"BDS": Why Jewish students no longer feel safe on some college campuses
Category: News & Politics
Via: the-irascible-harry-krishner • 12 years ago • 85 commentsAnd if the "Stand With Us" organization didn't exist, they'd have very little support. Much of this is not reported in the mainstream media, and some of what is going on on many college campuses may shock you.(Note if video doesn't start at the very beginning, use your mouse pointer to drag the circle at the bottom to the left).

Unless strong action is taken, things like thisare only going to get worse. To help go to their facebook page:
It's one thing to make speeches about Israel's policies as a matter of politics. It's quite another to make sweeping statements inciting hatred toward Jews or any other ethnic group, and it definitely should not be allowed on any US campus.
This is appalling and goes beyond what should be allowed within the parameters of freedom of speech in our educational facilities.
Very disturbing. College campuses should be a place for open dialog, no matter where you stand on this or any other matter. But to allow this level of hate to brew on a campus and to allow hate speech is crazy. For students to be fearful to express themselves because of retribution is insanity. I have two kids in college and if this or anything like this happened on campus, I would be taking it to the authorities. This is nothing less then intimidation at best, hate speech at worst.
Agreed. A difference of opinion is fine. But making death threats (for any reason!) against other people is totally unacceptable. (Although threats & intimidation are a significant part of BDS' arsenal-- both here and abroad. I saw a video of BDS action in Australia. There was no attempt at dialogue, itv was all an attempt at intimidation).
Its obvious that there is a "clash of civilizations here"-- or at least a clash of values. And part of the problem is that BDS totally does not want freedom of speech. It goes against their core values. (I'm sure that they did let Michael Oren speak, and present a different point of view, he would win the debate.)
I strongly agree. But after doing quite a bit of research on this, it became quite clear to me that the last thing that BDS wants is open dialogue!
And in terms of hate...well, that's part & parcel of who they are, its their driving force.
Screaming of angry accusations , unsupported ones at that , is certainly not dialogue .
What good is the American guarantee of free speech or freedom of expression when those pigs scream and shout so a speaker cannot be heard? Does the freedom apply only for the benefit of those who refuse to let others speak?
It was pointed out to me in another thread that the freedom of speech guarantee [in the 1st amendment ] only applies in a public venue , not on private property . The amendment mostly prevents the US Congress from taking actions which prevent the speech of citizens .
So the First Amendment is not only limited by the SCOTUS in situations like calling "FIRE!!!" in a crowded theatre, but it is not applicable in many places where it may be most needed.
The framers of the constitution perceived the necessity of protecting citizens from congress . As far as protecting some citizens from other citizens , that is impossible to do without resorting to favoritism . Speech is a tricky legal issue ... However , these days "hate speech" is prohibited ... I think .
"Hate speech" is a criminal offence in Canada, but I don't think it is in the USA. Maybe the fact that anyone can carry a gun is the best way to control hate speakers.
e.g. "Say that again and I'll blow yourfucking head off!!!"
Dear Friends: I concur. Freedom of Speech is not absolute. Hate speech is specifically a crime, and for good reason.
May G-d steel the resolve of those given to protect and defend the rights of those who seek peace and truth. May the Almighty motivate the lovers of freedom and tolerance againstthose who foment hatred to others, as their souls are indelibly stained with this very hatred in their hearts.
Peace, Freedom via Responsibility and Abundant Blessings to One and All.
Enoch.
Uninformed bigoted assholes, is the way to describe these people.
Historically, the only time any real action is taken to stop hate-mongering is after something very atrocious happens. My only hope is that when that event happens - which it will - there will be a minimum of fatalities.
Buzz,
Petey is wrong about this. Hate speech isn't allowed anywhere in the USA. It is a crime, and had he watched the video to the end, he would have found out that they are being prosecuted for hate crimes.
I was watching Jimmy Falon last night and U2 was on, and it got me thinking about whether or not Bono was part of BDS. What I found was that BDS and the Electronic Intifada does is harass celebs into not making engagements Israel.
I have to agree with Jonathan on this.
My question is, where is BDS, with the human rights violations in North Korea, China (Tibet) and numerous other countries. Seems that there is an agenda with BDS, and it isn't human rights.
BDS has quite a history with bullying musical artists. Interesting to note that most of the "supporters" are Brits.
3 interesting storiesof the exceptions tothat:
Elton John was accosted by BDS to not play in Israel. He pointed out to them that "The only place for queers like me in the Middle East is in Israel". They relented.
Paul McCartney was threatened by BDS after scheduling. Within days, there was no more discussion, as BDS was "contacted" by Interpol to STFU. Apparently, Paul McCartney is a global treasure. You just can't go around threatening Paul McCartney.
After scheduling a date in Israel, BDS contacted the Rolling Stones about performing in the "Zionist entity". Jagger actually met with them to discuss it. After the meeting, they scheduled a second date. And now they're coming back with a third gig.
For every douchebag who thinks they're doing the world a favor, there are others that actually know what's going on. Happily, there's still a good supply of the smart people.
2 bells for Kavika.
He asks the question so few ask.
Would you like me to tell you the answer before or after you venture a guess?
Spot on Kavika!
Kudos to Elton, Paul and the Stones.
Thanks for the information Jonathan.
I love the answer that Elton gave them...
Exchanging ideas is all okay. They even exchange ideas on how much they dislike the United States of America and its policies, the very country that funds the ground they stand on to express their dislike.
But they are not allowed to incite their audiences into hatred of blacks, Hispanics, Asians, or any other specific ethnic group that may support the policies they hate.
While screaming their hatred of Israel, this speaker, Malik Ali, specifically says that Jews are the new Nazis, inciting hatred toward a specific ethnic group. Campuses should in no way tolerate that.
Hi Enoch.
I agree about hate speech. And of course on campus, often the BDSers go beyond mere bigoted hate speech to actually making specific death threats to individual students.
In addition, I have observed rallies off campus where they admit that their real goal is not the creation of a Palestinian state, but rather the actual elimination of Israel, as they openly admit in one of their popular chants:
Perrie ,
I did . It said they are being prosecuted . It did not specify "hate speech" although that was suggested .
And in fact "hate speech " is , for the most part , legal. A hate crime goes beyond just speech into action :
Supreme Court Case Law[edit]
Some limits on expression were contemplated by the framers and have been read into the Constitution by the Supreme Court. In 1942, Justice Frank Murphy summarized the case law: "There are certain well-defined and limited classes of speech, the prevention and punishment of which have never been thought to raise a Constitutional problem. These include the lewd and obscene, the profane, the libelous and the insulting or fighting words those which by their very utterances inflict injury or tend to incite an immediate breach of the peace."[69]
Traditionally, however, if the speech did not fall within one of the above categorical exceptions, it was protected speech. In 1969, the Supreme Court protected a Ku Klux Klan members racist and hate filled speech and created the imminent danger test to permit hate speech. The court ruled in Brandenburg v. Ohio that; "The constitutional guarantees of free speech and free press do not permit a state to forbid or proscribe advocacy of the use of force, or of law violation except where such advocacy is directed to inciting imminent lawless action and is likely to incite or produce such action."[70]
This test has been modified very little from its inception in 1969 and the formulation is still good law in the US. Only speech that poses an imminent danger of unlawful action, where the speaker has the intention to incite such action and there is the likelihood that this will be the consequence of his or her speech, may be restricted and punished by that law.
In R.A.V. v. City of St. Paul, (1992), the issue of freedom to express hatred arose again when a gang of white racists burned a cross in the front yard of a black family. The local ordinance in St. Paul, Minnesota, criminalized such racist and hate-filled expressions and the teenager was charged thereunder. Scalia, writing for SCOTUS, held that the prohibition against hate speech was unconstitutional as it contravened the First Amendment. The Supreme Court struck down the ordinance. Scalia explicated the fighting words exception as follows: The reason why fighting words are categorically excluded from the protection of the First Amendment is not that their content communicates any particular idea, but that their content embodies a particularly intolerable (and socially unnecessary) mode of expressing whatever idea the speaker wishes to convey.[71] Because the hate speech ordinance was not concerned with the mode of expression, but with the content of expression, it was a violation of the freedom of speech . Thus, the Supreme Court embraced the idea that hate speech is permissible unless it will lead to imminent hate violence.[72]
Societal Implementation[edit]
Under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, employers may sometimes be prosecuted for tolerating "hate speech" by their employees, if that speech contributes to a broader pattern of harassment resulting in a "hostile or offensive working environment" for other employees.[73][74]
In the 1980s and 1990s, more than 350 public universities adopted "speech codes" regulating discriminatory speech by faculty and students.[75] These codes have not fared well in the courts, where they are frequently overturned as violations of the First Amendment.[76] Debate over restriction of "hate speech" in public universities has resurfaced with the adoption of anti-harassment codes covering discriminatory speech.[77]
That is correct.
One of the more shocking things is the video clip they showed (if you want to see it, it starts about 12:30 into the video) when Israeli ambassador Michael Oren attempted to speak. But in that case the right to free does apply.
Why? Because while many colleges are private, this happened at University of California at Irvine. So its a public university, not a private one.
Good point. Many people think its a matter of "either/or"-- i.e. that free speech is allowed, or its not. Actually the rules re: speech vary in various democracies. The U.S. & Denmark, for example, allow a higher degree of free speech than most of Europe. (The main difference is usually that many countries include laws against "hate speech". However countries such as the U.S. & Denmark have such a strong tradition of freedom in this ara that the laws here do pemit hate speech.
However, where we do draw the line is at speech that is a clear and present danger (shouting fire in a crowded movie theatre when there is no fire) or actually inciting violence.
Can't argue with that Krish . However that still doesn't mean that one group's speech is protected from interference by another group's speech [as long as both groups are not part of government ] . Even hate speech is permitted . The SCOTUS has addressed that issue as I quoted above :
Because the hate speech ordinance was not concerned with the mode of expression, but with the content of expression, it was a violation of the freedom of speech. Thus, the Supreme Court embraced the idea that hate speech is permissible unless it will lead to imminent hate violence.[72]
Yes.
And BTW, the real agenda isn't the establishment of a Palestinian state, either. Rather, their true goal is the elimination of Israel.
Gene Simmons of KISS as well...
I can't believe it, I'm in agreement with you Robert...I'm looking for a lightening strike any moment.
BTW, their sports team name is the ''Anteaters''...I'm not sure now fitting that is, but it does invoke a giggle.
That, I can believe Krish.
Probably is...
Interestingly, while the BDS a$$holes try to drown out speakers with opposing viewpoints, Jewish campus organizations do not do this when a bigoted nutcase like Ali speaks, as they believe ifn free speech, and the open interchange of ideas.
Here's more information about this delightful character:
I don't see an issue in the Muslim student organization support of Hamas . Hamas is honest about its intents . And it is sociologically aligned with the development & values of the region . The concept is brutally simple . You want government ? Select the Baddest MF you can find . He will keep order by dint of the fear he generates . That IS what they believe in there . Why deny them their beliefs ?
Hamas' beliefs are not the problem. Rather, its their actions that are the problem!
Yes . The actions are the problem . And they will continue until the beliefs change , with occasional timeouts due to Israeli retaliation . Having Israel interfere with the beliefs by trying to impose the western [& Asian ] style beliefs in their place will only result in a reaction against Israel .
One sees that in the middle east but also in the US college demonstrations . They won't change beliefs because other beliefs are imposed , only by discovering that their beliefs make enemies and bring about retaliation . They haven't figured out the basic moral principles that so many other religions have figured out ... These principles have names like "karma" & "the golden rule" . And you cannot force those principles on people who believe differently .
My expectation is that the beliefs will remain until the ruled rise up against the rulers .
Campuses Are Safe For Pro-Israel Students
While the article posted above is old, my point is that there is nowhere enough conclusive evidence that this BDS issue has has pervaded US colleges as a whole. Suffice to say, I'm skeptical.
Petey, can you explain what you mean by that statement? I didn't think Israel is trying to impose Western beliefs in the place of the suicidal terrorism of the Palestinians. As far as Israel is concerned, Israel is saying leave us alone and we'll leave you alone to live with whatever beliefs you want. But Israel simply will not turn the other cheek (a Christian belief?) when its citizens are attacked - they will react to it. So would you.
Perrie,
Other than this one unlinked video, have you read or saw anything else about this supposed video? I haven't. More to the point, I did a good check around the net for any unbiased news sources that have reported this and found none.
Oh, I found some news items and blogs emanating from the Jewish press and their sympathizes that try to elicit some pathos ridden response about such alleged incidences but none of these reports can substantiate some large conspiratorial effort by the MSM to hide such incidences, which if they do happen, are isolated.
A female stands a greater chance of being raped on any US college campus more than a Jewish student has to face any anti-Jewish BDS related backlash.
Aeon,
While I agree that rape on college campuses is far more of an issue, I watched that video and it was rather disturbing the level of rage in which Malik expressed himself. That being said, I have two college kids and neither have seen BDS at their college.
From the Jews, eh? Well in that case it must be unreliable
/sarcasm
What is BDS??? Seriously.
BDS stands for Boycott, Divest and Sanction.
It represents the concerted movement by the alleged supporters of the Palestinian movement to cause economic harm to Israel, believing that they will bow to every Palestinian demand and forgo their own in a negotiated "peace" settlement.
Of course I would . Its just human nature to want to protect yourself .
From a belief system viewpoint it doesn't matter what Israel does or doesn't do . They are going to be accused of every crime there is and attacked with violence [in a stupid & ineffective way ] . They don't understand the western way of doing things & they don't want to even be exposed to it . However , the latter is impossible . They will be exposed to western culture just because of Israel's presence there .
Bottom line : they don't like those who are different . They are ANTI-progress . When exposed to it they will react stupidly , irrationally & violently . This will continue until the ruled resist the groups like Hamas .
Bravo! A well deserved response, Krishna.
Perhaps this site isn't quite as "Jewish" as Aeon Pax believes:
Campus Anti-Semitism
A Briefing Before The United States Commission on Civil Rights Held in Washington, D.C., November 18, 2005
Go to findings and recommendations, pages 72-73.
No . So what ? They 3 students in the linked video described the problem on 3 different campuses . One of them was afraid to return out of fear for her safety . On UC Irvine the Muslim Students Association had its operations suspended . 11 of its members are facing criminal charges .
As a whole downtown Chicago is a safe location to walk . But if you encounter Leroy Brown all bets are off :
More than that, Jonathan. The leader of BDS has clearly indicated that the real purpose of BDS is the destruction of Israel.
"Palestine is free, from the river to the sea."
That is the REAL purpose.
Many people think the Nazis in Germany came to power all of a sudden, and suddenly started all their evil actions. But the reality is, it happened over time. (And one of their early actions was to boycott Jewish-owned businesses-- it seems that the BS movement is following the Nazi example).
No one is saying that they are.
I wonder-- would you also be as skeptical if the victims were blacks? Gays?
Not unreliable, just biased.
More biased than other minorities ?
And this has what to do with the article/video I responded to?
Without proof, "danger" or "fear for ones safety is a perception. As no campus or local police reports were filed, the credibility is in question.
Your analogy has nothing to do with the topic.
There are many Arab or Muslim student groups on college that coexist peacefully with Jewish groups. Their rights are equal to and no better than that of the Jewish groups.
Three people (three incidences) out of a thousand or so colleges does not a consensus make.
Who said anything about a consensus ?
Sure . Up until they start to cross the line of legality . Then all bets are off .
Your comment from about 16 hours ago implies that the claims of anti-Semitism on campus are exaggerated. You used the term "alleged incidences". What I posted obviously addresses that.
There is also the other possibility that they feel that efforts in NK and China are impossible whereas changes in Israel are.
Just a thought.
Unlikely.
Who started BDS? I don't think it was someone who had a bone to pick with NK or China.
I'm sure I'm not going to make any friends here with this statement.
Both sides in this conflict have invented each other to be something as less than human. This is what has enabled both sides to do such horrible things to each other for so long.
I would venture to say that some of you are too close to the problem and are guilty of spewing exactly the same myopic propaganda you accuse the other side of out of reflex.
The best part of any conflict is when it ends, and its participants get to die of old age and natural causes. This should be the goal. From what I see, people just keep stoking the same old flames.
So ... you're saying you would be just as happy living in the Gaza strip as living in Israel ?
It wasn't the Israelis who determined that 1 Israeli had the same value as 1,027 Palestinians.
That really isn't the point I was making now is it?
It makes it easier to kill someone when they have been villainized or made out to be sub-human. Both sides are way guilty of this and have been doing it for so long it is now accepted practice.
Do think there is any truth in that statement Buzz?
I understand what you're saying . That approach is what is often done there . But if you think Hamas will become more amenable to "peace" if the Israelis say soothing humanizing things to them I suggest not expecting that result .
No I don't expect that either after all this time Petey....
I is just I am very tired of killing and war. I have been part of it, and as I grow older I just am sick of the waste of life and treasure.
Like so many things that become points of conflict. The original reasons are long forgotten to the point to where the only thing that the parties have is their hate.
Long ago I realized that it is easier to hate than to compromise.
Its not like there haven't been some improvements in relations with other nations and Israel .
But we also have to face facts that other forces in the area such as Al Qaeda are working hard at undoing those same improvements.
The problem with Al Qaeda is that there is no one that speaks for them as a group, thus no way to negotiate. No way to stop the killing. When you put that into perspective, there are at least people within Hamas that Israel can negotiate with if the two sides really wanted to end the killing.
It is ABSOLUTELY true. Do you really believe the Israelis were happy with that ratio? I recall that during the Cold War, when there was an exchange of captured spies, it was on a one-to-one basis.
You made a statement above lamenting the fact that enemies demonize or dehumanize each other. I was a kid during WWII and I remember seeing comic books that depicted the Nazis and the Japanese as evil sub-human monsters. And more recently, have you not heard the expression Big Satan and Little Satan?
Nope. I freely admit that the US has done it's share of demonizing in the past, and has achieved new levels of it in recent times. Hell, we do it among ourselves, and have made it almost an art form.
The question to you Buzz. If that ratio was reversed, would you believe that to be true?
Somewhere, sometime, the majority on both sides have got to stop thinking about the past and start thinking about the future. They have to stop thinking about how people have died, and how people are going to be able to live. You can take those statements as being either idealist, or realistic. It just depends on if you see further conflict as inevitable, or something that needs to end.
Because of the Jewish belief that "L'Chaim" (life) is more important as opposed to glorification of death and martyrdom on the other, I don't believe the ratio is reversible.
Personally I see the "peace negotiations" as going nowhere, and conflict inevitably continuing. What we have there is a religious requirement in Islam to never give up what was once "theirs" (Ottoman Empire) on one part and "Never Again" on the other. A solution to the conflict will not occur during my lifetime and I certainly don't feel qualified to predict what will happen beyond that.
That boils it down to it's essence pretty well Buzz. In the short term I will always hope that you and those I know will remain safe and well.
In fact, I'm going to use your quote as I see fit in the future. Nicely done.
Thank you, and you and yours remain safe as well. I'm nowhere near the Middle East, although I've been there a couple times in the past. Frankly, I feel a lot safer where I am than I would if I were in the USA.
To quote a religious requirement on the part of Judaism, there is a biblical psalm that reads "Should I forget thee, O Jerusalem, may my right hand wither and my tongue cleave to the roof of my mouth."i.e. It's not people vs people, it's religion vs religion.
I sort of disagree. Consider if you will, Yugoslavia. Under generations of rule by the dictator, Marshal Josip Broz Tito, in-fighting between the Christians and Muslims were ruthlessly suppressed. Both sides, albeit under force of threat, actually started living together in some form of tranquility.
However, when Tito died, centuries old animosities were used to fan the dying embers of such cultural and nationalistic hatreds by the likes of Slobodan Miloevi, Radovan Karadzic and Ratko Mladic, that war resulted. It happened so easily and so quickly.
I would propose the same kind of prideful enmity exists in the ME, most prominent among the Arabs and Palestinians, in regards to Israel. Other than an enforced dtente (via use of a military) it would appear that human nature along with extreme nationalism can hold on to grudges for hundreds of years. That doesnt mean peaceful solutions should be abandon.
By sort of disagreeing, you are also sort of agreeing.
I know in reality we see things much in the same way. The waste, the loss of life, and all for what? Religious beliefs that don't allow for compromise? Saving face?
You and I are definitely after the same thing in both our hearts and our heads. Disagree with me all you want AP as I think the end results for the two of us are usually identical.
And sometimes conflicts perpetuate because they are continuously funded by well-meaning (?) organizations like UNRWA.
Negotiating does not seem to be part of middle eastern culture . Apparently one can only negotiate from a position of strength . If you don't have that you are expected to yield & become a "Dhimmi" .
I don't buy into the ME situation as being about religion. There are hundreds of millions dollars being thrown at the Palestinians in the form of arms, to keep the entire region unstable. Why?
It's basically the regional sport ...
Few are willing to admit why.
The Palestiniansare there now, in their present state, because they are viewed as less than second-class by the rest of the Arab world only to be valuedfor their usage as cannon fodder, and are obviously willing to be used so. The Palestinian's are the bait on the end of the Arab's 150lb.-test line.
Basically, its an attempt to falsely delegitimize Israel, and to ultimately bring about its destruction.
(Usually they are non-violent, but occasionally intimidate Jewish students by death threats, etc.)
1 - Can the Godwin stuff. It's so overused it has become meaningless.
2 - "No one is saying that they are." - We are in agreement.
3 - "would you also be as skeptical if the victims were blacks? Gays?" - Yes. While I support black, gay and woman's rights, I am not blinded by my ideology as some are. For an injustice to be corrected, there must be a preponderance of evidence that such an act was actually committed. The article did not pass that test.
BDS is clearly opposed to free speech. The idea of having both sides of a discussion presented clearly freaks them out.
Check out what happened when Oren tried to speak (starts about 12:30 or 12:35 into the video).
Yup.
I just came across this (a backlash against the extremism of the BDS crowd):
Interesting article, & some interesting comments as well. ( Link )
Shouting down and intimidation is not IMO an exercise in free speech, but a prevention of it. Those who support it as free speech or freedom of expression are no better than a dictatorship that censors and blocks freedom of expression and thereby are destroying democracy.
Not satisfied with their victory of the symbolic vote, they had to jeer at boo at their classmates... Jews... who walked out after the vote.
But let's all fool ourselves that anti-Semitism is not escalating in the Western world, which would have to be the wall that stands between Israel and the wave of anti-Jewish miasma that is flowing over the planet.
The last bastion of tolerance and forward-thinking individuals has always been the colleges and universities of Democratic countries. For these students to behave in such a manner toward those with whom they attend classes and share dorm rooms with certainly speaks to the truth of bullying and validates the feeling of a lack of safety for Jewish students at educational institutions.
Whi just goes to show you that mature intelligent adults have more wisdom and patience than immature propaganda-poisoned children.
When will those ignorant propaganda-infected immature kids grow up and accumulate enough wisdom to understand how they have been misled by the nose by a false prophet? Thank heavens the Ryerson University administration has the intelligence, maturity and common sense to know and stand up for the truth.
"The truth is on the march, and nothing will stop it." (Emile Zola)