Barack H. Chamberlain and Iran
Barack H. Chamberlain and Iran
By Michael Freund, The Jerusalem Post, February 6, 2015
Far away from the glare of the cameras, it appears that the commander-in-chief and his colleagues are swiftly caving in to the ayatollahs
If several alarming media reports are true, US President Barack Obama is moving perilously closer to a nuclear deal with Iran that will endanger Israel and all of Western civilization.
Far away from the glare of the cameras, it appears that the commander-in-chief and his colleagues are swiftly caving in to the ayatollahs, hoping to buy some short-term quiet by allowing Iran to remain a threshold nuclear state.
In a chilling exclusive filed on Tuesday, the Associated Press revealed that Washington and Tehran are discussing a compromise that would let Iran keep much of its uranium-enriching technology but reduce its potential to make nuclear weapons.
Under the proposal, the US would retreat from its previous demand that Iran dismantle most of its 10,000 centrifuges and allow the mullahs to keep them if they agree to reconfigure the equipment to produce a smaller amount of uranium.
This is a frighteningly nave idea because should the Iranians decide to renege on the deal at any point in the future, they would still have a breakout capacity that would leave them poised just a few months away from the nuclear finish line.
As the AP story noted, Experts warn that any reduction in centrifuge efficiency is reversible more quickly than a straight decrease in the number of machines.
In other words, such a deal would be like permitting a violent offender to keep his gun and his ammunition, but telling him sternly not to load the chamber.
This proposal is said to be similar to one that Iran itself made last year but which the US and its allies rejected at the time because they would not tolerate allowing the Iranians to have more than 2,500 centrifuges.
But with the approach of a March deadline in the negotiations, it seems that Obama is now willing to agree to the very same demand that even he was unwilling to countenance just a year ago.
This is nothing less than folly of the highest order, and it is difficult to overstate the danger involved.
For even if the ayatollahs commit themselves to limits on the amount of enriched uranium they will produce with their many centrifuges, does anyone really think they will abide by their commitments? Consider the following: Since July 31, 2006, the United Nations Security Council has adopted no fewer than six resolutions demanding that the Iranians suspend all enrichment-related and reprocessing activities, including research and development.
Most of these resolutions were adopted under Chapter VII of the UN Charter, which means they are legally binding on Iran and all UN member states.
Nonetheless, Iran has violated every single one of them. They have added more centrifuges, continued with their nuclear research and development, and persisted in enriching uranium.
And now, the Obama administration is willing to allow Tehran to violate the UN Security Council resolutions which Washington itself supported.
What message does this send to the ayatollahs? Simple enough: if you dither and delay, disregard and disobey, eventually the West will give in.
If that is not textbook appeasement, then what is? Indeed, last Friday, Israels Channel 10 quoted unnamed senior Israeli officials as saying that Obama has given the Iranians 80 percent of what they want in the nuclear talks.
And according to a report on Tuesday morning on IDF radio, European officials have told their Israeli counterparts that the US is willing to allow Iran to keep a larger number of centrifuges in exchange for their promise to keep things quiet in places such as Iraq, Afghanistan and Syria.
The European officials added that in recent weeks, the Obama administration had agreed to take a large step in Irans direction out of a desire for some regional quiet, even if it means that Tehrans centrifuges will continue to spin away.
If the above proves accurate and we will find out soon enough it will mark a watershed moment in modern history.
It will mean that until the end of time, Iran will always be on the brink of having atomic weapons, able at short notice to join the nuclear club and threaten Israel, neighboring Arab states, Europe and America.
And that is why it is so essential the Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu travel to Washington early next month to speak to Congress and warn the American people of the danger of appeasing Iran.
More than 70 years ago, Franklin Delano Roosevelt refused to bomb the train tracks to Auschwitz, thereby failing to stop the mass slaughter of our people.
Now, Barack Obama seems equally disinclined to stop the ayatollahs march toward building a nuclear Auschwitz, with all that might entail.
If the American president does agree to a feeble deal with Iran, he might as well sign his name at the bottom as Barack H. Chamberlain.
But while his legacy will merely be tarnished, our future and that of America too will permanently be at risk. That is a message that the American people need to hear. And no one is better suited to deliver it than our premier.
The writer served as an advisor to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu during his first term of office from 1996-1999.
Tags
Who is online
100 visitors

If you want to know the chances that Iran will care about any kind of deal it makes, think of this:
Since the Shah was assassinated, the Iranians have done as they wished. They will continue to do so until the ME countries step in a stop it - not the U.S. and EU.
1st, I whole heartedly agree. The Middle East and their varying governing entities must take leadership positions on Iran and their nuclear ambitions.
The agreement reportedly allows them to keep operating 7000 centrifuges. We should have quit when we were ahead.
I'm surprised he didn't just hand them a bomb given his negotiation skills, or lack of.
How do you know all that?
Right, Randy, Iran would NEVER provide weapons to terrorist organizations, like Hamas or Hezbollah, etc.
I will give you my answer.
The US should leave the talks, get the world to reimpose the sanctions and even intensify them.
If this does not stop Iran's march to weaponizing we should bomb their facilities with our bunker-busters.
That should not lead to war anymore than prior similar moves by Israel against Iraq and Syria. We do not need to invade or press for regime change. But that is up to Iran.
They need not be nuclear strikes. As Len points out below, Israel did a good job on the nuclear facilities in Iraq and Syria. Maybe Saudi Arabia should do it this time. The US has given then lots of firepower, I believe.
@Max. No, I think Saudi Arabia should do it with unexposed assistance from Israel and the US backing them (so it would have to wait until Obama is out of office).
Iran deserves to be taught a lesson it won't forget for providing terrorists with weapons and even taking part in terrorism themselves, such as the Argentina bombing (or in the face of all the evidence do you actually doubt they were involved?)
Len, really bomb their facilities? Given this list, I think we'd need more than bunker-busters.
The following is a partial list of nuclear facilities in Iran ( IAEA , NTI and other sources): [5] [6]
Good, Randy. Then write an article about it and post it on the Classic Cinema group.
Well, maybe it would mean like Obama says to Netanyahu that he has his back.
So Randy, now that you've seen the movie, does "Dark Victory" mean the satisfaction that Iran has in having pulled the wool over the eyes of the USA?
Israel has provided considerable benefits to the USA and the rest of the world, although the media that loves to demonize Israel will not admit it.
Max,
Who would you name as American allies then?
In sheersharing ofintelligence with Israel (alone), we are allies. I don't get what ya mean? Do you mean "all countries use each other for their own means as much as possible", well, ok?
Between the US viruses and Israel strikes we have thwarted their efforts so far. Why so quick to tow the party line?
I don't recall watching Dark Victory, but To Kill a Mockingbird is worth watching many times - such a great movie.
1. US special operations units trained in Israel before arrival to Iraq and Afghanistan;
2. Israel armor plating technology protects US soldiers;
3. Israel is a cost-effective, battle-tested laboratory for the US defense industries;
4. Israel provides the US more intelligence than all NATO countries combined;
5. US battle tactics formulated according to the Israeli playbook;
6. Israel is a strategic beachhead of the US in the Middle East;
7. Israel is the largest US aircraft carrier, which doesnt require a single US boot on board;
Israel is the only stable, reliable, predictable, capable, democratic and unconditional ally of the US, willing to flex its muscle.
Just about every Israeli election the Palestinians pull off some huge violence or terrorism just before the vote and virtually guarantee that the right wing will win the election. Let's see if they sit this one out, and if so, what happens.
Are you saying I'm not permitted to voice my opinion on world affairs? Who are you to decide what I can or can not write? My religion is none of your business, as if it should make any difference whatever my religion is.
Barbara,
Why does it matter what faith they are? I know people who are Christian who feel the same way.
And BTW, his name is Len, not Leon.
I actually did a bit of research on how far Iran's missiles could reach, and apparently, it is all of the ME and into Europe. It is believed that they are both in development of longer range missiles and in negotiations with Russia for them. This is relevant information to this discussion.
Nuclear radiation clouds travel around the world. Local radiation and radioactive dust clouds are the worst in say a 20 to 200-500 mile range depending on the weapon and at what altitude the bomb is detonated. So called dirty bombs are the worst. How many bombs would it take to destroy the USA not all that many. Heat waves also vary by size of bomb and detonation height 25 miles 50 miles it varies and also depends on terrain. Remember 3 mile island didn't explode nor Chernobel nor Fukishima none were nuclear explosions only melt downs huge difference. Get your facts straight or find a different argument. Radio active dust clouds are carried at the extremities by the wind. Nuclear missiles and nuclear bombs are the same difference both can be detonated surface subsurface or air burst.
What damned virus did we give Iran. Wow wonder when FOX threw that lie out there sounds like a blunder onion sniffing Beck fallacy.
If the middle East gets their nuclear weapons completed with missiles capable of reaching the USA Just who do you think ISIS or ISIL your call would aim them at the ( USA ). Attacking a religion never works. It doesn't work ever. It worked in the Crusades because Christians were fighting Christians for a good part of it. Getting rid of as many of the ancient religious texts which were not of the thinking of the Kings and Church. Books were burned Libraries decimated all for the plan of cleansing their Religion along with rape and pillage of women children as slaves and stealing riches.
The Pope now has the right to change the bible as he wishes. HUH!
Religious wars are wicked and sickening. Using religion and skin Color as a weapon to create hatred has been used since written history began and before. No one wins in A Nuclear war. We keep giving the ME more ammunition in the form of reasons to hate us. How would we feel about Europe invading the USA to control our killings, child abuse and Police brutality and out of control paid for Congress and Supreme court all other paid off politicians. And we wonder why they hate the Great Satan ( USA )! We cannot get our own country straight. All men are created equal just what city has that??? Rant over!
Len is not the only person she has asked that question. Perhaps she feels there are members here who should be diplaying a yellow six-pointed star as their avatar. There is another person back in history who felt that way.
Why do we protect Israel? Israel is not there by choice! Jesus was a Jew. Israel position we would maybe better understand if Mexico and Canada were both controlled by ISIS.
And by Hamas and Al Quaida and Hezbollah and everyone else who hates America, and with Iran providing them with weapons, missiles and ammunition like they provide to terrorists of all sorts. THEN people can talk about why Israel is so concerned about its security and defending itself.
If you think that a nuclear Iran isn't a world problem, you are kidding yourself.
So no, I don't see this as a Jewish v Muslim issue. I see it as an unstable Iran (that happens to be Muslim) vs all of the ME and Europe.
Jews or Israelis? There is a difference you know.
That isn't the purpose of a Bat Mitzvah. It is becoming a woman.
That was one strange Bat Mitzvah or one strange Rabbi. I have been to my fair share and have never heard that before. And while I wouldn't have walked out, I would have expressed my disgust, since that isn't the venue for that.
Please clarify?
MY dissertation? I didn't write it, although granted I agree with it.
It seems to me that there are members of NT of many religions (or non-religions) who think alike on the subject of Israel generally, and about this conflict specifically. So YOU are the only one who thinks religion is important for the issue. It so happens that there is quite a divide among Jews as to issues concerning Israel, so a person's specific religion is no guideline, except perhaps for you.
The Rabbi who said that all Palestinians should be killed should be removed from his post (if that is what he said). Rabbis should be leaders and teachers and one who voices such a statement does not deserve to be in the position he occupies. He is a shundah.
John, you are quite right. With that realization I have deleted my comment.
That itself is an issue. Barbara isn't the first person who imposes the actions of the Israeli government onto every Jew in the world, notwithstanding the huge differences in opinions about Israel among Jews. That is the reason for the substantial increase in anti-Semitic acts around the world.
Randy,
The assumption here is that Iran has western values. They may or they may not, depending on who is running the country.
Maybe they don't mind going down for a good cause? The Japanese sure had no problem doing that.
I guess, to you, what the Palestinians have done to the Jews is of no importance.
Have you ever been to Israel, Barbara, or do you get all your information from the media? I have been to Israel more than once. Let me tell you about the first time I went. I witnessed a bus bombing that slaughtered innocent Jewish women and children, and when I was in the north of Israel I had to hide in a bomb shelter because Hezbollah floated bombs by kites and balloons over the kibbutz I was visiting.
The next time I went to Israel was right after the "Passover massacre", if you ever heard about that, and I witnessed the devastation in the reception room of the Park Hotel in Netanyah where whole families celebrating the holiday were wiped out. I then interviewed the doctors at Laniado Hospital which received most of the victims and heard of the carnage.
Then let's talk about my daughter, who was on a trip to Tel Aviv when her classmate Marni Kimelman was blown up by a pipe bomb buried on the beach - it was only good fortune that it was not my daughter who stepped on it. You can google Marni's name to read about the murder. They caught the Palestinian perpetrator and then in a trade of 1027 Palestinian criminals with blood on their hands for one young Jew who had never killed anyone the perpetrator was released.
Then there is my son who was studying in Jerusalem, who happened to sleep in one morning and was knocked out of his bed when a bomb went off in the outdoor cafe outside his building. It was only a miracle that he was not having his morning coffee there at that time as he usually did.
So you see, Barbara, if I have certain feelings about the Israeli/Palestinian conflict it is not without PERSONAL experience. I am not poisoned by the biased media and the Palestinian propaganda. How about you?
The theocracy of Iran not only doesn't have western values, but despises those values. It may be hard for moral relativists to honestly grasp, but they are not like us in so many ways.
During the Iran-Iraq War in the 1980's both sides made extensive use of child soldiers. Boys between the ages of 12-16 were handed plastic keys representing the "keys to heaven" and sent out to clear minefields with their bodies. As many as 100,000 of these boys were senselessly sent to their deaths by the Ayatollahs. The tenets of Iranian Shia theology are particularly geared toward an "end of times" world view.
The world cannot allow Iran to possess nuclear weapons.
How do you bargain with people who concede nothing, who make no compromise, whose signature on an agreement does not bind them?
How good are threats to persons whose values and beliefs are so vastly different from ours that while we value and cherish life they see martyrdom and sacrifice to further their cause as being ordained, and the benefits of dying for their cause as being a reward worthy of praise?
Waiting patiently for a response.
"If that is what he said."
People see things or remember what they see or hear in different ways and maybe you remember exactly what was said and maybe you didn't, so I covered all the bases. Obviously I continued my comment on the basis that you repeated exactly what was said, so don't be so fucking oversensitive.
How do you remove a Rabbi?
Rabbis are employed by congregations that normally have a Board of Directors. If the Board of Directors decides to remove a Rabbi, they fire him (or her). If it is for cause, and in this case I would say it was, then there should be no successful claim for wrongful dismissal.
You said: "calling someone an Israeli is very different from the Jewish religion"
That is true. but your previous statement was: "what the Jews have done to the Palestinians is abhorrent"
And what the Palestinians have done to the Jews is abhorrent as well, is it not?
"However I had a problem that within the Bush administration that there where over 60 people in high places who had dual citizenship with Israel" "...Bush's dua-lcitizenship war hawks that pushed us into the Iraq War" "...we don't have the big Israeli Super Pacs pushing it"
Ah, and now come the expressions I expected to see. Now I get the picture. Thanks for your opinion as to who was behind starting the Iraq war - I'm not at all surprised.
Maybe I'm not. Maybe I'm a Buddhist, and maybe that's why I moved to China and married a Chinese Buddhist woman, so how would you know?
Damn!!! I think I'll start up the Cockroach Club again.
Hey Barbara,
To respond to your query, I am proud to be one of God's chosen and hope to live up to the obligation that entails.
But I am curious why you think an Obama critic would be Jewish. I suppose you are unaware that over 70% of Jews voted for him -- the highest off any group but Blacks. We are damned if we do and damned if we don't.
By your question, to me and Buzz, I would assume you are one of Hitler's antisemites.
Tell me if I am wrong! Now respond to me.
Hey John,
My message was in response to Barbara Adams Jackson who concluded I am Jewish because I am critical of Obama. I asked how she came up with that since over 70% of Jews voted for Obama.
Don 't you think that is a good question or did the implication pass you by?
I would have expected you to question her, as a moral person would have done, instead of me. The fact that you overlooked her innuendo says a lot about you; all not good.
Your citations of what I said come right out of the Bible that both Christians and Jews use. I know you think the Bible is garbage but that is also your problem.
May God have mercy on your soul.
Although I appreciate and enjoy John's comments on Classic Cinema articles, and wish he would write an article for that group, I almost never agree with him on political matters and find it hard to believe that on this one political article I have now agreed with him twice.
I agree with John's take on the Bible, and in response to Max's comment just below this one, I am not at all impressed by anyone who holds themselves out to be superior to others by making the egotistical statement that they are "chosen". There was no reason whatsoever for Len to respond in such a way to a person who is full of themselves, is a paragon of rudeness, uses innuendo to cast doubt on comments of another, deflects and derails rather than answering direct questions about the comments they make and whose personal prejudices are patently obvious.
My comment just above addresses your point, Max, perhaps not with such vehemence.
In a way, Max, I appreciate the fact that you don't pussyfoot and you say what you think - i.e. you call a spade a spade. My father was just like that. The fact that we disagree on some issues does not mean we can't be friends.
In Iraq we flew 1100 sorties daily. Unless Obama has scuttled our air force (which would be no surprise) it would not take much of an effort to take all these out.
It sounds like you think nuclear war after Obama leaves office is preferable.