Rights group asks for probe into shooting range that refuses to cater to Muslims
Rights group asks for probe into shooting range that refuses to cater to Muslims
By Dylan Stableford, October 9, 2014
Jan Morgan (JanMorganMedia.com)
A Muslim civil rights group is asking the Department of Justice to investigate an Arkansas shooting range whose owner recently declared it a " Muslim-free zone ."
In a letter to U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder , Jenifer Wicks, a lawyer for the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR), writes that the declaration is "a violation of federal laws prohibiting racial and religious discrimination" and "will inevitably result in a hostile environment for ordinary Muslims in Arkansas."
"This is not a coffee and donut shop," Jan Morgan, owner of the Gun Cave Indoor Shooting Range in Hot Springs, Ark., wrote in an online post last month . "This is a live fire indoor shooting range ... Why would I want to rent or sell a gun and hand ammunition to someone who aligns himself with a religion that commands him to kill me?"
Morgan, who says she has "read and studied" the Koran thoroughly, found "109 verses commanding hate, murder and terror against all human beings who refuse to submit or convert to Islam."
"People who shoot at my range come from all religious backgrounds," she wrote. "I do not care about their religious beliefs until or unless those beliefs command them to commit violent crimes against innocent people and I witness those crimes increasing, as we all have lately."
Morgan claims that when she received her license to sell guns, the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives informed her "that if we feel ANY reason for concern about selling someone a firearm, even sense that something is not right about an individual, or if we are concerned about that [person's] mental state, even if they pass a background check, we do not have to sell that person a gun. Two different ATF agents stressed that it is better to err on the side of caution. In other words, a federal agency has given [gun shops] discretion on firearms deals.
"I understand that not all Muslims are terrorists," Morgan continued. "I also believe there are as many Muslims who do not know what is in their Koran as there are Christians who do not know what is in their Bible. Since I have no way of discerning which Muslims will or will not kill in the name of their religion and the commands in their Koran, I choose to err on the side of caution for the safety of my patrons."
In the letter to Holder, Wicks writes that Morgan "appears to be misinterpreting the advice given to her and refusing service to all Muslims, which cannot be a correct interpretation of compliance with federal gun laws and the U.S. Constitution."
But according to Morgan who says she has received death threats from Muslims in the past the Sept. 11, 2001, terror attacks; Boston Marathon bombing; Fort Hood massacre; and a recent beheading at an Oklahoma food distribution center justify her ban.
"This is more than enough loss of life on my home soil at the hands of Muslims to substantiate my position that Muslims can and may follow the directives in their Koran and kill here at home," she wrote.
CAIR sent copies of its letter to the governor of Arkansas, U.S. Justice Department's Civil Rights Division, U.S. Commission on Civil Rights, the U.S. Attorney for the Western District of Arkansas and the ATF's Little Rock field office.
Morgan responded on her Facebook page : "Its easy for CAIR to bully and threaten average American citizens like me who have a business to lose and a life to destroy. It's what they do. We are the easy targets. Ive been a target of Islamist threats for five years ... fully expecting at any time one of them to follow through with the threat. I may go down for speaking the truth about Islam ... I may lose everything I have, (which isn't much) but they can't take my integrity ... This is a mountain Im willing to die on."
http://news.yahoo.com/muslim-free-gun-range-arkansas-160333108.html

An interesting argument.
C'mon Mike, show some tolerance. I'm sure she just wants to practice her squirrel shooting.
There are a lot of different aspects to this. Here are two that immediately come to mind:
1. If someone argues that the Koran contains verses ordering the killing of non-Muslims, a counter to that might be that other religions have holy books that advocate violence-- and most people don' take those verses literally.
But here's the catch (& many non-Muslims are unaware of this)-- it is an inherent part of Islam that the Koran is the exact word of God. Not so much as one period changed-- to say otherwise is heresy. (And BTW, this is a big deal in Islam-- I've seen non-Muslims arguing with Muslims that its inevitable that in all those years since the time of Muhammed (Peace Be Upon him) there must've been some changes-- even minor ones. But Muslims argue quite passionately that not even a single letter has been changed. And that none of it is "figurative"-- that it must be taken literally!
2. Prejudice is wrong-- and the overwhelming majority of Muslims would never commit acts of terror.
But the reality is that many people don't know that-- they have the false belief that many, many Muslims are violent. So-- even though that belief is false, if many of this women's customers believe it, they might no longer go to her shooting range but go elsewhere. Should she be forced to admit people-- even a single person-- if that would cause her to lose customers?
Why on earth does she think this will scare away her customers?
If she allows "Militia groups" (many are considered Christian and " extremist ") to use her facilities, it would severely dilute any legal claim she might have.
Maybe so, but would there be a particular direction in the bible for a Militia group (Christian and "extremist") to kill or harm her, whereas there are many directions in the Koran to kill or harm "infidels".
My comment was based more on legal sense. IF a case were brought up against her for illegal discrimination, she cannot use what the ATF agents said as a defense. But even what the agents said has has a disclaimer, "Two different ATF agents stressed that it is better to err on the side of caution."...key words; "err on the side of caution" meaning If you not sure, better to violate the law and let the courts work it out.
Her case hinges on proof, not hearsay or bias. She has to provide a defense for violating the law, aside from what she hears, what she believes and/or what her gut feeling says. Clothing, skin color, language and religion are not proof that those who want to use her public range are doing so with the intent on committing a crime, such as terrorism. That's a "slippery slope."
As for the holy books, it depends on who interpreted them. Both contain symbolic and figurative language. Christian militia, for example, think they are defending a Christian nation from the evil clutches of secular humanism...among other things, ordained by their bible.
She is one ballsy lady, and I salute her!!
I'd just put up a picture of Mohammed with a 9 year old girl and write "Pedophile Prophet" under it. If someone turns purple and starts muttering in Arabic, deny them entrance!
If you did, you can join Salman Rushdie.
Personally, I'd like to see if this case goes to court. It has already been legally established that public places of business cannot discriminate on the bases of race, culture, gender, national origin, religion (or lack thereof) or sexual preference. An example would be the Lakewood, Colorado bakery that unlawfully discriminated against a gay couple by refusing to sell them a wedding cake.
What ever happened in the case the hijab-wearing girl brought against Abercrombie & Fitch?
1) Abercrombie & Fitch to Face Supreme Court Over Hijab Controversy - This falls under the jurisdiction of the EEOC (Equal Employment Opportunity Commission) and is on the Supreme Courts docket this session.
2) Court Rules Bakery Illegally Discriminated Against Gay Couple - This fell under the Colorado Civil Rights Division (CCRD) and was adjudicated at that level.
While both involved alleged discrimination, they are covered under different sets of laws.
If and when this gets to court, the woman is going to lose. If she has the money to go through appeals up to the SC, it'll take time for her to lose, but legally this is an open & shut case. There is no more legal justification for a business to proclaim a'Muslim-Free Zone' than there is for a 'Christian-Free Zone', a 'Mormon-Free Zone', or a 'Jew/Black/Gay/Mexican/Female/(fill-in-the-blank)-Free Zone'. If Jan Morgan's 'position' is sincere (I'm more inclined to view it as a publicity stunt), then she's a fool who's going to see her business go down the tubes.
Anybody want to place bets on whether the NRA offers to pick up the tab for her attorneys?
'
I don't think the NRA will touch this issue - it has nothing to do with the right to own guns, but is an issue dealing with religion.
Some unrelated things.
From my perspective,
Win, Lose or Draw; she ahead.
You just proved her point.
I, being a Canadian and not entirely knowledgeable of American Law, am curious about something, (not that I agree with it), but perhaps those of you who defend so strongly your American Constitution, its Amendments, Bill of Rights, in the name of "Freedom" can answer it for me.
How can you say you have "Freedom" when you open a business and are so restricted in what you can and can not do, such as who MUST be your customers.*
*This question is not aimed at those who realize that Freedom has MANY limitations to the extent that perhaps it isn't Freedom at all.
I suppose the short answer to that would be that "freedom" is relative.
And often a country is not totally consistent-- for example, country A's laws might provide for more freedom than country B in some areas-- but the reverse may be true in others.
I believe the U.S.has much greater freedom of speech than Canada & most of Europe, for example.
I think that's mainly true-- at least in the short term. However, over time, the situation is often a bit more complicated.
The purpose of the U.S. Civil Rights movement was to end discrimination, especially segregation & ensuring that blacks have the right to vote.
One of the common arguments against this from "moderate" segregationists (or at least those pretending to be moderate) was that
By this they meant that changing realities by legislation would not make the people who thought that Blacks were inferior--and.or hated them-- would have their minds changed by legislation aimed at ending discrimination.
Were they right?
I think that initially they were-- but over time there's been an overall change in both behaviour and attitude towards American Blacks-- especially noticeable in the South.
The only way around it that I can think of would be to make those businesses private meaning a membership program to be accepted. That would take the "public" part out of the equation. This brings up an interesting question as to where a Costco, or BJs would fall under that category.
True, private clubs can generally discriminate based on Constitutional right of freedom of association. However, the overall question of what is considered "private" is still a legal issue being tossed around.
With COSTCO, to belong all you need to do is pay dues. With women's only health clubs, you cannot be a male (and of course pay dues). In this gun range case, going private with a clause stipulating, let's say, Christians only, is perfectly legal.
She could still include both gun sales and gun range into one single club. The essence behind all of this is the language that is used to "privatize" a business. You'll note I stated "Christians only" as opposed to "no Muslims". One is "inclusive", the other, "exclusive." In general, the more clauses or rules you have containing inclusive language, the better. However the downside, at least for a business, would be a loss of customers plus the laws can be finicky.
Consider;
How this would work for a for-profit business, I don't know.
There is a case here in town in which the landlord is a Muslim. He rented a building to a fellow who opened a BBQ restaurant. The Muslim fellow refuses to allow the restauranteur to serve pork in his BBQ restaurant.
well said. agree.
Warning: jwc and Mike, you are getting out of control. Please bring this conversation back to content and not each other. Any other personal attack will be deleted.