Tax Cheat Donald Trump May Owe The Government Two Billion Dollars
Absent Donald Trump's tax returns for the past 40 years, and knowing that in the 3 or 4 years where his tax information is known he paid ZERO in income tax, we can safely conclude that he owes Uncle Sam 2 B ig Ones. B illion that is.
Fortune magazine estimated his income at 180 million per, and at a 30% tax rate, that would make his tax bill 50 million per year. 40 years delinquent, that would be 2 billion owed. If we applied a penalty and charge interest on the debt, the bill could roughly double to 4 billion.
No wonder he doesnt want to release his taxes. When the public demanded payment, he would have to sell Trump Tower and all his golf courses to satisfy the tax man.
-------------------------------------------
related
"
If we make that assumption, then, how much has Trump avoided paying? A tax rate of $50 million multiplied by 38 years is $1.9 billion. Over the course of his career Trump has probably avoided paying somewhere in the neighborhood of 2 billion dollars, using loopholes and creative accounting that would be totally unavailable to the average American worker.
That is a lot of money. That kind of money would be a serious boon to the Department of Education ‘s effort to build new schools in New York City. That city has sustained Trump’s puffy brand for decades, while he has apparently given it back nothing in return.
The difficulty of quantifying Trump’s wealth and income highlights how bizarrely secretive he is. He wants the world to believe he’s a super-rich successful businessman, but he refuses to prove it. He readily admits that he does everything he can to dodge taxes, but won’t prove that his efforts are all aboveboard. He has pocketed billions of dollars over the decades of his career, but has done everything in his power to pay none of it forward to the nation that he wants to lead. Trump’s modus operandi is raking in the cash for himself, puffing himself up, and throwing up a veil of secrecy for everyone else. What exactly is presidential about that?"

Even he could not survive a revelation that he skipped out on 2 billion dollars in taxes.
Is he donating to his own charity to avoid paying taxes too? LMAO what happened to she/he has never been convicted? Only work one way does it?
Is he donating to his own charity to avoid paying taxes too? LMAO what happened to she/he has never been convicted? Only work one way does it?
You are woefully uninformed; he hasn't put any of his own money into his foundation for years and uses other peoples' money, in one instance, he may have paid a bribe to the AG of Florida who shortly after receiving $25,000 … backed out of joing the suit against Trump University.
I never bluff and always back my positions; feel free to rebut but don't double down on a falsehood.
Oh I specifically asked if he was. Because it is OK to donate to your own charity that all your friends and family work for to dodge taxes.
All the other discussions of Trump's finances aside, his debt load has grown dramatically over the last year, from $350 million to $630 million. This is in just one year while his liquid assets have also decreased. Trump has been blackballed by all major US banks.
Post-bankruptcy Trump has been highly reliant on money from Russia, most of which has over the years become increasingly concentrated among oligarchs and sub-garchs close to Vladimir Putin.
Here's a good overview from The Washington Post, with one morsel for illustration ...
Since the 1980s, Trump and his family members have made numerous trips to Moscow in search of business opportunities, and they have relied on Russian investors to buy their properties around the world.
“Russians make up a pretty disproportionate cross-section of a lot of our assets,” Trump’s son, Donald Jr., told a real estate conference in 2008, according to an account posted on the website of eTurboNews, a trade publication. “We see a lot of money pouring in from Russia.”
One example of this is the Trump Soho development in Manhattan, one of Trump's largest recent endeavors. The project was the hit with a series of lawsuits in response to some typically Trumpian efforts to defraud investors by making fraudulent claims about the financial health of the project. Emerging out of that litigation however was news about secret financing for the project from Russia and Kazakhstan. Most attention about the project has focused on the presence of a twice imprisoned Russian immigrant with extensive ties to the Russian criminal underworld. But that's not the most salient part of the story. As the Times put it,
"Mr. Lauria brokered a $50 million investment in Trump SoHo and three other Bayrock projects by an Icelandic firm preferred by wealthy Russians “in favor with” President Vladimir V. Putin, according to a lawsuit against Bayrock by one of its former executives. The Icelandic company, FL Group, was identified in a Bayrock investor presentation as a “strategic partner,” along with Alexander Mashkevich, a billionaire once charged in a corruption case involving fees paid by a Belgian company seeking business in Kazakhstan; that case was settled with no admission of guilt."
Another suit alleged the project "occasionally received unexplained infusions of cash from accounts in Kazakhstan and Russia."
After his bankruptcy and business failures roughly a decade ago Trump has had an increasingly difficult time finding sources of capital for new investments. Trump has been blackballed by all major US banks with the exception of Deutschebank, which is of course a foreign bank with a major US presence. He has steadied and rebuilt his financial empire with a heavy reliance on capital from Russia. At a minimum the Trump organization is receiving lots of investment capital from people close to Vladimir Putin.
Trump's tax returns would likely clarify the depth of his connections to and dependence on Russian capital aligned with Putin.
Paul Manafort, Trump's former 'campaign chair'/campaign manager and top advisor. Manafort spent most of the last decade as top campaign and communications advisor for Viktor Yanukovych, the pro-Russian Ukrainian Prime Minister and then President whose ouster in 2014 led to the on-going crisis and proxy war in Ukraine. Yanukovych was and remains a close Putin ally. Manafort ran Trump's campaign.
Trump's foreign policy advisor on Russia and Europe is Carter Page, a man whose entire professional career has revolved around investments in Russia and who has deep and continuing financial and employment ties to Gazprom. If you're not familiar with Gazprom, imagine if most or all of the US energy industry were rolled up into a single company and it were personally controlled by the US President who used it as a source of revenue and patronage. That is Gazprom's role in the Russian political and economic system. One cannot be involved with Gazprom at the very high level which Page has been without being wholly in alignment with Putin's policies. Those ties also allow Putin to put Page out of business at any time.
Over the course of the last year, Putin has aligned all Russian state controlled media behind Trump. This fits a pattern with how Putin has sought to prop up rightist/nationalist politicians across Europe, often with direct or covert infusions of money. In some cases this is because they support Russia-backed policies; in others it is simply because they sow discord in Western aligned states. Of course, Trump has repeatedly praised Putin, not only in the abstract but often for the authoritarian policies and patterns of government which have most soured his reputation around the world.
Trump's most conspicuous foreign policy statements track not only with Putin's positions but those in which Putin is most intensely interested. Aside from Ukraine, Trump's suggestion that the US and thus NATO might not come to the defense of NATO member states in the Baltics in the case of a Russian invasion is a case in point.
Tax avoidance is legal; tax evasion is not. The government is not a charity. Anybody in his right mind takes advantage of every provision and every loophole to legally pay as little in taxes as possible. If Trump has managed to legally pay zero taxes, then good for him. If Hillary pays more taxes than required, then she is a dope and will be no more responsible with other people's money than she is with her own.
Tax avoidance is legal; tax evasion is not. The government is not a charity. Anybody in his right mind takes advantage of every provision and every loophole to legally pay as little in taxes as possible. If Trump has managed to legally pay zero taxes, then good for him. If Hillary pays more taxes than required, then she is a dope and will be no more responsible with other people's money than she is with her own.
Yeah!
So, let's see TRUMP'S TAX RETURNS and settle this.
The state of New York (Atty Gen) has initiated today an investigation into the workings of the Trump Foundation.
So, let's see TRUMP'S TAX RETURNS and settle this.
Trump has already said that he's not releasing returns while they're being audited. No competent tax attorney would advise him to do otherwise.
Let's see his tax returns for every year prior to 2000 then. He hasn't paid any taxes since he got into the real estate business, has he?
Let's see his tax returns for every year prior to 2000 then. He hasn't paid any taxes since he got into the real estate business, has he?
If the IRS hasn't charged him with tax evasion, then I presume he's fine.
If the IRS hasn't charged him with tax evasion, then I presume he's fine.
And if he is personally INDEBTED TO RUSSIAN OLIGARCHS UNDER PUTIN'S INFLUENCE, "tax evasion" is not the issue … INDEBTEDNESS TO A HOSTILE GOVERNMENT'S LEADER -- ONE TRUMP CAN'T STOP PRAISING
… is the issue.
And if he is personally INDEBTED TO RUSSIAN OLIGARCHS UNDER PUTIN'S INFLUENCE, "tax evasion" is not the issue … INDEBTEDNESS TO A HOSTILE GOVERNMENT'S LEADER -- ONE TRUMP CAN'T STOP PRAISING
… is the issue.
Turn your evidence over to the FBI.
And if he is personally INDEBTED TO RUSSIAN OLIGARCHS UNDER PUTIN'S INFLUENCE, "tax evasion" is not the issue … INDEBTEDNESS TO A HOSTILE GOVERNMENT'S LEADER -- ONE TRUMP CAN'T STOP PRAISING
… is the issue.
Turn your evidence over to the FBI.
I can't; TRUMP WON"T RELEASE THE EVIDENCE.
Stop equivocating.
And for the record, I did not state, nor did I imply that being indebted to a hostile government is worthy of an investigation by the FBI.
What I am saying is that SUCH A CONFLICT OF INTERESTS COMPROMISES A PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE.
Can we have an actual discussion, my friend?
Turn your evidence over to the FBI.
I can't; TRUMP WON"T RELEASE THE EVIDENCE
If you're referring to his returns, then the IRS has them and they can refer it to the Justice Department if they see something illegal.
If you're referring to his returns, then the IRS has them and they can refer it to the Justice Department if they see something illegal.
I have already made the distinction between an illegality and a conflict-of-interests.
If you're referring to his returns, then the IRS has them and they can refer it to the Justice Department if they see something illegal.
I have already made the distinction between an illegality and a conflict-of-interests.
He's not going to release returns under audit, consistent with all competent legal advice I have seen and it doesn't matter to him whether that precludes an examination of illegality or a conflict-of-interest (assuming he has something in it that is traceable to Putin or an oligarch). How about this? The justice department can grant him blanket immunity from prosecution pertaining to any information publically disclosed on any return in a pending audit or any information disclosed in a prior return that impacts a pending audit.
Trump has already said that he's not releasing returns while they're being audited. No competent tax attorney would advise him to do otherwise.
Stop equivocating … let's see any/all of his returns that are NOT CURRENTLY UNDER AUDIT!
Why? Are you going to determine if he is a tax cheat, A Mac? Do you think the IRS investigates people? If they are interested, I'm sure they will and/or are doing a full audit on him. It would surprise me if he didn't get audited annually. What are you going to find that the IRS can't?
And the headline is silly. I could say that since JR hasn't released his tax records to us that he is a cheat and owes the government $600,000. Just more of the same.
Why? Are you going to determine if he is a tax cheat, A Mac? Do you think the IRS investigates people? If they are interested, I'm sure they will and/or are doing a full audit on him. It would surprise me if he didn't get audited annually. What are you going to find that the IRS can't?
I made it clear that I am not asserting nor implying that Trump is a tax cheat; he's made claims regarding his wealth and excuses alleging that an audit is preventing him from releasing his taxes. An audit does not preclude releasing his tax information … nor justify its delay as Trump has implied by saying he'll release it after the audit.
Wanting proof of an audit is fair game since Trump has made the assertion of such; and his business dealings with Russia along with his praise of Putin raise questions regarding the possible conflict-of-interests should he be elected.
Please don't mischaracterize my comments to mean other them what they state.
And the headline is silly. I could say that since JR hasn't released his tax records to us that he is a cheat and owes the government $600,000. Just more of the same.
You could … but JR isn't running for POTUS and consequently, from the standpoint of his taxes being potentially relative to national security, saying it would be an apples and oranges comparison vis a vis the comparative significance.
All the talk about Clinton lack-of-transparency while all the butt-covering regarding Trump's is hypocritical.
The headline is deliberately provocative. If Trump hasn't paid taxes in 40 years it would be a big deal no matter what the sum is.
People who don't pay taxes shouldn't be running for President. What is his "skin in the game?"
How many politicians did Trump bribe with the money he saved by paying zero taxes for 40 fucking years?
People who pay zero taxes have bribed the legislators to create the loopholes and laws that permit the zero taxes.
How is this fraud a man of the people and champion of the working man? Are you kidding?
Hate the game not the player. I'll leave the tax audit to the IRS.
People like him rig the game.
People like him rig the game
Then change the rules but, until they're changed, he can play by those rules to win.
If he helped rig the game he is RESPONSIBLE for the system, he is not a lucky bystander.
Hate the game not the player. I'll leave the tax audit to the IRS.
The "game" is not running for President, and, being audited DOES NOT PRECLUDE TRUMP FROM RELEASING HIS TAX RETURNS; And even if he insists on withholding his "under audit" return, ARE ALL HIS RETURNS FOR ALL YEARS CURRENTLY "UNDER AUDIT"?
Hate the game not the player. I'll leave the tax audit to the IRS.
The "game" is not running for President, and, being audited DOES NOT PRECLUDE TRUMP FROM RELEASING HIS TAX RETURNS; And even if he insists on withholding his "under audit" return, ARE ALL HIS RETURNS FOR ALL YEARS CURRENTLY "UNDER AUDIT"?
The game is at issue if the question is whether he's doing something illegal and if he's not, then he's free to pay as little in taxes as possible. Whether he's precluded from releasing his returns is irrelevant. The IRS doesn't preclude you from sticking your head in the toilet but it's not a good idea. And I have no idea whether the unaudited returns have a bearing on the audited ones. If they do, then I wouldn't release them either.
People who don't pay taxes shouldn't be running for President. What is his "skin in the game?"
I'd take it one step farther John. People who don't pay taxes shouldn't be voting for President.
Most people who don't pay income tax don't make enough money to pay income tax according to the tax schedules.
We don't punish the poor in this country by taking away their vote.
Where's their "skin in the game John"? You set the rules, if you've got no skin in the game then we take your political activity away from you; whether it's Trump running for President or Worthless Willie losing his vote.
I am not suggesting that people who don't pay taxes should run for president, am I?
If I were using your argument , I would be calling for the right to vote being taken away from Trump.
Why not? The right to run for office is just as important as the right to vote. If you're going to take one, then take both.
"People who pay zero taxes have bribed the legislators to create the loopholes and laws that permit the zero taxes."
Come on, John. Why do you want to damage your credibility with a statement like that?
Oh, should I say they influence the laws with campaign contributions? OK. I call it bribing.
Donald Trump is corrupt as the day is long. Only the willfully ignorant are avoiding learning that.
How Donald Trump retooled his charity to spend other people’s money
New York attorney general opens 'inquiry' into Trump Foundation
By LOUIS NELSON
09/13/16 06:40 PM EDT
Updated 09/13/16 07:06 PM EDT
'THE ONLY OPTION': Florida newspaper calls for federal investigation into Trump Foundation donation
Nice cut & paste!
Gee it is almost as bad as the Clinton foundation.
Gee it is almost as bad as the Clinton foundation.
Oh, it's much worse; the Clinton Foundation actually helps the sick and needy … the Trump Foundation uses other peoples' money to but $20,000 portraits of Trump!
Kurt Eichenwald @ kurteichenwald 5h 5 hours ago
My big cover story in @ Newsweek that could change the dialogue about this election season will be published online tomorrow.
Man, it feels like I'm shoveling manure out of the barn blocking all the anti-semites and racists who have suddenly appeared on this feed.
I can't believe I have to say this. Anyone making anti-semitic or racists comments on this feed will be immediately blocked.
I would really like it if Trump supporters who email me knew words other than those that can't be said on network television. Nasty people.
The basket of deplorables emailing me. Ive been called kike, jew boy, etc. Not that it matters, you Trump anti-semites, but I'm episcopal.
By the way … $25.00 wager for the American Cancer Society THAT THERE IS NO EVIDENCE THAT TRUMP'S TAX RETURN IS BEING AUDITED!
FIRST TAKER IS ON!
Tell ya' what; instead of producing his tax return, LET TRUMP PRODUCE A LETTER FROM THE IRS STATING THAT HIS RETURN(S) IS CURRENTLY UNDER AUDIT!
Let the equivocation begin.
NOTE: I'd love the opportunity to debate with any of you Trump supporters in a forum not in cyberspace, where there are neutral third party referees and a live audience.
I have been watching Lawrence O'Donnell on MSNBC and he just talked about this exact thing.
This morning the CNN anchor Alisyn Camerota asked Trump's campaign manager Kellyanne Conway if Trump will produce the letter he received from the IRS informing him that he was being put under audit. When Conway regained her composure she said to Camerota "are you calling him a liar"?
Mac, as we know, that is not an answer. If he doesn't produce this letter or some other proof he is under audit, we can assume that he is not.
Priceless... Trump 's campaign manager's jaw drops when asked to prove that Trump really is under IRS audit . #lastword
Priceless...Trump's campaign manager's jaw drops when asked to prove that Trump really is under IRS audit
I just watched that. I've got 2 words for her: Bim and bo.
Even if he got notice of the audit by telephone, there should be a confirmation letter.
I think the IRS informs them in writing. O'Donnell held up a copy of the form letter.
I think the IRS informs them in writing. O'Donnell held up a copy of the form letter.
I checked the IRS website and notice can be by letter or telephone but, if by telephone, there's a confirmation letter.
I think the IRS informs them in writing.
That is correct. In response to the over-abundance of email and phone scams, the IRS no longer uses those methods to notify tax-payers of important information regarding their accounts.
Notice can be by telephone (but it's confirmed by letter).
That should be clarified. They will send the letter first and follow up with a phone call, not the other way around.
That should be clarified. They will send the letter first and follow up with a phone call, not the other way around.
According to their website, they can notify you by letter OR they can notify you by phone and confirm by letter.
After reading a bit, I can see what Trumps's doing. Trump has no letter for a current audit. According to his attorneys in their own letter earlier this year, Trump's tax returns have been audited every year since 2002 as a standard practice because his returns are so large. His attorneys also stated that it's all part of one continuous audit so earlier years and later years are interrelated. A continuous tax audit is an interesting argument because that means he will never release his returns. If people want him to see his returns that badly, then he should be granted prosecutorial immunity so that he's not at risk by satisfying inquiring minds. It's similar to taking the fifth amendment by refusing to incriminate myself. If you want me to talk, then give me immunity from prosecution. Otherwise, I'm not talking.
If people want him to see his returns that badly, then he should be granted prosecutorial immunity so that he's not at risk by satisfying inquiring minds. It's similar to taking the fifth amendment by refusing to incriminate myself. If you want me to talk, then give me immunity from prosecution. Otherwise, I'm not talking.
lol. Any presidential candidate who would take the fifth should just give up.
I assume the IRS sends Trump a letter every time the audit expands to a new year. The media really needs to press the issue and stop pussyfooting with Donald Trump. They are embarrassing themselves.
If people want him to see his returns that badly, then he should be granted prosecutorial immunity so that he's not at risk by satisfying inquiring minds. It's similar to taking the fifth amendment by refusing to incriminate myself. If you want me to talk, then give me immunity from prosecution. Otherwise, I'm not talking.
I highly recommend re-thinking that particular argument, especially if you plan on running for office some day.
I highly recommend re-thinking that particular argument, especially if you plan on running for office some day.
And I highly recommend listening to your tax attorney, not your opponent, when deciding whether to make a return public.
I assume the IRS sends Trump a letter every time the audit expands to a new year.
Not exactly. They can skip a year or more and then notify you of their intent to audit past years.
There is something in Trump's taxes that he believes will cost him the election. That much we know. Either he is not as rich as people believe, he doesn't pay any taxes, or he gives nothing to charity, or all three. Trump has said that he knows that if he puts out his tax returns it will hurt him badly. There have been 21 other presidential candidates in a row (not counting 3rd parties) that have released their tax returns. The only reason for him not doing it is because there is very damaging information in them.
I don't care whether he releases his returns or not. There is absolutely nothing in his returns that could possibly give me a lower opinion of him. Same goes for Hillary and her $225,000 a pop speeches, the substance of which she keeps secret.
There is absolutely nothing in his returns that could possibly give me a lower opinion of him.
Not the point; all the callings out of Hillary for being a liar … let's see if Trump is being truthful about the audit, his sources of income …
Fair-is-fair.
There is absolutely nothing in his returns that could possibly give me a lower opinion of him.
Not the point; all the callings out of Hillary for being a liar … let's see if Trump is being truthful about the audit, his sources of income …
Fair-is-fair.
Fairness is not at issue. Nobody else is a party to his tax audit other than the IRS and his goal in the audit should be justifying his return to the IRS, not the public. If he's under an audit, then it makes sense for him to listen to his tax attorneys (not his opponent or the press) and decline to release his returns (pursuant to standard advice from any competent tax attorney).
All TRUMP needs to do to clear up the audit claim, is to PUBLICLY authorize the IRS to release the AUDIT NOTIFICATION IN ANY/ALL OF ITS VARIOUS FORMS … TO ALL MEDIA OUTLETS.
Easy, huh?
And BTW, this morning TRUMP reneged on release his medical reports/records on the Dr. Oz show.
Dr. OZ …
Just release the tax returns that are not under audit. Simple enough.
Sure he owes 2 billion. Just like Harry Reid lied about Romney not paying taxes and then justifying his lie after the election by saying "he lost, didn't he."
Sure he owes 2 billion. Just like Harry Reid lied about Romney not paying taxes and then justifying his lie after the election by saying "he lost, didn't he."
Not the point … there is a possibility of ties to Putin-supporting oligarchs to whom TRUMP is financially indebted.
You boys have no trouble alleging the Clinton Foundation has conflicts-of-interests … but you equivocate endlessly about a more potentially serious issue.
There is a difference. We know Clinton worked for Putins oligarchs after accepting a seven figure donation to the Clinton foundation. See the uranium mine agreement ratified by her state department. Trumps connections are more theoretical.
as usual, liberals are upset that Trump might do the type of things we already know Clinton has done.
There is a difference. We know Clinton worked for Putins oligarchs after accepting a seven figure donation to the Clinton foundation. See the uranium mine agreement ratified by her state department. Trumps connections are more theoretical.
WRONG ON SEVERAL LEVELS!
NOT TRUE! What you think "we" know!
The author of “Clinton Cash” falsely claimed Hillary Clinton as Secretary of State had “veto power” and “could have stopped” Russia from buying a company with extensive uranium mining operations in the U.S. In fact, only the president has such power.
At the time of the sale, Clinton was a member of the Committee on Foreign Investments in the United States , which is required by law to investigate all U.S. transactions that involve a company owned or controlled by a foreign government. Federal guidelines say any one of nine voting members of the committee can object to such a foreign transaction, but the final decision then rests with the president.
“Only the President has the authority to suspend or prohibit a covered transaction,” the guidelines say.
Through a spokeswoman, author Peter Schweizer told us he meant that Clinton could have forced the issue to the president’s desk. But that’s not what he said when he appeared on “ Fox News Sunday ,” where he discussed the uranium deal and his upcoming book to be released on May 5 .
Schweizer’s book — “Clinton Cash: The Untold Story of How and Why Foreign Governments and Businesses Helped Make Bill and Hillary Rich” — focuses on foreign donations to the Clinton Foundation, a nonprofit created by former President Bill Clinton. In his book, Schweizer, a former fellow at the right-leaning Hoover Institution, seeks to link some of those donations to the official actions taken by Clinton when she was Secretary of State .
The New York Times , which received an advance copy of the book, wrote an article April 23 that said the Clinton Foundation failed to publicly disclose millions in contributions it received from investors who stood to profit from the sale of Uranium One, a Canadian-based company with uranium mining stakes in the West, to Rosatom, the Russian nuclear energy agency. The Times said its article “built upon” Schweizer’s reporting.
That sale was approved by the Committee on Foreign Investments in the United States in October 2010, giving Russia control over 20 percent of uranium production in the United States, according to the Times .
The book in general and the Times article in particular have stirred up the 2016 presidential campaign. The Clinton Foundation was forced to acknowledge that it “ made mistakes ” in failing to disclose some of its donations, and Republicans have questioned Hillary Clinton’s role in the sale. Mitt Romney said the money donated to the Clinton Foundation “looks like bribery,” and Sen. Rand Paul called for an investigation.
But Schweizer and the Times presented no evidence that the donations influenced Clinton’s official actions.
The fact is, Clinton was one of nine voting members on the foreign investments committee, which also includes the secretaries of the Treasury, Defense, Homeland Security, Commerce and Energy, the attorney general, and representatives from two White House offices — the United States Trade Representative and the Office of Science and Technology Policy. (Separately, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission needed to approve ( and did approve ) the transfer of two uranium recovery licenses as part of the sale.)
Chris Wallace, host of “Fox News Sunday,” made that point when he questioned Schweizer about his lack of evidence connecting the donations to the uranium deal. (Fox News was among the media outlets that received an advance copy of his book.) Schweizer made the counterargument — again without any evidence — that the investors bought her silence by making contributions to the Clinton Foundation .
Schweizer speculated that investors were worried about Clinton’s history of opposing the sale of “critical assets” in the U.S., citing her opposition as a senator to the 2006 sale of six U.S. ports to Dubai Ports World, a state-owned business in the United Arab Emirates.
But Schweizer is wrong when he says that Clinton had “veto power” and “could have stopped the deal.” At best, she could have forced the president to make a decision.
The committee, which is known by its acronym CFIUS, can approve a sale, but it cannot stop a sale. Only the president can do that, and only if the committee recommends or “any member of CFIUS recommends suspension or prohibition of the transaction,” according to guidelines issued by the Treasury Department in December 2008 after the department adopted its final rule a month earlier .
Even the president cannot prohibit a transaction without “credible evidence” that the “foreign interest exercising control might take action that threatens to impair the national security,” according to the regulation.
We emailed Schweizer’s publicist with links to the CRS report and the regulation that governs the committee’s work. Schweizer responded through the publicist: “By veto I mean halt the deal and advance their concerns to the President.” He also noted that Clinton was the only committee member who had a family foundation that received donations from the investors in the uranium deal.
But Schweizer is trafficking in speculation.
Very little is known about the Uranium One-Rosatom deal or Clinton’s role in it. That’s because the law has “strong confidentiality requirements,” as Treasury explains on its site. “By law, information filed with CFIUS is subject to strong confidentiality requirements that prohibit disclosure to the public. Accordingly, CFIUS does not disclose whether parties to any transaction have filed notices with CFIUS, nor does CFIUS disclose the results of any review,” Treasury says. “When a transaction is referred to the President, however, the decision of the President is announced publicly.”
The Clinton campaign told the Times that generally these matters did not reach the secretary’s level, so she may not have been involved at all. According to the Times , Jose Fernandez, a former assistant secretary of state , represented the department on the committee. He told the Times : “Mrs. Clinton never intervened with me on any C.F.I.U.S. matter.”
Schweizer raises legitimate questions about the Clinton Foundation and its donations. He simply goes too far when he says Clinton had “veto power” and “could have stopped” the uranium deal.
— Eugene Kiel
__________________________________
Yeah! Copied and pasted! You post a declarative sentence that is factually incorrect and I post the whole story debunking your assertion.
Don't like long, factual rebuttals, boys? Then don't post falsehoods in summary form.
That's a long way of arguing whether she had actual veto power. She still took the money from Putin and supported the arrangement. Arguing semantics over what Peter Schweitzer said doesn't rebut what she actually did.
Look at the New York Times about what Clinton actually did, based on their own reporting:
"the sale gave the Russians control of one-fifth of all uranium production capacity in the United States. Since uranium is considered a strategic asset, with implications for national security, the deal had to be approved by a committee composed of representatives from a number of United States government agencies. Among the agencies that eventually signed off was the State Department, then headed by Mr. Clinton’s wife..
As the Russians gradually assumed control of Uranium One in three separate transactions from 2009 to 2013, Canadian records show, a flow of cash made its way to the Clinton Foundation. Uranium One’s chairman used his family foundation to make four donations totaling $2.35 million.
Those contributions were not publicly disclosed by the Clintons, despite an agreement Mrs. Clinton had struck with the Obama White House to publicly identify all donors. Other people with ties to the company made donations as well.
And shortly after the Russians announced their intention to acquire a majority stake in Uranium One, Mr. Clinton received $500,000 for a Moscow speech from a Russian investment bank with links to the Kremlin that was promoting Uranium One stock...
Before Mrs. Clinton could assume her post as secretary of state, the White House demanded that she sign a memorandum of understanding placing limits on the activities of her husband’s foundation. To avoid the perception of conflicts of interest, beyond the ban on foreign government donations, the foundation was required to publicly disclose all contributors.
To judge from those disclosures — which list the contributions in ranges rather than precise amounts — the only Uranium One official to give to the Clinton Foundation was Mr. Telfer, the chairman, and the amount was relatively small: no more than $250,000, and that was in 2007, before talk of a Rosatom deal began percolating.
PhotoBut a review of tax records in Canada, where Mr. Telfer has a family charity called the Fernwood Foundation, shows that he donated millions of dollars more, during and after the critical time when the foreign investment committee was reviewing his deal with the Russians. With the Russians offering a special dividend, shareholders like Mr. Telfer stood to profit.
His donations through the Fernwood Foundation included $1 million reported in 2009, the year his company appealed to the American Embassy to help it keep its mines in Kazakhstan; $250,000 in 2010, the year the Russians sought majority control; as well as $600,000 in 2011 and $500,000 in 2012. Mr. Telfer said that his donations had nothing to do with his business dealings, and that he had never discussed Uranium One with Mr. or Mrs. Clinton. He said he had given the money because he wanted to support Mr. Giustra’s charitable endeavors with Mr. Clinton. “Frank and I have been friends and business partners for almost 20 years,” he said.
The Clinton campaign left it to the foundation to reply to questions about the Fernwood donations; the foundation did not provide a response.
Mr. Telfer’s undisclosed donations came in addition to between $1.3 million and $5.6 million in contributions, which were reported, from a constellation of people with ties to Uranium One or UrAsia, the company that originally acquired Uranium One’s most valuable asset: the Kazakh mines. Without those assets, the Russians would have had no interest in the deal: “It wasn’t the goal to buy the Wyoming mines. The goal was to acquire the Kazakh assets, which are very good,” Mr. Novikov, the Rosatom spokesman, said in an interview.
Amid this influx of Uranium One-connected money, Mr. Clinton was invited to speak in Moscow in June 2010, the same month Rosatom struck its deal for a majority stake in Uranium One.
The $500,000 fee — among Mr. Clinton’s highest — was paid by Renaissance Capital, a Russian investment bank with ties to the Kremlin that has invited world leaders, including Tony Blair, the former British prime minister, to speak at its investor conferences.
Bill and Hillary, bought by Russian oligarchs.
You've already changed your position, Sean. And the Times story was based on the Schweitzer book.
As cited in my comment …
The Clinton campaign told the Times that generally these matters did not reach the secretary’s level, so she may not have been involved at all. According to the Times , Jose Fernandez, a former assistant secretary of state , represented the department on the committee. He told the Times : “Mrs. Clinton never intervened with me on any C.F.I.U.S. matter.”
Schweizer raises legitimate questions about the Clinton Foundation and its donations. He simply goes too far when he says Clinton had “veto power” and “could have stopped” the uranium deal.
But at least you and I are having a discussion and I respect that, and you for doing so.
It's true that only Obama could have vetoed the deal but that doesn't remotely get Hillary off the hook. Hillary was one of nine agency heads who could have each independently objected to the deal. She said nothing and that, in and of itself, could have been the quid pro quo. Specifically, if I wanted to extort $500,000 from the Russians in the form of a gift to the foundation, then I would say "As you know, I'm married to the Secretary of State and she has one of nine seats on the CFIUS. She could object to the deal like this but might not if you donate $500,000 to our foundation. She will forget to disclose the conflict-of-interest created by this transaction and nobody else will know about it so everything will be fine. You get control of significant uranium resources in the US and we get cash. Now if you don't donate, I can't promise what my wife will do when this matter crosses her desk."
Well said. It's just empty muckraking. Harry was a disgrace.
I read the article and most of the comments. Including the article and comments, I couldn't find a smidgen of evidence for any of the accusations.
The issue of "Tax Cheat" is NOT THE ISSUE AT ALL; the ISSUE IS, THE ONLY DOCUMENTS THAT WILL REVEAL TRUMP'S BUSINESS DEALINGS, PARTNERS, INDEBTEDNESS AND OWED FAVORS, TRUTH REGARDING CHARITABLE CONTRIBUTIONS AND CONFLICTS OF INTERESTS THAT COULD COMPROMISE AMERICA IF HE WINS …
… are his tax returns.
Why is it that anything that lacks transparency regarding Clinton is assumed nefarious, while Trump conceals virtually all important information about his dealings … and his supporters merely accept that he's clean and turn a blind eye?
One either wants to know the facts, or one doesn't deem facts relevant as long as the bullshit works for him.
I hate equivocators and apologist sycophants.
Put it all out there and let everyone decide on the information … not the bullshit!
All candidates, all parties, all elections.
AMac, I'm not saying he is clean as a whistle. There are a lot of people who already seem to know everything, but I haven't seen a shred of evidence. That's what the article is about.
Have you seen Hillay's tax returns? I mean after the Comey thing, they may have just decided to give her another get out of jail pass. I mean there is evidence there, plenty of it.
AMac, I'm not saying he is clean as a whistle. There are a lot of people who already seem to know everything, but I haven't seen a shred of evidence. That's what the article is about.
I already stated the issue is not whether or not he's a tax cheat … again …
The issue of "Tax Cheat" is NOT THE ISSUE AT ALL; the ISSUE IS, THE ONLY DOCUMENTS THAT WILL REVEAL TRUMP'S BUSINESS DEALINGS, PARTNERS, INDEBTEDNESS AND OWED FAVORS, TRUTH REGARDING CHARITABLE CONTRIBUTIONS AND CONFLICTS OF INTERESTS THAT COULD COMPROMISE AMERICA IF HE WINS …
… are his tax returns.
Have you seen Hillay's tax returns? I mean after the Comey thing, they may have just decided to give her another get out of jail pass. I mean there is evidence there, plenty of it.
I posted links in a previous thread to the many years of returns she and her husband have released: YES I HAVE SEEN THEM … I'll find them and post them again.
Comey did not prosecute based on a 99 year old standard that requires INTENT to commit acts such as treason … in order to prosecute.
I'll go find the Clinton tax returns and post the links.
Here, tax returns and more.
Clinton documents
Hillary Clinton’s medical information , released on September 14th, 2016
Hillary Clinton’s medical information , released on July 28th, 2015
Hillary Clinton 2013 speech income
President Clinton 2013 speech income
2015 tax return
2014 tax return
2014 signature page
2013 tax return
2013 signature page
2012 tax return
2012 signature page
2011 tax return
2011 signature page
2010 tax return
2010 signature page
2009 tax return
2008 tax return
TIME FOR TRUMP TO LET THE PUBLIC DETERMINE THE SIGNIFICANCE OF HIS DEALINGS.
I never bluff when taking a position.
How do we know Hillary disclosed her actual returns? There's nothing that requires disclosure so disclosing fake returns may not violate anything and the IRS can't comment on what was actually filed.
How do we know Hillary disclosed her actual returns? There's nothing that requires disclosure so disclosing fake returns may not violate anything and the IRS can't comment on what was actually filed.
This kind of comment makes me consider quitting NT.
I agree Mac. Ridiculous conspiracy thinking makes a farce out of the forum, and there is zero peer pressure to prevent it.
Hillary has a well-deserved reputation for being untrustworthy so I'm not about to take her word for anything. So my question stands. How do I know her return (or Trumps's for that matter) isn't fake?
What I hate is for you to go to all that effort. I didn't mean you had to do any of that at all, because the short of it is if Trump's tax returns are that important to you to see and you don't get to see them, just don't vote for him.
I've said it far too long when the "Stand By Your Man" in spite or regardless of what was doing was beyond his authority, no one seemed to care as long as they were getting what they wanted.
I've said that position would come back and bite those people in the ass one day. It appears setting the precedence for future presidents by over stepping his authority is moving right along.
Do I like it now? No more than I did then.
There's no use continuing on this. Trump will either produce his taxes or he won't. I don't recall any law saying he has to do so.
At least Trump can produce them If he wants to produce the taxes. Hillary can never produce all those emails she bleached out and we don't know if she can be bribed from some unknown hack job.