Via: petey-coober • 11 years ago • 58 comments
Please submit your answer to the title question . Offer evidence in a comment below . Of course your opinions about other members on NT is off topic and will be deleted .
Not being a Muslim, and not having any relationship with a Muslim wherein I could rely on the truth of their opinion, I really cannot answer that question. The only experience I could relate to in China is that Chinese people generally, and that includes moderate Muslims, have great respect for Jews, and anti-Semitism is virtually unknown here.
The Chinese have a lot to gain from Jewish values . For one thing they would not be plagued with an overpopulation problem if they had been following those values ...
As it happens, the Chinese do share many Jewish values, such as the importance of family, respect for elders, being industrious, education, etc.
I really don't think that the Chinese throughout history have treated population growth any different than other nations. It is an ancient culture, and even though the country is one of the biggest, it has taken millenia to grow the population to the extent that it did. In the early 1970s the one-child policy was instituted, but just now they have realized the economic consequences of that policy, and have now permitted 2-child families.
I think that is a fair evaluation of Chinese culture . Restraining population growth is a relatively modern phenomenon globally .
Since you don't have an opinion on the title topic would you care to comment about the article I posted in the first comment ? Can you access that URL ?
Yes, Petey, I was able to open that article. IMO the Muslims' attitude about Jews (and Americans) being behind the attack is just an example of their ignorance, vulnerablility to propaganda and ingrained belief in negative interpretation of the Q'oran and Hadith, as dictated to them by their radical imams.
So John and his yes-men NT poodles don't freak out about my comment, I am speaking here ONLY about the Muslims who were interviewed in that article who believed that Jews and/or Americans were the cause of the violence.
You can delete the latter paragraph if you feel it transgresses your initial warning.
I really don't think that the Chinese throughout history have treated population growth any different than other nations.
In the early 1970s the one-child policy was instituted, but just now they have realized the economic consequences of that policy, and have now permitted 2-child families.
These two comments contradict each other. What other nation in history has imposed an offspring limit ?
I meant that up UNTIL the 70s China was no different. Of course the one-child policy was a different direction. Sorry if I did not make it clear enough.
What other nation in history has imposed an offspring limit ?
If I'm not mistaken there have been none . But there wasn't a big motivation until now . There are well over 6 billion people on the planet now . Having said that I suspect that island nations have likely had some way of limiting their populations to avoid running out of space ... Japan comes to mind .
Very interesting video : "Are we screening for illiberal views ? You know we're not . " That is almost certainly not permitted because it would be considered not-PC .
The Levant dude is a far right Canadian commentator, voicing the same bigotry we see in the U.S. No more, no less.
That may be so John, but the sites you use are extreme in their own way as well. And I don't know if you looked at the video where he was interviewing Muslims in Paris that you can get to through Petey's comment where the Muslims pretty much put the blame on The USA and The Jews as being their leaders so to speak. Let me look for it and put it up.
Let me say the sites you choose are usually Left Wing and to you they are always right in your mind. Then any time you see anything that is right wing it is bad, bigoted and wrong. That's not the way it is in real life John. There's a right and wrong. Sometimes the Left get it right and sometimes the Right get it right. Here's the video.
I don't think you can simplify things by saying that Moderate Muslims are all one thing.
For instance, in the area that I live, are both Muslims and Jews who left Iran after the Shah. The live next to each other and are very modern. I don't know any Syrians.. so I can't say. Also where and when they came to their new host country seems to make a difference. In NYC, the Muslims who came in the 70's and 80's are very integrated. Newcomers, not so much.
Although you probably have some good points there Perrie I think the issue is one of "faux moderate" views . For example the article linked in my 1st comment seems to indicate that "moderate" French Muslims are inclined to use Jews as scapegoats . Americans too . Is that kind of attitude hidden among other moderate Muslims too ?
I really can't believe the percentage from China. First of all, there are hardly any Jews in China, and secondly the news about the I/P conflict is rarely broadcast. Thirdly, I know for a fact that Jews are admired by the Chinese generally, and finally, I think the research must have been done among the more populous radical Muslims in the north-west of China, the ones who are a big problem to the Chinese government.
Unfavorable Views of Jews and Muslims on the Increase in Europe
Ethnocentric Attitudes Are on the Rise in Europe
Overview
Ethnocentric attitudes are on the rise in Europe. Growing numbers of people in several major European countries say they have an unfavorable opinion of Jews, and opinions of Muslims also are more negative than they were several years ago.
A spring 2008 survey by the Pew Research Center’s Pew Global Attitudes Project finds 46% of the Spanish rating Jews unfavorably. More than a third of Russians (34%) and Poles (36%) echo this view. Somewhat fewer, but still significant numbers of the Germans (25%) and French (20%) interviewed also express negative opinions of Jews. These percentages are all higher than obtained in comparable Pew surveys taken in recent years. In a number of countries, the increase has been especially notable between 2006 and 2008.
Great Britain stands out as the only European country included in the survey where there has not been a substantial increase in anti-Semitic attitudes. Just 9% of the British rate Jews unfavorably, which is largely unchanged from recent years. And relatively small percentages in both Australia (11%) and the United States (7%) continue to view Jews unfavorably.
Opinions about Muslims in almost all of these countries are considerably more negative than are views of Jews. Fully half of Spanish (52%) and German respondents (50%) rate Muslims unfavorably. Opinions about Muslims are somewhat less negative in Poland (46%) and considerably less negative in France (38%). About one-in-four in Britain and the United States (23% each) also voice unfavorable views of Muslims. Overall, there is a clear relationship between anti-Jewish and anti-Muslim attitudes: publics that view Jews unfavorably also tend to see Muslims in a negative light.
The trend in negative views toward Muslims in Europe has occurred over a longer period of time than growing anti-Jewish sentiment. Most of the upswing took place between 2004 and 2006, and there has even been a slight decrease in some countries since 2006.
Negative attitudes toward Christians in Europe are less common than negative ratings of Muslims or Jews. And views about Christians have remained largely stable in recent years, although anti-Christian sentiments have been on the rise in Spain – about one-in-four Spanish (24%) now rate Christians negatively, up from 10% in 2005. Similarly, in France 17% now hold an unfavorable view of Christians, compared with 9% in 2004.
A notable parallel between anti-Muslim and anti-Jewish opinion in Western Europe is that both sentiments are most prevalent among the same groups of people. Older people and those with less education are more anti-Semitic and anti-Muslim than are younger people or those with more education. Looking at combined data from France, Germany and Spain – the three Western European countries where unfavorable opinions of Jews are most common – people ages 50 and older express more negative views of both Jews and Muslims than do those younger than 50. Similarly, Europeans who have not attended college are consistently more likely than those who have to hold unfavorable opinions of both groups.
There are some political parallels too. Anti-Muslim and anti-Jewish opinions are most prevalent among Europeans on the political right. For example, among respondents from France, Germany and Spain who place themselves on the political right, 56% express a negative view of Muslims, compared with 42% of those on the left and 45% of those in the center. Similarly, 34% of people on the political right have a negative opinion of Jews, compared with 28% of those on the left and 26% of centrists.
These are among the latest findings from the 2008 Pew Global Attitudes survey. The current report focuses on findings related to religion, and several sections are devoted specifically to issues among Muslim publics. The polling was conducted March-April 2008 in 24 countries from regions throughout the world. 1
Widespread Religiosity
In most of the countries included in the survey, religion is considered a central feature of life. However, this is often less true among younger people. In many nations, including the United States, people under age 40 are less likely than others to say religion is very important to them.
And there is also a notable gender gap in many nations regarding religion’s importance. Consistently, women are more likely than men to say religion plays a very important role in their lives. Among the countries on the survey, the largest gender gap is in the United States, where 65% of women rate religion as very important, compared with only 44% of men.
Muslim Views On Terrorism
The decline in support for terrorism observed in Pew Global Attitudes surveys over the last few years continues this year among Muslims in Nigeria, Turkey and Pakistan. Elsewhere, there has been virtually no change, or in the case of Egypt, a slight increase in support for terrorism.
Since 2002, the percentage saying that suicide bombing and other forms of violence against civilians are justified to defend Islam from its enemies has declined in most predominantly Muslim countries surveyed. For instance, in 2002 roughly three-in-four Lebanese Muslims (74%) said such attacks could often or sometimes be justified; today, 32% take this view.
Opinions about Osama bin Laden have followed a similar trend. For instance, only three years ago, about six-in-ten (61%) Jordanian Muslims voiced at least some confidence in the al Qaeda leader; today, just 19% express a positive view. In 2003, 20% of Lebanese Muslims and 15% of Turkish Muslims had positive views of bin Laden. Today, seven years after the September 11 attacks, bin Laden’s ratings have plummeted to the low single digits in both countries (Turkey 3%, Lebanon 2%). Still, substantial numbers of Muslims continue to express confidence in bin Laden in Nigeria (58%), Indonesia (37%) and Pakistan (34%).
Conflict in the Muslim World
Most Muslims in the nations surveyed by Pew continue to worry about the rise of Islamic extremism, both at home and abroad. Majorities in Indonesia, Pakistan, Tanzania, Lebanon, Egypt, Jordan and Nigeria say they are concerned about extremism in their own country and in other countries around the world.
Many are also concerned about growing tensions between Sunni and Shia Muslims. There is a widespread perception that Sunni-Shia tensions are not limited to Iraq and instead are a broader problem affecting the Muslim world more generally.
Large numbers of Muslims in several countries surveyed also see a struggle taking place within their countries between Islamic fundamentalists and those who want to modernize the nation. In Turkey, in particular, a large and growing majority sees such a conflict taking place, but this view also is common in Lebanon, Tanzania, Indonesia and Pakistan.
Additional Findings
France stands out as the most secular nation included in the survey. Only one-in-ten in that country consider religion very important in their lives and 60% say they never pray.
While European views towards Jews have become more negative, the deepest anti-Jewish sentiments exist outside of Europe, especially in predominantly Muslim nations. The percentage of Turks, Egyptians, Jordanians, Lebanese and Pakistanis with favorable opinions of Jews is in the single digits.
Two pillars of Islam are commonly practiced by the Muslims surveyed: prayer and fasting. Majorities in most of the eight Muslim publics included pray five times a day and fast most days of Ramadan.
Views of Hamas tend to be negative in Lebanon, Turkey, and Egypt. Jordan is the only predominantly Muslim country surveyed in which a majority express a positive view of the militant Palestinian organization.
Views of the militant Lebanese Shia organization Hezbollah are overwhelmingly negative in Turkey, while slim majorities in Egypt and Jordan express positive views of Hezbollah. In Lebanon itself, Hezbollah is almost unanimously popular among the country’s Shia community, but is overwhelmingly unpopular among Sunnis and Christians.
Saudi Arabia receives positive ratings from most of the publics in the predominantly Muslim countries surveyed, although Turkey is an exception; 43% of Turks express an unfavorable view of Saudi Arabia, while just 36% hold a favorable view.
Keep in mind this information is at least 7 to 10 years old.
Just an observation. It appears in general that Muslim countries have a much poorer opinion of both other religions in the survey than non Muslim countries do of Muslims.
Those are French Muslims. It might be very different here. It might have to do with socio economic status. It's all qutie fuzzy.. a lot like Jaywalking. It may be that is the view of moderate muslims in France, but that is hardly a census going on, in that article. I would have to find something more convincing, from a statistical POV.
that is hardly a census going on, in that article.
Agreed , and yet a result like that does not surprise me . I'm thinking that the US is unique as far as extreme muslim views goes . I expect that the US is fairly low in that respect . So perhaps the more useful comparison would be to look at other countries in Europe . We know there is no point in looking at the middle eastern countries because we already know what we would find : blaming Jews and the US .
Boy, does Petey's article sound familiar or what? We hear the same thing here all the time, just about Christians. So and so isn't a REAL Christian. This is why religion is so stupid. Even if you say you are devoted to a particular religion, there's always someone to claim you aren't a REAL adherent.
First comment :
Of course your opinions about other members on NT is off topic and will be deleted .
Here is an article about Paris moderate Muslims which seems to be pertinent :
French Muslims: Jews Are Behind Paris Attacks
Apparently muslims in Paris refuse to place blame on Islam but they do blame : Jews and Americans [see the above link }
Not being a Muslim, and not having any relationship with a Muslim wherein I could rely on the truth of their opinion, I really cannot answer that question. The only experience I could relate to in China is that Chinese people generally, and that includes moderate Muslims, have great respect for Jews, and anti-Semitism is virtually unknown here.
The Chinese have a lot to gain from Jewish values . For one thing they would not be plagued with an overpopulation problem if they had been following those values ...
As it happens, the Chinese do share many Jewish values, such as the importance of family, respect for elders, being industrious, education, etc.
I really don't think that the Chinese throughout history have treated population growth any different than other nations. It is an ancient culture, and even though the country is one of the biggest, it has taken millenia to grow the population to the extent that it did. In the early 1970s the one-child policy was instituted, but just now they have realized the economic consequences of that policy, and have now permitted 2-child families.
Buzz ,
I think that is a fair evaluation of Chinese culture . Restraining population growth is a relatively modern phenomenon globally .
Since you don't have an opinion on the title topic would you care to comment about the article I posted in the first comment ? Can you access that URL ?
Yes, Petey, I was able to open that article. IMO the Muslims' attitude about Jews (and Americans) being behind the attack is just an example of their ignorance, vulnerablility to propaganda and ingrained belief in negative interpretation of the Q'oran and Hadith, as dictated to them by their radical imams.
So John and his yes-men NT poodles don't freak out about my comment, I am speaking here ONLY about the Muslims who were interviewed in that article who believed that Jews and/or Americans were the cause of the violence.
You can delete the latter paragraph if you feel it transgresses your initial warning.
I really don't think that the Chinese throughout history have treated population growth any different than other nations.
In the early 1970s the one-child policy was instituted, but just now they have realized the economic consequences of that policy, and have now permitted 2-child families.
These two comments contradict each other. What other nation in history has imposed an offspring limit ?
I meant that up UNTIL the 70s China was no different. Of course the one-child policy was a different direction. Sorry if I did not make it clear enough.
What other nation in history has imposed an offspring limit ?
If I'm not mistaken there have been none . But there wasn't a big motivation until now . There are well over 6 billion people on the planet now . Having said that I suspect that island nations have likely had some way of limiting their populations to avoid running out of space ... Japan comes to mind .
How about this?
Oh I'll have to fix one for you Buzz. You have to see this.
Very interesting video : "Are we screening for illiberal views ? You know we're not . " That is almost certainly not permitted because it would be considered not-PC .
The Levant dude is a far right Canadian commentator, voicing the same bigotry we see in the U.S. No more, no less.
@johnrussell :
The Levant dude is a far right Canadian commentator, voicing the same bigotry we see in the U.S. No more, no less.
That may be so John, but the sites you use are extreme in their own way as well. And I don't know if you looked at the video where he was interviewing Muslims in Paris that you can get to through Petey's comment where the Muslims pretty much put the blame on The USA and The Jews as being their leaders so to speak. Let me look for it and put it up.
Let me say the sites you choose are usually Left Wing and to you they are always right in your mind. Then any time you see anything that is right wing it is bad, bigoted and wrong. That's not the way it is in real life John. There's a right and wrong. Sometimes the Left get it right and sometimes the Right get it right. Here's the video.
I don't think you can simplify things by saying that Moderate Muslims are all one thing.
For instance, in the area that I live, are both Muslims and Jews who left Iran after the Shah. The live next to each other and are very modern. I don't know any Syrians.. so I can't say. Also where and when they came to their new host country seems to make a difference. In NYC, the Muslims who came in the 70's and 80's are very integrated. Newcomers, not so much.
"I don't think you can simplify things by saying that Moderate Muslims are all one thing."
In a way, that's somewhat of a scary comment.
Although you probably have some good points there Perrie I think the issue is one of "faux moderate" views . For example the article linked in my 1st comment seems to indicate that "moderate" French Muslims are inclined to use Jews as scapegoats . Americans too . Is that kind of attitude hidden among other moderate Muslims too ?
"..."moderate" French Muslims are inclined to use Jews as scapegoats..."
Using Jews as scapegoats is a universal historical reality.
OK found something from The Pew:
I really can't believe the percentage from China. First of all, there are hardly any Jews in China, and secondly the news about the I/P conflict is rarely broadcast. Thirdly, I know for a fact that Jews are admired by the Chinese generally, and finally, I think the research must have been done among the more populous radical Muslims in the north-west of China, the ones who are a big problem to the Chinese government.
Buzz,
I doubt they are making up the numbers and who knows? There are hardly any Jews in Japan and they are very anti-semitic.
BTW: Just found this also in The Pew. It is very telling about where some of the European Muslims might be getting their cue.
Sorry, Perrie, I can't open that link.
@buzz-of-the-orient :
Sorry, Perrie, I can't open that link.
This is the link Buzz.
Unfavorable Views of Jews and Muslims on the Increase in Europe
Ethnocentric Attitudes Are on the Rise in Europe
Overview
Ethnocentric attitudes are on the rise in Europe. Growing numbers of people in several major European countries say they have an unfavorable opinion of Jews, and opinions of Muslims also are more negative than they were several years ago.
Great Britain stands out as the only European country included in the survey where there has not been a substantial increase in anti-Semitic attitudes. Just 9% of the British rate Jews unfavorably, which is largely unchanged from recent years. And relatively small percentages in both Australia (11%) and the United States (7%) continue to view Jews unfavorably.
The trend in negative views toward Muslims in Europe has occurred over a longer period of time than growing anti-Jewish sentiment. Most of the upswing took place between 2004 and 2006, and there has even been a slight decrease in some countries since 2006.
A notable parallel between anti-Muslim and anti-Jewish opinion in Western Europe is that both sentiments are most prevalent among the same groups of people. Older people and those with less education are more anti-Semitic and anti-Muslim than are younger people or those with more education. Looking at combined data from France, Germany and Spain – the three Western European countries where unfavorable opinions of Jews are most common – people ages 50 and older express more negative views of both Jews and Muslims than do those younger than 50. Similarly, Europeans who have not attended college are consistently more likely than those who have to hold unfavorable opinions of both groups.
There are some political parallels too. Anti-Muslim and anti-Jewish opinions are most prevalent among Europeans on the political right. For example, among respondents from France, Germany and Spain who place themselves on the political right, 56% express a negative view of Muslims, compared with 42% of those on the left and 45% of those in the center. Similarly, 34% of people on the political right have a negative opinion of Jews, compared with 28% of those on the left and 26% of centrists.
These are among the latest findings from the 2008 Pew Global Attitudes survey. The current report focuses on findings related to religion, and several sections are devoted specifically to issues among Muslim publics. The polling was conducted March-April 2008 in 24 countries from regions throughout the world. 1
Widespread Religiosity
And there is also a notable gender gap in many nations regarding religion’s importance. Consistently, women are more likely than men to say religion plays a very important role in their lives. Among the countries on the survey, the largest gender gap is in the United States, where 65% of women rate religion as very important, compared with only 44% of men.
Muslim Views On Terrorism
Since 2002, the percentage saying that suicide bombing and other forms of violence against civilians are justified to defend Islam from its enemies has declined in most predominantly Muslim countries surveyed. For instance, in 2002 roughly three-in-four Lebanese Muslims (74%) said such attacks could often or sometimes be justified; today, 32% take this view.
Opinions about Osama bin Laden have followed a similar trend. For instance, only three years ago, about six-in-ten (61%) Jordanian Muslims voiced at least some confidence in the al Qaeda leader; today, just 19% express a positive view. In 2003, 20% of Lebanese Muslims and 15% of Turkish Muslims had positive views of bin Laden. Today, seven years after the September 11 attacks, bin Laden’s ratings have plummeted to the low single digits in both countries (Turkey 3%, Lebanon 2%). Still, substantial numbers of Muslims continue to express confidence in bin Laden in Nigeria (58%), Indonesia (37%) and Pakistan (34%).
Conflict in the Muslim World
Many are also concerned about growing tensions between Sunni and Shia Muslims. There is a widespread perception that Sunni-Shia tensions are not limited to Iraq and instead are a broader problem affecting the Muslim world more generally.
Large numbers of Muslims in several countries surveyed also see a struggle taking place within their countries between Islamic fundamentalists and those who want to modernize the nation. In Turkey, in particular, a large and growing majority sees such a conflict taking place, but this view also is common in Lebanon, Tanzania, Indonesia and Pakistan.
Additional Findings
Keep in mind this information is at least 7 to 10 years old.
Thank you Six.
"Older people and those with less education are more anti-Semitic and anti-Muslim than are younger people or those with more education."
"Similarly, Europeans who have not attended college are consistently more likely than those who have to hold unfavorable opinions of both groups."
Ignorance and anti-Semitism go hand in hand.
Buzz,
Well, yeah. Isn't that always the way?
Thanks Six!
@perrie-halpern :
OK found something from The Pew:
Perrie those graphs are from 2005 and 2008. A lot has happened during the last 7 to 10 years.
Just an observation. It appears in general that Muslim countries have a much poorer opinion of both other religions in the survey than non Muslim countries do of Muslims.
Incidents like the Paris attack may change that ...
Those are French Muslims. It might be very different here. It might have to do with socio economic status. It's all qutie fuzzy.. a lot like Jaywalking. It may be that is the view of moderate muslims in France, but that is hardly a census going on, in that article. I would have to find something more convincing, from a statistical POV.
that is hardly a census going on, in that article.
Agreed , and yet a result like that does not surprise me . I'm thinking that the US is unique as far as extreme muslim views goes . I expect that the US is fairly low in that respect . So perhaps the more useful comparison would be to look at other countries in Europe . We know there is no point in looking at the middle eastern countries because we already know what we would find : blaming Jews and the US .
Dear Friend Perrie: As a Chaplain my experience with Pastors of all non-Jewish religions, and secular Chaplains is most positive.
I concur. It never is accurate to over generalize.
E.
Boy, does Petey's article sound familiar or what? We hear the same thing here all the time, just about Christians. So and so isn't a REAL Christian. This is why religion is so stupid. Even if you say you are devoted to a particular religion, there's always someone to claim you aren't a REAL adherent.
What about the Druids Hal ? How do you feel about them ? BTW being Jewish is every bit about a genetic background as about a belief system ...
I've dated several moderate Muslims and none of them particularly cared for Jews.