Disconnect ... ... by Bob Nelson
NewsTalkers' "Newest Discussions" page is frightening. A flood of "Trump is great!" encounters a barrage of "Trump is an idiot!" How can thinking creatures have such radically opposed positions? They cannot both be right.
We "know" very little, in the sense of having observed it under conditions sufficiently controlled to permit valid conclusions. We say "I 'know'..." but in fact, we most often are repeating something we heard from a source we consider reliable. In reality, we "believe" it, rather than "know" it.
None of us has ever seen an atom, but we "know" they exist... because our science teachers taught us about them, and we never hear any contradictions. We even "know" some things that are counter-intuitive: the Earth circles the Sun, although it certainly appears to be the opposite. We do not actually "know" these things; we "believe" them. Being intellectual slobs, we use "believe" and "know" pretty much interchangeably. Which leads to some very strange semantic constructions like "belief in science"...
As long as we hear only one story, we believe it. We even "know" it.
But when we hear two different tales... we must choose. And very often, we are not really competent to choose. Neither you nor I (nor, probably, anyone either of us is acquainted with) is a geologist or astrophysicist. Neither you nor I "knows" much about stratification or the expansion of the universe. We have no personally observed data, and we do not have the training needed to interpret such data, even if we had any.
Since we -- each of us -- is incompetent to "know" the age of the Earth, we must rely on "trusted sources" to tell us what to believe . In America today, there are basically two sources for this question: science or the Bible. Science says "Earth roughly four billion years, universe roughly 13 billion", while the Bible (or rather preachers who claim to have found their "knowledge" in the Bible, which does not in fact say a single word on the topic) says six thousand years for both. Big difference. Very big.
For people who believe that the Bible is inerrant, there is no "choice", here. They must believe that the world is six thousand years old. To believe otherwise would be to put all their beliefs in peril, because all their beliefs are based on Biblical inerrancy. Remove any stone from that edifice and it must all collapse, even their belief in God. So of course they hang on to Young Earth with desperation. Their belief is determined by their choice of "trusted source". (Personally, I believe in God and in Christ... but not in an inerrant Bible... so I have none of their worries. But that's a different topic!)
Meanwhile, most people accept the mass of evidence from various scientific domains (from astronomy to zoology) that disproved Young Earth, beginning almost two centuries ago...
And then... some of those same people who would not imagine disputing the reality of a multi-billion-year-old universe... are prompt to refuse other scientific results. AGW is agreed upon by a near-unanimous majority of climate scientists, but many non-experts simply reject it. Where climate is concerned, they do not consider science to be reliable. They find their "trusted sources" elsewhere. There are plenty of web sites that argue that AGW is not true, so alternative "trusted sources" are easy to find.
So... when there are candidates for "trusted source" that disagree... how do we decide?
Well... We generally prefer to hear things that we agree with, rather than things we do not agree with. Duh.
In fact... studies have proved that we would rather hear a pleasing falsehood than a disagreeable truth. Flattery is an obvious case. Flattery applies not only to physical appearance but at least as powerfully to ideas. "What a clever idea, sir!"
This turns the logic of "trusted sources" on its head! We end up trusting a source because it tells us what we want to hear, rather than what is true. Our "trusted sources" become untrustworthy... because of us .
The world is not always as we would wish. Sometimes reality is not what we would like it to be. So if our "trusted sources" always tell us what we want to hear, they must sometimes lie to us. Then again, sometimes the world is exactly as we would like it to be, so our "trusted sources" can tell us the truth. Thus, our "trusted sources" may tell us incoherent things... because our intimate desires are incoherent.
What does all this mean for conversation on NewsTalkers?
It means that no adult ever persuades another to change their mind. Never. So arguing in the hope of "convincing the other that they're wrong and they should change their mind" is pure hooey. Ain't gonna happen. Waste of time tryin'.
Unless...
I've said that we choose our "trusted sources" according to whether they tell us what we want to hear. But that raises a different question: where does "what we want to hear" come from? It comes from childhood. From the standards that we were inoculated with when we were little. Those standards stay with us for all our lives, rarely changing very much. Kids who were told that the government is bad grow into adults who think the government is bad. Pure visceral opinion... no facts needed or accepted.
Fundamentally, people can be divided into those who think in terms of "us", and those who think in terms of "me". If two people disagree on policy -- any policy -- and take the time to dig into why they feel as they do, they will almost always come to this point: one solution is for "us"; the other is for "me".
So if a conversation reveals that the opinion a person holds is not in fact the best expression of their visceral desires, then we may convince them to move to a position that better fits their visceral need. Example: I used to be opposed to gay marriage because for me marriage means raising children (necessarily adopted in a gay couple). I wondered if having both parents of the same sex would be problematic for the kids. (Full disclosure: my parents had an acrimonious divorce, so for me, it's "Priority to the kids!") An online conversation partner supplied me with reams of unassailable data showing that kids with parents of the same sex are just fine. Since there was no more impediment, I became a supporter of gay marriage. I did not change my bedrock position, but I applied it differently to the real world.
This is where conversation is fun. Digging through layers of inconsequential fluff to reach our bedrock motives. Learning why others feel as they do, and how those feelings are intellectualized into "opinion". Only when this work has been done is there any chance of showing a person that they are violating their own precepts, and therefore should... change their mind!
Patience, patience...
-----------------------------------
RED RULES apply:
Be polite
No insults whatsoever. No insults to particular people, to groups of people, to ideas, ... None!
Be smart and stay on-topic
Contribute substantive thought. Facts and/or reasoning.
One-line zingers and bumper-sticker mantras are by definition off-topic and will be deleted.

RED RULES apply:
- Be polite. No insults whatsoever. No insults to particular people, to groups of people, to ideas, ... None!
- Be smart and stay on topic. Contribute substantive thought. Facts and/or reasoning. One-line zingers and bumper-sticker mantras are by definition off-topic, and will be deleted.
It means that no adult ever persuades another to change their mind. Never. So arguing in the hope of "convincing the other that they're wrong and they should change their mind" is pure hooey. Ain't gonna happen. Waste of time tryin'.
Unless...
I don't make comments to try and change anyone's mind. I make them to express a point of view.
Bob, a number of times now in various articles you have "insisted" on people explaining their motivations for comments to you. Evidently you think that is the most interesting this about the forum.
Other people don't.
I make them to express a point of view.
Ok. NT is an open tribune.
But if there's no chance of changing anyone's opinion, what's the point?
But if there's no chance of changing anyone's opinion, what's the point? Changing someone else's opinion?
Intriguing idea-- I wonder what are the odds of doing that (on this site)...????
Krishna,
Changing anyone's opinion? On this site?
Not just on this site. Your Uncle George, too!
We can, however, dig down to (mutually) discover the bedrock imprinted-in-childhood values that we intellectualize into "rational" arguments at a conscious level. That's pretty good!
I don't make comments to try and change anyone's mind. I make them to express a point of view.
Same here. I have no hope that people who hold views that are opposite of mine will change because of what I have to say and I know I won't because of what they say. I am here simply to put out what I want to say and to present an opposing point of view.
I personally don't think you can change anyone's mind, unless they want to. I mean really.. is there anything I could say that would change your mind? I doubt it.
Adults rarely change their minds on fundamental topics. The only circumstance is when they realize that they have been wrongly applying their bedrock values.
Also, there may be conflict between basic values. "Standard Conservatism" includes both anti-abortion and pro-gun stances. That may be cognitive dissonance for some folks.
Perhaps I am an outlier, but much of my core belief systems have dramatically changed as a result of my interactions on the internet, and most of that is due to such a wide range of learning opportunities, many proffered by fellow bloggers. Including you Bob; so, thank you!
much of my core belief systems have dramatically changed as a result of my interactions on the internet
I envy you! I always wonder if my brain is completely calcified.
I can point directly at you and a few others who have helped me evolve. Krishna, Kavika, and kpr37; or, the big three "K's" as I call them, Jonathan,Buzz, Petey, Perrie and John Russell have all challenged my perceptions, and drove me to either defend my intellectual choices, or explain away the disconnect between my beliefs and the reality around me. The result is that I am growing, and for that I am truly grateful.
I too have been moved by the vast knowledge possessed by the astute intellectuals on this site and a few others.
I see you. Perrie will, too, eventually. You'll last longer if you stay away from me.
Nice to meet you too.
I'm pretty sure that we've met before.
Do you know Earl and Margaret from Beeville?
Or is it Effville?
...and then there are those who remind me that a keyboard and internet connection, do not necessarily mean that there is a worthwhile intellect or spirit behind them...
I couldn't agree more, excellent comment.
How many times will Perrie have to ban you before you understand?
I've never been banned, you must be confused. Can we get back on topic now and discuss the article? I'd like that very much.
kpr37
Uh-Oh!
Wherever did kpr37 disappear to?
Wherever did KPR37 disappear to?
To the same place where all the others have gone...
That's a loss for NT.
As are they all. Did you know that Ambivalent is gone, too?
No I didn't. That's unfortunate, because she was active in the groups, which is what this site needs more of.
"Jonathan,Buzz, Petey, Perrie and John Russell have all challenged my perceptions"
I'm not a Challenger, I just Dodge about.
That's awful!
You should be ashamed! 😁
Adults rarely change their minds on fundamental topics. The only circumstance is when they realize that they have been wrongly applying their bedrock values.
I think that's true for most adults.
Not that its all that important, I myself do change my mind-- fairly frequently.
(That's because of my personality type-- according to the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator-- AKA the "MBTI"). I've learned about it recently--I learned a lot from it. (Like most systems of classifying personality, it does have its flaws-- but I found it can also provide valuable insights). I will seed an article about it when I get a chance.
I will seed an article about it when I get a chance.
Please do. I did a quick Google search on MBTI and it sounds interesting... but your personal experience would have a lot more meaning.
How many psychologists does it take to change a light bulb?
None.
It has to want to change.
Isn't there always the implicit hope that someone will change their mind? I try to design most of my comments to get people to think about their initial statements and defend them in a logical manner. My least hope is to get people to think about their statements rather than just dismiss the antogonist. Doesn't seem to be working though. I persist nonetheless.
Emotion trumps reason. I suspect this is something that all atheists are keenly aware of.
I hear ya Hal, but think there is more there than that. Our reasoning is at times suspect, and that is often due to misinformation rather than reliance on emotional evaluations. What is present in our reasoning that allows for us to be told and then believe an untruth? It isn't always emotion that drives us to accept something untrue as being true; a lot of times we believe we have made logical conclusions only to be proved wrong. Is accepting a lie as the truth always a result of of our emotions trumping our reasoning; or, simply a mistake? Personally I think it goes much deeper than that. Imho our inability to reason precisely is a direct result of being disconnected from full relationship with nature and each other. If we had a more healthy relationship with the realty we live in, we would make drastically better choices.
What is present in our reasoning that allows for us to be told and then believe an untruth?
I respectfully request to not be included in that 'us' reference. My brain is influenced more by cynicism than emotion.
The other day I seeded an article about an environmental situation in CA, where a farmer was fined for inadvertently 'damaging' wetlands. Liberals responded in unapologetic support of the environment, conservatives responded in unapologetic support of extreme deregulation. I responded with reasonable cynicism, calling it an honest case of government overreach, and was told by a conservative that I better watch what I say lest I be kicked out of the liberal club. I hate that that emotional aspect of the human condition carries so much weight.
That was a pretty good conversation, Hal. We didn't resolve anything, but hey! It's NewsTalkers. And frankly, the other forum where I participate doesn’t ever "solve" anything, either. Getting people to put their thoughts on the table, with a minimum of civility, is a success.
Don't set your sights impossibly high.
I have no expectation of changing anyone's mind, ever. Tis the life of an outspoken atheist.
And as a theist, I have little hope of persuading you. But that's okay. Kant's secular formulation of the Golden Rule is a perfectly adequate substitute for Christ's One Commandment.
I respectfully request to not be included in that 'us' reference. My brain is influenced more by cynicism than emotion.
Cynicism isn't the opposite of emotion. Logic is. In fact, I try to look at everything from a logically POV. Emotions are reserved for relationships.
Emotions are reserved for relationships
Admirable intention. I wonder, though, if it's possible to separate things so neatly. A conversation is an exchange of information... and also a relationship.
Well we would need to define relationships. They are not all created equal. Some require little or no emotional output, while others do. On the internet, I can have a discussion with someone and have little or no emotional investment, or have a lot. It depends on the kinds of exchanges I have been having with them and also the length of time I have been having it with them..
I don't feel that any relationship is an equal one. Each, even the most loving one, is a form of a power struggle. That's why the idea of a truly 50-50 relationship is absurd and I have never seen one. Someone is always dominate, if only at some things while the other is dominate at others. The problem is when one is dominate at everything.
Agreed.
It seems to me that just about any conversation (on NT, at least) involves a significant emotional investment. I discuss "my ideas", and in those two words "my" is probably the more important. Online, there is no physical me. There is only my words. My ideas. My ideas are me.
So when someone attacks my ideas, they are attacking everything that I am, here on NT. Or when I attack someone else's ideas, of course...
Perhaps emotions play a more dynamic role than we realize. There is a ton about our own evolution that we don't yet understand, and emotions are still an interesting conundrum in that arena. Evolution of emotion is mostly described by the specific emotions that are drivers for evolutionary success (like fear), rather than an overall explanation for emotions, and that deserves attention. I think that it's possible that our emotions were at one time more closely tied to our instincts, and consciously applied communication.
I'm convinced that our behavior is almost entirely determined by emotions and by impulses that arise from our subconscious. We then put a veneer of rationality on top, and pat ourselves on the back for being "thinking beings".
Our relations with other people are determined by values that we are taught as children.
There may be free will in there somewhere... but I'm not sure where!
Our relations with other people are determined by values that we are taught as children.
At one time our relationships with other people, other creatures, (...and the air and soil and water, etc ...) and all of reality around us, were the determining factors of our values. Values, not just learned as children, but lived as reality by the vast host of humans on the planet. Ancient Human's very existence is based mostly on shared knowledge, cooperative living with other species, and an existence with, and within Nature, that many in the modern Industrial First World would consider miraculous or even supernatural. Humans did indeed live in concert with nature. Darwin's theories were merely a beginning of an understanding about life on this planet; and, the more we learn, the more I am personally convinced that shared genetic information is a MUCH larger key to the survival of any species, than that specie's ability to beat others in competition for resources. More and more, our reasoned, scientific explorations are discovering that success on this planet is tied to adaption and coevolution.
Our disconnect begins with believing that our intellect, use of tools, and seeming/assumed superiority over all of Nature, enables us to to escape the reality of Nature. That is foolish.
There may be free will in there somewhere... but I'm not sure where!
Is it possible to consider alternatives that are not so dualistic? Why do we assume that the opposing thought/force of lets say emotion, is cynicism or logic or any of the above choices. Why do we limit ourselves to such simplistic choices when the reality is that our choices, as shared by the bazzillions of other species we have always shared with, are literally in the bazzillions!
:~)
What if free will, and purpose, and sacredness, and our super awesome garden, and all of it's inhabitants, are nothing at all like we have led ourselves to foolishly believe? At all!? What if, what if it's all so , so much more?! What if Heaven is in our hearts after all?
Rational linear proof is what the mind demands. The heart's way begins when one lays one's head on a person's chest and drifts into the answer. — Coleman Barks
Ouf! I've read your post several times, and I am still not sure I understand. In fact, I'm pretty sure I don't... So please allow for my incomprehension...
Values, not just learned as children, but lived as reality by the vast host of humans on the planet. Ancient Human's very existence is based mostly on shared knowledge...
If we assume that we learn "values" as children, and then change very little as adults... those "values" take on an existence of their own, drifting down across the generations, inherited like DNA, and just as independent of the people carrying them.
"Values" would identify a group, in the same manner as genetic markers. We do indeed observe such linkage of "values" and geography in the real world.
A child is in contact with a variable number of adults, "inheriting" a portion of "values" from each. A nuclear family would have different consequences from an extended family... as we observe in the real world.
It's a fascinating approach... but I'm not sure it's where you were going. If not... thanks anyway, because you provoked me into this line of thought!
This conception of "values" almost gives them independence from the people who carry them... and leads fairly directly to
Our disconnect begins with believing that our intellect, use of tools, and seeming/assumed superiority over all of Nature, enables us to to escape the reality of Nature.
If we carry semi-independent "values", evolved over millennia, then we are inscribed in the world in ways that are indeed inescapable.
The Reality Is That Our Choices, As Shared By The Bazzillions Of Other Species We Have Always Shared With, Are Literally In The Bazzillions!
Yes and no. We apparently face a dozen decisions every instant of our lives, from when to get up to what to have for breakfast to what to watch on TV over breakfast to how to dress to ...
Fortunately, we have habit , which gets us through the day without going crazy... but which eliminates a large portion of the bazzillion choices.
And more generally, we have "values", which guide (at the least) our choices in larger questions.
And those "values" flow down through the generations... and we come full circle on the subject of Free Will.
Rational Linear Proof Is What The Mind Demands. The Heart's Way Begins When One Lays One's Head On A Person's Chest And Drifts Into The Answer.
— Coleman Barks
I wonder if Barks's "heart" is the same thing as "values"?
Thank you, Larry, for making me think .
Cynicism isn't the opposite of emotion.
I didn't say it was. But it's certainly not the same thing as emotion.
Interesting article Bob. I always enjoy what you post because it generally stimulates lively discussions. I agree that it's rare if ever that you can persuade someone to change their mind. I thinks it's a win if I can get the other person to a least try and see my perspective even if they don't agree.
Thanks for the kind words.
I suspect that some of the rancor we see on NT is frustration "because those idiots refuse to recognize what is so limpid to me". If we try to understand the mechanisms that lead intelligent people to hold different opinions, it's easier to stay zen.
😩
If we try to understand the mechanisms that lead intelligent people to hold different opinions, it's easier to stay zen.
Yeah....well I lost my zen here after the first couple of months of my joining. I've never seen such a concerted effort to make people feel bad. The act of always seeking out the differences rather than the common ground is paramount to many within this group. The personal attacks did me in and opened my eyes. This site is not a place to exchange ideas or to learn new perspectives or to even share an original piece. I left one and came here because it seemed so lopsided. Maybe all sites are similar to this one.
People are set in their ways because it's comfortable and because of our personal prejudices whether we want to admit it or not. I used to want to hear a different point of view because I know I still have a lot to learn and what better way than hearing about other people's life choices, environment and experiences but not from this group. I've only learned hate and intolerance here and how to give it right back.
Jeez... You sure know how to rebuild a guy's morale...
Hahahahaha - sorry Bob. I'm kinda bitter.
That's MUCH better!
The first thing that came to mind as I read this was, Sartre. The article has a "feeling" of the existentialist philosophy.
So, let's get to the conversation piece.
In order for a conversation to happen, both parties have to be willing to engage. I see this happening less and less, unless you count the conversations among those who apparently see things the same way. Both "Us" and "Them" decry the lack of conversation, or civil discourse from the other tribe, but neither is willing to say, perhaps you do have something to say. Not as a general rule anyway. There can, and are, specific individuals within each group who will engage in a seeking way. Attempting to find and engage with those individuals can be a daunting task.
From the standards that we were inoculated with when we were little.
I'll come back to the above statement later. It's a long story.
I'll come back to the above statement later. It's a long story.
Please do continue. You're off to a good start. Interesting.
From the standards that we were inoculated with when we were little.
Well, let's see, what was I inoculated with? Rather hard for me to say really.
When I was two, my brother was one, my father contracted polio. He was a quadriplegic for the rest of his life, 40+ years. My mother had to go to work. I learned to cook and wash clothes pretty early. I remember wearing an AuH2O button to school, just like all the other kids. I remember seeing a commercial with a white kid and a black kid playing on a swing and my dad said, "My kids ain't playing with niggers." What was a nigger?
Mom was mostly silent and enduring, as am I. They got divorced. I don't remember ever being home that year.
My brother and I spent our summers at our grandparent's farm in New Mexico. I consider them as much my parents as anybody. My granddad never spoke badly of anyone. He loved all children.
My interactions with churches were...rocky at best.
I've always loved knowledge, learning and sci-fi. It is my happy place.
So what was I inoculated with when little?
Broken bricks.
... and that's a large part of the problem...
Our memories from the age when we were inoculated are vague and contradictory. My guess is that assimilating (and rendering coherent) a set of values is a significant part of childhood.
But we remember almost nothing of that work.
Dear Friend Bob Nelson: I try to read but not comment on political, doctrinal, and other types of articles which divide people form people.
We both read and respect each others discussion threads. From this you know I focus on things that unite, include and promote fellowship and harmony. I leave division, acrimony, and jamming positions down the throats of others to those better suited for it by temperament and intention.
Often I see people ask the question "what is true" not realizing that life is more complicated than a two value system. They fail to ask the more important second half of the question, For whom?
What we find in metaphysics we first find ht the physical part of life. Diversity is more a part of the Divine plan than the law of excluded middle.
Bio diversity keeps a genus and species from going extinct. Answers and attributes that work well in one scenario fail miserably in others. Diversity keeps us going. This is as true for biology as it is for philosophy and theology.
The trick is to find what works best for us. Part of knowing we have it is that it brings out our better nature. A tell that happens is when we get along not in spite of, but because of what each of us believes, even if incompatible.
Less time committing the sin of evangelism, more on mutual respect and finding common ground to build on move us farther down the field toward the goal of Divine Will be done, the Divine Kingdom come on earth, as it is in heaven.
Great and thought provoking article Bob.
As ever, well done my good friend and brother in spirit.
Peace and Abundant Blessings Always to You and Yours.
Enoch.
Thank you for your contribution, Enoch. Your behavior on NT is an example of what you prone. I know you rarely post to "Politics", so I am honored.
Dear Friend Bob Nelson: I try not to post about politics.
There are people on every side of political issues who may and are encouraged to contact me for pastoral care.
I want them to feel comfortable so doing whoever they are, and whatever the believe.
It is I who am honored each and every time we can collaborate.
You are wise.
Your faith is strong.
Your good will sincere.
We need more of all these.
Peace and Abundant Blessings to You and Yours, Always.
Enoch,
A fascinating article and an interesting discussion - I feel I have learned from it.
Very kind of you, Buzz. Thank you.
Let's see if we can get this navel gazing article up to 200 comments too !
Innie or outie? Shallow innie here. Never collects lint.
Well, John... with contributions like yours, I'm sure that this conversation will continue to shine!