Does the "Right to Free Speech" include "the right to not be offended"?
Category: News & Politics
Via: the-irascible-harry-krishner • 12 years ago • 90 commentsDoes it?
╌>
Category: News & Politics
Via: the-irascible-harry-krishner • 12 years ago • 90 commentsDoes it?
Should we have the right to not be offended?
right NOT to be OFFENDED?....just who is going to define what is offensive. I'm sure what might offend you may not be offensive to me or to others.
There is a certain religion that takes punishment of what they perceive as offensive into their own hands, notwithstanding that the punishment they impose can be considerably more extreme than America's justice system permits.
How about speech that offends someone's religious sensibilities-- should people's religious views be protected from being offended?
BTW, it seems the UN thinks so:
What I have found so interesting of late, is this very concept, not only on a macro level, but as illustrated on a smaller scale, like blogging. Folks actually believe sometimes, that it is their god-given right, to not be offended. (that offends me (lol))
Good question. While there is nothing in the constitution that guarantees a right not to be offended (1st amendment wise) nonetheless, it is still a flash point for many people. Take this current example for instance; the Redskins.
Everything about the name smacks of disrespect and offends many people, in particular, the Native Americans. As it is not illegal, other pressures have been put upon the team to change their moniker. Is this Political Correctness run amok?
Speaking of PC, which is directly linked to the concept of not offending people, has that concept been so inordinately pounded into our sensibilities that we consciously make decisions not to offend at the risk of causing even greater harm? Consider the horror that happened in Rotterham, UK.
Consider the Jewish Anti-Defamation League (ADL) whose sole purpose it is to alert people to and defend against antisemitism. The lines get easily crossed when people have legitimate concerns about Israel only to be immediately branded as "antisemitic."
The question here opens a very broad range of topics and scenarios such as to what point does PC, under the guise of not offending people, become offensive in itself.
"The lines get easily crossed when people have legitimate concerns about Israel only to be immediately branded as "antisemitic.""
Educated and intelligent people do not consider criticism of Israel to be anti-Semitic. The Ottawa Protocol, the US Department of State and the European Union, do not consider fair criticism that could be laid upon any other democratic country to be anti-Semitic, nor do I. However, harping over and over again on the point time and time again as in the quoted line above is playing a card that I consider suspect.
Signed,
A Cockroach (a word that should be familiar to you).
Methinks the lad doth protest too much.
Coming from a person who has publicly stated he considers all criticism of Israel to be antisemitic, your comment is rather confusing...to say the least.
Anyways, that was just an example...deal with it.
I would like you to back up your accusation that I have called all criticism of Israel to be anti-Semitic. I have always produced the Ottawa Protocol as the basis of my comments. It says, as you damn well know, the following:
"Examples of the ways in which antisemitism manifests itself with regard to the State of Israel taking into account the overall context could include:
Denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavour.
Applying double standards by requiring of it behaviour not expected or demanded of any other democratic nation.
Using the symbols and images associated with classic antisemitism (e.g. claims of Jews killing Jesus or blood libel) to characterize Israel or Israelis.
Drawing comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy to that of the Nazis.
Holding Jews collectively responsible for actions of the State of Israel.
However, criticism of Israel similar to that levelled against any other country cannot be regarded as antisemitic.
Let it be clear: Criticism of Israel is not antisemitic, and saying so is wrong. But singling Israel out for selective condemnation and opprobrium let alone denying its right to exist or seeking its destruction is discriminatory and hateful, and not saying so is dishonest."
Did you notice the words:
"However, criticism of Israel similar to that levelled against any other country cannot be regarded as antisemitic.
Let it be clear: Criticism of Israel is not antisemitic, and saying so is wrong."
I challenge you to produce an example of where I have said that all criticism of Israel is anti-Semitic. If you cannot do so you are nothing more than a fucking liar.
Does the "Right to Free Speech" include "the right to not be offended"?
Does what I say offend you? Do you feel that you have a right to be offended by lashing out at a mere example? You certainly are all lathered up about this.
You have become a perfect example of the question that was raised here. There will always be people that want to be offended, that look to be offended. so they can vent their spleen on them.
Sorry, but if you want to be offended, start your own thread.
I notice that you are unable to prove your accusation. And yes, I'm offended by liars, especially deliberate unapologetic liars. Comment removed for CoC violation [ph] and I don't need to start my own thread to say so.
Obviously the right to free speech includes the right to be offensive, and the right to lie.
The term ''R*dskins'' is offensive. There is nothing PC about putting pressure on to have the name changed. One only has to understand the true meaning of the word to know that it is offensive.
There are many words that are offensive that are no longer used.Derogatory words describing a persons race. We no longer use certain words to describe, Blacks, Italians, Jews, Orientals, Hispanics etc. is that PC, or is it a bit of respect for a human being?
If a person has the need to use such derogatory words, then I suspect that they are they ones that need mental health help.
The questions I asked in my OP were rhetorical. One man's free speech is another mans hate speech. Where does one draw the line?
I agree, the name has to be changed, but out of respect as opposed to complying to the popular but fuzzy notion of being PC.
The common excuse for using the term is that ''we are honoring you''. That would mean to me, respect. If we wait for those that want to use a racial slur to change out of respect, then it will never change.
When the term is defined as a slur, that's the line not to be crossed.
I doubt that the terms for other races were changed out of respect.
Oh, I see, John. And are you as well going to accuse me of calling people like yourself who disagree at times with Israel's actions anti-Semites? Are you too going to say that people who criticize Israel are always called anti-Semites? If so, join your friend AP and me as well, because since I have on many occasions perhaps more on NV than here been critical of Israel, its government, judiciary, IDF, settlers and Haradim, according to AP and maybe yourself I'm an anti-Semite. Now the Cockroach Club can ridicule me.
It's fair game to ridicule a person who makes ridiculous accusations, don't you think? Tit for tat, as they say.
It seems to me that most of the time that I have invoked the Ottawa Protocol was to emphasize the caveat - that it is NOT anti-Semitic to criticize Israel fairly. Both you and your friend have deliberately missed the point.My "stones" seem to have hit their mark - one unable to back up their lie and the other unable to counter the truth. Two birds with one stone.
As most know I like to show that life imitates art. I'm thinking of Anthony Hopkin's line in the movie "Fracture" when he said "I killed both bastards with one bullet."We had a discussion similar to this on NT a while ago.
People have a right of free speech... the right to be rude, nasty, hateful, boorish, crude and belligerent to others at any time or place. They also have the right to run the risk that the individual with whom they are engaging is more of a badass than they are and can physically beat the crap out of them, or might be like the man in the movie theater and will pull out an equalizer to teach him some manners.
Just because the law says you are entitled to do something doesn't mean you should do it. But by all means, go ahead and make someone's day. There are consequences to every action.
Complete lack of respect and disdain are two very minor but obvious consequences, available even over the internet.
Yes. And actually its not as easy to answer as one might at first think..
While there is nothing in the constitution that guarantees a right not to be offended (1 st amendment wise) nonetheless, it is still a flash point for many people. Take this current example for instance; the Redskins.
Many people believe they have all sorts of "rights". Or "should" have various rights. But under the U.S. system of government, whenever there is uncertainly as to what rights we do or do not have under the law-- like it or not--the Supreme Court is the one to decide.
Well, for starters-- the right to "not be offended" is not a right granted under U.S. law. Of course it is different in different countries...
I believe that that was their initial goal, and is probably still their main goal. However it seems it is currently not their only aim-- they now also work towards opposing bigotry against other groups as well.(Just looked at their site .)
I see this as being about 2 somewhat different things-- what "should" be the way things are. What "should" and "should not" be permitted. This is of course a matter of opinion-- and opinions vary.
But on On another level, what is permitted and what is not permitted legally.
Readers of this column-- DNFFT!
("Do not feed the trolls!")
Good point! (Many people seem to forget that...or maybe they didn't know it in the first place...??)
Another excellent point! (Although there does seem to be a growing trend now-a-days to deny that-- many folks tend to blame the consequences of their actions on other people..or politicians..or "the Commies"...or..whatever)
"Are you talking to me? You talking to me?"
Goebbels said that if you tell a lie enough times people will start to believe that it's the truth. Could that be what I meant, as an EXAMPLE, but I NEVER called you a Hitler crony just because you might have used the same technique as Goebbels. Because I believe in Pantheism, like Spinoza or Einstein, and said so many times, does not mean that I am a Spinoza or an Einstein - far from it.
Goering was the Nazi Air Marshall who stole artworks from Jews. I don't think you'd ever do that.
By the way, I haven't been pissed at you for a long time so why the sudden sensitivity? Are you feeling guilty about something?
Speaking of free speech and the "right" to not be offended..anyone remember these?
Okay, if you weren't offended, what is the relevance of bringing it up now?
I believe they were published in 2005-- so if no one recognizes them, you are forgiven!
DNFTT!
Flame, when it comes to acronyms I'm a novice. Obviously you were angered by the letters DNFTT. I have no idea what they mean. What do they mean.
Kids who love to spend their time texting use acronyms and short forms a lot, I know. If I use acronyms it's because they're common and well known e.g. USA, UN, WTF, LMAO, NATO, etc. Can I guess what DNFTT means? How about "Dunces never fart two times", or how about "Do not fucking tell tales", or "Darling, next five times try", or "Donuts not fit to taste"....
No sweat. I knew you directed your comment to Krishna, not to me.
1) It was a good question, past tense. However I dont see it as a topic that can be discussed in this forum intelligently and unemotionally. Pity.
2) The Supreme Court has already ruled many times in regards to the Freedom of Speech and has never ruled in favor of the imaginary right not to be offended In fact, the SCOTUS ruled in Snyder v. Phelps that such a right does not exist.
3) Of course.
4) What ever their stated mission might be is irrelevant to the fact that as an organization, criticism about it and what they do, is protected speech.
5) There are limitations to the Freedom of Speech but none of them reflect the idea of a right not to be offended.
I didn't call you Goebbels. I may have said you used his technique.
Freedom of Speech is a sacrosanct right. Prudence, in exercising that right, is another issue altogether.
If I said that you had the same love of Corgi dogs as Queen Elizabeth I'm not calling you a queen, English or a woman, nor am I suggesting that in any way you resemble Queen Elizabeth other than resembling her love of those dogs. All I am saying is that you love Corgi dogs as much as she does. If Winston Churchill or Jack Kennedy or Humphrey Bogart or Frank Sinatra had said that if you tell a lie enough times naive people might believe it to be true I would have used them as examples, but they didn't say it. Does that mean to you that I am comparing you to Winston Churchill or Jack Kennedy or Humphrey Bogart or Frank Sinatra? NO. So you shouldn't create what I might have been suggesting other than what I WAS suggesting. Don't let your imagination run away with you.
Unfortunately, Goebbels was the only person who said it. Had it been Aristotle or Charlie McCarthy or Jesus Christ or Micky Mouse (the Disney one, not Randy) or Pogo who said it I would have used them. I thought I made that point. That's it - not worth belabouring it any further. I'm going out for a walk.
DNFTT is pretty mild actually. (A lot milder than, for example, an MLA such as FOAD! )
Heh
Back up your accusation. Put to public view the examples of which you speak. As well, what do you mean by "an indirect way"? Innuendo is a nice tool that you use, John, but intelligent people will not be impressed by it.
Most of the time I've invoked the Ottawa Protocol is to underline the caveat, as I said above. If I invoke the Ottawa Protocol to establish that a remark is anti-Semitic, there are obviously more opinions that mine, and ones in high places (including your own government), who are making the accusation.
You whole comment is BS...You have no frickin idea about the how long this has been an issue. And your comment about ''none of them are Native American'', is so off base that it's laughable.
It's you that doesn't know a damn thing about it. Throwing insults is all you have.
Sad that you use the avatar of ''Future Legal Eagle'', since you are far from having the knowledge to quality.
You missed the point and disregard the American Indian point of view, A, as do many discriminatory folks pretending not to be discriminatory. The white guy's view prevails yet again (umm......what's that called?) and those offended minorities should just take a Xanax cause you know better? Defining being an offended minority as a mental health issue is righteous bigotry and nothing less.
Additional education never hurts and sometimes it helps.
You certainly have no knowledge of Indian affairs, which you make quite clear.
IfIoffend you, so be it.
Interesting. You get to have an opinion and express it, but I don't? hee hee hee.
If you're sitting in a restaurant and the couple at the next table has a cranky baby, you have the right of free speech to tell them, "That damn screaming brat is ruining my freaking dinner and should be wearing a muzzle and to top it off it's the ugliest rat I've ever seen."
The parents at point may choose to tell you where you can shove your dinner, or the father may choose to beat the crap out of you for your freedom of speech, or he may have a CC weapon and choose to blow your brains out all over your dinner.
Which is why the right to do something doesn't always mean it is the best choice at the moment. Socially acceptable behavior used to be taught at home and reinforced by schools and religious institutions. Today's society has lost that grounding on all three levels for most young people who grow up to become carbon copies of entertainment whores whose outrageous behavior ensures them media coverage. They don't realize they are not covered by the same armor of wealth and privilege.
...
Back on topic and away from personal attacks. You haven't read this yet, have you? Please do. It will give you some insight. Let me know what you think of the article. Indian Country Today is one of those "front line" groups you wondered about.
May I interject here. That may be true in the real world, but it is not allowed by the CoC here. May I remind all of you, that the CoC was written by the group and that I and the other mods only enforce it. It is up for review and revision next week. If you want any change, please feel free to express that in the discussion.. or for that matter any other issues on the site.
Thanks for reminding me...Freedom of Speech only applies to the government and public places. It does not apply to private places, businesses, schools, etc which is why all such places, including this forum, may legally limit or curtail speech based on their own criteria.
...
...
...
...
Seems that your comment re Native Americans not involved or caring is false FLE.
As does flame, I most often enjoy your comments.
You are wrong about this topic and about Kavika, who is Ojibwe, and Grump as well. Do you know what the term means? Its origin described the bloody bounty paid for scalps of Native American men, women and children. It is offensive to many Indians, and they wish it gone.
Kavika is known to many of us as our Teacher and Friend in Native American affairs, and few are as knowledgeable across a wide swath of Nations and tribes, including indigenous peoples around the globe with whom he has lived.
Grump is a dear friend of Native Americans and indigenous people in the area in which he lives and is also quite knowledgeable.
Please take a moment and follow the link he provided. Thank you.
mimi
Though you may have lived so close to a reservation, you may not be aware than the American Indian is the last minority in this country to begin to assert the right to stand up for their right to free speech and to be treated with the respect and dignity demanded by other minorities.
We do not have the political clout nor the activists nor the media followers enjoyed by other minorities. In some parts of the country, Indians are still being run off the roads, pulled from their cars and beaten with chains, tire irons and baseball bats simply for being Indian and caught off the reservation.
Law enforcement, upon finding the bleeding Indians unconscious on the side of the road, might or might not send them to the hospital or to the local jails, and will ask them, "What did YOU do to incite this?"
To say this name was not a problem ten years ago is inaccurate; better to say that ten years ago, or at the inception of the team and its origin of the name, Indians had no clout to protest its naming and only now, with the aid of the Internet, cell phones that capture video and photos... the instant world-wide news that won't allow discrimination by wealth and law enforcement to hide their actions... Indians can now step forward with free speech to voice their discontent.
One question: Have you followed Grump's link to Indian Nation ro read about how Indians really feel about this? Seeing as how you stated that it's only a few white people who are going on about this, it would seem that you would want to hear from "real Indians" how they feel about it.
Thank you for taking the time to read my response.
mimi
How far do you live from the Oneida Tribe, FLE? Just down the road from you, right? Please walk on the rezervation and go in one of the grocery stores and yell "Hey, redskins !!" and see what happens. The Oneida have been leaders in the fight against the team name "Redskins" for years.
Education doesn't always happen in only the classroom. Sometimes it's on the streets and that's a dandy place to learn the realities of the world around us.
Yes, it did get lost in the translation. Indians have been fighting this name since the 1960's. It is not something new that just jumped into the American conscious. The American Indian Movement (AIM) has been a long time opponent of the name. Dennis Banks, Russell Means etc have been very clear about it. There have been court cases involving the term name.
When the name is associated with the massacre of a people, and the taking of their scalps, or in some instances their entire head for a bounty paid by the federal government or in some cases states, their should not be any question that it is very derogatory. Or, as in this case the dictionary defines it as a slur, should be enough for people to want the name changed.
If, as Snyder claims it is ''honoring'' us, then he should ask a real Indian if they feel honored. Yet, he has never done that, nor has he or the NFL met with an Indian group. In fact they have avoided it. He was said that the original owner of the team, claimed the team was named to honor us. In Geo. Marshall Preston's own words, he said it was not named to honor Indians. This is a fact in writing and Marshall's own words. The next lie that Snyder uses is that the first coach of the team was Indian. Again a lie, Dietz by his own birth certificate was born in WI. of German parents. Not in SD as a part Lakota Indian as he claimed. Interesting to note that he was also accused and tried for trying to dodge the draft in WWI by claiming he was an Indian and exempt from the draft.
There are some minds that will not be changed, just as the stopping the use of the N word hasn't changed some peoples minds. That does not mean that it should be allowed to be continued.
It should be noted that George Preston Marshall was a racist. He was forced by the US government to use black players in the early 1960's.
I'm sorry, FLE. Your above comment doesn't hold water. If it did, there would be no point in trying to erase the derogatory word "nigger" from the vocabulary of our nation.
The word is derogatory and racist to those it depicts. That alone is enough to have the logo changed on the face of it. Take into consideration the chain of restaurants that used to be called "Little Black Sambo's." Great food, clean establishments, well established. After the Civil Rights era, the name was deemed racist and offensive and after reiterations the stores were sold to different chains, several of them to Denny's.
Not using the word "nigger" anymore does not by any means stop some people from thinking it in their heads or stop racists from believing it in their hearts; but it is the right thing to do out of respect for the Black population in this country.
That is the same respect and consideration Native Americans are working for, and you trying to sugarcoat it with your rationalization in the above post by saying:
has made me lose patience with attempts to explain the situation from the Indian's point of view. I have attorneys in my family, and seeing both sides of an issue is crucial in strategy. Tunnel vision is rarely an asset in a courtroom.
All in all, I have followed with great interest the argument between "Future Legal Eagle" (hereinafter referred to as FLE) and others. Although FLE has professed considering both sides of the issue, I doubt that he has done so with genuine sincerity, for had he done so he would have admitted that the argument of others is not without merit. One of the first things one learns in law school is that there are at least two sides to every story, and a good litigation lawyer would have to know his opponent's side as well as his own. One cannot know the Indian viewpoint well without realizing that it has merit.
Noting that some of his remarks had to be obliterated due to CoC offences, perhaps other qualities of a good lawyer might be integity, patience and lack of arrogance. Holding oneself out as being a future "legal eagle" is to declare a superiority that just might be considered arrogant. Some of the language I have seen used confirms it.
FLE should display those qualities in order to gain the respect of others. Failing a better example, think of Atticus Finch as a role model - many in the judicial system have done so, and most likely still do.
Spoken by one who has had some experience in what we sometimes call the second oldest profession.
Comment removed for CoC violation It takes a while to learn to accept advice gracefully. Humility is a virtue that should come with maturity.
A read of FLE's blog post on the right, seems to support your conclusions and position, Buzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz.
Here's a thought; if the "right to lie" were Constitutional, the charge of "perjury" would be "unconstitutional."
Good point, A.Mac
Buzz, your comment bordered on the personal there. Talk about skirting the CoC. Please keep it within the lines, as you are professing to do.
Hey you pesky fish... I have a hit out on you and he's holding your bowl of water for ransom.
[Perrie looks for a noose to put around her neck] There was one comment that was an actual violation and that was what was removed. Moderation here tries to remove the least amount of any comment and still have it make sense.
Damn it, Buzzzzzzzz. Humor? No, my good fellow, this is serious stuff. I am coming down with a rash. Now I have to go watch porn to get my mind off this serious legal free speech stuff.
Hey, wait. FLE deleted his Blog post. What's up with that?
So true, BF. Except stuff hangs out both sides in the front. Victoria's Secret Big Girl Panties just don't do it for me.
Free Speech is limited to the public places. In the private sector, there is no constitutional protection. A&E, a private company, had every legal right to cancel Duck Dynasty for example, however they did relent as the show had fantastic ratings. Money wins over idealism.....(it's also a sad commentary on how low the public's threshold of what's entertaining has sunk.)
You are aware, of course, that the Supreme Courts decision in "Citizens United" equated money with "Free Speech."
Here's the reality and significance of the C.U. decision.
There are those who assert that the SCOTUS C.U. decision was about upholding the right to FREE speech.
I find this to be the ULTIMATE IRONY AND HYPOCRISY BECAUSE THE C.U. DECISION WAS/IS ABOUT SPEECH THAT IS MOST WIDELY EXTENDED TO THOSE BEST ABLE TO BUY IT AND DENIED PROPORTIONATELY TO THOSE FISCALLY LIMITED!
Nothin' "free" about that!
Reply by Robert G 5 hours ago
Reply by badfish 4 hours ago
Reply by Robert G 3 hours ago
Funniest exchange I've read in months.
He not only deleted his blog post he deleted his membership. I may have had something to do with that, since I find it difficult to tolerate arrogance and vanity. Once before in my life I had to put in his place a law student who had a superiority complex, so I've had some experience with it.
The CU decisions "misconstrues the nature of the competing constitutional interests at stake."
The dissent continues, "Taken together with Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission ,today's decision eviscerates our Nation's campaign finance laws, leaving a remnant incapable of dealing with the grave problems of democratic legitimacy that those laws were intended to resolve."
The decision is a boon for wealthy donors, a potential lifeline for the weakened Democratic and Republican parties, and the latest in a series of setbacks dealt by the Roberts court to supporters of tougher campaign laws.
The media outlets offset and compete with one another. THAT IS NOT EVEN REMOTELY CLOSE TO CORPORATIONS VS. INDIVIDUAL CITIZENS AND ENTITIES WITH FAR MORE LIMITED FUNDS.
You clearly either misunderstand the meaning and significance of the decision, or, want to convince others to misunderstand.
I'm still laughing about one of yourrecent unexpected, yet delightful,contributions. Thatone fellinto my single post category, while this one falls into my multi-participant category.
On the other hand, thanks for peeing on my parade.
While you are adept at attacking individuals, you are deficient in rebuttal of content.
The adverse effects on election financing and democracy that result from the C.U. decision are the issue.
How like you to off-handedly dismiss even the most obvious and completely disregard what's even more obvious, namely
And
I only bother with you because I deem it important to keep views like yours out there lest reasonable people lose sight of the myopic crap you represent.
See you in another thread some time.
Let's put it this way, the more money you have, the more of the fundamental right of "Free Speech" you can buy.
Oh, no. That's terrible. We were on a therapeutic adventure, but he just wouldn't have it.
Robert G demagogues without offering point-counterpoint rebuttals to specific points.
This is how the blind leads the blind and shockingly, there are followers who "rebut" reality in lockstep fashion.
"Free speech" offered up most abundantly to those entities best able to BUY it, is the very antithesis of "free."
Unless that reality is addressed by those who agree with the SCOTUS C.U. decision, a partisan SCOTUS will destroy other parts of the Constitution while simultaneously claiming the opposite.
Good point. There were some angry "letters to the editor". There were a few places where people picketed peacefully holding signs.
If memory serves, Piss Christ no injuries-- and certainly not even a single death.
And here's the difference-- the Mohammed cartoons resulted in over 140 deaths!
What I actually see is the repeated failures to make a viable case along with the avoidance of addressing specifics with specifics and an inability to refute viable rebuttals.
However, you excel at creative name-calling and ad hominem retorts.
1 for 2; if life were baseball, you'd be "Hall of Fame" material.
"Bad Facts/Bad Cases make bad laws."
You can look that up on your own, Robert G regardless of what the radical right SCOTUS wing decided in the C.U. case, it fucks up both the law and skews the realities in favor of Organized Wealth being able to buy elections and politicians.
Another Robert G. "rebuttal."
Cooperstown awaits.
There were no CORPORATIONS at the time the First Amendment was drafted, nor any conceivable intent by its authors to include such entities as "people."
In fact, the ability to disseminate "speech/information" is seriously ABRIDGED/RESTRICTED for those unable to afford it to the same degree as Organized Wealth!
The FREE exercise thereof!
You are not of an intellectual level from which you can justifiably talk down to people who are able to think.
"Reading" the decision only tells one what the decision "says," not necessarily what it "means" in terms of its effects upon implementation, in this case, one that undermines democracy by drowning out the voice of the common man!
You don't seem to be able to address that; if I thought you to be ignorant, I'd chalk it up to that. But you're a bright guy and consequently I take your apparent lack of intellectual acumen as "willful political bias."