Pink Floyd’s Roger Waters: Comparisons between Israel and Nazis ‘crushingly obvious’
Former Pink Floyd front man Roger Waters said the comparisons between present-day Israel and Nazi Germany in the 1930s were crushingly obvious.
Waters, a longtime critic of Israeli treatment of Palestinians, told CounterPunch magazine on Saturday that the powerful Israeli propaganda machine had influenced U.S. policy in the region and shaped the mainstream media narrative.
The Jewish lobby is extraordinary powerful here and particularly in the industry that I work in, the music industry and in rock n roll, as they say, Waters said.
He has called on musicians to boycott Israel for its treatment of Palestinians, which he also compared to ethnic cleansing and South African apartheid.
So for an artist to go and play in a country that occupies other peoples land and oppresses them the way Israel does, is plain wrong, Waters said. They should say no. I would not have played for the Vichy government in occupied France in the Second World War, I would not have played in Berlin, either, during this time. Many people did, back in the day. There were many people that pretended that the oppression of the Jews was not going on from 1933 until 1946, so this is not a new scenario except that this time its the Palestinian people being murdered. - http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2013/12/11/pink-floyds-rogers-waters-comparisons-between-israel-and-nazis-crushingly-obvious/
I've said this before, I'm only a casual Middle East watcher and have for the most part given up as a lost cause for peace. There are however, people whom are passionate about ME affairs and in this case Pink Floyd's Roger Waters is.
Movie, music and media stars are well known to shoot off their mouths about current event. Sometimes they are spot on, but most of the time; Not.
What I found interesting though was the reaction of the ADL, to wit:
Waters drew criticism in July for displaying a pig-shaped balloon covered with Jewish symbols, including a Star of David, during his concerts.
The Anti-Defamation League defended his use of the symbols, saying Waters had displayed similar items for years and was not expressing anti-Semitic views.
However, the ADL later reversed its stance after Waters called for the boycott, asking him why hed singled out Israel when there are other countries, such as China, Myanmar and Russia, that have been accused of persecuting minority groups and noted that Waters had recently performed in China and Russia.
Your single-minded obsession with trying to convince others to boycott the Jewish state, while ignoring the worlds true human rights violators, must be driven by something other than a guilty conscience, the ADL said in a statement. Taking all this into account, one must conclude that your views on Israel are in fact colored by offensive and dangerous undercurrents of anti-Jewish sentiment.
Aside from reversing it's stance on Waters use of props in his performances, they chose not to deny anything Waters said but instead, opted to use the Tu quoque defense which is a logical fallacy....that is a no win.
Another interesting thing about this article is the readers comments which are rather self explanatory.
As the late, great Voltaire once said; "I may not agree with what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it."
Tags
Who is online
93 visitors

I'll cut Rogers some slack for speaking his mind but the Nazi analogies are over the top.
....and this is related how?
LMAO Jim!
You haven't used enough.
A wise man speaks because he has something to say. A fool speaks because he has to say something.
OK, I'd like to dissect all of this....
First of all he's a horses ass, no different than Ted Nugget. I saw him spit on the audience during the "Wall" Concert. When it came out in the papers the next day, he said the adulation disgusted him. His old band members don't even want to go near him. So let's just say... Not an impressive guy.
He must be reading 'Stormfront" Right off the website.
The ADL... IDK. I find it hard to believe that Jewish symbols on a pig wouldn't be objectionable to them. Especially when the other part of the band goes on tour and doesn't do that.
The Tu quoque defense, might be not actually addressing the issue, but it alwaysfascinatesme how people choose to fixation on one thing or another. There is a level ofhypocrisy, and examining it does sometimes reveal motivation of the individual, but it doesn't address the issue.
Now this is a beauty!
"Oppression of the Jews"? You have got to be kidding. 6 million people die and he calls it oppression. That comment in itself isdisgusting. He's calling a genocideoppression? Talk abouthyperbole.And while he would like to draw comparisons to Nazi Germany and the Palestinian people that is a strawman argument, since there is no genocide inPalestinian. In fact, the population has only grown since 1970:
...
Advocates of thePalestinian people like to discuss it in a vacuum. There was a reason why that wall went up. Ironically, Egypt has a similar wall, for much the same reason that Israel does. No one ever discusses that. How about Rodger experiencing having a nice cup of coffee in a cafe, and have the person next to him, blow himself up. Maybe that would shut him up.
John, this is undeniable but it is a result of years of being surrounded by enemies. But Israel is still a democracy and so there is going to be decent within their population... which is healthy in a democracy.
LMAO Robert!
You both actually are quite entertaining. Carry on.
Really? I'll show you mine... and you show me yours. Let's start with this:
Oh here is the full version:
No John,
What I am advocating is that you produce said text books and show that his is part of the Israeli curriculum.
Again, not a primary source. I produced a primary source with a secondary one confirming it, for English speaking people.
Oh yeah Randy. That's why the Palestinian population has only grown and BTW, where are those ovens?
And that statement says it all. In pre-1948 there were no Israel, so there can't be Israeli soldiers. I would love to read the official text, instead of this propaganda.
If Jesus was white, then there were Israeli soldiers going as far back as 0 AD.
John,
That is because I know my history. That event happened in 1948 on April 9th. There was no Israel and therefore, saying it was Israeli soldiers makes it propaganda.
When I was in college, I saw a Palestinian grad student give a talk about Peace (student union) in that region. His idea was for all Palestinians to renounce the violence & warfare and become Israeli citizens. The birth (and unfortunately death) rate was (according to him) was 4x that of Israel. In time, with such a large voting population, Israeli citizens of Palestinian decent could start to democratically elect other Palestinians to high positions in theKnesset and eventually take over the government.
However flawed his plan was, it was thunderously applauded by the students there.
.....Then he went on to say he was firmly convinced Israel would never allow that to happen. At this juncture his ideas were a bit too far fetched for me. (now it would be called conspiratorial) But his point did get me to think how one country or organization would want to keep their enemy fractionalized and fighting amongst themselves.like here today in the US.
Not even close Randy. And if you could... tell me why that wall was erected? And why is it OK for Egypt to have a wall on their side of Gaza?
the lunatic, is in his head
Well then-- if he doesn't want to be seen as a hypocrite, then the only thing for him to do is to stop his concerts in the U.S.!
Given his strong dedication to human rights, I'm sure he will do this ASAP!
(/sarcasm)
________________________________________________________
*You can learn more about that here: Comment removed link to private group [ph]
Your comment reminds me of a famous olde saying:
And you really do excel at it. Somehow you manged to get 3 lies (or at least implied lies) into that one short sentence!
Congratulations!
No more terrorist than the Palestinians terrorists during these massacres of Jews pre-1948, Battle of Tel Hai , Nebi Musa riots , Jaffa riots , Palestine Riots , Safed massacre , 1938 Tiberias pogrom , Hadassah medical convoy massacre , Kfar Etzion massacre . Hate begets hate Randy.
LMAO
Aeon,
You do realize that you just made the best argument for the existence of Israel, right?
Randy,
They were no more terrorist than the Palestinians who did these acts of terror pre 1948, Battle of Tel Hai , Nebi Musa riots , Jaffa riots , Palestine Riots , Safed massacre , 1938 Tiberias pogrom , Hadassah medical convoy massacre , Kfar Etzion massacre . Randy, hate begets hate.
It sounds great-- and of course has a big positive in that it would be non-violent. But it is sooooo totally unrealistic, and would never work-- for several reasons.
First of all, the vast majority of Palestinians are of the mindset where they feel that only violence will work. The vast majority would never embrace non-violence. In fact, any Palestinian Arab advocating a peaceful approach would be accused of being a "Zionist spy" and be lynched (defintie;y would happen in Gaza, but in the West Bank the lynch mob might be stopped enroute).
Secondly, it assumes that the Palestinians would unite (against Israel) in this. But the fact is-- they couldn't. Wouldn't. Currently Hamas (rulers of one of the current Palestinian states-- that of Gaza) hate the PA (Fatah, the head of the Palis in the West Bank. In face, many hate each other more than they hate the Jews!
And aside from the fact that it could never happen, there's another problem: Currently there are some 20+ Arab staes in the world-- and if you add non-Arab Muslim countries, the tota; becomes 55. Why should the Arabs get 20+ countries, and the Jewss not be allowed even one? (And a teensy-weensy one, with almost no resources at that?)
Current situation: Muslim world in green, Israel in red:
And "Palestine" has been divided up so there are three areas with self rule-- one is run by Jews, two are run by Arabs.
There's not the slightest doubt in my mind that the vast majority of students were neither Israelis nor Arabs. At first, to the average unbiased and uninformed person it sounds great-- a solution at last! no violence! (And hey-- obviously the Arabs should be allowed a country-- in fact 20 of them-- but why shoud those pesky Jews be treated the same?)
And, a minor point-- Israel in that map is shown as it was pre-2005-- its somewhat smaller now!
Well, you don't seem to read.
Actually there's also another major difference:
I've been closely following the mid east situation dor years-- decades actually. After every Muslim terror attack, not only don't they apologize, they glorify the terrorists as mayrtyrs. And this attack was rare--- with the exception of a few rare attacks by some rogue group or individual, Israel directs its attacks at military targets. Palestinian terrorists (well, the terrorists in places like Syria, Jordan, Libya, lebanon, etc) deliberately aim their attacks at civilians! Its very, very rare that Palestinian terrorists attack soldiers or army units-- they prefer civilians on buses, in homes-- or else firing rockets aimed at civilian areas.
SAnd not only fail to apologize...they glorify the perps!
Link?
Of course not. But there are so many anti-Israel and downright anti-Semitic hate sites on the net-- some with huge funding-- that if your false allegation had any merit, you have no trouble find links from reputable sources.
But for some reason you can't (interesting though that Perrie seemed to have no trouble finding those videos.. Hmmm-- maybe because that sort of thing is so common in Pali areas., but not in Israeli books.
No god had nothing to do with it, Randy. It's a question of who were the indigenous people were. Clearly, Jews predates the Arabs.
Use google scholar John. Just because one person says it is, doesn't mean that it is. Some people have an agendas
That did it! You just made me wipe my coffee off my monitor!
Randy,
What you CHOSE to not recognize is the plain fact that there has always been a Jewish presence there.... dating back before the Romans. I don't use the bible as my reference.
You're bring Indians into this discussion? They are the indigenous people of this land, and in NYS that is recognized. You have got to stop watching those old movies.
And I don't think that thePalestinians are the "bad guys". It is you who brought extreme comparisons into this discussion, not I with off the grid comparisons to Nazis. In fact, I believe in a two state solution, which means that I believe they should have a homeland, which is more than their Arab brothers think, since their homeland was suppose to be the land that Jordan now has.
No Randy. Those massacres are historical. You might not like it, but there you have it. As I said earlier, hate begets hate.
Randy,
No. Not them. You really should have read Bob Nelson's articles.
Do I have to reprint that list of terrorist acts that happened before "48 again?
Then you don't know the Pink Floyd song.
Money was about greed. Shine on you crazy diamond was about mental illness and you are preaching to the choir here, Randy.
They say if you repeat a lir often enough, people will believe. They even had me fooled-- I also used to call it a wall. But that is misleading-- to say the least. Why would they call the separation barrier a wall- - when is clearly a low fence:
But wait-- haven't you seen pictures of it which clearly show a wall? What's up with that?
Fact: -- in over 95%of its length is looks like this photo-- and it is clearly a low fence- - not a wall. The scary looking photos of a wall the hate-Israel crows loves to show us is actually less than 5% of its length!
Food for thought:
1. If 95% of it is a an actual fence, why do Pali propagandists keep calling it a wall? Anyone know?
2. If its almost entirely a fence, why would the Israelis go to the trouble of constructing a tiny portion as a wall -- and bot a fence? What's so different about that area? Can you guess?
Therein lies the rub, as the article makes clear he was quite happy to play in China, I take it he's never heard of Tibet.
His false claims of genocide, media control and apartheid are common amongst the enemies of Israel. Please note, I didn't say the supporters of the Palestinians, I said the enemies of Israel, there is a difference.
Well Randy, Bob provided lots of links and factual information that is verifiable for those who doubt his articles, and it only takes a TINY amount of brainpower for the uninitiated to check his facts. He refers to actual history and treaties, all in the nutshell of 4 articles. If you are unaware of the history, and from your consistently posting false information I believe you are, may I suggest as a friend that you educate yourself. You know George Santayana's saying "Those who ignore history are bound (or doomed) to repeat it." Actually Santayana wasn't first to make such a statement. It was Edmund Burke who in the 18th century wrote "Those who don't know history are destined to repeat it."
In your case, consistently posting propaganda lies as if they were truths, and totally closing your mind to any other concept, leads me to believe that either you are just too damn lazy to learn the truth or else you do it purposely to cause controversial discussion. If it's the latter, it's your privilege; if it's the former, I pity you (but then maybe that's what you want). Whatever, I know damn well you're not stupid.
Was it to provide the Palestinians with a propaganda tool? (because it succeeded to do so).
OR, most likely, it was to be a barrier (and it is called a barrier - a 'separation barrier' - rather than a fence or a wall) to protect an area most vulnerable to Palestinian attacks.
That's a really good point.
Have not seen you for a while AFM. I'm glad you're back.
As for Waters' ignoring what could be considered equal or worse situations, such as your reference to China and Tibet, it is the reason why the normally tolerant Abe Foxman of the ADL named him to be an anti-Semite.
Yes. Correct on both counts!
1. What do most people think of when you say a "wall"? Probably the Berlin Wall-- a horrendous thing built to keep people from escaping to freedom. So imediately "wall" creates negative images.
But there isd a big difference-- in fact, the two are opposites. The Berlin Wall was built to keep people in. People trying to escape to freedom. But the Israeli fence is to keep people out- - people who are trying to create terror.
And of course building fences & walls to keep out barbarians is not new in history:
2. And you are right about why that small section is a wall (and a high wall at that). You can find many pictures of the 95% that is a fence-- and notice much of it is in relatively unpopulated areas.
But parts of it are in built up areas. There, Palestinians have been firing at civilians-- in homes, and in one section at cars on a busy road. The wall stops the bullets-- obviously a fence can't do that.
Ha ha!! Thanks for the photo of The Great Wall - I've been there. It truly is a man-made wonder.
Countries all over the world (including the USA) have barriers, fences or walls along their borders to maintain security and exclude illegal infiltrators. So the question, of course, has to arise as to why Israel is always the focus when no other country is? The answer to that is obvious, isn't it. Israel is the only Jewish country in the world.
You're right . And why ? Because they elected terrorists as the head of government there . THEY DID IT TO THEMSELVES !
Precisely Buzz, all too often support for the Palestinians is used as cover for something far darker. The only other reasonable explanations for him playing in China is complete and utter ignorance or a staggering level of hypocrisy.
That should be only the start . He should also hold concerts in the Gaza strip ... Then it would become "crushingly obvious" what the actual problem is .
The pig-shaped balloon should go over big in Gaza. Waters might get through one song before they cut off his head and drag his body through downtown Gaza behind a motorbike. His last thought might be to reconsider exactly who the Nazis are in the region.
1) One of the things the student speaker alluded to, which I thought was a bit far fetched at the time, was that Israel has been covertly funding opposition groups within the Palestinian people to keep them divided so an idea like his, could never happen. Now it seems very plausible.
2) "the vast majority of Palestinians are of the mindset where they feel that only violence will work." - I unconditionally reject that. Aside from being unprovable, the corporate controlled media in the US presents a totally one sided view of Palestinians has savage beasts. Their leaders have betrayed them for money, which is the universal coin of the corporate state strategy.
There is a hopelessness that prevails Palestinian life which in turn leads to violence. That's the cause.
Good, then make peace. Simple.
Wrong again. Still no cigar. They separate Israel proper from the West Bank or else they would not have been effective to stop the incessant suicide bombings and terrorist attacks.
Randy, why do you keep peppering your comments with absolute made-up bullsh*t?
Israel not only has the moral right, it has the obligation to keep its citizens safe from being murdered.
It was granted the land via UN Partition. Other lands were acquired through defending itslelf from invasion.
They've existed since 1948 without any need for nuclear bombs. The threat of nuclear bombs causes detente, no rights were acquired through that. I think you're not interpreting the word "right" correctly.
That was satirical irony, but whatever. If my memory serves me correct, the prophet Jesus and his family were in such danger in Palestine, they had to flee to Egypt.
Your deep ignorance of the history of that region is now plain for all to see . Anyone can google the history of Hamas which is classified as a terrorist organization by almost all of the western world ... Calling what I said a lie is a stinking pile of dung ... Phew !!
Again a reference to Nazis. The consequences cannot be compared. Making peace is not surrendering - it is giving up resistance and assuming a normal life. Please stop with the Nazi references. It does not become your arguments.
Blockade for a purpose. Give up WHY Gaza is blockaded then the blockade goes away. And, JFT, you know damn well Gaza also has a border on a fellow Muslim country. Thje deeper you get with your arguments, the less credibility you achieve. Don't make a fool of yourself.
Spot on BF.
Randy,
You think you know the history of the region. You never read anything that has been presented to you. You have no historical reference for what happened there, just what YOU BELIEVE to be true. Instead you use inflammatory and insulting language. I am utterly shocked.
Yeah, it is a shame. A very big shame.
The indication that Israelis are not oppressors comes from the fact that there are quite a few Arab citizens of Israel .
They have full rights and privileges . They vote and hold office . They even serve in the army ...
Also that Gaza is such a horror to live in !
Listen up Randy,
This is no ideological discussion for me. This IS my family history.
Don't school me on my Indian ancestorssince my paternal Indian great grandmother lived in the same house with my Russian grandmother. Both had great respect for each other, since they understood each other's losses and my father was raised to be proud of both. My grandmother's family left Russia due to the pogroms in the very late 1890's. Half of them went to Canada and the other half of them went Palestine. My grandmother's uncle was murder in a market place, bludgeoned to death by a gang of Arabs, for being nothing more than a Jew in the wrong place. You're going to tell me that he didn't have the right to be there? And let me be specific here, this was in the early 20th Century... long before 1948. Don't you be freakin' telling me about who are terrorist. There is nothing but history telling us that Jews where thrown out or killed in every Muslim country in the ME. It's you that need to be schooled on the facts, not me.
JFT: How dare you compare the rights and lives of the Arabs in Israel to the genocide, the Holocaust, the murder of half the Jews in the world. Your intransigence is pitiful.
About Indians you are correct. About the Israel and the ME, not only am I going to deny it, you don't know anything and you are not interested in learning anything.
Of course not . The faithful Islamic only sees value in death [martyrdom] . Why should anyone else care about their lives ?
Randy,
By implying that I don't think thatPalestinians are not human beings, you crossed the line with me. Go to hell.
Oscar Wilde said, "I do not suffer fools, gladly"
Nor do I. I'm through with this discussion.
Well then Pot meet kettle.
Speak for yourself!
So maybe you feel that the non-Washington insider (the average American) also can't feel even minimally confident to have a truly informed opinion on Obamacare, the tea Party, the war in Afghanistan, the budget crisis, the massacres in Syria, Hamastan/Gaza (and most of the rest of the Arab world), etc.
In that perhaps we should do away with voting...democracy since americans don't know didly-squat.
No democracy-- perhaps insitiute the kind of barbaric police state such as those in the Palestinian ruled Hamastan (AKA "Gaza"), Egypt, Libya, Sudan, Fraudi Arabia, Yemen, Syria-- heck, most of the Arab world.
Widespread hatred is the norm there-- persecution, torture, government encouraged attacks on gays, Jews, Christians, women-- even Shias by Sunni and versa vice. The sort of genocidal Arab governments of which you are so fond!
And which, perhaps even more strangely, you spend so much time and effort defending. (Don't you have anything better to do with your time than to defend this sort of barbarism? OH wait-- no need to answer-- the answer is obvious...)
You clearly have no idea what you are talking about . It has nothing to do with the west & everything to do with the Palis & the Arabs . The Palis are the PARIAHS of the middle east . No one in the middle east respects them . They are discriminated against in every country they have been allowed entry to ... and for good reasons ! They inevitably abuse the favors of everyone they deal with and then get kicked out ... Learn some ME history instead of stupidly spouting off about subjects you know NOTHING about .
"Palestinians" in Arab countries are treated quite harshly by other Arabs. I bet a lot of them wish tyhey could smuggle themselves into Israel-- where Arabs are treated much better..
Heck, even in the "occupied" West Bank:
In addition to being a really nasty bigot, he is indeed also a hypocrite.
Actually, if he was to be do what he claims to believe in, he wouldn't play in the U.S. either, given our horrendous treatment of the indigenous U.S. population (i.s. American Indians).
This racist moron claims that he's against "occupation" and "oppression"? What a friggin liar! (If he was truthful, he wouldn't play in American until we return to our Indians the occupied land that was stolen from-- and end all oppression!!!
Heh
And on a similar note-- I wonder if an Israeli wandered across the border with Syria-- would they treat her like this
Well then Pot meet kettle.
Just who are you referring to with that remark?
Blind denial? I doubt that there is anyone except you who thinks that.
The Jewish refugees didn't fight back, they made a life for themselves. Refugees all over the world walked away from EVERYTHING and made lives for themselves. There is only one example in all of history of people who refuse to make a life for themselves and prefer to seek world sympathy and live off the dole. My anscestors escaped the pogroms in Russia with NOTHING, and they made lives for themselves in Canada, worked hard and became successful. Refugees all over the world who have lost everything put it behind them and make lives for themselves - yes, NORMAL lives.
Oh really ? Which race ? What an incredibly stupid comment !
Actually it was founded on the Balfour Declaration but don't let the facts get in your way . Here's what you need to do , Stop bitching about Israel . Go to the Gaza strip and live there . Then if you live through that for a year or so , come back & relate your experiences . Until you do that you are just talking out of your ass ...
No way, he's a cowardly armchair critic who knows nothing about the issues first hand, but reads a lot of propaganda.
What does the pre-1947 map look like in terms of Muslim/Arab vs Jewish states??
"Why should the Arabs get 20+ countries, and the Jewss not be allowed even one? (And a teensy-weensy one, with almost no resources at that?)"
Why should Any religion get any land? And who put that little red dot there and thought that it would not create conflict?
As long as there are not sufficient political will from both sides of this utterly foolish conflict, there will be no peace. Both sides, as far as I can see, have the mouthpieces that yell, "They did it! Kill them!" while ignoring their own complicity in the events that unfold. Until all sides stop demonizing the other, there will be attempts to destroy the other,there will be actors who take advantage of the perceived differences to enable their own personal agenda.
The middle east is a playground for vicious, religious zealots, and power hungry religious zealots... and arm's dealers. Too bad that there are people who actually live there and try to get along.
The treatment of the "Palestinians" in Arab countries is horrendous-- no informed person would dispute that.
Stating a well known fact makes someone a "racist"???
DOH!
Your comments make it obvious that you are either really stupid-- or a nasty bigot!
But, being the nice guy that I am, I'd be willing to give you the benefit of the doubt and assume that you are not really stupid!
Well, even a stopped clock is right twice a day-- so you got that partly correct.
In 1948 there was supposed to be 2 new counties created, a Jewish Palestine and an Arab Palestine. However, 5 Arab countries attacked-- when the dust cleared, the main parts that were supposed to be the new Arab "Palestine" were occupied by Egypt and Jordan-- these two countries thereby effectively managing to totally prevent the formation of the new Arab "Palestine".
And aside from having other Arabs steal their land, Arafat stole from them bulk of the huge amounts of money they were (and still are) getting:
And yes, that's not a typo-- the amount of money Arafat stole the "Palestinians" was not millions-- it really was billions. (Most "Palestinians" still revere Arafat to this day).
Another ass has farted.
Here's an excellent animated map I discovered a while back that will easily clear that up:
Notice when palestine first appeared...notice when Israel first appeared.
GET SMARTER HERE!
So the UN Partition voted by most of the world's countries at that time is a criminal act? You're concepts are totally twisted.
Armchair critic? How many times have you been to Israel and the West Bank? I've been there twice. I've seen it with my own eyes, have you? Both my kids have been there many times. All of us Have yours?My son lived there for a year. All of us have personally experienced Palestinian terrorism and as well how much the Israelis try to do for them. If Perrie can tell you to go to hell, so can I.
Actually
"What makes the founding of Israel a crime" was that it was a theft of the land ... from the Israelis . Yes , they were granted all of "Transjordan" by the Balfour declaration but they only ended up with a tiny sliver of land . The rest went to the country now called Jordan ... a crime indeed !
My bad Buzz. I let my anger get the better of me and it screwed with my metaphors.
Brolly,
I totally agree. But this was never going to be a discussion based on the article we were working from. Personally, I believe in a two state solution. I believe in peace. But the rhetoric of this article got into full swing right away.
True. But that was an established fact a long time ago.
LMAO... talk down to you??? You've been calling me names throughout this article... just tip toeing up to the CoC... so don't get all high and mighty with me. So I missed that line. BIG FRICKEN DEAL RANDY!
John,
Where was this article supposed to go given the starting material? It wasn't going to bring out the the best considering the inflammatory remarks made by Waters. It was one that would only drive this kind of discussion... or there lack of.
Randy,
Arabs are not a race, they are an ethnicity. They are white... Semetic whites. The same as the Israelis you are complaining about. I'd give you a link to prove this, but I know you'll never read it.
Perrie,
An established fact, however old, does that does not release the players of today from their complicity in the deaths of people,be they of any nationality.
I was watching as you guys tore into one another, each person feeling justified in their own, righteous anger... it was like the conflict had come home to roost right here on NT.
I am sure that the majority of people in the middle east want peace, want to live their lives as they hear of others in more stable places living, without the cloud of ubiquitous violence hovering always near. So, why, pray tell, do they not live these types of lives. Is it because of religion? Is it because of the governments?
I would posit that it is largely because of the way that the people are conditioned to think about the conflict by those around them, by those who feel a need to have conflict to gain power and cannot or will not see it any other way, from any other pov.
John,
I would accept that, but at least, most brought what they felt were reasonable arguments and links... and frankly, an article of this sort should have been watched by Aeon. No one could have posted something that inflammatory and not expect this.
Brolly,
I think that was the point of this article. BTW, I was angry but there was nothing righteous about it.
Randy,
You have got to be kidding. Let me break it down for you. No European nation likes either, but they need Arabs for the Oil, so that gives Arabs a bit of an edge there. Otherwise they are viewed both as outsiders, Arab and Jews, both swarthy white Semites. Here in the good US of A, I live 2 miles from a country club that has an unofficial "no Jews allowed" policy. So please stop making this about race, cause if you are then you have to include Jews. Now I am done with this discussion, Trayvon.
I was not using the word Righteous in a derogatory manner, I was using it in the manner intended as it is defined. To Wit:
righteous|rchs|adjective1(of a person or conduct) morally right or justifiable; virtuous:he is a good, righteous man, I am sure|feelings ofrighteous indignationabout pay and conditions.See note atmoral.2informalperfectly wonderful; fine and genuine:righteous bread pudding.
Brolly,
There is no doubt that there is no right or righteous going on here. But when words likeLebensraum,which is the Nazi word for living space, you tell me, who is inciting who? The only thing I did was try to bring some facts to this discussion, and had words like that thrown in my face. How can one have a discussion with that going on?
So why did you seed it?
Would you seed articles by Ku Klux Clan supporters, or Nazi supporters?
Brolly,
In case you think I am being glib about the usage of the word Lebensraum, here it is from Websters:
Territory believed especially by Nazis to be necessary for national existence or economic self-sufficiency
and from the on line dictionary:
1. Additional territory deemed necessary to a nation, especially Nazi Germany, for its continued existence or economic well-being.
You have to be awfully egotistical to declare that your opinion is the truth. You're not God. When you get a little humility and realize that declaring what YOU say is unimpeachable because of your omniscience you could possibly earn a little respect around here.
Interestingly, the President specifically addresses just that in a speech a while back (in fact he actually started his speech off with those remarks-- take a listen):
Perrie,
This is a discussion, and for what it is worth, we can all bring our own points of view to the table. If some of our points of view are challenged, then we can respond however we wish.
The reason that I was pointing to righteous anger is because that is what one feels, the way one reacts, when challenged on core assumptions. Since these core assumptions are ubiquitous, in that we all have them, yet also different, as each individuals core beliefs and assumptions are formed internally and informed by life experiences, I was indicating that righteous anger is what you and all of the others were feeling, and with good reason.
But good reason for righteous anger does not always lead to a solution to a particular problem. It can and, in many cases, does actually impede the search for a solution to the problems that exist. (Look at the recent debacles in congress as an example.) What is most difficult to accept is to not have ones feelings of righteous anger acknowledged. And hence, Down the Rabbit Hole we go, and in a short time the talking devolves to shouting, then to further breakdown and all is done. The groups which were nominally at peace are now fuming and plotting, saying "how could they" and other such things.
So, in the microcosm of NT, I saw basically the same thing happening as happens in the ME. We so often say in the west, "How can they do that? Don't they have more sense than that?" not realizing that those very same reactions that people have shown right here, that righteous anger, is part of the source of the problem. We need to hold in check our righteous anger sometimes, because it is not only righteous, but it is also anger, and anger is a powerful force that screams for vengeance and blood.
Sticks and stones....
Brolly,
I understood where you were coming from and I don't disagree with you at all. But in the case of this discussion, one needs to look at the starting point, in this case, the seed. It was a poor place to start from as it made for shaky ground by pointing fingers right from the get go. When people go into a discussion that they don't want to turn heated, they need a more stable footing. This article was like seeing a fire and trying to put it out with gasoline. It was never going to bring out the best in any of us.
I will post an article I wrote years ago tomorrow. Maybe you read it, maybe you didn't. But it's where my mind is at on this subject.
I feel like I let you down in some way and that makes me feel badly. I am resisting getting back into this discussion. IDK what else to say.
What makes you think that? Did you ever hear of "jihad?"
Do you know that both the Hamas and Fatah chartersoppose negotiation andhave the end of Israel as their policy?
Oh well . You reap what you sow ...
Eg :
Yup . There it is ...
Thanks . I appreciate your vote of no confidence ... and you thought I needed acceptance !
Interesting thought. During the time of JC the Samaritans were treated with the same antipathy by the Jews as the Palestinians are today.
Are they people?
Peace with who ... exactly ?
Petey,
To have peace exist, it is not necessary for there to be any other.
Peace is the absence of strife.
That's accurate . Now please explain this : What makes you think the middle east has ever been peaceful ?
Wrong again!
Remember what happened in Gaza? After Israel gained control of Gaza from Egypt (there was never any such thing as a "Palestinian state" there)-- Israelis moved in and, yup-- built 'settlements" in Gaza. So if you theory is true, the so-called "Palestinians" in Gaza would never get "their land" back.
But what actually happened? israel unilaterally withdrew in 2005:
Since then Hamastan (AKA "the Gaza Strip") is no longer ruled by The Ottoman Empire, Britain, Egypt or Israel-- its now t he first entity in history ruiled by the so-called "Palestinians"- - ruled, specifically, the barbaric terror group Hamas.
And those settlements that were supposedly "a permanent obstacle to peace"? Well, all the land (100%) that the Gaza settlements were on is now controlled 100% by the Arabs! There's no longer even a single Jew in the place!!!
Duh!
You do realize I am just copying your earlier commentary ? What does that say about you ?
Whoa ! Delusions of the importance of what you just said ... A vast need to be accepted as an authority ...
Yikes !
Petey asked:
"What makes you think the middle east has ever been peaceful ?"
Who said that it had? Areas of the middle east have certainly seen periods of relative stability and, dare I say, relative peace.
But it is not necessary for peace to have existed for peace to exist. It is necessary for the energies of the righteous anger that circulates throughout the world to have an outlet that is not somehow harming other people, being directed towards non-peaceful ends and forming groups of others.
I think you're right ... in theory . In practice the middle east is a lot like the Hatfields & the McCoys .
Or, perhaps-- strife is the absence of peace...?
(food for thought....)
Excellent description, Badfish. I had wished to be a psychiatrist, and even spent my freshman university year in Pre-Medicine on the way to that goal, but then changed my mind and majored in English Lit instead. The symptoms you indicated are so very recognizable here, are they not?
Krish,
"Or, perhaps-- strife is the absence of peace...?"
They are opposing concepts that do appear to be mutually exclusive on first examination. With further examination, there does appear a gradual lessening of one with an increase of the other, kind of like most concepts that appear dichotomous at first blush.
In parts of the middle east things do seem to be getting worse-- particular the old Sunni vs Shia hatreds are more out in the open-- the Syrian Civil War (which is slowly spreading to Lebanon)-- and basically the same Sunni vs Shia war is increasing next door in Iraq.
The conflict in Egypt is still pretty bad-- no end in sight. (That's one of the few major conflicts is not Sunni v Shia).
In terms of actual violence between Israel and the Arabs, that is way down from where it use to be-- but the problem isn't yet resolved of course.
However, there are projects that are working towards peace and creating mutual understanding. None are big enough to make a broad change yet-- but at least some people are making the effort:
Finding a comparable region in the world to Gaza is difficult . I would suggest Somalia . If Gaza had a navy we could expect state sponsored piracy there as well .
Since that video is from 2002, it would be interesting to see how the children have progressed.
It would be very interesting to see how they have developed over time. I came across a more recent video about the school-- from 2010. So the schools do still exist, but it doesn't have any follow-up on earlier grads.