Crime and Punishment versus Cold Vengeance
There's not a day goes by I don't feel regret. Not because I'm in here, or because you think I should. I look back on the way I was then: a young, stupid kid who committed that terrible crime. I want to talk to him. I want to try and talk some sense to him, tell him the way things are. But I can't. That kid's long gone and this old man is all that's left. I got to live with that.
Ellis Boyd Redding from The Shawshank Redemption
In front of many court houses stands Lady Justice. She stands there blindfolded, holding the scales of justice in one hand and a double edge sword in the other. She represents the values of our justice system. She is blindfolded to show that justice is metered out objectively, without fear or favor, power or weakness. The scales represent the strength of the support and opposition of the case. The double edge sword represents the power of reason and justice.
But its also said that Justice is a bitch. That in practice, we fall very short of the ideals of what justice should be. The principle that a man is presumed innocent when he is brought forth in a court of law is fundamental to our Constitution. But our legal system falls short of that ideal, when representation for the poor is less than adequate, when evidence isnt collected or is hidden, or juries are skewed by experts. What is even less clear, is that after a man has served for his crime, is he ever considered free. I would say quite to the contrary. Once convicted, a man is never truly free. He wears a Scarlet Letter for the rest of his life.
There is an obvious pecking order to crime. A white collar criminal can enter society pretty much intact, most returning to a very comfortable life style. Often, these are the same people who have the best representation, since their crime usually had to do with money. Then there are your people who were involved with burglary or robbery, one not involving a weapon while the other does. These people are feared, but once they are off of parole, they can move and disappear into society. Only law enforcement will be able to find you when rounding up the usual suspects.
Then come murders and rapists. Of course these are the worst of crimes done in society. But we tend to break it down in our collective minds. Serial murders verse a one time killer. A cop killer verses a non cop killer. Pedophile verses a one time rapist. But what is the difference between a one time murders verses a one time rapist? Probably not much. Both crimes are derived from an emotional state, usually anger or hate and an array of other emotional issues. We fear them both perpetrators. This is where justice goes out the window and fear kicks right in. Both bring out mob mentality when we are confronted by them. And although both are as old as mankind, each society defines which is worse.
\
As a person who has had a loved one raped, I understand all too intimately what rape does to a person. I have bared witness to the damage it does to the soul. And although time heals the wounds to a certain degree, something is stolen forever. Rape takes the most intimate of acts and turning it against victim. It is a very personal act of violence. Murder can be personal, or very impersonal. But the damage is permanent and all encompassing. The murderer not only takes the joy of life away from the victim, but also takes them away from those who love them. Maybe that is why it is the crime included in the Ten Commandments. The damage is final with no chance of recovery on any level. I have never forgiven the person who raped my loved one. He was never brought to justice even though we could identify him. I think that is part of the reason that I have a hard time letting go. But I am glad that she wasnt killed during the rape. I know she feels the same way, too.
This brings me to those who have been brought to justice. What happens to the murder or the rapist once they have paid their debt to society? Are they are branded for life? The premise of our legal system is that once we have brought a person to justice, that they are free to live their lives. But in practice, this is far from the truth. Those who have committed any crime, but especially the worst ones, will wear a scarlet letter forever. Some may argue that they deserve this treatment and I can understand that for the individuals and families that suffered. But for everyone else, it is purely an emotional response and not one based on justice. As a society, we are constantly faced with the dilemma of not only finding the appropriate punishment for such terrible transgressions but also dealing with these individuals post punishment. Sometimes, due to our personal experiences, it is easy to let cold vengeance blind us to what should be the appropriate. When the law takes a back seat to emotion there is failure of our system. When fear, rumor, and speculation replace facts, there is no justice. And I am sure that there is many a criminal who looks back at the person they were and wishes they could take it all back. The question is do we ever let them?
Tags
Who is online
86 visitors

I was hoping to have a discussion about our legal system... hello?
Perrie
Crime, punishment, recidivism, second chances and debts to society
Complicated topics with strong positions on both sides of all of them filled with passion and emotions including hate, love, forgiveness and remorse.
I support truth in sentencing but also feel that once a person has served their sentence that their "debt to society" is paid and it should not hang over them like a black cloud for the rest of their lives.
That being said, I also support the death penaly (understanding that there have been and are inequities and problems in its application that must be ameliorated) or Life Without Parole for those that take the life of another intentionally. I also support stiff sentence enhancements for felonies committed while in possession of a weapon and live sentences for those convicted of sexually abusing a child.
Many will disagree with my positions and I respect their views and hope that they respect mine.
Assuming thatneither crimeis based on a false accusation, I have to think that there is a significant difference between the two. If there wasn't, the rapist would have tried to cover their tracks by murdering the victim. They're both dirtbags, but one of them has a more extreme callousness to their actions and disregard for the victim and their loved ones.
There are few things that can surpass the grand giddiness that goes along with the Lynching of someone one can somehow define as less less worthy of life and happiness than the accuser. Vigilantism at it's finest, I think, and some find nearly orgasmic joy and satisfaction in stringing the poor bastard up whether it be on a web page somewhere or the nearest cottonwood tree. The courts and laws of the land be damned.
Our laws were made by elected representatives and, hopefully, reflect the values of the community. If they don't, the law can always be changed. I figure when the sentence is completed it's over and done with. The price has been paid.
Lynching is taking the law into one's own hands, setting one's self up as a moral compass when morality has nothing at all to do with it. The giddy fun is in the destruction and pain inflicted on those who have already paid the price. They are deemed unworthy of our respect as a human being.
BF,
I have to agree with everything you said including the death penalty. If you kill one innocent person, you have committed murder and that is something I don't want to be a part of.
BF,
I do, too!
BTW I don't think we have it in NY.
Egilman,
Exactly.
IMO, our justice system leaves those that are poor without proper representation. The rich, can afford experts/the best lawyers, etc etc. The poor get a overworked public defender. Good luck if you charged with a crime, and your guilty of being poor.
Must be terrible to be afflicted with affluenza.
I saw that the other day Hal. Unbelievable.
Kavika, I have met many hard working and committed public defenders. But, generally, you are right. They are overworked and overwhelmed for the most part. Guilty of being poor - how true that is.
Exactly . And that is the whole problem with the position of the justice system on rape . Those who have been raped need to ask themselves if they would prefer to have been murdered afterwards . In fact I would go so far as to distinguish between rapists who attempted murder as much worse [& more premeditated] than those who merely raped . There should also be a distinction between those who used actual force &/or weapons from those who did not .
The fact that these distinctions have no bearing on the Megan's Law outcome [& permanent record] is a severe failure of our current system .
Hi Robert,
I can't support the death penalty in its current form, since it allows for evidence to be introduced that should not, which includes eye witness accounts, which have been proved to be unreliable. I am fine with life without parole. I think that pedophilia is untreatable, but they need to be put into a special facility.
Everyone has a right to their opinion, since there is so many ways to look at this.
Most crime experts would say that the pathology for a rapist is far different than that for a murder, and for that matter each murderer has a different pathology. For instance a crime of passion, which is generally a one time action, is driven by emotion, while a person who kills someone in the course of a robbery, is doing so to protect themselves.
Rapist generally have an anger issue, usually based on something in their past. The difference between a rapist who just rapes and leaves and one that kills their victim, is that one is acompulsionwhile the other is premeditated.
Grump,
Well said, and I totally agree with you. It seems that human nature likes to do two things. The first is to seek vengeance and the second is to be a part of a group (or mob). This is what the law is suppose to protect us from.
BF,
I totally agree with you there.
How objective of you ... Why not comment on the permanent Megan's law result of all of that ?
Perrie
Some eye witness testimony is unreliable just as some other forms of evidence have been found to be inaccurate or fraudulent in different cases.
AS I noted above there are problems with the process and application of sentencing someone to death, but the capital punishment is appropriate (in my view) for some crimes.
BadFish
For instance a sentence of Life Without Parole for the sexual assault of a child
Doesn't the child have anything to say about that ? After some years to think it over what happens if the child [now an adult] decides to forgive and forget ?
Petey
IN answer to your question, I would say NO.
Not sure that is how the justice system works, or should work - what if the child wants the criminal executed?
Should the victims determine the punishment of crimes? Seems there could be a wide variance of punishments for the same crime
Cold vengeance makes me think of an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth. I visualize vigilante justice and lynch mobs. That is where many errors can be committed - think of To Kill a Mockingbird, or Mississippi Burning. The USA, being a civilized country, has at least adopted the British legal system. What doesn't impress me is that the exercise of that system varies according to State law. The Criminal Code of Canada is used throughout the country so there is a consistency of expectation and application. However, that is not the point of this discussion - revenge is, inconsistent in accordance with the needs/desires of the victims or their families. Some feel justice is done when a criminal is executed and seek that penalty "to get even" whereas others profess forgiveness. As well, in the movies at least, there appears to be a need for prosecuting attorneys to show their mettle by overdoing their job while seeking political careers, but I don't know if that's the same in reality.
I have to agree with you EG. The bar on our legal system is set pretty low and also inconsistent from state to state and even within a state. This is one part of the law that I feel should be standard from state to state.
BF I totally agree with your opinion. If the Judge could meter out the punishment, knowing what he did, he deserved the same. But in many jurisdictions, a judge is an elected position, and conviction rates count. I am not sure if that was the case here, but being a Judge should never be an elected position, but be based on their performance on the job, which is usually prosecutor.
I used to be very pro capital punishment... and in cases like Jeffery Dahmer, I really don't have an issue with it. But law can be a slippery slope and there runs a danger of putting a innocent man to death. How would any of us like to be in that position, yet there have been hundreds, if not thousands of such cases.
As for eye witness testimony... I'll tell you a quick story. About 4 months ago I witnessed along with 3 other people a terrible car accident, involving 2 cars and an intersection. We all saw it and gave our testimony to the police. Not one of us told the same story. There is a phenomenon where the brain filters information that makes eye witness accounts faulty. A general description of this:
You can read more about it here:
I totally agree. It's a double act of violence and very calculated at that.
Perrie
I have no argument with the fact that some eye witness testimony can be inaccurate or ambiguous and a case should not be based solely on eye witness testimony but there are as many cases where eye witness testimony was correct as where it is inaccurate though I doubt statistics exist to prove either.
In my view, the appeals process is designed to keep an innocent man/woman from being convicted of a crime, once the conviction is reached and upheld through appeals then the punishment death or LWOP as deemed appropriate at trial is appropriate
I have to admit, the phrase "Cold Vengeance" (which is also a book series) has a "cutting edge" to it...metaphorically speaking.
There are also two different trains of thought here; Avenge or Revenge.
btw: Justice in the US is a joke.
In the current system judges are given latitude to show mercy and also maximum sentence guidelines .
Are you saying that the victim should not have the right to show mercy as well ? The whole idea that the state has the sole discretion to decide punishment is odd IMO . After all the agrieved party is the victim . Why doesn't the victim get input ?
What troubles me is the finality of a life sentence . There should be some latitude for the victim to change her [or his] mind . What is the justification for completely eliminating that latitude ?
I have also heard where a girl in her later teens but still considered a minor by the courts had consensual sex with a boy considered an adult. These cases are kind of nuts.
Yes a one time rapist is different than compulsive.
But lets talk about college campuses. Everyday across this country college boys rape girls and call it consensual. They don't go on to become rapist in their adult life. They still raped... and often even the schools know about it. What is that demographic? It has been shown that adult rapist fall into many categories, (excluding pedophiles) and that these differences should be taken into consideration. Of course as a person close to this subject, it is difficult for me to remain philosophical, but our legal system must.
I totally agree with you, Kavika. All anyone has to do is look at OJ Simpson to know that he got what he paid for and walked away from a double murder because of his money. And we have a pile of people sitting in jails over stupid little charges becoming hardened criminals from the experience. There is something wrong with our legal system that we have the most number of inmates per capita of any other western nation.
So have I Grump. This is also true of our social workers. Both make for a very toxic mess. Once in family court for a student of mine, the judge asked me to stop leading the public defender... she was just a young girl fresh from her bar.
Which is very important. Something I am a huge advocate for.
That isn't fiction Buzz. That is true. I have a friend serving 36 months for a white collar crime, he wasn't even a part of, other than his legal fees. The ones who made the money from this scam, had money to give back and could squeal on others, so they got less time. This was from a new hot gun DA, who wanted to prove his stuff.
Cold Vengeance is when the logic goes out the window and is replaces with emotion when it comes to justice. It is very cutting.
This is true. Often revenge is metered out,especiallyonce a case hits public opinion and the DA's office gets wind of it.
Gotta agree with ya there.
Again BF I am in total agreement with you. For profit prisons is an industry and does nothing but rob the tax payer of money as they act as nothing more than holding pens.
The appeals process is only as good as the representation you can afford, which is why we have so many people in prisons that were the wrong person. Often they were poor, and couldn't afford better representation at any trial.
I think that there is room for eye witness testimony, but often it has been the main thrust of a trial and that is where there is a problem.
'For profit' prisons have the motivation to retain rather than rehabitulate and return prisoners to society.
Exactly Buzz.
OK , sounds like were coming towards an understanding here .
I'd like to take this opportunity to thank you for publishing a very difficult topic and fielding all of these complex comments .
Can you take this one step futher and comment on what the law says about the distinction I tried to make ? It seems to me that the law makes no such distinction ...
BTW if you like this article vote it up on reddit
An interesting philosophical question might be, "Of what purpose is retributive justice"?
Does it in any way compensate victims, serve a positive function for the society that imposes it, or, act as a deterrent?
The law can't seem to make a distinction from state to state. Just google sodomy in NY and then in Kansas. So I guess the answer is that the law is inconsistent.
A good question Mac. I guess it would depend on a society wanted.
Petey
The victims are given the opportunity to make victim impact statements, which may or may not influence the jury and the judge when it comes to sentencing.
That is how the system works.
Perrie
I think we are in agreement that eye witness testimony can be valuable but needs to supported by physical evidence and that improvements need to be made in the public defender system
There was an interesting program on NPRs TED Radio Hour about this...Scott Fraser: Can Eyewitnesses Create Memories?
"Forensic psychologist Scott Fraser studies how we remember crimes. He describes a deadly shooting and explains how eyewitnesses can create memories that they haven't seen. Why? Because the brain is always trying to fill in the blanks."
Daniel Kahneman: How Do Experiences Become Memories?
"Nobel laureate and founder of behavioral economics Daniel Kahneman goes through a series of examples from vacations to colonoscopies. He explains how our "experiencing selves" and our "remembering selves" perceive happiness differently."
Have you ever had a friend describe an event you both witnessed and you saw it differently? Happens all the time. And, when we "fill in the blanks" months or years later, the two observations are even more divergent. I always found it fascinating.
Akira Kurosawa's classic movie 'Rashoman' makes that very point. It relates the divergent viewpoints of various witnesses to a crime.
Wonderful article, Perrie!
Having grown up watching Perry Mason, I had this ideal in my head that justice meted out in a court room was right and good, fair and honest, and that the truth would prevail. We all know that it doesn't work like that. That a good lawyer can twist facts to seem innocuous, etc.
It's a complicated issue, for sure.
Dowser,
It is a shame that like most things in life, the ideals don't measure up. And as you pointed out, it is also a very complicated issue. There is so much gray in this discussion. The only thing we can all agree on, is that the system is broken.
A broken system for broken people. By that I mean repeat offenders who live a life of crime.
This is true Grump. Our prison system makes small time criminals into harden criminal. We spend billions on incarceration, when we could be spending much less if we spent on rehabilitation. We are so short sighted.
It's hard to do when the rates of criminal recidivism is greater than 60%. It's extremely hard to do when the crimes are violent sex acts.
One of the biggest problems with America's prisons IS THEIR PRIVATIZATION!
In Pennsylvania, at least one judge has been himself sentenced to prison for arbitrarily sentencing juveniles to privatized facilities and getting essentially KICKBACKS (taxpayer-subsidized) for doing so.
Ariziona has a similar situation, using among other ploys, a now-declared unconstitutional law used to stop individuals who "looked like" illegals and packing the privatized prisons with them. Governor Brewer's top assistant was involved in the business of one such privatized facility!
'Kids for cash' judge sentenced to 28 years for racketeering scheme
A Pennsylvania judge was sentenced Thursday for his part in what prosecutors called a 'kids for cash' scheme that sent juvenile offenders to privately run detention facilities in return for kickbacks.
By Warren Richey , Staff writer / August 11, 2011
And
I can agree with you on that.
You might want to check that redd.it thing. I'm not sure it's working.
Mac ,
That was the theme of an episode of Hawaii five 0 [newer version] . Is it possible that TV is now more honest than the justice system ?
I think damn near anything you could name is more honest than parts of our judicial system.
HI Pat,
I think there are some misnomers about who is doing the recidivism. According to the DOJ:
And the number of drug arrests have only gone up, most of which are on minor offenses. They actually make up the largest part of the prison population
...
I am sure our society is really not that much different than most other western nations, yet we have the largest prison population per capita and I think that says something more about us as a people than those weincarcerate.
I have seen that happen twice in my life to people I know. Even with a good lawyer, if the DA is hungry enough, he or she will get their conviction, even if there is no time served. They want their numbers they need for their position.
Ditto.
It figures that "motor vehicle thieves" would be at the top of the list ... Guess why .
Big bucks from China.
I didn't expect that guess ... You may be onto something . But most of the time stolen cars are stripped down for parts so I'm inclined to say no . Wanna try another guess ?
OK you've got me!
Its a crime of opportunity ... Stealing a car provides both the stolen goods and the means to get away . Best of all you can sell the parts for a lot more than the vehicle ... Warning to readers : Don't try this at home ... It is strictly for professional cars thieves !
And why should you? Especially with your whole life ahead of you.
Good Adivce
One of the problems with the Criminal Justice System is that everyone is an expert on the Criminal Justice System.
LOL, Grump! Very true. They are experts until they need an expert. Then they are just dumbasses.
Also Trure BF! Did you know that NYS has a law that doughnuts with holes in them, are illegal? In Baltimore, if more than 3 woman live together, it's considered a brothel... hence no sororities are allowed to have houses, but frats are. I am sure there are a ton of these silly laws hanging around.
He would be laughed out of office.
I got out of jury duty permanently by declaring that ethos . You'll never guess what the case was about ...
Fortunately my profession was banned from doing jury duty. I wanted neither the responsibiliity nor the ten bucks a day when I was earning a huge miltiple of that when I was working.
How about illegally obtaining prescription drugs ?
I'm not talking about robbery . Which is "worse" : getting illegal drugs orprescription drugs through the black market ?
Is there a problem, Abby?
If you really want to do that leave a comment on my homepage and I'll be glad to direct you . Are you dissatisfied with the place or merelyshort of time to spend here ?
I am also a member who has family members who suffered rape at a very early age actually two people I know of. Both were sexually abused/raped as young children 5 to 8 years old and repeatedly by a family member but different family members. The hurt and miss trust never goes away one natural defense of the adult that was sexually used and abused as a child is to erase child hood from all memory that is ones approach the other has the guilt that they didn't expose the family member out of fear of reprisal blaming themself. Vulnerability of a child and defense mechanisms against exposure once set in place tend to remain for life.
The mind is a wonderful and in many cases a self healing component each person deals with these travesties in their own and usually different way.
Petey,
Sorry for missing this, but IMHO they are about the same. The dealer isn't. Our justice system should not really care about users unless they have committed some other crime, like robbery to get money for drugs. But the dealers are making problems for society and therefore, I view them as criminals.
Gene,
Death penalty for who?
I would never minimize the horrors of rape. But I do know from personal experience, that woman and men who were molested/raped who want to get better, do. You are right about the human mind.
I recall learning in my university psychology class that the mind tends to forget bad experiences, as a sort of defensive mechanism.
This is what scares me most...what I remember is bad enough what about everything that I've "forgotten"?
I get that Uppy.
It's a good thing you've forgotten then.
I can't argue with that but there are other situations . I saw a case where a young man had obtained legal pain killers for his father . He got them through illegal means [no prescription] . The "dealer" who sold them was not part of the case , only the son .
Dam BF I agree with you totally again. I think you are wearing me down. For profit Prisons must be outlawed but with big Corporations like Boeing and thousands of others it's almost impossible to stop in our current political Legal system.
I disagree with rape being a compulsion in that to me leans toward the idea that she wore a dress that made the rapist loose control. Rape is not an act of sexual attraction or an act of tripping a switch like a certain perfume or type of apparel.
The person who is triggered by such is a true danger to society. This has been used as a defense and I personally believe its hog wash.
Some things are probably best forgotten. But then I wonder if the same problems still persist in the affected families. Three girls that I knew of who were abused committed suicide.
They lived with it for twenty years first.