This time, gang members choose wrong victim
Armed defender shoots, kills 15-year-old attacker and known gang-member.
Yesterday I wrote of yet another vicious deadly-force gang attack: Caught on video: Another black-on-white racially motivated gang attack.
In that post, I cautioned that gang attacks of this kind were likely to end very badly for the attackers once they stumbled upon a victim who was lawfully armed and prepared to defend himself.
It wasnt long before I received an example of this type of attack happening in Milwaukee, four days prior to the September 7 attack described in yesterdays post.
As reported by the Daily Caller (video embedded below), on September 3 a gang of teens attempted to rob a group of people in Milwaukee. According to police spokesman Lt. Mark Stanmeyer, the gang had been involved in dozens of robberies in prior days,
Unlike the racially-motivated gang attack on the young white couple in Missouri, covered here ,resulting in serious injury, or the gang attack on the three white men outside Krogers in Memphis, covered here , resulting in all three of the victims being beaten unconscious, the Milwaukee victims were not helpless: one of them was armed with a pistol, and used it to thwart the attack.
The result was the death of one of the teen attackers, who was just 15 years old. He was a known gang-member, and already had serious criminal charges for robbery and auto theft filed against him before participating in his final, fatally flawed gang robbery attempt.
Perhaps most remarkably, this thug had already been shotin a robbery attempt as recently asAugust 1, and was back committing crime barely a month later.
Five other members of the attacking gang have been arrested, ranging in age from 1414! to 18 years of age.
Tags
Who is online
57 visitors

Mamas, better protect your children. Evil forces out there are getting them killed. Better come together because more people are getting prepared to deal with the situation of having their lives put in jeopardy.
These type of attacks are on the rise, they are not fading away. And it is the reason there will be more deaths of young Blacks in the future, regardless of how many marches Sharpton and Jackson lead, or how many investigations Holder instigates, or how many police forces are told to diversify their hiring practices.
Because it will be common civilians who will be doing the shooting, not LEOs.
A story about crime that was stopped by a law abiding citizen with a gun? The source must be untrustworthy!
Absolutely, 96... completely fabricated.
A lot depends on where you hang out or are forced to. I have to go to Detroit a lot for my job. I have been victimized (mugged) and am constantly on the lookout for it again, this extra paranoia/vigilance/preparation has saved my ass more than once since then. My advice to you, is to worry plenty if you are in town, it may save your life.
So you are supposed to surrender whatever the crook wants? If so you better plan on it every time you happen to run in to that thug again...and he will be looking for your generous ass. Nope not a good option, then when the next crook stops you and you have nothing left to give they get real mad and shoot you, or if your lucky, they just beat the crap out of you. You have actually not had any experience in this kind of situation have you Flame?
Carry protection or avoid the potentialarea of discontent.
Kind of makes me think of Crocodile Dundee. "You call that a knife? THIS is a knife."
There are too many factors that we don't know in order to intelligently comment on this article. Did any of the attackers show a weapon? How many of them were there that would have caused sufficient paranoia? My understanding is that self defence is a good defence, but it cannot be so if the force used to defend was unreasonably extreme for the circumstances. Killing is extreme, so was there a reason why that was the amount of force needed to defend the shooter? Could just showing the gun have been enough?
Elsewhere in the comments for this article I mentioned Crocodile Dundee. Those of you who have seen the movie would recall the scene where he and his girl friend were threatened by robbers wielding a knife. Crocodile then pulled out a huge machete and said "You call that a knife? THIS is a knife" and scared the robbers off. He did not have to slice off the head of the robbers to defend himself.
But keep in mind, he who chooses to live by the sword will die by the sword. According to the facts in this article, the robber had reason to know that he was taking a very big gamble with his life to have done what he did. He had already been shot while carrying out a robbery.
Some people say "Art imitates life," and I also say "Life imitates art."
Calm down a little, MiG... [reviewed by ph]
Not putting me off personally, Flamer... I'm simply concerned when I see a thread going downhill and heading toward another derailed pissing contest. Just trying to get things chilled out a little... kind of like tossing a bucket of cold water on two dogs that are stuck screwing. It's never 'pointless' from their perspective, but all the snarling & rolling around sometimes bothers the neighbors...
[comment reviewed by ph]
And, again as in most of the recent "news" casts - not all the facts are in, so, who really knows - who really knows?
Running away doesn't work. Eventually, you will run out of places to run to. You have to learn to deal with it.
Just read through these comments and I'm surprised at you jumping Gunny about waiting for a judge to announce guilt or innocence even if there were twenty witnesses to a murder; that the Constitution and Bill of Rights should be upheld at all costs.
I remember you advocating that someone shoot Zimmerman in the back after he was found not guilty by a court and judge. It seems you follow the Constitution only when it suits you, Randy... which makes you no better, and no worse, than anyone else here. Most of us see things through the glasses we personally wear, not through those worn by someone on the other side of the fence.
Great run-a-round and derailing of the thread. Sex offender???? hamas???? Jerry Sandusky???? Gaza???
Please - keep your "rants" directed at the subject - not all the peripheral attachments you can find.
A MISTAKEN BELIEF that there is a valid article in the Constitution known as the "Fourteenth Amendment". No such amendment was ever legally ratified by three fourths of the States of the Union as required by the Constitution itself. The so-called "Fourteenth Amendment" was dubiously proclaimed by the Secretary of State on July 20, 1868. The President shared that doubt. There were 37 States in the Union at the time, so ratification by at least 28 was necessary to make the amendment an integral part of the Constitution. Actually, only 21 States legally ratified it. So it failed of ratification.
Enough off-track discussion.
And here we are.
Mamas, you are going to have to learn to be loving parents who give your children the inner confidence in themselves so they will never be caught in this situation. I know it isn't always easy, but it is a responsibility you have taken on when you decided to bring that child into this world.
Protect your children by doing everything you can to provide the kind of love that inspires your children to grow up to be fine adults who respect others as you have taught them to do, then you will be less likely to find yourself crying at their grave sites,
This is for all parents. You can't spoil a child by giving him/her too much love and time. You can not create criminals by setting good examples for them to follow and you can not allow discipline to not be a part of your children's lives.
Some are born into situations where it is much more difficult to accomplish this. This is when you need to come together with other parents and rid yourselves of the bad influences your children face every day of their lives. Teach your child to be an individual.
A community has to work together at times to provide the kind of environment that will promote a long happy life for you and your children.
There is no such thing as too much encouragement.
......................................................................
I don't know that there's any proof that the attack was "racially motivated" particularly when the report indicates that robbery was the motive.
I know there are people on this site and people on the right-wing, Daily Caller who will make out any/all crimes committed by non-whites to be "racially motivated" like their racially-motivated reporting.
Still, when thugs, assholes, criminals initiate an illegal form of contact upon would-be victims, if they come out on the short end, so be it. But a society in which there are armed individuals on the street more-and-more, incidents of "poetic justice," IMO, will be eclipsed many times over by the macho armed-dickheads who kill when they could just walk away instead.
That is not always the situation . Look at this video from Chicago :
Of course not, Petey nothing is "always," but for the times a life is not taken, each one is
A HUMAN LIFE.
Some of the stories don't have a "walk away" option, Mac. Take the Kroger incident where the thugs beat three people unconscious; they never had the choice to walk away and if they had been armed they no doubt would have chosen to shoot.
These "flash mob" cretins don't leave anyone standing to walk away. They beat their targets to the ground and have left several of them permanently physically damaged and some of them brain damaged. They are dangerous and I don't care what age they are, they are lethal in their intent.
Personally, every school should have copies of "Lord of the Flies" given to every student over twelve years old, tell them they had better read it and pass it on to their parents, because that, my dears, is why you are not considered "children" by the victims you encounter in your street wanderings.
A thirteen year old boy was convicted of beheading several people in Mexico. Twelve and thirteen year old "children" are killing people in Mexico, Africa, Central America, Syria, all over the world, so don't cry that they are "children" when they form a mob and permanently injure people.
A twelve and fourteen year old shot a baby in his stroller point blank in the face in Georgia last year because the mother didn't have money to give them. They didn't give her an option to walk away and I'll bet if she had a gun she would have put them both down like dogs in the street rather than let them kill her baby.
These arguments against an armed citizenry are one-sided when you talk about "dickheads" who kill when they could walk away, because not all circumstances are the same.
I am referring only to the circumstances in which the absence of a gun means a life not taken.
And if I can find statistics, I'll bet you 10 bucks for charity that there are more needless gun deaths than gun deaths resulting from a legitimate, virtually unavoidable situation of self defense.
When the only eye witness to a shooting is the one who did the shooting, the verdict will almost always be "a case of self-defense." And that's the problem with dickheads running around with guns simply because they can.
An evil destructive blood thirsty human life from the evidence in the video . That was a situation which would have ended a lot better if the victim had pulled out a gun & killed the machete wielding gang bangers ...
Advocating victim-hood, in any form, makes me sick. Just walk away?Great.Nothing betterthan sending a successful and emboldened criminalon his way to do the same thing to someone else just around the corner.
Yes, I take precautions to keep myself and my family as safe as possible, but those traditional methods don'tseem to be working for most people these days. Countless innocentswho are just trying to live theirlives without being robbed, raped, murdered, and whatever elsea sickcriminal mind can conjure up to do to them, are being robbed raped and murdered anyway. Iwonder how many of those innocents tried to run away...only to meet their fate moments later.
Just for the record, I don't give two shits what color the thief, rapist, murderer, car-jacker, etc., might be. If they want to take what is mine, or hurt me or my family,then seeingthem dead or dying from a bullet or bullets that just came out of my gun,doesn't bother meone bit.
Just walk away? Hell. No.
But it's the "dickheads" who, by my referencing them thus, are the ones who kill unnecessarily - as per the statistics I posted above.
When a killing is justified I have no problem with it. But most gun deaths are not done in "self-defense."
In a perfect world, the dickheads would be unnecessary but it's not a perfect world; and statistically and in reality, the dickheads are actually the "bad guys" more often than the so-called "bad guys" who get shot deservedly.
The NRA fantasy world is just that a world in which gun manufacturers and dealers do well and lots of people who needn't be shot
GET SHOT.
All the adjectives in the world don't change the statistical realities.
If you want to keep paying for that behavior have fun . My ancestors were not involved in the slave trade . I refuse to pay for those past "sins" . I think the many thousands of deaths in the Civil War were payment enough .
Wow - what analogies - wow.
Again, no solution from the flame-pit - only more wiggle room.
The statistical realities are that someone was severely injured by a machete wielding gang banger . But feel free to ignore that . Choose the stats that support your "higher moral ground" against the rest of the human race .
I say bullshit ...
Ahhh - yer gonna bring up that one Yankee ship again, and again and again??? One ship does not make a Navy.
Someone who couldn't understand the Nicomachean Ethics shouldn't be talking about intellectual achievements .
And someone who doesn't understand the Marshall Trilogy shouldn't be talking about property rights.
Agree John - and long before the Civil War.
And they get so frustrated when they don't know what they're discussing and get caught at it
So your solution is to allow black minorities to vent their rage by physical means without consequence ... really stupid . But you don't have to worry . You are immune from that.
Didn't see anything in there that even closely resembled the subject of the thread.
Nice try though.
I think what amazes me more than anything is my comment above has been completely ignored and if parents of each ethnic group followed the advice in that comment there would probably be no need for this article in the first place.
Yet the race thing is much more important. It has to be some sort of racism if the victim is white and they try to protect themselves. They don't know if they are going to die or not. Oh, I could put hundreds of incidents where they were murdered on here but I will not do that at this time. The the apologists try and turn it around and make the victim the actual villain instead. Bringing up past incidents that were bad done by whites since this is a black on white crime for the most part and looking at it from an entirely different perspective if it is the other way around.
The fact is it would never even happen if the parents of these children took their responsibility as parents seriously. No one can blame this on anyone other than the parents, although I expect the foolish attempt to do so will be done anyway in spite of the lack of logic and common sense in that theory.
A Mac, you seem to be obsessed with people who own guns and think they are dickheads who go around shooting people if they can get away with it. I'll say it one more time and you and the others here can make all the excuses you want, but a parent who loves their child, encourages their child, disciplines their child is a lot less likely to go to their child's funeral because their child robbed someone or beat someone up and got shot to death. That's the real point of this article.
They may very well be, but according to A Mac blog entry there aren't that many. And whether there are or not, the people they eliminated from society would have never been in the situation to die unless they hadn't been making someone feel their life was possibly in jeopardy. You can play this game all you want, but if most of these criminals had decent parents they wouldn't be doing things like this to put their lives in jeopardy when they just happened to run across a dickhead or an innocent person who isn't a dickhead. We need to put the dickhead on the body that is committing the crime like people with common sense do.
It's always the people protecting themselves. The criminals don't always tell them when they attack them, "Oh, by the way, I'm not going to kill you. Give me a few years to do that when I can get my hands on something besides this stick."
Maybe we should start a business for criminals where they can buy T-Shirts that have "I'm Only Going To Rob You And Your Girl Friend." Under that it can say, "I'm Not Going To Cut Your Manhood Off and Rape Your Girl Friend."
If the race were in reverse this would have been considered a hate crime and we all know it would.
So stop trying to make excuses for violent behavior and some way trying to make it insignificant when it is not.
Flame no offense but you're way off the article. If you want an article where you talk about the Indians or slaves then put one up. This article is about people who make a conscience decision to put their lives in danger by victimizing others. My point is if parents took their responsibility seriously these situations wouldn't happen nearly as often. It has nothing to do with Indians or Slaves.
Flame
Still this has nothing to do with the article of people making a conscience decision to terrorize, beat up, rob, rape and even kill innocent people just because they think they can get away with it and thereby putting their lives in danger by doing so and my suggestion is parents need to take their responsibility of being parents seriously by doing the things I put in an earlier comment that seemed to go right over everyone's head.
Six, your comment box is blank, they only time I see anything written is when I do a refresh...
I'm amazed at your logic Randy. Most people with guns are concealed. I certainly would have my concealed. I want every advantage I can get if I encounter someone who wants to make me a victim. I want my cards dealt face down, then I can make the choice which ones I want to turn over. Open carry may do one of two things. It may deter the criminal or it may encourage the criminal to shoot first and then victimize me. Like I said if parents took their responsibility as parents more seriously, then we would have less chances of this happening in the first place.
And here we are.
Mamas, better protect your children. Evil forces out there are getting them killed. Better come together because more people are getting prepared to deal with the situation of having their lives put in jeopardy.
Mamas, you are going to have to learn to be loving parents who give your children the inner confidence in themselves so they will never be caught in this situation. I know it isn't always easy, but it is a responsibility you have taken on when you decided to bring that child into this world.
Protect your children by doing everything you can to provide the kind of love that inspires your children to grow up to be fine adults who respect others as you have taught them to do, then you will be less likely to find yourself crying at their grave sites,
This is for all parents. You can't spoil a child by giving him/her too much love and time. You can not create criminals by setting good examples for them to follow and you can not allow discipline to not be a part of your children's lives.
Some are born into situations where it is much more difficult to accomplish this. This is when you need to come together with other parents and rid yourselves of the bad influences your children face every day of their lives. Teach your child to be an individual.
A community has to work together at times to provide the kind of environment that will promote a long happy life for you and your children.
There is no such thing as too much encouragement.
There may be a copy of my original comment above as it also would go blank for me as well.
I'm with you on that Flame. Whatever it takes to remove the word or idea of "victim" from the liberal mind would also be a good start. Whatever it takes to save the lives of the ones committing the crimes and the victims of the crimes is the objective.
I think I stated it pretty well on page 7.
All the things I said were true. Notice I didn't say what it took to spoil the child or how you can spoil a group of people. Well let me say it now, You can give people too much and expect too little from them in return.
It takes both sides to do their part to make things better for all. Condemning these actions by all whether they are white or any other race.
Cleaning up the communities without the fear of being a racist. You know Michael Brown had the opportunity to go to a much better school, but opted to remain in the 2nd worst school in the state.
We're giving so much opportunity to succeed to minorities including in state tuition to the Mexicans when the parents of American's have to pay full price and if they work hard they don't qualify for anything while others who don't do anything qualify for everything.
The middle to upper middle class is footing the bill for everyone.
That could change if the people who brought children into this world took responsibility as parents should.
The poor can get free birth control, but will they take advantage of it? Face it, we live in a welfare state funded by working Americans who made fair money and that doesn't have to be much. A person with family can received approximately the same amount as a person with family after taxes brings home by doing nothing.
And don't lead by example by selling cocaine and expect your child to become an outstanding citizen.
flame - it'd be nice if you actually knew what you were talking about from the educational standpoint.
"Charter" and "private" schools can pay different salaries - public schools have to pay ALL of their staff according to the wage schedules established by the state board. These kids are going to public schools where the teachers are required to meet the same standards and get paid the same as all public school teachers.
Ask Perrie - she'll explain it to you in detail - great detail - so that maybe even you can understand it
My wife is also a teacher and I'm speaking from the NM and FL standpoints. In those two states, even the substitutes have to have teacher's certification. 'Course, other than Orlando, Jax, and Miami, many of the school districts have Charters/private/church, but the public systems hold you to the line pretty solidly.
Yes, I'm involved - even getting ready to do teaching in night school next Spring.
This incident was completely ignored by Wisconsin's largest newspaper, the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel .
1stwarrior: Flame is correct as to the differences and opportunities in Wealthier schools as opposed to the not so rich schools, just the subjects been taught are far more advanced in the wealthier schools, poor students do not have the opportunity to study sciences. Chemistry, Physics etc...Reading and Writing is taught everywhere, yet, some still do not know how to comprehend what is written, so no, the education is not equal, for those who thinks its the communities fault, not entirely...First, if the USA wanted equal education for all the people, we would have had it, but of course, who is going to sweep the streets and clean the public toilets if everyone had opportunities to be advanced in life...
No more obsessed than you are with those of us who see problems with the purchase of guns without serious background checks,
No one argues with that; BUT, there are more family members killed by other family members with guns than there are criminals shot to death by would-be victims defending themselves or family members.
That's my real point.
Randy - I think the folkswho would need the proper parenting would be the ones whom the open carry folks would be meeting in the public. If they were, the numbers of open carry would be less.
You still love to throw in apples and oranges.
When you're ready to stick to one topic, i.e. the thread, come'on'down.
Did Adam Lanza have "proper parenting?"
How about the Columbine shooters?
How about Jared Loughner?
There is no question to the rhetorical premise that "proper parenting" might yield law abiding citizens. But "improper parenting" doesn't necessarily yield criminals.
Things are much more complicated than that.
Carrying a weapon IMO, is potentially a "to-a-child-with-a-hammer-everything-looks-like-a-nail" temptation. There are obviously responsible gun owners/carriers who will always use discretion.
And then there are those, who in a heated moment, go for the gun in their home (purchased to protect family members) AND KILL FAMILY MEMBERS!
Not knowing anything about crime in Milwaukee, I don't know if that would be because it happens so often it's not news, or if the newspaper just didn't think it was worth the space. Either way, it's sad.
Surprised?
The most important thing in a child's life is their parents. I saw this black woman crying when her daughter was graduating say, "She can't even spell 'girl". They don't teach the kids in those schools anymore." I wondered where were you all these years? Can you spell 'girl'?
Then I read a story a black woman wrote how her entire life was black until the 4th grade when she had her first white teacher. Everything was great until then and the white teacher couldn't see the gifted black girl she was. Well let me tell you my first 3 years were great except for a couple times of getting paddled, which I deserved, then in the 4th grade I met Mrs. Carroll and she didn't see the gifted little boy in her class and I hated her, but I did learn some valuable lessons from her I wasn't aware of for years to come.
So school is important, mostly if the parents are doing their part in getting involved in their children's education, but too many don't. I think one of the biggest problems most teachers have is not pay, but lack of parent participation in the child's education.
And this goes for the community as well, participation of the parents in the community to do all they can to eliminate the dangers and bad influences their children are likely to be subjected to on a daily basis.
I came from out in the country in a school that had about 1/4 to 1/5 the number of students as most of the larger schools. My school didn't offer all the courses the schools in the city offered, but I never joined a gang. I never went out and beat an innocent victim up, nor robbed, raped or killed anyone.
To put the blame on the school, teachers or courses taught for these actions is an unacceptable excuse for these actions and I revert back to the most important people or person in a child's life.
And your point is well taken A Mac, but the reason these teenagers or this teenager is dead at 15 is because he made bad choices in life which could have possibly been good choices if the parent or parents had taken their responsibility seriously. I know it is not always easy, especially when you are already in a bad neighborhood to start with and have no education yourself, but dickheads with guns aren't the problem here. This is not a gun issue article, although it has drifted off in that direction. It is an article asking the question, why was this 15 year old where he was doing what he was doing in the first place. I would like to try to keep it more in line with a solution for that problem.
Flame, why don't you be the first to lead the way to answer the question, "Why was this 15 year old where he was and as we know is dead because of it?" You can have the helm.
Take the helm Flame. Don't be a follower. Be a leader. Put this ship back on course.
And that has NOTHING to do with the property right's innuendo of the article - jjeeezzzzz - quit pontificating.
Where do you get that from Petey????????
Your attempts at "cuteness" aren't really "cute".
This incident was completely ignored by Wisconsin's largest newspaper, the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel .
No, not really AeonPax.
Police identify alleged teen robber killed in Walker's Point
An alleged teenage robber shot to death by an intended victim in Walker's Point was identified by Milwaukee police Wednesday as Camron T. Powell, 15.
Powell was allegedly a member of a ring responsible for up to 35 Milwaukee-area robberies when he was killed about 5:30 a.m. Monday at S. 2nd St. and W. National Ave., according to a news release from the Milwaukee Police Department.
He was with a group who allegedly tried to rob a 30-year-old West Allis man, who drew a gun and shot the teen, according to police. Powell had been previously arrested on charges related to armed robbery, auto theft, fleeing and theft.
The teen also was wounded Aug. 1 during a shooting in the 3100 block of N. 55th St., according to police.
Five teens believed to be part of the ring were arrested following the shooting two 14-year-old boys, a 16-year-old boy, a 17-year-old girl and an 18-year-old man and the case will be referred to the Milwaukee County district attorney's office, police said.
The West Allis man, who was taken in custody and released Monday, will be ordered to appear at the district attorney's office at a future date, police said.
The shooting took place in a parking lot on the northeast corner of the intersection, where a silver-colored Chevy Impala taken in a carjacking at N. 76th St. and W. Mill Road was found, according to a report from the Milwaukee County medical examiner's office.
A golf-type glove matching one lying next to Powell was found inside the vehicle, according to the report.
It isn't necessarily that they don't tell you what you want to hear. It's that they only tell you what they want you to hear. BTW what is it you think I want to hear?
Since I've been informed a few of my comments have been vanishing shortly after you arrive on the page here is a copy of the one referring to AeonPax's saying the incident was completely ignored by The Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. You may see two of them on this page, who knows?
Police identify alleged teen robber killed in Walker's Point
An alleged teenage robber shot to death by an intended victim in Walker's Point was identified by Milwaukee police Wednesday as Camron T. Powell, 15.
Powell was allegedly a member of a ring responsible for up to 35 Milwaukee-area robberies when he was killed about 5:30 a.m. Monday at S. 2nd St. and W. National Ave., according to a news release from the Milwaukee Police Department.
He was with a group who allegedly tried to rob a 30-year-old West Allis man, who drew a gun and shot the teen, according to police. Powell had been previously arrested on charges related to armed robbery, auto theft, fleeing and theft.
The teen also was wounded Aug. 1 during a shooting in the 3100 block of N. 55th St., according to police.
Five teens believed to be part of the ring were arrested following the shooting two 14-year-old boys, a 16-year-old boy, a 17-year-old girl and an 18-year-old man and the case will be referred to the Milwaukee County district attorney's office, police said.
The West Allis man, who was taken in custody and released Monday, will be ordered to appear at the district attorney's office at a future date, police said.
The shooting took place in a parking lot on the northeast corner of the intersection, where a silver-colored Chevy Impala taken in a carjacking at N. 76th St. and W. Mill Road was found, according to a report from the Milwaukee County medical examiner's office.
A golf-type glove matching one lying next to Powell was found inside the vehicle, according to the report.
Still the point of the article is why was this teenager involved in these activities and how can it be changed. My main point is parents are the most important thing in a child's life over and above anything else.
I think, as usual, that you don't have a clue what your talking about and how to connect it to this thread.
Keep on derailing flame - that's your strongest point.
You are only direct when you want to derail - which is always. Out of all of you comments on this thread, 2 of them are on topic. All of the others, you throw your sideviews out and totally disregard what you're supposed to be addressing.
Why don't you start addressing the topic of the thread - 15 year old killed by a person defending his property - what is your issue with that?
Since this was posted right below my comment, I assume you were speaking to me, there is no apples and oranges, I speak as it is, if the USA wanted an equal education for all citizens they could have achieved on a Federal Level, but they do not...Americans wonder how come the Indians and Oriental kids are so advanced academically, also children who were early education in some African Countries, the common denominator is those people were educated under the British System of Education, the same courses taught in England, Whales and Scotland, I am not too sure about Ireland, are the same subjects taught throughout the British Commonwealth, therefore, everyone got the same level of education...
Jumping the gap between a US and UK high school education
by Andrew Maynard on July 29, 2012
T omorrow, my 16 year old daughter is leaving her home in the US for the UK. Shell be there for the next two years while she studies for her A levels. It was a heart-rending decision for my wife and I to agree to her living apart from us in a different country. But the stark reality is that my daughters high school education here is just not good enough to prepare her for a British University and in two years time, thats where she wants to be.
Ive long been worried about the US approach to science education in particular. When I was at school in the UK, we started studying physics, chemistry and biology in parallel from the age of 13. It didnt suit everyone. But I wouldnt be here as a science professor and department chair in a major university without this early start. It was key to me getting hooked on physics at an early age, while gaining a broad and integrated understanding of how the different disciplines complemented each other. In contrast, both of my kids have been following a sequential science track biology (grade 9), geophysical science (grade 10), chemistry (grade 11) then physics (grade 12).
Seeing physics pushed back to 12th grade still breaks my heart. It makes some sense if you view students as a blank slate to be written on. But for those students who are primed to fall in love with discovering how the universe works and just dont know it yet theyre lucky if they dont have that capacity for awe crushed out of them before they get to the really interesting stuff (if youll forgive my bias).
The same goes for chemistry and biology, and all the ill-defined areas that cross between the three big disciplines. With biology, how can you possibly inspire students with an intense year of teaching when they are just 14 years old, before dumping it as you move on to geophysical sciences the next year? My daughter was potentially interested in biology. But a year of didactic teaching five days a week (they didnt do labs) wore her out. And that was it her one and only shot at being hooked, blown.
Them came chemistry. Up until this last year, my daughter had done minimal chemistry, and no real lab work at school. She took chemistry as she is interested in studying medicine. And because of this she took the Advanced Placement (AP) course the equivalent of A level. In other words, an A level in 12 months. With minimal preparation.
This would have been tough, even with the best teacher and resources. But to make matters worse, she was in an overcrowded, under-resourced class in a school that doesnt think much of science, surrounded by kids that seemed to adopt the school philosophy. And remember, this was her one-shot chance to get the chemistry bug!
I admit, when I visited the class at the beginning of the year, I nearly cried. There were half a dozen lab benches at the back of a small room with a smattering of tired equipment that were being stretched to serve a class of over 30 students. And this was the only AP Chemistry class in a high school with over 1600 students. It was a shambles compared to the chemistry classrooms I had at a mainstream comprehensive school in the UK 30 years ago. It did not inspire confidence.
Then the classes started. Ive spoken with my daughters teacher and I am convinced she was doing the best she possibly could. But is was quickly apparent that my daughter would not come out of this class knowing much about chemistry and certainly being no-where near what was needed for a chemistry-related degree course in the UK. Labs were the worst. This was the first time my daughter had actually carried out experiments on a regular basis in a science class. Yet these were little more than chemistry recipes instruction sets with no explanation of what was going on or why, and minimal tie-in with class work. And no lab write-ups!
Early on, my daughter told me she would get an A in this class and not understand a word of chemistry at the end of it. She got an A-, and Im pretty sure she would admit that she still struggles with some of the most basic concepts in chemistry!
So rather than endure a final year of US high school getting and education that is little more than worthless in the UK, she is heading back to study for A levels. This means doing an extra year at school. And it means living apart from the rest of us for two years. But if she wants to get into a UK university and do anything remotely connected with science, its the only option at this point.
Of course, I have no illusions about British schools or A levels. Fortunately the school she will be attending has a good reputation and are very responsive and accommodating of their students. Likewise, to judge the US education system on one school would be foolish although you might have expected more from a state school co-located with one of the top US universities.
In the meantime, we have another related challenge my son. He is at the same school my daughter is leaving, and is heading into AP Chemistry next year. Unlike my daughter though, he has discovered his inner enthusiasm for science, independently of anything the school has done to prevent this. And because of this, I think he will do fine. But despite the system rather than because of it. He indulges his interest in science outside the school. He reads widely, and participates in Science Olympiad one of those US initiatives designed to inspire young people. But where in other schools his extra curricular activities might be supported and applauded, here they are ignored.
No CM - it wasn't addressed to you.
Yes, we all know the differences of education in the U. S. versus the world - and guess what - the U. S. lost.
I would like to hear this. My #1 choice.
Wouldn't everyone like to hear this? My second choice.
That is inevitable. I don't think he can BS his way out of that one.
Ridiculous Now you're just being a smart ass.
Geez, thanks for the visual Jihad. I don't think I did anything to deserve that.
That would be the standard liberal position about parenthood , especially black parenthood .
Flame, I can see where you are coming from on this and I agree. It's pretty alien for me to think of drugs like heroin, cocaine, meth and others of that nature to be legal, but you make a very good point which I find is true.
Studying places like Sweden I realize there are two ways to tackle this problem and the one that has been going on for so long has only produced more crime, more gangs, more money for some and less for others.
This has not been a fruitful environment for those children born into that world. I think you said it best when you said "a young adult on their way to college is a person with a future, but a young adult with no hope is an addict."
It's difficult to have good parents when their parents weren't good parents either. When you figure "what the hell, I'm not going to live that long anyway," how hard it is to look to the future and aim high when you already feel you will be dead in a few years?
"So what difference does it make? Let's get it on!!!" With mothers and fathers addicts, dealers or both, their children have little hope for the future and with gangs that have grown from years of living this way, facing it every day and being basically forced into a gang just to have protection from gangs leads nowhere.
Of course we both know good parents are the most important thing a young child could have in his/her life, but where can this good parent be found in an environment like the one described. It has to start somewhere. It has to start with cleaning the neighborhoods up. The legalization of drugs, which I still am growing use to the alien thought, with the medical attention and education to start a new generation with a future seems to be the correct solution.
Then we should hope the good parents will be plentiful. It's a hopeless plight when you have nothing to look forward to or example to go by in this world to be all you can be.
Thanks for your comment.
Those who are desperate enough to steal 20 or fifty dollars could be well ready to change the method and kill then take the money. That is the situation that will come to pass when vigilantes rule the streets. There is enough fire power on all sides to cause many a mass shooting. Gunny you and I are old enough and smart enough that when the poor no longer can make a living they will they will do what ever is needed to see their family survive. Were these kids from homes where there was plenty to eat and hope for the future or was the gang their only viable hope?
I've been robbed at gun point. What good would a gun have done me? Well if I had tried to pull a gun at that time I probably wouldn't be here today. When all of you new gun owners see your friends blown away as many of our military have seen life becomes precious. But go for it quick draw. Martial arts I've seen didn't work well against a shotgun. Sometimes you win the confrontation then moments later loose your life. Ak's only work when you shoot first are you ready to do that. Militias or Mobs scare me and scared people will do irrational things. When you kill jobs and pay starvation wages remember that the majority of the American people do not have a college degree nor are they likely to get one now or even less likely in the future.
Says the man collecting disability as a way of meeting expenses ...