The Best Teachers are ......
What Americans like best about their favorite teachers!
What attribute do Americans find most compelling in the teacher they have identified as having the greatest impact on their lives?
I learned the answer recently when I was listening to a speech byBrandon H. Busteed, the executive director of Gallup Education, about public education and what polls show about how Americans view their teachers.
He noted that a strong majority of Americans say they have trust and confidence in public school teachers (even if many school reformers dont). He also said that when asked to describe the teacher who had most affected their lives, the attribute that was seen as most important wasnt smart or demanding but, rather, caring.
The 2012 Gallup study, titled Public education in the United States: A nation divided, said this:
Over 40% of Americans describe the teacher who hadthe most positive influence in their lives with wordssuch as caring, compassionate, motivating, and inspiring; while just 17% of Americans thoughtintelligent, knowledgeable, persistent, hard-working, and demanding were words that describe the teacher who had the strongest influence on them.
Id like to see how teacher evaluations linked to student standardized-test scores measure for caring.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/answer-sheet/wp/2014/04/05/the-no-1-trait-of-americans-favorite-teachers/

All of us (well most of us at least) can look back on that one teacher in middle school or more likely high school that had the greatest effect on the course of our academic pursuits and on our lives.
The article points out that the majority of Americans identify a teacher who was a master of the soft skills (compassion, caring, inspiration, motivation) rather than one who has intelligent, knowledgeable persistent, hard-working and demanding.
I count myself very fortunate that Mrs. Rehm (English and Literature as well as class advisor) was all of those things and more. She was strict and uncompromising of standards of excellence (in performance and behavior) that she established from the outset and yet still managed to make each of us feel as if we were the only student she cared about as she helped us with problems (with schoolwork and with our lives).
Compassion and inspiration are indeed important to the process, but without competence and high standards of performance and behavior they fall well short of what is needed in today's classrooms.
I am sure that many of you had that special teacher in your lives, who was it?
Well, maybe that's true for the type of people who typically answer these surveys (middle class white adults).
But a friend of mine is a teacher in a really "bad" neighbourhood. Her kids are all "economically challenged" Blacks & Hispanics. Almost without exception, their main complaint about teachers they don't like is:
I think I mentioned this on another thread once; I am so old that most all of my teachers had those qualities you mention, Robert. It has been the last several decades that it has become a rarity to find all of them in the majority of teachers in the majority of schools throughout the country.
Interesting side note: A small news article in ABC news says a teacher wrestled a student to the ground and pinned him to take a "drug substance" from him in a CA school. It was captured on a phone, sent to the Internet and has had over a million hits. A campaign has been launched to save the teacher's job, who was fired for "fighting" with the student. The students in the class are supporting the teacher.
The best teachers I remember constantly gave encouragement to their students as a whole and individually. They never spread the accomplishments of one student out over the entire class other than to encourage others to realize each one of them had the same ability to do just as well and promoted confidence in each one of that ability.
Although I have to admit the teacher Newstalker #1 described also remains implanted in my mind as well. Control over their class from a disciplinary aspect as well as respect also played a big part. Didn't like teachers who had favorites unless I was one of them. LOL
Grover
Not sure how you know who typically answers surveys, but okay
It is refreshing to hear that students are desirous of a disciplined and structured learning environment and I imagine that is not isolated to "economically challenged" neighborhoods.
scremminmimi
Most of my teachers in high school are long retired and many have passed onto to their greater reward as well and there were many that were exceptional though I did not always know it at the time, I merely mentioned the best of the best in my example,
Isaw the "fighting" news clip as well and would hope that perhaps the student would be arrested and the teacher would not only keep his job but would receive the same accolades he is getting from his students from their parents and his administrators.
Doing the right thing - what good teachers do!
New Talker #1
Not exactly the criteria I was hoping people would use to recognize the best teacher they knew, but thanks for the perspective
Sixpick
Great perspective on the issue
Enoch
As always a wise and reasoned perspective
Expertise is important in the teaching profession, but the ability to relate, communicate and motivate is also a key to the success of the teacher and his/her students
Thanks for the feedback
Just to be a PITA I'm gonna point out that 40 % is not a majority . I suspect there is a strong gender component in that 40 % ...
Petey
You are never a PITA in my view
A poor choice of words in my comment, I should have said many versus majority. Thanks for catching that error on my part.
Not sure there is a gender issue involved in this, but I am sure some males favorite teachers were women and some females favorite teachers were mean but not sure that is germane to the point of the article.
Always appreciate your input on an article
Good to hear that I am not a PITA ... This is an important topic . It will require some more thought on my part .
I had two very special teachers in my life. Mrs. Bonder and Mrs. Hower. One had the patience of a saint and helped me get over my dyslexia and the other taught me what it meant to be an American. I can never thank either of them enough for what they did for me. And yes caring would a lot of what made them, them. Without caring, children are not inspired to learn. They need to know that the teacher cares to get further than that.
I taught for 20+ years and I can only hope that my students felt that I cared about them and that my knowledge base was good enough to meet their needs.
I always thought a PITA was a kind of Greek bread that you open and stuff with food.
I think it was 5th grade at catholic school. The nun who was teaching was great. One time I brought fossils from my collection and she was thrilled to see a piece of fossil coral with the animals (star shapes) on the surface. She was a great teacher.
When I teach English to Chinese students one of the things I get them to speak aloud about is to describe their favourite teacher of all time, and why they were their favourite. The example I give them to follow is my description of the one who was my favourite of all time. While I am teaching I think of him and how he taught.
Mr. Steel was my teacher in my last two years of high school, which I spent at an English-style boys' school. (It could be the reason why I enjoy watching Goodbye Mr. Chips so much.) He had freshly arrived from England and fortunately didn't drive because he would certainly have stuck to the left side of the road in order to show us colonials who was right. He taught Math (Algebra, Geometry and Trigonometry). He also was appointed to be the coach of the football team (Canadian style - 3 downs and a hundred and ten yard field). Of course he knew nothing about Canadian football so he took home the book of rules for the game one night and returned having memorized the whole thing. As well, he was our advisor for the school yearbook, staff master for our House (in English style schools the students of all ages are put into equal "houses" which means groups for the purpose of competing with each other) and was the director of the school play - I considered him a Renaissance Man. He was strict, but also caring. Although he threw the chalk at us if we did not pay attention to him, he took care not to hit us with it in the face.
In the Shakespeare play "Twelfth Night" I played Sir Toby Belch. ("For Andrew, if he had so much blood in his liver as would clog the foot of a flea, I'd eat the rest of the anatomy." "What a plague means my niece to take the death of her brother thus. I'm sure care's an enemy to life."- I still remember some of my lines.) About 40 years after I graduated a special dinner was held celebrating Mr. Steel's retirement which I attended after not being back to the school or having any contact with him for all that time. When I arrived I walked over to say hello to him. He looked up at me and bellowed "SIR TOBY BELCH!!!!
While here in China I got his address from the school and wrote him a letter about my life and how I felt about him and how he had influenced me. (He didn't have or use a computer so no email.) He replied to me with a lovely hand-written letter that I treasure which indicated to me that he still had all his mental facilities. He passed away a couple of years ago and I wrote a long letter to his family about him and how I felt about him. I have always missed him - he was to me the perfect teacher and the best example I could have had for what I do now.
Perrie
I am sure that there are many students who feel that you are the best teacher ever as well.
Always appreciate your views and perspective on education related points as it adds the reality of the situation to the discussion.
Take good care
pat
Sounds like a great teacher thanks for the feedback
Buzz
Looks like you were influenced by an accomplished educator and caring human being and that you are now paying it forward
Thanks for the perspective and feedback
NewsTalker #1
Well I gotta admit that the teacher you have highlighted here provides honest feedback
Good choice
Obviously he/she's dedicated (and oblivious).
Expanding on the theme of the original article, this is an excerpt from another article on LinkedIn today -
Working for a purpose - now that is a concise way to describe a teacher who truly cares about the children he/she teaches and what becomes of their lives.