Black college student tells her white classmate he can’t wear dreadlocks ‘because it’s my culture’
community » Discussions » Category » News & Politics » Discussion » Black college student tells her white classmate he can’t wear dreadlocks ‘because it’s my culture’
SFSU = San Francisco State university. Its known in N. California for its radical (& often bizarre) student behaviour. Taking political correctness to a new extreme...
And I think she was culturally appropriating. That looks like she is wearing a Jewfro to me.
"Of course she is. She's obviously Jewish. Dreadlocks are certainly a part of her culture-- they go way back. (LINK)
Takers of the Nazirite oath in the Book of Numbers display their devotion to their religion by not cutting their hair, and possibly letting it grow into dreadlocks. This vow required the man or woman to:
Abstain from wine, wine vinegar, grapes, raisins, intoxicating liquors, [11] vinegar distilled from such substances, [12] and eating or drinking any substance that contains any trace of grapes. [13]
Refrain from cutting the hair on one's head; but to allow the locks of the head's hair to grow. [14]
Not to become ritually impure by contact with corpses or graves, even those of family members. [15]
The vows described in this part of the bible has a significant impact on the Rastafari movement of the 20th century, and is the source of the Rastafari affection for dreadlocks.
According to the biblical account, Samson was given supernatural strength by God in order to combat his enemies and perform heroic feats [16] such as killing a lion, slaying an entire army with only the jawbone of an ass , and destroying a pagan temple . Samson's one weakness were his seven dreadlocks, which led to his death when they were cut off. These dreadlocks are particularly prominent in medieval European depictions. (LINK)
Vertebrates have culturally appropriated their bones from life forms lower down on the evolutionary scale (unless you believe in creationism...but do we really want to go there?)
You do know that "culture" pertains to human beings only, don't you ?
A culture is a way of life of a group of people --the behaviors, beliefs, values, and symbols that they accept, generally without thinking about them, and that are passed along by communication and imitation from one generation to the next.
You know I don't care what sex you are, she had no right to grab him. Had the situation been reversed, he would have been arrested for assault.
I agree. I was also rather surprised to learn that she was an employee of the university, and NOT a student. Had the roles been reversed, he would have been fired (and rightly so).
Shame on her for doing that. And lucky for him he just smoked a big fatty, otherwise his response to her physical aggression might not have been as mild-mannered as it was.
My friend is Jewish/American Indian and wears her hair in a Jewfro with a braided pony tail with feather.
She also insists on being called a JIP. Kind of confuses some of us Indians, but we're a mellow group so we go with the flow.
Breakfast is always ordered at Jay's Diner where the world reknown chef, Chief Chef Boiling Water Goldstein invented the world famous ''kosher Winnebagel''...
When I was in Jr High and High school I picked my curly hair out into an afro. Looked damned good on me too. I never went anywhere without my pick to keep it in nice shape either. No one, white or black, ever told me that I couldn't have a 'fro because I'm white. People can wear their hair any way they want.
Of course my step-father hated it, but he was nearly bald so I think he was just jealous.
I am a little surprised no one noticed the body language and hand gestures of the white guy.
He appears to absolutely be "appropriating" "black" (urban) body language and hand movements. Not that I give a crap one way or the other, but he is trying to "act" black, at least to that extent.
His behavior is nothing new. This phenom has been going on since the late 80's. No black person minded then (more often they laughed). What do you think Eminem was doing?
Most every male, black and white, in my school (Battle Creek Central) walked like George Jefferson from the TV show and that was in the early 1970's. No one seemed to mind that either. We called it pimpin'.
I didn't say it was anything new. The truth is, if he is trying to act black, as opposed to wearing a cool hairstyle, then he is "appropriating" . Personally I don't care if he appropriates or not, and I don't think the black girl should care either. But he is appropriating.
As the young women in the video that followed, so colorfully pointed out, technically he didn't (dreads didn't come from Africa) and we all appropriate, as in Rock n Roll (from black Jazz) Country music (from Irish), jeans, from "96er's.. Frats from the Greeks.. the list is to long...
Well, there are two parts to this - Did he "appropriate" ? and , Should anyone care if he did?
I think the answer to the first question is yes, for the reason I have given ( he has 'gangsta' body language and hand movements) and the answer to the second question is no.
You Tube and social media turn nothing into something. I also think the girl in the second video was no better than the ones in the first. She missed the other clues about the white kid as well.
Back in the day, black musical artists believed they were robbed of popularity, and thus money, by whites "appropriating" black music. Elvis was most famously accused of that, although the case was weak. Maybe I will start a thread about that one day.
The truth is, if he is trying to act black, as opposed to wearing a cool hairstyle, then he is "appropriating" . Personally I don't care if he appropriates or not, and I don't think the black girl should care either. But he is appropriating.
Or just wearing a cool hairstyle. I doubt it ever even crossed his mind that it might be a "black thing" and that it's just a new style he likes.
Not at all. When I combed my hair into a 'fro I did it because I thought it looked cool (it really did) and it never really crossed my mind that it might be a black thing. I mean Art Garfunkel was wearing his hair in one. Bo Derek had dreadlocks and I doubt it crossed her mind that it might be a black thing (because it's not). They just looked good!
I'd grow it back out and get a new pick and have a 'fro again...except I am terrified of my wife....
Not at all. When I combed my hair into a 'fro I did it because I thought it looked cool (it really did) and it never really crossed my mind that it might be a black thing. I mean Art Garfunkel was wearing his hair in one . . .
Well at the time, early 1970's, I went to an inner city High School and many white males wore 'fros. I know of no one, black or white, who thought of it in any kind of racial terms. It was simply just another hair style that some white males chose, like wearing your hair straight and long or short or whatever. I have very curly (and somewhat frizzy when it gets long) hair to begin with, so it was natural for me to choose to wear a 'fro (No one then, black or white, around me ever called them afros. Just 'fros.). I even kept my hair pick in it so I was already ready for touch ups. It was common enough that it simply never occurred to me that some people might think it was a black thing, especially since no one I knew ever thought or said so. It was much more of a time period thing then anything else.
And yes I was usually high in High School. Until I dropped out and then I was high in the Air Force.
I like You Tube because there is a lot of music and educational material on there. Crap like these videos is a waste of time. I don't care what some girl thinks about what some other girl did in another video. Don't care.
Just to reiterate for clarity's sake. The white kid is trying to act black, although I suspect it is more subconscious than conscious. His body language and hand movements are a dead giveaway. So saying "dreadlocks are not an African or black thing" is somewhat immaterial here. They are to him, and that is what the confrontation was about anyway.
He likes the style, John. Just like the girl who accosted him likes skinny jeans. They are not part of her culture either. They belong to the LA crowd.
And if you are going to make an informed opinion, you should have watched both videos. It says a lot about the youth culture of today. I would know, since I have twin 21 year olds in university.
Perrie, the white kid has the body language and hand movements of a wannabe "gangsta" as he has seen in film or video. These movements originated in underclass urban areas, mostly black. Unless he hails from such an area, he is a poser in that sense.
I don't know what you mean about watching two videos. I watched three of them.
I think the young black woman in the video is silly. But I doubt if her attitude is all that prevalent. My guess is that most young people don't care about this issue all that much.
Recent polling showed that over half the country harbors racist tendencies in their thinking. If that is true we are talking about tens of millions of adults. That is a bigger problem than this collegiate "political correctness" epidemic.
There was a news story today about a study that was done of Trump voters who were also Evangelicals ( the most Christian , according to them) and the study determined that these Evangelical Trump voters were noticeably more racist than other people who were part of the study. How about them apples?
Well, we have been hearing people like you accuse everyone else of being racist for so long that no one cares anymore.
And I know that such is an issue for people like you and causes people like you to ratchet up the rhetoric.
There are racial problem in this nation no doubt. But, pointing the accusatory finger is becoming the largest racial problem today in most peoples minds. Especially when such pointing is designed to instigate hate.
You ever hear the term blowback?
Cause that is what is beginning to happen. people are less concerned with racial stereotyping today than they are the hate mongering being perpetrated by the racist.
Of course according to your paradigm over half of America is racist.
It's not true, of course, but people are becoming much more discriminatory towards the race baiters.
Its a form of being petty in political arguments. Obsessing about insignificant trivial thing. ("Playing the 'rabbit card'-- also known as "splitting hares"-- or "hare mongering"*)
_________________________________
*The term "hair" was originally culturally appropriated from the Ancient Gaelic "hare"-- i.e. "dreadlocks". Hence the term "Hare Mongering"!
*The term "hair" was originally culturally appropriated from the Ancient Gaelic "hare"-- i.e. "dreadlocks". Hence the term "Hare Mongering"!
in one of his more erudite tomes. Chomsky (yes, that Chomsky, of cunning linguist fame) has culturaLLy appropriated the phonemic "hair" from the ancient Polynesian "ha-re", or "dreadlock":
L ook O n M y W ords, Y e M ighty, A nd D espair !
Summarizing, then, we assume that the systematic use of complex symbols suffices to account for the system of base rules exclusive of the lexicon. Clearly, any associated supporting element cannot be arbitrary in irrelevant intervening contexts in selectional rules. It appears that most of the methodological work in modern linguistics appears to correlate rather closely with the extended c-command discussed in connection with (34). Of course, the notion of level of grammaticalness is not quite equivalent to the ultimate standard that determines the accuracy of any proposed grammar. For one thing, the descriptive power of the base component can be defined in such a way as to impose the requirement that branching is not tolerated within the dominance scope of a complex symbol.
You can create your own culturally appropriated & disturbingly pompous (but totally meaningless) faux-profound paragraphs using the "Chomskybot" --> (link)
[click on that link then just keep clicking on "next paragraph".
Of course according to your paradigm over half of America is racist.
It's not true, of course,
"According to a (2012) poll from the Associated Pres race relations in America have actually gotten worse since Obama took office. In 2008, the survey found that nearly 48% of people had a negative attitude toward African Americans. Today, that number sits at 51%.
Jon Krosnick, a Stanford University professor, said:
“As much as we’d hope the impact of race would decline over time … it appears the impact of anti-black sentiment on voting is about the same as it was four years ago.”
The survey measured “explicit racism” by asking respondents whether they agreed or disagreed with various statements about black and Hispanic people. The survey also measured “implicit racism” by quickly showing the respondent a photo of a black or Hispanic person before asking them questions about a “neutral” person. The study found that 56% of Americans expressed implicit racism, compared to 49% in 2008.
The survey comes out a day after a Colin Powell’s ex-chief of staff said that the GOP was full of racists.
“Let me just be candid: My party is full of racists, and the real reason a considerable portion of my party wants President Obama out of the White House has nothing to do with the content of his character, nothing to do with his competence as commander-in-chief and president, and everything to do with the color of his skin, and that’s despicable.”
The Associated Press survey, however, racism was prevalent in both the Republican and Democratic parties. The survey found that 79% of Republicans expressed explicit racism and 65% expressed implicit racism. For Democrats, the 32% of the party expressed explicit racism and 55% expressed implicit racism."
This has nada to do with PC. This has to do with a bully, pretending to be pissed off over "cultural appropriation, accosting a guy who has every right to dress as he feels (even if he looks like a freak), and the odd conditions on college campuses.
Cultural appropriation, seems like our college campuses are becoming more PC by the day. But we do know one thing, at least they learned to use a thesaurus.
The positive thing about this?, we KNOW they learned something. (now we gotta figure out what it is)
These movements originated in underclass urban areas, mostly black. Unless he hails from such an area, he is a poser in that sense.
Both my Jr High and High School were in areas like that. Part of so-called acting black was to fit it as a white kid. However even much, much more of it was an appreciation of the culture. A culture I had never been exposed to before that, since I grew up in a very rural area of Michigan until then. To me it opened up a whole new world of (incredibly great) music and dance and attitude that I had never known about and that I loved. Even all of these years later I still carry a lot of it inside of me and think I am a better person for it.
Both my Jr High and High School were in areas like that. Part of so-called acting black was to fit it as a white kid. However even much, much more of it was an appreciation of the culture. A culture I had never been exposed to before that, since I grew up in a very rural area of Michigan until then. To me it opened up a whole new world of (incredibly great) music and dance and attitude that I had never known about and that I loved. Even all of these years later I still carry a lot of it inside of me and think I am a better person for it.
OMG-- you're one of them! You are..a "cultural appropriator"! Who woulda thunk?
You are a genuine cultural appropriator-- on our beloved Newstalker site.You owe the entire black community an apology. You must apologize at once!
Although I know this is going to be considered WAY anti-PC and in fact racist, I couldn't help thinking when I read the title of this article that he missed the opportunity to respond to her that she shouldn't be wearing clothes because "it's his culture".
BTW, I seem to remember learning in school that much of the U.S. Constitution is based on English Law. (I generally try to forget everything I earned in school since so much of it is sheer horsesh*t-- but occasionally some of it slips thru
Imagine-- the very basis of our nation is-- culturally appropriated! Therefore, we are a country of poseurs.
His hair is straight, so it doesn't count, Sister.
I do know what an Indian would tell him. Hey you, wash and brush that hair, you look like you just crawled out of a manhole. If your gonna do it, do it right.
OMG, we went from light hearted commentary to a more serious vein in the flash of an eye.
There is such a thing as appropriating another culture, it's done quite often. This is not one of those cases. The guy looks like a dufus with a manic rat on his head. She is being an obnoxious ass.
I have not yet figured out the guy in the pink tights, what is he appropriating?
What about when the ''Mohawk'' hair style was popular with whites? Was that appropriating Indian culture. I suppose that you could say that, but to me it looked ridiculous on those non Mohawk that chose to wear it. Nothing more, nothing less.
JJ's a really good player. He got a little banged up at the end of the season. I saw Houston picked up Denver's quarter back - bet that didn't go over too well with Manning retiring.
Mohawks (and "Faux-Hawks, where the side of the head isn't shaved) and variations are also somewhat popular for woman, especially Black women. ( Pictures )
It was made in 1959, back when they had genuine rosewood backs. It was too much to bring with me so I gave it to my son along with my similar vintage Gibson B45-12 (no tailpiece - exact model that Gord Lightfoot uses) - two very precious instruments.
Both rare, and highly sought for instruments. Many may assume that their value lies in their monetary value as antiques , but that is not the case. Both of these guitars in playing order would have a timbre and tone that cannot be had in modern instruments, even given if it is the same maker and model. I hope your son appreciates how wonderful they are!
This article highlights a number of problems. First of all, this woman has no right whatsoever to publicly chastise someone else for how they choose to dress or wear their hair. What gall!
Secondly, unlike cornrows which are uniquely African, dreadlocks are not exclusive to any particular continent. Yes, some Egyptians wore their hair in dreads but so did some in India, Europe, and the Middle East (Nazarites). Hair left on its own will naturally mat. The current iteration of dreads is "rooted" in Ethiopia, dating back to the coronation of Halie Selassie (Ras Tafari). It sparked a cult in Jamaica called Rastafarianism which has, as one of its beliefs, a view that the hair should not be cut or tainted with anything unnatural. Bob Marley was a Rastafarian and spread the style to the US along with his music. Some blacks adopted the hairstyle as a kind of cultural protest against copying white hair styles but they can't "own" it.
Third, if this woman wants to lecture somebody then she should lecture other black women for straightening their hair to imitate the texture and style of white people. I suggest she try it in the nearest ghetto. Grab another young black woman's arm with straightened hair and tell her that she is an embarrassment to the entire race . . . I bet she keeps her mouth shut after that if for no other reason than her lips are bruised and swollen.
My advice to this young woman is a) Get a Grip, and b) MYOB. She seems to be "power happy", and is misusing her status as a campus employee to tell the fellow what he can and can't do. Very immature.
After reviewing the video a couple of more times, I'm not sure this guy is white. In lieu of a DNA test we could ask him to jump or dance. If he can do neither, when we know that he's white.
His race has to be determined before we can continue this conversation.
The kid looked and acted like a juggalo, so he's wasting his time with the education thing. His future will likely involve standing in front of a deep fryer.
White people hair doesn't naturally form dreads like black people. If you're white, you have to let it get really dirty and sweaty under a wool cap to get them going, which is pretty gross. I don't get it. I had a couple white friends with real dreads back in the day. They both stunk like hell, and one of them had to shave his head because his dreads were full of eggs.
You gotta admit that white boy does look a little weird with dreadlocks.
What is SFSU? I immediately think of shut the f*** up university...
It isn't her business how he wears his hair. To me, anyway.
SFSU = San Francisco State university. Its known in N. California for its radical (& often bizarre) student behaviour. Taking political correctness to a new extreme...
What a hoot!
Kids do stupid shit. That's an eternal truth. This woman? An employee? Put her hands on someone? Time for her to be fired and possibly prosecuted.
Clearly she wants his body ...
Or maybe just his dreadlocks?
Nasty hair styles aren't for one culture only. anyone can have bad hair.
Nasty hair styles aren't for one culture only. anyone can have bad hair.
In some parts of California its mandatory!
Nasty hair styles aren't for one culture only. anyone can have bad hair.
Which is why I smoke a cigar...so no one will notice my hair.
A cigar?
Yet just another case of "cultural appropriation"...this time of Cuban culture! (Castro should bring up your actions with Obama next time they meet!)
And here I thought you were just warding off mosquitoes... Seriously, Mrs. Ample Bottom, I like I your hair, AND your cigar!
You know I don't care what sex you are, she had no right to grab him. Had the situation been reversed, he would have been arrested for assault.
As for this cultural appropriation crap, It used to be considered a compliment to copy another cultures clothing, hairstyles, etc.
And I think she was culturally appropriating. That looks like she is wearing a Jewfro to me.
''That looks like she is wearing a Jewfro to me.'' oh no, here we go...LOL
And I think she was culturally appropriating. That looks like she is wearing a Jewfro to me.
"Of course she is. She's obviously Jewish. Dreadlocks are certainly a part of her culture-- they go way back. (LINK)
Takers of the Nazirite oath in the Book of Numbers display their devotion to their religion by not cutting their hair, and possibly letting it grow into dreadlocks. This vow required the man or woman to:
The vows described in this part of the bible has a significant impact on the Rastafari movement of the 20th century, and is the source of the Rastafari affection for dreadlocks.
Samson was a judge of the ancient Israelites mentioned in the Book of Judges in the Hebrew Bible and is usually depicted wearing dreadlocks.
(Link: Ancient portrayal of the Biblical Sampson as a Young Man)
According to the biblical account, Samson was given supernatural strength by God in order to combat his enemies and perform heroic feats [16] such as killing a lion, slaying an entire army with only the jawbone of an ass , and destroying a pagan temple . Samson's one weakness were his seven dreadlocks, which led to his death when they were cut off. These dreadlocks are particularly prominent in medieval European depictions. (LINK)
slaying an entire army with only the jawbone of an ass ,
To be fair though it was a fully automatic jawbone . Most ass jawbones can't be shut off once they have begun jawing ...
To be fair though it was a fully automatic jawbone .
Does the 2nd Amendment allow for fully automatic ass jawbones?
These events preceded the existence of the US ... So did ass jawbones .
Vertebrates have culturally appropriated their bones from life forms lower down on the evolutionary scale (unless you believe in creationism...but do we really want to go there?)
You do know that "culture" pertains to human beings only, don't you ?
Culture definition
You know I don't care what sex you are, she had no right to grab him. Had the situation been reversed, he would have been arrested for assault.
I agree. I was also rather surprised to learn that she was an employee of the university, and NOT a student. Had the roles been reversed, he would have been fired (and rightly so).
Shame on her for doing that. And lucky for him he just smoked a big fatty, otherwise his response to her physical aggression might not have been as mild-mannered as it was.
Agreed.
Hair is the least of this guys worries...where are the fashion police?
LOL Lynne!
My friend is Jewish/American Indian and wears her hair in a Jewfro with a braided pony tail with feather.
She also insists on being called a JIP. Kind of confuses some of us Indians, but we're a mellow group so we go with the flow.
Breakfast is always ordered at Jay's Diner where the world reknown chef, Chief Chef Boiling Water Goldstein invented the world famous ''kosher Winnebagel''...
This is a true story.
Hey! You never invited me... Humph!
So, where can we get a copy of the The Essential Ojibwe/Jewish/Italian/Mexican/Korean/Vegetarian/Aboriginal/Irish Cook Book?
Amazonian.coms?
How many Ojibwe/Jewish/Italian/Mexican/Korean/Vegetarian/Aboriginal/Irish people do you plan on cooking?
I'm sorry... I just don't eat people. That's where I draw the line!
I do...depending on how one defines the word..."eat"...
So do I, but in a very sexist way.
Naughty man! Hehehe
Sorry, it's not my title.....
It's Kav's title......
The Essential Ojibwe/Jewish/Italian/Mexican/Korean/Vegetarian/Aboriginal/Irish Cook Book
You catch where I suggested we purchase it? (or did you miss it?)
I, for one, doubt it's been written yet. Perhaps one should be?
Actually, the dishes he describes in that article sound pretty good, at least some of them do.....
Actually it has been written. In fact the latest printing (number 23) has added more new and delightful recipes..
In collaboration with the well knows Italian/Ojibwe Chef, NT's very own Nona we came up the classic II (Indian/Italian) dish.
Yes, it's called FRIZZA, a cross between pizza and fry bread...
I want to order some of that fry bread mix that was on the site your recommended! I hope it comes with complete directions!
I heard of that!
someone was telling me is was great for when your having a bad hair day....
I have some better questions.
Why is the guy in the tan coat wearing pink tights?
What is the white stuff in the two black individuals hair ?
Where is Egypt?
How do we know she is a campus employee?
I think the girl was very cute by the way.
Where is Egypt?
Wherever it is, de Nile is a river in it!
(A river runs through it )
So is this the Black Hair Matters "BHM" movement?
Good one PJ!
PJ,
LOL...but I think ALL hair matters!
When I was in Jr High and High school I picked my curly hair out into an afro. Looked damned good on me too. I never went anywhere without my pick to keep it in nice shape either. No one, white or black, ever told me that I couldn't have a 'fro because I'm white. People can wear their hair any way they want.
Of course my step-father hated it, but he was nearly bald so I think he was just jealous.
I also listened to a whole lot of Motown and soul music. Was that stealing someone's culture too?
Not as much as what Vanilla Ice did ...
That's true.
I am a little surprised no one noticed the body language and hand gestures of the white guy.
He appears to absolutely be "appropriating" "black" (urban) body language and hand movements. Not that I give a crap one way or the other, but he is trying to "act" black, at least to that extent.
John,
His behavior is nothing new. This phenom has been going on since the late 80's. No black person minded then (more often they laughed). What do you think Eminem was doing?
Most every male, black and white, in my school (Battle Creek Central) walked like George Jefferson from the TV show and that was in the early 1970's. No one seemed to mind that either. We called it pimpin'.
I didn't say it was anything new. The truth is, if he is trying to act black, as opposed to wearing a cool hairstyle, then he is "appropriating" . Personally I don't care if he appropriates or not, and I don't think the black girl should care either. But he is appropriating.
John,
As the young women in the video that followed, so colorfully pointed out, technically he didn't (dreads didn't come from Africa) and we all appropriate, as in Rock n Roll (from black Jazz) Country music (from Irish), jeans, from "96er's.. Frats from the Greeks.. the list is to long...
Where does this lunacy end?
Well, there are two parts to this - Did he "appropriate" ? and , Should anyone care if he did?
I think the answer to the first question is yes, for the reason I have given ( he has 'gangsta' body language and hand movements) and the answer to the second question is no.
You Tube and social media turn nothing into something. I also think the girl in the second video was no better than the ones in the first. She missed the other clues about the white kid as well.
Back in the day, black musical artists believed they were robbed of popularity, and thus money, by whites "appropriating" black music. Elvis was most famously accused of that, although the case was weak. Maybe I will start a thread about that one day.
The truth is, if he is trying to act black, as opposed to wearing a cool hairstyle, then he is "appropriating" . Personally I don't care if he appropriates or not, and I don't think the black girl should care either. But he is appropriating.
Or just wearing a cool hairstyle. I doubt it ever even crossed his mind that it might be a "black thing" and that it's just a new style he likes.
I doubt it ever even crossed his mind that it might be a "black thing"
You've got to be kidding.
Not at all. When I combed my hair into a 'fro I did it because I thought it looked cool (it really did) and it never really crossed my mind that it might be a black thing. I mean Art Garfunkel was wearing his hair in one. Bo Derek had dreadlocks and I doubt it crossed her mind that it might be a black thing (because it's not). They just looked good!
I'd grow it back out and get a new pick and have a 'fro again...except I am terrified of my wife....
Bo Derek had corn rows, not dreadlocks...
Not at all. When I combed my hair into a 'fro I did it because I thought it looked cool (it really did) and it never really crossed my mind that it might be a black thing. I mean Art Garfunkel was wearing his hair in one . . .
You didn't think an Afro was a black thing?
Not in my school it wasn't.
Not in my school it wasn't.
You all must have been really high in your high school. I should have gone there.
Well at the time, early 1970's, I went to an inner city High School and many white males wore 'fros. I know of no one, black or white, who thought of it in any kind of racial terms. It was simply just another hair style that some white males chose, like wearing your hair straight and long or short or whatever. I have very curly (and somewhat frizzy when it gets long) hair to begin with, so it was natural for me to choose to wear a 'fro (No one then, black or white, around me ever called them afros. Just 'fros.). I even kept my hair pick in it so I was already ready for touch ups. It was common enough that it simply never occurred to me that some people might think it was a black thing, especially since no one I knew ever thought or said so. It was much more of a time period thing then anything else.
And yes I was usually high in High School. Until I dropped out and then I was high in the Air Force.
No black person minded then (more often they laughed).
I seriously doubt if many of them care now either.
On social media today, everyone has an opinion, & isn't shy about posting it (Warning: NSFW language later in the video):
I like You Tube because there is a lot of music and educational material on there. Crap like these videos is a waste of time. I don't care what some girl thinks about what some other girl did in another video. Don't care.
Just to reiterate for clarity's sake. The white kid is trying to act black, although I suspect it is more subconscious than conscious. His body language and hand movements are a dead giveaway. So saying "dreadlocks are not an African or black thing" is somewhat immaterial here. They are to him, and that is what the confrontation was about anyway.
He likes the style, John. Just like the girl who accosted him likes skinny jeans. They are not part of her culture either. They belong to the LA crowd.
And if you are going to make an informed opinion, you should have watched both videos. It says a lot about the youth culture of today. I would know, since I have twin 21 year olds in university.
Perrie, the white kid has the body language and hand movements of a wannabe "gangsta" as he has seen in film or video. These movements originated in underclass urban areas, mostly black. Unless he hails from such an area, he is a poser in that sense.
I don't know what you mean about watching two videos. I watched three of them.
John,
LOL, I realize that and why should that matter to her or anyone else? Were you mad when blacks developed tap dancing from Irish High Stepping?
This is a much to do about nothing.
I think the young black woman in the video is silly. But I doubt if her attitude is all that prevalent. My guess is that most young people don't care about this issue all that much.
Recent polling showed that over half the country harbors racist tendencies in their thinking. If that is true we are talking about tens of millions of adults. That is a bigger problem than this collegiate "political correctness" epidemic.
There was a news story today about a study that was done of Trump voters who were also Evangelicals ( the most Christian , according to them) and the study determined that these Evangelical Trump voters were noticeably more racist than other people who were part of the study. How about them apples?
John,
This article isn't about Trump or his posse. It's about hypersensitive youth, or at least fake indignation.
BTW posse is an appropriated word.
I think the black girl in the video needs to chill.
Well, we have been hearing people like you accuse everyone else of being racist for so long that no one cares anymore.
And I know that such is an issue for people like you and causes people like you to ratchet up the rhetoric.
There are racial problem in this nation no doubt. But, pointing the accusatory finger is becoming the largest racial problem today in most peoples minds. Especially when such pointing is designed to instigate hate.
You ever hear the term blowback?
Cause that is what is beginning to happen. people are less concerned with racial stereotyping today than they are the hate mongering being perpetrated by the racist.
Of course according to your paradigm over half of America is racist.
It's not true, of course, but people are becoming much more discriminatory towards the race baiters.
It means that attitudes are changing.
And that is a good thing.
What is "hare mongering" ?
What is "hare mongering" ?
Its a form of being petty in political arguments. Obsessing about insignificant trivial thing. ("Playing the 'rabbit card'-- also known as "splitting hares"-- or "hare mongering"*)
_________________________________
*The term "hair" was originally culturally appropriated from the Ancient Gaelic "hare"-- i.e. "dreadlocks". Hence the term "Hare Mongering"!
*The term "hair" was originally culturally appropriated from the Ancient Gaelic "hare"-- i.e. "dreadlocks". Hence the term "Hare Mongering"!
in one of his more erudite tomes. Chomsky (yes, that Chomsky, of cunning linguist fame) has culturaLLy appropriated the phonemic "hair" from the ancient Polynesian "ha-re", or "dreadlock":
L ook O n M y W ords, Y e M ighty, A nd D espair !
Summarizing, then, we assume that the systematic use of complex symbols suffices to account for the system of base rules exclusive of the lexicon. Clearly, any associated supporting element cannot be arbitrary in irrelevant intervening contexts in selectional rules. It appears that most of the methodological work in modern linguistics appears to correlate rather closely with the extended c-command discussed in connection with (34). Of course, the notion of level of grammaticalness is not quite equivalent to the ultimate standard that determines the accuracy of any proposed grammar. For one thing, the descriptive power of the base component can be defined in such a way as to impose the requirement that branching is not tolerated within the dominance scope of a complex symbol.
You can create your own culturally appropriated & disturbingly pompous (but totally meaningless) faux-profound paragraphs using the "Chomskybot" --> (link)
[click on that link then just keep clicking on "next paragraph".
Of course according to your paradigm over half of America is racist.
It's not true, of course,
"According to a (2012) poll from the Associated Pres race relations in America have actually gotten worse since Obama took office. In 2008, the survey found that nearly 48% of people had a negative attitude toward African Americans. Today, that number sits at 51%.
Jon Krosnick, a Stanford University professor, said:
The survey measured “explicit racism” by asking respondents whether they agreed or disagreed with various statements about black and Hispanic people. The survey also measured “implicit racism” by quickly showing the respondent a photo of a black or Hispanic person before asking them questions about a “neutral” person. The study found that 56% of Americans expressed implicit racism, compared to 49% in 2008.
The survey comes out a day after a Colin Powell’s ex-chief of staff said that the GOP was full of racists.
Republican Lawrence Wilkerson said :
The Associated Press survey, however, racism was prevalent in both the Republican and Democratic parties. The survey found that 79% of Republicans expressed explicit racism and 65% expressed implicit racism. For Democrats, the 32% of the party expressed explicit racism and 55% expressed implicit racism."
Read more at
Again...
This article isn't about being racist. It's about the phenom of "cultural appropriation" on college campuses. Can we redirect??????
White people concern themselves too much with dismissing political correctness. It is not a big deal in a big picture.
John,
This has nada to do with PC. This has to do with a bully, pretending to be pissed off over "cultural appropriation, accosting a guy who has every right to dress as he feels (even if he looks like a freak), and the odd conditions on college campuses.
Cultural appropriation, seems like our college campuses are becoming more PC by the day. But we do know one thing, at least they learned to use a thesaurus.
The positive thing about this?, we KNOW they learned something. (now we gotta figure out what it is)
These movements originated in underclass urban areas, mostly black. Unless he hails from such an area, he is a poser in that sense.
Both my Jr High and High School were in areas like that. Part of so-called acting black was to fit it as a white kid. However even much, much more of it was an appreciation of the culture. A culture I had never been exposed to before that, since I grew up in a very rural area of Michigan until then. To me it opened up a whole new world of (incredibly great) music and dance and attitude that I had never known about and that I loved. Even all of these years later I still carry a lot of it inside of me and think I am a better person for it.
Both my Jr High and High School were in areas like that. Part of so-called acting black was to fit it as a white kid. However even much, much more of it was an appreciation of the culture. A culture I had never been exposed to before that, since I grew up in a very rural area of Michigan until then. To me it opened up a whole new world of (incredibly great) music and dance and attitude that I had never known about and that I loved. Even all of these years later I still carry a lot of it inside of me and think I am a better person for it.
OMG-- you're one of them! You are..a "cultural appropriator"! Who woulda thunk?
You are a genuine cultural appropriator-- on our beloved Newstalker site.You owe the entire black community an apology. You must apologize at once!
/sarc
Actually since all of humankind originated in Africa, everything is all of our culture. All of ours!
All their culture belong to us!
Although I know this is going to be considered WAY anti-PC and in fact racist, I couldn't help thinking when I read the title of this article that he missed the opportunity to respond to her that she shouldn't be wearing clothes because "it's his culture".
Bravo!
Good point.
BTW, I seem to remember learning in school that much of the U.S. Constitution is based on English Law. (I generally try to forget everything I earned in school since so much of it is sheer horsesh*t-- but occasionally some of it slips thru
Imagine-- the very basis of our nation is-- culturally appropriated! Therefore, we are a country of poseurs.
I wonder what sister would have to say about Michael Ballard?
His hair is straight, so it doesn't count, Sister.
I do know what an Indian would tell him. Hey you, wash and brush that hair, you look like you just crawled out of a manhole. If your gonna do it, do it right.
OMG, we went from light hearted commentary to a more serious vein in the flash of an eye.
There is such a thing as appropriating another culture, it's done quite often. This is not one of those cases. The guy looks like a dufus with a manic rat on his head. She is being an obnoxious ass.
I have not yet figured out the guy in the pink tights, what is he appropriating?
What about when the ''Mohawk'' hair style was popular with whites? Was that appropriating Indian culture. I suppose that you could say that, but to me it looked ridiculous on those non Mohawk that chose to wear it. Nothing more, nothing less.
The Mohawk style is so "last century" ...
Apparently not petey...
David Beckham
His excuse is that he's British ... which is itself inexcusable !
BTW :
David Beckham reveals Sir Alex Ferguson forced him to shave off famous mohawk - in Wembley toilets!
This is J.J. Watt. NFL MVP who plays for the Houston Texans. That is in America, petey.
JJ's a really good player. He got a little banged up at the end of the season. I saw Houston picked up Denver's quarter back - bet that didn't go over too well with Manning retiring.
I guess I don't keep up with the trends ...
Mohawks (and "Faux-Hawks, where the side of the head isn't shaved) and variations are also somewhat popular for woman, especially Black women. ( Pictures )
Ok Krish, this is the real deal.
Wait, that's Wes Studi, he isn't Mohawk, he's Cherokee...Oh, never mind us Indians all look alike.
Who would wear a bunch of battleships on their head anyway? Oh, you didn't mean dreadnoughts.
Actually, my Martin D28 was called a dreadnought as well.
Martin D28
THAT is a serious guitar.
It was made in 1959, back when they had genuine rosewood backs. It was too much to bring with me so I gave it to my son along with my similar vintage Gibson B45-12 (no tailpiece - exact model that Gord Lightfoot uses) - two very precious instruments.
Both rare, and highly sought for instruments. Many may assume that their value lies in their monetary value as antiques , but that is not the case. Both of these guitars in playing order would have a timbre and tone that cannot be had in modern instruments, even given if it is the same maker and model. I hope your son appreciates how wonderful they are!
Larry,
You're so spot on regarding the tone of the "vintage" guitars. Husband has a 1939 Martin 00-18 and it's like a fine wine!
Husband has a 1939 Martin 00-18 ...
Oh my; I'm having guitargasms.
"I hope your son appreciates how wonderful they are!"
He does.
This article highlights a number of problems. First of all, this woman has no right whatsoever to publicly chastise someone else for how they choose to dress or wear their hair. What gall!
Secondly, unlike cornrows which are uniquely African, dreadlocks are not exclusive to any particular continent. Yes, some Egyptians wore their hair in dreads but so did some in India, Europe, and the Middle East (Nazarites). Hair left on its own will naturally mat. The current iteration of dreads is "rooted" in Ethiopia, dating back to the coronation of Halie Selassie (Ras Tafari). It sparked a cult in Jamaica called Rastafarianism which has, as one of its beliefs, a view that the hair should not be cut or tainted with anything unnatural. Bob Marley was a Rastafarian and spread the style to the US along with his music. Some blacks adopted the hairstyle as a kind of cultural protest against copying white hair styles but they can't "own" it.
Third, if this woman wants to lecture somebody then she should lecture other black women for straightening their hair to imitate the texture and style of white people. I suggest she try it in the nearest ghetto. Grab another young black woman's arm with straightened hair and tell her that she is an embarrassment to the entire race . . . I bet she keeps her mouth shut after that if for no other reason than her lips are bruised and swollen.
My advice to this young woman is a) Get a Grip, and b) MYOB. She seems to be "power happy", and is misusing her status as a campus employee to tell the fellow what he can and can't do. Very immature.
After reviewing the video a couple of more times, I'm not sure this guy is white. In lieu of a DNA test we could ask him to jump or dance. If he can do neither, when we know that he's white.
His race has to be determined before we can continue this conversation.
That's who I've been missing.......where's Gunny? I haven't seen him. I hope he's just taking a break and nothings wrong.
The kid looked and acted like a juggalo, so he's wasting his time with the education thing. His future will likely involve standing in front of a deep fryer.
White people hair doesn't naturally form dreads like black people. If you're white, you have to let it get really dirty and sweaty under a wool cap to get them going, which is pretty gross. I don't get it. I had a couple white friends with real dreads back in the day. They both stunk like hell, and one of them had to shave his head because his dreads were full of eggs.