╌>

The Terrible Destruction of Syria in Graphic Photos

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jerry-verlinger  •  13 years ago  •  122 comments

The Terrible Destruction of Syria in Graphic Photos

The Death and Devastation occurring in Syria is hard to imagine until you look at this photo array of about 300 photos. Even then it is difficult to comprehend what you are looking at.

Click on the below linkfor a array of photos showing the massive extent of the destruction, then click on any photo in the array for a description of the photo and a link to the story behind it.

Here is a small sample of what you will see in the array;

010723-570d83bc-0abc-11e3-8e3e-24f3529673f4.jpg?width=200

world_01_temp-1342596271-500664af-620x348.jpg?width=300

[Photo: Times of Malta.com]

Fire-on-ta-building-in-th-007.jpg?width=350

[Photo: APF/Getty Images]

s_a01_88683002.jpg?width=400

[AP Photo/Manu Brabo]

014863-39e63b04-0ab6-11e3-8e3e-24f3529673f4.jpg?width=450

[Photo : AP/Getty]

assadBdayCake_2283528b.jpg?width=500

[ Photo: CAMERA PRESS ]

Click here for full photo array

The issue today, regarding Syria is very simple. Bashar al Assad unleashed the worst chemical weapons attack in the history of the world, killing some 1,400 people of which at least 460 were children. T he Geneva Protocol* of 1925 prohibits the use of chemical weapons, making Assads' action a war crime.

If something isn't done to deter future attacks, Assad, as sure as you are reading this post, will do it again, and he possessesthe largest stockpile of chemical weapons in the world. Not to mention theotherrogue nations that posses chemical weapons getting the idea it is ok to use them.

So IMO, as the most powerful and influential nation in the world, with the most powerful and capable military in the world, the United States of America has an obligation to step up and stop this mass murderer from committing more of these war crimes, even if some of our allies have elected to allow the war crimes to continue.

* TheGeneva Protocol, is a treaty prohibiting the first use of chemical and biological weapons. It was signed at Geneva on 17 June 1925 and entered into force on 8 February 1928. It was registered inLeague of Nations Treaty Serieson 7 September 1929. [4] [ Wikipedia ]


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

These are Syrian children gassed to death by there own government

016840-12f06484-0ab6-11e3-8e3e-24f3529673f4.jpg?width=500

[Photo: APF/Getty Images]

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

if assahd also "must go", has the administration already selected an anti-Christian dictator to take his place?

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

Some Before & After Photos

o-ARDALHAMRA-900.jpg?1&width=500

Photo: Astrium/Digital Globe]

BFTOdEsCMAAQYo8.jpg:large?width=500

[Photo: Syria Live Update News @YallaSouriya]

syrian-child-2.jpg?w=627&h=375&width=500

[Source: raymondibrahim.com/from-the-arab-world ]


syria-nour-alahmad.jpg?w=632&width=500

[Source: News Photo | Damascus Rural | Sabeenah | October 21, 2012]

This is little Nour Alahmad, before and after Assad forces indiscriminately shelled her town Oct. 20, 2012

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    13 years ago

I wonder how bad it will be if Assad falls and the terrorists we armed take over....I think this will pale in comparison.

 
 
 
retired military ex Republican
Freshman Silent
link   retired military ex Republican    13 years ago

I cllick on the photos but don't get the associated story. Think I'm having computer melt down. Cannot accept friend requests or send acceptance replys.

 
 
 
retired military ex Republican
Freshman Silent
link   retired military ex Republican    13 years ago

I cllick on the photos but don't get the associated story. Think I'm having computer melt down. Cannot accept friend requests or send acceptance replys.

This is a Religious war and hundreds if not thousands of years old. We are not goig to stop it just maybe tip the scales to the other side for awhile. Why do weconsistantly get into religiouswars the only thing that changes is who the agressors are and which sideis being killed. Neither side believes in Democracy but wants their religion to reign.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

well, at least powers (who replaced rice, who got promoted for benghazi)is back from vacation

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

I don't know about the glitch regarding the problem with your FR's, that's something that should be reported via the "Report Issue/Abuse" tab in the above header.

But the issue about the link to the photo info is my fault for not posting the proper instructions in the article. (Since corrected as a result of your heads up. Thank you for that)

All you have to do is, click on this link for a array of photos showing the massive extent of the destruction, then click on any photo in the array for a description of the photo and a link to the story behind it.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

I wonder how bad it will be if Assad falls and the terrorists we armed take over....I think this will pale in comparison.

Assads' power comes from his military, to bring down Assad, his military must be made ineffective, and the only way to accomplish that is through air and missile strikes conducted by the west. The opposition simply lacks the air and missile assets to conduct such strikes now, nor will they have them if and when the rebellion is successful.

If the opposition, the "terrorist" as you call them, takes control, they will not have nearly the same capabilities, nor the motive, to reign the massive amount of death and destruction that is depicted in these photos.

How do you think the opposition could ever dwarf the most deadly use of chemical warfare ever in the history of the world? Do you honestly believe the opposition, once in power, will slaughter another 100,000 Syrians, and continue to destroy their own homes and and infrastructure?

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

JoAnne,

Are you totally incapable of divorcing yourself from the domestic politics surrounding this issue? Can you not focus on the intent of this article, which is to bring attention to the massive destruction occurring in Syria as depicted in the photos?

If the inhalation of entire neighborhoods, and the murder of thousands of men, women, children and babies has no meaning to you, then please save your political comments for articles that are posted for the purpose of discussing the political aspects of the Syrian situation, such as this one;

The Syrian Dilemma - What To Do?

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    13 years ago

Jerry,

Have you been paying attention to the aftermath in Iraq, Afghanistan and Libya?

Are you not aware that we are about to aid AQ, the monster we created and have been fighting for a decade?

Do you really think a regime change from Assad to AQ and terrorists is a good idea?

Do you believe we can find the "right people" to arm after McCain went to visit the Free Syrian army and was photographed with a terrorist during his visit?

Have you seen the executions and other atrocities committed by "our friends"the "free Syrian Army" who are supposed to be the LEAST radical Islamist group fighting Assad?

...

I think if Assad falls the 40 years of peace Israel has shared on the Syrian border will be gone.

I think the Islamist's will kill and drive out all religious minorities and Syria will no longer be the most diverse country in the middle east.

I think the fighting will go on for years and there will be suicide bombings and other attacks with civilian casualties on a regular basis for years, maybe decades. (it has been happening for a decade in Iraq hasn't it?)

Why would I think this, because I have already seen it happen with every country in the Middle East we have been involved in that's why. Why would I think Syria will be worse that all the rest? Because Syria is already full of terrorists waiting for our help, and it looks like we are going to be stupid enough to give it to them (again) and train and arm them (again) that's why.

I think it is high time we looked at history and actually learned from our mistakes.

Getting involved in another countries civil war is a bad idea. Given the situation in Syria we are in a lose-lose situation. I think all other avenues should be thoroughly explored before we bite off more than we can chew.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

Have you been paying attention to the aftermath in Iraq, Afghanistan and Libya?

Yes I have. Afghanistan and Iraq were not Obamas' doing. They are wars that were started during the previous administration. Afghanistan is Afghanistan and will probably never change, and we should never have gotten involved there.

The Iraq situation was totally mishandled from the beginning, we had no right to invade that country, and the Bush administration post war policy was a disaster.

Libya, on the other hand was a situation handled by President Obama, and our "intervention" there concluded in a successful rebellion without the loss of one American life andwithoutputting one American boot on the ground. That country, althoughstruggling to learn how to function as a democracy, is slowly finding its' economic and political footing.

The issue today, regarding Syria is very simple. Bashar al Assad unleashed the worst chemical weapons attack in the history of the world, killing some 1,400 people of which at least 460 were children. T he Geneva Protocol* of 1925 prohibits the use of chemical weapons, making Assads' action a war crime.

If something isn't done to deter future attacks, Assad, as sure as you are reading this post, will do it again, and he possessesthe largest stockpile of chemical weapons in the world. Not to mention theotherrogue nations that posses chemical weapons getting the idea it is ok to use them.

So IMO, as the most powerful and influential nation in the world, with the most powerful and capable military in the world, the United States of America has an obligation to step up and stop this mass murderer from committing more of these war crimes, even if some of our allies have elected to allow the war crimes to continue.

* TheGeneva Protocol, is a treaty prohibiting the first use of chemical and biological weapons. It was signed at Geneva on 17 June 1925 and entered into force on 8 February 1928. It was registered inLeague of Nations Treaty Serieson 7 September 1929. [4] [ Wikipedia ]

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

Some of the photos used to compose this article have been changed since it was originally posted. Also, I didn't realize the Google array has links on each page that will take you to an additional 6 or 7 hundred photos.

There are literately hundreds, maybe even thousands of photos coming out of Syria depicting the horrendous amount of death and destruction going on in that country. Those photos tell the story in a way that cannot be matched with words.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

To the top

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

To the top

Thanks

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    13 years ago

While I am wholeheartedly against any U.S. military involvement in Syria, I don't foresee a diplomatic resolution to the situation. Compromise is not the norm in Arab culture, and the religious Sunni-Shia rift has been going on since Islam's inception. This is a raw, no-holds bar fight to the finish between fanatics who revere death more than life. It is not a brawl outside a bar when the bystanders can step in and say "Enough".

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

Why are you assuming air and missile intervention will result in troops coming home in body bags, when no troops are going to be on the ground? We successfully intervened in Libya without the loss any American troops.

Have you looked at the photos? Are you so dispassionate about human life, that you are willing to allow hundreds, possibly thousands, more children and their mothers and fathers to die horrible deaths at the hands of this maniac while we putz around trying to get him to a negotiating table?

This is no longer a political or military issue, it is a humanitarian issue. We as human beings have a responsibility to do whatever we can to prevent the further proliferation of chemical weapons usage anywhere in the world

Doing nothing after a head of state authorized the largest chemical weapons attack in the worlds' history, is sure to result in other rogue nations, like North Korea for instance, thinking the use of chemical weapons are ok to deploy.

Kim Jong Un, the 30 year old dictator of North Korea, has already stated he is targeting the United States in hisdevelopmentof nuclear weapons, and although experts do not believe NK has yet developed the technology to marry a nuclear warhead to an ICBM, they do know they have thecapability of reaching Alaska with theirTaepodong-2 rocket, whichcould carry Chemical weapons. And, North Korea does have chemical weapons, up to 5,000 tons of chemical weapons, including mustard gas , sarin and other nerve agents . [ source ]

Keep in mind there are 28,000 American troops in South Korea and the Korean DMZ. Those guys will fit in body bags also.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

In the first place Roy, there is no reason to use bold text it post your comments, we all can read standard text just fine.

There is no real proof that the Syrian Government gased (sic) it's own people.

But there is real proof proof the Syrian Military gassed its' own people. The question at this point is, did Assad himself, or somebody in his administration, like maybe his brother, authorize the attack, or was it a rogue military commander?

Intel reports from various European countries say they have intercepts of communications between Syrian military commanders, both before and after, discussing the attack. Also, there is no question Assads' Military has the chemicals and the hardware to deliver them. But there is much doubt whether the Rebels posses any chemicals and almost no doubt they do not have the hardware to deliver them.

What I can find out, from the friends of mine with relatives in the middle east, it was the radical Muslims that used the gas.

Real reliable information you have there Roy, friends of yours with relatives in the Middle East, big place that Middle East, I'm sure your sources have impeccable and accurate information to support what they have told you, and hold no political or sectarian bias in their assessment.
(personally, I don't believe you have friends with relatives in the Middle East, but that's just my opinion)

Obama, Karry (sic) and McCain are all liers.

Yeah they are, the whole bunch of them, you just go on believing saying that. (I know don't really believe it, but you think it helps you make your argument stronger, sorta like the bold text thing) (And it's Kerry)

They know the real truth, but are lying.

Sure they are, you've got the inside scoop don't ya Roy. Any minute now your gonna grab your keyboard and prove to us how the President of the United States, the Secretary of State and a man that has served in the United States Senate for 27 years after returning from Nam as a wounded U.S. Navel pilot, POW, war hero, is lying to us. Sure they are, none of them have an ounce of scruples do they?

Not a word or action from any of then with all the ones killed and still being killed in Africa.

What part of Africa? Seems to me I've heard a thing or two about countries like Tunisia, Sudan, Egypt, Chad,Libya and Mali tossed around from time to time, all those countries are in Africa, but they're in North Africa, you must be talking about central Africa, where we have very little, if any economic interest, and practically no geo-political or military strategic interest. So why would we go there, let the UN take care of that, that's why we give them billions of dollars every year.

 
 
 
red shadow
Freshman Silent
link   red shadow    13 years ago

It is more complicated than this. I agree 100000 dead is a major tragedy.

But it is not Assad vs the opposition but Assad vs many opposition groups and opposition groups vs each other; ranging from al Qaeda to liberal democrats and separatists like the Kurds. If Assad falls there will be civil wars among the victors.

A few air strikes will not get rid of Assad or his chemical weapons. Remember the massive bombing of Iraq in 91 and Hussein remained in power.

The question is what do we do when a few air strikes fail to remove Assad?

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

I hope you know Jerry there is no one here who wants to see all this happen to all these people. If we had gotten support in the beginning we may have been able to have enough world support to have made a difference, but now what they have are two bads don't equal one good. It's terrible, but it's fact. These poor people haven't known peace in my lifetime for the most part.

Aside from that what do you think of these videos. I bet you weren't even aware they existed.

Clinton Iraq War WMD Speech in 1998 Desert Fox Bush Lied? P1

Clinton Iraq War WMD Speech in 1998 Desert Fox Bush Lied? P2

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

JoAnne... Maybe Morsi would be interested. He was fired from the last job Obama and Hillary got him, but he does have experience.

 
 
 
retired military ex Republican
Freshman Silent
link   retired military ex Republican    13 years ago

JoAnne 1400 people were gassed ( killed )not to mention these included hundreds of children and your still locked on what 4 or was it six people in Benghazi that died. When you rush people into a conflict more would have died. Glad your not in charge. 1400 terrible but not bad enough to do anything about it but you would hang people thousands of miles away that gave orders to Generals to do what was needed. When the next 2 3 4 5 or even 10 thousand die keep those 4 in the forefront of your mind ok.

 
 
 
retired military ex Republican
Freshman Silent
link   retired military ex Republican    13 years ago

You are absolutely correct why can others not see this. How to stop it without inialation of one religion or another is impossible. This is a war rather like siblings you step in the middle and they both turn against you. This is a hot bed that has the religious factions locked in a death match. Its similar to the Right wing in the USA wanting tdrive down the wages on the middle class and the poor whie driving up the cost. Just another death match that is likely to eventually end up in a similar situation to Syria. Wonder how many countries would supply weapons armament chemical weapons to the non government side of a USA civil war? Stay out of it it is a no win battle till the death. Religious wars are fought for faith non solvable or unanswerable argumets writted decades or even centuries after the incidents happened. Faith is like believing in the Easter bunny have you ever seen it then what proof is there that one doesn't exist or does exist.

People have been killing each other over religion and nothing is ever resolved.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    13 years ago
We successfully intervened in Libya

Ohnow that IS rich! Well, I suppose it depends on what you consider "success", If you consider destroying a country and plummeting it into chaos success then I would agree with you. I am sure by your statement you have not been paying attention to what has been happening in Libya since our "success". I must admit, if you only read US media you will be hard pressed to find any information on what is going on over there (other than Benghazi) and that is only because they couldn't very well keep that quiet could they?

Well Benghazi is a perfect example of what has, and still is going on, you just won't see anything about it in our news until another prominent American in killed.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

I hope you know Jerry there is no one here who wants to see all this happen to all these people.

It's too goddamn bad if people don't want to see it, it's happening and people should see it. If you can't stomach it, don't look at it. But if you simply want to ignore it like it isn't happening, then say, "fuck those people" and go live your life.

Aside from that what do you think of these videos. I bet you weren't even aware they existed.

What I think of those over dramatized pack of distortions with the fake Clinton speeches, that are obviously not even his voice, I can't even print.

My question is, how the fuck can you be sucked in by that bullshit??!! If you can't see the lies and distortion packed into that pile of propaganda, you are one of the most naive people I have ever encountered.

Yeah, I know they exist, not those particular pieces of crap (most are done much better) but am aware the Extreme Right propagandist get their rocks off every day putting those things together. The only people that watch them are other Right Wing Extremist, so their really just wasting their time (except for getting their rocks off)

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

The UN needs to be in control. WhenObama doesn't like how they do things, he whines like a little puppy. He can try toget the US to leave the UN but that aint gonna happen.

From that asinine comment dennis, you make it clear to me you are more supportive of the policies of China and Russia than those the United States.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

The UN needs to be in control. WhenObama doesn't like how they do things, he whines like a little puppy. He can try toget the US to leave the UN but that aint gonna happen.

From that asinine comment dennis, you make it clear to me you are more supportive of the policies of China and Russia than those (of) the United States

Not at all. I believe that the UN issmarter than Obama on the chemical situation in Syria. I said nothing about China and Russia. For you to list them is what is asinine.

Obviously your not considering any action the UN takes regarding Syria must be approved by Russia and China. So, your accusation that "Obama 'Whines' because he doesn't like the way they do things", is an indication you support the Russian/Chinese Security Counsel veto against UN action in Syria.

Don't be so sure the United States would not leave the UN, many Americans support just such an action. The UNs' continued inability to help resolve international strife because of the SC Permanent Member veto power, often causes them to be more of a hindrance than a help.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

Time for this article to be taken off as the 1st story on NT.

Why? Has the destruction ended?

Anyway, it's not the "1st story on NT", it's listed as a "Featured Article" on the Forum page. The 1st story, as of this posting, is the AP story," Over 100 dead in typhoon onslaught in Philippines ".

Beyond that the 1st Story on the front page is always the last article commented on, so thanks for putting this article back on the front page for me, andthanks for reminding me this article needs to be updated with some of the latest photos and information.

Like this;

Syrias-Destruction.jpg?width=250

Daniel Pipes Promotes Syrias Destruction

Zionism Needs A Balkanized Syria

by Joshua Blakeney

Many Zionist propagandists seem to be losing their knack for deceptiveness (but clearly not their chutzpah).

Whereas Oded Yinons nefarious plot to balkanize the Middle East was hitherto implemented under the guise of advancing American oil interests and democracy, increasingly Israels pre-planned genocide and bantustanization of the Middle East, which jeopardizes oil-interests , is being called for more overtly in neocon circles. One such instance seemingly arises in this newly posted video in which Zionist-neocon Daniel Pipes calls for us (i.e. Israels satellite states like the US , Britain, France) to back Syrias president-elect Bashar al Assad against Western backed mercenaries so as to keep them fighting each other.

And this;

20121205-1322161292228195.jpg?width=300

Photo: share_png_full_page.png

Syrians suffer with the advent of winter from a shortage of electricity, gas and fuel increases the difficulty of access to means of heating.

Btw, as far as the UN being smarter than Obama, have you noticed the WMD have been removed from Syria, w/o a shot fired or one US boot on the ground? Read the whole article .

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

All this stuff about the evil Zionists, and attempting to blame the Israelis for the situation in Syria is not only total bullsh*t-- but it just more of the same bigoted crap from Veterans' Today-- a known hate site. Shame on you for linkng to an article from them-- their stuff is not only false, but full of hate!

Which one of their hate filled articles will you post next? How about this one: Under Jewish Rule .

How about one of their "factual" 911 articles? (Note the Jewish star in the pict):

Giulianis fingerprints are all over 9/11 and the follow-up anthrax attacks

GiulianiMug.jpg What's next Jerry-- perhaps a seed about the "truth" about Jews from David Duke's site? Or, maybe...Stormfront? Their views are quite consistent with the so-called "Veterans Today" site!

Blatant anti-Semitism. Insane 911 conspiracy theories. Why are you trying to promote all this vile bigoted filth on NT?

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

What the hell is wrong with you Krish!!

You have some set of balls to go off on me for posting news related to this article!

Dennis Smith posted a comment about taking this article out of the NT "Featured Articles" section, so I decided to look up the latest news being posted relating to Syria, and I found the article published by Joshua Blakeney revealing a piece of propagandist video published by the anti-Zionist neo-con Danial Pipes, calling for Israel and the US to back Assad.

Because I made people aware that Pipes had published another ludacris anti-Semitic hate filledvideo, does not mean I'm promoting what he is saying, any more than Blakeney is promoting him.

Ya know Krish, anytime you guys see anything anti Zionist, you go blind with rage and start foaming at the mouth, spitting off your outrage before you even know what your talking about.

Off course Pipes video is hate filled bullshit, that's what Joshua Blakeney and I are trying to point out.

You better get a grip Krish, you are completely out of line accusing me of posting anti-semitic hate.

Anyway this article is about Syria and the suffering it's people, especially the children. Did you bother reading this article linked under the photoof the little girl regarding winter closing in on the homeless and hungry displace Syrians? What have you got to say about that?

Or were you too busy foaming away with you misplace rage about me "promoting anti-semitic hate?

I've always had respect for you Krish, dating back to when we shared friends list on NV. But these accusations and insinuations of yours are over the top!

You owe me an apology Krish! Until I get it, you will remain at your recently acquired post at the top of my shitlist!

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago
And this:

20121205-1322161292228195.jpg?width=300

You "forgot" to mention this:

Israel Provides Humanitarian Aid To Syria War Victims

Israel acknowledged for the first time Tuesday that it is providing humanitarian aid to victims of the civil war inside neighboring Syria, saying it has funneled food and other emergency supplies to embattled villages just across the frontier.

Defense Minister Moshe Yaalon made the announcement during a visit to the Israeli-controlled side of the Golan Heights. Syrian troops and rebels have been clashing in the area for months, and hundreds of civilians have fled especially heavy fighting to neighboring Lebanon in recent days.

"We can't sit by and watch the humanitarian difficulties on the other side," Yaalon said. "We've transferred water, food, including baby food, taking into consideration that these villages are besieged and they don't have access to any other place. So therefore yes, we are assisting with humanitarian aid along the fence."

Oh--- and this:

Israel and Syria are bitter enemies, and Israel has avoided taking sides in the Syrian fighting that pits President Bashar Assad's government against rebels seeking to oust it. Still, dozens of wounded Syrians have been treated at Israeli hospitals. Last month, a pregnant Syrian woman escaping the bloodshed gave birth in an Israeli hospital. (Link)

And this:

humanitarian aid along the fence."

Israel and Syria are bitter enemies, and Israel has avoided taking sides in the Syrian fighting that pits President Bashar Assad's government against rebels seeking to oust it. Still, dozens of wounded Syrians have been treated at Israeli hospitals. Last month, a pregnant Syrian woman escaping the bloodshed gave birth in an Israeli hospital.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

I didn't "forget" to mention it, I just didn't come across that information. Thank you for bringing it to our attention Krish.

Winning the hearts and minds of the Syrian people is a smart thing for the Israelis to do. When the smoke clears in Syria (if it ever does) it will be much better if Syria is an ally of Israel rather than a threat.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Winning the hearts and minds of the Syrian people is a smart thing for the Israelis to do. When the smoke clears in Syria (if it ever does) it will be much better if Syria is an ally of Israel rather than a threat.

This is not about them trying to "win the hearts and minds" of the Syrians! Israelis are realists-- they live right in the middle of several Arab states-- and have for decades:

isr-world.gif

(On the above map, the Muslim world is green, Israel is in red).

Many Israelis are fluent in Arabic, and are well aware of the cultural values in the Arab world. These prejudices against Jews are ingrained from early childhood-- and in most cases will never change. Most Israelis know this. So then why do they offer so much help to Arabs?

Its because of their values of compassion-- it is not some propaganda ploy.

Here's another example of how the "Zionists" are helping the Syrians. This assistance is not a government effort however-- it is done on the part of individual "Zionists. (Unlike most of the other 20+ Arab countries, Jordan does not have a goal of trying to exterminate Israel-- Israelis are allowed into Jordan-- a country which has large numbers of Syrian refugees). When watching the video, please note the reactions of the people these Israelis are trying to help-- its obvious how deep is the brainwashing they've been subject to since early childhood! Frown.gif

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

You need to take a hard look at the way you twist things in your mind Krish. Trying to "win the hearts and minds" of a nations people is a far cry from a "propaganda ploy".

Like you, I watched the video, what you focused on is the rejection by the refugees when they learned they were being helped by people they have been taught to hate. And yes, that is an appalling and sad thing to note.

What you seem to have overlooked is the reaction of the Israelis when they realized they were being rejected. They were disappointed and frustrated when they realized that, even after bringing help to the desperate Syrians, the hatred remained.

Actually, your video supports my contention that part of the motivation of the Israelis was to win the hearts and minds of the Syrians and help dispel the hatred toward Israel ingrained in the hearts and minds of the Syrians. A far better approach than hating the Syrians in return.

I disagree with your implication that the Israelis are content to live in the heart of the Arab world with the knowledge they are hated, and are willing to just leave it that way. I believe this particular group of humanitarians, knowing their own country is among the most impoverished of the worlds developed nations*, decided to help the Syrians because they felt it might, in some small way, help dispel some the hatred the Arabs hold toward the Israelis.

*Israel is the most impoverished of the 34 economically developed countries, with a poverty rate of 20.9%, according to a report released by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development in May of this year.

Read the entire report in this Haaretz National Israeli News report.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

I disagree with your implication that the Israelis are content to live in the heart of the Arab world with the knowledge they are hated, and are willing to just leave it that way.

I didn't imply thsat-- you inferred it!

However, my knowlwge of Israel is due to a large part in my having lived there--- on several occasions. So many Israelis I met were truly motivated by pure altruism-- and nothing more.

What about schools like this? Do you judge this to be selfish? Why do you think they are doing this? Do you feel this is further proof as to how "bad" the Jews are?



And BTW, this isn't the only project between Arabs and Jews in Israel...there are so many...(There are some 20+ Arab countries-- I can't possibly imagine any of them having a project like this).

It seems that every post of yours is an attempt to bash Israel....lol!

I don't know if these figures are accurate (I tend to be skeptical of data from extremist sources, whether from the extreme rights, like Pipes, or the extreme left, like Ha'Aretz).

However, it may be true that Israel rate so low on the economic scale compared to other economically developped countries. I'm not sure why you chose to mention that-- seems like another attempt to bash the "Zionists"?). However, if it is true-- why? Care to hazard a guess?

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

I disagree with your implication that the Israelis are content to live in the heart of the Arab world with the knowledge they are hated, and are willing to just leave it that way.

I didn't imply thsat-- you inferred it!

You made the implication with this statement;

" Many Israelis are fluent in Arabic, and are well aware of the cultural values in the Arab world. These prejudices against Jews are ingrained from early childhood-- and in most cases will never change. Most Israelis know this. "

What happened to your contention that me saying the Israeli relief efforts are an attempt to "win the hearts and minds" of the Arabs is the same as a "propaganda ploy", have you realized how foolish that sounded?

It seems that every post of yours is an attempt to bash Israel....lol!

I'm BASHING Isreal?? You say I'm bashing Israel, and you think it's funny?

This is the 2nd time in this thread that you have falsely accused me of posting anti-Israeli comments. Apparently you are unable to make accurate assessments ofwhatyouare reading. Your problem is you, like so many other supporters of Israel, are unable or unwilling to accept any comment that is in the slightest way critical of that country.

I don't know if these figures are accurate (I tend to be skeptical of data from extremist sources, whether from the extreme rights, like Pipes, or the extreme left, like Ha'Aretz).

There is no question as I said before, Danial Pipes is a Right Wingradicalwhacko, however although Haaretzmay lean a little to the left, it certainly is not "extreme". Anyway Haaretz is only a news organization reporting the news. The report was done by t he Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development ( OECD ), aninternational economic organization of 34countries founded in 1961 to stimulate economic progress and world trade.

I'm not sure why you chose to mention that-- seems like another attempt to bash the "Zionists"?).

I mentioned it because, in the video you provided, the question of why these Israel relief workers were helping the Syrians rather than impoverished Israelis came up, and I wanted to find out what impoverished Israelis they were referring to, I decided to look it up, and came across the Haaretz article. Frankly I was quite surprised to find there is so much poverty in Israel.

However, you should not be surprised, having lived there on several occasions. So why are you accusing me of "bashing Zionist" when I simply point out the poverty level in Israel? Could it be your are an Israeli and you areembarrassed by the fact that Israel is so impoverished?

However, if it is true-- why? Care to hazard a guess?

I would suspect it is true, but I have no idea why Israel is so poor. You've been there, why don't you tell us.*

No, I don't care to hazard a guess, unlike you, I prefer to do a little research before I go shooting off my mouth.

*Having come across thissurprisinginformation about thepovertylevel of Israel, I intend to find the facts behind the report and post an article about it here on NewsTalkers, you can tell us there.

This article is about Syria.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

I would suspect it is true, but I have no idea why Israel is so poor. You've been there, why don't you tell us.*

I thought you'd never ask! Grin.gif

It mentioned that:

Israel is the most impoverished of the 34 economically developed countries

Well, I'm not surprised it ranked low-- I was a bit surprised it ranked that low.

However, there are several reasons why-- mainly two important ones:

One of the main ones is that have next to nothing in terms of natural resources-- the land itself is "poor". (BTW this is all suddenly going to change due to recent discoveries of deep water gas off the coast-- but from the re-establishment of Israel in 1948 until about only 2 or 3 years ago they next to nothing in resources. So currently yhey have next to nothing + undeveloped gas fields).

Israel's negev desert is not like many deserts which have some rain and abundant life forms--for example the Mojave in parts of Arizona & California. Israel's Negev looks like this:

Negev-2005-1.JPG negev304.jpg

Mostly not even sand-- its bare rock. Looks a bit like the surface of the Moon. Which wouldn't be so bad if it were only a small part of the country, but in fact it comprises well over half the country!

And, the other 45% or of the country that's not desert? Well, the entire country is really quite tiny -- in fact, the entire country is about the size of New Jersey. Here are some size comparison maps to give you an idea just how tiny it actually is:

1. Israel area compared to Egypt:

egypt.gif

2. Compared to Norway:

norway.gif

Compared to Viet-Nam:

vietnam.gif

(And of course unlike NJ, its over half desert). But what about resources from the entire country-- what have they got. Well, the only natural resources it has are things like sand, clay, potash, etc-- hardly a source of wealth.

Almost all of what they have is due to their own hard work (in the early days of the state, Kibbutz would work 16 hours days in tractors in the fields, much of it in very hot sun), incredible innovation (last time I checked they had more tech startups than any countries other than the U.S. and Canada-- many more than say Germany or Russia), and their willingness-- actually even their encouragement-- of immigration. (Plus, the way they integrate immigrants):

th?id=H.4907465194078368&pid=15.1 1322146159-ethiopian-jews-celebrate-the-sigd--jerusalem_938417.jpg th?id=H.4864932142122168&pid=15.1

And btw, Syria has more natural resources-- lots of good land and climate for agriculture, and significant oil (not nearly as much as the Gulf states, but at one point its was their largest source of export income). Of course the cultural values of the countries are vastly different...

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Dennis Smith posted a comment about taking this article out of the NT "Featured Articles" section, so I decided to look up the latest news being posted relating to Syria,

There's a lot of it-- everyday. But it is interesting that of all the sources you choose, you would choose an extremist hate site like Veterans Today. Not on;y extremist and bigoted, but totally nutty as well:

World Trade Center Scam Exposed

Was the whole World Trade Center concept a gigantic scam from the very beginning?

Skyscrapers Pre-Wired to Come Down

Conspiracies not conspiracy theories are destroying democracy

Mainstream Journalists Expose 9/11 Hoax: ... the US governments claim to have killed Osama Bin Laden on May 2nd, 2011 is a big lie. There is not one word of truth in it. Other top mainstream journalists say 9/11 was an inside job but cant get the story into print.

Murdering 9/11 truth: Caltech-educated physics professor Crockett Grabbe exposes the murders and attempted murders of 9/11 truth-seekersincluding several attempts on his own life.

In addition to a constant barrage of bizarre 911 conspiracy theories, hthe site constantly promotes hsatred of America, and Jews: Jewish Light Bulb Jokes (They screwed up on this one-- I think they wanted to be "politically correct" by referring to Jews as "Zionists"-- but their true feeling accidentally slipped out...heh :-)

But the question remains-- its not hard to find news in the mainstream media-- why, of all sources did you pick this totally nutty & blatantly anti-Semitic and anti-democracy website?

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

But the question remains-- its not hard to find news in the mainstream media-- why, of all sources did you pick this totally nutty & blatantly anti-Semitic and anti-democracy website?

I said ".....this article needs to be updated with some of the latest photos and information.

Like this;"

And I posted the article by Pipes, to show one of the things that was being said about Syria. That doesn't mean to say I endorsed anything Pipes said ... I was just giving a report.

I also posted a photo with a comment and a link regarding the suffering the Syrian people, especially the children, are going to endure this winter, but I don't see you making any comment about that, which is the real concern here.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

And I posted the article by Pipes, to show one of the things that was being said about Syria. That doesn't mean to say I endorsed anything Pipes said ... I was just giving a report.

I also posted a photo with a comment and a link regarding the suffering the Syrian people, especially the children, are going to endure this winter, but I don't see you making any comment about that, which is the real concern here.

Well, I'm sure it was unintentional on your part, but the attention you gave to that is, in effect-- a derail of your own article!

Puipes? A truly minor figure. And, the staement that

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Update, 12/16: Its tragic that, aside from the Syrian victims themselves, very few people care about their plight.

However, while its just a drop in the bucket, there is one middle eastern country that, rather then sending even more weapons to prolong the conflct, is actually helping the victims:

Three more injured Syrians treated at Nahariya hospital

(Over 300 casualties of civil war brought for treatment in the "Zionist Entity's" hospitals since March 2011!)

Screen-Shot-2013-08-04-at-1.07.25-AM-e1375567941402-635x357.png

(Link)

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Zionists' action re: the Syrian situation-- Update, 12/24: The 200th wounded Syrian refugee brought into Israel

The 200th wounded Syrian refugee was brought into Israel by the IDF for medical care at the Ziv Medical Center in Safed Monday night. The 21-year-old patient was in serious condition with gunshot wounds to his hip and stomach. He was operated on overnight and remains in intensive care.

Ziv Medical Center began receiving injured Syrian refugees in February of this year, and reported that there are currently 10 Syrians under their care. Israel brought eight refugees to Ziv in the last week alone, including four children.

The expense of medical care for victims of the Syrian civil war so far has surpassed NIS 14 million.

(Link)

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

However, while its just a drop in the bucket, there is one middle eastern country that, rather then sending even more weapons to prolong the conflict, is actually helping the victims:

It's great to see the Israelis are stepping up to help the Syrian people caught up in this nightmare, even though the religious and political beliefs of the two countries are diametrically opposed. Also, other countries surroundingSyria are also helping by way of accepting hundreds of thousands of refugees, many arriving sick, injured and starving with few or no possessions.

" With a million people in flight, millions more displaced internally, and thousands of people continuing to cross the border every day, Syria is spiraling towards full-scale disaster ," U.N. High Commissioner for Refugees Antonio Guterres said.

The pace of the exodus has spiked dramatically in recent months.

More than 400,000 have fled since the beginning of this year to countries such as Lebanon, Jordan, Turkey, Iraq and Egypt. About half the refugees are children.

In Jordan's Zaatari camp more than 130,000 people are officially registered at Zaatari, which is struggling to cope with the flood of refugees.

Check out these CNN articles;

State of Syria: Exodus reaches 1 million; seesaw battles rage on

Opinion: Refugee crisis 'spiraling out of control'

_69348511_69348046.jpg?width=450

Syrians stream across the new pontoon bridge over the Tigris on 15 August 2013
[ Photo: BBC News ]

An_Aerial_View_of_the_Za'atri_Refugee_Camp.jpg?width=450

Zaatari camp for Syrian refugees in Jordan [ Photo: en.wikipedia.com ]

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

I've read about the refugee crisis. The situation is horrendous.

Also, other countries surroundingSyria are also helping by way of accepting hundreds of thousands of refugees,

Helping?

WTF???

You really do have a tendency to make outlandish assumptions. (Either that, or else you've been reading biased propaganda organs like al Jazeera too much Frown.gif )

The refugees are just trying to escape the barbarism in Syria-- they'll do anything to escape, and to survive (even if it means selling their daughters into sexual slavery, which, sadly, many are forced to resort to). They are in these countries not because these countries have helped them escape, or because they want them!

But it is not correct to say the surrounding countries are welcoming them, and are eager to help them. That's an assumption. In fact, in most cases the opposite is true!

From HRW (Human Rights Watch):

Iraq/Jordan/Turkey: Syrians Blocked from Fleeing War

Border Closures Leave Thousands Stranded in Dangerous Border Areas

(Hatay) Iraqi, Jordanian, and Turkish border guards are pushing back tens of thousands of people trying to flee Syria. Iraq, Jordan, and Turkey have either closed numerous border crossings entirely or allowed only limited numbers of Syrians to cross, leaving tens of thousands stranded in dangerous conditions in Syrias conflict-ridden border regions. Only Lebanon has an open border policy for Syrians fleeing the conflict.

Syrias neighbors should stop pushing desperate people back to places where their lives are in danger, said Gerry Simpson, senior refugee researcher at Human Rights Watch. (Link)

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    13 years ago

YES, HELPING!!!!

Where the fuck do you think the food, water, shelter and medical supplies are coming from to feed and care for the these people?!

But it is not correct to say the surrounding countries are welcoming them, and are eager to help them. That's an assumption.

Your the one making the assumption, I did not say they are " welcoming the and are eager to help them ", those are your words. I said they are "accepting" them, which they do not have to do.

Btw, Mr. "The Israelis Can Do No Wrong", aside from the 2 or 3 hundred people your handful of Israeli Good Samaritans have helped, what else is Israel doing to the help the Syrians?

According to what I can find, they are doing ........ practically NOTHING!

The World Affairs Journal ;

" Israel is the only country in the Eastern Mediterranean that isnt involved in the Syrian refugee crisis. It doesnt even occur to Syrians to seek refuge in what is supposed to be an enemy state. "

The Times of Israel ;

" Health Ministry warns it will freeze hospital admittance for injured Syrians next month until financing sorted; 400 treated thus far at cost of NIS 30 m. "

400 people, a far cry from the 130,000 in the Jordanian Zaatari camp.

Sure, the UN and other international humanitarian organizations are providing what help they can to the countries that are trying to help, but READ THE GODDAMN ARTICLES YOURSELF AND STOP MAKING ASININE COMMENTS !!

When hundreds of thousands of homeless, empty handed, sick and wounded refugees stroll into a county looking for food and shelter, resources are stained and a burden is placed upon the people of that host country.

So, some countries have been forced to close their borders, what are they supposed to do when the don't have enough food and water to provide for them and the 1/2 million refugees they are already feeding? (Those numbers are from last February -March, at this time, there are over a million displaced Syrians)

I'm sure if a dozen or so people showed up at your house in desperate need of help, you would do all you could to help them. But, if a couple thousand showed up and were streaming unhindered into your home, you would be forced to do something to stop them.

You really do have a tendency to make outlandish assumptions. (Either that, or else you've been reading biased propaganda organs

Ya know Krish, I'm getting a little WHOLE LOT pissed off at your constant bullshit accusations.

Assumptions?! I provide provide photos, I provide links .... and you say I'm making assumptions??!!

I'm reading biased propaganda organs??!! Yeah like the BBC and CNN ( read the credits )

Of course your source, The Jerusalem Post, is not in the least bit biased.

We're done here K, this is way over your head, your much too biased and misinformed to understand what is going on here. So I'm not even going to bother responding to any further comments you may want to waste your time making.

Have a nice day.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

It doesnt even occur to Syrians to seek refuge in what is supposed to be an enemy state."

That's slightly inaccurate. It isn't merely "supposed" to be an enemy state-- Syria and Israel are technically at war!

Of course Israeli aid can't make any significant difference-- the size of the Syrian population so horribly effected is so huge. But the significant thing is that a country is letting in some severely injured people from a country that they are technically at war with. In addition, groups of Israelis, on their own, are secretly aiding Syrian refugees in Jordan.

(What other country-- especially in the Mid-east!-- would do this?)

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

Daniel Pipes Promotes Syrias Destruction

Jerry-- you forgot the /sarcasm tag! Smile.gif

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Why would I need it?

The comment clearly points out Pipes article was posted for factious reasons;

"Daniel Pipes Promotes Syrias Destruction"

"Zionism Needs A Balkanized Syria"

by Joshua Blakeney

"Many Zionist propagandists seem to be losing their knack for deceptiveness (but clearly not their chutzpah)"

[ Link ]

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

Why would I need it?

The comment clearly points out Pipes article was posted for factious reasons;

"Daniel Pipes Promotes Syrias Destruction"

"Zionism Needs A Balkanized Syria"

by Joshua Blakeney

"Many Zionist propagandists seem to be losing their knack for deceptiveness (but clearly not their chutzpah)"

Totally false!

In fact, most of us aware of the fact that a united Syria under Assad (despite his cruelty within Syria) has resulted in the Israeli border being one of Israel's most peaceful in recent history!!!

The main fear now is that a Balkanized Syria will result in al-Qaeda affiliates kicking Assad's troops out of that border area. Al-Qaeda controlling that border area.

Unlike Assad, al Qaeda would begin attacking Israel. So from a standpoint of peace with Syria, as atrocious as Assad's rule is towards his own people, the best hope for avoiding attacks on Israel would be a united Syria.

Yes, Pipes may have a different opinion, but he represents an extremist view. What you are doing is looking at the opinion of one man and stereotying an entire group based on the views of a relatively insignificant right-wing extremist.

Shame on you! Frown.gif

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Totally false!

In fact, most of us aware of the fact thata united Syria under Assad(despite his crueltywithinSyria) has resulted in the Israeli border being one of Israel'smost peacefulin recent history!!!

YOU DON'T FUCKING GET IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

The Pipes article was posted on this thread ONLY to show there are SOME withinIsraelthatare calliong for Israel to take drastic action;

Correspondent Joshua Blakeney posted an article to show what some extremist neocons are saying, and I posted it here. Not to show support for Pipes, but to show what some people are saying.

But you just don't get it is spite of the fact that I have told you that numerous times!

Read the fucking article, CAREFULLY, and try to comprehend it's meaning .... or get off the fucking thread. I'm tired of trying to explain this to you!

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

YOU DON'T FUCKING GET IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Whoa, Jerry-- calm down! There's no need to freak ot just because someone has a different opinion than you do! Smile.gif

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

Just came across this-- it really hits the nail on the head as to why this horrendous slaughter is taking place:

D14112_3.gif

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Whoa, Jerry-- calm down! There's no need to freak ot just because someone has a different opinion than you do!

It has nothing to do with your fucking opinion!

It has to do with your obsession regarding the reference to the Pipes article. Ever since you have misinterpreted the meaning for the article being referenced in this thread, in spite of how many times I have explained it to you, you insist on drawing this thread off the horror going on in Syria and trying to make it all about Israel.

If you want to discuss Israel, write an article about. This article is about SYRIA, not Israel.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Like I have been saying..... you don't get it, apparently you have completely lost sight of what this article is all about.

I suggest you go back to the beginning and get yourself back on topic.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

Update, 4/4/2014:

UN: Syrian refugees hit million mark in Lebanon

With 2,500 new Syrian refugees daily - more than a person per minute, Lebanon, numbering only 4.5 million people, is now home to a million Syrian refugees.

52527640100893640360no.jpg Refugees registering daily. Photo: Reuters 2500.

A teenager from central Syria became the one millionth Syrian refugee to register in Lebanon on Thursday, a "devastating milestone" for the tiny Arab country with about 4.5 million people of its own, the UN refugee agency said.

Signing up for aid, 19-year-old Yahya recounted his long ordeal. After being trapped by the fighting for more than two years in his native city of Homs, he was evacuated earlier this year and traveled to Yabroud, a rebel held town near the Lebanese border that soon came under a crushing government offensive.

When staying there was no longer an option, he crossed into Lebanon with his mother and two sisters on March 8. Yahya's father was not with them - he died from sniper fire in Homs in September 2011.

The war has uprooted millions of Syrians from their homes, and the UN estimates there are now more than 2.5 million Syrians registered in neighboring countries, with more than 47,700 more awaiting registration.

Three years after Syria's conflict started, Lebanon has become the country with the highest per-capita concentration of refugees recorded anywhere in the world in recent history, the UNHCR said. (link)

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

I was just coming here to post the same information about the number of refugees. I've stayed away from this article; the photos of the children are worse than the photos of the restavik children in Haiti that leave me with weeks of sleepless nights.

Over one million people homeless (that doesn't even begin to describe their situation), hungry, hopeless, maimed, forsaken... and that doesn't even begin to account for the dead.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Krishna, Scremin,

The situation is becoming a bigger nightmare than we have envisioned.

David Schenker,the Aufzien Foundation Fellow and director of the Program on Arab Politics at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy, posted a special report on CNN's Fareed Zakaria-GPS, which reads in part;

Demography is a central problem for Lebanon. Syrian exiles are overwhelmingly Sunni Muslims, and the influx has skewed Lebanons delicate sectarian balance of Sunnis, Shiites, and Christians. Adding to the religious strains are the ubiquitous complaints about Syrian workers driving down wages , and the burden refugees place on Lebanons already overtaxed and underfunded infrastructure. According to a recent World Bank report , over the next three years, Lebanon which had a $4 billion budget deficit in 2013 will require an additional $2 billion just to provide basic services to its new residents and to address the expected additional impoverishment of the Lebanese people generated from the Syrian crisis.

Absorbing refugees is also a burden for Jordan. [ Read why ]

The report also says;

The United Nations and the European Union describe Syria as the greatest humanitarian tragedy of our times. Unfortunately, things will get worse. Without a dramatic reversal of the momentum on the ground and a reduction of refugee flows, the stability of Lebanon and Jordan could be the next casualty of the war.

I'm not an advocate of U.S. boots on the ground, or any other serious direct intervention in Syria. But if our State Department doesn't stop focusing on Putin and start pressuring the UN and the EU to do something about this Syrian mess, the instability in the Middle East will become uncontrollable.

It's a good thing Putin is pre-occupied with his Ukraine mess, or he would be all over this Syrian thing. If Putin steps in and becomes a hero to the Syrian people, the U.S. can put it's Mid-East foreign policy in the nearest paper shredder.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

".....you are in a dream world if you think the Syrians will ever change....."

Of course the the Syrian people aren't going to change, that's not what the problem is,theproblem is Assad and what he's doing to his people.

And that is what this article is about, human suffering at the hands of an inhumane asshole.

Read the comment I just posted on page 6, in response to a post by Krishna , seven months after the date I posted this article. This problem isn't going away by ignoring it. If the economic stability of the Mid-East completely collapses, which is where it's heading, you can bet your ass it will have an effect on your little world.

Why are you even on this thread Mike? This isn't your kind of thing. maybe you should just crawl back into your shell of selfish indifference and leave this discussion to people that care about the suffering of innocent children.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

".....you are in a dream world if you think the Syrians will ever change....."

Of course the the Syrian people aren't going to change, that's not what the problem is,theproblem is Assad and what he's doing to his people.

Jerry I can understand your being ignorant of the situation (and the history) of the Middle East.

Comment removed for CoC violation

Why not limit your outbursts to topics where you are well informed?

theproblem is Assad and what he's doing to his people.

And that is what this article is about, human suffering at the hands of an inhumane asshole.

No, that is not what the problem is about!!!

The real problem are the cultural norms, the values that re so pervasive throughout the contemporary Arab world. This guy is not the exception-- he's typical! Eventually he will die, & another evil one will take his place. But he's not unique (Do you know anything about what Saddam did? Mubarak? Qaddafi? What's his name in Yemen? OMG-- Saudi Arabia....)

Yes-- the guys a horrendous homocidal maniac. But what you fail to realize is that this sort of disregard for fellow humans beings when they are of a different group, is the norm in the modern Arab world!

Its not about this guy alone. Do you have any idea abut the atrocities being committed in Egypt? Yemen? Saudi Arabia? And many other Arab countries????

Or do you want to go a little further back in the History of the Arab World? Hmmm...how about "Black September"?

One reason Bashir Assad has created suffering on such a large scale because he has so many, many weapons --and such horrendous weapons such as poison gas-, supplied by the Russians. Other Arab countries don't have such a horrendous array-- that's the main difference.

I just googled Bashir Assad. He was born in 1965. He wasn't responsible for what happened in 1982-- he was only 17 years old! So as horrible as he is, you can't pin all the problems on him!!! To do so is an avoidance of the really significant fact-- that this sort of thing is typical of the cultural values in the Arab world today.

1982 - The Hama Massacre

297px-After_Hama_Massacre.jpg

A section of Hama, Syria, after the government attack

Subsequent estimates vary, with the lower estimates claiming that at least 10,000 Syrian citizens were killed, [5] while others put the number at 20,000 ( Robert Fisk ), [1] or 40,000 (Syrian Human Rights Committee). [2] [6] About 1,000 Syrian soldiers were killed during the operation and large parts of the old city were destroyed. Alongside such events as Black September in Jordan , [7] the attack has been described as one of "the single deadliest acts by any Arab government against its own people in the modern Middle East". [8] The vast majority of the victims were civilians. [9]

According to Syrian media, anti-government rebels initiated the fighting, who "pounced on our comrades while sleeping in their homes and killed whomever they could kill of women and children, mutilating the bodies of the martyrs in the streets, driven, like mad dogs, by their black hatred." Security forces then "rose to confront these crimes" and "taught the murderers a lesson that has snuffed out their breath". [10]

Before the attack, the Syrian government called for the city's surrender and warned that anyone remaining in the city would be considered a rebel. Besieged by 12,000 troops, the fighting in Hama lasted for three weeks the first week "in regaining control of the town," and the last two "in hunting down the insurgents."[15] Robert Fisk, in his book Pity the Nation, described how civilians were fleeing Hama while tanks and troops were moving towards the city's outskirts to start the siege. He cites reports of high numbers of deaths and shortages of food and water from fleeing civilians and from soldiers.[16]

According to Amnesty International , the Syrian military bombed the old city center from the air to facilitate the entry of infantry and tanks through the narrow streets; buildings were demolished by tanks during the first four days of fighting. Large parts of the old city were destroyed. There are also unsubstantiated reports of use of hydrogen cyanide by the government forces. [17] After encountering fierce resistance, Rifaat's forces ringed the city with artillery and shelled it for three weeks.

After the initial attacks, military and internal security personnel were dispatched to comb through the rubble for surviving members of the Muslim Brotherhood and their sympathizers. [18] Torture and mass executions of suspected rebel sympathizers ensued, killing many thousands over several weeks. [ citation needed ] Rifaat, suspecting that rebels were still hiding in tunnels under the old city, had diesel fuel pumped into them and set ablaze and stationed T-72 tanks at the tunnel entrances to shell people trying to escape from the tunnels. [19]

Reports by the Syrian Human Rights Committee estimate "over 25,000" [23] or between 30,000 to 40,000 people were killed. [6] The Syrian Muslim Brotherhood also suggests a figure of approximately 40,000 victims.

Twenty years later, Syrian journalist Subhi Hadidi , wrote that "under the command of General Ali Haydar , besieged the city for 27 days, bombarding it with heavy artillery and tank [fire], before invading it and killing 30,000 or 40,000 of the city's citizens in addition to the 15,000 missing who have not been found to this day, and the 100,000 expelled." [2]

Bashir al Assad was 17 at the time. He was not responsible for this one!

As horrendous as he is, his behaviour is the rule, not the exception. And apparenty you have no idea as to what's happened with the so-called "Arab Spring" in other Arab countries. (And actually, ongoing even before the so-called "Arab Spring").

Read the comment I just posted on page 6, in response to a post by Krishna , seven months after the date I posted this article. This problem isn't going away by ignoring it.

Agreed. And BTW, as important a person as you happen to be-- this problem isn't going away by you posting articles about it on NT either! (For some reason Assad & other Arab despots don' give you the respect & admiration you deserve...they don't seem to be swayed by your arguments. Why?).

If the economic stability of the Mid-East completely collapses, which is where it's heading, you can bet your ass it will have an effect on your little world.

Oh please...gimmee a break! Comment removed for CoC violation



The "economic stability" of the Middle east has collapsed numerous times recently-- and keeps collapsing....again and again and again...yawn...

Why are you even on this thread Mike? This isn't your kind of thing. maybe you should just crawl back into your shell of selfish indifference and leave this discussion to people that care about the suffering of innocent children.

Well, well, well Jerry...aren't you just soooo special! Because you really, really, care care about human suffering...and anyone who has any disagreement with your (ill-informed) opinions ....doesn't!

Oh-- wait! Its not only that you care about human suffering in general, but:

people that care about the suffering of innocent children.

Aha-- so Jerry! I see you now play "the innocent children card!"

So you are so very special and wonderful-- you care about the suffering of innocent children...and people like Mike & myself don't. Golly gee-- how come you are so wonderful-- and how come the two of us are such heartless bastards?

Food for thought!!!Grin.gif Grin.gif Grin.gif

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Whatever Krish. I hope you don't think I'm going to dignify that insult laden rant with a response other than to remind you that you posted an entire passage from Wikipedia without citing the source.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

It is more complicated than this. I agree 100000 dead is a major tragedy.

But it is not Assad vs the opposition but Assad vs many opposition groups and opposition groups vs each other; ranging from al Qaeda to liberal democrats and separatists like the Kurds. If Assad falls there will be civil wars among the victors.

A few air strikes will not get rid of Assad or his chemical weapons. Remember the massive bombing of Iraq in 91 and Hussein remained in power.

The question is what do we do when a few air strikes fail to remove Assad?

Anyone who knows anything about the current situation in Syria is aware of the unusually barbaric tactics being employed-- by both sides. And also, the hugescale on which this is happening. The huge number of refugees. The widespread & deliberate torture of children, etc. So the horror of what's going on should be obvious...

There are lots of different aspects of this that can be discussed-- but I think you have raised the single most important question: what can be done to end this suffering? We should take a realistic look at what military action-- even airstrikes without any American "boots on the ground"-- would accomplish. Look what happened in Iraq-- and that went well beynd airstrikes. We had boots on the ground-- and for a long period. But the ongoing violence and terrorism continues (In fact we've gotten so used to it that ongoing terrorism there hardly even makes headlines anymore..& when it does, how many people even bother to read about it? We now take it for granted thatIraq is unstable, and that there's constant Sunni vs Shia violence.).

Would airstrikes remove Assad? Heck-- would that plus even the presence of American troops make any significant change? Would any of that end the horrendous barbarism? If Iraq is any indication, I would say no.

But here's the other key question when dealing with the Arab world-- if Assad was removed from power: what are the odds that any government replacing him would be significantly better? Remember, this is the Arab world...

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

Update, 4/15/2014:

Syrian Opposition calls on Obama to stand up and stop the genocide of Syrian people

In the last weeks, the Assad regime has been conducting a particularly intense bombing campaign on Aleppo with crude barrel bombs, indiscriminately killing and maiming scores of civilians destroying entire neighborhoods and causing a new mass exodus of refugees, Jarba said in the letter.

We are still waiting for an appropriate and proportionate response to these massive crimes against humanity, and urge the leaders of the international community, especially the United States and its allies, to take position on this genocide of the Syrian people, he said. (Link)

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

But if our State Department doesn't stop focusing on Putin and start pressuring the UN and the EU to do something about this Syrian mess, the instability in the Middle East will become uncontrollable.

FYI: Here's how the UN works. The General Assembly has no power. But in the Security Council, even one veto can stop any resolution.

And Russia & China veto anything that is ant-Assad (that's two guaranteed vetoes).

So much for that idea...

(So what's your second best idea?Smile.gif )

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

So much for that idea...

(So what's yoursecond bestidea?

I'm fully aware of how the UN works thank you.

My comment was not an attempt to float an 'idea', it was a statement suggesting where I thought the State Department should be focusing their attention.

The American people are certainly not going to allow the Pentagon to get involved in the Syrian problem, nor should we. If we're going to offer any leadership at all toward helping bring that conflict to an end, we're going to have to do it through our Department of State.

Beyond that suggestion, I don' have any ideas, nor do I pretend to be knowledgeable enough to formulate any that would be practical. I'll leave that up to the DOS who can solicit members of the UN an EU for ideas and assistance.

Btw, since 2005 the UN Security Council has passed 6 resolutions concerning Syria, the latest being Sept of last year re the Chem. weapons. China has no dog in that fight, but Russia has economic ties in Syria, and you can bet your ass as soon as he gets the Ukraine issue under control, Putin will be turning toward Syria.

You have been fairly vocal regarding Syria Krish, what would be your suggestions regarding a solution to the Syrian crisis?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

If we're going to offer any leadership at all toward helping bring that conflict to an end, we're going to have to do it through our Department of State.

C'mon--- get serious! Do you actually believe that our State Dept. can get Assad to stop his atrocities? (And remember-- he has the backing of both Putin and Iran!Frown.gif )

Beyond that suggestion, I don' have any ideas, nor do I pretend to be knowledgeable enough to formulate any that would be practical. I'll leave that up to the DOS who can solicit members of the UN an EU for ideas and assistance.

Sheesh-- let's get real here. If our illustrious State Dept (/sarcasm) can't have qny effect, do you honestly believe the EU-- & the friggin' U.N. could? Seriously, I would have thought you were brighter than that...

China has no dog in that fight,

Oh-- really?

Syria allies: Why Russia, Iran and China are standing by the regime . . . (Link)

Hmmmm.....

You have been fairly vocal regarding Syria Krish, what would be your suggestions regarding a solution to the Syrian crisis?

I have no suggestion, because I am quite familiar with the prevailing cultural values in the Arab wold. (Which is why I know there is no "solution"-- the killing, torture, etc will continue for the foreseeable future).

The best that could be done, ideally, is massive humanitarian aid, perhaps through the UN to at least relieve some of the suffering..but that is highly unlikely as the UN's strongly biased political agenda won't allow for it.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Whatever. No sense in responding, I know you, there is nothing I can say that will alter your opinion.26.gif

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

ifAssad was removed from power: what are the odds that any government replacing him would be significantly better?

The odds that innocent children are going to killed and tortured with Assad in office are about 100%

The odds that a new regime will less brutal cannot be any worse than that!

Remember,this is the Arab world...

Yes, and most of the Arab nations are considerably less brutal than Assad.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

if Assad was removed from power: what are the odds that any government replacing him would be significantly better?

The odds that innocent children are going to killed and tortured with Assad in office are about 100%

The odds that a new regime will less brutal cannot be any worse than that!

But I wonder what the odds are that it would be any better...

However this is probably all irrelevant. At one point early on I had thought the odds were just slightly better than 50-50 that he would be ousted, but now there's very little doubt he will remain in power.

Perhaps the best that we can expect is that the country will fragment-- Assad ruling part of it (if he totally crushes resistance in that part he might moderate considerably), and then there would be (?) a new Sunni ruled Syria and, finally, an independent Kurdistan. (Of course the Sunnis would probably continue to fight each other-- extremists factions like al Qaeda fighting moderates. If the Sunni moderates win, it might not be too bad). And if the Kurds looked like they were gaining autonomy, Erdogan might surpress that...).

I can't see an end to the fighting anytime soon.Frown.gif

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

Update, 4/18:

American missile spotted with opposition forces in Syria

(Link)

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

I can't see an end to the fighting anytime soon. Frown.gif

Finally we agree on something!

( I knew if we argued long enough we would eventually stumble upon common ground )

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Interesting update Krish, thanks for the link.

Personally, I have never doubted the U.S. is working behind the scenes to aid the rebels, however the problems seems to be which rebels should we help, and the question remains ... how much aid are we really pumping into the uprising.

Excerpt from the link;

It was not possible to independently verify the authenticity of the videos or the supplier of the BGM-71 TOW anti-tank rockets shown in the videos. Some analysts suggested they might have been provided by another state such as Saudi Arabia, a U.S. ally, probably with Washingtons acquiescence.

U.S. officials declined to discuss the rockets, which appeared in Syria around the same time Reuters reported that Washington had decided to proceed with plans to increase aid, including delivery of lower-level weaponry.

Keep in mind Putin has an interest in Syria, and his patience with Assad seems to be wearing thin. However, the US also seems to be backing away from the conflict, at least on the surface.

During an interview with ABC News on Feb. 14, 2014, Mark N. Katz, a professor at George Mason University specializing in Russian foreign policy and the international relations of the Middle East, said in part;

" Moscow's preferred solution is what the Algerian military accomplished in the 1990s, which is to brutally suppress the opposition, the same as the Russians themselves did in Chechnya. But that doesn't seem to be the long term outcome in Syria Assad may remain in office, but he cant seem to eliminate his opponents, so this could just drag on indefinitely."

"The Obama administration seems to be just walking away they're not stopping the Russians from supporting Assad. If the Iranian-American rapprochement pushes through, Russia has to worry about whether Iran will make a deal with America [as regards Iran's support of Assad]. It may not seem like it's in the cards, but the Russians worry about these things. "

Read the full article ;

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

We have the power to destroy Assad but should we? We are not the world's policeman nor are we the God-like arbiter of internal or regional disputes. Syria is now in the center of a sectarian dispute between Shia and Sunni in large part exaccerbated by our clumsy actions in Iraq. Iraq was in the Sunni camp under Saddam. We toppled Saddam andIraq moved into the Shia camp with Iran. Assad is a member of a Shia subsect. Hezbollah, a Shia client organization of Iran,now helps Assad. Hezbollah has helped spread the sectarian fight to Lebanon. Every other Arab state is Sunni and opposes Assad. Neither side has our backs and supporting one sideis an affront to the other. That's in addition to the problem of helping terrorist organizations fight Assad when we know full well that they will later turn around and attack us with the weapons we gave them. Obama is understandably reluctant to wade any deeper into this mess. Moreover, although using chemical weapons against the civilian population is a violation of the Geneva Protocol (and my recollection is that both Russia and Syria dispute that Syria is guilty), using force against Assad when we are not acting in our own self-defense, would require the approval of the UN Security Council. Russia would block a Security Council resolution against Syria just as we block them against Israel.If we ignore the UN Charter, then it undercuts our ability to invoke the Charter against Russia if Russia decides to invade Ukraine. Yes, I know the situation in Syria is more serious but that's really not a legal exception to the use of force. We like to think that every wrong has a remedy but sometimes that just isn't so.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

We are not the world's policeman nor are we the God-like arbiter of internal or regional disputes.

Except that we are.

As the worlds wealthiest nation, with financial interest around the globe, it is necessary for us to police and act the God-like arbiter of certain internal and regional disputes in order to protect our financial, diplomatic and military interest.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

As the worlds wealthiest nation, with financial interest around the globe, it is necessary for us to police and act the God-like arbiter of certain internal and regional disputes in order to protect our financial, diplomatic and military interest.

I disagree completely. The time of one nation unilaterally choosing tointerfere in the affairs of another has passed. Our interests are not directly involved; our big noses should not be either.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

I disagree completely. The time of one nation unilaterally choosing tointerfere in the affairs of another has passed. Our interests are not directly involved; our big noses should not be either.

It's a very rare occasion when we act unilaterally regardinginterference in another nations' affairs. We almost always act with the assistance of the UN, NATO or some other coalition ofallies.

Our interest may not be directly involve, but they are most certainly indirectly involved, the economic impact is the same either way. So if you don't want to be paying $10.68 a gallon for gas to get to work, you better hope our diplomatic and military influence in the Middle East is successful.

We are in a very competitive global economy and it is critical we make every effort to enhance and protect our interest regarding the U.S.international trade in goods and services.

In the late 70's the Khmer Rouge slaughtered over 3 million people, about 25% of the Cambodianpopulation. No US financial interest there, no US intervention.

Today there is terrible genocide occurring in Darfur, Rwanda and Uganda. NoUS financial interest there, no US intervention.

As the global economy grows and becomes more and more competitive, it isimperative we keep our alliances strong, andsuppressviolence and conflict whenit threatens to interfere with the adhesion and flow of international goods and services . The success or failure of our efforts to protect our international financial interest will have a 'direct effect' on your family budget.

P.S. Tip, Read this article

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

. . . We almost always act with the assistance of the UN, NATO or some other coalition ofallies.

If we intervene militarily, and we're not acting in self-defense, then intervention should ONLY be with the approval of the UN Security Council.

Our interest may not be directly involve, but they are most certainly indirectly involved, the economic impact is the same either way. So if you don't want to be paying $10.68 a gallon for gas to get to work . . .

This would, in my view, set a preposterous precedent. Others would follow suit and every country would think it had a right to interfere in the affairs of another for as little motivation as avoiding higher gas prices.

. . . The success or failure of our efforts to protect our international financial interest will have a 'direct effect' on your family budget.

No doubt but playing the Lone Ranger on a global scale has proven inordinately expensive and I have no added security or benefits to show for it. For instance, I'm paying for Afghanistan, Iraq, and Libya.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

If we intervene militarily, and we're not acting in self-defense, then intervention should ONLY be with the approval of the UN Security Council.

Does Putin have Security Council approval for his actions inUkraine? Do you think Putin might use his veto power to keep the UN from giving us permission to intervene in theUkraine or Syria, should it become necessary?

This would, in my view, set a preposterous precedent. Others would follow suit and every country would think it had a right to interfere in the affairs of another for as little motivation as avoiding higher gas prices.

Would set?! Countries have been interfering in the affairs in other countries since man invented borders. I only used the price of gas as a rhetorical example. Conflict between nations can be over any number of things, but it always involves the 'national interest' of everybody involved.

playing the Lone Ranger on a global scale has proven inordinately expensive and I have no added security or benefits to show for it.

It's always important to know what you don't know.

Unless you're a fairly savvy economist, or are willing to do an awful lot of research, you don't know how expensive our military and diplomatic expenditures are, and you don't know what the differential is when you factor in the results of our international trade for goods and services.Therefore you cannot know how much security and benefits you're getting.

However, because we are the wealthiest nation in the world and havethe most powerful military in the world,we have the most control and influence regarding the global economy. So you can pretty much bet you are getting the lions share of the security and the lions share of all the benefits this world has to offer.

That's why it's important we must constantly 'poke our nose' into the affairs of other countries.

For instance, I'm paying for Afghanistan, Iraq, and Libya.

That's all part of and included in the very fluid overall Mid East picture, and I'm sure the bean counters have figured out what we need to do to cut our potential losses, and the Pentagon and State Department have a reasonable amount of control on their fronts. I'm just going to let them figure out what to do.

I know what I don't know. I know I don't have enough information to be calling the shots in the Middle East.

I'll leave that up to you.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

delete

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

Does Putin have Security Council approval for his actions inUkraine? Do you think Putin might use his veto power to keep the UN from giving us permission to intervene in theUkraine or Syria, should it become necessary?

I'm referring to military intervention which is what requires Security Council approval. Putin has not "intervened" in Ukraine militarily. So far, all that has happened is that Crimea voted to secede from Ukraine and join the Russian federation. We supported Kosovo seceding from Serbia and Putin is using our support for that action as the basis for his own. Even if Kosovo hadn't happened, all people have a right to self-determination. That principal is the basis for Ukraine declaring its own independence and the basis for many countries (including us) breaking their colonial chains. And, yes I'm sure Putin would block Security Council action in Ukraine and Syria the same way we block Security Council action on Israel. To me, that has no bearing on the basic principal that one nation should not take military action against another (other than in self-defense) without approval of the Security Council.

Would set?! Countries have been interfering in the affairs in other countries since man invented borders. I only used the price of gas as a rhetorical example. Conflict between nations can be over any number of things, but it always involves the 'national interest' of everybody involved.

The fact that countries have been running roughshod over one another for centuries is precisely why the principal of non-aggression was developed. I know why you used the "price of gas example" and, for me, it underscores why we should be careful about acting in our short-term economic interests and undermining our long-term interest in protecting an international rule of law.

Unless you're a fairly savvy economist, or are willing to do an awful lot of research, you don't know how expensive our military and diplomatic expenditures are, and you don't know what the differential is when you factor in the results of our international trade for goods and services.Therefore you cannot know how much security and benefits you're getting . . .

All quite irrelevant if we adhere to the international rule of law. Again, military action should be limited to instances where we are acting in self-defense or with approval of the Security Council.

That's all part of and included in the very fluid overall Mid East picture, and I'm sure the bean counters have figured out what we need to do to cut our potential losses, and the Pentagon and State Department have a reasonable amount of control on their fronts. I'm just going to let them figure out what to do. I know what I don't know. I know I don't have enough information to be calling the shots in the Middle East. I'll leave that up to you.

A responsibility I'm happy to take. This is a democracy. I have no intention of leaving to bean counters and bureaucrats the power to determine how my money is spent or when my blood is spilled. They are accountable to me, not the other way around.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

1ofmany,

Although I am enjoying this discussion, and have no problem with temporarily continuing with it here, we are actually way off topic, as this article is about Syria and the suffering non-political innocent men, woman, children and babies are suffering as a result of the conflict going on there.

My suggestion is that you or I (preferably you, as I'm a littlejammedright now) post a seed orwrite an articleregardingwhatis going in Ukraine and we can continue ourdiscussionthere,plus we will likely pick up some input from other members.

If you post something I'll pick it up in my NT email alerts, and will join you there asap.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

Putin has not "intervened" in Ukraine militarily.

That is highly questionable, because there is the issue of who are the men in unmarked military uniforms that have entered East Ukraine.

Russian-Soldier-2-600x374.jpg?width=200

Aljazeera;

"It's all nonsense, there are no Russian units, special forces or instructors in the east of Ukraine," Putin said.

He did admit, for the first time, that the troops in unmarked uniforms who had captured Ukraine's Crimean Peninsula before its annexation last month by Moscow were Russian soldiers.
[ Photo: BagNews ]

Looks like military intervention to me.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------

The fact that countries have been running roughshod over one another for centuries is precisely why the principal of non-aggression was developed.

I agree, but you said the action would set a "preposterousprecedent".
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Unless you're a fairly savvy economist, or are willing to do an awful lot of research, you don't know how expensive our military and diplomatic expenditures are, and you don't know what the differential is when you factor in the results of our international trade for goods and services. Therefore you cannot know how much security and benefits you're getting . . .

All quite irrelevant if we adhere to the international rule of law. Again, military action should be limited to instances where we are acting in self-defense or with approval of the Security Council.

I understand, I was referring to your comment about not knowing where your foreign policy dollars were going ie;

" No doubt but playing the Lone Ranger on a global scale has proven inordinately expensive and I have no added security or benefits to show for it. "
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

This is a democracy. I have no intention of leaving to bean counters and bureaucrats the power to determine how my money is spent or when my blood is spilled.

They don't "determine" anything.

We hire those bean counters and bureaucrats through our democratic process to keep the wheels and cogs of our government fuctioning. We spend about 35 trillion dollars a year, well more than half of which is spent on our military and the administration of our foreign policy. You don't think we need bean counters to keep track of that money?

Also, if we don't have bureaucrats, who is going to administrate the thousands and thousands of agencies and bureaus operating within the 60 or 70 departments that make up our three branches of government?

Btw, this is not a democracy , it's a republic .

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

I agree that we're off topic. I'm a little tied up myself right now but I'd be happy to debate this further on another seed when I get a chance.

psst . . . How do you start a seed?

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

psst . . . How do you start a seed?

Put it potting soil and keep it watered.24.gif

No, seriously26.gif

I could explain it to you here, but it would be much easier for you to follow and understand if you go to Perries' NT Instructional Videos . They will give you visuals to follow asthey walk you through the steps. If you run into any problems, feel free to give me a shout using this link , click on 'Send aMessage' in the upper left under my avatar,and I'll get back to you asap.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

Guess who else is supporting Assad? I just came across this old video:

White Supremacist David Duke Speaks at a pro-Assad Rally-- in Damascus!!!

OK, so Duke is a racist and an anti-Semite. But why on earth did he travel all the way to Syria... and why is he suporting Assad? It makes no sense...

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

That speech was made in 2005, when Duke was traveling throughout Europe, assumably paid by anti zionist groups, to spread his hate. Many countries have since banned him. The Czech Republic expelled him in 2009, then Switzerland issued a residence ban against him in 2013, which was co-signed by 25 other countries, effectively ending his hate speech tour.

The racist infested Tea Party tried to get him to to run in the 2012 GOP presidential primary, but the racist bastard couldn't couldn't raise enough money to launch a campaign. As of 2013 he isn't even showing as a registered voter in Louisiana, so I don't know where the prick is.

I assume he's making his living off the KKK and other radical right wing assholes, like the Tea Party crowd, that buy his anti Zionist, anti black books and pay to hear him make his hate speeches.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
This is a regional sectarian struggle between Sunni and Shia. In Syria, we're supporting the Sunni and in Iraq, we're supporting the Shia. George Bush was a boob but it takes real nitwittery for Obama to get on both sides of the same fight. The support we provide in Syria is used against us in Iraq. If people weren't dying this would be comical.
 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Well it looks like we were wrong to aid the Terrorist rebels in Syria.

Wheres the s/ symbol. We did nothing in Syria.

People said it would end in too many dead civilians and destroy the country.

Did you click in the link for the full array of photos ?

A few pictures of wounded children works every time.

A few?! And they're not wounded, they're dead. Almost 8,000 children had been killed in Syria as of March of this year.

Works every time to do what?

According to a TIME report on March 13, 2014, roughly half of the 146,065 deaths in Syria were civilians, including 7,796 children.

UNICEF said in a report this month that 1.2 million children have fled the country and 5.5 million Syrian children in and outside the country are in need of humanitarian assistance.

Syria is a humanitarian disaster! And the kids, who have absolutely nothing to do with the causes of the conflict, are the ones suffering most from the effects.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

This is a regional sectarian struggle between Sunni and Shia. In Syria, we're supporting the Sunni and in Iraq, we're supporting the Shia. George Bush was a boob but it takes real nitwittery for Obama to get on both sides of the same fight.

Actually it show the United States and the rest of the west just don't understand the conflicts in the Middle East are not about nations and national borders, it's about religion. Religion has no borders, and religion has noconscience.

Formillenniums people of one religion have had absolutely NOcompunctionabout slaughtering anyone and everyone that is of another religion.

Today Christians sit in judgement of the Muslims as they go this period of murder and mayhem, forgetting that 2,000 years ago the Christians were going through the same thing.

Until the people of the world realize religion is nothing more than hokas-pokas, fantasy bullshit, the world will remain inturmoil, dictators and tyrants will use religion to gain and keep power and people will continue to die.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

forgetting that 2,000 years ago the Christians were going through the same thing.

Yea, but we are not living 2000 years ago. Most of those people are no longer even alive!

Why blame for things our ancestors did many generations ago?

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Why blame for things our ancestors did many generations ago?

For Chrissake! What you talking about ... BLAME?!

I was just pointing out that the Christians went through a similar period of chaos 2000 years ago, that may explain and make easier to understand what the Muslims are going through today.

I do not "blame" the Christians for anything. Why didn't you post the entire comment? What I said was:

Today Christians sit in judgement of the Muslims as they go this period of murder and mayhem, forgetting that 2,000 years ago the Christians were going through the same thing.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
Before we stick our nose into palaces where it can be chopped off, I'd like to know why our involvement advances our vital national interests. Children dying is not enough for me since children are dying everywhere and we don't have the capacity to save them all. So we push Assad out of power . . . then what?
 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

I can't see a whole lot of thinking behind your comments Dennis, apparently you have no idea of what has been going on in Syria. But that's ok, the reason I posted this article is to make people aware.

The Syrians are seeing the results of what they have permitted.

In the first place the Syrian people are not "permitting" anything. They have fallen under the control of a ruthless dictator, and they are trying to overthrow him and his brutal regime.

The Syrians need to clean up their own mess.

If you click on this link you will get an instant look at the "mess" these people have to clean up. That mess was caused by the dictator, Bashar Assad, as were the dead children right above the photo of Mr. Assad, celebrating his childs' 2nd birthday.

If killing their children is how they chose to do it, so be it.

(?!) I can't believe you said that! Do you think those people actually CHOSE to let their children die?

If killing their children ........ so be it?!!

What kind of a person are you Dennis?!! The people did not kill those children, the birthday boy with the cake and his own children safely tucked under his arms, killed those children, and he used poison gas to do it.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Our arming of the ISIS rebels in Syria has done nothing but cause more children to die, not in one country but now two countries.

It was a horrible mistake to arm terrorists.

You may be right BF, BUT,....... I've been listening to as many foreign policy and political analyst as possible on this topic, plus searching the net for some direction regarding the events in the middle east. My take away is, right now the situation is so fluid it's impossible to for guys like you and me to determine what were/are the right calls.

From what I gather, the makeup of the ISIS fighting in Iraq right now, is not the same ISIS that was in Syria. Many Jihadist have joined them changing the dynamics and motives of their movement. So what was a good move in Syria, has become a bad thing for Iraq. So, it wasn't a mistake to arm ISIS, at the time it was done. However, when things change it sometimes causes things to be a mistake in hindsight.

It must be like playing a 3 dimensional chess game for the Heads of State that have to deal with the fluid an unpredictable events in the Middle East. Each has their own agenda and concerns about their own interest and national security.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

Disagree Jerry. The Syrian people have allowed a dictator to control their country.

Don't be ridicules, people of a country don''t "allow" a dictator to control their country.

When Hafez al-Assad was in power in 1970 he integrated the military into the government gaining tremendous power. He then set up his son, Bashar to become President, who was "elected' with over 97% of the 'vote' in a referendum with no opponent.

" Assads's government and secret police routinely tortured, imprisoned, and killed political opponents, and those who speak out against the government. Since 2006 it expanded the use of travel bans against dissidents. In that regard, Syria is the worst offender among Arab states ." [Wikipedia]

As far as children dying, that is very sad but is still the people of Syria's doing that has allowed it to get where it is.

Again, don't be ridicules, the people of Syria are powerless to stop the killing of their children unless they agree to live under a brutal dictator. You say the people of Syria 'chose' to live under Assad, but when they try to get out from under his ruthless hand, and he reacts by bombing and gassing them. So, who is killing the children, the people orthe dictator?

There are children dying throughout the world. We cannot fix everything everywhere

Of course we can't. But we can help. We can lead and we can encourage leaders of other counties to get involved and help.

In my opinion it's not the American way to turn our back on a humanitarian disaster.

UNICEF said in a report this month that 1.2 million children have fled the country and 5.5 million Syrian children in and outside the country are in need of humanitarian assistance.

If that's not a disaster, I don't know what is.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

I'd like to know why our involvement advances our vital national interests.

I don't know why I should have to answer that, anyreasonablyinformed news blogger should not even have to ask a question like that. You don't know that stabilityin the Middle East is vital to our economy and our national security?

Our economy. In one word ... oil.

Our national security. In one word .... terrorist.

So we push Assad out of power . . . then what?

With the help of UN forces to maintain order, and we help the people set up a stable government.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

Our economy. In one word ... oil.

Yup. When the neo-cons got us into the mess in iraq in the first place, they claimed it was because Saddam had WMDs & was a threat to the region (& possibly the world). Some also mentioned what a brutal dictator he was. (:the former was a li;e, the latter was true).

But liberal opponents of the said that that the Neo-cons were trying to mislead us-- the real reason they & Bush wanted war was to exploit Iraq's oil. Their mantras during protests were:

Its all about oil

and:

No blood for oil!

Solely in terms of self-interest, instability in Iraq threatens the oil. Not only the profits of oil companies or traders, but the price could skyrocket. This would cause a rapid downturn in the already fragile world (& U.S.) economies.

BTW, many pundits see the wars in Syria and Iraq as separate & different. Actually, they are the same religious war (Sunni vs. Shia). While Syria doesn't have significant oil, iraq has huge amounts. ISIS/ISIL terrorists may be anti-Assad, but they don't care which side of the border they are fighting on....

Our national security. In one word .... terrorist.

Yup.

So we push Assad out of power . . . then what?

1. At this point neither we nor anyone else can push him out of power-- he is too powerful.

2. Air power is limited. As the Israelis discovered in their last war (against Hezb'Allah in Lebanon) airpower alone isn't all that effective in asymetrical warfare. it takes boots on the ground.

With the help of UN forces to maintain order, and we help the people set up a stable government.

UN forces???

LOL!Grin.gif

(Tell me Jerry-- where can I get some of that stuff that you are smoking?)

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
"I don't know why I should have to answer that, any reasonably , informed news blogger should not even have to ask a question like that. You don't know that stability in the Middle East is vital to our economy and our national security?"This may come as a shock to you but reasonably informed people can have a difference of opinion. My question was not whether stability is in our national interest but rather how you think you can achieve it by intervening. Do you, as a reasonably informed blogger, see stability in Iraq after the removal of Saddam? What, if anything, would you do to achieve a different result?"Our economy. In one word ... oil.""Our national security. In one word .... terrorist."Maybe you should have strung together more words. Syria is ranked 32 in oil production. In any event, if Iraq is an example, pushing a dictator out of power can create a vacuum filled by terrorists which imperils oil. So how does your cryptic one-word analysis address that?"So we push Assad out of power . . . then what""With the help of UN forces to maintain order, and we help the people set up a stable government."That's your informed solution? What makes you think the Security Council would vote to intervene or vote to place peace keepers after we unilaterally topple the government? And by the way, do you see a stable government in Iraq after all these years? Why do you, as an informed blogger, think Syria would be any different? I assume that you, as an informed blogger, are aware that we now have a regional sectarian war created, in large part, by our funding terrorists to topple Assad? Do you think that war is going to just disappear when Assad is gone or possibly get worse as radical Sunnis try and take the place over as they're doing in Iraq?
 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

News (6/23/14):

Israeli Air Force attacks positions in Syrian-controlled Golan Heights in retaliation for missile attack which claimed life of 13-year-old teen.

The Israel Air Force launched attacks on nine Syrian military positions in the Golan Heights late Sunday night in response to a missile attack earlier in the day that killed a 13-year-old boy on the Israeli side of the border.

The IDF said the targets belonged to President Bashar Assad's Syrian army, and included command posts and firing positions. The military confirmed direct hits on the targets. High-precision ground-to-ground Spike (Tamuz) missiles were also used in the attack.

The strikes were launched shortly after midnight, when IAF jets fired missiles on Syrian army positions on the Syrian-controlled Golan Heights.

Syrian opposition sources claimed that there were 3 attacks on Syrian army positions. They said the headquarters of Syria's 90th Division, which is stationed in Quneitra, was also attacked.

(Link)

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago
 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

How can we ignore Detroit but pay attention to Syria?

That's good question BF. Why DO we ignore the plight of the children in Detroit and the other inner cities of America?

The Right Winigers in this country always use the argument that "we should take of our own first", but then when it comes to actually doing something about "taking care of our own", they refuse to provide the funding and brand every piece of legislation designed to help the inner cities as "socialist".

The truth of the matter is conservatives don't want to help anybody but the people that provide the bulk f their campaign funds. Conservatives are extremely selfish people, totally lacking in compassion and empathy. It's all about "it's mine, I earned it and I'm NOT sharing.

So until Republicans actually start doing something about helping our inner city children, your argument amount to nothing but a cop-out.

Anyway, the children of Americas' inner cities, while being ignored, are not being bombed and gassed by their government.

Is it easier for us to help Syrians than it is our own neighbors?

Are your neighbors being bombed and gassed?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

In my opinion it's not the American way to turn our back on a humanitarian disaster.

Well,perhaps Obama could send in more American troops to die in the Middle east?

But things might change-- right now the two groups most successfully fighting Assad are ISIS and the regular al Qaeda froces-- & ISIS' effectiveness against Assad is diminished as so many of them have moved in to Iraq...

Perhaps if Obama decides to give financial aid to ISIS, they can be bribed into going back to Syria to fight Assad?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

(?!) I can't believe you said that! Do you think those people actually CHOSE to lettheirchildren die?

Of course they do!

Geez are you ever naive! (Or perhaps you just like to spout whatever ideas come into your head-- regardless of whether or not they have any truth to them)....???

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

I wonder how bad it will be if Assad falls and the terrorists we armed take over....I think this will pale in comparison.

There's an old saying:

There's no choice amongst rotten apples

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

(?!) I can't believe you said that! Do you think those people actually CHOSE to lettheirchildren die?

Of course they do!

Geez are you ever naive!

Holy shit.

If you think I'm going to respond to a comment that absurd, you are sadly mistaken Krish.

You're calling ME naive??!!

After reading your last couple of comments, it is my opinion that you're really not up to this discussion. I was under the impression you were a reasonably intelligent and informed person to have a this discussion with. However I now realize you don't even have an understanding of how a man gains control of a nation even when it is explained to you in some detail.

I have not got the time to have a discussion with a person that is trying to tell me the the people of Syria actually chose to let their children die.

It's over Krish, I am not going to respond to anything else you have to say on this thread.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

So we push Assad out of power . . . then what?

Then his enemies will take over-- Syria would be ruled by either al-Qaeda or ISIS-- whichever ends up stronger.

Instead of a brutal secular dictatorship allied with Iran that constantly commits the most unspeakable atrocities against its people, Syria would be ruled by an Islamic Caliphate, ISIS,a brutal religious dictatorship of extremist crazies allied with Saudi Arabia and Qatar,that constantly commits the most unspeakable atrocities against its people.

Those are the current values in the Arab world today-- either a secular dictator (like Mubarak, Saddam, Assad) or a religious fundamentalist dictatorship (Iran, Syria).

Take yer pick.

(But please, please, please-- don't send any more Americans kids off to die for these barbarians...)

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

"With the help of UN forces to maintain order,

Like they did so well in Rwanda... remember what happened there?Frown.gif Frown.gif Frown.gif

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

I can't believe you said that! Do you think those people actually CHOSE to let their children die?

Good grief Jerry-- don't you ever read the news????

Hamas Caught Using Human Shields in Gaza

The IDF is currently engaged in Operation Protective Edge against Hamas and other Palestinian terrorist groups in the Gaza Strip.Hamas placesweapons and missilelaunchers in densely populated areas. They also send men, woman and children to act as human shields for terrorists.

image.png

Hamas uses graphics such as the one below in order to assure Palestinians in Gaza that that they can become heroes, achieving martyrdom by acting as human shields.

.

A strong people written in Arabicword play on the name Hebrew name of Operation Protective Edgeencouraging Palestinians in Gaza to stand on the roofs of their homes to act as human shields.

 
 
 
thoughtful conservative
Freshman Silent
link   thoughtful conservative    11 years ago

Just a little historic fact there is no place in history where a country intervened in a area run by clans, Religious leaders, or ethnic majoritiesthat resulted in a stable environment over time.Only where dictators have been in power has it worked and then only until civil war. From Juan Peron to Marcos, To the ShawFrom India to the Soviet Union, Banana Republicsanyplace in Africa including South Africa benignhegemony is temporary at best as it ultimatelyuses up the resources of the empire building state. Assad gone ... so what. We either have a vested interest in Syria or we don't.

It's Proximity to Israel is reason enough for me to believe we have a vested interest but beyond that it is simply a game of cost vs benefit and I am not smart enough to make that calculation. our past has been typified by and we have been used to conflicts that actually are about natural resourcesor territory. Our collective mentality will not allows us to come to the politicallyincorrect discussion that we are in a conflict of Religion right at a time when our country is mostly secular and cannot comprehend putting our kids on a rooftop to keep people from blowing up our house. It is considered bad manners to say what needs to be said.

Until we come to grips with the basis of this regionalconflict and come to understand that we are now in a fight over something we really do not want to fight over but the other side doesn't care. they do not want our oil, gas, coal, water, etc they want us dead or converted. Go rent Gunga Din.

 
 
 
thoughtful conservative
Freshman Silent
link   thoughtful conservative    11 years ago

ditto.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    11 years ago

So we push Assad out of power . . . then what?

Then ISIS rules Syria, its as simple as that.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

Who gives a shit about the plight of the Syrians, it's Gaza that the world is concerned about.

Are there any "rescue flotillas" on the way to Syria?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    11 years ago

Who gives a shit about the plight of the Syrians, it's Gaza that the world is concerned about.

Are there any "rescue flotillas" on the way to Syria?

The hypocricy & double standards are disgusting

 
 

Who is online







96 visitors