╌>

Expertise ... ... by Bob Nelson

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  bob-nelson  •  9 years ago  •  32 comments

Expertise   ...   ...   by Bob Nelson

We need experts all the time. 

When I was a young man, I knew how to disassemble an automobile engine, and (probably) find whatever was ailing it. Cars have evolved enormously since then... and I have not. I cannot do the work myself. I need an expert.

My teeth are pretty good... but I occasionally need a dentist.

Arizona can get pretty hot. Air conditioning is needed. It sometimes breaks down.

I belong to a website where people exchange their experiences with local service providers, like auto mechanics, dentists, or air conditioner repairpeople, so I have a means of evaluating the "expertise" of these people.

But then... I want to go to Helsinki on the 15th... and not take a couple days to drive there. Flying depends on a whole bunch of experts. I have no way of knowing the competence of aircraft mechanics or pilots. I have no choice but to depend on "the system". Of course, the statistics tell me that the system works pretty well... praying

Our modern world requires experts for... everything.

Unfortunately, aside from local services, it is very hard to distinguish between a truly qualified expert and a self-appointed charlatan. 

I used to be an expert... officially! Twenty years ago, I participated in the elaboration of a few standards... along with other people who were also supposedly experts. I think the idea was that we would each be a guard-rail against the others' incompetence. I have lost touch with those fields of competence, to the point that today I would not claim more than "layman's knowledge".

Today, I am fairly well-informed on a number of topics, but "expert" on nothing. At the same time, I recognize that the future of the whole world -- my grandchildren's world -- depends on the competence and efficacy of experts.

This is a relatively new situation. In 1789, the assembly that wrote the Bill Of Rights (or La déclaration des droits de l'homme et du citoyen ) knew everything that was known to mankind. There were no "experts who know stuff that ordinary people just do not have the time and opportunity to learn". The result is that the system of government those men created does not recognize "expertise". Anybody's opinion is as valid as anyone else's. That was a reasonable idea at the time.

Today, it is just plain crazy!

We wouldn't dream of confiding an airliner to just any guy who proclaims himself "pilot". But we let "just any guy" make highly technical decisions that determine the future of the world.

Our world today is a dense tangle of topics that interact and interfere with one another... and all of them are currently left in the hands of Sorcerer's Apprentices.

Genuine expertise is a full-time job. The basis is intensive training and / or long years of practice.

Peter Higgs is a charming fellow, but that isn't why CERN built the LHC. It was built because there was a consensus in the community of particle physicists that actually finding Peter Higg's brainchild would be a very important step toward understanding the nature of the universe... and the EU Commission followed the opinion of those experts. It didn't have to.

As the AGW debate demonstrates, we have no political process for managing expertise. We have no way of defining expertise, and no process for translating expert opinion into policy.

This situation is ultimately suicidal.

If AGW doesn't destroy the world, then there will be some other problem, observed by "experts" but ignored by the "just any guys" who make the decisions. If we do not find a way to put experts in charge of policy, we are playing Russian roulette, and sooner or later the hammer will come down on a loaded chamber.

It's uncomfortable for everyone. For democrats, it means recognizing that demos  can no longer be competent. For authoritarians, it means recognizing that Glorious Leader cannot be competent in everything, either.

We must find a political process for confiding our destiny to experts whose opinions we may not even understand. Since "power tends to corrupt", we must find checks and balances.

Our politicians do not recognize this problem. They cannot, because they are a large part of it.

So let's start the conversation without them...

-----------------------------------

RED RULES apply:

Be polite
No insults whatsoever. No insults to particular people, to groups of people, to ideas, ... None!

Be smart and stay on-topic
Contribute substantive thought. Facts and/or reasoning.
One-line zingers and bumper-sticker mantras are by definition off-topic and will be deleted.
 


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    9 years ago

RED RULES apply:

   - Be polite. No insults whatsoever. No insults to particular people, to groups of people, to ideas, ... None!

   - Be smart and stay on topic. Contribute substantive thought. Facts and/or reasoning. One-line zingers and bumper-sticker mantras are by definition off-topic, and will be deleted.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    9 years ago

Mandarins?

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

Great oranges?

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Randy   9 years ago

Mandarins?

Great oranges?

      laughing dude

The EU Commission is undemocratic. It is far from the ravening mob. That can be good, allowing it to decide policies that are good for the Union, even if they are not "popular". But by the same occasion, the Commission suffers from a lack of accountability, sometimes making bad decisions, and not having adequate checks and balances.

That was kinda sorta the problem with China's... mandarins... who ran the country pretty well for a couple thousand years...

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

Government officials?

Language?

Fruit?

This post does not comply with your RBR, but then your single word question does not as well.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    9 years ago

We must find a political process for confiding our destiny to experts whose opinions we may not even understand. Since "power tends to corrupt", we must find checks and balances.

This is the rub of course,,,trusting others to be as expert as they possibly can, to have my benefit in mind, to not be for sale, to be moral....

This will require more than a system of checks and balances; a sea change in our very way of living, will need to happen for us to share and trust to this degree. 

Great article btw.

:~)

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Larry Hampton   9 years ago

The problem is that we have only two possibilities for decisions engaging the future of the world:

  • Experts
  • Amateurs

The deciders will have power in any case. 

I don't have a good suggestion, but it seems pretty necessary to find some! 

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

Bob,

I can point to one specific area where I am an expert, where the amateurs have clamored to handle matters themselves, and have been granted every advantage by corporations and governments.

I am a financial advisor. I get paid to do what I do. You can handle your own matters yourself for far less, but you're still an amateur. If you blow yourself up without the benefit of professional advice, it's all on you. But this is the trend, until the next wave of trouble besets our financial markets. Needless to say, this is but a single aspect of our lives.

I'm going to guess that you're lamenting the advent of unelected officials that decide the fate of many. I agree that's wrong. But then we in America were handed a ballot in November with no apparently viable candidate to lead us for the next 4 years. One was elected, and we can guess that we could have done better, but the fact is that we could have done a better job; that is, create a better way to give us better candidates that we could have voted for. Like you, I have no solutions. And, like you, I believe that it is a necessity to find a better way.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Jonathan P   9 years ago

Jonathan P,

I'm going to guess that you're lamenting the advent of unelected officials... 

Not at all. I'm lamenting the fact that we are governed by Sorcerers' Apprentices, who make decisions of lasting importance about topics which they do not understand. 

We need to have experts making those decisions, but our institutions ensure that that cannot happen. If we do not find a way to empower experts, our Sorcerers' Apprentices will, inevitably, make a fatal error. At the same time, we must not give inordinate power to anyone, because "power tends to corrupt". 

I see the problem. I don't see any solution. 

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    9 years ago

So many ways to go with this Bob. 

If you are talking about Trump pulling out of the Paris accord, this is our elected official and not an expert in this field, so we are kind of stuck. 

If you are talking about AGW, well some of our "experts" screwed with the numbers and because of that, most conservatives, had the perfect excuse not to take AGW seriously. The shame is on the experts who did that, because there was valuable information that was lost to them due to this.

Experts should act like experts.

And for the record, I do believe in AGW, even though it can never be tested by the scientific method. What we can see and test are the ice cores, and they have always looked like we are at fault.

Let's hope the good news is that the sun is going to be going through a cooling period. Maybe that will straighten out the mess caused by man.  

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Perrie Halpern R.A.   9 years ago

Very conservative like position you are emanating Perrie. thinking

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.  replied to  JohnRussell   9 years ago

Excuse me John, for stating the facts. That doesn't mean that I am not concerned about AGW, so I am not sure how that makes me sound like a conservative. But thanks for talking about me and not the content. 

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Perrie Halpern R.A.   9 years ago

Perrie, 

I'm not talking about any particular decision. 

We have an institutional quandary. The problems facing us are complex and interlocking. They must be managed by experts, because amateurs will do great harm. Our system of government ensures that the decisions are made by amateurs. 

 

You have been drinking anti-AGW kool-aid. No one "manipulated" climate data in any devious way. All complex data sets must be cleaned up. All complex data sets, not just climate, not just science. The statistical methods applied to the incriminated climate data were examined and validated by at least two independent third parties. 

Actually... this is an excellent example of the quandary that I have tried to evoke in the article. We have people talking about AGW without understanding how data is gathered, treated, analyzed. I'm sure you never personally examined either the climate data or the statistical methods. And yet you express an opinion without any attenuation ("as far as my inexpert knowledge goes"), as though you are certain of what you say. Such attenuation is sadly rare online...

Most of us feel like we must have an opinion on everything, and a competent opinion at that! The idea is absurd, if we think about it for more than ten seconds. Expert on climate science and expert on particle physics and expert on health insurance and expert on education and expert on... 

Ain't gonna happen. Neither for us nor for our Congresspeople. Nor for any President. 

So how can we run the country? 

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  Perrie Halpern R.A.   9 years ago

Experts should act like experts.

I agree ... but in climatology the "experts" are ignoring evidence & asserting a political position with no backup .

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    9 years ago

First of all, I have not drank any Koolaid. I read the emails myself. They were inappropriate at best, and poor science at worst. I have also read all the following information, and I feel that they did great damage to AGW cause.  

The amateurs count on these people to give them the correct information. When you get a defect like this, you get doubters. When you get a really dumb amature, well, they are just going to go on their gut. That is what is going on with our government.

As for my opinions on AGW, you seem to forget that I have a degree in Earth Science. It doesn't make me an expert, but it does make me knowledgeable, which is why I referenced the ice cores. It is why I believe in AGW, but I do because I studied up on the academic research and have done my own evaluation of the information. Of course I rely on the experts, and that is why I am annoyed at those emails. 

As for our elected officials... you will never get them to read what they have to read to do their job, much less climate change. Their opinions will be based in the court of public opinion and gut reactions. 

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Perrie Halpern R.A.   9 years ago

I read the emails myself. 

I assume you are referring to the "trick" emails. And the fact that you read them explains a lot. They were private communication between persons who knew each other well. They used shorthand language (like "trick") that they understood correctly, but which was hermetic to outsiders. Those emails were "edited" by anti-AGW activists to underscore anything that might possibly be construed unfavorably. 

Aren't you put off by the abuse of those emails by their hackers? Doesn't that kind of intellectual dishonesty make you mistrust its perpetrators?

But AGW is not the point. 

 

As for our elected officials... you will never get them to read what they have to read to do their job, much less climate change. Their opinions will be based in the court of public opinion and gut reactions. 

That's the point. Our world will not get simpler in the future. If it isn't AGW, it will be something else. Some problem that requires unpopular action. If decisions are left to amateurs, sooner or later we're screwed. 

What institutions could accomplish this? 

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    9 years ago

The problem is that we have only two possibilities for decisions engaging the future of the world:

 

  • Experts
  • Amateurs

 

The deciders will have power in any case. 

I don't have a good suggestion, but it seems pretty necessary to find some! 

 

The solution may be found is regarding more than two possibilities. Not that I am completely disregarding your nomenclature as a working model; rather, how the terms are defined and applied. Perhaps further refinement would reveal more complexity.

Our Modern World exists on a teeter, an illusion of our own making, one that will provide a rude awakening as we understand, for real, how easily it can be brought down. I do not believe that our present course is sustainable one wit, nor do I believe we will pull outta the nosedive in time to prevent a crash. A new start is what will drive us in the direction that must be taken, one that is focused on coexisting with  Nature (reality) rather than bending it to our will. We are still learning to adapt. We are still evolving. The species is adolescent, in puberty.

As any teenager does, they begin to come into their own, their growing power and the freedom that presents, is as dangerous as beneficial. We must learn in an existential manner that coevolution and the sharing of information in a myriad of ways (think DNA) with the other species, has made us who we are. Human beings are not islands unto themselves at all, and cannot be separated from reality except in their own heads.

Just as we have a multitude of organisms in and on our very bodies, so is life in and on planet earth. Hopefully we will grow up soon and start being caretakers rather than selfish immature brats bent on having our own way. 

 

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Larry Hampton   9 years ago

I do not believe that our present course is sustainable one wit, nor do I believe we will pull outta the nosedive in time to prevent a crash.

That is indeed our most likely future. The prospect of that crash, with billions of victims, is horrifying. 

Our best chance of avoiding the crash is probably... China. How depressing is that!?  stunned

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

Interesting, as I was just hearing how China may capitalize on the US dropping this ball...

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Larry Hampton   9 years ago

China's leaders are succeeding in balancing general welfare and individual wealth. They have a great deal to do, yet... and sooner or later they'll have to accept the notion of human rights. 

Singapore-ish. 

 
 
 
Fermit The Krog
Freshman Silent
link   Fermit The Krog  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

In Singapore 3.5 oz of marijuana will win you the death penalty. That is an awful comparison.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Fermit The Krog   9 years ago

Dope is what's important... 

 
 
 
Fermit The Krog
Freshman Silent
link   Fermit The Krog  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

Another brilliant statement. We are talking human rights and it appears you to believe they aren't that important.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Fermit The Krog   9 years ago

I defer to your well-known sensibilities... laughing dude

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

If it weren't for emoticons you wouldn't have any comments to add !

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Petey Coober   9 years ago

thumbs up

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika   replied to  Fermit The Krog   9 years ago

Only 3.5 oz of cannabis RESIN for the death penalty.

Straight cannabis/MJ takes 18 oz. for the death penalty in Singapore

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  Larry Hampton   9 years ago

One of the ways China is expanding clean energy is by building multiple nuclear reactors. That type of scientific thinking is anathema in the US in most regions.

 
 
 
Enoch
Masters Silent
link   Enoch    9 years ago

Dear Friend Bob Nelson: Checks and balances, transparency, accountability, and consensus building are all part of this package.

A major problem for a Democratic Republic like ours is that the basic strength of the system is also its basic weakness.

As was quoted in another recent article by our good friend Buzz of The Orient, Alan Dershowitz quoted Isaac Asimov. Mr. Asimov wrote, "The ignorance of others counts the same as my knowledge".

Jack Bogle, Founder of Vanguard Investments said essentially the same thing in another context.

All votes count the same. Those who do the research, think, act out of enlightened self interest and a concern for the greater good, and those who mindlessly repeat sound bites because it satisfies their baser instincts and lower level emotions.

As is frequently the case, however good or bad a system, it is still only as good as the people using and/or misusing it.

As each of us can do is to do our best on our own.

We can and should be a role model for others.

We need to be prepared to have many even most of them ignore our example.

Vox Populi. One person, one vote.

Imperfect.

Still the best of all possible alternatives.

May the G-d of Mercy and Wisdom grant us wisdom, and show us mercy when we elect not to use it.

Enoch.

 

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Enoch   9 years ago

As is frequently the case, however good or bad a system, it is still only as good as the people using and/or misusing it.

Exactly. And our quandary is that, no matter how hard they may try (which isn't very hard, usually Sad ) the electorate simply cannot be competent on all the multitude of complex subjects before us. One must be of doctorate level to really understand any one topic, and define the best path forward. So we would need, each of us, a couple dozen doctorates, to handle everything. Ain't gonna happen... 

So I'm not criticizing John Doe. I'm sympathizing with his impossible situation. He is required to make decisions that he is not competent to make. Demos is not competent, and never again will be. 

If demos is incompetent, democracy is... problematic... thinking

So... What do we do? 

 
 

Who is online




116 visitors