EL PASO - UPDATED: 3:20 P.M
Diocese of El Paso's Spokeswoman Liz O'Hara tells Abc-7 Catholic Priest Mike Alcuino out of Presidio was called to the ranch and administered Justice Scalia's last rights just moments ago.
ORIGINAL STORY:
EL PASO -- An El Paso source close to Justice Antonin Scalia tells ABC-7 that the 79-year-old died in his sleep last night after a day of quail hunting at Cibolo Creek Ranch outside of Marfa, Texas.
The Justice did not report feeling ill and retired to his room after dinner. The source, who was traveling with Scalia, told ABC-7 an El Paso priest has been called to Marfa.
Scalia was the longest-serving current Justice on the Supreme Court. He was appointed by President Ronald Reagan in 1986.
Texas Governor Greg Abbott released the following statement:
"Justice Antonin Scalia was a man of God, a patriot, and an unwavering defender of the written Constitution and the Rule of Law. He was the solid rock who turned away so many attempts to depart from and distort the Constitution. His fierce loyalty to the Constitution set an unmatched example, not just for judges and lawyers, but for all Americans. We mourn his passing, and we pray that his successor on the Supreme Court will take his place as a champion for the written Constitution and the Rule of Law. Cecilia and I extend our deepest condolences to his family, and we will keep them in our thoughts and prayers."

WOW - This is BIGGGGGGG
I'm completely in shock
Terrible news.
WOW - This is BIGGGGGGG
I'm completely in shock
I think the entire country is in shock pj. It is an enormous loss to the country, I was never in ideological or philosophical alignment Scalia, but I recognize him as an icon in American Jurisprudence. He will be remembered as one of the Supreme Courts most important Justices.
Yes, the position should be respected without question. I can't even think about what this means.
The Court lost it's leading intellectual and the best writer that's ever sat on it's bench. A terrible loss for the country.
The Court lost it's leading intellectual and the best writer that's ever sat on it's bench. A terrible loss for the country.
For once we're in agreement Sean, Scalia was indeed the most intellectual Justice on this court, the country has lost a great man.
I thought this was one of those fake death reports that freak people out for 10 minutes. Then I turned on CNN.
What a tremendous loss.
Was Scalia one of the SC judges who appointed Bush as President as against the popular vote for Gore?
No. There were no such judges.
Was Scalia one of the SC judges who appointed Bush as President as against the popular vote for Gore?
No. There were no such judges.
I think you're wrong Cerenkov:
Scalia joined the majority per curiam opinion in the 2000 case of Bush v. Gore , which effectively ended recounts of ballots in Florida following the 2000 US Presidential election , and also both concurred separately and joined Rehnquist's concurrence. [107] In 2007, he said of the case, "I and my court owe no apology whatever for Bush v. Gore . We did the right thing. So there! ... get over it. It's so old by now." [108]
[ Wikipedia ]
No, I'm quite right. The SCOTUS did not appoint a president. They ruled on an unconstitutional recount.
It was not a unanimous decision, in fact only a one-vote majority rule. There were valid dissents, but I believe the decision was political rather than judicial in those circumstances.
Their decision had the effect of anointing Bush as against the leader of the majority popular vote. I thought America meant Government of the people by the people for the people. In this case that was a lie.
Nope. Presidents are not elected by majority vote. That's our system.
" In the United States, each state conducts its own popular vote election for President and Vice President. The voters are actually voting for a slate of electors, each of whom pledges to vote for a particular candidate for each office, in the Electoral College . Article II, § 1, cl. 2 of the U.S. Constitution provides that each state legislature decides how electors are chosen."
No, I'm quite right. The SCOTUS did not appoint a president. They ruled on an unconstitutional recount.
They ruled on the Florida Supreme Court finding, effectively "appointing" Bush to the Presidency.
We're playing with semantics here. The real issue is who is going to nominate the justice that is going to be the swing vote tor the obviously politicized US Supreme Court.
They ruled on the Florida Supreme Court finding, effectively "appointing" Bush to the Presidency.
Bingo.
Was Scalia one of the SC judges who appointed Bush as President as against the popular vote for Gore?
Yes, Scalia was appointed by Reagan in 1986
As much as I would like to discuss the political ramifications of Justice Scalia's passing, I feel we should take some time to reflect on the man, and not his political ideology.
Antonin Scalia was an avid hunter, and he passed away in his sleep while he was on a hunting trip. So at least we can know he died while he was doing something he loved.
He will be sorely miss by his followers, his friends and his family.
I extend my condolences to his wife Maureen, and his five sons and four daughters. May he rest in peace.
" A couple of years ago, US Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia was at a function that Congressman Tom Cole (R-OK) was also attending. Upon hearing that Congressman Cole is from the Chickasaw Nation, Scalia said: “ Don't forget you belong to a conquered race .”
Read more at You'll never guess what my opinion of Scalia is based on his other SCOTUS cases dealing with Native Americans. Just from this year, Scalia's passing leaves a significant void on the nation's highest court. The justices have a record four Indian law cases on the docket, with decisions pending in three of those.The court already decided Menominee Indian Tribe of Wisconsin v. US , a contract support costs case that went against the Menominee Nation . The decision to limit the tribe's claims to self-determination shortfalls at the Indian Health Service was unanimous.
In December, the justices heard Dollar General Corporation v. Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians , a tribal jurisdiction case, they haven't issued a decision. The lack of a ninth justice could affect the outcome of the case, with a 4-4 decision or better resulting in a victory for the sovereignty of the Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians .
The court also already heard Nebraska v. Parker and even Scalia appeared to be skeptical of attempts to diminish the reservation of the Omaha Tribe of Nebraska. But a decision hasn't been issued.
The fourth case, US v. Bryant , will determine whether tribal convictions can be used in federal courts. Briefs are still being accepted.
He definitely was no friend to the tribes/nations.
Will it now be up to Obama to appoint a judge to take his place? Could his appointment, if confirmed, affect the balance of the court?
Will it now be up to Obama to appoint a judge to take his place? Could his appointment, if confirmed, affect the balance of the court?
No, and most definitively.
All federal judges, including SCOTUS, are nominated by the President, and confirmed by the Senate.
This President and the Left Wing community would like nothing more than to have an Obama nominee confirmed to replace the conservative Justice Scalia. Any nominee coming from a progressive President will most definitely harbor a more progressive philosophy and swing the balance of the now evenly divided Court to the Left.
However, it is highly unlikely Obama will get the current Republican majority Senate to confirm anyone he nominates, leaving Scalias' seat vacant until after the election. If the GOP wins back the White House and retains control of the Senate, Scalias seat will be filled by a conservative Justice. If the Dems retain the White House and don't regain the Senate, the new President will have to nominate a very 'middle of the road' candidate. in order to win a confirmation.
That's why, in addition to the enormous presence Scalia as taken with him, his passing in the middle of an election year is such a huge event , and will likely will make this particular election year the most important of the new century.
What a scary thought. His appointments have been terrible.
The President is here in the Valley for an Asian summit meeting. He needs to take his time and appoint someone who is both more liberal, but can pass the Senate committee and confirmation. Not an easy task. Mitch McConnell said the seat should stay open until the next President in sworn in. There has never been a vacancy to the SCOTUS that long (360 days) and with so many important issues coming before the court there should not be now.
If the court is made up of an odd number of Judges, there would not normally be a tie unless a judge were to abstain (if they did that - it's possible that there could be circumstances where a judge would recuse him/herself which could also lead to a tie.) What happens in the event of a tie?
What happens in the event of a tie?
In the case of a tie, the lower court's decision is upheld and no precedent is set. The court traditionally does not issue an opinion.
There are no "fixed" number of Justices for SCOTUS - it has been suggested that they have 15 for a better variety of decisions and context of Constutional continuity.
"The judicial Power of the United States, shall be vested in one supreme Court, and in such inferior Courts as the Congress may from time to time ordain and establish. The Judges, both of the supreme and inferior Courts, shall hold their Offices during good Behaviour, and shall, at stated Times, receive for their Services, a Compensation, which shall not be diminished during their Continuance in Office."
Cool. I did not know that.
Wasn't there a year vacancy under John Tyler in his last years of presidency?
Wasn't there a year vacancy under John Tyler in his last years of presidenc y?
I didn't know you were a presidential history scholar Dean, Your right, Tyler lacked political support in the Senate, resulting in all four of his nominees being unsuccessful, including three who were nominated by Tyler on multiple occasions.
John C. Spencer was nominated on January 9, 1844
R euben H. Walworth was nominated on March 13, 1844,
Edward King was nominated on June 5, 1844.
Then there was a whole lot of nominations, withdrawals and re-nominations until Samuel Nelson was finally confirmed and appointed to the court on Feb. 14, 1845
So, by my calculation there was a vacancy for 401 days .
He needs to take his time and appoint someone who is both more liberal, but can pass the Senate committee and confirmation. Not an easy task. Mitch McConnell said the seat should stay open until the next President in sworn in. There has never been a vacancy to the SCOTUS that long (360 days) and with so many important issues coming before the court there should not be now.
CNN has just reported (2/13/16 7:23 pm EST) that President Obama has announced he will nominate a replacement to take Scalia's seat.
I agree it's not going to be an easy task. The Republicans will want a conservative that follows Scalia's ideology, and the President will want someone that is more progressive.
I have a feeling the GOP is going to stonewall any conformation until after the election.
I hope so.
I hope so.
Doesn't make any difference, the next President is going to be a Democrat and the Dems will win a Senate majority in the process.
Lol. And unicorns will frolic in celebration during this acid trip you're imagining...
Lol. And unicorns will frolic in celebration during this acid trip you're imagining...
I would give some credence to what you're saying Kovy, but unless the GOP takes the likes of Cruz and Trump out of the lead for the nomination, the election is going to the Dems, and the Senate is going with it, that is unless Darling Donald and his pal from Texas, has not damaged Republican brand beyond repair.
I don't agree, Gher.
I don't agree, Gher.
I kinda thought you wouldn't.
He could add to the universality of the court by appointing a gay Muslim Native American.
He could add to the universality of the court by appointing a gay Muslim Native American.
That would be fine with me, as long as they lean to the left.
He will nominate someone and they will get through the confirmation progress or the Senate will look far too political and dragging their feet for partisan reasons (which only helps independents and moderates want to vote Democrat), if they want to keep a GOP majority in the Senate. They can block whoever he appoints and when Hillary Clinton is elected President she will (with that helps) have coat-tails enough to take back control of the Senate anyway. Now or later there will be at least a semi-liberal taking his seat.
Being pig-headed and stupid is not a good policy for the GOP when It comes to this appointment. I sort of hope they are because it'll be worse for them then. Swallow GOP. You'll get used to the taste. Man up and accept it GOP. It's your turn in the barrel.
Even with a new democratic POTUS it will be a long slog to get a nominee confirmed.
Unless of course the make up of congress shifts again.
Unless of course the make up of congress shifts again.
I'm keeping my fingers crossed.
Hmmmm - interesting thought. Nowhere in the Constitution does it say that the SENATE will be the approving authority for filling vacancies on the Court. It is stated that CONGRESS, i.e., both houses, will fill. (as the Congress may from time to time ordain and establish.)
Where does this thing about the Senate come up except in the venue of spending and paying???
actually art 2 sec 2 states the President is the one to appoint judges , the caveate is it also says with the advice and consent of the Senate , so the appointment is a nomination until the senate gives its consent. every federal justice has to be consented to by the senate , once consent is given they are considered appointed .
So, the language, without an amendment, "reads" the SENATE instead of Congress?
powers of the president art 2 section 2 that pertains; He shall have Power, by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, to make Treaties, provided two thirds of the Senators present concur ; and he shall nominate, and by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, shall appoint Ambassadors, other public Ministers and Consuls, Judges of the supreme Court, and all other Officers of the United States, whose Appointments are not herein otherwise provided for, and which shall be established by Law:
I believe the reason the senate is used and not the entire congress is the house of reps represents a different group than the senate does , the house represents the peoples rights , the senate represents the States rights one is to look out for what is good for whom they represent the other the other , sometimes what is good for the state is not so good for the people , and vise versa, the confusion arises by who elects them , people tend to think senators work for them because they vote them into office , when in fact they are elected top protect the states interests , not the peoples , that's what a house of rep member is for . use to be the states would appoint their senators , either the governor or the legislature chose them , that was changed in the early 1900s by amendment to stop cronyism and graft. I would also add that the senate having fewer members is easier to keep track of since each state only has 2 senators vs any number of HoR members based on population yet limited to a certain number. besides if its hard to agree with a smaller group imagine trying to get 400+ to all agree, herding cats and chickens comes to mind. the way its written each state has an equal say irregardless of situation or circumstance.
I gotta say, I am no fan of Obama, but I do think that he is smart enough to only consider a nominee that would be a moderate, and already had been confirmed by lesser court positions by Republicans. I don't think he will pick someone too left, but rather moderate. By doing this, he will also possibly impact the election. If the Republicans turn turn down a rational choice, the backlash might lead to a win for the White House for the Prez.
perri, I would respectfully disagree, just because a person has gone through the process already favorably , does not guarantee that same person should or could be advanced higher, the confirmation process , does take into account the position being fielded , a person might sail through as a federal district nominee , or an appellate court nominee , but might be considered not qualified for the next highest court until some time passes in the other position , and that is left to the individual senators to decide for themselves what criteria they will use in considering a nominee.
Confirmation votes are routine for lower court nominees unless the home state Senator objects or the nominee has major red flags such as being a militant extremist. Or, in the case of Miguel Estrada, being Hispanic. Confirmation vote totals bear no relation to whether a judge is a moderate.
For instance, no liberal would call Scalia a moderate, even though he was confirmed 98-0.
It would not look good for the Republicans to vote down someone they had previously confirmed 97-0.
Get real.
Could they and would they do it? Of course. But the reason they don't want to be in that position is twofold , they hate Obama, and the election is coming.
Unfortunately for them, precedent is quite clear and it is not in the Republicans favor.
John that depends on who you talk too, it might not look good to a liberal if they pass over someone they already voted overwhelmingly for for a lower court appointment , it also would not look good for the president if he nominates someone the senate will not confirm for an even higher position because they say not qualified for that position, its a double edged sword. and totally dependant on whom is asked.
Sean,
The reason he was confirmed by that wide a margin, was because an even more conservative nominee, Robert Bork was voted down. At that time, the Republicans and the Democrats were not as nasty with each other.
Agreed Perrie. There used to be a level of respect afforded to the President but that’s no longer practiced in Washington. Partisanship has destroyed so much in the country.
That's false. Scalia was confirmed a year before Bork's nomination.
If you want to a judge a judge's "moderation" look at his/her actual record, not the confirmation vote to an inferior court, which often has nothing to do with that particular judge.
That's false. Scalia was confirmed a year before Bork's nomination.
Sean,
You are correct. What I was remembering was that both were being considered, but Bork had much more of a history than Scalia did, and Regan wanted an easy confirmation. Bork not getting in, was replaced by Kennedy.
Confirmation vote totals bear no relation to whether a judge is a moderate.
Of course not. You must have missed the point of my comment. The person chosen as a nominee with have had a long track record.... that usually tells if someone where someone is politically.
I gotta say, I am no fan of Obama, but I do think that he is smart enough to only consider a nominee that would be a moderate, and already had been confirmed by lesser court positions by Republicans.
Sandra Day O'Connor turned out to be a moderate. I'm a liberal, but a realist. He's not getting an out and out liberal through. Another Sandra Day would be fine with me.
Hi Mark,
Nice to see you! I agree that there is no guarantee that just because someone served in a lessor court that means that they are qualified, but, I do think Obama will pick as senior a judge he can find with a substantial record, and I don't believe he will pick a liberal, but a moderate. This is not just about a replacement but an election, so appearances are equally important.
it will be a very fine line that will have to be walked , even a so called moderate dependant on leanings will have a hard time and such is the situation, any number of things can happen between now and election day , as this proves , I do remember that scalia , back in the 80s was considered a moderate at the time , but look at whats said now , time has a way of redefining things and perceptions. I have see some said about limiting the amount of time justices serve, doing away with the lifetime appointments so to speak , I do not think that's a good idea , someone that's term limited , to use a phrase , gets concerned for their job, as it is and not many seem to know it is that even those lifetime appointments , can come to an end , more federal justices have met their end through impeachment ( yes they can be impeached and removed from office) than has presidents, to date 2 presidents have had articles of impeachment served , and neither removed from office In the end I don't think the GOP will hold out for an ultra conservative , nor will the president nominate someone considered too far the other way , and that is the dance that we are about to watch unfold and of course people do change over time so even a moderate could go either way over time.
I agree that a moderate can change over time, but then nothing in life is a guarantee, and Scalia was never considered moderate, but not as conservative as he became or as Bork was. The one thing I am sure of, is that any nominee from Obama will not be a the current class of liberal, but a moderate now, with a proven record. What they will become in the future, no one can tell.