TN bill would allow death penalty for women who have an abortion
Tennessee has some of the strictest anti-abortion laws in the country. The Human Life Protection Act prohibits all abortions from fertilization, without exceptions for rape or incest.
S E E D E D C O N T E N T
Key Points
- Two Tennessee Republican lawmakers have proposed a bill to allow the death penalty for women who have abortions.
- The bill would classify abortion as fetal homicide and remove current legal protections for pregnant women.
- The legislation is supported by some faith leaders and the Foundation to Abolish Abortion.
- If passed, the bill would take effect on July 1 but would not allow for retroactive prosecutions.
Two Tennessee Republicans are seeking to impose the death penalty on women who have abortions, requiring the same penalties for women “involved in the homicide of her own unborn child” as defendants charged with homicide.
An amendment drafted for House Bill 570/Senate Bill 738 that's not yet been voted on would allow prosecutors to charge women who obtain abortions with fetal homicide, punishable by life imprisonment, life without parole, or in some cases, the death penalty.
Sponsored by Rep. Jody Barrett, R-Dickson, and Rep. Mark Pody, R-Lebanon, the bill was referred to the House Population Health Subcommittee and is not yet on the calendar to be considered.
The bill specifically removes legal protections for pregnant women currently in statute, and classifies harm done to an unborn child as equal to assault on a person "born alive."
It would not apply to “a spontaneous miscarriage,” or to “unintentional death of an unborn child” after “undertaking life-saving procedures” to save the life of the mother and “to save the life of the unborn child.” No other exceptions are specified in the amendment text.
Retroactive prosecutions of women who were “involved in the assault of her unborn child” or “involved in the homicide of her own unborn child” before the bill goes into effect would not be allowed.
If passed, the bill would take effect July 1.
Faith leaders, politicians line up behind Tennessee abortion abolition effort
Southern Baptist Convention President Clint Pressley endorsed the bill on Feb. 19, saying it would “provide preborn children with equal protection of the laws.”
“By protecting the lives of preborn children with the same laws that protect people who are born, we are simply loving our neighbors in the womb as ourselves,” Pressley wrote in a social media post.
The issue of abortion abolition has been contentious in the denomination in recent years. In 2022, a leader of the denomination's public policy arm signed a letter opposing any measures "seeking to criminalize or punish women who have abortions."
Barrett thanked Pressley for his support.
Barrett and Pody's bill is also backed by the Foundation to Abolish Abortion, a nonprofit whose mission is to “exalt and vindicate the image of God by promoting sound public policy that provides all preborn human beings equal protection of the laws."
Since the state’s total abortion ban went into effect, the Foundation to Abolish Abortion claims that there were more than 5,000 telehealth abortions “on Tennessee soil” in 2024, and more than 10,000 abortions provided to Tennesseans by clinicians out of state, based on estimates from the Guttmacher Institute.
“Under this legislation, murdering anyone would be made illegal for everyone, ensuring that all humans made in the image of God are equally protected in accordance with the Tennessee Constitution, the United States Constitution, and the Law of God,” the group said in a press release.
Tennessee has had some of the strictest anti-abortion laws in the country since the state’s “trigger ban” took effect in 2022. The Human Life Protection Act prohibits all abortions from fertilization, with no expectation for rape or incenst. Narrow medical exceptions exist for ectopic and molar pregnancies, but does not cover fatal fetal diagnoses.
Performing an abortion is a Class C felony in Tennessee, resulting in up to 15 years in prison and fines for physicians.
In recent years, lawmakers have made it a felony for companies and delivery services to fulfill orders for abortion pills by mail in Tennessee, made it a crime to help a minor travel out of state for an abortion without parental consent and required school children to watch a video on fetal development.
A measure to encode women’s access to contraception and in-vitro fertilization care very narrowly passed the House of Representatives last year. A group of lawmakers urged Gov. Bill Lee to veto the bill.
Legislation is currently pending that seeks to heavily regulate IVF.
Rep. Monty Fritts, R-Kingston, who has signed on to the bill as co-sponsor, and is running for governor, has repeatedly expressed support for imposing the death penalty on women who receive abortions.
“Murder is murder. I know that’s hard for people to hear, and I don’t mean to be hard with it, I promise,” Fritts recently told the Tennessee Holler, later likening abortion-inducing pills to “a cyanide capsule.”
Fritts said he feels abortion should be considered a “capital crime because we have failed to identify that tiny little, jelly-bean-sized baby as a human being. If we kill a human being, we have to say it is murder."
Fritts did not respond to a request for comment from The Tennessean.
Tags
Who is online
86 visitors
And birth control pills/devices/condoms aren't accessories????
They aren't 100% effective either.
But, according to the logic of these two "representatives" and "church leaders", they are "potentially" killing the "unborn" "tiny little, jelly-bean-sized baby as a human being" since the contraceptives are supposedly stopping an unborn's birth.
I would love to see their proof. This is religious theocracy run amuck. Sickening.
So the plan is to murder 15,000 TN women per year? Welcome to Iran.
And they consider themselves a pro life state. The irony...
Is there where the round peg meets the square hole?
We used to have a workable national "consensus"/compromise on abortion. Even the great Carl Sagan, the best explainer of science of our lifetimes , said compromise was the most logical thing to do. It is impossible to "win" a debate on the topic.
Except the compromise was set by the wrong branch. It should have been set by Congress, not by the Judicial. I said it when they first overturned Roe v Wade that a federal law was the correct option but due to the split in Congress caused by the two parties I didn't think it would be settled any time soon. So we end up with this patchwork of laws that is very much like the 1960's.
It's really a shame, compromise used to be how Congress worked. But the two party system has gained too much power and the extremists from both sides are running the show. It's going to take a lot of time to remove those extremists from power.
If that's even possible anymore.
Right now, no it's not possible. It will take time to get the extremists out of power and the current partisan divide in the country will only delay that from happening.
What are you talking about?
You can't possibly mean the time period between 1973 and 2022 when abortion politics dictated who could be nominated to the Supreme Court when Judges imposed on everyone in the country a regime allowing abortion until birth no matter the people voted for?
People propose things in state legislatures all the time that have zero chance of passing. This is one of them.
Hope you're right.
It is very dangerous in these times to assume anything is too extreme to happen in reality. Look at who is running the FBI.
Morning...well seeing it takes two to tango just so long as they bump of the man as well.
Equal opportunity and all that..
Nah, "pro-life, family values" Tennessee keeps sending Scott DesJarlais, who terrorized his ex-wife, had sex with his patients, and pushed his mistress to get an abortion, to Congress. They don't practice what they preach. Fuckin' hypocrites.
I cannot fathom why in a civilized modern nation such as the USA there exists ANYONE who is so desperately attempting to recreate the Spanish Inquisition.
These people live on another planet.
When will the new laws extend to the dead as well, since " all humans made in the image of God are equally protected in accordance with the Tennessee Constitution, the United States Constitution, and the Law of God,”