╌>

Boycott of Israeli Academic Institutions is Bigotry Personified

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  buzz-of-the-orient  •  13 years ago  •  61 comments

Boycott of Israeli Academic Institutions is Bigotry Personified

Boycott of Israeli Academic Institutions is Bigotry Personified

By Alan M. Dershowitz, The Gatestone Institute, December 17, 2013

You would think that historians and others who belong to the American Studies Association would understand that in light of the history of discrimination against Jews, you can't just pick the Jewish state and Jewish universities as the place to "start" and stop.

President Mahmoud Abbas of the Palestinian Authority himself opposes academic boycotts of Israeli institutions.

The American Studies Association [ASA] has just issued its first ever call for an academic boycott. No, it wasn't against China,which imprisons dissenting academics. It wasn't against Iranwhich executes dissenting academics. It wasn't against Russiawhose universities fire dissenting academics. It wasn't against Cubawhose universities have no dissenting academics. It wasn't against Saudi Arabia,whose academic institutions refuse to hire women, gay or Christian academics. Nor was it against the Palestinian Authority, whose colleges refuse to allow open discourse regarding the Israeli Palestinian conflict. No, it was against only academic institutions in the Jewish State of Israel, whose universities have affirmative action programs for Palestinian students and who boast a higher level of academic freedom than almost any country in the world.

When the association was considering this boycott I issued a challenge to its members, many of whom are historians. I asked them to name a single country in the history of the world faced with threats comparable to those Israel faces that has had a better record of human rights, a higher degree of compliance with the rule of law, a more demanding judiciary, more concern for the lives of enemy civilians, or more freedom to criticize the government, than the state of Israel. Not a single member of the association came up with a name of a single country. That is because there are none. Israelis not perfect, but neither is any other country, and Israelis far better than most. If an academic group chooses to engage in the unacademic exercise of boycotting the academic institutions of another country, it should do it in order of the seriousness of the human rights violations and of the inability of those within the country to seek redress against those violations. By these standards, Israeli academic institutions should be among the last to be boycotted.

I myself disagree with Israel's settlement policy and have long urged an end to the occupation. But Israeloffered to end the occupation twice in the last 13 years. They did so in 2000-2001 when Prime Minister Ehud Barak offered the Palestinians a state on approximately 95% of the occupied territories. Then it did so again in 2008 when former Prime Minister Ehud Olmert offered an even more generous deal. The Palestinians accepted neither offer and certainly share the blame for the continuing occupation. Efforts are apparently underway once again to try to end the occupation, as peace talks continue. President Mahmoud Abbas of the Palestinian Authority himself opposes academic boycotts of Israeli institutions.

China occupies Tibet, Russiaoccupies Chechnyaand several other countries occupy Kurdish lands. In those cases no offers have been made to end the occupation. Yet no boycotts have been directed against the academic institutions of those occupying countries.

When ASA president Curtis Marez, an associate professor of ethnic studies at the Universityof Californiawas advised that many nations, including all of Israel's neighbors, are far worse than Israel, he responded, "One has to start somewhere." This boycott, however, has not only started with Israel. It will end with Israel.Marez's absurd comment reminds me of the bigoted response made by Harvard's notorious anti-Semitic president A. Laurence Lowell, when he imposed anti-Jewish quotas near the beginning of the 20thcentury. When asked why he singled out Jews for quotas, he replied, "Jews cheat." When the great Judge Learned Hand reminded him that Christians cheat too, Lowellresponded, "You're changing the subject. We are talking about Jews now."

You would think that historians and others who belong to the American Studies Association would understand that in light of the history of discrimination against Jews, you can't just pick the Jewish state and Jewish universities as the place to "start" and stop.

The ASA claims that it is not boycotting individual Israeli professors, but only the universities at which they teach. That is a nonsensical word game, since no self-respecting Israeli professor would associate with an organization that singled out Israeli colleges and universities for a boycott. Indeed, no self-respecting American professor should in any way support the bigoted actions of this association.

Several years ago, when a similar boycott was being considered, a group of American academics circulated a counter-petition drafted by Nobel Prize Physicist Steven Weinberg and me that read as follows:

We are academics, scholars, researchers and professionals of differing religious and political perspectives. We all agree that singling out Israelis for an academic boycott is wrong. To show our solidarity with our Israeli academics in this matter, we, the undersigned, hereby declare ourselves to be Israeli academics for purposes of any academic boycott. We will regard ourselves as Israeli academics and decline to participate in any activity from which Israeli academics are excluded.

More than 10,000 academics signed this petition including many Nobel Prize winners, presidents of universities and leading scholars from around the world.

Shame on those members of the American Studies Association for singling out the Jew among nations. Shame on them for applying a double standard to Jewish universities. Israeli academic institutions are strong enough to survive this exercise in bigotry. The real question is, will this association survive its complicity with the oldest and most enduring prejudice?


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

I truly cannot understand how intelligent academics can decide to cut themselves off from institutions and their staff who provide amazing technological, medical and other scientific benefits to the world. To me it is no different than book burning.

And this is in the light of Abbas himself announcing that boycotting Israel is wrong, and only causes strife.

Mind you, it's not as if I haven't seen closed minds on social news sites.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    13 years ago

The answer is in your statement: Intelligent Academics. Not all Academics are near as intelligent as they think they are. A prime example is the ASA President, Curtis Marez.

You expect this from Hollywood types that think because they are stars, their opinion and intelligence is suddenly somehow more important. Academics display their arrogance and prejudices but rarely do they hit the radar of the national news media, as the MSM is pretty much on the same page with them.

I'm guessing they don't like social media so much becuase they have no way to control the voices like they can do with their students.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

''Intelligent Academics'', there seems to be quite the question about their intelligence Buzz.

Sadly, it's their ilk that are teaching the next generation.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    13 years ago

So, according to the author, all of the other ills of the world need to be taken care of before protesting an itty bitty one?

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    13 years ago

Why not take on, let's say, Iran, where the are killing homosexuals....because? Because they are homosexuals? And all the other dictatorships who kill their people every single day, but don't take 1/10th of the crap that Israel takes for responding to the attacks and the killing of their own...

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Then John, how would YOU have established the 'double standard' to which Israel is forced to rebut? It wasn't "They do it so why can't we?" It's "Why is it ONLY us?"

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago
 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   Len    13 years ago

A Slap in the Face for Anti-Israel BDS Movement

by Khaled Abu Toameh December 17, 2013 at 5:00 am

Abbas's stance against the BDS campaign should serve as a wake up call to all its supporters, especially those who are not Palestinians, that negative campaigns only serve to promote hatred and extremism in the region.

Many Palestinians seem to share Abbas's view. That is why many Palestinians continue to do business with Israelis on a daily basis and continue to hold joint conferences in Israel and different parts of the world.

329.jpg
US President Barack Obama and PA President Mahmoud Abbas meet at the memorial service of Nelson Mandela in South Africa. In a press conference, Abbas denounced the BDS campaign against Israel. (Image Source: GCIS)

The international campaign for boycott, divestment and sanctions [BDS] against Israel received a slap in the face last week from Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas.

As BDS supporters continue to campaign against Israel around the world, Abbas, asked about his position regarding the BDS campaign at a press conference in Johannesburg, where he was attending Nelson Mandela's funeral, stated that he does not support the boycott of Israel.

It is ironic that while Abbas is saying no to a boycott of Israel, the American Studies Association, an association of U.S. professors with almost 5,000 members, voted to endorse an academic boycott of Israeli colleagues and universities.

Continue Reading

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

The "American Studies Association" isn't the only group here boycotting academic co-operation here;

"The general membership of the Association for Asian American Studies has unanimously approved a resolution endorsing the boycott of Israeli universities, making it the first scholarly organization in the U.S. to do so, according to the U.S. Campaign for the Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel." - ...

Maybe it's a branch of the same group, I don't know. Anyways, it's stupid.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

That's not fair Buzz. I have known Brolly for a long time, and that isn't his position on things. I realize that the last couple of days have some nerves on edge, but let's not look into every comment for hidden agendas.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

My kids go to Johns Hopkins, but are pre-med, so they didn't know anything about this, and I assumed since the bulk of the school was either pre-med or engineering that it wasn't going on there. Much to my surprise and horror, I found that the ASA is published by Johns Hopkins!!

...

I think most parents don't know this and I am going to speak with my pocketbook.

Also it is interesting to note that I couldn't find a single Jewish name among their officers.

I think you might find your explanation there.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    13 years ago

Is Russia the only country that mistreats LGBT? Somehow I doubt it. I remember a boycott that was organized once here in Chicago against a local TV station because they allegedly did not have enough minority employees.

There is a difference between a company boycotting gays and an entire country boycotting them from an international game.

Any academic who boycotts Israeli institutions iscutting off a nose to spite a face. I refuse touse the word "intelligent" to describe such idiocy.

Israel is always facing a double standard, regardless of the subject at hand.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

When I was in my final year of high school I intended to study medicine, and in fact did enter the pre-med couirse at a Canadian university. However, I had also applied to Johns Hopkins knowing it was a leader in the field, and received back a wonderful personal letter from the Dean. Now I'm glad I never accepted his invitation to attend that medical school.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Buzz,

Each school is separate at JHU, which is why when I asked my daughters if they heard anything about this, they didn't.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Okay, then on your advice that he probably didn't mean to be sarcasticly ridiculing the author's theory, I have deleted my comment.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   Len    13 years ago

Being condemned and abused goes with the territory. As the Passover Haggada says:

"In every generation they rise to destroy us but the Lord saves us from their hand."

If people want to hate someone, any excuse will do. Read the following quote by Konstantyn Jelenski in the Parisian journal Kultura, May 1968:

"Poles have never come out against Jews 'because they are Jews,' but because Jews are dirty, greedy, mendacious, because they wear earlocks, speak jargon, do not want to assimilate, and also because they do assimilate, cease using their jargon, are nattily dressed, and want to be regarded as Poles. Because they lack culture and because they are overly cultured. Because they are superstitious, backward and ignorant, and because they are so damnably capable, progressive, and ambitious. Because they have long hooked noses, and because it is sometimes difficult to distinguish them from 'pure Poles.' Because they crucified Christ and practice ritual murder and pore over the Talmud, and because they disdain their own religion and are atheists..... Because they are bankers and capitalists and because they are Communists and agitators. But in no case because they are Jews."

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Very good description of an anti-Semite who denies they are an anti-Semite. Such a person would say Jelinski was "playing the anti-Semite card".

...as in..."I have nothing against Jews, it's Israel that I am criticizing"(although I would never criticize any other country for doing what Israel does.)

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   Len    13 years ago

The only card Jelenski was playing was exposure of antisemitism.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

Jews are apparently supposed to be perfect :

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

The answer is in your statement: Intelligent Academics. Not all Academics are near as intelligent as they think they are. A prime example is the ASA President, Curtis Marez.

Many people assume that "academicians" are extra intelligent. Of course that's hardly the case. (in fact many are more closed minded than average-- they feel superior because they got an academic degree. Given the lowering of academic standards in recent years, in many cases these degrees are meaningless.

often they are hypocritical in many ways. perhaps the worst example-- the decry the Israel "wall" (which for over 95% of its length is actually a fence):

fence%20-%20chain%20link.jpg

Because, they pronounce, the only way to peace is to break down barriers. Peace can only be achieved through understanding-- through interaction & communication.

Yet these very same folks push for barriers between communications and mutual understanding amongst academics. This apartheid-like mentality amongst the BDS crowd exposes their rank hypocrisy! Frown.gif

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Why not take on, let's say, Iran, where the are killing homosexuals....because? Because they are homosexuals? And all the other dictatorships who kill their people every single day, but don't take 1/10th of the crap that Israel takes for responding to the attacks and the killing of their own...

And abusing women. And other minorities. To say nothing of imprisoning and torturing anyone whondares speak out against their brutal regime.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Israel is always facing a double standard, regardless of the subject at hand.

I find it ironic that people defend Iran-- when they treat gays like this:

gay-iranians.jpg

And life for gays in Israel is so, so different from Iran-- and most of the Arab world (from Trip Advisor) :

Tel Aviv: Gay Israel

Although Tel Aviv, the 24-hour non-stop city, only has a population ofabout 400,000 people, most of them are young-ish, it is agreat gay destination. With the #1 gay scene in the whole mediterranean area , amazing beaches, great year-roundweather, and other attractions like Jerusalem and the Dead Sea not too far away, Tel Aviv is definitelythe place you should check outfor your next trip.

Unlike other international cities, there is no "gay ghetto" in Tel Aviv - although there are areas that seem "pinker" than others.
Bars, restaurants and hotels are gay friendly, there is a "gay" beach, but it is mixed.

Tel Aviv has been cited numerous times for its warm and friendly gay scene.

Check out the following sites for all the gay information you need about coming to Tel Aviv!
* Gay Map - easily find all gay locations in Tel Aviv
* Nightlife - bars, clubs and more, around the clock
* Cruising and fun
* Gay culture in Israel

Of course is not just progressive in its treatment of gays. Israeli Arabs can vote and have representatives in the Knesset (Parliament). Strangely, Arabs in most Arab countries do not have this right.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Maybe it's a branch of the same group, I don't know. Anyways, it's stupid.

In many cases the boycott is based on bigotry, plain and simple. But in many cases its based on ignorance-- and the Arab hate machine is well oiled by vast sums of money from their oil...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

Here is their website :
And the intro heading :

What the ASA Does

The American Studies Association is the nations oldest and largest association devoted to the interdisciplinary study of American culture and history.

Chartered in 1951, the American Studies Association now has 5,000 individual members along with 2,200 library and other institutional subscribers.

* Together these members represent many fields of inquiry, such as history, literature, religion, art and architecture, philosophy, music, science, folklore, ethnic studies, anthropology, material culture, museum studies, sociology, government, communications, education, library science, gender studies, popular culture, and others.

There it is in print ... NO interest in business or finance . Translation : We are to F'in lofty to sully our lilly white hands with anything to do with MONEY . And as EVERYONE KNOWS that would include them F'in Jews ! BTW ... do they have any blacks among their members ??

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

...or Asians?

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     13 years ago

''do they have any black among their members''? Or American Indians?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

There is a way to fight these bigots. If anyone is interesting in learning more about this, here's an excellent resource I came across. I spent a lot of time there--- as well as being useful its quite interesting. But you can just click on the relevant portions (link following each bullet:

BUYCOTT ISRAEL SITE:

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Another useful site to counter BDS is 'Buy Israel Goods'. It tells you on its many links what goods are sold and where:

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

I would be extremely surprised if they had any Indians in their membership . I could see them maybe having a few other non-whites but likely not many . But I would not be flabbergasted to see none at all ...

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

I would be extremely surprised if they had any Indians in their membership . I could see them maybe having a few other non-whites but likely not many . But I would not be flabbergasted to see none at all ...

Some of these groups that pretend to be for "equality" and "minority rights" are hypocrites-- and in fact some are for "minority rights" onl;y for certain minorities.

However in a few cases something else is at play. A small radical group seizes control of the board of directors, and institutes policy with letting members know. In some cases the members mainly agree with the policy-- but sometimes they don't. Usually the members eventually find out, and then, often, all hell breaks loose! Grin.gif .

BTW, this has happened more than once where radical members pass a BDS resolution, and when the members find out they reverse it.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Another useful site to counter BDS is 'Buy Israel Goods'. It tells you on its many links what goods are sold and where:

Thanks-- great link!

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Most of these kinds of organizations have their token non-whites for show to establish how unbigotted they are.

 
 
 
Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty
Freshman Silent
link   Broliver "TheSquirrel" Stagnasty    13 years ago

I was offering my perspective on the content of Dershowitz's argument, of which I am struggling to find any logical cohesiveness.

The thesisstatement of his argument, logically taken from the title, is: The American Studies Association is bigoted because they support a boycott of Isreal. If he had pointed to flaws in the actual boycott or flaws in the reasoning of the ASA's arguments for supporting the same in the title and essay, I would not have made the comment that I did. But he did not. He starts his essay with an inflammatory headline and fails to substantiate that headline.

It really takes more than the proximity of the same paragraph to show that the ASA is bigoted on the same level as an ancient Harvard president was, and Dershowitz fails to make the case. "It reminds me...," is not an adequate argument, it is a non-sequitor. Perhaps more and better critical thinking skills should be utilized by Dershowitz and the people who read his articles, so that the word "Bigot" does not pop out as a reaction to any action that they do not like or disagree with. Words do have definitions, and those meanings should be followed closely to prevent the watering down of language.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Perhaps a more comprehensive and sourced perspective on the unfair criticism of Israel is this, which refers to it as "Israelophobia":

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

And, Brolly, here is an article which gives some background to the vote, fills in some holes that had not been filled by Dershowitz.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

However, it's possible that a wake-up is starting to happen: Penn State Harrisburg to drop American Studies Assoc membership after Israel Boycott

As a prominent program in American Studies concerned for the welfare of its students and faculty, Penn State Harrisburg is worried that the recent actions by the National Council of the American Studies Association (ASA) do not reflect the longstanding scholarly enterprise American Studies stands for. The withdrawal of institutional membership by our program and others allows us to be independent of the political and ideological resolutions issued by the ASA and concentrate on building American Studies scholarship with our faculty, students, and staff. There might be alternative organizations forming in the future that better represent the field of American Studies. When and if that occurs, we will re-examine our independent position. In the meantime we view this move as one intended to protect students and faculty from opprobrium as a result of the ASAs claim to represent scholars of American studies.

( Dr. Simon J. Bronner , who Chairs the American Studies Department, which has the only Ph.D program in American Studies in Pennsylvania.)

...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

Interesting development . That list seems to have some likely candidates for droppage , notably :
Brandeis University and New York University . Harvard ... unlikely . I'm happy to not see my alma mater on the list ...

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

. That list seems to have some likely candidates for droppage , notably :
Brandeis University and New York University . Harvard ... unlikely .

Brandeis has had more than its share of "Useful Idiots" for many years...(If you're not familiar with the term, here's the Wiki article ).

Of course more often than not, those who believe committed facists and their ilk can be made "reasonable" by dialogue (and/ or appeasement) often get a rude awakening. Here's an interesting even that occurred just last month:

Brandeis University has suspended its partnership with the Palestinian Al-Quds University.

Demonstrators marched in black military gear with fake weapons, waved Nazi flags, offered traditional Nazi salute.

Brandeis University President Frederick Lawrence made the announcement Monday, saying the university will re-evaluate the relationship in the future. The universities have been sister institutions since 1998.

The decision was made in light of recent events at the university, which has campuses in Jerusalem, Abu-Dis and Al-Bireh, including a November 5 Nazi-style demonstration at the main campus.

During the demonstration, protesters marched in black military gear with fake automatic weapons while waving flags and offering the traditional Nazi salute. Banners with images of Palestinian suicide bombers decorated the campus main square, according to a statement from Brandeis. Several students also portrayed dead Israeli soldiers...

(Link)

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    13 years ago

Petey, I am disturbed to see my alma mater, Rutgers University, on that infamous list. I am going to send them a letter informing them they can no longer expect any alumni donations from me until they repudiate this boycott.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

I guess there's no accounting for the prevalence of useful idiots ... What a pity .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

That's a good idea PM . Maybe I'll threaten them as well [even though Rutgers is not my alma mater ] . Perhaps informing them that Penn State Harrisburg has dropped their membership would get their attention ...

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Brandeis has had more than its share of "Useful Idiots" for many years..

That's a misdirected statement. It was Al-Quds University that held the demonstration and Brandeis broke its relationship with that university because of the demonstration and the failure of the staff to criticize it, but was justified in ending it because of the inflammatory pronouncement of the Al-Quds University following it. It's not clear from your intro that this is what your quotation refers to.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Harvard rebukes ASA Resolution:

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

That university is probably still a member though ...

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Just the same as Israel is still a member of the United Nations. Someone needs to be there to be a watchdog and critic, and who is more revered and respected than Harvard?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    13 years ago

who is more revered and respected than Harvard?

In national politics yes .

In most scientific disicplines ... not so much . Also Harvard seems to have a history of being anti-Israel ...

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Harvard rebukes ASA Resolution:

Here's an update on the story as of 12/22:

List of Universities rejecting academic boycott of Israel

This list is based on positions expressed by the Presidents of such Universities or others in a position to statea universitys position (e.g., communications staff). We are aware of no university in the U.S. endorsing the boycott.

Boston University
Brandeis University
Brown University
Cornell University
Dickinson College
Duke University
George Washington University
Hamilton College
Harvard University
Johns Hopkins University
Kenyon College
Indiana University
Michigan State
New York University
Northwestern University
Princeton University
Tufts University
Tulane University
University of California-Irvine
University of California-San Diego
University of Chicago
University of Connecticutt
University of Kansas
University of Maryland
University of Michigan
University of Pennsylvania
University of Pittsburgh
University of Texas-Austin
Washington University in St. Louis
Wesleyan University
Willamette University
Yale University

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Perhaos it their history, which is a common history among ivy league colleges (i.e. restricting the numbers of Jewish applicants), but the statement made by Harvard does make the correct point.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

No surprise that some UCLA colleges especially UCLA Berkeley and Santa Cruz as well as U of Southern California (one of my daughter's alma maters) have not joined them. However, the list is impressive. I wonder how the bigot of the ASA National Committee feel about that.

Interesting that Johbs Hopkins U turned against them.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

Rex Murphy: The failed boycott campaign against Israel

The National Post, January 4, 2014. Last Updated: Jan 6.

An intellectual hatred is the worst. Yeats

When university professors, stewards of knowledge for the next generation of thinkers, propose to fence off all contact, all mental commerce, with others of their kind, they lose the right to be called professors. When they selectively embrace a boycott of a single countrys academics and institutions, they reveal themselves as activists. Not professors but propagandists.

No scholar with any intellectual integrity would support freezing all contact, or seeking to isolate other scholars and researchers, simply because of their national origin, ethnicity or religion. The very idea of an intellectual boycott is a betrayal of a scholars mission.

..

The champions of this academic quarantine offer as their rationale the fact that Israeli institutions of higher learning are a party to Israeli state policies that violate human rights and negatively impact the working conditions of Palestinian scholars and students. Have these learned folk considered what such a stand reveals? Here we have a studies association one that purports to represent 5,000 experts on American culture and history that seeks to amputate all connection with thousands of other scholars. Not because of the content of those scholars ideas, their research, their intelligence, or their field of study. But because they are Israelis. Or teaching and researching in Israel. Why its a form of intellectual what label applies? ah, yes, apartheid.

Click this link to read the whole article:

...

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

From Johns Hopkins:

Dear Faculty, Students, and Staff:

The American Studies Association voted recently to boycott Israeli academic institutions. Two other organizations of scholars have announced similar boycotts. We are writing to express our views on this issue.

Johns Hopkins stands for the belief that we will advance the human condition through dialogue rather than isolation, and the dissemination of knowledge rather than its restriction. An academic boycott is, thus, an affront to principles that this university cherishes. To curtail the freedom of institutions to participate in the exchange of ideas because of the policies of the government of the country where they reside is to strike at the very mission of our university. The ASA tries to defend the boycott on the ground that it applies formally to Israeli universities rather than individual faculty, but of course, this neglects the profound impact such a ban will have on the scholars who form the intellectual heart and participate actively in the academic life and governance of those universities.

The Israeli-Palestinian conflict is, of course, a complex matter on which many in our community hold passionate and competing views. We can all agree, however, that one essential ingredient to the resolution of that conflict will be the free exchange of information and open debate of ideas. This boycott is a contradiction, one that threatens what it purports to protect: the freedom of thought and expression that is the heartbeat of our academic community.

We therefore reject the ASA's efforts to impose a boycott on institutions of higher education in Israel, or any other nation. For the same reasons, although Johns Hopkins is not an institutional member of the American Studies Association, we also reject calls to boycott the boycotters, or to dissociate from the Association or other organizations of scholars as an expression of protest against their votes.

We fully expect that members of our community will, in the finest traditions of our university, continue to give voice to their ideas and convictions. We oppose closing off avenues for fellow scholars in another nation to do the same.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

However, it's possible that a wake-up is starting to happen: Penn State Harrisburg to drop American Studies Assoc membership after Israel Boycott

And action is now being taken on a other front as well:

NGO threatens to sue US academic group which boycotts Israel

In the wake of the American Studies Association (ASA) December-announced boycott of Israel and Israeli universities, Shurat Hadin has threatened to sue the ASA for unlawful discrimination. (Link)

Shurat Hadin has been doing a lot of great work:

When Shurat Hadin was founded in 2003 its stated purpose was to "combat terrorism and promote civil rights through research, education and litigation."

According to its founder, Nitsana Darshan-Leitner, its creation was inspired by the Southern Poverty Law Center in the United States, which used civil litigation to cripple and bankrupt the Ku Klux Klan, and other neo-Nazi groups in the US. (Read it all)

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

The ASA will probably defend by saying they are anti-Zionist ... Sound familiar ?Tongue.gif

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

Sadly, it's their ilk that are teaching the next generation.

Also the present generation, the last generation and the one before that as well.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Nazis don't always wear uniforms with swastikas.

Robert, a most profound and true statement.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

Column One: The Left against Zion

The Lefts doctrinaire insistence that Israel is the root of all evil is not limited to campuses.

In the 1960s, the American Left embraced the anti-Vietnam War movement as its cri de coeur.

In the 1970s, the Lefts foreign policy focus shifted to calling for unilateral nuclear disarmament by the US and its Western allies.

In the 1980s, supporting the Sandinista Communists takeover of Nicaragua became the catechism of the Left.

In the 1990s, the war on global capitalism that is, the anti-globalization movement captivated the passions of US Leftists from coast to coast.

In the 2000s, it was again, the anti-war movement.

This time the Left rioted and demonstrated against the war in Iraq.

And in this decade, the main foreign policy issue that galvanizes the passions and energies of the committed American Left is the movement to delegitimize Israels right to exist.

This week has been a big one for the anti-Israel movement. In the space of a few days, two quasi academic organizations the American Studies Association and the Native American and Indigenous Studies Association have launched boycotts against Israeli universities. Their boycotts follow a similar one announced in April by the Asian Studies Association.

These groups actions have not taken place in isolation. They are of a piece with ever-escalating acts of anti-Israel agitation in college campuses throughout the United States.

Between the growth of Israel Apartheid Day (or Week, or Month) from a fringe exercise on isolated campuses to a staple of the academic calendar in universities throughout the US and Canada, and the rise of the boycott, divestment and sanctions (BDS) movement to wage economic war against the Jewish state, anti-Israel activism has become the focal point of Leftist foreign policy activism in the US and throughout the Western world.

Every week brings a wealth of stories about new cases of aggressive anti-Israel activism. At the University of Michigan last week, thousands of students were sent fake eviction notices from the universitys housing office. A pro-Palestinian group distributed them in dorms across campus to disseminate the blood libel that Israel is carrying out mass expulsions of Palestinians.

At Swarthmore College, leftist anti-Israel Jewish students who control Hillel are insisting on using Hillels good offices to disseminate and legitimate anti-Israel slanders.

And the Lefts doctrinaire insistence that Israel is the root of all evil is not limited to campuses.

At New Yorks 92nd Street Y, Commentary editor John Podhoretz was booed and hissed by the audience for trying to explain why the ASAs just-announced boycott of Israel was an obscene act of bigotry.

Many commentators have rightly pointed out that the ASA and the NAISA are fringe groups.

They represent doctorate holders who chose to devote their careers to disciplines predicated not on scholarship, but on political activism cloaked in academic regalia whose goal is to discredit American power. The ASA has only 5,000 members, and only 1,200 of them voted on the Israel- boycott resolution. The NAISA has even fewer members.

It would be wrong, however, to use the paltry number of these fringe groups members as means to dismiss the phenomenon that they represent. They are very much in line with the general drift of the Left.

Rejecting Israels right to exist has become part of the Lefts dogma. It is a part of the catechism.

Holding a negative view of the Jewish state is a condition for membership in the ideological camp. It is an article of faith, not fact.

Consider the background of the president of the ASA. Curtis Marez is an associate professor in the Ethnic Studies Department at the University of California, San Diego. His area of expertise is Chicano Film and Media Studies.

He doesnt know anything about Israel. He just knows that hes a Leftist. And today, Leftists demonize Israel. Their actions have nothing to do with anything Israel does or has ever done. They have nothing to do with human rights. Hating Israel, slandering Israel and supporting the destruction of Israel are just things that good Leftists do.

And Marez was not out of step with his fellow Leftists who rule the roost at UCSD. This past March the student council passed a resolution calling for the university to divest from companies that do business with Israel.

Why? Because hating Israel is what Leftists do.

The Lefts crusade against the Jewish state began in earnest in late 2000. The Palestinians decision to reject statehood and renew their terror war against Israel ushered in the move by anti-Israel forces on the Left to take over the movement. And as they have risen, they have managed to silence and discredit previously fully accredited members of the ideological Left for the heresy of supporting Israel.

This week, Harvard Law Prof. Alan Dershowitz retired after 50 years on the law faculty. His exit, the same week as the ASA and the NAISA announced their boycotts of Israeli universities, symbolized the marginalization of the pro-Israel Left that Dershowitz represented.

For years, Dershowitz has been a non-entity in leftist circles. His place at the table was usurped by anti-Israel Jews like Peter Beinart. And now Beinart is finding himself increasingly challenged by anti-Semitic Jews like Max Blumenthal.

The progression is unmistakable.

The question is, is it irreversible? Must supporters of Israel choose between their support for Israel and their affinity for the Left? Certainly it is true that the more the issue of support for Israel splits along ideological and partisan lines, the more reasonable it is for supporters of Israel to move to the ideological camp and the party that supports Israel, and away from the ones that do not support Israel.

The average voter is not in a position to change the positions of his party or the dogma of his ideological camp. He can take it or leave it. With rejection of Israel now firmly entrenched in the Lefts dogma, and with the Left firmly in control of the Democratic Party under President Barack Obamas leadership, for those who care about Israel, the Republican Party is a more natural fit.

So, too, the ideological Right is far more congenial to the Jewish state than the Left.

While the most sensible place for supporters of Israel to be today is on the political Right, it is also true that it is neither smart nor responsible to abandon the Left completely. Jews should be able to feel comfortable as Jews, and as supporters of Israel everywhere. Ideological camps that castigate Jews for their pride in the accomplishments of the Jewish state, and for their support and concern for its survival and prosperity, are camps in desperate need of fixing.

But we should not fool ourselves. Challenging the likes of Marez, or the Swarthmore students, or Max Blumenthal or Peter Beinart to a reasoned debate is an exercise in futility. They do not care about human rights. They do not care that Israel is the only human rights-respecting democracy in the Middle East. They do not care about the pathological nature of Palestinian society. They do not care about the Jewish peoples indigenous rights and international legal rights to sovereignty not only over Tel Aviv and Haifa, but over Hebron and Ramallah.

Being hypocrites doesnt bother them either.

You can talk until youre blue in the face about the civilian victims of the Syrian civil war, or the gender apartheid in Saudi Arabia and the absence of religious freedom throughout the Muslim world. But they dont care. They arent trying to make the world a better place.

Facts cannot compete with their faith. Reason has no place in their closed intellectual universe.

To accept reason and facts would be an act of heresy.

Marez may be a hypocrite, and even a servant of evil. But he is no heretic.

The only real way to mitigate the hard Lefts devotion to Israels destruction is by changing the power balance on the Left. For the past decade, donors like George Soros have been open in their commitment to elect Democrats who oppose the USs alliance with Israel. A decade ago, Soros and fellow Jewish American billionaire Peter Lewis funneled hundreds of millions of dollars into Moveon.org. Moveon.org became a clearinghouse for anti-Israel and anti-Jewish messages that became the stock in trade of the ideological Left, and of Democratic candidates in need of campaign funding.

It was due to then-Democratic senator Joe Liebermans refusal to get on the Soros- and Lewis-funded anti-Israel bandwagon in the 2004 elections, that they turned Moveon.org against Lieberman in the 2006 Democratic primary for his seat in the Senate. His Democratic challenger, Ned Lamont, who won the primary, ran a campaign laced with anti-Israel and anti-Jewish propaganda.

There are Democratic funders, like Penny Pritzker, Lester Crown and Haim Saban, who support Israel. If they were so inclined, they could use their considerable funds to change the power equation in the Democratic Party. They could cultivate and support pro-Israel Democratic candidates. They could take the Democratic Party back.

This week ended with Democratic Sen. Charles Schumer finally breaking his silence on Obamas Iran deal and joining forces with his fellow Democrat Sen. Robert Menendez and Republican Sen. Mark Kirk to defy Obama on Irans nuclear weapons program. Given Obamas floundering popularity, it is possible that Schumers move will open the door for a change in the Democratic Party.

In truth, there is no reason for the Democratic Party to remain in place. It isnt ordained that the Democrats must cleave to the hard Left.

The rejection of Israel is not a natural component of leftist dogma. Its just that for the past decade, the smart money and the rising power on the Left has been with those who oppose Israels existence as a strong, independent Jewish state.

While the ASA and its comrades are on the fringes of academia, they are not fringe voices on the Left. The Left has embraced the cause of Israels destruction. And its financial power has made it difficult for pro-Israel Democrats to act on their convictions, and those of their voters.

The combination of an exodus of supporters of Israel Jews and non-Jews alike from the Left and from the Democratic Party on the one hand, and generous funding for pro-Israel Democratic candidates on the other, can change the equation.

America lost the Vietnam War. The Sandinistas are back in change in Nicaragua. But if people are willing to stand up now and be counted, America need not harm Israel.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

Lisa Duggan, NYU and Curtis Marez, UC San Diego: Deserve to be Boycotted?

Duggan is the president-elect of the American Studies Association and Marez is the president. According to this Inside Higher Ed piece , they both support a pending motion to have the ASA endorse a boycott of Israeli universities. If the IHE piece is correct, I think they should be treated by all academics (and others) of good will and sound mind the way they would treat Israelisno lecture invites, no publications, no nothing. In short, boycott the boycotters. And that goes for anyone else who votes for the boycott. [UPDATE: Cathy Young has a fine column on the hypocrisy of the boycotters. Duggan is one of the "queer theorists," who, as Young notes, in some bizarre logical inversion have focused their wrath on the Middle East's most gay-friendly country, by far.]

UPDATE: Perusing the ASAs website, I see that they have a prize named after Angela Davis yes, that Angela Davis , Gus Halls two-time running mate on the Communist Party ticket in 1980 and 1984 (so much for the ASAs commitment to academic freedom (the purported rationale for the boycott), not exactly something Communists are known for). When did mainstream academia become such a circus?

...

Angela Davis

Angela Yvonne Davis (born January 26, 1944) is an American political activist , scholar, Communist and author. She emerged as a nationally prominent counterculture activist and radical in the 1960s, as a leader of the Communist Party USA , and had close relations with the Black Panther Party through her involvement in the Civil Rights Movement despite never being an official member of the party. Prisoner rights have been among her continuing interests; she is the founder of Critical Resistance , an organization working to abolish the prison-industrial complex . She is a retired professor with the History of Consciousness Department at the University of California, Santa Cruz , and is the former director of the university's Feminist Studies department. [ 2 ]

Her research interests are in feminism, African-American studies , critical theory , Marxism , popular music , social consciousness , and the philosophy and history of punishment and prisons. Her membership in the Communist Party led to Ronald Reagan 's request in 1969 to have her barred from teaching at any university in the State of California. She was tried and acquitted of suspected involvement in the Soledad brothers ' August 1970 abduction and murder of Judge Harold Haley in Marin County, California . She was twice a candidate for Vice President on the Communist Party USA ticket during the 1980s.

CONTINUE

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

It's worse than a break-up where one party tells another "We can still be friends"; instead it's like "I don't really like or respect you, but we can still have sex". If these schools wanna make a trueimpact on free speech, then they should absolutely withdraw their membership from any group that strives to hamper free speech.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

Thank you, Sixpick, for posting

Column One: The Left against Zion

which to me makes the most common sense to counter the useful idiots of the anti-Israel left, and thank you, Robert G, for posting the link to Krauthammer's article which contains a link to join with brilliant academics of the world in declaring themselves to be Israelis in light of the hypocritical boycott of Israeli Academics. I have added my name to their distinguished list of Nobel Laureates, University Presidents and other famous academics (not that I am comparing myself to them, but that I am joining them in the battle).

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Nazis don't always wear uniforms with swastikas.

True.

Lt. Raine has a ratheringenious solution to that problem...

 
 

Who is online





86 visitors