╌>

Should We Get Completely Out of Afghanistan?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jerry-verlinger  •  12 years ago  •  69 comments

Should We Get Completely Out of Afghanistan?

Americans are tired of Afghanistan, many say we should pull out of there completely. Others say, if we do that the Taliban will take over, giving them a place to flourish and enabling them to continue spreading terrorism around the world .

taliban_supporters_1368931c.jpg?width=350 I'm with the pull out completely crowd. The Taliban is an Islamic fundamentalist political movement that originally went to Afghanistan from Pakistan. They are part of a culture that literally goes back to the 1st millennium and they are not going to stop spreading terrorism, because they are part of the culture of that region. Even if we could eliminate them in Afghanistan, they will simply flourish in Pakistan and/or Iran, spreading their terrorism from wherever they decide to gather.

Taliban supporters march in Pakistan (Photo: AP)

We, and the Russians before us, have been trying to eliminate the Taliban by shooting them all for the last 20 plus years. It has not worked, and it is not going to work because Al Qaeda and the Taliban are culture that is intellectually stuck in the last millennium, and we cannot shoot a culture to death.

The only way the Taliban and al Qaeda can be eliminated is by changing the culture of the entire region, and that we cannot do because we don't really understand the culture and are not a part of the culture. However, we can help re-educate the people of that culture and bring them into the 21st century.

The change must come within the people through education and enlightenment. We can help them do that by providing funds for education, and send educational assistance.

Desks are cheaper than weapons, and teachers do not come home in caskets.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    12 years ago

Absolutely we should get out!

We should have been out after the battle of Tora Bora in December of 2001!

We have done nothing but wasted blood and treasure since.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

reuters_logo.jpg?width=80 NY Times Afghanistan's President Hamid Karzai has been holding secret talks with Taliban officials in the hope of persuading them to make peace with his government, the New York Times reported on Tuesday [ Feb.4, 2014 ], citing unnamed Afghan and Western officials.

In November - around the same time the secret talks reportedly began - Karzai announced his intention to avoid signing a bilateral security deal with the United States until after a presidential election in April. Karzai has served two terms and cannot run again.

President Barack Obama, frustrated by Karzai's refusal to sign the accord, was due to meet top commanders at the White House on Tuesday to discuss the future of the U.S. mission in Afghanistan.

Read article ;

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    12 years ago

Yes

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     12 years ago

Get out now!!!

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Yes

And we should take out money out of Afghanistan going forward as well

 
 
 
retired military ex Republican
Freshman Silent
link   retired military ex Republican    12 years ago
Yes but big business and China don't want that to happen.
 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    12 years ago

Get out now before the Obama administration sends more men and women to their graves. Add it to our long list of lost wars. Let it be a lesson learned in government incompetence. Mothball our military and return the money being wasted to the taxpayers pocket.

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    12 years ago

We have no obligation to provide anything for Afghanistan. Pull all the troops out now and cut off every last cent in future aid. I would make an exception to the loyal translators and others who have saved American and coalition lives. We cannot leave them to the mercies of the Taliban. As for Karzai, it wouldn't bother me one bit if he receives the same fate as previous Afghan ruler, Najibullah (you can check Wikipedia for all the gruesome details).

Let them enjoy the "benefits" of the 7th century Islamic culture they have chosen. We have already wasted far too many lives and money in a futile attempt to assist them.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Absolutely we should get out!

I don't think we should have gone in there in the first place.

It was just like Nam, the French were in there for years trying to fix animpossibleproblem with the Khmer Rouge before they gaveup, so then we go in to show them how do it should be done.

Well, we all know how that worked out.

But do we learn? Yeah we do, but the All American Right Wing needs to keep it's military/Industrial campaign donors happy, so when theRussianspulled out of the same kind ofimpossibleproblem withtheTaliban inAfghanistan, in we go to save the day.

Now, after losing over 2,200 American Troops and spending well over 4 TRILLION! dollars, Americans have had enough.

We need to start putting our money in education and infrastructure or our economic competitors around the world are going to overtake us.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    12 years ago

no, in order to try and limit the enemies retaking all gains, alqueada running back to fly the flag over towns we have builtup with blood and treasure....obama should put joe biden in charge of negotiating a small remaining presence in the region. perhaps involving hillary with her indisputable resume.

otherwise, all those deaths would be for naught, all our billions would be thrown down the tubes, our enemy would be more emboldened, mass rapes and murder would resume, human rights would be destroyed again, and we would be less safe.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Teachers don't come home in caskets.

Yes they do. As do doctors. Nurses. Healthcare workers.

Not by the thousands.

The change must come within the people through education and enlightenment

Are presumptions too. As to what education means.

Education! You know, teaching people how to improve their lives.

As to what is "enlightened."

You wouldn't understand.

And as to who should be educated.

Everybody.

Does a young girl really need to become an Islamic scholar?

If that's what she want to become, why should she be denied?

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Yes but big business and China don't want that to happen.

Exactly.

From my comment above;

".....the All American Right Wing needs to keep it's military/Industrial campaign donors happy, ......Now, after losing over2,200American Troops and spending well over4TRILLION!dollars, Americans have had enough. "

"We need to start putting our money in education and infrastructure or our economic competitors around the world are going to overtake us."

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    12 years ago

Jun 22, 2011 Obama called Afghanistan the "good" war...period

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Get out now before the Obama administration sends more men and women to their graves.

WTF?!

Afghanistan is not Obamas' war, he has been pulling troops out of Afghanistan since he took office.

Add it to our long list of lost wars. Let it be a lesson learned in government incompetence. Mothball our military and return the money being wasted to the taxpayers pocket.

I agree with most of the rest of your comment, however the money needs to go into education and our infrastructure, not the taxpayers pockets.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

We have already wasted far too many lives and money in a futile attempt to assist them.

Yeah, like an estimated 4 to 6 TRILLION! dollars and over 2,200 American lives.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

"....obama should put joe biden in charge of negotiating a small remaining presence in the region."

Not such an easy problem to solve Joanne, see related article;

NY Times Report: Says Karzai In Secret Talks With Taliban

Excerpt;

In November - around the same time the secret talks reportedly began - Karzai announced his intention to avoid signing a bilateral security deal with the United States until after a presidential election in April. Karzai has served two terms and cannot run again.

President Barack Obama, frustrated by Karzai's refusal to sign the accord, was due to meet top commanders at the White House on Tuesday to discuss the future of the U.S. mission in Afghanistan.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Rolls eyes.

Typical response from Right Wingers when the word "education" come up.

Too many people have no idea what is going on.

Exactly, that's my point. There is more education needed, on both sides of the pond.

No idea what "education" means to Muslims in Afghanistan.

What does it mean Robert?

No idea that the most important and most respected "educators" are mullahs.

Just why is that seen as a problem to you? Apparently you have some preconceived ideas about the issue.

In Afghanistan, Mullahs Use Islam to Protect Women and their Rights

cq5dam.web.460.306.jpeg?width=200

Abdul Wasa Antazar, Depuity of Rodad District in Nangarhar Province of Afghaanistan, speaks during a training about Womens Rights in April 2102.

[Photo: Farzana Wahidy/UNDP Aafghanistan]

The Government of Afghanistan is tapping mullahs and religious elders to make people aware of the rights women are entitled to in accordance with Islamic laws through a programme supported by the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP).

The national programme, which is being implemented by the Ministry of Haj and Religious Affairs and the Ministry of Women Affairs, is requiring mullahs and other Islamic and community leaders to raise awareness about the consequences of early marriage, forced marriage and gender-based violence. Participants also discuss inheritance issues, including a comparison between what Islamic law says about a womans right to inheritance and what happens in practice.
Read the full article :

No idea that they think schools for girls are silly, but also a dangerous corruption of society.

Yeah, right. Like I said, you have preconceived ideas about what's going on. Bad habit ofyours Robert.

So they burn down those schools. Terrorize those who would attend.

No question there are still terrorist in Afghanistan that Will try to do that. That'swhy it's necessary to leave a contingency force in place to assist the Afghan security forces to maintainorder.

But you're thinking the Thomas Jefferson Elementary school.

Whatever.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

No, Jerry.

In the future it might be a good idea to do some research before you say that.

After Obama took office the Pentagon was clamoring for more troops in Afghanistan. About 40,000 if I recall correctly. So Obama met with his military commanders and discussed the issue atlength, then after carefully considering his options, a delay that theRight criticized him for, he decided to give the Generals 14,000 of the 40,000 they wanted. Which resulted if the so called "surge".

Now these additional troops wereapparentlynecessarilyin order to get control over certain strategicareas, so we could safely extract the majority of our forces withoutleaving the contingency troops being left behind in any more danger than necessary.

So ofcoursethere was a rise in the death toll when the surgeoccurred, there wasincreasedaction,but that was theactionthe Commanders convinced thePresident theyneeded in order to get us out of George Bushes' war.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

The US invasion of Afghanistan (unlike Iraq) met all the qualifications of a "Just War". Unfortunately, our stay turned into an "occupying force" far beyond what the "Just War" tenets support.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    12 years ago

Out after the battle of Tora Bora in December of 2001!

Unfortunately, those that drafted and implemented the "Project for the New American Century" had other ideas.....

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    12 years ago

jerry dear, i was being sarcastic

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

The US invasion of Afghanistan (unlike Iraq) met all the qualifications of a "Just War".

Maybe so, but was it legal?

Marjorie Cohn, a well-known professor of international law, wrote in November 2001:

The bombings of Afghanistan by the United States and the United Kingdom are illegal.[2]

In 2008, Cohn repeated this argument in an article entitled Afghanistan: The Other Illegal War. The point of the title was that, although it was by then widely accepted that the war in Iraq was illegal, the war in Afghanistan, in spite of the fact that many Americans did not realize it, was equally illegal.[3] Her argument was based on the following facts:

First, according to international law as codified in the UN Charter, disputes are to be brought to the UN Security Council, which alone may authorize the use of force. Without this authorization, any military activity against another country is illegal.

Second, there are two exceptions: One is that, if your nation has been subjected to an armed attack by another nation, you may respond militarily in self-defense. This condition was not fulfilled by the 9/11 attacks, however, because they were not carried out by another nation: Afghanistan did not attack the United States. Indeed, the 19 men charged with the crime were not Afghans.

The other exception occurs when one nation has certain knowledge that an armed attack by another nation is imminent too imminent to bring the matter to the Security Council. The need for self-defense must be, in the generally accepted phrase, instant, overwhelming, leaving no choice of means, and no moment for deliberation. Although the US government claimed that its military operations in Afghanistan were justified by the need to prevent a second attack, this need, even if real, was clearly not urgent, as shown by the fact that the Pentagon did not launch its invasion until almost a month later.

U.S. political leaders have claimed, to be sure, that the UN did authorize the US attack on Afghanistan. This claim, originally made by the Bush-Cheney administration, was repeated by President Obama in his West Point speech of December 1, 2009, in which he said: The United Nations Security Council endorsed the use of all necessary steps to respond to the 9/11 attacks, so US troops went to Afghanistan [u]nder the banner of . . . international legitimacy.[4]

However, the language of all necessary steps is from UN Security Council Resolution 1368, in which the Council, taking note of its own responsibilities under the Charter, expressed its own readiness to take all necessary steps to respond to the terrorist attacks of 11 September 2001.[5]

Of course, the UN Security Council might have determined that one of these necessary steps was to authorize an attack on Afghanistan by the United States. But it did not. Resolution 1373, the only other Security Council resolution about this issue, laid out various responses, but these included matters such as freezing assets, criminalizing the support of terrorists, exchanging police information about terrorists, and prosecuting terrorists. The use of military force was not mentioned.[6]

The U.S. war in Afghanistan was not authorized by the UN Security Council in 2001 or at anytime since, so this war began as an illegal war and remains an illegal war today. Our governments claim to the contrary is false.

This war has been illegal, moreover, not only under international law, but also under U.S. law. The UN Charter is a treaty, which was ratified by the United States, and, according to Article VI of the US Constitution, any treaty ratified by the United States is part of the supreme law of the land.[7] The war in Afghanistan, therefore, has from the beginning been in violation of US as well as international law. It could not be more illegal.
[Source: The Foreign Policy Journal ]

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    12 years ago

What if, rather than simply abandon any meaning from this situation, we instead switched from purchasing all our pharma grade opium from Turkey to partnering with Afghani growers (warlords) to provide a cheaper pharma opium option for us. That would secure far more funding for the Afghani infrastructure, give us a return on our efforts there, and secure another place for the U.S. to operate out of in the region? I'm sure this isnt necessarily a popular viewpoint, but it would provide dividends and some sort of meaning for our involvement there outside of trying to win a war that cant be won.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

jerry dear, i was being sarcastic

I detected thesarcasm dear, I just wanted to point out,sarcasmnotwithstanding, thattheKarzai accord problem is not to betrivialised. If we cannot leave a contingency force in Afghanistan to assist the Afghan security forces, the Taliban will take over the county within weeks. Then, as you pointed out in another comment, all our sacrifice over the past ten years will been for naught.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    12 years ago

as biden failed to do, in iraq

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

"......partnering with Afghani growers (warlords) ............................. I'm sure this isnt necessarily a popular viewpoint,........"

Very thought provoking and interesting idea Pedro, logistically I think it could work, and even possibly open the way for meaningful negotiations to end the violence. However, I think you providedthemost likely response to your suggestion, because it is too unorthodox an idea.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

as biden failed to do, in iraq

Please explain.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Not even close enough to earn you a trip to the next level, Jerry.

Don't worry about my level Robert, you need to be more concerned about what level you're on.

So I got the numbers wrong, I remember the Generals got fewer troops than they asked for (they likely expected that) and I know there was a 14,000 in there someplace. So they asked for 40 something, he gave them 30 something with a 14k +- difference.

Your detailed breakdown is of no value because it's the overall picture that's important, and understanding what it means.

Obama takes office with a war going on he and most Americans want to get out of, and although he may be the Commander-in-Chief, he's not a field commander. So he calls together the Pentagon, the Chiefs of Staff and the Field Commanders and asks them what it's going to take to get us out in one piece without losing the gains we've made.

They tell him they need 40 some odd thousand troops, ex amount of equipment and probably give him some kind of time frame. Obama contacts the Heads of State of all the allies involved in the mess, tells them what he wants to do and gets their feedback,includinghow much additional assistance, if any, they will contribute to the effort.

Then, after evaluating all the feedback he's getting from the allies, getsanswersto allthe questions he has asked the Field Commanders re; strategy, timing etc., he goes home andcogitates.

Finally, after much more cogitating than the media had patience for, he makes his announcement to move forward. Telling the Brass he's giving them 30 something thou in troops plus whatever in hardware, and has the Generals start working on the strategy to get of out of Bushes war.

So, of course there was an escalation in KIAs, we had to put in more troops and escalate the action in order toimplementan exit strategy, what did anybody expect?

But the question is not what happened in the past over there. It's what are we going to do moving forward? Should we get 100% out of there, or should we leave 60+thousand troops behind to help the Karzai government keep order?

(I was tempted to say "the corrupt Karzaigovernment", but I dont' want to appear to be bias, so I won't say it)

We needto say "fuck it', and we need to get out of there and we need to let them suffer their own fate.I really believe that's what we should do.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    12 years ago

It would be unorthodox for sure. I think we (U.S. Gov't) are capable of thinking outside of the box every so often though.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    12 years ago

Ummm....Afghani of course! Sheesh!

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    12 years ago

Ummm.....Afghani Kush!

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

I just stated facts,

You posted stats, Stats that add nothing ofsignificanceto the discussion.

compelled to after you said I didn't know what I was talking about.

I didn't say you don't know what your talking about. I just implied you are wrong. Perhaps your the one that's thinking you don't know what your talking about after reading my response.

After you had statedthat Obama didn't add any troops.

I didn't say Obama didn't add any troops, I said he didn't add as many troops as the Generals requested.

McCrystal thought we need 500,000 troops if you want the whole range of military opinions covered.

500,000 troops was the total strength McCystal wanted to see in Afghanistan, we're discussion the increase required for the surge.

Studied for a year, before coming up with a polticy.

Bush didn't need to study a problem, he used "gut reaction"

The rest of your comments is little more than parroted Right Wing talking points.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

I was responding to acommentmade by Dean M.;

Get out now before the Obama administration sends more men and women to their graves.

WTF?!

Afghanistan is not Obamas' war, he has been pulling troops out of Afghanistan since he took office.

Then you and I got into the discussion about the surge, where I proved my point ... as usual, and you failed to prove your point ..... as usual.

Anyway arguing about stats is boring, so let's quit while I'm ahead.

At least you finished with a tie on the "Should we get out" issue.

Apparently we agree on something. Quit while you're even.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

"....Pakistan's military government was the difference between success and failure in Pakistan."

".....mastering the intricacies of Islam 's role in democracy in Afghanistan...."

"Pakistan has alternated between military rule and corrupt families taking turns as elected governents, since Pakistan became a government."

The above excerpts from your comment describe, to a small degree, just how intricate and complicated the problems that our State Department has to deal with in that region. Administrating foreignpolicy in the middle east is like playing multi level chess.

I have toconcentratefairly hard toprevail on a single, untimed chessboard when playing anexperienced opponent. Keep in mind that the leaders and diplomats of other countries are, for the most part, intelligent and clever men, and foreign policy is no simple chess game.

Once they knew were were leaving ,

Think chess game.

they had no reason to do more than hold out until we are out of their hair.

The Afghani people do not want us to leave, they know they're at great risk without our military presence, but t looks like Karzai would like us out of his hair. (Think chess game)

Helping us gets their own cities bombed.

(?!)

Our leaders are fools, Jerry.

WE THE PEOPLE ..... that's who elects our leaders. So who is at fault here, our leaders or the people that elected them?

Maybe you should run for public office, perhaps you have have the political chess skills needed to manage some of our problems.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

They have both proven to be inept regarding how long they kept American troops there.

I wouldn't say Obama "kept" them there. Apparently, afterconferringwith the Generals on the ground, hefound it was not possible to simply pull our people out. There are always logistical problems to be dealt with when withdrawing. troops, especially with the presence of enemy forces.

It's easy to kibitz, but we don't know all the facts.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

You can't pin this on "liberals" per se. There are way too many of them whom disagree with his performance and strategies especially on his war mongering ways.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

True that.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

There are way too many of them whom disagree with his performance and strategies especially on his war mongering ways.

Are you one of them Aeon?

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

I am pinning it on the president who deceived liberals.

The president didn'tdeceivethe liberals,theliberals deceived the liberals. They thought Obama was a liberal because he's black and he's a Democrat.

The neocons think Obama is a flaming liberal. The flaming liberals think he's a fuckingfascist. The truth of the matter is he's really a moderate and moderates please no one accept other moderates.

Now ..... define moderate.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

The U.S. Has Finally Outfoxed Hamid Karzai

For months, Afghan President Hamid Karzai has refused to sign a long-term security agreement with the United States, causing mounting frustration within the White House and the Pentagon. Now, it appears as if President Obama and his advisers have finally outfoxed Karzai, marking the end of a long and tumultuous relationship.
The White House and DOD have decided not to make any agreement until after Aprils presidential elections in which Karzai is not expected to be a candidate. Theyll only make a deal with Karzais successor, according to a report in the Wall Street Journal, and will no longer deal with the current Afghan president.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    12 years ago

Don't you think that with some real effort we could have all our troops and equipment out by the April elections?

I always thought that it was a tactical military advantage to be able to get out of trouble FASTER than you got into it.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

Obama is a corporatist and he's not even moderate about it.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    12 years ago

A moderate is one who doubles our debt, sends men to the grave for no reason, murders American citizens without a trial, spies on American citizens without a warrant, balloons the welfare, disability population for political gain while kissing his crony capitalist campaign contributors asses handing them billions stolen from the taxpayers.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

I'm an American who feels Obama wishy-washy style has sold out to the bankers and corporations.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Today's news....

Karzai is releasing a truck load of terrorists from prison that we put there, against express wishes of our government and caution that they may rejoin the Taliban.

Nevertheless, they were released.

Time for our guys to come home. All of them.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

The first time our Afghan allies turn their guns on our men could have been called a tragic fluke. But the second time it happened, particularly when an Afghan high level commander invited two of ours for dinner, sat down at a table with them, then pulled out a gun and shot them dead at point blank range... THAT is when we should have pulled everything we had out of that crap hole.

To keep our men there facing the threat of death at the hands of men and women wearing the uniform of those who are supposed to friendly allies, never knowing when the bullet or knife or suicide bomb is going to get you, then if you make it home having to fight tooth and nail for every VA benefit you get, is asking too much.

Hell yes, we should already have been out of there, along with the billions of dollars we stuffed down the pants of Karzai and his brother who bought property in Dubai.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

I posted that news item not because I agree with it but because it demonstrates the horribly low standards that are commonly used to evaluate Obama's performance . As I've been saying for quite a few months now , Obama is neither venal nor evil , only incompetent . His performance is judged not as a "real" president would be but only as an affirmative action student would be judged ... graded on a severe curve .

 
 
 
Cletus Wilbury
Freshman Silent
link   Cletus Wilbury    12 years ago

Your humor is good. Reminds me of what one Senator said of the proposed purchase of Alaska:

If Seward is force to live there, and the Russian army makes sure he can't leave.

(paraphrased)

I'll guess that was also a joke.

 
 
 
Cletus Wilbury
Freshman Silent
link   Cletus Wilbury    12 years ago

I agree it qualified, and supported it at the time, through the 2008 election at least.

 
 
 
Cletus Wilbury
Freshman Silent
link   Cletus Wilbury    12 years ago

Legalistically, it got UN approval and eventually involvement.

At least, I though so. It sure looks like it.

UN Security Council Resolution 1510

 
 
 
Cletus Wilbury
Freshman Silent
link   Cletus Wilbury    12 years ago

Obama is neither venal nor evil , only incompetent .

Fair enough.

 
 
 
Cletus Wilbury
Freshman Silent
link   Cletus Wilbury    12 years ago

Looks like all but one here have had enough of boots in Afghanistan.

On the 'all our efforts will have been wasted' issue, that's a really bad way to think about military strategy. When you're losing at one position, at some point you have to realize when it's time to cut your loses.

See Stalingrad, for one example of bad strategy.

(screw Goodwin)

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

The U.S. Has Finally Outfoxed Hamid Karzai

Meantime Karzai releases 65 potential terrorist back into the countryside.

" Afghan officials described the release as justice for its own citizens who had faced unfounded U.S. accusations. But the United States expressed deep concern over the decision and NATO, which runs the 12-year-old foreign military operation supporting the Karzai government, denounced it as "a major step backward". "

[Reuters ]

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

They're extinct now.

Not quite.

If it weren't for us old stone agers, you young radicals wouldn't even know where the lights are.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Spoken like a true typically misinformed Conservative.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Is that why you call him acorporatist?

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

I have said it over and over... countries have to grow into a democracy by blood, sweat and tears and will of the entire citizenry of the people, over THEIRefforts and THEIR sacrifices and THEIR vision of what they want their government to be... not ours.

Their people do not have the most basic education, sophistication, worldly mind set, nor exposure to the concept of self governance to even begin to have a military force come in, topple their ruling structure, and say, "Okay, now you are a democracy."

We have had ours for over two hundred years, a school system that teaches Civics, an open education system for anyone that wants to learn, open media that talks politics 24/7, access to libraries with computers and daily newspapers... and well over half the population in this country couldn't begin to explain the process of our government's democratic republic.

Trying to "give" every country around the globe a democracy has created nothing but chaos.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

I have said it over and over... countries have to grow into a democracy by blood, sweat and tears and will of the entire citizenry of the people, over THEIRefforts and THEIR sacrifices and THEIR vision of what they want their government to be... not ours.

Well said Screamin, keep saying it as loudly and often as possible, perhaps eventually Americans will realize not everybody wants to be like us.

Sometimeseven I don't want to be like us.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

See Stalingrad, for one example of bad strategy.

The Battle of Stalingrad, badstrategyand all, was over in less than a year. We've been in bad strategy mode in Afghanistan for 10 years.!

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Save the last drone for Karzai.

A rare kudos from JV to Robert G113.gif

 
 
 
retired military ex Republican
Freshman Silent
link   retired military ex Republican    12 years ago

I don't believe Corporate America will allow that the deaths are so minimum compared with the trillions of dollars being made by the Military Establishment number one.

Our number one source of commodities across the board and getting bigger is China and they have the Oil Contract to develop the oil production IN AFGHANISTAN and the sources are gigantic. Afghanistan has the lions percentage of almost every known raw material used by the worlds Industrial base. Stay and fight for it or pay through the nose to China or some other top industrial country like we used to be. Now even our shoes and under ware and Chicken comes from China. Dog Food from China. We are screwed we have destroyed our own industrial base by the billionaires and millionaires who love the almighty dollar more that their own Country. Get the hell out of Afghanistan we are being duped. Send Romney to his favored country where he has lists of thousands of women who want to work in his factories in China.

We need to invest in our Public schools and expand the technical schooling in these public schools. If we wanted our children to learn Religion that is what Sunday school and Church is for. Wake up the American People Extreme Politics are becoming Religion based. Kill the trend stop using our Tax Dollars that are used to fund private Schools. Equal education for every one not just the Rich. Get out of Afghanistan now. TEACHING THERE MIGHT BE THE FAR BETTER ANSWER.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

We need to invest in our Public schools and expand the technical schooling in these public schools.

I couldn't agree with you more RM, that's exactly whatthePresident has been preaching for the past 5years. However we need bi-partisan agreement in congress to pass legislation that will accomplish that end.

The problem is, to a Right Winger, investing in schools and education is soft liberal 'pussy talk'. It doesn't win wars and isn't 'macho' enough ...... and, it doesn't put any money in the pockets of the all powerfulmilitary/industrialcomplex crowd that President Dwight Eisenhower (a five star general) warned us about in 1957.

To a Native American; (a quoteattributedtotheoldIroquoisNation)

"A society grow great when old men plant trees whose shade they know they will never sit under."

That, is what investing in education is all about.

But try selling it to the GOP

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

We got out of Vietnam within weeks/months once the decision was made.

Once the decision was made? The decision to get out of a war as soon as possible is made the day we get involved.

we got out of Vietnam in days/weeks. Obama could also do that if he wanted to.

Oh really! (The Viet Nam war lasted over 10 years)

To make such a comment you must be privy to all the logistics and other variables we have to deal with in order to safely wind down a conflict that has gone on for 12+ years, so why don't you send the Pentagon a memo and explain to them how to do it?

How about the war in Northwest Pakistan, we've been there for 10 years, do you have a plan for that also?

 
 

Who is online

JohnRussell


89 visitors