Marijuana vs. Alcohol
Is marijuana safer than alcohol, or vice versa? Each substance has different effects on the body. Here's how the two compare. In most cases, these effects have been studied in heavy, chronic smokers and drinkers, not occasional users.
Marijuana Alcohol Immediate Effects
- Impairs judgment
- Slows reaction time
- Affects coordination and motor skills
- Increases risk for accidents
- Changes behavior and mood
- Impairs judgment
- Slows reaction time
- Affects coordination and motor skills
- Increases risk for accidents
- Changes behavior and mood
Brain
- Reduces blood flow to brain
- Interferes with learning, memory, and attention
- May increase risks for schizophrenia and other mental illnesses
- May contribute to anxiety and depression
Cancer
- Linked to precancerous lung changes
- May increase testicular cancer risk in young men
May increase risks of these cancers:
- Breast
- Esophagus
- Liver
- Throat
Driving
- Impairs judgment
- Slows reaction time
- Affects coordination and motor skills
- Increases risk for accidents
- Impairs judgment
- Slows reaction time
- Affects coordination and motor skills
- Increases risk for accidents
Liver
- No known effects
Increases risks for:
- Fatty liver disease
- Alcoholic hepatitis
- Cirrhosis
Lungs
- Contributes to precancerous lung changes
- May lead to more coughing and wheezing
- May damage lungs
Pregnancy
- May lead to low birth weight
- May lead to developmental and behavior problems in baby
- No evidence it causes birth defects
Increases risks for:
- Miscarriage
- Preterm birth
- Stillbirth
- Birth defects
- Low birth weight
- Learning and behavior problems
Reviewed by Michael W. Smith, MD on February 18, 2014
SOURCE:
Hall, W. The Lancet, October 2009.
Jeanette Marie Tetrault, MD, FACP, assistant professor of medicine, Yale University School of Medicine.
National Institute on Drug Abuse: "DrugFacts: Marijuana."
Li, M-C. Epidemiologic Reviews, October 2011.
National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism: "Alcohol's Effects on the Body."
National Council on Alcoholism and Drug Dependence Inc.: "Drinking and Driving."
National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism: "Examples of Alcohol's Effect on Organ Function."
March of Dimes: "Alcohol During Pregnancy."
http://www.webmd.com/news/breaking-news/marijuana-on-main-street/marijuana-vs-alcohol?ecd=wnl_wmh_040214&ctr=wnl-wmh-040214_ld-stry_3&mb=%2f6yNSKf47OP5Za9FOmx1DOHnVev1imbCD37nKWAkeeo%3d

I have seen a lot of articles and commentary on whether marijuana should or should not be legalized (at least de-criminalized) and whether it is more or less harmful than alcohol.
As more and more states are legalizing or taking up the question of legalization, I thought this article on WebMD was relevant to that discussion.
I am sure others will have thoughts as to the data in the article and all opinions are welcome and appreciated
Relative to "second-hand smoke" effects of the marijuana versus cigarettes, I found this
http://www.webmd.com/news/breaking-news/marijuana-on-main-street/is-marijuana-safe-web?ecd=wnl_wmh_040214&ctr=wnl-wmh-040214_ld-stry_1&mb=%2f6yNSKf47OP5Za9FOmx1DOHnVev1imbCD37nKWAkeeo%3d
John
A lot of people also think alcohol is harmless
Both lots are wrong in my view, but that is only my view
I am sure it has killed a lot more people than marijuana use has.
Badwabbit
Appreciate your perspective
96WS6
Another debatable point, I would say but that same argument might be made for other "drugs" as well I suppose
Thanks for your sharing your point of view
I think that marijuanahas more benefits thanalcohol. It has proven to help those going through chemo and who have AIDS. Itrelieveschronic pain. You don't have to smoke it, to get the good benefits or the high and you can get it without THC, which is the chemical involved with the high.
Alcohol on the other hand, has shown on a mild connection to loweringcholesterol, and is far more linked to liver and stomach issues.
I have no problem with legalizingmarijuana. I think we should all move past "Reefer Madness" and realize that bothmarijuana and alcohol have down sides andmarijuana actually has real medical benefits.
Perrie
Thanks for the perspective and feedback
I noted these opinions on current research as well
And
Really?
Really (x2)?
I wonder how many medical studies support those assertions?
Badwabbit
I appreciate your feedback and perspective and I am sure that there are many that will agree with you, but I am equally sure that there are many in the medical community that while agreeing that overindulging in diet soda or alcohol are not healthy choices that there are still many questions to be answered before we declare marijuana use to be without health implications
I am not against decriminalization or even legalization if it is the will of the people in the states or country but I do not think that marijuana (like alcohol and other things) is not without health risks and societal challenges.
I do not denigrate those who use marijuana (you call them stoners) or people who think that it is a bad thing (you call them slobs)...the real problem may be intolerance of others and their views and actions
IMO there are 2 relevant (& different) questions that need to be asked.. One is primarily medical, the other political. Both questions are important:
1. Medical Q: Is Marijuana totally safe-- or at least much significantly safer than alcohol, as its users claim? There has been a tremendous amount of research on the effects of alcohol and smoking (Tobacco). But not much research on the effects of smoking pot, so we really don't know that much about its effects yet.
2. Political Q: How much should the government decide what is "safe"-- and how much should the gov't regulate potentially harmful substances & objects? From regulating unsafe autos (or, for that matter, even setting speed limits) to alcohol to guns to tobacco to marijuana...or even big high calories soft drinks & HFCS (Hi Fructose Cprn Syrup)? While the first question is more about actual facts, this is more about ones' political opinion.
Perrie is right . Pot users don't have to smoke it to get the desired effect . And it has the stated effects on improving appetite in cancer patients . That could actually save the life of someone on chemtherapy .
Those effects might be accomplished by a product which has the THC ingredient removed . Its called "Charlotte's Web " .
That's a good point. While smoking it may have the same effects of increasing the odds of lung cancer that smoking tobacco has, that problem could be eliminated by ingesting it in other ways.
I wonder if that is actually true? I had thought the benefits of medical Marijuana were due solely to the THC....?
Marijuana comes from the Hemp plant. I eat Hemp everyday , but don't get high. Why? because there are two types of Hemp:
1. One has a fair amount of naturally occurring THC. This is what people use to get high. Up until recently possession has been illegal throughout the U.S.
2. The other type has no THC, or actually has a really miniscule amount. You can legally buy it on Amazon, in Whole Foods Markets, & other stores. Generally people buy it for its nutritional value, as either Hemp Protein Powder (as a Protein supplement) or Hemp seed (mainly for its high content of essential fatty acids)-- or Hemp clothing, particularly shirts and blouses. However as far as I know ingesting this type of Hemp that has no THC does not have any significant effect on reducing pain and/or nausea, or altering mood.
(Incidentally, due to a weird quirk in the law, all non-THC Hemp of the type that is legal to possess is imported...generally from Canada).
Charlottes Web Hemp Strain
This special strain of hemp was developed by the Stanley family for the purposes of bringing the extremely beneficial cannabinoid, Cannabidiol or CBD, to patients who need the therapeutic benefits of the plant, without the psychoactivity accompanied by THC. There is a significant body of published research over the last 50 years, suggesting many potential benefits of CBD ....
Thanks for that information, I hadn't know about that.
Is that type of Marijuana legal (by Federal Law)?
The legality probably varies by state ... but I'm not certain . If I'm not mistaken the Colorado medical pot dispensaries offer it for sale not as a raw plant but as an extract which is taken orally .
I used to-- but of course I didn't inhale
.
While that is true, there may be a different danger. Marijuana makes most users feel good, often very good-- a sense of euphoria in some cases. And often a feeling that nothing can go wrong, and an increased sense of feeling more in control over ones' life. Also, of having more acute thoughts... & perceptions.
So I wonder if that may cause some individuals to take risks that they might not otherwise take. For example, driving... even doing risky things while driving?
Also, some people have claimed that a frequent state of euphoria such as this may kill some individuals' motivation....???
I recall reading or seeing somewhere that there are some study's which suggest that the age of the marijuana user affects how the brain develops and functions at equal amounts differently.
Has anyone else heard or read anything about this clinical research?
It may be on point in a discussion on medical use (recreational) for legalization.
Good decisions are based on facts. Can anybody shed light on them in this context?
Thanks, Enoch.
P.S. I never inhaled diet soda.
I just believe pot should be legalized across all 50 states.
OMG!!! I actually have to agree with AP AGAIN!!!
And Mike L has a man-crushon John Russell-- must be the gov't putting hallucinogensin the water again...
Krish
Excellent perspective and info thanks for sharing it
Enoch
An excellent question, other than the data I presented from the WebMD site I have not seen much (if any) actual clinical testing data but I will look around (and hope everyone else will do the same)
As always your feedback is appreciated
And an excellent example for others - not inhaling that diet soda I mean
A P
Because ??????
Badwabbit
You can characterize those people however you like
I got our point and appreciate the feedback
Looser
Good point
People do a lot of things to escape from or avoid dealing with the reality of their situation, because other people are doing it or because they have nothing better to do.
None of those are good reasons for doing anything
I read a report about this research; that using marijuana excessively when you are young can have harmful effects on developing brains such as symptoms of paranoid schizophrenia.
People are always saying that marijuana is harmless; I have had up close and personal experience with young people who have smoked and experienced nothing but the laid back mellow feelings attributed to marijuana use. I have also had up close and personal experience with young people who become extremely paranoid when high, and confrontational with others.
There is not a single man-made or natural plant on this planet that delivers the exact same reaction to each and every individual who encounters it; it is a scientific and medical impossibility, and regardless of what marijuana enthusiasts proclaim, the use of the plant and its effects become addictive for addictive personalities.
It has become a life saver for those children who use the strain Charlotte's Web, and for those suffering from medical problems where the pain is relieved by marijuana. Like alcohol, there is no separating the casual user from those who abuse it. If we are going to allow its legal use, we will have to accept and gear up for the consequences.
There will have to be legal parameters for abusing its use while operating machinery on the job, performing certain services and jobs under its influence, driving, etc. But it is certainly no more harmful, and probably less so, than alcohol.
For my part, it smells like old gym socks when it is smoked and I can't stand the stench. But I'm not fond of cigarette smoke either. As long as it is indulged in the home, I have a choice to enter the dwelling or not.
scremminmimi
Good points and excellent perspective on the issue
The point on schizophrenia was mentioned in the seeded article as well
Your point that marijuana (like other drugs) affects each person differently is a very important point in the discussion.
I feel the same as you about the smell of cigarette smoke, pot and for me throw in beer as well all of it is offensive to me
Agree about the smell of both beer and whiskey.
Larry, I was about to read your comment about Colorado DUI limits or something along those lines, I blinked before beginning to read, and it all disappeared.
same for me
Well let's try it one more time then:
A motorist in Colorado can be ticketed for impaired driving if his or her blood shows more than 5 nanograms of active THC, the active constituent of marijuana, NORML says on its website.
Some users will fall below that level three hours after consuming pot, but "some people will still be well above 5 ng," NORML says. "Do recognize that the effects of alcohol and marijuana together may be more than the sum of their parts."
10 things to know about nation's first recreational marijuana shops in Colorado
Here is a second read if you are interested:
...
And this is the official Colorado DOT posting:
Larry
Thanks for sharing the information
Not a problem I just had to find documentation to post so there wouldn't be any question about the amount. I live in Colorado and this has been an interesting year.