Donald Trump Is The World’s Greatest Troll
A troll, according to one definition , is a person who sows discord by starting arguments or upsetting people with the deliberate intent of provoking readers into an emotional response or of otherwise disrupting normal on-topic discussion.
The goal of the troll is to provoke a reaction by any means necessary. Trolls thrive in communities that are open and democratic (they wouldnt be invited into a discussion otherwise) and which operate in presumed good faith (there need to be some standards of decorum to offend). Presidential nomination contests are highly susceptible to trolling, therefore. Access is fairly open: Theres no longer much of a filter between the campaigns, the media and the public. And its comically easy to provoke a reaction. How many times between now and next November will we hear that a candidates statement is offensive, whether or not it really is?
Trolls operate on the principle that negative attention is better than none. In fact, the troll may feed off the negative attention, claiming it makes him a victim and proves that everyone is out to get him.
Sound like any presidential candidates you know ?
Theres a notion that Donald Trumps recent rise in Republican polls is a media-driven creation. That explanation isnt entirely wrong, but its incomplete. It skims over the complex interactions between the media, the public and the candidates, which can produce booms and busts of attention. And it ignores how skilled trolls like Trump can exploit the process to their benefit.
Lets look at some data. In the chart below, Ive tracked how media coverage has been divided among the Republican candidates over roughly the past month (the data covers June 14 through July 12), according to article counts on Google News. In turn, Ive shown the share of Google searches for each candidate over the same period. The data was provided to FiveThirtyEight by Google but should closely match what youll get by searching on Google Trends or Google News yourself.
The chart I showed you above contained data on each GOP candidates chances of winning the nomination, according to the prediction market Betfair . 1 Candidates who are perceived as having a credible chance to win the nomination like Bush, Walker and Rubio receive proportionally more media attention than public attention. The reverse is true for candidates who are seen by the press as long shots, such as Rand Paul and Ben Carson. 2
As is usually the case, however, life gets more complicated when we go from identifying correlations to trying to understand their causes. As weve seen, press coverage is highly correlated with the level of public interest in a candidate and the candidates perceived chances of winning the nomination. It could be, however, that public attention to a candidate is triggered by media coverage rather than the other way around. Likewise, while the media might be fairly sophisticated at identifying which candidates are more likely to win and provide correspondingly more coverage of them, the media can also produce a self-fulfilling prophecy. Being ignored by the media or labeled as a loser can make it hard for a candidate to attract money, endorsements and other resources that might allow them to make a comeback.
http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/donald-trump-is-the-worlds-greatest-troll/

Media hype and entertainment value versus electability -- thatis the paradox when it comes to Donald Trump.
Mr. Trump has a seemingly infinite supply of the former and virtually none of the latter
The key questionfor some is whether Mr. Trump will destroy whatever small chance the Republicans have of winning in 2016, either through a destructive primary process or by running as a third party candidate and sealing the deal for whoever runs for the democrats.
Mr. Trump has virtually no chance of getting the nomination from the Republican Party and even a smaller chance of being elected president in 2016.
This is clearly the media's fault. They are covering his every move and stupid comments. They should be covering the real candidates more. This is the issue with what passes as journalism these days.
Perrie
Excellent point
He is using the media to promote his persona, rather than a viable political agenda, it is a political spin off of Celebrity Apprentice
Thanks for the perspective
They have done it time and time again, too... Did I need to know all that about Sarah Palin? Nope. And yet, her coverage seemed to go on forever...
Dowser
Excellent point
Always appreciate false assertions (Trump is the leader of the GOP now.) and ridiculous predictions (He's going to take Ohio!)
Every day, I actively miss Walter Cronkite, Chet Huntley, Dave Brinkley, etc.
Dowser
Yes the das before news journalists became extinct and were replaced by opinionated talking heads advocating one side or the other, often at the expense of the whole truth.
On a lighter note -
Up until the late 70's, TV news was considered a "cost center" and a public service. It produced some of the best journalists of our time. By the 80's, corporations started buying NBC, CBS, ABC, ect and turning news into a "profit center." That was the beginning of the end of Journalism on TV news.
And that is why journalists are becoming extinct
Reply by Perrie Halpern :
"This is clearly the media's fault."
As for-profit businesses, naturally "the media," (corporations, generally) will seek profit over all other values. That's what large-scale businesses do. They cannot help themselves. It's programmed into their machinery.
Broadcasting media seeks " ratings " as necessary for money-profit, their entire raison d'etre and modus operandi .
Perhaps we who find the media at fault for not serving the general public good should take a step back and fully acknowledge and understand that the first job of "the media" is to make money/profit. We cannot even say that "the media" is internally conflicted because at cross purposes--, because as a society we have long ago ceased to demand integrity in either media or in government. We have not even begun to address the cross purposes which define our current culture and civilization (in most or all industries).
It is apt to call Trump a troll. But it would appear that he's a profitable troll, and an apt reflection of our rather pathetic current cultural condition.
I don't think anything CAN change until we effectively address the role of monetary (profit) motivation in most everything. As a society, we need to empower cultural processes and activities which are not profit (money)-driven.
I think the Republican party, itself, helped create the anti-establishment environment in which Trump thrives. Let's take illegal immigration. A significant part of the Republican base wants to keep illegal aliens out and doesn't give a rat's ass about their pathway to citizenship. The Republican establishment, on the other hand, is seeking to compete with the Democratic party for hispanic votes and that competition has moved the anti-illegal immigration issue to the background because it could create controversy that establishment candidates would prefer to avoid. Candidates who avoid difficult issues look weak as they inspire little confidence that they can solve a problem that they're too cowardly (or politically correct) to even discuss. As candidates avoid the issue, dissatisfaction in the base grows until it reaches a boiling point. Enter Donald Trump.
Donald Trump puts illegal immigration on the table like an exploding grenade and he rockets to the top of the polls. The media hates him but can't ignore the front runner. Plus, outrageous statements make news as the press covers what is usually an attempt by the candidate at damage control. But Trump is independently wealthy and doesn't answer to anybody but himself. Prodding him to apologize only results in him repeating his original statement and maybe making another one even more outrageous. With Trump, politics has become theater and he generates public interest that drives media coverage.
Others have to think of their political careers; Trump thinks about his wallet. When people tried to protest Trump's statements by affecting his wallet and canceling deals with him, he released his (probably inflated) net worth to say don't waste your time because I'm much too rich for you to affect. Because the base is so angry, Trump's poll numbers remain constant no matter what he says and does. The other candidates will begin running out of money and their supporters will go elsewhere. It's anybody's guess who will reap those supporters in the end but if the field of candidates narrows to three or four, a solid hold on 20-24% of the base plus any supporters he picks up from candidates who drop out, could mean that he's the Republican nominee.
If Trump became theRepublican nominee I'd have to party in the streets with all of the others who would be ecstatic about that outcome.
First of all, it would be utterly hilarious (though also weirdlyfrightening).
But, secondly, it would assure that an independent, Democrat, or third party candidate would win. And I've had more than my fill of Republicans.
We should probably begin to form a new political party real soon whose purpose is to gradually phase out representative "democracy" in America, replacing it, basically, with some form of direct democracy -- a variety which is overwhelmingly empowering to the local scale while sustaining basic human rights for all people.
I don't know what sort of design such a society would have, but I'm sure it could not be worse than the fraudulent scam which is "representative democracy".
Of course, we will be needing to phase out most Big and Centralized things, including giant corporations.
One can dream, can't one?
That's the general assumption but all the assumptions regarding Trump have, so far, been dead wrong. The Democratic base among non college degree white voters is eroding. The far left part of the party is breaking away under Bernie Sanders. Hillary is notenergizing young voters and she appears to be losing married white female voters as well. Hillary's support in the South is weak. Hispanic voters could go either way.Black voterswill not normally leave the Democratic party but there is no guarantee that they will show up in the numbers they did for Obama and, without those numbers, Hillary willhavea problem. Plus, a total renegade Republican like Trump, who is running basically as an independent within the party, might have a much better chance of skimming some black votes than any other Republican. If I were Hillary, I wouldn't be so certain that she can beat Trump especially when a nobody like Bernie Sanders is running on her heels, drawing crowds of almost 30,000 people.
"The far left part of the party is breaking away under Bernie Sanders."
Why would it? He's running as a Democrat.
I meant breaking away from Hillary.
A very good point
James
Do you mean big government entitlement programs?
There is a fine line between being a troll and being way ahead of your time ...
RIO: "Do you mean big government entitlement programs?"
Ultimately, yes. Though I'd not use that language, "entitlement programs". Rather, I'd create a New New Deal, with two News in it. Everyone should be offered an opportunity to build their own homes with their own hands..., and grow their own food within their own communities -- on land held in common, or communally. No one should be born without land access enough to provide for themselves within community in this way.
Those who find this whole notion preposterous can consult with me on the human ecology, integral design and human justice philosophy aspects. It's not something most people have any handle on, since were now so thoroughly industrialized as a people.
"There is a fine line between being a troll and being way ahead of your time ..."
Uh-huh. And there's a very fine line between being a narcissistic troll with delusions ofgrandeur and a psychopathic, pathetic nincompoop who hasn't read a book since fourth grade.
he key questionfor some is whether Mr. Trump will destroy whatever small chance the Republicans have of winning in 2016
Why do you write things that aren't true? The only actual democrat capable of running the race, HRC, is losing head to head match-ups against 3 republicans in Iowa ( a blue state) and only beating this "troll" Donald Trump 43-40%. Pretty much every Republican you can name is within the margin of error against her.
If you don't think the Republicans have a 50-50% chance to win the election right now, you haven't been paying attention.
I'm actually enjoying Trump's total disruption of our uber-corrupt political process. The democrats should be taking notes. Ain't anarchy pretty?
It's a shame the fate of the free world hangs in the balance.
There is no fine line between you & Trump . You read lots of leftist propaganda . He makes money .
Dear Friend Dowser: Don't forget John Chancellor and Edward R Murrow.
Those were the days.
Ratings didn't matter.
Fluff wasn't professional.
Stories were about what the public needed to make up their own minds.
Hard journalism. Fact based and objectively reported.
The story was about keeping the nation informed.
I wasn't principally about personalities, either running for office or who told the story.
Not everything that is good is new.
Not everything that is new is good.
E.
Dear Friend John Martin: I concur all this is true today. It wasn't always so.
The First Amendment Freedom of the Press isn't that to make quarterly profit projections, or ratings target goals.
Media has devolved to the bottom line. Fine. But no more First Amendment Freedoms.
They are reserved for the public good.
Not for shareholder interests.
Media may not have it both ways.
Good post. Thought provoking,
Thanks for sharing.
E.
Dear Friend Aeonpax: Well said.
Great post.
Thanks,
Enoch.
1 of m
Absolutely correct in my view.
The bottom line is that Trump cannot win the election as a Republican or an Independent, but he can absolutely insure that a Democrat wins
Feronia
Glad you liked the article thanks for the feedback
The correlation you mention is the main point and it may play out that the entertainment value fades as the election nears, or not......
James
Yeah right
You should not hold your breath waiting for that to be on any candidate's platform
It is not likely that the nation or the world will de-industrialize to create the hunter/gatherer communal society you envision
Thanks for the feedback
Petey
Unfortunately, the Donald is way over on the troll side of that score sheet
o m
The Donald will fade from the political scene without unbalancing the free world or anything else
Appreciate the perspective.
That might be true of any Republican candidate if minority voters turn out in large numbers in swing states. However, different dynamics can produce different results. A large part of the public is tired of scripted speeches and carefully crafted approaches designed to avoid the pitfalls of saying anything controversial or politically incorrect. They are also tired of Republican candidates who cynically run to the right in the primary and then run to the left in the general election. Democrats have a similar issue with their candidates. Most voters do not have any real depth on policy issues, often choosing candidates for superficial reasons e.g. do I like him/her, does he/she actually care about people like me etc.Althoughenergy/enthusiasm are not necessary in governing, it may make the difference in an election. Energy/enthusiasm carried Obama to victory and the lack of it helped doom Romney to defeat.
I just heard Trump say that Iran funds ISIL. This is a ridiculous statement but nobody called him on it. He stands before audiences, blathering in a stream of consciousness, and his supporters don't care. What catches their attention is that: he's a self made billionaire who may be able to do for them and the country what he has done for himself; he says what he thinks without scripts and coaches; some what he thinks is also what they think; and he's enthusiastic about what he says. Enthusiasmis often contagious and he has the potential of reaching voters that other Republicans cannot (e.g. black voters and blue collar Democrats . . . that predominate in swing states).
1 of m
Another excellent point and Hillary is not drawing the minority vote that Obama did the past two elections and the Republican appeal to minority groups is still be determined