.
That's correct, Bro. His Theory of Relativity was advanced in stages to get to the final one, and he had drawn on many theories and discounted others to finally accomplish it.
Buzz,
Once, while taking the written portion of a drivers exam when I moved to Washington state, I came across a question that I considered poorly worded and ambiguous. (There was no correct multiple choice answer on the page as per my reading of the question.) The question was about parking on a hill, in regards to the direction that the tires should be pointing. I asked the person at the counter of the DMV for clarification and she looked at me like I had three heads.
Your question, What is the shape of a full moon? is ambiguous. The way that the question is asked and the context it is in have a lot to do with the answers that you will receive. Not because people do not know the answer, they may not know the answer you are looking for.
Your question implies the moon going through its different phases. So, if looked at from that perspective, Robert (...round or nearly round at least...)would be at least partially correct, even to an astronomer, because the projection of shadows contributed to how we figured out our place, if you will, in the universe.
So, being a literal minded person, your question would have raised several questions in my mind which needed answering before I could feel comfortable answering the original question.
Going back to my A.R. world now.....
It sounds like a typical phrase invented so often by academicians involved with the public sector-- academicians in the Social Sciences-- and particularly in education!
Its a "feel good" term, some jargon that is deliberately not clearly defined....but is designed to give the public the sense that they are addressing the problem, that they are trying a "new" -- yes, even a "creative" approach. (And if the public doesn't quite know what the term means, most of the public then assumes that that is because its really profound-- that only the "experts" know what it is...).
In other words-- the term is total bullsh*t!!!
Bro, I think you are right, because I realized after posing the question that I should have said just "moon" rather than "full moon".
Therefore, Robert, you pass, for being partially correct. I'm sure that would be the criterion used to pass holistically.
Thanks Krishna, that's what I thought.
flameaway
Great to be getting feedback and critique from you again
Not me but I agree that is what we need to strive for!
I agree partly in that there is no doubt that affluence gives one a better opportunity to succeed on merit or to bypass the merit requirement because of money.
Excellent point. It is up to society to establish a balance of merit, but that should not deter us from establishing merit advancement systems and attempting to make them as fair as possible in out school systems.
Again thanks for the feedback.
Buzz
I think that is true as well, but our education system especially elementary and secondary, must also provide a mastery of basic skills and knowledge units that will enable that critical thinking process in post secondary education and indeed in life. Those basic skills and knowledge units are what is lacking in many "graduates" these days
Sixpick
Moderation in all things, a lesson we all need to learn
Larry
But what holistic attributes would be measured/evaluated in order to formulate a decision to promote a child to the next grade level who has not mastered the academic requirements of the current level
Social skills are indeed important but, basic skills and knowledge is also critical to life success
Perrie
Thanks for that perspective
I too see merit in the educational methods of days gone by, but reality would indicate that we need to find a way to meld some of those educational approaches, with the technology and social aspects of the current society to really reform and improve our educational processes.
Broliver
You are right of course
I guess holistically I should have said it is shaped like a nearly circular balloon
Dr Krishna
We need a little less feeling good and a little more learning in my humble opinion
flameaway
Critical thinking skills and social skills are very important but if not accompanied by a basic understanding of math, science, language skills and social studies critical thinking will not get people too far
flameaway
As much as I think balance and moderation in all things is important, this is more about the basic level of learning that all must have
Merit and effort must count for some things gained or nothing gained means anything
We should be striving for the highest achievement not striving for the lowest common denominator of achievement.
Just my view and thanks for the feedback
I actually saw Gattica, didn't like it much but I get your point
flameaway
I understand your point but do not totally agree that something cannot be meaningless
On that we will have to agree to disagree
Thanks for all the feedback and perspective, I missed your direct commentary on topics
It's a sad reality to see college become the equivalent of high school, not because it is necessitated by the majority, but it is part of the nation's dumbing-down process to meet the mentality, backgrounds, languages, and cultural values of immigrants and other generational groups of non-academics.
Chloe
Sad but a very true perspective on the matter
Thanks for the feedback
Thank you for your kind and fair [unbiased] regard, Robert; it is always appreciated.
Chloe,
What exactly does this statement mean:
I read that to say that these things that you mention are less than insome groups of others, whomever they may be.
Well, if I am interpreting your query correctly, here's an example that won't get me into 'racial' connotative hot waters.
...just career-choice hot waters.
As you know, this is a state that supports the logging communities, tho differently in different areas. I know someone that teaches in one of those communities, with most coming from generations of loggers, having said the kids are extremely difficult to teach, such that she had to modify her annual lesson plans to meet their backgrounds. If she took a more academic approach, she would have to fail many.
What is wrong with failing many?
I taught as a TA at WSU, and, to be quite frank, thought that the educational level of the students who I was exposed to was very poor, IMO. But, then again, I was teaching lab sections of Rocks for Jocks...
From a learning perspective, I agree with you. But with all things considered, poor test scores aren't acceptable at all levels, especially since President Obama is in a push to look good on paper, on a national median scale. I think national achievement tests are a bad idea, and the student suffers in the long run. I read a Nv member link a report from her state that teachers that have had trouble meeting national requirements, resorted to changing test scores. I wonder how many others have been doing that, but might not need to eventually, if the tests are no longer a basis for evaluation.
For purposes of clarification, the WSU mentioned is Washington State University.
You must mean President Bush with his No Child Left Behind testing...
I see no problem with standardized testing, as long as it is testing the concepts and not the curricula.
Yes, I know of the school, Brolly.
No, I meant President Obama. I don't have any links, but I believe he is concerned with national quotas, wanting to improve the scores. I might be wrong on that, Brolly. It was an article showing the US with poor national averages in a past article.
The cartoon is political hyperbole and in no way represents the aggregate problem facing all public schools in the us regardless of ideology, In my vernacular, it's a very stupid and ignorant cartoon.
The public school system is at the mercy not of the government but is controlled by a school board whose members may or may not be liberal or conservative. The point is, because of tight budgets they are not being taught to reason but instead are being taught to pass tests to pass then along. There is no learning here.
Ideological schooling is being taught in private schools, not public schools and therein lays the greatest problem.
A P
Indeed it is, thanks for the explanation.
Schools, public, private or religiously affiliated can all be good or bad, depending a number of factors which include but are not limited t funding, administration, teaching cadre, parent/community involvement and the students themselves
Different school boards (you are correct) can and do shape how a school functions, to an extent, but meeting state and federal requirements (in order to sustain funding) is the primary driver of atmosphere, culture and opportunity for success of most schools (especially public schools)
In my view the community (in which a school is located) and the involvement it takes in the school through support of school levies, donations, volunteerism, etc is truly what shapes the direction of the educational and socialization mission of the school.
Appreciate the feedback
Chloe
Are you talking about -
Chloe, The purpose of my telling you was disambiguation, as there is more than one WSU in the nation.
You may have meant president Obama, but President Bush also had his own brand of national testing and performance reviews based on such. The emoticon
was supposed to indicate that it was an attempt at humor.
There is nothing bad about wanting the children of the nation to have a baseline of learning and defining what that baseline is, aka setting standards. The problems come in the development of just how such standards are to be implemented.
Some people wish to not only impart knowledge, but to impart their own personal political perspective or have the same taught as a matter of course, and this is where we run into a whole load of trouble, because, inevitably, the discussion spills over into the political sphere of conservative vs liberal, Democrat vs Republican ideology and hyperbole. Then we get just a bunch of hate, and the children get lost in the shuffle.
Brolover
It seems to me thatestablishing (implementing) the standards the easy part, while the challenge is developing, fielding and perfecting the infrastructure, organization and processes that enable all children to meet the standards and set themselves up for success in life.
Every teacher, no matter how altruistic and dedicated to teaching children has their own perspectives and biases and they are imparted, intentionally or inadvertently in the process of teaching.
RiO:
is what I would consider the implementation.
Potato --- potatoe
I guess we agree then
Thanks for the feedback
Flame,
Firstly, welcome back (even though I did try to chase you away on our first encounter).
The testing indicates the test, not the ability of the people taking the test. In other words, tests show what you know and also what you don't know. I had a chemistry teacher once who held to the opinion that a well designed test shows what the students don't know, and that deficiency of knowledge could then be addressed. He was perfectly happy with a mean raw score on a test of 50%.
Standards for minimum education to graduate from High school, therefore, are not saying this is all you should know. What they are saying is that the students have demonstrated a competency in certain actions deemed to be the basics of what they will need to adapt to the situations that the world, which is largely comprised of employers, will throw at them. As employers needs for people who have demonstrated a competency increase, so should the number of students that can perform these actions increase.
I guess that what I am trying to say is that our standards and expectations should be higher of all students. Further, we should abandon the one size fits all method of teaching, because that does not work in all cases and often conflicts with our interests towards effectively teaching. It is important to remember that testing and teaching are two different things entirely. Entirely.
The students who have seemed to come out of the woodwork with new and innovative ideas often do so because of non standard teaching or learning roles. If we truly were worried about the next generation of out of the box instead of out of a box thinkers, we would be addressing these types of educational strategies combined with rigorous standards and expectations. But we don't wish to pay for that, or for anything, apparently, so we sing our own swan-song to the beat of gnashing teeth on the bones of political traction devices.
Brolly, yes - true about Bush, ie.. his "it takes a village..." with the problem with that being (as you also imply) - all villages don't come from the same backgrounds, wants & needs, lifestyle, values, etc., and what I've noticed is that an individual is all too easily influenced by that school village (Admin. policies, teachers and peers) such that whatever values they had, can be altered.
Aside from mind-control
, the biggest travesty, imo, that I've seen is turning education into group project work to make grading and pushing them through easier. The Admins. cite they are doing it to facilitate a different work ethic - group instead of personal responsibility. Imo, I think it's been a huge social experiment that has majorly failed the individual and our nation for developing 'the best' in people. Now, everyone gets an A and nothing really matters other than hoping the groups you sailed through with were decent. I know curriculum and teaching styles vary by area, school and state. Some will be 'luckier' than others. Parents are expected to carry a lot more of the responsibility, so that their child is the 'teacher' in the group, in some schools.
Thank you Robert! Yes, I believe it was the Race to the Top program implemented by the Obama Admin. in 2011 for education reform that I was thinking of.. Interesting how the word "education" doesn't mean what it used to.
RiO said:
Yes. I agree. However, a thinking, reasoning student will be able to challenge or be challenged on these points, whereas a person who learns strictly for the test may not have the logic and background to assert his or her self in the same situation. Therein lies the difference between teaching to the test and teaching a subject, imo.
Chloe,
I believe the village was Mrs. Clintons idea.
Much of this is due to the decreasing funding for education, necessitating the reduction in staff levels. One person can only do so much.
Do they???? I don't think so.
Parents, child and teacher should bear equal responsibility for theirchild'sperformance. Being the teacher in the group raises expectations on the child and should also make the child think differently about the subject, thereby promoting the development of logic and critical thinking skills. That said, no child should be left hanging out on the limb, that just means a teacher is not doing the job, for whatever reason.
Also, the classroom should be a mixture of learning/teaching styles.