Israel bars Amnesty, Human Rights Watch workers from Gaza
"Israel has been refusing to allow employees of Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch to enter the Gaza Strip in order to conduct their own independent investigations into the fighting, using various bureaucratic excuses.
Both human rights organizations have been trying to obtain permission from the Civil Administration to enter Gaza since July 7. Two different reasons have been cited for the refusals: The first is that the Erez border crossing between Israel and the Gaza Strip is closed and no entry permits are being granted until further notice; the second is neither group is registered with the Social Affairs Ministry as a humanitarian aid organization.
In fact, Erez was open throughout most of Israels Operation Protective Edge, which began on July 8. Among others, journalists, United Nations employees and Palestinians needing medical care or returning from abroad (with special permits), were allowed to pass through.
The spokesman for the Coordinator of Government Activity in the Territories told Haaretz yesterday that it was suggested to both groups that they submit a special request with the COGAT ombudsman, but that no such request had as yet been received. Human Rights Watch said it had only received the suggestion late last week. Amnesty said it had not heard of the suggestion at all." - Source
**************************
While I support Israel's right to defend themselves, I also support the right of NGO's such as Amnesty and HRW, to investigate claims of innocent people being killed in the process.

I sincerely understand your comment, Aeon; but Israel has nothing to gain in allowing these two organizations to enter. The world has made up its mind about Israel's guilt, has steadfastly refused to even consider the evidence and words of journalists who revised their accounts of what happened in Gaza after they managed to escape the area ("escape" was their word), and with the idea at the forefront of Amnesty International being right of return, there is no purpose to be served allowing them inside Israel.
At this point, every member of both organizations would have to be vetted to be sure there were no enemy plants. Israel has no friends or allies outside her own nation in the realms of government even though individual citizens of many countries support her, with the possible exception of Australia.
It might give Israel some credibility if Netanyahu were to invite a human rights contingent from Down Under to visit along with these folks to keep them honest.
That is what I was saying, blue.
Amnesty International is not independent. They have made up their minds. That's why I suggested they be allowed along with someone such as Australia, who is favorable to Israel but is not blind.
As opposed to Gaza, you mean?
I do believe we are talking about opening the border crossing here, flame.
Why isn't everyone on Egypt's case about opening the border crossing between Egypt and Gaza?
Doesn't Moses qualify for dual citizenship as he was adopted by the Egyptian princess?
Yes he was Gene.
A+ for Bible class or Passover.
Otherwise she would have gotten herhandmaiden to fetch him out of the water since she just had her nails done.
I wonder howAmnesty International would have rated the bombing of Dresden or thefirebombingofTokyo?
That isn't a bad idea. Or a group of neutral countries.
This is the reason why Mimi:
In 1987, following the Intifada, the Islamic Resistance Movement , or Hamas [138] [142] was established from Brotherhood-affiliated charities and social institutions that had gained a strong foothold among the local population. During the First Intifada (198793), Hamas militarized and transformed into one of the strongest Palestinian militant groups.
The Hamas takeover of the Gaza Strip in 2007 was the first time since the Sudanese coup of 1989 that brought Omar al-Bashir to power, that a Muslim Brotherhood group ruled a significant geographic territory. [143] However, the 2013 overthrow of the Mohammad Morsi government in Egypt significantly weakened Hamas's position, leading to a blockade of Gaza and economic crisis. [12
I know RL... got a bit sidetracked.
Why don't Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch go to Nigeria to investigate Boko Haram or to Iraq to check up on ISIS? I've heard some claims of innocent people being killed there.
Hamas killed a four year old Israeli boy today. Do you think they might care about that?
Silly me, of course not... the three Israeli boys who were kidnapped and murdered never even register on the anti-Israeli radar, so it stands to reason Daniel wouldn't either.
You are so holding your breath waiting for that, right Buzz?
What makes you think they are not?
...
...
My reply was in response to this question; " Why don't Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch go to Nigeria to investigate Boko Haram or to Iraq to check up on ISIS? " Follow the arrows.
You know, you criticize Hamas for killing informers but Amnesty is already on that - Gaza: Hamas must end summary executions as informers face firing squad
Now on the flip side of the coin, Israel is going after its own citizens; 'Witch hunt' against Israel's war critics
Your moral equivalence is equating ostracism of a tiny percentage of self criticswith execution. A witch hunt implies execution, burning at the stake,but critics in Israel are not executed.
B'tselem, Amnesty and HRW are congenitally anti Israel self haters. Some refer to them as "Jews for a Second Holocaust," and with good reason.
Your citation of a criticism of Hamas is the exception that proves the rule. If you look at all the positions of these three NGOs you will find upwards of 99% critical of Israel.
Are there any Arab organizations like this? You know they will not survive very long.
1) If the NGOs wanted to maximize efficiency with respect to actual (rather than fabricated) human rights issues, Israel would be low on the list. 2) Given their laser like focus on the only Jewish state, one suspects other motives.
1) Your opinion, quite skewed one at that.
2) You obviously know nothing about Amnesty International or Human Rights Watch .
From Wikipedia:
Criticism related to Amnesty's criticism of Western-backed countries [ edit ]
Amnesty International has been accused of ideological bias by governments and citizens of Western or Western-supported countries, including Israel and the United States . [ 8 ]
Israel [ edit ]
Elliott Abrams , writing about the November 2012 Israeli military response in Gaza , says that AI treats " Hamas and other terrorist groups" "with an 'evenhandedness' that bespeaks deep biases," citing NGO Monitor 's detailed research. [ 23 ]
The Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs criticized the May 2012 report on administrative detention saying it was "one sided, and not particularly serious, and "that it seemed little more than a public relations gimmick. Gerald Steinberg , of NGO Monitor , said that the report was tied to the recent Palestinian hunger strikes and that AI jumped on the bandwagon to help their Palestinian allies. [ 24 ] Steinberg also pointed out that one of the researchers, Deborah Hyams was not a neutral party, saying that Hyams has volunteered as a human shield in Beit Jala (near Bethlehem ) to deter Israeli military responses to gunfire and mortars targeting Jewish civilians in Jerusalem, and that in 2008 she signed a letter claiming Israel is 'a state founded on terrorism, massacres and the dispossession of another people from their land.' [ 25 ] The Israeli embassy in London called AI ridiculous. AI admitted that this report is not intended to address violations of detainees rights by the Palestinian Authority, or the Hamas de facto administration. These violations have been and will continue to be addressed separately by the organization. [ 26 ]
In May 2012, NGO Monitor criticized AI's 2012 World Report in a few areas:
AI criticized Israel's blockade on Gaza without mentioning that the blockade was in place "to stop the smuggling of weapons and rockets used to target Israeli citizens." NGO Monitor continued and said that "UN Secretary Generals Palmer Committee declared in September 2011 that the blockade is legal under international law." AI "failed to mention the thousands of tons of goods provided by Israel to Gaza each week." NGO Monitor also pointed out that AI's report "mentions Israel 137 times, while making only 74 mentions of the Syrian regime," during a year in which thousands of people have been killed by the Syrian government. [ 27 ]AI allowed a speaking event to take place in London in May 2011, organized by the magazine Middle East Monitor Online (MEMO) and the Palestine Solidarity Campaign . Much controversy surrounded this event since one of the speakers included Abdel Bari Atwan , editor of the London-based al-Quds al-Arabi newspaper. In the past, Atwan has said that "he would dance with delight in Trafalgar Square if Iran attacked Israel , "and that the terrorist attack on the Mercaz HaRav yeshiva, in which eight students were killed, was justified as it was responsible for hatching Israeli extremists and fundamentalists. Amnesty responded by saying that "while we did have concerns about the way the event had originally been organized, these have been resolved." [ 28 ]
AI also allowed a speaking event to take place in January 2012, which included a speaker who is viewed as anti-Israel. UKs Zionist Federation said that the speaker "goes beyond the bounds of acceptable behavior" and asked that the event either not take place or that a pro-Israel speaker be allowed to attend as well. In addition, NGO Monitor 's Gerald Steinberg said that the speaker's "intense hatred directed at Israel, which is the embodiment of Jewish sovereign equality in the world, is entirely inconsistent with the universal values that Amnesty claims to promote. If Amnesty seeks to restore its tarnished moral credentials, it must end this cooperation, and join in denouncing Whites anti-Israel campaigns." [ 29 ]
Some people have criticized AI of promoting an unbalanced and excessive focus on Israel. The American Jewish Congress asserts that AI's criticism of Israel distorts the law of war by "read[ing] the law of war as if it was a law banning war", and misinterprets the Geneva Conventions with regard to the issue of proportionality in war. [ 30 ] Yael Beck and Merav Fima of NGO Monitor , a Pro-Israel NGO, claim the AI has an "obsession with Israel" and "persistently condemns Israel while ignoring suffering elsewhere". [ 31 ]
Alan Dershowitz , professor of law at Harvard University , in his book The Case for Israel , is very critical of AI and their comparison of Israel to nations such as Sudan and other offenders of human rights. Amnesty International has consistently called on Israel to bring any officer suspected of human rights violations to justice and to remove its settlements in the West Bank. It has also opposed "discrimination" against Arab citizens of Israel , and claims that the Law of Return and Entry into Israel Law are discriminatory, as they grant automatic citizenship to Jews worldwide, while denying Palestinian refugees the right of return . It has also opposed the blockade of the Gaza Strip , calling it "collective punishment". [ citation needed ]
In 2010 Frank Johansson , the chairman of Amnesty International- Finland called Israel a "nilkkimaa," a derogatory term variously translated as "scum state", "creep state" or "punk state." [ 32 ] [ 33 ] Johansson stood by his statement, saying that they were based on Israel's "repeated flouting of international law", and his own personal experiences with Israelis. When asked by a journalist if any other country on earth that could be described in these terms, he said that he could not think of any, although some individual Russian officials could be so described. [ 33 ] According to Israeli professor Gerald M. Steinberg of NGO Monitor Amnesty International has promoted an intense anti-Israel ideology, resulting in statements like these." [ 33 ]
In November 2012, Amnesty UK began a disciplinary process against staffer Kristyan Benedict, Amnesty UK campaigns manager, because of a posting on his Twitter account, said to be anti-semitic , regarding three Jewish members of parliament and the Israeli military operation in Gaza where he wrote Louise Ellman, Robert Halfon and Luciana Berger walk into a bareach orders a round of B52s #Gaza. Amnesty International UK said the matter has been referred to our internal and confidential processes. Amnestys campaigns director Tim Hancock said, We do not believe that humour is appropriate in the current circumstances, particularly from our own members of staff. An Amnesty International UK spokesperson later said the charity had decided that the tweet in question was ill-advised and had the potential to be offensive and inflammatory but was not racist or antisemitic". [ 34 ] [ 35 ] [ 36 ]
I agree, Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch has something to hide or they would be in Syria where 190,000 civilians have been murdered, 11,000 of them children, by their own government, instead of trying to get into Israel without registering where an actual war between two countries is going on.
War correspondents who have manged to escape from Gaza and Hamas with their lives have made statements about the staged photos and stories they were required by Hamas to file but little has been said about them by the national media. They would rather stick to the theme that Israel is the total evil in this situation.... as do you.
Exactly!
Both AI and HRW are basically political organizations with a rather extremist political agenda.
Although in the past they've been pretty good at deception, more & more people are beginning to catch on!
The way the rest of the world has gone hog-wild over condemning Israel for defending itself from Hamas, it would be the height of irresponsibility to allow any organization or agency inside the country that has a history of anti-Jewish or anti-Israel sentiment without an in-depth knowledge of every person attached to the group as well as a thorough search of the people and their luggage/equipment by the Mossad before they step off the plane.
Just as an aside....Israel Police are asking the public to help search for Aaron Sofer, 23, a yeshiva student who went missing around midday last Friday in the Beit Zayit area of the Jerusalem Forest.
He was hiking with a friend when they came to a steep slope on the way down. The path went two ways and they each decided to take a path and see who got to the bottom first. Softer, who is an American who lives permanently in Lakewood, New Jersey, never made it to the bottom and has disappeared. Even though police have used a K-9 unit to help search for him he hasn't been found.
Only the Great Spirit knows what the consequences will be if this young man is not found.