Pedophilia: A Disorder, Not a Crime
By some estimates, 1 percent of the male population continues, long after puberty, to find themselves attracted to prepubescent children. These people are living with pedophilia, a sexual attraction to prepubescents that often constitutes a mental illness. Unfortunately, our laws are failing them and, consequently, ignoring opportunities to prevent child abuse.
The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders defines pedophilia as an intense and recurrent sexual interest in prepubescent children, and a disorder if it causes a person marked distress or interpersonal difficulty or if the person acts on his interests. Yet our laws ignore pedophilia until after the commission of a sexual offense, emphasizing punishment, not prevention.
Part of this failure stems from the misconception that pedophilia is the same as child molestation. One can live with pedophilia and not act on it. Sites like Virtuous Pedophiles provide support for pedophiles who do not molest children and believe that sex with children is wrong. It is not that these individuals are inactive or nonpracticing pedophiles, but rather that pedophilia is a status and not an act. In fact, research shows, about half of all child molesters are not sexually attracted to their victims.
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/06/opinion/pedophilia-a-disorder-not-a-crime.html?_r=2

Gee, that's comforting ! What a crock of crap article !!! What's next, the poor sado-masochist is misunderstood ?
''not attracted to their victims''...Geez, that makes the victims feel so much better.
I agree pat, a piece of crap article.
I am going to barf.
There is definitely treatment for a pedophile and for a child molester.... kill on sight.
Ditto Pat's first comment and in addition I'm taking the child's side as the victim and to hell with the pedophile. Seems with the Islamic Fascist like ISIS and many of these people, they marry children who haven't even reached puberty.
Did you read the article ? It's a big apology for pedophilia.
OMG... blech.
OMG!!
I don't know if you are addressing me Pat, but yes I read the article. That's why I dittoed or agreed with your first comment and the remark about the Islamic Fascist refers to the way there must me a lot of Islamic Fascist pedophiles as they take on wives who are really children most of the time which would be pedophilia as well or they would choose something other than a little 8 or 9 year old girl which is more of a sarcasm toward the accepted lifestyle in some Muslim countries. You must have been referring to someone else. I certainly understand the article was apologizing for pedophiles saying they were sick or had a mental disorder, we should help them overcome their desires and child molestation is an entirely different thing all together.
The medical community has for years thought they could "cure" and "treat" psychopaths, who have then been released back into society only to do further mortal harm. Pedophiles/child molesters fall into that category as well.
I have noted that most of the pedophiles I have chanced to read about are in the upper class; whether that is because their stories are more sensational because of their money and positions I don't know. But I do know that if they are "born that way" in the same way that homosexuals are hardwired toward their sexual preferences, then pedophiles cannot be "cured" of their sexual desire for children. Neither can it be tolerated.
The line about them not being sexually attracted to their victims is bull crap, and in any case makes no difference at all when they commit the crime.
The best solution is bullet to the brain.
Yes, I do.
Speaking of which, I wonder if New York ever made that Muslim Imam fix the slum apartments he owned that were such a hazard. He was the first guy that was in control of the development of the new Twin Towers Muslim center; we gave him lots of money to travel around the world to promote "understanding" of Muslim-Western relationships, before it was discovered he was about to be arrested for not appearing in court to answer charges he had failed to fix dangerous violations in his buildings where low income families were living... after being ordered by the court to do so.
Their rent was being subsidized by state money and the renters were Muslim and Hispanic immigrants. He had already failed to appear in court three times on the charges and they were threatening to take the apartments away from him. He also owed taxes on them.
I should inform them I'm willing to do the work Pro Bono; maybe they will keep me on.
You have been offering more reasoned and substantive comments lately, flame, and it has been refreshing.
On this one, I am going to say I disagree with you when you call the reactions "foolish." It is those reactions that result in an overabundance of caution to keep our children away from such people when it is obvious our courts won't do it. It is not our responsibility to hold the hands of such people and "feel" for them.
To help them would take a lifetime of care and understanding and most parents don't have that energy to give; we have all we can handle to give it to our children during their brief, intense stay in our homes before they fly out into the world on their own.
I don't care about pedophiles and child molesters. They need to be permanently removed from civil society. If the medical and science people want to study them, they should do so while they have them under controlled conditions, and I don't mean put an electronic monitor on them and tell them they can have several hours where they don't have to account for their whereabouts.
As Spock has said many tiimes, "The needs of the many outweigh the need of the one."
While this affliction certainly does result in many offenses that make people say things like "the only cure for people like you is a bullet in the head", I think it's important to realize that there are way more people out there that are attracted to children and in control of their sickness.
In a couple of Richard Dawkins' books he describes an instance as a child where a pedophile priest at his school had slipped his hand down the front of Dawkins' pants. He was mortified by it, and that teacher (whose problem was widely known about by the students) eventually committed suicide, but Dawkins recognized that it wasn't an incident that ended up having a lasting impact on him. Somewhere there is a line where a bullet is warranted, but let's be realistic about where that line isn't.
OK, I can buy that this is a mental disorder. I mean, something has to be wrong with these people... But it is a crime against humanity, ruining/harming thousands and thousands of lives. Since there appears to be no effective treatment, and no effective "cure", what do we do?
Is there a way to "screen" for it? Can it be treated? Do we wait for one of them to molest a child until we put them in jail? Can we put them in jail for a long time? Can we develop a "cure" for it? Can we lock them up somewhere for the criminally insane so that they have to get some kind of treatment and not set free to harm more children?
In my honest opinion, simply because it is a disorder, does not give one a free ride to practice it. No more so than the psychopath who murders someone...
The whole article makes me sick to my stomach.
If the history of homosexuality is an indication, then pedophilia is moving to stage two (pathology). Homosexuality was initially a sin/crime. Later, it was downgraded to a mental disorder because people with an illness are less blameworthy than sinners and criminals. Then it was removed from the list of mental disorders (mostly for political reasons). Following that, it was an issue of tolerance. Later it became acceptable as just one behavior on the sexual continuum. Now it's becoming an immutable characteristic or identity, like race and gender. So, after the children's rights movement for sexual equality, expect pedophiles to argue that they're no different from anybody else and all laws restricting them are unlawfully discriminatory.
Just so you know, I find your views equally repugnant.
Flame-- we'll see. I should have added polygamy because that prohibition will fall next.
I threw in polygamy already in response to Flame and, yep,bestialityshould have been included as well. Thanks for reminding me of the slippery slope your view poses.
I tend to disagree a mental disorder perhaps but a learned activity for many. Often from a parent, grand parent other relative or neighbor or church or school employee. Pedophiles are of both sexes and rape or sexually abuse same sex or opposite sex children.
Society has for way to long covered up or ignored stopping known sex offenders. If you want to know how many live in your area call the local sheriff. When I was in early years of college our course on abnormal psychology showed that 1 in every three women have been sexually molested as a child or teenager. Stupid statements and media expanding the no means yes fallacy should not be tolerated. I would not doubt that the percentages are worse now.
The Media starting with FOX NEWS needs to be held liable with the all the rest.
screminmimi - I agree the very problem proliferates because of people not taking this seriously and by not watching for the signs of change in behavior of children or adults towards their children. Children crave attention and all to often get the wrong kind.
Yep but don't give them meds or counseling and then put them back out on the streets to be your neighbors or church members or teachers or or where they can make contact with your children in any way.
I'll be part of the firing squad. They are never cured/never .... if there is one in your family turn them in. I know of two who are dead hope they burn for eternity. People who believe in reincarnation man I hope they are wrong.
You managed to marrypolygamyand bestiality (woman marries flock of sheep) to create a new perversion as you slide. Make all the sheep female and you can slip even further. Or perhaps the woman used to be a man and the sheep are dead so you can work in transgender andnecrophilia.
No, it isn't, for sure. It is a difficult subject and a difficult thing to even think about. I don't know what to do. And that's the truth!
Having been a child approached by a pedophile (on more than oneoccasion) and having raised a child myself, I think the most effective course of action is toinoculateyour child with a healthydoseof common sense. "Don't ever go anywhere alone with a stranger (no matter what story they cook up) and an adult (outside a doctor's office) has nobusiness concerning himself with anything in your underwear."
I was addressing Robert G. The article was making pedophilia into a disease. And therefore pedophiles are "misunderstood". Bullshit !
Pedophilia is a criminal, deviant behavior. If it's a disease or mental illness maybe the pedophile should consider chemical castration, which would result in no offspring, two birds with one stone !
Chemical castration might help.
The key difference is that a pedophile preys on children, homosexuals aren't known to prey on children.
My "bullet to the brain" remark was, of course, made on the emotional level, and that is what I would give a pedophile who touched one of my kids. There is no way I would ever trust the courts to take care of it.
One of the things I have noticed when I read about crimes of pedophilia is that so very often the children are found dead and show signs of having been tortured beyond the sex act. For this reason it is my feeling that castration, physical nor chemical, would be of no benefit to the personality types who take pleasure in the pain of others.
Pedophiles seem to run the gauntlet of all ages. I've read news articles of disgusting trolls who raped babies and toddlers. There are those who prefer children five, six, seven, ten years old. There are those grown men who want sex with teens.
So it's not as if a blanket statement can be issued to say "all pedophiles prefer teenage girls fifteen and sixteen years of age."
I will say in closing that with the majority of the news articles I have read, the bullet to the brain sounds the better solution.... or I could go for "attack by dog."
Yes. And bank robbery is also a "disorder", not a crime. (Other research has shown that half of all bank robbers are not attracted to money)!
(/sarcasm)
I hate to say it but you seem to know a lot about pedophiles.
Give me a break !
Seriously !!!
Your first sentence is correct. Your second couldn't be more wrong.
That raises an interesting question-- what sort of asocial behaviour is normal-- and what is not? Is it "normal" to enter a liquor store, demand cash, then shoot the person behind the register? And battered wives...is it "normal" for a man to repeatedly and brutally beat his wife for years?
Do robbers and wife-beaters choose to behave like that-- or is it "an affliction"?
I remember reading an article about a serial killer who when caught said it wasn't his fault because the voices in his head told him to do it. (If true-- would that excuse what he did? And-- what if he was lying and there were no voices?)
Which brings up a much wider issue-- to what do degree should we hold people responsible for their actions? (I don't know the answer, just raising the question).
There was a incident once, where someone broke into her car while she was at work and stole her purse that was hidden under the seat. She was fucking PISSED because she knew it had to be one of her deviant clients. The cop asked if she had any idea who might have done it. She said: "Smell their hands. It was one of these motherfuckers, and I'm positive that when they found my lavender hand cream they could not possibly resist jacking off with it, because it smells like me." He wouldn't follow her suggestion, but I bet she was right and whoever it was was probably sweating when she said that. The more deviant ones had a deep resentment about having to participate in this group counseling, particularly when it was head by a female.
The statement is 100% correct based on the plain meaning of both the words "homosexual" and "pedophile." To be clear, Websters defines the term "homosexual" to mean "relationship to or characterized by atendency to direct sexual desire toward a member of the same sex." A 'boy" is defined as "a male child." A "pedophile" is one "afflictedwith pedophilia" and "pedophilia is "sexual perversion in which children are the preferred sexual object."Boys and men are both male. Therefore, a man who has sex with a boy is a homosexual pedophile.
I worded it so any fool couldunderstandit and I see I hit my target.
If you weren't so obsessed with the vision of a penises mingling with anuses, then you might just be able to envision how small a part sex plays in a meaningful relationship. Why are you so obsessed with other people's sex lives anyways?
Thanks but you may keep it and follow the direction yourself.
Actually, I was simply defining terms rather than thinking about mingling penises and anuses. I have no interest in other people's sex lives and, in fact, that's my point. If you, and others like you, keep your perversion behind closed doors, then I would have no interest and no comment on what you do. If you put the perversion in public and demand that it be accepted as normal, then I'm going to express my opinion. Period.
As I explained to you once before and will do so again, if you call me ahomophobefor my views then I will label you a pervert for yours.
On behalf of the rest of us, you need to do the same.
My reference to "the rest of us" wasn't limited to the infinitesimalpercentage of the population that expresses views onthisforum. I was referring to a broader population that does not see perversion as a civil right or misuse the term bigot to apply to those who see unnatural relationships as abnormal.
Thisconversationis pointless. You can't believe that you have to explain something and I can'tbelieveyou think you have anything worth explaining. You think I'm fucked upand I damn sure think the same thing about you. That's how we started; that's how it ends. Have a nice weekend.
Why do you think its "deviant"? what is that based upon?
How do you define which forms of sexual behaviour are "deviant" & which are not?
IF you are going to parse this down to the word level, the title of the piece is correct, regardless of what ones personal feelings are on the matter. Words do have meanings, as much as the pundits try to make words have the meanings that they would prefer, and it is important to recognize these meenings for the sake of rational discussion.
Pedophilia: A Disorder, Not a Crime
So by that reasoning murder and carjacking and assault etc.... are not crimes but disorders instead.
Yeah right.
1 - Pedophilia once was thought to stem from psychological influences early in life. Now, many experts view it as a deep-rooted predisposition that does not change . - Source
2 - I have found no bona fide medical journal or source that says pedophilia is related to homosexuality.
3 - Being a pedophile is one thing, acting on it is another. Concerning the latter, it is extremely illegal as judged by a civilized society and punishable accordingly.
4 - Pedophilia does not appear to be curable, as shown by its rate of Recidivism .
Sorry - Pessimism about Pedophilia
It brings up recidivism and the apparent lack of a cure for pedophilia.
All things considered, I'll follow bona fide medical research and studies as opposed the the easily skewed DOJ statistics. Reducing recidivism of pedophilia crimes is not the same as curing the disease itself. Just because the rate may be falling is not an indicator that those infected will not do so again.
Those pedophiles whom have had psychological therapy are indeed likely not to commit such crimes again IF they stay on the therapy. In a manner of speaking, you have offered proof that medical intervention is the key to criminal pedophile crimes meaning that is is a disease.
The DOJ stats only report that the rate has gone down. It does NOT explain how or why. When the weather is below zero, certain crimes drop such as breaking and entering decline sharply. As soon as it warms up, the crime raises back again.
Crime rates are a barometer. Short term drops, such as the DOJ stats imply, only state that the rates are down. They do not point out the cause for that.
There are other factors involved, such as how crimes are reported to the DOJ. Consider this incident; Hundreds of assault cases misreported by Milwaukee Police Department . Simply by redefining what a crime is, the police can look good. These stats were reported to the DOJ which skews their data.
They are obviously related in that they are both deviant sexual behaviors and clearly intersect when male adult homosexuals have sex with boys. Your attempt to define homosexuality as never related to pedophilia is beyond ridiculous. Homosexuality is a same sex attraction. Both men and boys are members of the same sex. If that weren't enough, NAMBLA is an actual organization of homosexuals openly promoting sex with boys. But you close your eyes. I can venture a guess as to why but I'll spare you that.
Homosexuals have banded together, not to get treatment, but to force society to bend reality to accommodate a mental disorder. Your confusion on multiple levels, coupled with a limited understanding of logic and the English language, makes you the perfect enabler. If you're an example of the confusion the 21st century has to offer, then the 19th will appear like a golden age by comparison.
With obsessive determination, homosexuals have turned society upside down. However, homosexuality is a behavior not an immutable characteristic. Attitudes toward behaviors change so all that has been done can be undone and the world set right side up again . . . In time.
Let me just say that I don't claim to "get it" - that is, I don't understand how a man could be interested in an intimate relationship with another man. But I don't need to get that, just like how I don't need to get how anyone can enjoy Lima beans, which I consider to be gross.
My step son is gay, and he and his partner are two of the most respectable, fun, intelligent, and hard working people in my life. A few weeks he showed me a facebook picture of a girl he dated in college, and she was seriously beautiful. Without exaggeration, this woman looked like a Miss American contender. He's a good looking kid too, but she looked way out of his league. He broke up with her, and they remain good friends. He's even good friends with her current boyfriend. Your idiotic assertion that there is no genetic component to sexuality, and the countless horrible statements you have made about homosexuals based on that flawed reasoning, is repulsive.
By the way, I've known far more gay people throughout my life than just my stepson. Don't pretend like my example is just some anomaly anecdote. I have to presume that there is a religious component to your extreme bigotry. It sickens me to think that you likely see yourself as due for a reward in the great beyond by expressing such hideous hatred for your fellow man. In this respect, you are a truly sickening individual. You are the one who needs help.
No. Pedophilia is the psychological condition. Sexual contact with a minor is the crime.
From Wikipedia :
If by that you mean that there are adults that get off sexually on little kids .... well yeah.
I get off on adult women, that is my orientation, a pedophiles orientation is for little children so why is their orientation called a psychological condition and mine is not, it sounds as though they are using psychological mumbo jumbo to justify and excuse their criminal tendencies to hurt children.
I agree with that absolutely, and that is why I don't think they should hide behind psychological excuses for their criminal acts. My pre-eminent concern is that the children be protected and that the child rapist should suffer serious punishment for their crimes against children.
Your condition is called heterosexuality.
I wonder, do you act on every impulse that happens to wander through your brain? Are your impulses so strong that when you see a very attractive woman, you feel compelled to ask for sex? Or maybe you instead do not act on thosethoughts?
This is the distinction that the article is drawing: There are people who are attracted to children, yet do not act on those attractions. If they do not act on those attractions, are they still criminals?