From a Pacifist: Maybe Guns Aren’t the Problem…
Here we go again Yet another mass murder. President Obama said,
Somehow this has become routine. The reporting is routine. My response here at this podium ends up being routine. The conversation in the aftermath of it [has become routine]. We've become numb to this. We talked about this after Columbine, and Blacksburg, after Tucson, after Newtown, after Aurora, after Charleston.
ROUTINE!!! We live in a country where mass murder is routine! What is the problem???
Pretty much everyone agrees this is a problem But there are widely divergent ideas about the root cause of this problem. Pacifists (like me) say we have too many guns, and it is too easy for people who shouldnt have guns to get them. Pro-gun advocates say guns arent the problem. They say, Guns dont kill people people kill people. Well I gotta say, when I think about it, it does seem to me that people really are at the root of this problem. More about that in a minute
Now before all you gun control people start railing at me for acknowledging an idea from the pro-gun folks, let me just say that I am a strong advocate for gun control. I really do think some kinds of gun control will mitigate this problem. So Im all for that But it wont completely solve the problem because it doesnt address the root cause of the problem. So, arguing for and against gun control is NOT the point of this article. The point of my article is to shed a little light on what I see as the root cause of this problem. So I would appreciate it if anyone who chooses to leave a comment on this article would keep their comments focus on what I will propose as the root cause of this problem.
Back to Guns dont kill people people kill people. That is absolutely true. So Is there a common thread that ties all of the people who kill people together? I think so. Some people will say its mental illness. Well In some cases thats true. But unless we are going to widely broaden the definition of mental illness, there are still many mentally normal people who kill people. So what is it??? One thing that seems to be universally common to all people who commit this kind of mass murder is anger. Well, DUH!!! That seems so obvious that it might be easily dismissed. But should we look at where that anger comes from??? Should we consider whether these people might be less inclined to commit these heinous acts if they were, at the very least, less angry???
We live in a society that says it is not only okay to be angry it says we should be angry We live in a society that foments and nurtures anger a society manipulated by people peddling anger and hatred to forward their own personal agendas.
How many of these mass murderers have committed their crime with love for others filling their heart???
Lets be clear this anger and hatred disease infects people of all ideological stripes. Some people may say, Its the other side that has most of the mass murders. Even if thats true, and Im not sure it is, that really isnt relevant! ANYONE throwing hate bombs is just throwing gasoline on the anger and hatred fire that is burning this country down!!!
If you really want to solve the mass murder problem we have here in America, start loving, accepting, and cooperating with others especially with the people who are most different from you. And at the same time discourage the promulgation of hatred stop nurturing anger and do that especially with people who are most like you.

Excellent article Mal..BTW, good to see you again.
Gakina Awiiya (we are all related)
Great article Mal, and I think you are spot on. The one thing that all of these mass killers have in common is a strong belief and a lot of hate. It is rumored that this guy was trying to kill only "christians". Not sure why and unless the FBI finds a manifesto, probably will never know.
As we saw with the Aurora killer, he was just filled with hate... not even specific.
The one thing that I have noticed is that a lot of this seems to be generated from the internet. Lonely, isolated people who feed off of one another till one flips a switch, and goes nuts on the public.
I actually think it is its own form of mental illness, and the mentally ill should not have guns.
The problem is also our HIPAA laws. It makes it so hard to report those who are a danger to society. Heck, it makes it hard on families who know that there is a problem.
We need to adjust our ideas about who can purchase a gun and have a consistent data base. We don't have that now. We also need to give our mental health providers some more leeway when it comes to reporting.
That is certainly a big part of it...
I have thought, for some time really, that "liberals" are flailing a little when they go after the availability of guns as the cause of mass murders. I would certainly like to see the availability of guns, and ammo, recede in the U.S., and hopefully one day the political will may develop to pass sensible gun regulations. As all knowledgeable people understand, there is nothing in the second amendment that prohibits regulation of gun ownership. Even Scalia has said so.
But, all the focus on guns as if they were the reason we have these mass killings is very ill advised because it takes suspicion and attention away from areas that may be the real explanation.
Is there something about the 21st century that would lead to more frequent and more deadly instances of mass shootings? Broadband highspeed internet came into wide use around 2000-2001. Prior to that there was no social media as we know it today. The world was not "connected" in the sense it is now until high speed internet. There was no texting, or sexting, no You Tube, no selfies, no online bullying, no FB, no twitter, no 4 chan, none of it.
Out of curioisity and because the link appeared in a blog that I look at most days, I looked at the 4 chan forum page associated with the Oregon shooter, a 26 year old named Chris Mercer.
Normally one could say that we can look at "evidence" of disturbed thinking mostly after the fact , and conclude that it was not that evident before the fact. But looking nat the 4 chan page, ... , and looking at these comments, and the whole theme of the forum, this is something that was visible prior.
There are all these disturbed young people on these forums, talking , very regularly, about how miserable and worthless their lives are. Young men who hate women because they believe women hate them. They call themselves "robots", and discussing , with others, their options for acting out on their misery is a regular routine.
Chris Mercer , like many before him, became detached from reality , most likely through a destructive relationship with 21st century communications venues and modes.
High speed internet access and activity is only 15 years old. Often the masses act as if it has been around forever. I suggest that we don't know what effect instantaneous mass communication is having on the psyche of the population, and I think it should concern us much much more than it does.
Guns don't kill people; people kill people...
with guns
Well said... and I agree...
TV news is reporting that the shooter told some of the victims that he had been planning this act for two years.
Well... is true too... guns and many other things...
I guess the point of my article is we will never eliminate every way people have to kill each other... If we make the instruments of death less available then there will probably be less killing of innocent people... but as an engineer, I tend to look for the root cause... I'm suggesting less hatred would be more effective than... what we are doing...
Love the article Mal, and thank you.You say what I think a lot of folks are thinking.
I'm of the firm belief that having lost our way, is caused by not being attuned to one another and Mother Nature the way we should be.
At one time humans lived on the planet like any other animal, being competitive, yes; but, alsoequally symbiotic, and adaptive. As well, humans were meant to be very tight knit groups/tribes where all were known to one another, when a person was known by their relationships to others, their role in society is how they came to be defined. A goodperson is one that contributed to the betterment of society, and that was reflected in relationships. transparency would be so much more obvious (if ya know what I mean) because hiding of the truth would be by the very dynamics, much more difficult and rare.Cultural norms and expectations are communicated much more efficiently when people are close. One result being, that loneliness and boredom were so much more remote, than they are now. Whenone communes closer with Nature and her creatures(which includeseach other) on a continuous basis vision is cleared of a lot of unimportant stuff; the true value of life starts to become clearer.That's whenclear and pragmatic gratefulness fills ya up. Realizing that life is a gift, and it is all around us thriving.
Then, life becomes sacred.
Mal, I can't tell you how very glad I am to see you! Your smiling face is such a breath of fresh air!
Truer words were never spoken! All of us need to listen to that statement!
Actually males kill people with guns . Women are more in favor of other methods like poisoning ... If you wanted to address mass killings you should have specified that .
And then there are those who make people laugh themselves to death.
Dear Friend MalamuteMan: Its so great to see you here.
Been far too long.
How are you and yours? Well and happy, I hope.
Enjoy a fabulous fall, my good friend.
Peace and Abundant Blessings.
Enoch.
Maybe we should enact the gun controls that have cleaned Chicago up so well./ SARC
Anger is an emotion and we have very little control of other peoples emotions. Many people have trouble controlling their own emotions. Many of these anti-depressants are intended to control their emotions but have side effects and can trigger other negative emotions. In certain individuals such as narcissists loving them can actually trigger anger within them.
Yes the hate and division that constantly bombards us could be the root of the problem indeed.
You mean like the guy that treats you awfully, and then feels guilty for doing it? So then, he blames you, because obviously you're making him feel guilty, and then he dumps you?
Let's talk about "emotions".
Let's talk about "drugs".
Let's talk about... anything that get's us away from
g u n s
Wow! Someone finally looking at this as a behavior issue!
What a breath of fresh air!
Or there are actually people that feel no guilt or it's so deeply buried under the false image they portray they have ways of blocking it out. Some of them were so badly damaged as a child they've been able to build a wall to deaden their own emotions. There are people that have no concept of empathy and compassion.
Yeah, we can talk about the real issue for a change.
Ain't it wonderful!
Wholeheartedly agree!
Time to put action to the words....
Problem is, I doubt the politicians and politically motivated will allow it.
Oh yes! I was married to one, once... Officially diagnosed. It was get out of that marriage or die. Literally.
I think so, too.
It's a shame that that's what "sells".
Hi Enoch,
It has been too long. Makes seeing you all the sweeter...
I'm well... busy, but well. And you???
This fall is quite beautiful here in the northwest...
Best Wishes,
Mal
[Mal wags to his Dowser friend... Leans against her with a big Malamute hug...]
BTW - I forgot to let you know how much I miss you and all my NT friends...
[Mal lies down next to his Perrie friend... sings a quiet little Malamute song...]
Arroooo... rooo rooo... Arroooooooooooo...
I miss you too, Mal. You're such a good fur friend.
[Pets Mal on the side and gives him a nice chew toy]
Thoughtful and makes one think, enjoyed it.
We the people allow our leaders to kill anyone, who acts or thinks they might act against our national interests. I have no foreign interests, maybe others do, but when our military can be so easily manipulated like chess pieces, country after country the world over, we are the problem. Make it harder for our leaders to kill and society will follow.
Ive read that mental health should be a factor in Second Amendment determinations. Who will decide who can exercise their "right to bear arms", Doctors, Nurses, Insurance companies, Actuaries, the government?? If we start singling out people for mental health, we can expect to screw it up and deny the wrong people, who usually lawyer up.
Hey Mal,
Glad to see you!
Agreed; but in the interim, it must be made more difficult for the un-nurtured to acquire fire arms.
Is that so far-fetched?
I didn't create this graphic to be liked I did it to evoke commentary no inane pronouncement, quip and slogan commentary, but actual, thoughtful commentary as to why this image IS OR IS NOT ANALOGOUS TO THE NRA'S APPROACH TO UNNECESSARY DEATHS.
I have mixed anticipation.
Over-simplifications seem to be your focus these days .
If it's so over-simplified, help us with a cogent explanation as to what might mitigate the loss of life by gun violence.
We await elucidation.
When confronted with a complex problem I prefer to think about it instead of spouting ideological propaganda ... the candy of the mind .
If it's weak, give us the strong.
I asked if the image IS OR IS NOT ANALOGOUS TO THE NRA MANTRA I didn't take a position I ASKED YOU TO DO THAT.
If you can't, rather than mock my attempt to find thinkers, see if you can, pardon the pun viably shoot holes in the analogy.
So far, we're 0 for 2 a pair of cop outs with no attempt to tell why the analogy is or is not valid.
The little picture is what grown ups would refer to as an editorial cartoon.
Check your local media for their juvenile little pictures.
Sometimes, when one cannot enter a dialogue on its particular level it's better to remain silent.
Now that we've had our pissing contest, is the analogy on-target (pun intended) or not and explain your position.
Criminals steal lots of cars everyday. They don't care.
In other words, you can't deal with the analogy
So noted.
Also a lot more concealed weapon permits.
Bottom line : you will inevitably choose low info content propaganda in favor of the hard work of using your own brain . Not surprising ...
BTW I am not on your timetable . You seem to be interested in only being glib , not in being creative or flexible ... not someone who is interested in actual discussion .
When identified, do their names become part of a data base?
What if physicians decide to stop trying to cure cancers because they can't cure all of them?
Does progress need to be perfect, and when it isn't, should we abandon attempts to continue progressing/trying to make progress in a particular endeavor?
How many lives need to be saved before efforts to save them are deemed worthwhile?
When a guy commits a crime with a gun he is already logged into a database.
And include this info : when a gun is used to deter a crime but no one is shot it is NOT logged into any data base .
How about we continue with what is working more concealed weapons permits more open carry states and less crime.
Got a problem with us following the laws as written A. Mac - or do you want to make an big issue over that too?
Concealed handgun permits have no impact on crime rates
I want universal background checks and the end of the gun show loophole; that's it, that's all.
Do you want to make an big issue over that?
To curb the illegal use of firearms and enforce the Federal firearms laws, ATF issues firearms licenses and conducts firearms licensee qualification and compliance inspections. In addition to aiding the enforcement of Federal requirements for gun purchases, compliance inspections of existing licensees focus on assisting law enforcement to identify and apprehend criminals who illegally purchase firearms.
The inspections also help improve the likelihood that crime gun traces will be successful, since inspectors educate licensees in proper record keeping and business practices. Compliance inspections target licensees likely to divert firearms from legitimate trade to criminal use and dealers with a history of poor compliance.
All you need is right there. Follow them - FOLLOW them and your problem will be reduced.
1st,
Unlicensed "Collectors" at gun shows do not have to conduct background checks! Internet sales also evade current laws.
I am advocating cutting off one source of gun acquisition. What's the objection to that?
Stanford Report, November 14, 2014
Right-to-carry gun laws linked to increase in violent crime, Stanford research shows
Impressive looking article but : the only graphic was a picture of a handgun . If this was supposed to be scholarly it had no supporting data . There was no data & no graphs or stats . Is it possible this was just a political hit piece ? I see NO evidence to the contrary .
BTW law professors may or may not have any background in statistics . Law is such a large field in itself I would be surprised to see that complex study in their curriculum vitale [sp ?]
Actually, I've tied that the "gun debate", like most political debates, is highly polarized. Most people tend to look for "the cause" (of course those on the left and theright disagree as to what the cause is).
IMO, we should focus on solutions. (Plural). I think there are several contributing factors, nd we should address them-- its not just one thing.
That is the reason why I have changed my mind about gun control. Now that your President wants to make America a home for so many potential, if not actual, terrorists, I think EVERYONE in the USA needs to arm themselves, to the teeth, and as the Boy Scouts would say, be prepared. And what your President wants, your President gets no matter how large a majority of Americans and their elected representatives wants otherwise.
Personal gun ownership in American seems to be trending downward and stricter gun laws do seem to help.
From Politifact;
"The statistic generally holds up, but the implications are less clear" , kind of like how fewer Americans now own guns than in the past but the ones that do seem to ownmany more and how murder rates are down across the board while CC permits are up.
Well... I have to say I'm not surprised, but the nature of the discussion on my article has turned away from the discussion I hoped to see... On the promulgation of hatred and anger, and how that negatively impacts all aspects of our society...
Don't give up hope Mal.
Itis a very passionate subject, and folks are easily swallowed by the emotional impact.
We will not always be so hollow and far apart; but, we will never learn the lessons imparted by such division, until we reap the consequences of that division. My hope and discernmentis that we will snap out of it, because we will be snapped out of it.