╌>

Nations and the Vine

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  peter-loves-the-real-tea-party  •  14 years ago  •  200 comments

Nations and the Vine

I've been getting messages via my active Newsvine groups lately talking about nations and beta testing, or somesuch. I know many of you still have active accounts as well. Do you know anything about this? I asked a friend who is a beta tester a few minutes ago and anticipate he will respond when he sees it, but just curious about your thoughts, as current and ex members over yonder.

Also, I find the NV note attached to the emails I recieve to be interesting as well:

"Newsvine is a place to read, write, and influence the news. We take your privacy seriously. If you feel that you have received this email in error, please contact "newsvineabuse {at} newsvine {dot} com"."

In what way is Newsvine supposed to be influencing the news, and why do people feel a need to tamper with the news in the first place? Shouldnt the news simply be the news without further influence?


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
islandgirl
Freshman Silent
link   islandgirl    14 years ago

Actually I do get along with Krishna and love his YouTube posts! As far as the election officials, yes I am in the midst of officially launching a complaint. Farkers!

 
 
 
islandgirl
Freshman Silent
link   islandgirl    14 years ago

Well they are D'Wayne if your naked, if your not then they only serve tochap your ass.

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    14 years ago

If a seeder doesn't allow their board to become contentious, it won't, or rarely will happen.

Oh, I disagree. I was on the Vine very, very early on, early 2007. Came over with Jack Gillis and others. Left after three years or so, just couldn't take the crap any longer. I still go to see Jack, Lisa, Jazz of the NYT Refugees, but that's about it.

And it's STILL the way that if you post an article or seed that is against the lefty way, then the name callers, etc come out in droves, collapse comments, even seeds and articles.

I wonder if the new Vine will prevent that?

 
 
 
wmolaw
Professor Silent
link   wmolaw    14 years ago

Yeah, but she is a flaming lib, hiding behind the mask of an indie! LOL

 
 
 
MsAubrey (aka Ahyoka)
Junior Participates
link   MsAubrey (aka Ahyoka)    14 years ago

That's why some of us LOVE the private groups that are said to be done away with... Hence many of us having a new acct here even though we still have accts over there. Things don't get nasty in the private groups. Grin.gif

 
 
 
islandgirl
Freshman Silent
link   islandgirl    14 years ago

Well you do. LMAO!!Grin.gif

 
 
 
MsAubrey (aka Ahyoka)
Junior Participates
link   MsAubrey (aka Ahyoka)    14 years ago

Not talking about nasty as in naughty my dear.5.gif

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

36.gif

 
 
 
MsAubrey (aka Ahyoka)
Junior Participates
link   MsAubrey (aka Ahyoka)    14 years ago

I have a feeling the kids should not be in the room for that link.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

Nah ... it's PG13 .

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Pedro    14 years ago

You can (or could anyway, havent tried in a while) track the views, along with their points of origin, how often each individual looks, etc...That being said, my articles were generally averaging 200-300 comments, 60-70 votes, but were logging as many as 10k views. Google analytics as I recall.

I do agree with your post though. I cant believe they even put that line in their base email format (or whatever you call it). Trying to influence the news seems 100% wrong and completely lacking in integrity IMO.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Pedro    14 years ago

True. I used to call Newsvine my Starbucks gift card, because the $75-$100 a month I made there paid for my coffee habit, lol. At some point though, the payouts dropped off significantly. Although my views increased, my payouts dropped until, at one point, with nearly 30k views, I made something like $12 that month.

The analytics was more of a curiosity used to try to calculate how they determine earnings and to track the success of the site accordingly. I lost interest after my personal dispute with Newsvine that led to the not news category though.

There was one thing of interest though. I checked my analytics one month and found that my estranged father had been tracking my articles. I found that to be interesting.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Pete,

That happened to me, too! I had some outstanding months when I first started. My best month I made about $150! My page views were averaging about the same as yours...Then suddenly, bam! making $15 for the same number of comments and page views. I think that was the reason that ED Kain left. He's now writing for Forbes and I bet, he's not getting $25 an article.

Still don't know why Jack Gillis remains there. He's much better than most of the tripe that is written there.

 
 
 
Ben
Freshman Silent
link   Ben    14 years ago

LOLX2

 
 
 
Ben
Freshman Silent
link   Ben    14 years ago

DAMN! "...a couple hundred?" I always assumed I had two readers. Me and at least one person who would accidentally end up on my page...........Grin.gif

 
 
 
Ben
Freshman Silent
link   Ben    14 years ago

Oh hell....I'll bad mouth them as long as Brian Ford still believes he runs the joints and gets the staff to back him up with non-sense such as "Not News." Anyone with half a lick of sense knows that the very definition of news is ANY subject that is found to have interest. Just look at how MSNBC puts recipes on the Newsvine front page, but regular users have to label every thing as "not news," because Brian talked Mike into it.102.gif

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Oh Ben, I am so with you!

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    14 years ago

It's hard to explain . He wrote an article a while back recommending a zero tolerance policy for CoH violations .NV management pretty much followed his suggestions .

 
 
 
Arch-Man
Freshman Silent
link   Arch-Man    14 years ago

I think he was one of the founders, or whatever you call it, a developer.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Who is Brian Ford? That is like asking who is Kaiser Soze, LOL. But really on some level that is true. He should be a nobody, who isn't.He is a friend of Viki's and Mike D's who wrote a very infamous article called "How I would fix Newsvine". You can find it here . He had gone into a self imposedseclusionfrom NV because he wanted some strange rule that 1. there should be no more polls and 2. every article should be at least 500 words. When he wrote that article, it was almost instantly that "not news" was started. You can read Peter's commentary here . He is an arrogant man with an ego to match. Got as petty as calling this site, the New Stalkers. I mean really?

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Pedro    14 years ago

Brian Ford....my former internet stalker.

He is just another guy with a bad attitude and an opinion that his opinion is the only opinion that should be recognized on Newsvine...and that it should be written into the CoH there as well.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Hey Peter,

Funny how we can say the same thing, but you say it with far fewer words. LOL!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    14 years ago

I have no illusions regarding certain management styles ... particularly not the styles foisted by insecure, ego-maniacal, micro managers. They are what they are, and, from my career as a representative of working middle class individuals, I could tell you stories that belie much of the right-wing anti-union hype (although some of it is accurate).

Then there is the so-called "company man." That's a working person whose primary allegiance is to his/her employer ... often a snitch and a sell-out who benefits from being something of a traitor.

History has its examples ... the overseers of slaves ... Jews in Egypt, Negroes as slaves in America ... they got their perks by working both sides of the street. Are there "company men" playing both sides of certain web sites?

Could be.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Not true Readers!

Ben was well loved andreceived. He wrote some of the funniest stuff and the most honest..

I never missed an article.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Wait.. was that 500 words long?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    14 years ago

Brian Ford, Dennis McCann, the Killfile groupies, you can have all those people.

Well, at least as far as Dennis McCann (PBUH) is concerned, he did make some interesting contributions to the Vine-- at least in terms of helping to keep track of troublemakers and/or suspected troubemakers. (If you haven't read this before I highly recommend reading it carefully-- if you have read it before, re-reading it slowly and carefully at this point may provide some fascinating insights!

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    14 years ago

Pete,

That happened to me, too! I had some outstanding months when I first started. My best month I made about $150! My page views were averaging about the same as yours...Then suddenly, bam! making $15 for the same number of comments and page views. I think that was the reason that ED Kain left. He's now writing for Forbes and I bet, he's not getting $25 an article.

I had the same experience. At time I was curious as to why the sudden drop in earnings that we all experienced. It seems that what happened was that one (or more) companies handling Internet advertising took a closer look at the realities-- and discovered that Internet ads were a lot less effective that they had realized-- so they cut the rates of reimbursements.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    14 years ago

Yeah, that's pretty weird.

And then again- occasionally there's still stuff such as this ...also, check out the discussion there (sound familiar?)

 
 
 
Ben
Freshman Silent
link   Ben    14 years ago

Nawwwww Perrie. It wasn't the reality, it was "what I assumed and expected." Some times it was good and sometimes it wasn't. But I always assumed it to be poor and it made me happy when it was better and didn't bother me when it didn't.Grin.gif

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

You are being way too modest, Ben. It was almost amantra. Everyone loved Ben ( of course that would be me, too).6.gif

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    14 years ago

"Well, at least as far as Dennis McCann (PBUH) is concerned, he did make some interesting contributions to the Vine-- at least in terms of helping to keep track of troublemakers and/or suspected troubemakers."

Were you not his favourite troublemaker, Krishna? By the way, I'm pissed that so many of your articles are YouTube.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    14 years ago

I'm very confused about "nations". What constitutes a nation? Is it anumber of groups that share some particular concept?- for example: Classic Cinema, My Favourite Movies, The Movie Watchers.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Pedro    14 years ago

I think that would be a likely scenario. Since it's only being enforced with beta testers,I cant really say. I do know that Vlad turned my How To group into a nation, and Ben Josephs did the same with his photography group. I suspect that, should this get through beta testing, all groups with similar concepts will be annexed and/or dissolved. I also know that private groups are no longer private. Dunno beyond that.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

I also know that private groups are no longer private. Dunno beyond that.

I read that too, and I have to say that I was quite upset. I have 2 private groups, and there is a reason why you have one. Making it public is like the NV saying, "Here, I spit in your eye." BTW, I don't want to come off as blaming the Beta testers. I don't. They are good people. I blame NV administration. Ugggg.

 
 
 
MsAubrey (aka Ahyoka)
Junior Participates
link   MsAubrey (aka Ahyoka)    14 years ago

Opinions are like assholes.... Everyone has one... Everyone elses stinks.

Or is it, opinions come from assholes?

Grin.gif Tongue.gif

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

LMAO!

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    14 years ago

400 more have been invited to Beta, myself included. However, I sympathize with Perrie's comment because I'm totally confused by the nation.-trough, stuff myself. I culled almost 50 groups down to the required 15 not without my complaint that my broad interests have now been extremely limited. Now I want to add a "nation" about a totally different topic but can't unless I do away with a group I really wanted to keep.

However, what really concerns me now, because I have always known that I could be among friends here, is that I've now discovered that at least one person from the "dark side" has joined here, and I thought I could get away from the "rense.com, mondoweiss, stormfront" propaganda in what I had considered a safe haven.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Pedro    14 years ago

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Pedro    14 years ago

Not a fan of the beta format personally. It's too busy and yet also difficult to navigate intuitively. The "trough" is kind of insulting as an observer. If I was relegated to the trough, I simply wouldnt participate.

As they say, "You can tie a ribbon around a piece of shit, but at the end of the day, it's still a piece of shit"...

 
 
 
MsAubrey (aka Ahyoka)
Junior Participates
link   MsAubrey (aka Ahyoka)    14 years ago

And shit it is. Grin.gif

 
 
 
Rebecca "Brite" Kesler
Professor Silent
link   Rebecca "Brite" Kesler    14 years ago

OK... the Nations -- you can have 15 of them. They are trying to combine like the Classic Movie groups into one Classic movie Nation. All the pet groups into one pet Nation... that kind of thing.

My biggest bitch?? No threading outside of the Nations. In otherwords, if the conversation is not taking place within one of your nations, there is no threading, not in the "Trough" (Gods I hate that name!) and you can't comment outside of your "Nations". Frankly.. I hate the format.

What?? I'm one of the beta testers...Frown.gif

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Pedro    14 years ago

Yeah, the format is crap. It isnt intuitive and is kind of insulting overall.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

Hey Peter, you started this article in Aug and it's still going almost into Oct. Not bad!

 
 
 
Rebecca "Brite" Kesler
Professor Silent
link   Rebecca "Brite" Kesler    14 years ago

The format DOES suck. And I've been complaining about it from the beginning and all I get is a pat on the head and a "You'll learn to LOVE it!"... no... no I won't... and I'm thinking that if I'm not going to be taken seriously... I'm going elsewhere to do my blogging... this is ridiculous!

 
 
 
MJL3
Freshman Silent
link   MJL3    14 years ago

Well as a beta tester on NV, I can tell you , it doesn't work...NV should just fix it's issues and leave it alone, they will lose members....I was encouraged to come here and so far, this is so much user friendly Grin.gif

 
 
 
MJL3
Freshman Silent
link   MJL3    14 years ago

I know this is so cool, and I have a purple background for my page like I have always wanted

I

am

happyGrin.gif Grin.gif

 
 
 
leonahardware
Freshman Silent
link   leonahardware    14 years ago
I'm finding that I'm spending more time here. The interface IMO is better.
 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

I think that is the whole point. They are hoping that people find their "comfort zone" in being with a selected group of people, and hence they will do their own moderation by peer pressure or community standards and taking the load of the NV mods.

 
 
 
LoneRanger01
Freshman Silent
link   LoneRanger01    14 years ago

their idea of self policing will never work,...first they must have clear and presise rules in place. simply saying you must be respectul of others has so many diferent meanings it makes self policing imposible. what I call disrespectul may not be to another person,....

The way I see it is they are trying to paint the car before they fix the body work,..it just wont work,....

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    14 years ago

I have to agree LR!

 
 
 
LoneRanger01
Freshman Silent
link   LoneRanger01    14 years ago

I am going to have to say that is not what I call self policing. When one person is doing all of the policing it is a dictatorship. self policing is when everyone polices everyone else,....and all understand the rules as the same thing.

Thats to say they are all clear on the definition of the rule and they all have the same definition...

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    14 years ago

Hot and heavy input, that is ignored, completely. 12.gif

But, with this site, I'm feeling MUCH more hopeful. do you think it would be all right to ask some of my dear friends, congenial souls all, to join us?

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    14 years ago

Me, too. But a transfer may help us get what we really want and need, right here.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    14 years ago

One of many, for sure.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    14 years ago

Yep!!!

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    14 years ago

He is one of my LEAST favorite people.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    14 years ago

I personally know of 3 people who left because of him. Arrogance, nastiness, and just being mean. ugh!

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    14 years ago

And it's FUN again! Yeeehaaa!

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    14 years ago

We were suckered in, and you know? I wish I'd never signed on. I HATE it.

Sigh...

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    14 years ago

What FUN they are!

 
 
 
retired military ex Republican
Freshman Silent
link   retired military ex Republican    13 years ago

You are absolutely correct the news is morphed so badly that the only true thought and honesty is on the internet in small pockets like I hope this one is. I'm sorry I don't know the answer to your question.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Hi Tink and welcome.

Actually NT just looks a bit different but operates pretty much like NV. The forum is just like the top stories on NV and the groups (found on the left side of the page and under a tab on top) function just like the groups on NV. The tabs are our archives by subject. You also have your own personal homepage, which you can get to by using the tabs or clicking on your avatar. Actually most of the site is hyperlinked so you can get anywhere quickly.

If you need any help, just get me on chat!

 
 
 
MJL3
Freshman Silent
link   MJL3    13 years ago

I have a feelilng that there will be a mass exodus from NV to here, hope you are ready Perrie Grin.gif

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

Yeah, me too, and I hope the 100+ emails I sent out from my friends list helps.

I need to go over to the member page again and see who is here! Grin.gif

 
 
 
Linda Ladywolf
Freshman Silent
link   Linda Ladywolf    13 years ago

I couldn't find my friends list, I had such a headache after trying to read the site for just a few minutes, I couldn't stay long enough to look. I guess I'll try again tomorrow, too much eyestrain for now. I have such a short memory. I was linda ladywolf over there. I goofed when I applied over here!

 
 
 
Zydor
Freshman Silent
link   Zydor    13 years ago

They have little choice to travel the road they are. For sure its easy to put a cost saving spin on it at the moment, but I am not entirely convinced by that argument, albeit no doubt some savings lurk around the place.

The main issue is the size of the Vine Community, its not practical - or sensible - to have a "Flat" structure where everyone gets access to everything. I doubt many scroll through the hundreds of posts on the heavyweight Threads. Somehow they need to break down the chats into more manageable sizes, both from a Cost and common sense viewpoint.

The current first hack certainly is not it, but then I suspect whatever spin they took, the first turn at itwould be a Nightmare due to a transition to a more modern Backbone. Lots of work to do on the Interface and economical use of space, that I suspect will take 12-24 months to get right - users are in Millions not hundreds :)

It will evolve, these kinds of things always do when there is no other choice if its to move forward with a less wieldy front end that restricts the employment of more modern designs for the Front End. I think they unwisely rushed it, thats for sure, and created a mess. However, I have a feeling it will evolve into a ground breaking Site - in the end - but thats going to take 12-24 months to achieve. We shall see what we shall see.

 
 
 
Linda Ladywolf
Freshman Silent
link   Linda Ladywolf    13 years ago

That would help, I just can't spend much time on NV anymore, the headache doesn't go away for hours, I tried yesterday and finally gave up.

I can change my screen name here? How? I thought once it went in, it was in stone.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Go to your home page and click settings at the top right of the page; you'll see the field where you can change your screen name.

 
 
 
Linda Ladywolf
Freshman Silent
link   Linda Ladywolf    13 years ago

Yahoo tried that too, on their old 360 pages, there were a lot of people using it, we begged them to keep it, they just told us to like it or lump it, they wanted a site more like face book, I don't think many people use profiles. I know very few people who stayed with it.

 
 
 
Linda Ladywolf
Freshman Silent
link   Linda Ladywolf    13 years ago

Have done so, I am used to having the same one, it gets used a lot. Thanks so much. I feel like me now.

 
 
 
magic3400
Freshman Silent
link   magic3400    13 years ago

As someone that was a very prolific seeder on NV, I find the changes (all of them) horrible, they've completely destroyed the site, I'm done there. I don't even recognize the site anymore. I don't know why they think what they've done is so great, it sucks.

 
 
 
Stephi Cantley
Freshman Silent
link   Stephi Cantley    13 years ago

I kind of feel that if it is truly "news," then it is supposed to be objective. "Influencing" news is presenting opinion, or, worse-yet, manipulation of information....and then I have to wonder if it is really "news" at all anymore! I think that is crossing a line. I was just starting to get to "know" my way around the Vine and then they changed everything, so I left. I hope they will take a look at how many have left and try to correct the situation....but I'm with Rodney... "I don't know why they think what they've done is so great...."33.gif

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

Me either. That became very evident during Beta testing.

Oh well, onward and upward!!!

 
 
 
bluearcher
Freshman Silent
link   bluearcher    13 years ago

Influence the news? No. Participatory journalism is to influence and educate each other.

Facts should determine opinion, opinion should not effect the facts.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

Rescue, in all honesty, we rarely discuss NV here. I just think that people are upset and need a place to vent. It will pass, as we all can get over the shock of the change.

I loved NV. I was there for 4.5 years, and found many many wonderful people there. I had a wonderful time, published 597 articles, of which only 23 were seeds. I loved the venue, and loved the site. I did my best to foster the growth and well-being of the vine.

I'm not bitter, but I am very sad. Upset that the site has made so many changes-- many of which the Beta Testers fought against, to no avail. I leave the site in tears. That is not to say it can't get better-- but it is going to take quite a while.

Quite a few of us are angry, (I'm not really angry, just sad and very disappointed). Other people, who were not Beta testers were hit in the face of all the changes, and are upset. It's not their fault.

I really think that if we are allowed to vent for a bit, we'll all feel better and be able to move on. If you look at our front page here, there are all kinds of articles, not just NV bashing. :-)

Stay a bit, and see if it doesn't get better for you, too!

MUCH love to you! I will really miss your articles about dog rescues and all the wonderful social issues that your write about so well! Let us all share them here-- I think you'll find them to be very well-received!

I love you, my dear friend! I surely don't want to lose having you in my life! Smile.gif

 
 
 
MJL3
Freshman Silent
link   MJL3    13 years ago

So what is Vicki to Mike D???

I thought Vicki was just a guide?

 
 
 
MJL3
Freshman Silent
link   MJL3    13 years ago

You can post in the public discussion to any nation as long as it is open or gated, you can not post to private nationsno trolls....keeps out troll and ass holesGrin.gif

 
 
 
MJL3
Freshman Silent
link   MJL3    13 years ago

Now that I am using the New Vine, I like it, whole different out look , like many I resisted change and didn't want to learn anything new, liked the old format

well I love the new one..Grin.gif Grin.gif Grin.gif Grin.gif Grin.gif Grin.gif

 
 
 
Zydor
Freshman Silent
link   Zydor    13 years ago

It will settle - tha backgound structure changed enormously, they had to if it was going to take advantage of more modern facilities and features. Technically, the old designwas like standing a pyramid on its Apex, not its base - shaky, wobbly will no stability or future. It was in a cul-de-sac in a technical sense withlittle long term future.

It will take time - at least 12 months - with changes in stages before it gets settled, its impossible to do it all at once. The leap they just took was the big one, it broke away technically from a structure that was out dated and had no future. Now they have to work on the asthetics and practicalities of its day to day Use - they couldnt even start doing that until it had a Modern Backbone to its technical structure, cant do such massive changes all in one go. It will take time to resolve, but they will, if for no other reason than there is too much long term Revenue at stake to fail.

I predict that in 12-24 months when its forging ahead on its new base structure, all the "veterans" will be saying .....

"ahhh, I was there in 2013 when they changed it to what it is now, that was fun I can tell you ..."

You wait ..... it'll be like nothing ever happen :)

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

I think you are absolutely right! Smile.gif

I'm just tired of all the angst!

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

Really? What was the suggestion?

FL went over with people, but it is inactive. You can see your list, but you can't do much with it.

And yes, the visitor thing was added, which was important!!! and they changed the name from the Public Trough to the Public Discussion. That helped, too...

They still need a way to kill old groups. Meaning no disrespect to NV.

The attitudes with which this started were seemingly punitory, or disciplinary in context, (i.e. Public Trough). I don't really see any change in that. The like it or leave it comments, the seeming unconcern for those who are really having problems. The total lack of support for IE9 users. No where has anyone said that IE9 is a problem, officially, other than to say, we will support no IE product earlier than IE9. And having IE9, it doesn't work. One must use chrome or firefox. Too bad that many many computers come with IE9.

It is a tech's dream, a user's nightmare. And, I feel like I was punished. Why? I haven't done anything but do my best to help build the community. I know that they were tired of trolls and re-regs. Then fix THAT at their end. Surely, they could have blocked people from re-regging, as opposed to taking it out on the entire site.

NO meanness intended. Just bewilderment.

 
 
 
Edward Fiebke
Freshman Silent
link   Edward Fiebke    13 years ago

Hi -

Just joined "The News Talkers" after reading how other NV members made the decision to join here. I'm known as "ICU NURSE" at NV. At this point, I'm quite uncomfortable with the change that was made at NV. Although, I will say that if the older NV layout was outdated then I can understand the need to upgrade and even change format. A number of years ago, I used to be a moderator/co-administrator for a large nursing-focused bulletin board. During that time, and since then, that bulletin board made similar changes. It was startling at first not only to the members but to the staff as well. But as membership grew, it became obvious that the needs of the bulletin board needed to grow and change as well. (If you want to check out that bulletin board, please feel free to visit: www.allnurses.com )

I'm still not sure if I like the new layout for NV. It's still slow! It still gives a relatively limited amount of time to edit posts which always bothered me. (I need more than 4 minutes to edit all of my spelling and grammar errors! LOL!) But I liked the basic layout of the older NV. I also like the ability to make "Friends" which the old NV provided (although I never really established close friendships there, to be honest). Regarding the new NV, I'm bothered that one can belong to only 15 "Nations" so far. Why was there a set number of 15 established? I guess "the jury" is still out on the new NV for me. I'm mostly a luker there but I do visit it frequently. On occasion, I have enjoyed many thoughtful and sometimes heated debates there. It just seems that the process of setting up "articles" and establishing thoughtful debate and discussion is counter-intuitive. At the very least, it seems limiting to me. Hope they get the bugs worked out.

In the meanwhile, I've established myself with a new bulletin board here. I see many "NV Members" here. I like how this community is a bit smaller. I have to wonder how this bulletin board manages growth if/when its faced with an increasing membership. In the meanwhile, please feel free to say "hello"!Smile.gif I'm looking forward to sharing some photos, sharing some music (I'm a composer/musician as well as a full-time nurse) and some friendly banter as discussions/debates present themselves.

Peace

Ted (aka ICU NURSE). . . oh and "Ted" is my nickname since childhood.Smile.gif

 
 
 
MJL3
Freshman Silent
link   MJL3    13 years ago

I wish viners would just settle down and learn it instead of bitching about it over there, attacking others that try to help and they really have turned on Sally and Tyler, absolutelyridiculousthe way some of them act...I like my Private Nation, so I don't get trolls, people can suggest other but if they have trolled me or are nasty then forget it.

 
 
 
MJL3
Freshman Silent
link   MJL3    13 years ago

The old NV had issues ALL sites do....

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Pedro    13 years ago

Well, Sally in particular deserves whatever she gets. She was never anything close to being impartial and fair. Tyler at least made an effort, even though it was an overwhelming volume for him to handle at times.

As far as people "bitching", that is one thing that people should do and are entitled to do. Voice their discontent. We arent all dogs who roll over to be pet in the belly just after being kicked in the face. Without "us", no site finds success, so rather than alienate their user base, they should be trying to accommodate them. You always had the option of staying away from trolls by posting in private groups. Now however, the option has been taken from you, and you have no certainty of avoiding trolls either. Just being in a nation doesnt guarantee you protection, especially considering that no groups/nations are private there anymore.

 
 
 
Edward Fiebke
Freshman Silent
link   Edward Fiebke    13 years ago

Generally speaking, people don't like change. On one hand, I can empathize for many of the NV "old-timers" who have to cope with the really drastic change that NV made. As I said in my previous post (above), the nursing bulletin board that I used to co-administer also went through similar changes in format and look. Many of its "old-time" membership had a mini-rebellion. Some even went on to create their own bulletin board!! LOL! Others, like me, just "dealt with it" and got over it. Those "Viners" will settle down eventually. To this I have no doubt. But I would hope that the administrators of NV would have prepared themselves for a lot of reaction. I would argue that it's human nature to resist change. But part of being human is having the capability to adapt and be resilient.

I can see the plus-side of having "Nations" if it can help keep trolls down. But again I ask, why only 15 "Nations" per membership?? Maybe there needs to be a limit. It seems that 15 might not be enough, though. Besides, there are other ways to control trolls from joining a bulletin board. For example, this bulletin board requires a kind of application and acceptance for membership. This is helpful. Another bulletin board requires that members use their real names. THAT really helps keep the trolls down. ;)

 
 
 
Rebecca "Brite" Kesler
Professor Silent
link   Rebecca "Brite" Kesler    13 years ago

Part of the problem with the Nations is that they will turn into "circle-jerks". I seed and write, pretty often myself... (You usually see my byline as "Brite"!) But here's the thing -- and I said this during Beta Testing -- You end up in Nations with people who already agree with you. There is no give and take. And then there is the "Public Trough" (Now since the roll out, called the "Public Discussion")... there is no threading, you have to hunt to find the comment you want to respond to, there is no rhyme or reason to it.

And this was all brought up during the Beta Testing -- and the generally attitude was a pat on the head and a "There, there... you'll learn to LOVE it!" squee. No... No, I didn't learn to love it. I hated it then, and I hate it now.

My articles that get clipped to Nations that I'm not a member of... I can't comment on those conversations. The conversations that happen in the "Trough" are almost impossible to keep track of. I have to wade through a bazillion Nations (and redundant comments), all of which take time.

Many of the Beta Testers tried telling them the same things... and after awhile... we gave up. Some left the Vine prior to the turn over, some are threatening to leave now, and some of us are trying to figure out our next step.

And while I get that they had to update the software, and update the infrastructure of the site... what I don't get is why they thought that they had to dumb it down, make it less user friendly, and generally more like MSNBC.com...

 
 
 
MJL3
Freshman Silent
link   MJL3    13 years ago

Einsteinian Insanity (again)

Well, they should have had a guide out for people to get used to...answer question strictly on that article but,....I see absolutely nothing wrong with the new vine, anything will run slower with the amount of traffic that was there, I saw people who hadn't been on for a long time all of a sudden postsing....

To tell you the truth, I can't believe members of NV coming here and bitching about it. It should stay in NV.....

 
 
 
MJL3
Freshman Silent
link   MJL3    13 years ago

Tacos y Margaritas

No she doesn't

 
 
 
Rebecca "Brite" Kesler
Professor Silent
link   Rebecca "Brite" Kesler    13 years ago

That's just the point... it's ONLY within your religious group that you can talk about the moral impact of abortion... what?? Only the religious have the corner on morality?? (and yes... I DO know how that sounds...) and only women know how rape impacts the community?? Or how VAWA impacts the country as a whole??? You have 80 different conversations going on... NOW... be the seeder/writer.... and monitor it all... And you can only respond in 15 of those conversations.... AND the Trough...

As loud and raucous as the Vine got... and as stupid and childish as people got, what ever political/moral line that separated us was also a mirror. We had to look at them, to see ourselves. And maybe... just maybe it made us think more about our positions and how we stated them. (and then again... maybe not!)

By putting people into Nations, you are separating them into cliques. Even more so than before. Because the only way to really communicate is going to be through the Nations. And eventually, only those that agree, are going to be in those Nations. And it's all going to be back patting and congratulatory baby kissing. I see it starting already...

Like I said... I won't totally leave the Vine for awhile yet... not until I can find a place to write and get it established a find a following for the weird crap that I put out... But until then...

 
 
 
MJL3
Freshman Silent
link   MJL3    13 years ago

By putting people into Nations, you are separating them into cliques. Even more so than before. Because the only way to really communicate is going to be through the Nations\

Pick you Nations wisely...some will be that way, but if they are diverse enough, no problem . My private group is to keep the nasty , nasty and trolls out and it will stay that way.

 
 
 
MJL3
Freshman Silent
link   MJL3    13 years ago

Dowser

It is no different than the old vine, the only difference is you don't start new discussion under a different tab ,they are all on the same page and eventually those will die down

 
 
 
MJL3
Freshman Silent
link   MJL3    13 years ago

They have to ask to join, No private discussion for me to moderat. Only the Nation, If they leave they leave but I think you will find most won't because they know I will not put up with nastiness or trolls if they start doing it , they are gone....Whole purpose of a Private nation, I think you will find more go to that as they figure it out..

Sally and Tyler are only two people , they couldn't keep up with all the BS, viners know better..but kids being kids push the limit. we can still report and yes collapse article but eventuayl I think we will lose the ability to collapse articles/seeds , I hope anyway.

Yep if a troll creates a group on my discuss they have to moderate, I lose thatabilitybut I canunpublishthe article or delete it and I will

 
 
 
Zydor
Freshman Silent
link   Zydor    13 years ago

How does someone get in as a non troll if they can't comment in your nation. As people leave, your group becomes smaller and smaller, and it is harder and harder for you to attract new members.

I run the "Theocratic Life" Nation. Its wide enough Scope to get over the possibility of too small and narrow a focus that people cant join in with alternate angles on the impact of Religion in their lives, whether they are one of the "Faithful" or "Heathan" - I'm the latter :)

When a request comes in to join the Nation, I always go look at what they have been up to on The Vine, which is easy to do by visiting their Column. Trolls and Zero comment counts dont get in, nor do those whose intenet to just tobe obnoxious. The latter is easy to do by having a look at their existing posts.

So it can be Policed. At the moment the Theocratic Life Nation count has significantly increased, not decreased, since the New Vine went live.

Does someone get in with an existing Post Count of Zero - nope, never, and I hear the issue that can cause -but thats a small disadvantage, there are enough non gated Nations (which are the overwhelming Majority)where individuals can post and I get an idea of what their motivation is. Trolls dont get in - period, and when one slips through its not for long ....

 
 
 
MJL3
Freshman Silent
link   MJL3    13 years ago

John

Actually it is improving every day..glitches are being taken car of , withanythingnew you have to get used to it, I guess some just aren't that patient

 
 
 
MJL3
Freshman Silent
link   MJL3    13 years ago

EI

They have to apply or request, I check them out and if they seem OK they get a change, they screw up, they are gone.

 
 
 
EmmaJo
Freshman Silent
link   EmmaJo    13 years ago

I just came over from NV...I'm liking this!

 
 
 
EmmaJo
Freshman Silent
link   EmmaJo    13 years ago

Thanks

 
 
 
magic3400
Freshman Silent
link   magic3400    13 years ago

don't you think it's a little early to make a judgment like that.

No, I don't. I don't like the changes, it has nothing to do with happens on this site or any other, I don't like the changes for what it has done for NV. That site has not been the same since Calvin (and all the others) left and/or forced out and it will never be the same.

I asked Tyler a question ON HIS OWN article over a month ago, a very important question about the Adsense nonsense. He's been logged on everyday since I posted my question but didn't have enough respect for me, and all the other people that have been asking questions on that article, to answer any of us.

That speaksvolumes about what they think about those of us that provide the content that makes NV the money they need to operate the site. Frankly, I hopeenoughpeople leave that it goes under.

With all due respect, if NV discussions are that distressing to you maybe you shouldn't enter NV discussion here...just sayin. I just got here but it seems there is plenty of non NV content.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

If you are the same Rodney with whom I have often sparred on Newsvine, I have to say that I absolutely agree with your statement:

"That site has not been the same since Calvin (and all the others) left and/or forced out and it will never be the same."

I really liked Calvin. He was accessible and reasonable - a truly good person. TheNewstalkers was started and is run by a truly good person - one who is not only not in it for the money, but foots the bill herself.

 
 
 
bluearcher
Freshman Silent
link   bluearcher    13 years ago

It isn't so much about learning as dealing with the new restrictions and the compartmentalization.

If trolls were a problem then you were either too thin skinned or didn't know how to ignore them or shut them down.

 
 
 
bluearcher
Freshman Silent
link   bluearcher    13 years ago

Pick them wisely? I dumped most of mine and funneled my activity to just a few Nations that are looking to be the largest to retain a public forum "feel".

Again with the "trolls"? If that's the best justification for liking the new mess that is NV...

 
 
 
Unpaid Shill
Freshman Silent
link   Unpaid Shill    13 years ago

Someone said 70% of Newsvine traffic comes from India.

It's true. Go back to Alexa, and click the "Audience" button, then look where you found the India ranking. It's all spammers. It's one of the reasons NV is so slow. They're sucking up bandwidth and processor time with their macros and link-farming. NV's tried to hide them in NNV by just showing the commenters from MSNBC/NBC, but the spammers still show up in the old Greenhouse.

I don't think they are going to care what the users think.

They didn't during the testing. There were only 5 old time viners they listened to, and they have a personal agenda. I won't name names, but I have nicknames for them:

Steve Jobs' Stunt Double

The potty-mouth from the NYT

The Wicked Witch from the Mid-West

her 2 winged monkeys.

They crushed all dissent during the testing, and now they're reveling in the fact that so many people are unhappy with it.

Those are just volunteers. NV Staff spends too much time in Myrtle Edwards Park , or in their break room with its fridge full of beer . They're too casual to get anything done right.

10773_discussions.jpg

That happened on the 20th of June. I joined the group even though I wasn't a tester. When they found out I wasn't a tester, they booted me. They finally unbanned me the night before the rollout. I'm still banned from their artsy-fartsy support system.

The first [less than] 100 testers didn't even come from the nominations that Tyler asked for. Someone picked names from their friend list. 2 of them hadn't been seen on the vine in 3 1/2 years before they got the invite. They logged in, got their token, and then logged out, never to be seen again. There was one who, when they got the invite, must've said "WTF? I'm still a member there?". They logged in, got the token, and then deleted their account.

I should write a book...

 
 
 
AmericanDreamsShattered
Freshman Silent
link   AmericanDreamsShattered    13 years ago

I happened to stumble across this site today and yes i do agree that NV is dead, well at least to me.

 
 
 
MJL3
Freshman Silent
link   MJL3    13 years ago

not true, you have NO idea what I went through for 3 weeks..No Idea. I have list of viner's that will NEVER be allowed in my private group. NEVER

 
 
 
MJL3
Freshman Silent
link   MJL3    13 years ago

EI,

That's fine, if over time I feel they can join I will invite them..This will remain a private group...I think that is why the membership is so high

 
 
 
Rebecca "Brite" Kesler
Professor Silent
link   Rebecca "Brite" Kesler    13 years ago

I also run 3 businesses from home, go to school and chase a grandbaby for fun... I don't HAVE 3 hours to read through every Nation's commentary on one article or seed... not to mention, go look up one of your comments... click on it... it takes you to the article NOT to your comment. You can't navigate this dog's pile without a map. And the "Help" guide isn't really all that much of a guide. (Sorry)

When I was actively Beta Testing... I wasn't the only voice in the wilderness. But after a while, most of us who were saying that what I am saying now, (and what is being said about the changes) just shut up, quit testing, went back to the old Vine, for as long as we could. Not because we don't like change... but because NO ONE WAS LISTENING TO US!

WE are the end users. The Nations idea is a good idea... up to a point. But don't FORCE everyone into it. It's going to end up cliquish, it's too much to try and get through, and frankly, it's a pain in the ass for someone to try and moderate. Sure... we've weeded out the "trolls"... no... we've weeded out Dissenting voices. You know... I've learned more from dissenting voices... they make me think, they make me have to DO MY WORK AND SHOW IT! And now, I demand it of them.

I'll be that NO one even LOOKS into the "Public Discussion". Oh! NO! We are all too good for that now... It has become nothing more than MySpace and Facebook mashed together with some news to keep things interesting... And Gods help us if we meet someone new, because it's not like we can invite them or befriend them -- the only interaction that we can have with them is in these Nations... In which we are guaranteed that they agree with our point of view...

When I posted something to the Vine, I treated my column as if it was a party in my home. It is my job to keep the conversation flowing smoothly. Not to keep everyone agreeing. But definitely to keep everyone from throwing punches.

Now... If I did that... I would have to work my way through how many Nations, in which they all agree with their point of view. Why bother? It's no fun for me... I don't learn anything... and I can get my ego massaged just fine when Himself is around...

These issues that I'm talking about with the Vine (the new version) were long standing. They knew about them, during Beta Testing. They ignored what the testers were saying and basically treated the testers that telling them what they didn't want to hear, as if we were annoying spoilt 3 years olds... we got a pat on the head, a "You will learn to LOVE IT!" squee, and were sent out side to play.

That you like it is fine, my love... I'm glad. I don't. I haven't since early last Summer. That's not going to change.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

What you had to say is all the more reason I think the only true reason for the change is the money. The whole concept was to cover up the real purpose. The connection with adsense, the concept of creating your own advertising windows to maximize income, and worst of all, the theft of our earnings. Newsvine was holding our earnings, and by doing so they made themselves a trustee. Before they had the right to confiscate those earnings it was necessary to give each beneficiary actual notice, and publishing on article that says they are going to take the money on December 31 is NOT actual notice. Actual notice to a beneficiary would have to be an individual email to each person. Can you imagine how much money they ended up with considering the purported number of Newsvine members? They got over $100 of MY money, now think of the magnitude of what they were able to amass. One beneficiary suing for a small amount doesn't make sense, but a class action makes a lot of sense. Some smart litigation lawyer should pick this thing up and run with it.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Pedro    13 years ago

Rodney isnt wrong. If you dont like content, you have it in your own power to not participate. Pretending to be the moral authority and then act in a dismissive manner when people make valid points, while par for the course with your style of discussion, certainly adds nothing to it. Why not move on to another article, or sift through the nations on Newsvine instead? Save yourself the heartache that comes from being morally superior in a world filled with heathens.

I almost forgot, this is actually my article, so I'd like to close with: fuck, shit, cunt, pussy, motherfucker, balls

 
 
 
Rose Gardener
Freshman Silent
link   Rose Gardener    13 years ago

Hello Tacos:

I'm new here from the Vine. I own and manage a top ten group called Successful Solutions. I'm going to give it a month or so before I either shut the group/nation down (or hand it over to someone staying at the Vine).

I'm not happy about leaving, but feel I've no choice. They've completely ruined it. Turning groups into Nations is just the beginning.

I started a new group here called Newsvine Refugees . Hopefully it can serve as a place for all of us to find each other and reconnect.

I look forward to making a new home here at Newstalkers, it'll be a lot easier to do so with others who have left the Vine. At least I'll know a few people and have folks to learn the NewsTalkers site with.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Pedro    13 years ago

The Newsvine Refugees group is a good idea. Realistically, we do try to steer clear of talking about other sites on the main page even though it is unavoidable whenever there is a new influx of members who are invariably from one or two other sites. It's good to have a spot to talk about NV for those who are interested in doing so.

I actually own the How To nation and a few others on NV, but I relinquish control to other more active members such as Vlad's Dog, for example. Aside from stopping in to look at the nation thing while it was in beta, I really havent had any activity over there since they created the Not News category in my honor and suspended me simultaneously, lol.

Anyway, I think you'll like it here, whether as your full time stop off or simply a place you visit from time to time. We arent always the nicest bunch when the conversations get heated, lol, but we always welcome anybody who would like to participate. Great to have you here.

 
 
 
magic3400
Freshman Silent
link   magic3400    13 years ago

@RecueDogs

Decaf, try decaf...you asked me a question and I answered.

If my opinion doesn't matter don't say shit to me, don't asked anything and don't reply to my posts.

I hope we are clear on thisbecauseI hate to have to say what I really think!

 
 
 
magic3400
Freshman Silent
link   magic3400    13 years ago

Yep, one in the same Buzz.

They forced Calvin out and have taken NV down in the process.

 
 
 
magic3400
Freshman Silent
link   magic3400    13 years ago

Pretending to be the moral authority and then act in a dismissive manner when people make valid points, while par for the course with your style of discussion, certainly adds nothing to it.

No kidding, I didn't know commenting on this site was based on membership date, that should have been on the sign up page.. [sarc].

Maybe the very first person to sign up needs to go around and act as referee [sarc].

Only an idiot would leave a site because they didn't like the discussion THEY CHOSE to enter, how dumb is that...LOL

I think you made it very clear what this discussion was about, no bait and switch in the title either.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Pedro    13 years ago

True, true. R.D. has a history of getting flustered and leaving, lol. No biggie.

She also doesnt like swearing. :)

 
 
 
magic3400
Freshman Silent
link   magic3400    13 years ago

I didn't say Calvin would or would not like the new site, I said NV (as a whole) has not been the same since he left. There have been many things that have happened, the least of which is the site changes.

 
 
 
magic3400
Freshman Silent
link   magic3400    13 years ago

LOL...

You would think when someone says "with all due respect" whatever is said after that is said with...wait, wait - RESPECT.

Respect in her book is a one way street.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Pedro    13 years ago

Doesnt mean I dont either. Besides, I wasnt swearing at her. I was swearing for the sheer joy of swearing. I'm all about breaking down useless taboos.

 
 
 
Rose Gardener
Freshman Silent
link   Rose Gardener    13 years ago

The Newsvine Refugees group is a good idea. Realistically, we do try to steer clear of talking about other sites on the main page even though it is unavoidable whenever there is a new influx of members who are invariably from one or two other sites. It's good to have a spot to talk about NV for those who are interested in doing so.

Thanks Tacos - I hope you'll join Newsvine Refugee s and invite others you know from the vine as well.

I actually own the How To nation and a few others on NV, but I relinquish control to other more active members such as Vlad's Dog, for example.

Yeah ... I'm trying to figure out who I'm going to have take over Successful Solutions. Before they turned it into a Nation, it was 9th in the ratings for number of members. It took me years to build the group to that size. And it's not easy to turn it over. But, if that's the only reason I'm staying at NV, it's time to leave :(

I think I'm going to give it a week or so to see who is staying behind and that I could trust with the group. (sigh)

Anyway, I think you'll like it here, whether as your full time stop off or simply a place you visit from time to time. We arent always the nicest bunch when the conversations get heated, lol, but we always welcome anybody who would like to participate. Great to have you here.

I really am looking forward to getting to know folks on this board.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

I back up Rodney's opinion on that. The moderation changed from neutral to bias, from responsiveness to ignoring since Calvin left. I blame that on Tyler and Sally. However, the technical help to cure technical bugs, from people like Mark Budos, has been first class.

 
 
 
magic3400
Freshman Silent
link   magic3400    13 years ago

Exactly Buzz, Calvin would have NEVER ignored viner's questions on HIS OWN article about something as major as the move to Adsense.

He may not have answered every single person individually, but you can bet everyone would have had their questions answered. Whether that was in anseparatearticle or whatever, he would have addressed it.

Many viners can not get an Adsense account and some have gotten them only to be banned by Google afterwards because of the content on NV. If Tyler really cared, he would address it instead of ignoring the questions. There are only a couple dozen people that have contributed more content to NV than I have (25 to be exact - the last time I checked) after nearly 5,000 seeds, I think I earned enough respect around there to get an answer to my questions about Adsense. Oh well, their lost, I will never seed another article.

 
 
 
Stephi Cantley
Freshman Silent
link   Stephi Cantley    13 years ago

Grin.gif

 
 
 
Rose Gardener
Freshman Silent
link   Rose Gardener    13 years ago

When did Calvin leave? I don't seed as much as others, mostly read content. So... I'm not as aware of the behind the scenes politics as all of you?

 
 
 
Stephi Cantley
Freshman Silent
link   Stephi Cantley    13 years ago

Time heals so many things.Smile.gif

 
 
 
Rose Gardener
Freshman Silent
link   Rose Gardener    13 years ago

RescueDogs:

I was not in a Beta Testing Group. But... no I don't think it's too early for me to make a judgement. I've been a programmer for 20 years. Because of that experience, I can generally work through new user interfaces faster than most lay people. It didn't take me long at all to get the hang of the New interface at NV.

Problem is... the new product is lacking in many ways. Even if we were to set aside personal preferences, there are still some major problems. The bandwidth time alone should be a major technical concern for the developers and "powers that be" at NV.

And the use of "Nations" is a major technical blunder. It's something a beginning programmer should have been able to foresee, and how it got past the decision makers is beyond me. By forcing the Nations on everyone, they designed a process which encourages people to start multiple discussions about the same topic. Man... that decision alone makes me wonder what the heck they were thinking. It is beyond baffling, from a purely technical perspective - it is shoddy design. It encourages sloppy content, more storage space will be needed, etc..

Also... from a technical perspective, the way they show articles sucks up bandwidth (especially all the pictures). If they were trying to clean up a heavy and cumbersome backend, they've failed miserably. And that is a technical analysis - not a user opinion.

Beyond all the technical failures, there have been many failures in leadership over the past several years. I am thrilled to find NewsTalkers. I feel like I've found a place that is truer to what a social newsite should be. Not a site run by the dictates of a big-money News organization. I am so thrilled I started the Newsvine Refugees group just so all of us refugees can reconnect after finding our way here.

 
 
 
Rose Gardener
Freshman Silent
link   Rose Gardener    13 years ago

Well see... there you go.... bringing in another dimension. My entire 20 years of programming has been as an independent contractor. So... I've had to be the "Usability person" as well as the programmer.

It only makes sense that in larger organizations they'd have "Usability" people who's job functions are separate from the programmers. It's like large organizations having one person do the html and css and another person doing the jQuery, javascript, php, etc...

And... it confirms something I've felt for years. When I do programming projects I have to do it all, usability has to be a concern to me as a programmer, just as css and html do. I can't separate any of it - if I did my clients would not be happy at all.

My clients help me design, they do the testing. I don't have my own testers and I never would, because no tester can ever anticipate the way end users will want to interact with a product. They just can't. In my case, my clients have to dedicate time to testing, but as I tell them all the time, "no tester can know what your job is, they aren't sitting at your desk 40 hours/wk, week in and week out".

When these functions are all treated as separate entities you get results like the recent remake of Newsvine. I am honestly sad in saying that .. just sad ... I enjoyed my time at Newsvine.

 
 
 
Rose Gardener
Freshman Silent
link   Rose Gardener    13 years ago

As for you, based on what you appear to be doing (hopefully I am not being too presumptuous here), you had your users testing for usability based on their workflow, but also your products generally didn't have as wide a market/user base as what newsvine would. You are right though, you need to have a certain kind of product to make a dedicated usability tester, but when you have that product, it's extremely important. I would say that NewsVine is such a product, but I also understand that they probably don't have the budget for it.'

Yep - you're right, my users are the testers. That's how I can be so successful. If not for my client's willingness to collaborate with me, and test everything I do, I wouldn't be able to build what they need.

I have done some applications for pretty large organizations. But, they're all internal. Nothing like Newsvine.

One other sign they should pay attention to, I doubt they will, but they should, is that so many of us geeks are critical of the final product as well. If it were the typical roll-out problems, those of us in the industry would hang in there, and encourage others to hang in there. Because we recognize typical roll-out problems. But many of us geeky types have been the most vocal in our disappointment.

It was hard for me to just put it all there when I first saw the problems. I was intentionally pretty "in-your-face" about what I saw, because I have a programming background. I was hoping they would see those of us with a technical background, and our response as something to pay attention to.

My last attempt to get their attention was a thread asking for a community wide poll. I doubt it will happen. :(

 
 
 
Unpaid Shill
Freshman Silent
link   Unpaid Shill    13 years ago

I already had this argument with PWT.

The only people that know how NV is doing is NV, and that's proprietary info, and they're not telling.

Alexa's data supports other things I've been seeing.

 
 
 
Rose Gardener
Freshman Silent
link   Rose Gardener    13 years ago

"The vine fall down and go boom.."

All the kings horses and all the kings men can't put it back together again.

 
 
 
volfan
Freshman Silent
link   volfan    13 years ago

ditto your sentiments and many others who feel the same way. The whole thing is a convoluted mess...

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

And here is another Newsvine refugee. I spent the last four years on NV, but between the new format change, and all the trolls working at blowing up good discussions, I have had enough.

I'm convinced that the change was a premeditated attempt to kill off that site, or at least lessen the discussion there.

While waiting for my approval, I have to say I like the types of discussions, and more importantly, the tenor of them.

 
 
 
magic3400
Freshman Silent
link   magic3400    13 years ago

Welcome FlyNavy, good to see ya here

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

Rodney.... Flameaway

I took a break after the November election on NV. When I came back I found that all of the paid political trolls had departed back to the nether regions. At that point we able to hold some decent conversations and discussions.

Then last week they dropped the big one with the format change! I'm sure it will survive as is, but I was using NV to catch up on events over coffee and my evenings libation. The new format makes that a much more inefficient process, plus it just isn't fun anymore with the "Nations" thing. You learn so much more from others of different viewpoint than you do from like minded people. NV is going to degenerate into a site of 1000 different echo chambers.

So far I like what I have read, and the interaction here much better.

Best regards to you both.

 
 
 
bitemore Gfotwo
Professor Silent
link   bitemore Gfotwo    13 years ago

Rose Gardener and Einstein: What a thrill to read the two of you: geeks who know exactly what they are talking about and who can still relate to the anguish of us non-geeks and understand exactly what we are trying to say! Youse guys just hit a home run with your conversation!!!! Thank you!

 
 
 
bitemore Gfotwo
Professor Silent
link   bitemore Gfotwo    13 years ago

"There, there... you'll learn to LOVE it!" squee. No... No, I didn't learn to love it. I hated it then, and I hate it now.

Absolutely, right-on, 100% correct. I'm going to start deleting my NV account tomorrow (I'm on Vine-Strike right now). To those who like it there: fine. You like it. I get that. But to those who, like me, absolutely LOATHE it, well... we, too, are entitled to our opinions, and the "Likers" are never, ever, not in a gazillion years, going to make someone like me LIKE that travesty of a web site. In fact, the more you denigrate us for having our opinions and feelings, the more we will continue to resist what you say and you are only confirming to us that we ARE correct and thus you are locking our minds as securely as though you had a key to twist...

Newsvine, for me, is dead. Gone. Finished. I have mourned, I have cried, I have tried to resuscitate it, but every time I dig up that corpse it is just a little more rotten, a little more decomposed, a little more in need of a decent, but hasty, burial. As far as I know, resurrection only happened once, and his name was Jesus, not Newsvine.

It. Is. Finished.

 
 
 
bitemore Gfotwo
Professor Silent
link   bitemore Gfotwo    13 years ago

This is better, more friendly and intuitive.

Amen.

 
 
 
magic3400
Freshman Silent
link   magic3400    13 years ago

Thanks Navy

I agree 100%, they turned an open forum into a bunch of walled off areas. I don't have time to check a bunch of differentnations. Plus they really pissed me off with the Adsense thing.

Good to see ya my friend and welcome. Grin.gif

 
 
 
Sharon J
Freshman Silent
link   Sharon J    13 years ago

I am a newsvine refugee. When they changed it they took away what made it a great place to debate and talk to people from everywhere in the world. Now I could not even find friends list and am being told to quit :"whining" and get used to it. I said never mind and found my way here. I see many posters that I so enjoyed reading here. I am liking it already. It will take a few to get used to this format but it is already way better thanb the new vine. I hope some more people try this out.

 
 
 
Sharon J
Freshman Silent
link   Sharon J    13 years ago

The last msnbc site I was a part of changed their format which sucked and then closed it. I think Newvine will go the same way.

 
 
 
bitemore Gfotwo
Professor Silent
link   bitemore Gfotwo    13 years ago

Welcome, Sharon. Yes, this place is a LOT better than the "new" Vine. At least people here make you feel welcome and will try to help you get used to navigating and such. I came here back in July, shortly after being chosen as one of the first 100 beta testers at Newsvine and realizing that I didn't like what I was seeing. Someone pointed me here... and I've been here ever since - in both places, actually, but here most of the time since the beta version of the Vine went live on the 7th.

The influx of newcomers here has been huge since the 7th... actually, it started for real on the 6th, and has increased since then. I'm guessing over 100 Vine refugees since then...

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

Welcome Sharon!

I've been a member for only 24 hours and I know that I have found a new home. The civility is much better here with many of the same quality writers from .... whats that place...?

 
 
 
Sharon J
Freshman Silent
link   Sharon J    13 years ago

Yes I think it will be good. We need to a liberal presence I believe..

 
 
 
GeeGee64
Freshman Silent
link   GeeGee64    13 years ago

I followed you here, FLYNAVY1. I hope you don't mind. I saw your comment about this site over at the forum that shall not be named and decided to come over here for a visit. I've already found so many of my old friends, I feel quite at home.

It feels good to be home.8.gif

 
 
 
Spooky Boyfriend
Freshman Silent
link   Spooky Boyfriend    13 years ago

Boatrocker, I also just took a look and didn't walk back in. I have no sense of being something as dramatic and full of portent as being an 'Vine refugee". I was around during the Great New York Times Clusterfuck of '02"; now those linefolk were refugees. Their accents were thick and believed their opinions held some sort of individual weight. They washed up on the shore of NewsVine. I'm not sure if the NYT refugees were invited or simply came to NewsVine as immigrants, being pushed by the hostile ropes of the New York Times Corporation and quarterlies.

elmerette, I have not figured out groups or nations or whatever yet. I'm just to the point of adjusting the screen colors and font sizes so as this site to be readable to these old and rheumy eyes.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

Welcome GeeGee64.... You will find this to be worth the trip.

 
 
 
infohack
Freshman Silent
link   infohack    13 years ago

I believe that the influx of NYT forum refugees (aka Fugees) was mid to late '07. I had been a member for only a few months and I joined in February of 2007.

 
 
 
friday jones
Freshman Silent
link   friday jones    13 years ago

Most people, myself included, have bee stressing and tellin sally and tyler how this new vine suckes but ms cyparah, rescue and others have been sing the new vine praises. Are they by chance paid trolls now?

 
 
 
friday jones
Freshman Silent
link   friday jones    13 years ago

I agree with ya there.....I'm just on there trying to recruit my friends as I find them.

 
 
 
friday jones
Freshman Silent
link   friday jones    13 years ago

Me too boatrocker. I immediately wrote and told them how fucked up it was!

 
 
 
friday jones
Freshman Silent
link   friday jones    13 years ago

I;m not there am I MJL3....I was petridishofideas there.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

That's an interesting theory, friday jones. I regret only that I have abandoned my baby, its Classic Cinema group, but I am going to transfer a lot of the articles I wrote there to the Classic Cinema group I opened here before I close my account there.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

No, they're not.

I look at it this way-- it is pretty much all based on personal preferences. NV is very different, with a very different outlook than what we're used to... It is still a viable site and there are many people that like it a lot! That's great!

I don't happen to like it-- I miss the freedom. But that's my personal preference.

Smile.gif

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Pedro    13 years ago

Naw, not paid trolls. Just people who like the new venue. I know Ms. Cyprah is really only concerned with personal growth, both for her and for those who interact with her.

 
 
 
Rorschach
Freshman Silent
link   Rorschach    13 years ago

In what way is Newsvine supposed to be influencing the news, and why do people feel a need to tamper with the news in the first place? Shouldnt the news simply be the news without further influence?

Last question first:

"Shouldnt the news simply be the news without further influence?"

Yep. In journalism school, one of the essentials that's banged into your head from the start is the five W's: Who, What, When, Where, Why. "How" is a close friend of the first five.

In what way is Newsvine supposed to be influencing the news

You could make a case that a forum like Newsvine (or this one) can call attention to stories that don't get the attention they deserve.

Frankly, what really influences news coverage these days - particularly in broadcast media - is advertising dollars. Promotion departments have a large say in what gets covered. The goal is to jack the ratings, which jacks the price of advertising and draws more advertisers who want the audience exposure.

why do people feel a need to tamper with the news in the first place?

Because, for whatever reason and there are plenty, they have a vested interest in getting the story that they want presented out for public consumption.

Bottom line is that money talks.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Pedro    13 years ago

I dont disagree with any of that. It is unfortunate though.

 
 
 
Truth Sleuth
Freshman Silent
link   Truth Sleuth    13 years ago

There are already twosuper powers. And we all know what that can portend. :)

 
 
 
One Really Fed Up Boomer
Freshman Silent
link   One Really Fed Up Boomer    13 years ago

I have "emigrated" from the nations of NV in disgust over their changes. Frown.gif

 
 
 
bitemore Gfotwo
Professor Silent
link   bitemore Gfotwo    13 years ago

Welcome, Boomer. What was your NV handle?

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

Yep. Smile.gif

 
 
 
Leotie
Freshman Silent
link   Leotie    13 years ago

Tacos, I was a member of News Vine, and it went from something fairly easy to navigate and get around to a bizarre mess. The people on there don't influence the news, the talk about it, sometimes, it gets kind of ugly and contentious.

I know there are a LOT of former Viners here, but I don't know if any of them still have open accounts there, I know for the time being, mine is still open. I don't know if this helps any, maybe someone else can add more to it.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  Pedro    13 years ago

Oh, it was actually the by-line Newsvine included in their letters to me during beta. Apparently the site feels that it DOES influence the news even though clearly, the membership simply discuss the stories at hand.

Anyway, it's nice that you are here and I'm glad for your participation.

 
 
 
Leotie
Freshman Silent
link   Leotie    13 years ago

Are you on my friends list on the vine? I think I said it before, but I was Phuggy there; that's my furbeast.

I didn't like the new thing they put out, it's a pain in the arse as far as I'm concerned, and I never will understand why they did that. I've got a lot of stuff I wrote over there, so I'm not going to close the account for now. Also have some friends that that I'm going to ask them to check this out.

As far as I'm concerned, NT is much better than what the Vine is now. Just please don't go mucking it up. I'm finally getting the hang of it, and I LOVE the chat feature. Do you think we could get voice chat for the folks that want it? I have no idea how to do that or what's involved.

 
 
 
bitemore Gfotwo
Professor Silent
link   bitemore Gfotwo    13 years ago

I closed my account on Wednesday, the 13th, after nearly 4 years and 4 months there. I loved the place, the way it was before the rollout of 3.0. I met so many wonderful people, both in person and online... and, fortunately, many of them have found their way here.

Losing the original Newsvine has been a traumatic experience for most of us. It had become part of our lives... most of us at least looked in on it every day, even if we didn't comment every day. We became familiar with the writing styles and personalities of hundreds of people... we made friends of them, we met some of them at Vinemeets... it was a unique experience.

Now, we are going to carry that experience over to here. Same people, some of whom have different names, but still the same individuals, largely... and we are rebuilding our community from the ground up.

Some of us have closed our NV accounts; others have kept them; still others are on the fence or in the process of closing their accounts. There's nothing to say what one MUST do; only what individuals feel is best in their case.

Anyway, I am always happy to greet a new refugee!

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

(((((((((((((Par))))))))))))))))))

I'm glad you're here!!! It's very good to see you! Smile.gif

 
 
 
bitemore Gfotwo
Professor Silent
link   bitemore Gfotwo    13 years ago

Yep! For me, it was easier to give up smoking after 40 years! Parting with the Vine was heart-breaking!

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

I think that the site we loved is already dead. They will have a new, active site, and be fine with that.

Perhaps they wish to attract more of a younger demographic. Most of their users were boomers. Little do they know that boomers are the ones with the money to spend, otherwise advertising wouldn't be catering to us-- they use music on commercials, any more, that are boomer's greatest hits, etc. But, what can we expect from a ethos of youth? More and more, their generation is talking about how we are a 'drain on society', rather than functioning members of society that actually drive the economy.

And yes, I'm with bitey. I've mourned it since last July-- and I'm through grieving. (I keep telling myself this, anyway.) I harbor no ill-will toward the site-- I don't wish it to sink into oblivion. It just doesn't meet my needs any more. Smile.gif

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

You are very much among friends here Boomer!

 
 
 
bitemore Gfotwo
Professor Silent
link   bitemore Gfotwo    13 years ago

I should have paid more attention to you and to Augur Well back in July... but, I'm stubborn, and actually didn't realize how emotionally invested in the Vine I had been, until the 7th of this month when I realized that the Vine I knew and loved was, in fact, gone.

So, I'm gone, too. From there. Happy to be here.

 
 
 
Debora Zahn
Freshman Silent
link   Debora Zahn    13 years ago

I know that it has become to much for me to deal with. Mostly because I don't like being in a "Nation" category and because we are so segregated.

I'm glad to be here and hope to enjoy my stay. Grin.gif

 
 
 
Debora Zahn
Freshman Silent
link   Debora Zahn    13 years ago

Hello Dowser,

So nice to see you, it has been a while. Smile.gif Trying to completely break away from the vine, I need a new home that is not so explosive.

 
 
 
Alisa S
Freshman Silent
link   Alisa S    13 years ago

I'm a fairly new Newsvine refugee. I didn't partake much in debates and discussions as much as I would have liked. However, I enjoyed the exchanges that took place there. I followed the discussions, read the information provided by those debating when I could. I despise the new format and cannot find the members who, I believe, contributed a lot to the site. I'm of the younger generation but I enjoy words of wisdom and reason from individuals who have it to offer. Seems manner of the Viners I used to watch are here and I am much relievedSmile.gif . I shall indulge in discussions more than before.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Welcome Alisa! I am the Resident Advisor here. If you need help, I'm the person you go to!Grin.gif

 
 
 
Alisa S
Freshman Silent
link   Alisa S    13 years ago

Hi Perrie!

Nice to meet you. I shall message if I have trouble navigating the site. Thanks for your help.

 
 
 
Gen Vanasco
Freshman Silent
link   Gen Vanasco    13 years ago

Today, news is not always News. I use to learn more about issues from the comments and added information than from the article. That was prior to the new version arrived. I am so disappointed with the new vine. Excellent seeders/writers can back up and add to News.

 
 
 
Unpaid Shill
Freshman Silent
link   Unpaid Shill    13 years ago

THINGS THAT REPUBLICANS ARE NOT ENTITLED TO:

WTF has this got to do with the subject of this article?

Every time one of these out-of-the-blue derails turns up, it reminds me of Anthony Perkins " Crimes of Passion " 1984 .

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

I'm missing so many replies! I'm sorry!

I hope you like it here, I do! Smile.gif

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Absolutely, Roy. The whole restructuring program using beta testers (whose opinions were ignored) and the revamping of the site was nothing more than camouflage for the real purpose of the change,which was to make the NV owners more money (more advertising sites per page, etc.) and to enable the theft of our earnings. Anyone who thinks differently deserves a Darwin award.

 
 
 
Wheel
Freshman Quiet
link   Wheel    13 years ago

Buzz, you're channeling my article about this very thing. Every change they made increases page loads/ad views and taking our money was just an extra kick in the teeth.

 
 

Who is online